I wanted to say that Goldi and her family were my personal favourite characters and the highlights of the film. Despite being a "crime" family, they are just as charming, amusing and loveable as the Moomins.
I honestly imagine their “crime” family thing was more of a mafia deal, where the bears mostly run a sort of forest crime syndicate. They’re not too demanding, but not too forgiving.
If I could provide an alternative wish that would make everyone happy, perhaps Goldi realizes that the bears have provided for her their entire life, and now wants to use the star to repay the favor. Instead of wishing for a new family, she wishes for her family to be given a new chance, and to live like a family, not on the run or living in the shadows as they evade the police, but rather to actually be part of a community of other friendly people, and to grow and evolve with them. After the wish, Mama and Papa feel a bit younger, but when they see Goldi and Baby, the two are definitely younger than before the wish, and they realize that Goldi didn't wish for a new family. There are three slips of paper in Goldi's hand, with three different addresses. One is an address for their new home; still in the forest, but much closer to civilization so they won't have to worry about being alone, another slip being the location of a school that Baby and Goldi will be attending, and another being the location of Mama and Papa bear's new family business, but instead of pie making like it is in the movie, it's porridge making. They're still the same bears and people, but Goldi wanted to give them a chance to start a new life and to let everyone know just how great they are. Baby Bear is moved to tears by this wish she made, while Papa gives a soft chuckle and ruffled her head, saying how when all they had is porridge for their lives, perhaps trying this new life out won't be such a bad idea, and Mama Bear is proud of Goldi for her idea, happy to see that she saw what has been in front of her all this time, with them leaving the forest, with Baby on Papa's back, while Mama carries off Goldi on her back, ready to at least give this new life a chance. But I will admit, Goldi accidentally causing global damage with her wish was something I never expected, so good job on creativity.
What if the bears prefer their old life? Like, while a new life would be better, arent they happy with their normal life? Besides, a new life may not be fitting for them.
@@dylanzlol7293 Yeah, I admit I didn't word that part very well. I was going on a path of suggesting that Goldi offered to make a wish that could let them have a better life, and coming up with that idea, while still offering them the chance to back out if they want. Should have put a bit more thought into that one.
Damn this is great, tho they would never leave their home lmao, maybe if it was uprooted and plunked down elsewhere but if assume they'd know the area well aswell
What if in the good ending. When Goldielocks makes her wish. She wishes that she and the bears would forever be a true family. And when it's granted she turns into a bear with golden fur. Ofcourse she and the bears are shocked at first. But then they just except it as something extra. Now they are the four bears and lives happily ever after.
While i cant help but like that idea, i also cant agree with it. The whole point is that theyre already family and everythings "just right". Something like them having a more 'normal' happy family life, were theyre not a criminal family on the run but live in/among a town working/going to school and just being happy in a community fits more.
My bad ending would be a lot crueler... Firstly it doesn't bring the entire book's setting into the real world. What it does do is that it replaces anything from Goldi's life with something from the book. I.E. the house of the bears becomes the house from the book. And the bears would be replaced too. They'd be swapped with the family from the book, as in the people she once knew have basically been erased from existence and replaced with her ideal family. Goldi is happy initially, but laments over the absence of the bears. So she wonders where they are, and asks around only to find that no one knows who she's even talking about. Eventually after investigating the house, and finding that it's in the same spot as the bear's house she realizes what's going on. Regreting the mistake she made, she confronts the parents and tries to pry and find a way to reverse what she did. However the parents are unsure of what she's even talking about. So in frustration and regret she runs away trying to find a way to fix it. After a long while she realizes that there is nothing she can do. So Goldi continues to wonder the world as the orphan girl that she once was, painfully accepting that nothing can go back to being just right.
I imagine Puss and Kitty are still thieves and they rob from the many kingdoms. Although I don't think they would have started over their relationship in this AU so....
@@zomboss3904 Wasn’t death still after Puss? And wasn’t he in the same city when Puss would get turned into a defenceless chicken in this reality? Also, forgot to ask about perrito in this world
I think Puss would try and kill Puss in Jacks building but would accidentally kill Jack instead, then Kitty and Puss would escape with Perrito. With his only option of getting his lives back gone, Puss would pour his heart out to Kitty and they would make up. Death would leave them alone and then the kingdoms would merge, so Puss and Kitty would make a new mission to find others like Shrek and donkey while looting kingdoms along the way.
One idea that came to mind is what would the other characters in the story be like. I feel like Jack, Perrito, and Kitty would stay the same with Jack still being a self entitled prick, and kitty and perrito still possibly becoming friends. However I feel like the idea of the wishing star being gone and with no way to get his live back, push would become deranged and crazy always attacking people who looked liked or resembeld the wolf or even his whistle would cause him to lose it. We could see not only is puss still an outlaw but a psychopath seemingly attacking people at random, which would get the bears attention with one of the refugees being a victim of puss's attack. Eventually kitty would come to the bears asking for help to find and help puss as even she is terrified of what her once best friend, and lover, became. When they start to search for him baby decides to do a little whistle which he thinks is nothing but to quell the silence, but they eventually hear a rustling in the nearby bushes and try to find out what it is. When they get close puss jumps out like a maniac attacking all of them thinking they are a part of Death's little trick. Even with them trying to get him to calm down it does nothing, and when they try to get him to explain why he is like this which leads to him telling them about the wolf and how he was going to use the star to get his live back. Goldi realizing the way wish affected puss tells him that she used it to get a proper family, the bears give a little side eye, but before she could explain anything else puss lunges at her blaming her for his hysteria. When Goldi finally gets a moment to speak she talks about how the wish wouldn't give him any satisfaction and only leads to more pain. Puss starting to calm down begins to realize everything he did and start to breakdown, but as kitty comes to comfort him death shows up. Puss realizes that if he keeps running he will never be free of his fear so when death challenges him to fight puss agrees, an excuse to get the awesome fight still. when Puss wins death realizes that he finally accepts life for what it is and leaves saying, "Took you long enough Gato." Even with death gone puss still feels terrible for everything he did and tries to fix every bit of pain he caused. Not only would Goldi learn her lesson but puss as well.
Based on what you mentioned about that “bad ending” it immediately made me think of what happened in Shrek. With Lord farquod (not sorry for misspelling his name) kingdom, taking over everything and not letting the fairytales have their own territory.
(In a universe where Jack never escaped from the bag) Puss: You should have the wish. You deserve someone you can trust. Kitty: I don't need it. I got what I wanted. No magic required. Puss looked around to see Perrito, Goldie, and the Bears. None of them needed the wish. Puss: Well we can't just leave empty handed after coming all this way. Everyone put your heads together. There has to be something we all want. ???: If none of you require the wish, I could take it. They all turn towards the familiar voice as Death stood amongst them once again. Puss: You want it? Death: Does it surprise you that Death has a wish? Puss: More just concerned over what that wish could be. Death: (sigh) I swear on my honor as a reaper and a warrior that I will not use it to harm you or anyone else. I wish to regain something precious to me that was lost. Something that lies beyond even my reach. But perhaps not the Star's. After a few moments, Puss hesitantly relinquished the map. Death: Starlight, Starbright, first star I see tonight. I wish I may, I wish I might, have the wish I wish tonight. Suddenly, Death stops speaking as he begins fighting back tears to the surprise of those gathered. Death: Please...give me back my brothers! With that, the star exploded into the sky in a massive beam of light, leaving the gathered standing in a crater. And a moment later, three more beams of light slamed into the ground in between them and Death, revealing three new figures. A rat who seemed to make them sick just from looking at him, a raven who made them feel insatiably hungry, and a lion who filled them with inexplicable rage. But Death could only smile. Death: War, Famine, Pestilence. War: It is good to see you again too, Brother. Famine: It's been far too long. Pestilence: Indeed. Shall we ride, again? Death: Nothing would make me happier. With that, the four brothers summoned spectral steeds and rode out of sight. The remaining creatures stood there in shock and terror as Puss turned to Kitty. Puss: Did we just unleash the Apocalypse? Kitty: Yep.
