2020 Proton X70 vs Proton X50 Comparison Review in Malaysia, Which Family SUV to Buy? | WapCar
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ค. 2024
- The 2020 Proton X70 and Proton X50 overlap in their price point. While their product positioning is aimed at different groups, many can't help it to compare the two cars based on the price factor alone.
The X70 is very obviously a larger car with more space and better practicality. On the other hand, the X50 offers better tech and a much more stylish design.
Let Adrian break it down to you which is the perfect SUV that will suit your needs.
Download WapCar’s official app on Google Playstore now: wapcar.onelink.me/spIk/ytb
_____________________________________________
Quick Specs:
2020 Proton X70 1.8 TGDi Premium X 2WD
Engine: JLE-4G18TD 1.8L turbocharged 4-cylinder TGDi
Power: 184 PS & 300 Nm
Transmission: 7-speed (wet) dual-clutch automatic
0 - 100 km/h: 10.4 seconds (as tested)
Fuel Consumption: 10.8L/100 km (as tested)
Price: RM 115,800 (OTR without insurance & SST)
Read More: www.wapcar.my/cars/proton/x70
2020 Proton X50 Flagship 1.5 TGDI
Engine: 3G15TD 1.5-litre 3-cylinder turbocharged petrol
Power: 177 PS & 255 Nm
Transmission: 7-speed (wet) DCT automatic
0 - 100 km/h: 8.6 seconds (as tested)
Fuel Consumption: 10.2L/100 km (as tested)
Price: RM 103,300 (OTR without insurance & SST)
Read More: www.wapcar.my/cars/proton/x50
_____________________________________________
WapCar Best Fuel Consumption Ranking
1) 2020 Nissan Almera 1.0L VLT - 5.8L
2) 2020 Mazda 2 Hatchback 1.5L - 6.2L
3) 2020 Volkswagen Passat 2.0TSI Elegance - 6.5L
4) 2019 Honda Jazz 1.5 V - 6.7L
5) 2019 Honda CR-V 1.5 TC-P 2WD - 7.0L
6) 2019 Toyota Yaris 1.5G - 7.0L
7) 2019 Mazda 3 Sedan 2.0 High Plus - 7.6L
8) 2020 Toyota Corolla Altis 1.8G - 7.7L
9) 2020 Honda Civic 1.5 TC-P - 7.9L
9) 2019 Perodua Aruz 1.5 AV - 7.9L
10) 2020 BMW 320i Sport - 8.0L
Full List: www.wapcar.my/car-ranking/
_____________________________________________
Intro: 00:00
Exterior Design: 00:34
Size: 01:23
Boot Space: 01:54
Proton X50 Interior: 03:00
Proton X70 Interior: 03:36
Rear Legroom: 03:53
Engine Specs: 04:34
Proton X50 Review: 05:20
Proton X70 Review: 07:35
Conclusion: 09:29
----------------------------Follow Us----------------------------
Website www.wapcar.my/
Facebook: / wapcar.my
Instagram: / wapcar.my
Shot by: Ibrahim ( / ibrahimfaiesall ) & Fadzli
Edited by: Fadzli
Host: Adrian Chia ( / adriannnchia )
#ProtonX70 #ProtonX50 #ProtonReviewMalaysia - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
![[4K] PROTON X50 vs. PROTON X70 - Sibling Rivalry | Comparison Review](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bdJ00Ga7lY0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] PROTON X50 vs. PROTON X70 – Sibling Rivalry | Comparison Review](/img/tr.png)
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 69 | คู่เอก "กุหลาบดำ vs นาบิล"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PNM6U8e_HMo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Why I Would Choose This Proton X70, 1.5 TGDi Executive AWD [Genting Hill Climb] - YS Khong Driving](/img/n.gif)
"if you have spare cash, why not both" - ok, i dont :)
X 70 is a super smooth car and it is designed for family car.X50 is a sporty car.
X50 has wind noise issue after speed 85 km and Proton aware about this issue. For long run X70 are better then X50 .
Less tired on long journey...totally agree...just done tour to terengganu with it and to compare it with my alza...definetely can tell the difference.
For singles, definitely x50
Test drove both, x50 feels solid to drive while having ample space. X70 feels like im driving a boat and feels abit claustrophobic because of the chunky centre console. X50 is definitely the better choice 🥲
First of all nice video, totally underrated. Second, X70 with ADAS 2.0 be the thing i will wait.
