FAQ's: Why didn't you include the Order 66 scene from Jedi: Fallen Order? This scene is revealed as a flashback over halfway through the story of the game and I think it is better left as a reveal in that story. This way I also don't spoil it for people who haven't played the game. Why didn't you include any of the 2003 2D animated Clone Wars show? I don't think the attack on Coruscant from that show would work well being edited into Ahsoka's return for pacing and tonal reasons. Also it's not canon, which is a lesser issue to me since I included non-canon deleted scenes. Why didn't you include more deleted scenes? The remaining deleted scenes from Revenge of the Sith either have unfinished special effects or do not line up with the continuity of the scenes in the film.
A lot of these scenes are way out of order. I don’t mean to sound mean but idk why all fan project suddenly become masterpieces just because they’re unprofessional.
Given how long it must've taken them to get to the ship, recover the bodies, and then bury them it would've fit better at the end but it's a minor flaw.
These are some of the best transitions I’ve seen in any fan edit of RotS and CW:SoM. I really like the use of chapter titles, but the reason they work so well is your use of music and audio to blend the clips into a seamless story. Really great job!
That looks amazing! But personally I would not cut in-between anything from anakin, obiwans, yodas and sudiouses duel with anything from the bad batch the scene feels way less climactic and whats happening in the bad batch seems so inconsequential to everything else. Regardless I'm super exited to watch it
Thanks! If you are referring to the sound of the applause from the live-action scene, I replaced it because it was the only way to make the music from both scenes mesh together.
How long can this edit get? Let's see, it could be longer with: -2003 clone wars battle of coruscant -Revenge of the sith tie in game cutscenes -fallen order flashback -all of the deleted scenes even if they contradict each other -literally any footage of anything happening during episode 3
@@Fandmadetrailers It wouldn't fit the pacing or have any impact for someone who hasn't played or doesn't care about fallen order. This was about making the best possible RotS+ experience, while still being a good film(s), not adding every little thing just because.
@@xdress1746 I understand but it would be cool to have all the jedi deaths be recorded in such a long edited movie. The whole movie was made to show all the events of Revenge of the Sith without watching them separately.
Amazing! In a vacuum, I can see how having The Bad Batch squeezed in there interrupts the flow, but if you're watching The Clone Wars, Revenge of the Sith, and Bad Batch back to back, this is perfect! It would interrupt the flow even more if you have to go right back to Order 66 and Palpatine's speech again after having wrapped up the movie already, lol 😅. The one thing I'd add is the Tales of the Jedi episode 6 with Ahsoka speaking to Bail Organa during Padme's funeral. Even the rest of that episode would fit in with the "New Hope" Epilogue, actually, imo! It could even be edited down into a montage, or something to flow better with the rest of the Epilogue.
I always liked to think that Ahsoka was landing on Mandalore at the same time Anakin and Obi Wan were approaching Grievous’ ship, hence the same theme playing.
Dude Disney should pay you to release this on Disney plus. This would be bigger then the snyder cut, bigger then endgame, bigger then anything we have seen. I would love see how big the hype would be. Great job.
This is a very great project you made with these edits. It was fascinating to see the end of the clone wars from so many different perspectives from Ahsoka and clone force 99. It reminded me of a GTA4 walkthrough I watched years ago which showed the perspectives of Niko Bellic, Johnny Klebitz and Luis Lopez in chronological order. It was a bit odd at first because I thought the second half of the first Bad Batch episode after the Palpatine speech took place days after the end of ROTS, not concurrently. It was a very interesting experience watching this edit nonetheless. If I had one criticism about the edit I thought the Bad Batch episode took a lot of the focus out of the second part, but then again it was still a great experience to see the transition between both the movie and the series. If there was a highlight to these edits I would say 16:03 - 16:34 was one of the best where you introduced the Bad Batch and transitioned to Ahsoka. This was a very great video that you have done and you should feel proud of yourself for doing this.
I watched another YTers ultimate/extended cut of ROTS (without the ROTS del. scenes and Bad Batch clips) and found that one to be a bit jarring as full scenes of CW would start and stop around ROTS complete scenes. Today I’ve watched your cut MK and it is better, you’ve got the classic SW scene transitions, better soundtrack to scene transitions and full scenes from each of CW final season arc and ROTS in sequence that feels more organic to the nature of the development of the story and flows better than trying to say make it more real time like the other user did. It feels like a Lucas-level edit. Bravo.
Ideally, if it didn’t include deleted scenes, a split between two movies, and had scenes from when ahsoka went to padmes funeral, this would be spectacular. Everything else is perfect
WOW ive never seen anything so close to the 4 hour cut (well i guess with the bad batch and cws7 its a lot longer) of revenge of the sith! the edits are truly a work of art!
Now all this needs is the addition of the Battle of Coruscant from the 2003 Clone Wars and this really would be the complete “Fall of the Jedi” experience.
I didn’t watch his edit that included the Bad Batch, but thematically, I don’t think it would fit very well with ROTS. The Clone Wars was building up to ROTS, and Ahsoka’s story was integral to the Clone Wars. I watched his 2.0 version and it was incredibly enjoyable. Very well done! 👍
Yeah, Bad Batch definitely doesn’t fit in as well. This is not a definitive version of the film, but it is cool to see when events took place in relation to each other.