Way to imagine new locations. I especially loved Papa handling the molten locks in the mountains and both endings were great Finn. Not even all that depressing tbh since the bad ending at least had a good semi redemption. My route was somewhat similar when Goldi makes the wish and does get her perfect parents and they obviously love her but as days go by they start either smothering her or try to make her just as perfect and critize/iron out her bearish tendencies like burping, fighting, getting dirty, committing crimes, singing that silly pie song, or basically any acting out etc. Eventually Goldie just can't take it anymore but the only reminder of her real family is just 3 stuffed toys that look like Mama, Papa, and Baby. Or to make it really dark have her new dad be a hunter and he mounted the formers heads in the house as the Stars reminder "You got what you wanted, but at what cost? least you can be together forever. Hope everything is finally just right now you selfish ungrateful brat." Unsure if either choice would fit the Shrek franchise but that was just my take on it.
I dont think that the Wishing star is like the monkey's paw that goes "granted, but your new family is strict and they kill your old family.", like, while the wishing star may try to make you realize that you dont need to make the wish, it isnt going out of its way to prevent you from getting your wish if youre unconvinced, and would adjust the wish to make it better.
This is an interesting take. Goldie’s wish definitely had a lot of gray area to it. Since she wasn’t too descriptive of her wish, it sounded like how a genie would grant a wish and find a loophole. Reminds me a lot of the first Shrek and Shrek Forever After. Everyone being driven off their land due to kingdoms taking over. Wonder what happened to Puss and Kitty in this scenario.
Please do kitty next! There's so much we can learn about her through the Shrek and previous puss in boots movies. I'm actually surprised you didn't have Goldie say something like; "you said it yourself baby...I'm not a bear. I'm an orphan lookin for my own parents" as a way to not only justify her motive but also point out that baby, in her perspective, always treated her as temporary instead of family.
Considering the wishing star will always bring someone an introspective three step journey to make them understand that they don’t need a magic wish, is Perrito the opposite of the usual rule? He had a much harsher origin that, while it could get better it could never be “fixed”, so was his journey an attempt to convince him to use the wish for a good reason, instead of everyone else who it tried to prevent from backing a bad one.
Like many people said, I thought that if Goldie did made her wish, either it would end up with the bears transforming into humans or Goldie transforming into a bear with blonde fur. Also for the second ending, I choose option C. Another wishing star would eventually fall so Goldie can undo what she did and get everything back to normal.
This is great! I hope you do Jack next, because I am really curious on what the Wishing Star would do to help him with his problem. Me and my friend theorized that the Map would make him realize that he already has all the magic with how many magical artifacts he has stolen over the years. But I would like to see your take? Also two other requests, both for the same movie. 1. What If Po Never Made It Over The Gate? Quite self-explanatory, what if Po's fireworks chair never worked and Oogway picked Tigress instead. Would she be able to beat Tai Lung? What about Po and Ping? And what would happen to the Valley of Peace? And the next one What If Oogway Made Tai Lung the Dragon Warrior? This one got me because Tai Lung only became evil because he couldn't have the title. Which, further proved Oogway's point. But what if he did? Would he able to prove Oogway wrong, or would he still become filled with darkness
These are pretty good, I'd also add a new one, what if Po forgave Tai Lung's Life? What if Maybe instead of skadooshing Tai Lung, Po decided to spare him since he acknowledged that Tai Lung only did what he did out of feeling like he disappointed his father figure and gave him a chance to start over, i feel like that could have a lot of potential for a story
I said how Jack horner's path would be like. First path: it shows what would happen if Jack got his wish, everyone is suffering obviously, but what matters is, the Jack of this illusion is unhappy, after all, he got everything he wanted, and it feels empty. "Youll always want more." Second path: this would show how Jack horner's life would be like if he went down another path. Doesnt necessarily have to stop being evil, but even being a bit kinder could make things better than pure evil. Third path: nothing, just infinite nothingness, the only way to get past this path is if Jack horner starts to reconsider his ideas, maybe it isnt necessary to be evil? Maybe theres nothing to gain from this? Even if it is admittedly fun and quirky, how far would that get him? Many have probably tried to get Jack to change, but its not like he ever started to consider these words before.
@@dylanzlol7293 Yeah and the thing I noticed he kept saying he was *EVIL* with the same tone (I felt) like Puss saying he was *FEARLESS* ... A possible result of redemption? So he would try to avoid greed/envy? If only, if only...
I think what would have been more tragic is either A( the bears don’t remember Goldi since they never adopted her. B( some time past on and mama died of a broken heart and papa soon after, baby is alive with a family of his own. He resents Goldie and doesn’t want her involved with his family, breaking her heart in the process.
Y’know what would be interesting for a mini theory? What if death didn’t forgive puss at the end and killed him there That could also tie into a theory where jack gets his wish
Then puss dies and we get boohoo waambulance funeral, thats it. It kinda depends on his role on shrek 5, its possible that nothing could change or something does change (through at that point youre better off making a "what if puss didnt do x thing that advanced shreck 5's plot" vid.)
Finn, have you heard of something called Mort Theory? It was created by TH-camr "The Theorizer", originally intended to just be a dissection of Mort from "Madagascar", he found that it could not only tie to every Dreamworks film but also to every theory (or at least most) he made on one. The reason I say this is because Death in this movie canonized the theory to a terrifying extent. Interested?
@@amitamaru maybe the star QUITE LITERALLY gives him all the magic in the world, yea everyone looses the ability to use magical spells or potions or stuff like that as it all gets absorbed into Jack but he gets SO much that his body can't take it and he explodes.
Fun fact: In the Latin American dub for this movie, Goldi and the Three Bears speak with an Argentinian accent, much like how they speak with an Australian accent in the original dub.
Great scenario! Love the too hot, too cold, just right theming despite not picking up on it until you said it. Heck, you got me into thinking of a couple What If scenarios of my own! My personal favorite of those is an Incredibles scenario, being "What If Frozone Was Sent To Nomanisan?" which is based on the implication that Mirage originally planned to send Lucius the invite before realizing Bob was Mr. Incredible.
Another amazing story. I was impressed by the depth of the challenges they faced. They were nothing I could have imagined myself. The themes were clear, and I enjoyed it so much. I aspire to be such a great storyteller as this.
Now can we finaly get "what if Jack Horner made his wish" so we can finaly see our boy take over the world so no one can stop him not even steven universe ( if you know the memes you know) and get rid off all those pesky magical creatures once and for all!
I already have an idea for how it starts: After Jack emerges from the battle unscathed with everyone else turned into frogs, He smiles smugly as he reaches into his bottomless nanny bag as his frogified foes just stand there. Jack: "Sorry, not sorry, little toadies, but I'm not just gonna bury the hatchet after you broke in here and tried to take MY wish!" He then pulls out a hatchet and promptly kills everyone in the room to ensure that they can't meddle in his affairs any further. Then, just like in the movie, he stuffs the bag full of his magic collection, assembles the bakers' dozen, and they roll out in a pumpkin turned carriage as they leave the city.