Great production, love the quality of fhe editing, camera angles and the review also very on point ans easy to understand!
Has carwow vibes!!
First of all, great video! Never been in the X50, but I do love my X70 very much. I'd recommend it to people if they ask :)
I would still choose the X50 and I'm old and retired. The X70 looks like my father's car. Just a little to laid back.
😂
Haha .. SAme ..just love x50 designed
but when i compare to fortuner what happned, x70 more sporty. i think you go buy exora only.. good for your teste
hello btw x50 is bit smaller design for youngster
I loved X50 tech and X70 premiums. I wish i can get the best of both in a car. Maybe next generation of those then I'll decide. Meanwhile my saga still running fine.
Yeah, I will choose that instead.
@@mirollacap l
Good comparison review! Makes picking the right model much easier...thxs
Thanks for watching!
Husband choose X70, wife go for X50. Balanced.
Good review sir.. help me a lot to decide which one..
I’m a single man who doesn’t wanna be tied down by marriage. Which one you think I chose? X50 lorr, it’s been 1month now with x50. I’m happy with her. Even moved condo using her. Perfect!
Lol. Same. I'm thinking the same as single guy. At the moment, I thought to go with Mini Countryman, but looking at the x50 and x70 reviews and the price, this seems a better choice, plus I can save almost double the price.
Also looking forward the new HRV 2021 review too. I hope Honda brings that sooner tho.
@@Fakhrulzakry The X50 is value for money but the Mini is another level bro. why not getting a used GL-A 200
?
@@markomarin3414 I prefer a new car, and GLA is nice, but I think it’s just my preference. There's always sparks whenever I look at Mini... But as a financial geek, I don't think I'm ready to spend that extra money, hence looking for a cheaper alternative for my new car.
tq tq🤝.. gud info👍🙋.. after watching dis video.. direct to proton & booking x70.. 😎👍👍👍👍👍
x70 for me. as grow older, need more spacious & comfy ride with more power
As simple as showing the luggages fitting in the boot, i was sold with X70. 😁
My opinion...
X70 : big family
X50 : small family
both are great cars with good value, you can't go wrong with either one.
for a family of five, I think X70 spaces are much more comfortable and bigger than X50..
I've chosen x70 over x50, I've been driving x50 awhile in my friend's car, it's fast and feel sporty. Handling is good. Touring around city without any issue but as for the highway when you speed I've 100km/h, it has the whistle wind noise. As for the x70, I only test drive it in city area, the turning when over 30km/h can feel the car moving to one side but the rear passenger wouldn't fall over to the other side because of the sudden turning. As for the speed, there's not much different since it's not a sport car and as long as it provides you safety and comfort in my opinion. I'm 5ft 10 and I needed to adjust my seat to very front 😅
I’m a bit annoyed by proton service centres, I’ve been going to the one in cyberjaya, almost 3 times for the same issue, my steering wheel in my 2020 proton saga keeps vibrating badly, they said they tuned it better every time and didn’t really do much.
My point being, I don’t think the proton service centres and technicians are skilled enough to take care and maintain these modern “Geely” vehicles
Local assembled X70 does not have Nappa leather in brown color. Hope they give as new option and also wireless Apple carplay or Android auto in the next facelift or paid option.
Good review Adrian. Bought the X70 for my wife, have no regrets about it. Absolutely love the car!
It's Adrian
@@farouqjohari oops
😂
I know the Flagship variant is the go-to but it would be nice to see the review for the more affordable variants of the X50 especially the standard and executive, I think those 2 are very good value for its price plus at that price, those variants coincidentally compete against few of the newly launched Japanese B segment sedans like City, Almera, Vios FL. I bet many cross shopping between these cars as they sit in very similar price range. Thanks :D
I'm a x70 CBU user for 1year and my car did 20k of mileage, these are the problems arises
1. The steering always steer to the left from , what proton did was an alignment everytime I raise this issue, the problem still there.
2. My car gear change when I flaw the throttle very harsh and scary, this happens the 4th month when I brought the car for a long drive to Cameron.
3. 2nd hard gear change is from way down from genting it just drop very harshly from 6th to 4th suddenly then it ran smoothly.