This is amazing, and while I do love the Bad Batch, it doesn't flow as well with RotS like Siege of Mandalore does. It would be incredible if you made a version that was essentially the Extended Edition but with the deleted scene included.
More Revenge of the Sith Tie-Ins I want from Disney: The Battle of Coruscant (in The Clone Wars style and different from the 2003 version) The Rise of the Inquisitorius (following established canon from Inquisitor: Rise pf the Red Blade, maybe the Grand Inquisitor's story) Death Star Context (Poggle's escape and death and the Empire's seizure of the project involving Tarkin and Krennic, following Catalyst canon) Battle of Kaller Leadup (maybe one episode) Contextualization for the missions the Jedi councilmembers were on during Order 66. Where Maul went after he escaped the Tribunal I would love to see another 5 or more season of the clone wars, but the arcs focus on otherJedi like Plo Koon, Kit Fisto, Ayla Secure, Stass Allie, Saesse Tin, KiAdi Mundi, and Yarael Poof, and the last season could be one giant epic revenge of the sith tie in, like starting with a Battle of Coruscant arc starring the other councilmembers I mentioned. THen they spread out to go on their individual missions and we get an episode each that show us why they were where they were for Order 66. Another arc could be the Rise of the Inquisitorius. We know how they survived order 66 from Rise of the Red Blade, so seeing the Grand Inquisitor's story would be very interesting since he's the most important one. It could also culminate in a fast-paced action sequence that would give more flow to the latter half of a supercut. Maybe he has to duel one of his closest companions or prove himself to the Empire. One-off episodes could include the Death Star's context, the Battle of Kaller, and what Maul did after he escaped the Tribunal. Just imagine how epic a supercut could be if all of this was included. Aside from being upwards of 10 hr long, it would be amazing as long as there's enough added action to the Obiwan/Anakin duel time period.
This is awesome. As someone who has attempted this himself, this is fucking awesome. I never would've thought to separate it into chapters. I'm trying something similar but I'm making it 5 parts instead. I would love to see the full thing
I hope Disney makes an Episode III Special Edition with the addition of The Clone Wars, Jedi: Fallen Order, and The Bad Batch. It can be either animated or live action. It would show all of the Jedi in the Outer-Rim Sieges.
Actually if they did combine Revenge of the Sith and Clone Wars season 7 together, then split them into 2 movies, and get rid of the majority of Attack of the Clones (save the clone fighting at the end), we could've had better episodes 2 and 3.
@@therealremedy oh no, i wouldn't cut those out. I'd probably cut down or cut out the long talking scenes from the first half of attack of the clones.
Did you know the Clone Wars attack on Coruscant was based on the original planned opening for Revenge of the Sith. That may be why it was included in Mecha Salesman's edit.
I agree with you that The Bad Batch interrupts the flow too much. I’d say it would work better if The Bad Batch was only included up until The Emperor’s speech. After that point, it’s only The Clone Wars and Revenge of the Sith that continue, and then The Bad Batch picks up again after they have both finished. So it kind of jumps forward from the end to show Vader but then jumps back afterwards to the rest of the bad batch
Your viewing order for this movie is so perfect. I love how you broke down all of the episodes into skipability and grouped all of the arcs together. I was wondering if you had a viewing order for 4,5,6 including SW rebels, mandolorian and rogue one. And i was also wondering if you would make a rogue one/new hope edit.
I think the idea of the bad batch being a main character(s) in this version really gives a different feel to the story. Idk it makes them seem more integral and I really like that Also fantastic job man, based on these edits I know this is going to be amazing
If you ever run out of inspiration. You could make an Extended Edition for The Phantom Menace, using one specific Tales of the Jedi episode. And if anyone ask, you didn't hear this from me. It came to you in a dream ;)
I've been planning an edit like this, but yours is outstanding. As far as The Bad Batch's inclusion goes though, I would have ended their inclusion after Hunter's comment "This day just keeps getting weirder." Why? Because Tarkin's presence on Kamino clashes with the end of Revenge of the Sith. He is on the bridge of the Star Destroyer with Palpatine and Vader as they observe the early construction of the Death Star. The way I interpreted it was that Tarkin went to Kamino after the ending of "Revenge of the Sith". But that's just me. But I also interpreted it this way because we also saw Tarkin on Kamino until during the fourth episode (if you count the pilot as two), when he turned command over to Rampart. Again, that's my interpretation, but it also seems to me that leaving the rest of "Aftermath" until after the main production serves the pacing and story better. Have you done a version that includes the new elements from "Tales of the Jedi"? Such as Ahsoka being at Padme's funeral? My idea for the Obi-Wan message from the Rebels pilot was to have it begin playing in the background as Kenobi informs Yoda about his modification. I couldn't tell from this, but did you include the deleted scenes with Padme, Bail, and Mon Mothma? That's definitely on my list of things to include, based off the ROTS novel. Lastly, your reason for not including the Coruscant attack from the 2-D CW makes sense, and I respect your choice. I will definitely be interested in seeing the edit.
I don’t get where the original Bad Batch episodes fit in at as Anakin KNOWS she’s pregnant. But Captain Rex is with him so it can’t happen at the same time as the Siege of Mandalor. I get that the original scene of the Padme art was removed because of its context, but doesn’t make sense for Anakin to see her pregnant and then she surprise him after he returns to her.