Actually, I can imagine a proper twist ending would be that Jack was never that evil at all. He wishes for all the power in the world, and promptly uses that power to bring back all of his workers who died helping him get there. He then uses his power for good from there. And in this scenario, because Puss and Goldi and co were never in the way, never actually stole his map, and never partially to blame for the accidental deaths of his workers, he shows no interest in hurting them. It turns out he only pretended to be apathetic to the lives of others to wind up Jiminy because he was questioning his character. In reality he had his mind set on bringing them back the whole time from the very beginning if he needed to.
@@jamiedannatt4577 what about doing a Double Subversion and make it so Jack is like "actually i dont care about them i just revived them to kill them again lmao" and he actually did this to make jiminy think that he was actually kind but then end up trolling him afterwards
It's sad how this story is relatable to me.. Wanting something and just finding out it's right in front of you, I am just.. Numb.. My mind, my life, everything, I don't feel like myself, I don't feel like who I was born as and neither who I wish to be, I am just *empty*, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, *make the pain stop* !
Oh boy, now you HAVE to do one for Jack (idea; Jack says he wants all the worlds magic for himself right? well what if its too much magic and he explodes into a bunch of confeti like the unicorn horns? and once the smoke clears puss, kitty, and Goldi's family are just standing in a giant star shaped crater covered in confetti. and Kitty can go "wow, that was anti-climactic")
Yeah, I can't do it. I can watch the bad ending. Your writing and description was so compelling and heartwarming that I couldn't ruin it. You are a master story teller. Still an awesome video though. Next up, Kitty Softpaws. That should be really tricky to do, as her wish is the only one not inherently bad.
Here one What if puss never left kitty at the wedding Examples. 1. Death would never go after puss since he valuing his life with kitty. 2. Perito would never met puss but still be happy/safe In the home of retired cats. (As long as doesn’t get caught that he’s a dog) 3. The wishing map would fall into the hands of jack or goldi.
you managed to make me cry again , this family just gets me so emotional all the time, and i had to take a break before continuing to the bad ending cause i just didnt want to see the bears hear what she was gonna wish for, all the journey you built for them was actually pretty emotional lol and i love this series of what ifs although for beeing the bad ending it wasnt that bad, i imagined more tragedy
Only one who here is how he describes how the Wishing Star works and think that either his events would happen or it would just make magic necklaces that allow the Bears to just turn human making them perfect by the storybooks rules as they fit every other descriptor accept their bear the bear part is the only thing that makes the family in perfect
even the bad ending isnt that bad at first i was alittle sad but eventually they could probably forgive her and make her part of the family as she wanted things to truly be just right.
you could have gone for a gray middle route not to sweet, not to sour, but just right she realizes her bear family is her perfect family and simple changes her wish to what fits for all 4 of them
I’m still waiting on the last two wishes kitty and Jack Horner considering this was 7 months ago nearly a year I wonder if these two wouldn’t have much of a story to tell or if this is case of writers block or if he just doesn’t have the time either way I’ll wait as long as I need to
My ideas for possible what-ifs? Monsters University - What if Mike joined Roar Omega Roar? Toy Story - What if Zurg was the toy that Andy got rather than Buzz Lightyear? Cars - What if McQueen never went to Radiator Springs? Turning Red - What if Mei Lee was permanently trapped in her Red Panda form? Puss in Boots: The Last Wish - What if Big Jack Horner encountered Shrek?
Hi.... Hello. I would wonder: since these "what if...." Stories are great, how about a Kitty Softpaw as well? Also, maybe just an idea, but.... Perhaps a Death wish "what is...."?
A possible addendum/alternate sappy end to the bad ending: The 3 bears don't remember her. The world has always been this way. What is this poor girl talking about? maybe she's sick...come now dear, we'll let you rest and talk after we've gotten you some water... And so, while they don't remember her...she, via working hard to fix her mistake and being with them, gets to re-experience falling in love with and becoming a part of their family all over again.
I am *sooo* incredibly happy you gave such an underrated character(s) from this otherwise acclaimed (For all the right reasons, obviously) movie the justice she deserved... Not only are Goldi and the bears an amazingly written and compelling and really funny characters in a vacuum that make most of every single scene they're in and play off of each other wonderfully, but also they are an incredibly well-remade adaptation of Goldi and the Three Bears storyline. The biggest downside of the first Puss in Boots movie, as everybody, me included say, is that it doesn't use the fairytale material it has at its fullest, which otherwise held a *TON* of potential. The second movie however, much like (Three fourths of) the original Shrek movies, not only subverts and changes up the fairytale tropes, but overall just uses them in an incredibly effective way. Like, instead of following the original fairytale step to step, unlike the first Puss in Boots would have (I'm not disrespecting that movie by any means, unlike most I actually think it was quite decent. It could've been a landslide better though, as shown by The Last Wish), it completely changes up Goldi and the Bears. Instead of the bears fearsomely scaring Goldi away because of the messed up beds and the eaten porridge, they take her in and adopt her, serving as the actual, *real* family instead of a made up generic fairytale family, which is a really cool change of events [The same charming subversive adaptation applies to Jack Horner as well, a literal harmless nursery rhyme character turned into sadistic psychopath who rules over a dystopian pie corporation and wants to take over all magic in the world. But this text blob I'm writing is not about him :p]. Anyways, regarding your fanfiction, it's really darn well made and really wholesome, truly does leagues to further underlining the core themes of Goldi's side-plot in the original movie. It's nowhere close as amazing, mature and dark as Puss's one but I guess I have to take that for granted as *he's* the true -favorite fearless hero- main character. One single complaint is that in your story, Goldi should've been punished _WAAAY_ more for her foolish decision at the end than she did, simply not having the life the old, nostalgic, great way, and simply having it fine and the literal storybook definition of ''just right'' ain't cutting it for me. Like come on, Puss got punished with everybody close and beloved to him dying in front of his eyes including Perrito, his favorite -fearless hero- little companion just because he tried to escape his cowardly nature, and then there's Goldi destroying lives and homes of possibly *millions* and simply getting a bland fairytale life that she wasn't content with? Nah man that ain't gonna cut it. I'd expect you to have taken the story in much darker territories, like her ''real'' family appearing to have taken the roles of the bears from the tale (The roles have switched, basically, with the bears being the real loving family and the fairytale ones being the sinister uncaring ones), being cold and strict to the downright insane degree, at one point kicking her out and letting her almost starve to death away, with everybody refusing to help her, until she accidentally stumbles across the little safe haven for the fairytales run by the bears you already described at *25:04**,* after which she truly realizes the gem of a family she had lost and apologizing for her admittedly stupid, downright diabolical decision. But hey, your version is still great as it is.
I still want to see some ideas for what would happen of Jack Horner never had to struggle with the rest of the cast for the map. What would the forest turn into with Jack holding the map? It seems the star's main goal when it terraforms the dark forest is to make the person looking for their wish realize they already have that wish, presumably so that only someone who needs it will actually complete the journey and make the wish. But Jack's wish is actively a bad thing so I could see it more desperately trying to keep Jack from even getting to make the wish at all.