4. 3rd hard gear change when it was on Adaptive Cruise Control from malacca when a car comes in front it suddenly dropped very harshly.
5. My car always wobbles/vibrate when the speed 50kmh -80kmh after that speed it rides smoothy.
6. My car always wobbles/vibrate when climb uphill 70kmh- 100kmh. This is even happens either I drive the car or its on Adaptive Cruise Control.
7. Already two time I address this issue to proton, proton said there is software update for CBU models which is latest software is 005 and my model was running on 000 software update. Proton didn't even notify us until my 3rd service, only when the problem arise they update the software.
8. Proton said they need to open my gearbox to check why it wobbles/vibrate. How sure this will be solved, my car is just 1 year old and I'm not confident with what they going to do. I just don't want another new problem arise from this issue.
9. I'm just not happy on how proton is handling this issue, is this how they solve issue, everytime I need to send the car for the whole day and they problem still there. 10.This is really not helpful, my time and my money to send the car and had to take grab to work.
11. Even my friends warn me to not buy x70 when it launch, I bought it on the confident that they might have improved and I would like to support proton.
12. To all x70 CBU owners kindly go to service center and update your TCU software.
13. Very seldom I use this car and it gives this kind of problems, my daily drive myvi is even better and I had no issues even though it has done 160k km.
14. I was even thinking of buying x50, after all this matter with x70 I have no confidence with next proton cars.
15. Hopefully TH-cam reviewers can help me on this matter to add in your reviews because before buying anything we always trust your reviews before buying new cars.
My car solved when i send to Setia Gemilang. You can try send to them.
Ah better sell it off while you still able to. Get a reliable brand so all this problem will be solve
How about the ckd version?
Is there anyone who faced problems with the ckd x70?
Is it better to look for another imported brand?
So its just a software update away to solve your problem? My CBU 2wd is doing well at 30k though. You got a lemon unit?
@@lingv5452 software update is good, the car is more responsive, but the problem is there.
Overall for daily use the only thing x50 is better then x70 is the level 2 ADAS & maybe fuel consumption.
X50 is a sporty car X70 best for long distance & relaxing car ....
X70 is more for family usage and also much more comfortable compare to x50.. The NVH also lots better than x50...
X70 NVH is actually the best in class.
What is much sir
Nvh
First time being early!
So i have a family of 1 year old sister parents and 12 year old me soo what suits us better?
Interesting that legroom is the same for both cars. So most of the length went to the boot for X70.
How's the after sales services?
Please review on Proton X70 2022.
Family or first car go for x70 vs have bigger like vellfire alphard estima or for wife singles x50
wait x70 get an "updated version"/ facelift/ 2nd gen with ADAS 2.0 and new infotainment then perfect liao? 🤔
Hopefully, and also if it comes with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto 🤔
@@WapCar Will it though? Especially with Google's and Apple's trade issues with China, I am not sure we will see that too soon
Does Proton allow you to drag race these two cars?
I prefer the look of the x70. It’s boxier and sharper. The x50 looks great too but I prefer boxy cars
2:58 ice bear is not pleased 😂
If you wait for x70 pro, maybe in 2022 will come in or not
What about fuel consumption?
saya nak langgan video ni awak tunjukkan boleh main games dalam kereta x 50
this two cars have different benefits, features and design.. seems like both are nice tho
is the roof rack usable? is it real??
nice car since proton established
somehow with the price point, the x50 interior should've been the x70 interior.
The X50 is a newer model than the X70, so it made the X70 aged quite a bit haha
X70 look aging in the interior time to give a facelift.
funny how one of your peer motor journalist kept saying X50 is not being tuned by Proton Ride and Handling Dept. yes the so called famous automotive site. I still prefer your reviews compared to their commercialised biased reviews.
Thanks! We can confirm that the X50 has been indeed tuned by Proton Ride & Handling department www.wapcar.my/news/malaysias-proton-x50-will-ride-and-handle-better-than-chinas-geely-binyue-6413
im waiting for the x70 facelift. current version kinda out of date aldready.
me too haha
do the van damme-split, Adrian
😂
Was considering upgrading from a saga to an x50 but shitty proton after sales service is making me look elsewhere.
in the end, u bought what car?. and 1 more things, X50 waiting period is 4 months. fuh.