I doubt the Jedi really do a proper birds and the bees talk, so I doubt Anakin could expertly judge that Padme is pregnant just by looking at her hologram. In any case if he knew that she was pregnant he would’ve mentioned it during the hologram call
LORD, can this PLEASE BE an actual theatrical reality?! I really like your poster for ROTS Extended Edition. Though, honestly, I prefer to think of the trilogy, after TPM, as The Clone Wars. I'm still hoping for an official theatrical release of THE CLONE WARS: The Siege of Mandalore; along w/ a theatrical release of The (70 min.) Bad Batch premiere. Footnote: Hopefully, when We officially know how Grogu (Djarin) was rescued from The Jedi Temple, that can be incorporated in to your edit, as well.
Fantastic editing and I look forward to watching the whole thing. However, my only concern with these "Ep 3 mixed with Clone Wars" is that it takes the ending of Ahsoka's story, which is supposed to be this incredible resolution and ending beat and separates it so far from the ending, and adding a bulk of Bad Batch on top of that only extends that separation and makes it so the last time we ever see Ahsoka within this story is probably 45-50 minutes from the ending and that just adds a strange story beat where a pivotal story conclusion happens at roughly the 75% mark, two whole chapters from the ending. Granted, we do get the Vader picking up the saber, but where that is meant to be a moment we return to after immediately seeing her for the last time, it's now separated by a large chunk of time. Maybe seeing the whole thing at normal speed changes that, and really, due to the nature of this whole edit, it's unavoidable to do that, it just seems like a beast that can't really be conquered.
I have a suggestion, I know this might take a long time but what about a fan edit of all of Star Wars canon into one long film, including all 11 films, all of the clone wars, rebels, mandolorian and bad batch and also the clone wars movie. You could also add any upcoming shoes like Kenobi. That would be so cool to have it all in chronological order in one film but I know this would take some time. Anyway thank you for all the hard work.
this looks like a movie where Most of these clones revealed that they are good still for a chance of survival. Someone do director's cut in live action mode.
Super impressed by this editing my guy. Sounds like a weird small thing but my favorite part was the combination of the calm before the storm. After grevious’s and maul’s defeat. Before Mace vs palpatine
Thanks! The ominous ambient music from TCW and Padmé’s Ruminations really work best when the tension of both Maul and Grievous having been dealt with but the tension still being higher than ever because of what Anakin is about to do.
@@MadmansKnowledge Oh, I hadn't noticed that, but I'm really looking forward to it now I always watch your cut when I do a rewatch, for me it's the best Star Wars movie thanks to the additions Would love to see a live action version from Lucasfilm at some point
Amazing man. I'm from Poland and basing on your movie I did the same thing but in polish language verison (I understand english but i think it's more immersive when you watch it in your own language.). I have it just for me and friends to watch together, not to send it enywhere. But to do it more fun I add scenes from Padme's funeral from Tales of the Jedi, ecape of Grogu from Mandalorian and Order 66 from Obi Wan. It look's in 95% like your movie (but with this scenes and I have few smal mistakes with sound). It's all thank to you. I really want to thank you man. You made really big and hard job. And because of it, I can have movie that i wanted from a litle child. Thank you.
You’re welcome and that is so awesome! I’m working on adding those scenes myself right now. If you’d be willing to share your version, I’m sure others would love to have access to the film in Polish! DM me a link on Discord or Instagram if you’re okay with me adding it to me Google Doc to share.
A edit of the entire battle of christophsis would be cool, the battle spans across many episodes with the movie in the middle. It would be interesting to say the least.
Here's what my own Star Wars universe is going to be like: 1. Opun Mcgrrrr is one of Jabba's most loyal henchmen. He's also known as "Heater" and "The Fat Man". Jabba ordered him to hire bounty hunters (including Boba Fett) to pursue Han after he killed Greedo in A New Hope. He was there at Jabba's Palace when Luke, Leia, Chewie, and Lando infiltrate and try to rescue Han. He decided to remain in the palace. After hearing of his employer's death, he went on his own as the leader of his own little criminal empire, with his employees who were also loyal to Jabba. 2. Padmé survived childbirth. But Yoda and Ob-Wan sensed she has an incurable illness she caught from Mustafar that's slowly killing her. They chose not to tell her so she would not worry and to focus on her children. She became a handmaiden to the Organas to help raise Leia. She succumbed to the illness when Leia was 4. 3. Obi-Wan's dialogue: "A young Jedi named Darth Vader, who was a pupil of mine until he turned to evil, helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights. In a final dual, your father and Darth Vader fell into a pit of lava. Only Vader came out. Now the Jedi are all but extinct." "Your father was seduced by the dark side of the Force. He ceased to be Anakin Skywalker and became Darth Vader. When he fell into the molten pit, the good man who was father was destroyed." 4. I thought of a character. He's a human Jedi named Noltaw Sacul, the ancestor of Egroeg and Jorg, is possibly one of the Lost Twenty (he's the bronzium bust of George Lucas). He's considered the greatest Jedi of all time, besides the Skywalker/Solo family. So great, in fact, that it is said that upon his death he became the Force and/or the Force is him. 5. Kalhar is the town bully of Mos Eisely and the bouncer at the Cantina bar. 6. Vader has two Stormtroopers who follow him. One is a very fat guy and the other is a beautiful and curvaceous blonde woman. 7. Palpatine and Darth Sidious (Sheev) are two separate people. Palpatine is a name of state, his true name is Cos Dashit. He's a weak-willed dullard with delusions of grandeur who had been elevated to Chancellor by Sidious. After Sidious's death following the end of the Clone Wars, he possess/manipulate Palpatine into becoming Emperor and eliminate the Jedi. 8. Humans originated from Earth. In the 25th century, a group of humans escape a computer-controlled society. They accidentally travel backwards through time and through intergalactic space to arrive in the "galaxy far, far away". 9. During the Clone Wars, a power-hungry warlord takes advantage of the conflict by creating his own army of clones to attack both the Republic and the Separatists. Something Darth Sidious hadn't foreseen, and orders Count Dooku and General Grevious to deal with the problem. Palpatine asks the Jedi to help stop the warlord. 10. Gray Jedi participate in the Clone Wars, doing more to help the Republic than the Jedi Order could do without having a strict code. This makes them uneasy allies with the Jedi Knights. Ahsoka Tano herself becomes a Gray Jedi after leaving the Order. Ultimately, this wasn't enough to prevent Order 66 and the rise of the Galactic Empire. 11. Dark Jedi helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights.