Hello. I like these “what-if” videos that you are posting. In the future, can you do a scenario where the superheroes in The Incredibles were never outlawed and forced underground? Or one where Mack never fell asleep on the highway and Lightning made it to California for his tie-breaker race on time?
Imagine how funny it would have been if when Goldie made her wish the Three Bears turn into people like their literally the exact same just humans and not bears😂
Considering that Jack Runs the Factory….I always wondered how The Escape from Jack Horner’s Factory if Jack Horner was the one who escaped the/his Factory triumphantly with The Map.
@@adammartinez8061 Maybe Jack Horner will be a little bit more smarter, finding out that Puss and Kitty was abt to steal the map before they really get it/the bears come, then he’ll just lock them up (or just kill them, depending on what he chooses) and simply leave the factory
1 of 3 things would happen 1. The star turns the bears into humans 2. The star turn Goldi into a bear 3. The star just teleports the bears a few steps closer to Goldi
Awesome Hey dude I’ve been watching these “multiverse” videos and I FREAKING LOVE EM! And I have some ideas for some others But it’s ok if you don’t wanna hear I’m just saying that I really enjoy them , keep up good work
Cannot wait for Jack's version of this! Gonna be the shortest of them all honestly but I REALLY wanna see Finn's interpritation of what Horner's version of the map looks like :D
An ad that was just right, paussing for me before the bad ending because i didn't have mi hands available, first and probably only time that has happened
Yup. Especially since Right as Puss, Kitty and Perrito escaped in the movie….death appeared so he was probably making his way up to Jacks office where a incapacitated Puss, Kitty and Jack were while Goldi and three bears escaped with the map In this. F.
I know it's been a while since you did this one, but could you do one of these for the Shrek-verse: 1.) Puss doesn't scratch the Constable at that crucial moment in the original Puss in Boots, meaning that Humpty gets arrested and Puss stays the hero and never becomes an outlaw. (This one has far-reaching implications that span even into the Shrekverse, starting with Shrek 2.) 2.) Shrek and Fiona DO become the new King and Queen of Far Far Away instead of Artie at the end of Shrek the Third. (Maybe Artie pulls the sword from the stone and becomes king of Camelot instead.) 3.) Shrek and Fiona DO choose to KEEP their beautiful forms at the end of Shrek 2. 4.) Fiona does reveal herself to Shrek (become she can transform at sunrise) and the two share true love's first kiss (we can also assume that Shrek never misheard Donka and Fiona earlier) and that the two are married, BUT, they don't return to DuLoc, meaning Shrek didn't technically complete his mission to Farquaad, and so now they have to defeat him. (We can also assume that, with this change in events, Donkey may not have wandered off and found Dragon, so they might have to defeat the tyrant of Duloc without her.) 5.) What if Fiona had been the one who had been who had been frustrated with life in Shrek Forever After and had made the "Deal of a Lifetime" with Rumple instead of Shrek being the one that did it? 6.) What if Charming had rescued Fiona before Shrek got there? 7.) What if Fiona was NEVER cursed?
It would’ve been kinda funny if, when Goldi made her wish, clones of the three bears just appeared and that’s it
I wanted to say that Goldi and her family were my personal favourite characters and the highlights of the film. Despite being a "crime" family, they are just as charming, amusing and loveable as the Moomins.
I honestly imagine their “crime” family thing was more of a mafia deal, where the bears mostly run a sort of forest crime syndicate. They’re not too demanding, but not too forgiving.
@@battybuddy they’re just right lol
@@astralaurora4165yeah and pretty balanced too
Ayo, I didn't expect a Moomin mention. (ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ
@@triceratops3 yes definitely
If I could provide an alternative wish that would make everyone happy, perhaps Goldi realizes that the bears have provided for her their entire life, and now wants to use the star to repay the favor. Instead of wishing for a new family, she wishes for her family to be given a new chance, and to live like a family, not on the run or living in the shadows as they evade the police, but rather to actually be part of a community of other friendly people, and to grow and evolve with them. After the wish, Mama and Papa feel a bit younger, but when they see Goldi and Baby, the two are definitely younger than before the wish, and they realize that Goldi didn't wish for a new family. There are three slips of paper in Goldi's hand, with three different addresses. One is an address for their new home; still in the forest, but much closer to civilization so they won't have to worry about being alone, another slip being the location of a school that Baby and Goldi will be attending, and another being the location of Mama and Papa bear's new family business, but instead of pie making like it is in the movie, it's porridge making. They're still the same bears and people, but Goldi wanted to give them a chance to start a new life and to let everyone know just how great they are. Baby Bear is moved to tears by this wish she made, while Papa gives a soft chuckle and ruffled her head, saying how when all they had is porridge for their lives, perhaps trying this new life out won't be such a bad idea, and Mama Bear is proud of Goldi for her idea, happy to see that she saw what has been in front of her all this time, with them leaving the forest, with Baby on Papa's back, while Mama carries off Goldi on her back, ready to at least give this new life a chance.
But I will admit, Goldi accidentally causing global damage with her wish was something I never expected, so good job on creativity.
This is amazing and so creative I love it you're so creative
What if the bears prefer their old life? Like, while a new life would be better, arent they happy with their normal life? Besides, a new life may not be fitting for them.
@@dylanzlol7293 well I think a new life where you don't have to worry about going to jail is real nice ya wanker
@@dylanzlol7293 Yeah, I admit I didn't word that part very well. I was going on a path of suggesting that Goldi offered to make a wish that could let them have a better life, and coming up with that idea, while still offering them the chance to back out if they want. Should have put a bit more thought into that one.
Damn this is great, tho they would never leave their home lmao, maybe if it was uprooted and plunked down elsewhere but if assume they'd know the area well aswell
What if in the good ending. When Goldielocks makes her wish. She wishes that she and the bears would forever be a true family. And when it's granted she turns into a bear with golden fur. Ofcourse she and the bears are shocked at first. But then they just except it as something extra. Now they are the four bears and lives happily ever after.
Eh it's cute but ruins the whole adopted dynamic thing.
a golden bear... now where have a seen that before.
@@komannbahadur2767 omg fnaf reference (real)
While i cant help but like that idea, i also cant agree with it. The whole point is that theyre already family and everythings "just right".
Something like them having a more 'normal' happy family life, were theyre not a criminal family on the run but live in/among a town working/going to school and just being happy in a community fits more.
My bad ending would be a lot crueler...
Firstly it doesn't bring the entire book's setting into the real world. What it does do is that it replaces anything from Goldi's life with something from the book. I.E. the house of the bears becomes the house from the book. And the bears would be replaced too. They'd be swapped with the family from the book, as in the people she once knew have basically been erased from existence and replaced with her ideal family. Goldi is happy initially, but laments over the absence of the bears. So she wonders where they are, and asks around only to find that no one knows who she's even talking about. Eventually after investigating the house, and finding that it's in the same spot as the bear's house she realizes what's going on. Regreting the mistake she made, she confronts the parents and tries to pry and find a way to reverse what she did. However the parents are unsure of what she's even talking about. So in frustration and regret she runs away trying to find a way to fix it. After a long while she realizes that there is nothing she can do. So Goldi continues to wonder the world as the orphan girl that she once was, painfully accepting that nothing can go back to being just right.
Damn, that's dark...
Honestly, I thought that that was where the video was headed :/
2 things.
1: Will we get endings for Kitty and Jack? (Maybe Perrito)
2: What would happen to Puss and Kitty in this new reality?
I imagine Puss and Kitty are still thieves and they rob from the many kingdoms. Although I don't think they would have started over their relationship in this AU so....
@@zomboss3904 Wasn’t death still after Puss? And wasn’t he in the same city when Puss would get turned into a defenceless chicken in this reality? Also, forgot to ask about perrito in this world
@@punmasterlv1677 I forgot about Death as well. I think Death would still be after Puss and Perrito would just still follow Puss around
I think Puss would try and kill Puss in Jacks building but would accidentally kill Jack instead, then Kitty and Puss would escape with Perrito. With his only option of getting his lives back gone, Puss would pour his heart out to Kitty and they would make up. Death would leave them alone and then the kingdoms would merge, so Puss and Kitty would make a new mission to find others like Shrek and donkey while looting kingdoms along the way.
One idea that came to mind is what would the other characters in the story be like. I feel like Jack, Perrito, and Kitty would stay the same with Jack still being a self entitled prick, and kitty and perrito still possibly becoming friends. However I feel like the idea of the wishing star being gone and with no way to get his live back, push would become deranged and crazy always attacking people who looked liked or resembeld the wolf or even his whistle would cause him to lose it. We could see not only is puss still an outlaw but a psychopath seemingly attacking people at random, which would get the bears attention with one of the refugees being a victim of puss's attack. Eventually kitty would come to the bears asking for help to find and help puss as even she is terrified of what her once best friend, and lover, became. When they start to search for him baby decides to do a little whistle which he thinks is nothing but to quell the silence, but they eventually hear a rustling in the nearby bushes and try to find out what it is. When they get close puss jumps out like a maniac attacking all of them thinking they are a part of Death's little trick. Even with them trying to get him to calm down it does nothing, and when they try to get him to explain why he is like this which leads to him telling them about the wolf and how he was going to use the star to get his live back. Goldi realizing the way wish affected puss tells him that she used it to get a proper family, the bears give a little side eye, but before she could explain anything else puss lunges at her blaming her for his hysteria. When Goldi finally gets a moment to speak she talks about how the wish wouldn't give him any satisfaction and only leads to more pain. Puss starting to calm down begins to realize everything he did and start to breakdown, but as kitty comes to comfort him death shows up. Puss realizes that if he keeps running he will never be free of his fear so when death challenges him to fight puss agrees, an excuse to get the awesome fight still. when Puss wins death realizes that he finally accepts life for what it is and leaves saying, "Took you long enough Gato." Even with death gone puss still feels terrible for everything he did and tries to fix every bit of pain he caused. Not only would Goldi learn her lesson but puss as well.
Honestly I was expecting Goldie to get her wish in the movie and for the star to just turn her into a bear
Prefer what we got but if that did happen it would have foreshadowed what Godie said to them earlier that she not a bear
Would’ve been better than Brother Bear
Based on what you mentioned about that “bad ending” it immediately made me think of what happened in Shrek. With Lord farquod (not sorry for misspelling his name) kingdom, taking over everything and not letting the fairytales have their own territory.
(In a universe where Jack never escaped from the bag)
Puss: You should have the wish. You deserve someone you can trust.
Kitty: I don't need it. I got what I wanted. No magic required.
Puss looked around to see Perrito, Goldie, and the Bears. None of them needed the wish.
Puss: Well we can't just leave empty handed after coming all this way. Everyone put your heads together. There has to be something we all want.
???: If none of you require the wish, I could take it.
They all turn towards the familiar voice as Death stood amongst them once again.
Puss: You want it?
Death: Does it surprise you that Death has a wish?
Puss: More just concerned over what that wish could be.
Death: (sigh) I swear on my honor as a reaper and a warrior that I will not use it to harm you or anyone else. I wish to regain something precious to me that was lost. Something that lies beyond even my reach. But perhaps not the Star's.
After a few moments, Puss hesitantly relinquished the map.
Death: Starlight, Starbright, first star I see tonight. I wish I may, I wish I might, have the wish I wish tonight.
Suddenly, Death stops speaking as he begins fighting back tears to the surprise of those gathered.
Death: Please...give me back my brothers!
With that, the star exploded into the sky in a massive beam of light, leaving the gathered standing in a crater. And a moment later, three more beams of light slamed into the ground in between them and Death, revealing three new figures. A rat who seemed to make them sick just from looking at him, a raven who made them feel insatiably hungry, and a lion who filled them with inexplicable rage. But Death could only smile.
Death: War, Famine, Pestilence.
War: It is good to see you again too, Brother.
Famine: It's been far too long.
Pestilence: Indeed. Shall we ride, again?
Death: Nothing would make me happier.
With that, the four brothers summoned spectral steeds and rode out of sight. The remaining creatures stood there in shock and terror as Puss turned to Kitty.
Puss: Did we just unleash the Apocalypse?
Kitty: Yep.
(After they rode in the mists and all the creatures stunned frozen, *insert Darksiders' storyline as a fairy tale theme*)
This is kinda wholesome despite it being the apocalypse
@@SaoryEmanoelle Sure.
Death making a wish sounds cool
@@SaoryEmanoelle lol based
I thought the bad ending that Goldilocks “perfect family” killed the tree bears and turned them into a rugs like from Shrek 1 I glad he didn’t do that
Way to imagine new locations. I especially loved Papa handling the molten locks in the mountains and both endings were great Finn. Not even all that depressing tbh since the bad ending at least had a good semi redemption. My route was somewhat similar when Goldi makes the wish and does get her perfect parents and they obviously love her but as days go by they start either smothering her or try to make her just as perfect and critize/iron out her bearish tendencies like burping, fighting, getting dirty, committing crimes, singing that silly pie song, or basically any acting out etc. Eventually Goldie just can't take it anymore but the only reminder of her real family is just 3 stuffed toys that look like Mama, Papa, and Baby. Or to make it really dark have her new dad be a hunter and he mounted the formers heads in the house as the Stars reminder "You got what you wanted, but at what cost? least you can be together forever. Hope everything is finally just right now you selfish ungrateful brat." Unsure if either choice would fit the Shrek franchise but that was just my take on it.
I dont think that the Wishing star is like the monkey's paw that goes "granted, but your new family is strict and they kill your old family.", like, while the wishing star may try to make you realize that you dont need to make the wish, it isnt going out of its way to prevent you from getting your wish if youre unconvinced, and would adjust the wish to make it better.
@dylanzlol7293 yeah good point I was leaning more towards my first option
This is an interesting take. Goldie’s wish definitely had a lot of gray area to it. Since she wasn’t too descriptive of her wish, it sounded like how a genie would grant a wish and find a loophole. Reminds me a lot of the first Shrek and Shrek Forever After. Everyone being driven off their land due to kingdoms taking over. Wonder what happened to Puss and Kitty in this scenario.
Death was shown to be near in the movie when Puss, Kitty and Perrito escaped. So Puss is probably dead.
Please do kitty next! There's so much we can learn about her through the Shrek and previous puss in boots movies.
I'm actually surprised you didn't have Goldie say something like; "you said it yourself baby...I'm not a bear. I'm an orphan lookin for my own parents" as a way to not only justify her motive but also point out that baby, in her perspective, always treated her as temporary instead of family.
Considering the wishing star will always bring someone an introspective three step journey to make them understand that they don’t need a magic wish, is Perrito the opposite of the usual rule? He had a much harsher origin that, while it could get better it could never be “fixed”, so was his journey an attempt to convince him to use the wish for a good reason, instead of everyone else who it tried to prevent from backing a bad one.