Love what I'm seeing, just can't watch it unfortunately due to Google Drive limits but I'll keep trying every hour or so until I can finally watch it, same with your Hobbit edits, thank you again for doing so much hard work man! Update: Getting them now! Whoop-Whoop!
FAQ's:
Why didn't you include the Order 66 scene from Jedi: Fallen Order?
This scene is revealed as a flashback over halfway through the story of the game and I think it is better left as a reveal in that story. This way I also don't spoil it for people who haven't played the game.
Why didn't you include any of the 2003 2D animated Clone Wars show?
I don't think the attack on Coruscant from that show would work well being edited into Ahsoka's return for pacing and tonal reasons. Also it's not canon, which is a lesser issue to me since I included non-canon deleted scenes.
Why didn't you include more deleted scenes?
The remaining deleted scenes from Revenge of the Sith either have unfinished special effects or do not line up with the continuity of the scenes in the film.
I’m glad you didn’t include CW 2003
@Obi-Wan Kenobi there's a thing called torrent
@@Code1Lyoko sorry but it should've been added
@@jswatch9270 nope not canon it doesn’t exist in the timeline not anymore
@@jswatch9270 also George Lucas says it’s not since he didn’t make it
Marvel: Endgame is the most ambitious crossover of all time
ROTS Ultimate Edition:
Have you even seen endgame now that’s a masterpiece
Masterpiece?
@@vadamsvengeance3219 yeah endgame is a masterpiece
A lot of these scenes are way out of order. I don’t mean to sound mean but idk why all fan project suddenly become masterpieces just because they’re unprofessional.
@@Legoboy55able the only one I saw out of order was the Order 66 on Kanan (Caleb)
this man fears no copyright claims the claims fear him
LOL I wish. This video has a claim for the music, but at least it can still be public.
@@MadmansKnowledge Yo I just emailed u could in get the link?
@@hypnotic_o how did you email
A New Hope.. will emerge
*the force theme starts blaring*
Goddamn that gave me chills
Thanks!
Rots covers anakins fall to the dark side, bad batch covers the rise of the empire and clone wars covers order 66
but they all take place at the same time so its perfect
I think the scene with Ashoka, Rex and the buried clones should have been in the epilogue. Otherwise great!
Yes
Given how long it must've taken them to get to the ship, recover the bodies, and then bury them it would've fit better at the end but it's a minor flaw.
These are some of the best transitions I’ve seen in any fan edit of RotS and CW:SoM. I really like the use of chapter titles, but the reason they work so well is your use of music and audio to blend the clips into a seamless story. Really great job!
Thanks! I used a few musical cues from ROTJ to bridge the ends of the two trilogies.
@@MadmansKnowledge If you were gonna do something like this again you should include Tales of the Jedi with padme’s fueneral.
Obi Wans message makes it so much more emotional to the viewers
The Bad Batch is definitely the black sheep but it makes sense for the story. Fantastic edits man!
Thank you!
@@MadmansKnowledge how dare you offer go the tragedy of dahrt plaguis!!!??
Baaaaaaaaahhh...
Bad batch is really good
KREMIT! How have you been man?
0:02 that poster is so Infinity War style.
Love the edit at 28:24. It just struck me as "fitting" burying the old and giving birth to the new empire.
The transition at 6:30 was smooth as glass, well done 👍
Now there is also the opening scene from the sixth episode of "Tales of the jedi" that has to be add to the finsl edit
[edits furiously]
That looks amazing! But personally I would not cut in-between anything from anakin, obiwans, yodas and sudiouses duel with anything from the bad batch the scene feels way less climactic and whats happening in the bad batch seems so inconsequential to everything else.
Regardless I'm super exited to watch it
Yeah it's tough. If I don't cut during the fight then the pacing gets even weirder.
Apart from them reacting to sideouses reaction. That was cool
you missed the scene where tech says that obi was has engaged grievous on utapau.
Great editing but how come you replaced some of the “thunderous applause” from revenge of the Sith with that from the bad batch at 24:57?
Thanks! If you are referring to the sound of the applause from the live-action scene, I replaced it because it was the only way to make the music from both scenes mesh together.