Aside from maybe Goldies and Jack I don't think any of the main charecthers wishes are bad, just not what they actually needed
Like many people said, I thought that if Goldie did made her wish, either it would end up with the bears transforming into humans or Goldie transforming into a bear with blonde fur.
Also for the second ending, I choose option C. Another wishing star would eventually fall so Goldie can undo what she did and get everything back to normal.
This is great! I hope you do Jack next, because I am really curious on what the Wishing Star would do to help him with his problem. Me and my friend theorized that the Map would make him realize that he already has all the magic with how many magical artifacts he has stolen over the years. But I would like to see your take?
Also two other requests, both for the same movie. 1. What If Po Never Made It Over The Gate? Quite self-explanatory, what if Po's fireworks chair never worked and Oogway picked Tigress instead. Would she be able to beat Tai Lung? What about Po and Ping? And what would happen to the Valley of Peace? And the next one
What If Oogway Made Tai Lung the Dragon Warrior? This one got me because Tai Lung only became evil because he couldn't have the title. Which, further proved Oogway's point. But what if he did? Would he able to prove Oogway wrong, or would he still become filled with darkness
These are pretty good, I'd also add a new one, what if Po forgave Tai Lung's Life? What if Maybe instead of skadooshing Tai Lung, Po decided to spare him since he acknowledged that Tai Lung only did what he did out of feeling like he disappointed his father figure and gave him a chance to start over, i feel like that could have a lot of potential for a story
@@v1ct0r1n01 That sounds interesting.
I said how Jack horner's path would be like.
First path: it shows what would happen if Jack got his wish, everyone is suffering obviously, but what matters is, the Jack of this illusion is unhappy, after all, he got everything he wanted, and it feels empty. "Youll always want more."
Second path: this would show how Jack horner's life would be like if he went down another path. Doesnt necessarily have to stop being evil, but even being a bit kinder could make things better than pure evil.
Third path: nothing, just infinite nothingness, the only way to get past this path is if Jack horner starts to reconsider his ideas, maybe it isnt necessary to be evil? Maybe theres nothing to gain from this? Even if it is admittedly fun and quirky, how far would that get him? Many have probably tried to get Jack to change, but its not like he ever started to consider these words before.
@@dylanzlol7293 Yeah and the thing I noticed he kept saying he was *EVIL* with the same tone (I felt) like Puss saying he was *FEARLESS* ...
A possible result of redemption?
So he would try to avoid greed/envy?
If only, if only...
@@ellienugent6839 Jack is like a more-evil version of puss?
I think what would have been more tragic is either A( the bears don’t remember Goldi since they never adopted her. B( some time past on and mama died of a broken heart and papa soon after, baby is alive with a family of his own. He resents Goldie and doesn’t want her involved with his family, breaking her heart in the process.
It would be funny if she made her wish and it just turned the three bears into humans
Mission succesfully failed
Y’know what would be interesting for a mini theory?
What if death didn’t forgive puss at the end and killed him there
That could also tie into a theory where jack gets his wish
Alternatively "what if death wasn't a massive drama queen and just killed him in the final fight"
Then puss dies and we get boohoo waambulance funeral, thats it. It kinda depends on his role on shrek 5, its possible that nothing could change or something does change (through at that point youre better off making a "what if puss didnt do x thing that advanced shreck 5's plot" vid.)
Kitty and Perrito use the wishing star map to bring Puss back
@@zephyr9852 the idea entails that without puss to help jack somehow gets the wish
It’d be a neat tie in theory
@@zephyr9852 Death be like:
"What, you can't do this to me. You know how much I sacrificed"
Finn, have you heard of something called Mort Theory? It was created by TH-camr "The Theorizer", originally intended to just be a dissection of Mort from "Madagascar", he found that it could not only tie to every Dreamworks film but also to every theory (or at least most) he made on one. The reason I say this is because Death in this movie canonized the theory to a terrifying extent. Interested?
I need to review this theory of what it was. I remember it was quite an interesting treat when I first heard it.
@@BuizelCream Just search "The Theorzer Mort", and you'll find it with no problem. Part 17 gives a summary of the theory.
@@BuizelCream dude there are now like over 30 parts its wild you need to see it
@@amagicalbeing7427 Yeah, I just checked, and I'm gonna binge watch it all, and have a lot of interesting things for my mind to ponder over xD
“what if soft paws made her wish?” “what if Jack Horner made his wish?” “what if PERRITO made a wish?” “WHAT IF THE CHEFFS MADE A WISH?”
Imagine Perrito's wish is like that one episode of gravity falls and he wishes for a life supply of snacks
@@kaylaHat bro i think everyone would go:.... PERRITO YOU PIECE OF SH-
What if shrek made a wish?
I want Jack Horner
Can’t wait to see how Jack’s story turns out
I always pictured him popping like a balloon. No one mortal creature could survive all the magic in the world being infused into it.
@@amitamaru maybe the star QUITE LITERALLY gives him all the magic in the world, yea everyone looses the ability to use magical spells or potions or stuff like that as it all gets absorbed into Jack but he gets SO much that his body can't take it and he explodes.
@@amitamarusorta like kai from kung fu panda
Fun fact: In the Latin American dub for this movie, Goldi and the Three Bears speak with an Argentinian accent, much like how they speak with an Australian accent in the original dub.
Australian? You’re havin’ me on, they’re definitely up for a spot of tea rather than a barby mate. No they’re definitley British plum fam.
@@amberwolf9401 Yeah, maybe they sound more British, sorry about that
Great scenario! Love the too hot, too cold, just right theming despite not picking up on it until you said it. Heck, you got me into thinking of a couple What If scenarios of my own!
My personal favorite of those is an Incredibles scenario, being "What If Frozone Was Sent To Nomanisan?" which is based on the implication that Mirage originally planned to send Lucius the invite before realizing Bob was Mr. Incredible.
Another amazing story. I was impressed by the depth of the challenges they faced. They were nothing I could have imagined myself. The themes were clear, and I enjoyed it so much. I aspire to be such a great storyteller as this.
Now can we finaly get "what if Jack Horner made his wish" so we can finaly see our boy take over the world so no one can stop him not even steven universe ( if you know the memes you know) and get rid off all those pesky magical creatures once and for all!
I already have an idea for how it starts: After Jack emerges from the battle unscathed with everyone else turned into frogs, He smiles smugly as he reaches into his bottomless nanny bag as his frogified foes just stand there. Jack: "Sorry, not sorry, little toadies, but I'm not just gonna bury the hatchet after you broke in here and tried to take MY wish!" He then pulls out a hatchet and promptly kills everyone in the room to ensure that they can't meddle in his affairs any further. Then, just like in the movie, he stuffs the bag full of his magic collection, assembles the bakers' dozen, and they roll out in a pumpkin turned carriage as they leave the city.
Lord Farkwad's legacy...
@@blueandthecrew okay that is actualy a really good idea
Actually, I can imagine a proper twist ending would be that Jack was never that evil at all. He wishes for all the power in the world, and promptly uses that power to bring back all of his workers who died helping him get there. He then uses his power for good from there.
And in this scenario, because Puss and Goldi and co were never in the way, never actually stole his map, and never partially to blame for the accidental deaths of his workers, he shows no interest in hurting them.
It turns out he only pretended to be apathetic to the lives of others to wind up Jiminy because he was questioning his character. In reality he had his mind set on bringing them back the whole time from the very beginning if he needed to.
@@jamiedannatt4577 what about doing a Double Subversion and make it so Jack is like "actually i dont care about them i just revived them to kill them again lmao" and he actually did this to make jiminy think that he was actually kind but then end up trolling him afterwards
It's sad how this story is relatable to me.. Wanting something and just finding out it's right in front of you, I am just.. Numb.. My mind, my life, everything, I don't feel like myself, I don't feel like who I was born as and neither who I wish to be, I am just *empty*, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, make the pain stop, *make the pain stop* !
I wish you could feel happy
I pray God helps you through the dark times you are facing ❤
Oh boy, now you HAVE to do one for Jack
(idea; Jack says he wants all the worlds magic for himself right? well what if its too much magic and he explodes into a bunch of confeti like the unicorn horns? and once the smoke clears puss, kitty, and Goldi's family are just standing in a giant star shaped crater covered in confetti. and Kitty can go "wow, that was anti-climactic")
And considering Jack Runs his Factory….How would the escape scene play out….If He Escaped.
Yeah, I can't do it. I can watch the bad ending. Your writing and description was so compelling and heartwarming that I couldn't ruin it. You are a master story teller. Still an awesome video though. Next up, Kitty Softpaws. That should be really tricky to do, as her wish is the only one not inherently bad.
Here one
What if puss never left kitty at the wedding
Examples.
1. Death would never go after puss since he valuing his life with kitty.
2. Perito would never met puss but still be happy/safe In the home of retired cats.
(As long as doesn’t get caught that he’s a dog)
3. The wishing map would fall into the hands of jack or goldi.
@@josiahtekira5114 death is still going after puss, considering that he is still filled with ego, which would make him lose more of his lives.
Same here. I really want to bit I also really don't
I’d be interesting to hear an AU of what Death’s wish could be, if he had one.
I think someone wrote a very fun scenario somewhere in these comments. Think it was towards the top
Problably do the oppisite of Pusse's wish, killing Puss right then and there.
Any chance we'll get to see Kitty make her wish?
you managed to make me cry again , this family just gets me so emotional all the time, and i had to take a break before continuing to the bad ending cause i just didnt want to see the bears hear what she was gonna wish for, all the journey you built for them was actually pretty emotional lol and i love this series of what ifs although for beeing the bad ending it wasnt that bad, i imagined more tragedy
We need to see what would happen in jack got his wish. We have to see what'll happen along the way
Jack Horner kinda reminds me of Kefka from FF6
Can you do one about what would have happened if Oogway let Tai Lung become the Dragon Warrior
Very Good and Goldilocks is a sweet redeemable lady voiced by Helena Belofa aka 2nd Black Widow Florence Pugh.
Only one who here is how he describes how the Wishing Star works and think that either his events would happen or it would just make magic necklaces that allow the Bears to just turn human making them perfect by the storybooks rules as they fit every other descriptor accept their bear the bear part is the only thing that makes the family in perfect
that would be the best ending for goldilocks bc she realises she already has a family early
even the bad ending isnt that bad at first i was alittle sad but eventually they could probably forgive her and make her part of the family as she wanted things to truly be just right.
you could have gone for a gray middle route
not to sweet, not to sour, but just right
she realizes her bear family is her perfect family and simple changes her wish to what fits for all 4 of them
She wishes to turn the bears into humans maybe? That way it’s the same family only now she fits in
Or she tosses Baby the map and he wishes for a really purple suit
I’m still waiting on the last two wishes kitty and Jack Horner considering this was 7 months ago nearly a year I wonder if these two wouldn’t have much of a story to tell or if this is case of writers block or if he just doesn’t have the time either way I’ll wait as long as I need to
THIS MAN NEEDS TO MAKE A MOVIE
My ideas for possible what-ifs?
Monsters University - What if Mike joined Roar Omega Roar?
Toy Story - What if Zurg was the toy that Andy got rather than Buzz Lightyear?
Cars - What if McQueen never went to Radiator Springs?
Turning Red - What if Mei Lee was permanently trapped in her Red Panda form?
Puss in Boots: The Last Wish - What if Big Jack Horner encountered Shrek?
Hi.... Hello. I would wonder: since these "what if...." Stories are great, how about a Kitty Softpaw as well?
Also, maybe just an idea, but.... Perhaps a Death wish "what is...."?
Please come back with this series, it's my favorite "What if" videos in TH-cam, it's really well done
A possible addendum/alternate sappy end to the bad ending:
The 3 bears don't remember her. The world has always been this way. What is this poor girl talking about? maybe she's sick...come now dear, we'll let you rest and talk after we've gotten you some water...
And so, while they don't remember her...she, via working hard to fix her mistake and being with them, gets to re-experience falling in love with and becoming a part of their family all over again.
You integrated your ideas into the story nicely. 👍
Who else wants a spin-off series about the Crime-Bear family's many escapades??? Maybe a prequel of Goldi growing up with the bears?
I do!
I sooo definitely do!!!!!
25:51 NO WRONG, Wouldn't they forget her??
This man needs to be a writer. Books, movies, anything. He makes gold worthy of shrek himself!
If she made her wish, nothing would have happened. She had what she wanted, but just didn't see it. Same with Kitty.
It's impressive how you fit all these words in 30 minutes. :3
Now I wanna know how screwed everyone would be if Jack got his wish.
Hey! I know you have a series going on but I would LOVEEE a the ghost and Molly McGee video! And also this video is really good :D !
I remember seeing your original video and it scared me because it was at night at 2 a.m. . Good memorys
Sounded like a fairytale version of Wandavision for a second
I am *sooo* incredibly happy you gave such an underrated character(s) from this otherwise acclaimed (For all the right reasons, obviously) movie the justice she deserved... Not only are Goldi and the bears an amazingly written and compelling and really funny characters in a vacuum that make most of every single scene they're in and play off of each other wonderfully, but also they are an incredibly well-remade adaptation of Goldi and the Three Bears storyline. The biggest downside of the first Puss in Boots movie, as everybody, me included say, is that it doesn't use the fairytale material it has at its fullest, which otherwise held a *TON* of potential. The second movie however, much like (Three fourths of) the original Shrek movies, not only subverts and changes up the fairytale tropes, but overall just uses them in an incredibly effective way. Like, instead of following the original fairytale step to step, unlike the first Puss in Boots would have (I'm not disrespecting that movie by any means, unlike most I actually think it was quite decent. It could've been a landslide better though, as shown by The Last Wish), it completely changes up Goldi and the Bears. Instead of the bears fearsomely scaring Goldi away because of the messed up beds and the eaten porridge, they take her in and adopt her, serving as the actual, *real* family instead of a made up generic fairytale family, which is a really cool change of events [The same charming subversive adaptation applies to Jack Horner as well, a literal harmless nursery rhyme character turned into sadistic psychopath who rules over a dystopian pie corporation and wants to take over all magic in the world. But this text blob I'm writing is not about him :p].