How long can this edit get? Let's see, it could be longer with:
-2003 clone wars battle of coruscant
-Revenge of the sith tie in game cutscenes
-fallen order flashback
-all of the deleted scenes even if they contradict each other
-literally any footage of anything happening during episode 3
He added deleted scenes, and they didn't contradict the films, I still have no idea why he removed the Mon Mothma scenes.
Battlefront 2 2005 cutscenes
I only care about the Fallen Order flashback scene for more sadness for Order 66 and showing more Jedi who died.😪
@@Fandmadetrailers It wouldn't fit the pacing or have any impact for someone who hasn't played or doesn't care about fallen order. This was about making the best possible RotS+ experience, while still being a good film(s), not adding every little thing just because.
@@xdress1746 I understand but it would be cool to have all the jedi deaths be recorded in such a long edited movie. The whole movie was made to show all the events of Revenge of the Sith without watching them separately.
Amazing! In a vacuum, I can see how having The Bad Batch squeezed in there interrupts the flow, but if you're watching The Clone Wars, Revenge of the Sith, and Bad Batch back to back, this is perfect! It would interrupt the flow even more if you have to go right back to Order 66 and Palpatine's speech again after having wrapped up the movie already, lol 😅. The one thing I'd add is the Tales of the Jedi episode 6 with Ahsoka speaking to Bail Organa during Padme's funeral. Even the rest of that episode would fit in with the "New Hope" Epilogue, actually, imo! It could even be edited down into a montage, or something to flow better with the rest of the Epilogue.
I always liked to think that Ahsoka was landing on Mandalore at the same time Anakin and Obi Wan were approaching Grievous’ ship, hence the same theme playing.
Dude Disney should pay you to release this on Disney plus. This would be bigger then the snyder cut, bigger then endgame, bigger then anything we have seen. I would love see how big the hype would be. Great job.
This is a very great project you made with these edits. It was fascinating to see the end of the clone wars from so many different perspectives from Ahsoka and clone force 99. It reminded me of a GTA4 walkthrough I watched years ago which showed the perspectives of Niko Bellic, Johnny Klebitz and Luis Lopez in chronological order. It was a bit odd at first because I thought the second half of the first Bad Batch episode after the Palpatine speech took place days after the end of ROTS, not concurrently. It was a very interesting experience watching this edit nonetheless. If I had one criticism about the edit I thought the Bad Batch episode took a lot of the focus out of the second part, but then again it was still a great experience to see the transition between both the movie and the series. If there was a highlight to these edits I would say 16:03 - 16:34 was one of the best where you introduced the Bad Batch and transitioned to Ahsoka. This was a very great video that you have done and you should feel proud of yourself for doing this.
Thanks! My previous edit is the better one in my opinion too for those reasons, but both were fun to make.
"I will make it legal." has to be the best edit in the intro. 😆
I watched another YTers ultimate/extended cut of ROTS (without the ROTS del. scenes and Bad Batch clips) and found that one to be a bit jarring as full scenes of CW would start and stop around ROTS complete scenes. Today I’ve watched your cut MK and it is better, you’ve got the classic SW scene transitions, better soundtrack to scene transitions and full scenes from each of CW final season arc and ROTS in sequence that feels more organic to the nature of the development of the story and flows better than trying to say make it more real time like the other user did. It feels like a Lucas-level edit. Bravo.
Thank you so much! Making it as seamless as I could was my goal.
The amount of work put into it, email logistics and explanations are clearly the ultimate fan way
Ideally, if it didn’t include deleted scenes, a split between two movies, and had scenes from when ahsoka went to padmes funeral, this would be spectacular. Everything else is perfect
The cut between the Clone Wars and ROTS versions of the “I sense a plot to destroy the jedi” conversation were sick
Man, it makes such a difference when you edit the scenes together. Everything feels so much more impactful
DUDE!!!!! This is amazing!!! So professional and perfect! Keep up the good work man! I absolutely love it!!
30:49
Yoda: Hurry
Video: * accelerates to the speed of light"
I was wondering if anyone would notice that. I did it on purpose because it made me laugh.
@@MadmansKnowledge did you put all the deleted scenes or Just the yoda exile?
Loved the use of the clone wars and bad batch intros as the title crawls. Really good use of all aspects there.
WOW ive never seen anything so close to the 4 hour cut (well i guess with the bad batch and cws7 its a lot longer) of revenge of the sith! the edits are truly a work of art!
You never notice how well the story was put together till you see it all together. And it’s beautiful, shame we never got this version all together
*Revenge of the Sith ultimate edition is here!*
Tales of the Jedi: "Yes but no"
Agreed. That scene NEEDS to be included in this fanedit because it's CANON.
@@King-lb4pi BRB...
i want more of this snyder cut style movies, where its long as fuck, and its put into chapters
and a copy of this superedit
2:08
Now all this needs is the addition of the Battle of Coruscant from the 2003 Clone Wars and this really would be the complete “Fall of the Jedi” experience.
I didn’t watch his edit that included the Bad Batch, but thematically, I don’t think it would fit very well with ROTS. The Clone Wars was building up to ROTS, and Ahsoka’s story was integral to the Clone Wars. I watched his 2.0 version and it was incredibly enjoyable. Very well done! 👍
Yeah, Bad Batch definitely doesn’t fit in as well. This is not a definitive version of the film, but it is cool to see when events took place in relation to each other.