Anyways, regarding your fanfiction, it's really darn well made and really wholesome, truly does leagues to further underlining the core themes of Goldi's side-plot in the original movie. It's nowhere close as amazing, mature and dark as Puss's one but I guess I have to take that for granted as *he's* the true -favorite fearless hero- main character. One single complaint is that in your story, Goldi should've been punished _WAAAY_ more for her foolish decision at the end than she did, simply not having the life the old, nostalgic, great way, and simply having it fine and the literal storybook definition of ''just right'' ain't cutting it for me. Like come on, Puss got punished with everybody close and beloved to him dying in front of his eyes including Perrito, his favorite -fearless hero- little companion just because he tried to escape his cowardly nature, and then there's Goldi destroying lives and homes of possibly *millions* and simply getting a bland fairytale life that she wasn't content with? Nah man that ain't gonna cut it. I'd expect you to have taken the story in much darker territories, like her ''real'' family appearing to have taken the roles of the bears from the tale (The roles have switched, basically, with the bears being the real loving family and the fairytale ones being the sinister uncaring ones), being cold and strict to the downright insane degree, at one point kicking her out and letting her almost starve to death away, with everybody refusing to help her, until she accidentally stumbles across the little safe haven for the fairytales run by the bears you already described at *25:04**,* after which she truly realizes the gem of a family she had lost and apologizing for her admittedly stupid, downright diabolical decision. But hey, your version is still great as it is.
I still want to see some ideas for what would happen of Jack Horner never had to struggle with the rest of the cast for the map. What would the forest turn into with Jack holding the map? It seems the star's main goal when it terraforms the dark forest is to make the person looking for their wish realize they already have that wish, presumably so that only someone who needs it will actually complete the journey and make the wish. But Jack's wish is actively a bad thing so I could see it more desperately trying to keep Jack from even getting to make the wish at all.
OOOH, A SERIES FOR THIS! HOW EXCITING!
That story felt like it could’ve been in the actual movie. Very well done
I loved their story line more that Puss’s in the movie, made me tear up a bit
Also considering what happens to puss in this scenario, any minute now a certain whistle shall ring out in Jack’s office.
This movie gave us so many great characters 😊
Hello. I like these “what-if” videos that you are posting. In the future, can you do a scenario where the superheroes in The Incredibles were never outlawed and forced underground? Or one where Mack never fell asleep on the highway and Lightning made it to California for his tie-breaker race on time?
Why did a story WITHOUT ANIMATION make me tear up
👁👄👁
I am truly blown away by the effort that he put in this
(Also there’s a undertale reference soooooooo 10/5)
(The reference is here 2:28)
You should've had some explanation as to what happened to Puss, as Death would still certainly be hunting him...
Probably died...........
Death was near when Puss, Kitty and Perrito escaped with the map in the movie……
He’d certainly still be near in this What if……
7:36
Dude, you had the opportunity to call her Goldirocks and you just missed it.
You should do kitty soft paws next!
That would be cool 😎
Imagine how funny it would have been if when Goldie made her wish the Three Bears turn into people like their literally the exact same just humans and not bears😂
Will you ever do a part 3 because I really want to see Kitty's wish
Great video and what if scenario, cant wait to see you tackle what if with other characters like Kitty Softpaws and Jack Horner
Considering that Jack Runs the Factory….I always wondered how The Escape from Jack Horner’s Factory if Jack Horner was the one who escaped the/his Factory triumphantly with The Map.
@@adammartinez8061 Maybe Jack Horner will be a little bit more smarter, finding out that Puss and Kitty was abt to steal the map before they really get it/the bears come, then he’ll just lock them up (or just kill them, depending on what he chooses) and simply leave the factory
if jack got his wish the entire world would turn to ashes
I’m happy it’s just 2 good endings unlike the “what if puss got his wish” one
1 of 3 things would happen
1. The star turns the bears into humans
2. The star turn Goldi into a bear
3. The star just teleports the bears a few steps closer to Goldi
Are we gonna get a if kitty made her wish
I love the good (it clicks) ending, as it just feels true and pure. I also love the main (wish made) ending, for the existentialism.
Awesome
Hey dude I’ve been watching these “multiverse” videos and I FREAKING LOVE EM!
And I have some ideas for some others
But it’s ok if you don’t wanna hear I’m just saying that I really enjoy them , keep up good work
What if Jack got his wish? Or kitty softpaws?
Cannot wait for Jack's version of this! Gonna be the shortest of them all honestly but I REALLY wanna see Finn's interpritation of what Horner's version of the map looks like :D
I wonder what would happen if Jack Horner picked up the map to the wishing star.
There would be at least 30 areas all of them just being the result of the star/map just saying "stop..." "Stop" "STOP IT!"
So is there actually a “good ending” for him
@@adcoxfamily9656 The map would try to make Jack's journey a utter hell if he got a hand of it.
I know what happens if he actually made the wish. Magical power causes him to explode into confetti!
I like this series. Here is a suggestion:
What if ACU Ben convinced Glad'X to get rid of his curse?
This came up on my recommended while eating porridge
I was half expecting the bears to turn into humans. But, I do like both endings.
I imagine that meme with a genie:
Goldi: But, nothing has changed...
The star: Exactly.
I just thought her family would just....appear.
Can you do what if perrito wanted a wish pls
i feel like there could be a third ending where goldi still makes a wish but since the adventure changed her point of view her wish changes with it
Please do Kitty Softpaws next!
What if no one got their wish but the wishing star survived?
I haven’t even watched the movie yet and I’m already hyped to watch it after the waiting for it when it comes out on streaming
More of this please
An ad that was just right, paussing for me before the bad ending because i didn't have mi hands available, first and probably only time that has happened
I like to think in this or any future versions of the last wish AU death actually succeeded with killing puss press F to pay respect
Yup. Especially since Right as Puss, Kitty and Perrito escaped in the movie….death appeared so he was probably making his way up to Jacks office where a incapacitated Puss, Kitty and Jack were while Goldi and three bears escaped with the map In this.
F.
dammit, i want a goldilocks spinoff movie now
You can make a video If kitty softpaws made her wish?
this is cool ngl. I saw the video of puss getting the wish and it made me cry- Imagine living forever...That would suck.
I know it's been a while since you did this one, but could you do one of these for the Shrek-verse:
1.) Puss doesn't scratch the Constable at that crucial moment in the original Puss in Boots, meaning that Humpty gets arrested and Puss stays the hero and never becomes an outlaw. (This one has far-reaching implications that span even into the Shrekverse, starting with Shrek 2.)
2.) Shrek and Fiona DO become the new King and Queen of Far Far Away instead of Artie at the end of Shrek the Third. (Maybe Artie pulls the sword from the stone and becomes king of Camelot instead.)
3.) Shrek and Fiona DO choose to KEEP their beautiful forms at the end of Shrek 2.
4.) Fiona does reveal herself to Shrek (become she can transform at sunrise) and the two share true love's first kiss (we can also assume that Shrek never misheard Donka and Fiona earlier) and that the two are married, BUT, they don't return to DuLoc, meaning Shrek didn't technically complete his mission to Farquaad, and so now they have to defeat him. (We can also assume that, with this change in events, Donkey may not have wandered off and found Dragon, so they might have to defeat the tyrant of Duloc without her.)
5.) What if Fiona had been the one who had been who had been frustrated with life in Shrek Forever After and had made the "Deal of a Lifetime" with Rumple instead of Shrek being the one that did it?
6.) What if Charming had rescued Fiona before Shrek got there?
7.) What if Fiona was NEVER cursed?
I love Goldie and the bears in the movie
The places really do like tormenting Goldie as therapy. It works too
It would be interesting to see the journey Kitty would take if she made her wish.
Here's a little fairy tale fun fact:
Both Puss in boots and goldilocks are sometimes foxes in variants of their tales.
I want to see what Jack’s story would be like? I don’t know if there’ll be a good or bad ending, or both?