This edit deserves more views then it has, the detail and perfection of the editing is amazing feeling like a snyder cut to revenge of the sith
This is so beautiful
This is amazing, and while I do love the Bad Batch, it doesn't flow as well with RotS like Siege of Mandalore does. It would be incredible if you made a version that was essentially the Extended Edition but with the deleted scene included.
More Revenge of the Sith Tie-Ins I want from Disney:
The Battle of Coruscant (in The Clone Wars style and different from the 2003 version)
The Rise of the Inquisitorius (following established canon from Inquisitor: Rise pf the Red Blade, maybe the Grand Inquisitor's story)
Death Star Context (Poggle's escape and death and the Empire's seizure of the project involving Tarkin and Krennic, following Catalyst canon)
Battle of Kaller Leadup (maybe one episode)
Contextualization for the missions the Jedi councilmembers were on during Order 66.
Where Maul went after he escaped the Tribunal
I would love to see another 5 or more season of the clone wars, but the arcs focus on otherJedi like Plo Koon, Kit Fisto, Ayla Secure, Stass Allie, Saesse Tin, KiAdi Mundi, and Yarael Poof, and the last season could be one giant epic revenge of the sith tie in, like starting with a Battle of Coruscant arc starring the other councilmembers I mentioned. THen they spread out to go on their individual missions and we get an episode each that show us why they were where they were for Order 66. Another arc could be the Rise of the Inquisitorius. We know how they survived order 66 from Rise of the Red Blade, so seeing the Grand Inquisitor's story would be very interesting since he's the most important one. It could also culminate in a fast-paced action sequence that would give more flow to the latter half of a supercut. Maybe he has to duel one of his closest companions or prove himself to the Empire. One-off episodes could include the Death Star's context, the Battle of Kaller, and what Maul did after he escaped the Tribunal. Just imagine how epic a supercut could be if all of this was included. Aside from being upwards of 10 hr long, it would be amazing as long as there's enough added action to the Obiwan/Anakin duel time period.
Great job loved the clone wars edit can’t wait to watch this
Thanks!
did u get an email? he hasn’t emailed me back and it’s been weeks and i’ll verify my disney plus with u if need be😂
this is *superb* , you almost brought me to tears. Congratulations.
episode 3 is a 12/10 you just made it a 16/10
This is awesome. As someone who has attempted this himself, this is fucking awesome. I never would've thought to separate it into chapters. I'm trying something similar but I'm making it 5 parts instead. I would love to see the full thing
If you want to see the full thing: 2:08
I hope Disney makes an Episode III Special Edition with the addition of The Clone Wars, Jedi: Fallen Order, and The Bad Batch. It can be either animated or live action. It would show all of the Jedi in the Outer-Rim Sieges.
"Still don't think the Regs are programmed?" This is what the edit needed to reach perfection
Justice for Fives, eh? Nice touch. Great edit tho that was beautiful it made me cry on the inside 😭😭😭😭👌👌👌👌
This is absolutely incredible. Can't wait to watch it!
Actually if they did combine Revenge of the Sith and Clone Wars season 7 together, then split them into 2 movies, and get rid of the majority of Attack of the Clones (save the clone fighting at the end), we could've had better episodes 2 and 3.
@@therealremedy oh no, i wouldn't cut those out. I'd probably cut down or cut out the long talking scenes from the first half of attack of the clones.
The TH-cam algorithm has blessed me yet again with a gem
Can you add some of the recently found deleted scenes ?
Did you know the Clone Wars attack on Coruscant was based on the original planned opening for Revenge of the Sith. That may be why it was included in Mecha Salesman's edit.
The fact there was technically a Gotal on Onderon, while Obi-Wan and Anikan fought on Mustafar is literally unbelievable to me.
in the moment when i get back a email i will instantly watch it :)
I agree with you that The Bad Batch interrupts the flow too much. I’d say it would work better if The Bad Batch was only included up until The Emperor’s speech. After that point, it’s only The Clone Wars and Revenge of the Sith that continue, and then The Bad Batch picks up again after they have both finished. So it kind of jumps forward from the end to show Vader but then jumps back afterwards to the rest of the bad batch
Your viewing order for this movie is so perfect. I love how you broke down all of the episodes into skipability and grouped all of the arcs together.
I was wondering if you had a viewing order for 4,5,6 including SW rebels, mandolorian and rogue one.
And i was also wondering if you would make a rogue one/new hope edit.
I actually have a viewing order list for all of Star Wars! docs.google.com/document/d/1JUKqFfF8QuBcI0F-PLMNSm0XOtBuz9ifqDhgZQB-rsA/edit?usp=sharing
@@MadmansKnowledge thanks also now i realize a 6 hour movie is ridiculous, i can just queue up the next film 😆
I think the idea of the bad batch being a main character(s) in this version really gives a different feel to the story. Idk it makes them seem more integral and I really like that
Also fantastic job man, based on these edits I know this is going to be amazing
Thanks!
I love how you included Star Wars' legendary powerpoint transitions
LMAO
😱I want that poster!
If you ever run out of inspiration. You could make an Extended Edition for The Phantom Menace, using one specific Tales of the Jedi episode. And if anyone ask, you didn't hear this from me. It came to you in a dream ;)
This edit deserves to be on Disney+
Flawless execution on your part, well done.
That 15:15 intro though🔥
I've been planning an edit like this, but yours is outstanding. As far as The Bad Batch's inclusion goes though, I would have ended their inclusion after Hunter's comment "This day just keeps getting weirder." Why? Because Tarkin's presence on Kamino clashes with the end of Revenge of the Sith. He is on the bridge of the Star Destroyer with Palpatine and Vader as they observe the early construction of the Death Star. The way I interpreted it was that Tarkin went to Kamino after the ending of "Revenge of the Sith". But that's just me. But I also interpreted it this way because we also saw Tarkin on Kamino until during the fourth episode (if you count the pilot as two), when he turned command over to Rampart. Again, that's my interpretation, but it also seems to me that leaving the rest of "Aftermath" until after the main production serves the pacing and story better.
Have you done a version that includes the new elements from "Tales of the Jedi"? Such as Ahsoka being at Padme's funeral?
My idea for the Obi-Wan message from the Rebels pilot was to have it begin playing in the background as Kenobi informs Yoda about his modification.
I couldn't tell from this, but did you include the deleted scenes with Padme, Bail, and Mon Mothma? That's definitely on my list of things to include, based off the ROTS novel.
Lastly, your reason for not including the Coruscant attack from the 2-D CW makes sense, and I respect your choice. I will definitely be interested in seeing the edit.
I don’t get where the original Bad Batch episodes fit in at as Anakin KNOWS she’s pregnant. But Captain Rex is with him so it can’t happen at the same time as the Siege of Mandalor. I get that the original scene of the Padme art was removed because of its context, but doesn’t make sense for Anakin to see her pregnant and then she surprise him after he returns to her.
I doubt the Jedi really do a proper birds and the bees talk, so I doubt Anakin could expertly judge that Padme is pregnant just by looking at her hologram. In any case if he knew that she was pregnant he would’ve mentioned it during the hologram call
LORD, can this PLEASE BE an actual theatrical reality?! I really like your poster for ROTS Extended Edition. Though, honestly, I prefer to think of the trilogy, after TPM, as The Clone Wars. I'm still hoping for an official theatrical release of THE CLONE WARS: The Siege of Mandalore; along w/ a theatrical release of The (70 min.) Bad Batch premiere. Footnote: Hopefully, when We officially know how Grogu (Djarin) was rescued from The Jedi Temple, that can be incorporated in to your edit, as well.
This deserves more views and likes
I just watched the fulld edit. And it was f*cking amazing. You did an excellent job
Thank you!
@@MadmansKnowledge I immediatly recommended it to all my friends.
@@thanos_6.0 Hey, thanks for sharing it
Thank god you fast forward through Burry The Dead was already getting chills
Wow Dude, this is awesome
Thank you!
The only thing that could make this better is if you added cutscenes from the RoTS game, Original Battlefront 2, Elite Squadron, and Fallen Order.
Fantastic editing and I look forward to watching the whole thing. However, my only concern with these "Ep 3 mixed with Clone Wars" is that it takes the ending of Ahsoka's story, which is supposed to be this incredible resolution and ending beat and separates it so far from the ending, and adding a bulk of Bad Batch on top of that only extends that separation and makes it so the last time we ever see Ahsoka within this story is probably 45-50 minutes from the ending and that just adds a strange story beat where a pivotal story conclusion happens at roughly the 75% mark, two whole chapters from the ending. Granted, we do get the Vader picking up the saber, but where that is meant to be a moment we return to after immediately seeing her for the last time, it's now separated by a large chunk of time. Maybe seeing the whole thing at normal speed changes that, and really, due to the nature of this whole edit, it's unavoidable to do that, it just seems like a beast that can't really be conquered.
Yeah there are some things like that that make my edits inferior to the original cuts in a few ways.
@@MadmansKnowledge With all that said, I watched the whole thing, and bravo. Very well done. This is definitely one of the better edits out there.
Thanks!
Cant explain how much i love this,thank u
This looks freaking amazing
5 stars probably my favorite adding bad batch, revenge of the sith, and Clone wars final all together.
i wish filoni and his team would remake rots to have good dialogue, have that beautiful artstyle, and include scenes from clone wars as well
I have a suggestion, I know this might take a long time but what about a fan edit of all of Star Wars canon into one long film, including all 11 films, all of the clone wars, rebels, mandolorian and bad batch and also the clone wars movie. You could also add any upcoming shoes like Kenobi. That would be so cool to have it all in chronological order in one film but I know this would take some time. Anyway thank you for all the hard work.
That is suicide, also, that makes no sense
this looks like a movie where Most of these clones revealed that they are good still for a chance of survival. Someone do director's cut in live action mode.
should of added the part of tales of the jedi when ahsoka goes to padme's funeral
Maybe a lot to ask, but I wonder if you could add the tales of the Jedi sequence next, where Ahsoka visits Padme’s funeral 🥴
Wow this was amazing
*Yes, my lord.*
A masterpiece
Super impressed by this editing my guy. Sounds like a weird small thing but my favorite part was the combination of the calm before the storm. After grevious’s and maul’s defeat. Before Mace vs palpatine
Thanks! The ominous ambient music from TCW and Padmé’s Ruminations really work best when the tension of both Maul and Grievous having been dealt with but the tension still being higher than ever because of what Anakin is about to do.
The video was released because of the new series "The Bad Batch" and now it ends today
We got old
It ended and on Saturday the next update to the cut is out too! My releases bookended the series in a way
@@MadmansKnowledge
Oh, I hadn't noticed that, but I'm really looking forward to it now
I always watch your cut when I do a rewatch, for me it's the best Star Wars movie thanks to the additions
Would love to see a live action version from Lucasfilm at some point
I never really said thanks for sending it to me so, thanks.
We need a tales of the jedi edit as well both the funeral and the extended venator scene! Also possibly a TPM edit that adds The Sith Lord
Amazing man. I'm from Poland and basing on your movie I did the same thing but in polish language verison (I understand english but i think it's more immersive when you watch it in your own language.). I have it just for me and friends to watch together, not to send it enywhere. But to do it more fun I add scenes from Padme's funeral from Tales of the Jedi, ecape of Grogu from Mandalorian and Order 66 from Obi Wan. It look's in 95% like your movie (but with this scenes and I have few smal mistakes with sound). It's all thank to you. I really want to thank you man. You made really big and hard job. And because of it, I can have movie that i wanted from a litle child. Thank you.
You’re welcome and that is so awesome! I’m working on adding those scenes myself right now. If you’d be willing to share your version, I’m sure others would love to have access to the film in Polish! DM me a link on Discord or Instagram if you’re okay with me adding it to me Google Doc to share.
actually, watching 'pirated' or content like this is not illegal, however, the possession of it is.
as far as i know
That's like Zack Snyder's Justice League, that appear all these chapters
A edit of the entire battle of christophsis would be cool, the battle spans across many episodes with the movie in the middle. It would be interesting to say the least.
I would have disney+ if disney didn't have some weird ass business model where their apps aren't even available in half the world
Good lord imagine if they did this, and people thought episode 2 was all over the place lol
Man I wish we could have both as either animated or live action so it isn't as jarring of a transition.
Here's what my own Star Wars universe is going to be like:
1. Opun Mcgrrrr is one of Jabba's most loyal henchmen. He's also known as "Heater" and "The Fat Man". Jabba ordered him to hire bounty hunters (including Boba Fett) to pursue Han after he killed Greedo in A New Hope. He was there at Jabba's Palace when Luke, Leia, Chewie, and Lando infiltrate and try to rescue Han. He decided to remain in the palace. After hearing of his employer's death, he went on his own as the leader of his own little criminal empire, with his employees who were also loyal to Jabba.
2. Padmé survived childbirth. But Yoda and Ob-Wan sensed she has an incurable illness she caught from Mustafar that's slowly killing her. They chose not to tell her so she would not worry and to focus on her children. She became a handmaiden to the Organas to help raise Leia. She succumbed to the illness when Leia was 4.
3. Obi-Wan's dialogue: "A young Jedi named Darth Vader, who was a pupil of mine until he turned to evil, helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights. In a final dual, your father and Darth Vader fell into a pit of lava. Only Vader came out. Now the Jedi are all but extinct." "Your father was seduced by the dark side of the Force. He ceased to be Anakin Skywalker and became Darth Vader. When he fell into the molten pit, the good man who was father was destroyed."
4. I thought of a character. He's a human Jedi named Noltaw Sacul, the ancestor of Egroeg and Jorg, is possibly one of the Lost Twenty (he's the bronzium bust of George Lucas). He's considered the greatest Jedi of all time, besides the Skywalker/Solo family. So great, in fact, that it is said that upon his death he became the Force and/or the Force is him.
5. Kalhar is the town bully of Mos Eisely and the bouncer at the Cantina bar.
6. Vader has two Stormtroopers who follow him. One is a very fat guy and the other is a beautiful and curvaceous blonde woman.
7. Palpatine and Darth Sidious (Sheev) are two separate people. Palpatine is a name of state, his true name is Cos Dashit. He's a weak-willed dullard with delusions of grandeur who had been elevated to Chancellor by Sidious. After Sidious's death following the end of the Clone Wars, he possess/manipulate Palpatine into becoming Emperor and eliminate the Jedi.
8. Humans originated from Earth. In the 25th century, a group of humans escape a computer-controlled society. They accidentally travel backwards through time and through intergalactic space to arrive in the "galaxy far, far away".
9. During the Clone Wars, a power-hungry warlord takes advantage of the conflict by creating his own army of clones to attack both the Republic and the Separatists. Something Darth Sidious hadn't foreseen, and orders Count Dooku and General Grevious to deal with the problem. Palpatine asks the Jedi to help stop the warlord.
10. Gray Jedi participate in the Clone Wars, doing more to help the Republic than the Jedi Order could do without having a strict code. This makes them uneasy allies with the Jedi Knights. Ahsoka Tano herself becomes a Gray Jedi after leaving the Order. Ultimately, this wasn't enough to prevent Order 66 and the rise of the Galactic Empire.
11. Dark Jedi helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights.
YES! I loved your cut last year, looking forward to checking this out.
maybe do one with cal kestis order 66 moment
I edited Ahsoka v Maul w/ duel of the fates into your original extended edition
No way. Can you send me a link?
Love what I'm seeing, just can't watch it unfortunately due to Google Drive limits but I'll keep trying every hour or so until I can finally watch it, same with your Hobbit edits, thank you again for doing so much hard work man!
Update: Getting them now! Whoop-Whoop!
Thanks! I don't know of a way to share that wouldn't block it for copyright and has no download limits, so oh well, glad it worked.
and you haven't thought about making a new edition: now including scenes from Tales of the jedi???