@@rabbitcat5371 will wait for the new p2 SUV and see how the reviews are.
@@Rlh88888 just opt for toyota. Reliable and less headache.
@@anandsamy5194 i will never buy any car with cvt gearbox like toyota & honda anymore. This is pure headache plus the spare parts are very expensive
@XxKaiju_123xX P1 = proton, P2=Perdua
Definitely X70 ! AND COME ON there’s a reason why X70 pricey than x50
in the thumbnail, thought u wanna do the van damme-split
😂
Awak ni yang selalu kat tik tok tu kan , yang selalu dengan ativa tu
For my Family car Toyota Fortuner Roll too Much in Corners and it's not a good thing. When Goes for Turning. And I Could Agree that I will get X70 because for Corners and Turning for Some Characteristics. And I Love the interior. It will be more Comfortable to be in
Its confusing ... I like X50 but my mom like X70... such a hard decision to make...
mantul bang
Nice one idol. Thanks for sharing this update video. Done coloring your home. Shoutout! #MOVEONTV
Hey Adrian, watched all your X50 reviews and wanted to ask if you think Civic FC TCP is a better alternative for a young family car? Putting aside the RM30k difference, is the car handling, lower ride height, paddle shifters and Apple Carplay+Android Auto and reliability of Honda cars worth it? Usage will be Klang Valley driving + monthly drive to Penang to visit family. Also, it's tiring to wait for X50 for more than 2-3 months with no updates on the ETA!
Based on your needs, definitely the Civic would suit you better. Because it's more spacious and practical for a family car 😃
Oh this is a Geely Coolray in the Philippines
I love the fact that JLR's infotainment is laggier than a proton 😂
🤭
@XxKaiju_123xX jaguar land rover
@XxKaiju_123xX I'll tell you why when i could afford one 😂
'ice bear is not pleased' 😂
As a family man..X70 is the one..enough space for the kids..no quarrelling 😂
X70 CKD much better than X50 CKD
BS, x50 or x70 both expensive feel inside
if both got android auto or apple carplay then i choose x70...if none no thank you
X50❤️
The video quality seems off. Why is this
X70 much more better than the younger brader.
Servis ....aiyaaaaa..
X70 interiors design are soo communist, you will get much older by driving it😅but I own one, the imported model, is super comfortable drive, no regrets, that's why now getting X50👍🏽
Congratulations on your new car!
soli ask ah, if x70 standard and x50 premium, take which 1? both 94k
X70 for better comfort & NVH, X50 for the ADAS & technology
I also in doubt between x50 flagship n x70 executive.. the price is not much different.. i love the sportiness and advance tech features in x50, but i also love the comfortness and space offer by x70.. i know the different between this two model but i still cannot decide it yet..🥲
@@mrzephert7940 same -_-
Personaly i will go for x50 premium.
Amazing how far China has come in the automotive industry. Have you seen a Chinese made car in the 90's?
U should try haval. China brand. Very good quality. I think slightly better than mazda and honda suv.
Pasok, Paul Adrian Ilasin!
Petrol fuel consumption?
x50 is much better in feul consuption. 1.8t is too old. its almost given up by geely
Jason, faster do Arteon full review la. TQ
Its Adrian
Pls compare apple with apple, its 2 different segment suv & about 20k price difference. If price the same should compare with the x70 executive one or segment wise is the hrv or chr. Why all keep reviewing the flagship model? I thought there's the standard variant which is more affordable
@@wong924 too much hype of something tends to get bored or disappointed in times, like already own it for a year or two lost interest
Malaysians consumers cross shop between segment www.wapcar.my/news/Why-crosssegment-shopping-is-now-a-trend-1903
most malaysian wont care about segment, and i do agree to do comparison like this since X50 price is very near to x70. The standard variant lose my interest with only offering 4 airbags. Giving that the X50 premium doesnt come with ADAS, its much more sense to go for X70 standard since it really well equipped
Is x70 sunroof feel hot if park outdoor long time?
We recommend to get the sunroof tinted for better hear rejection
Why not both? For d same price as a rav4!
🤔
so hard to pick between them both XD
haha, same
I'm stuck in this too..
Why does your videos have a darker filter?
x70
Btw normally which car oil do you guys more prefer ?
Like Me, after compared with ron97 with new version of ron 97 , I truly recommend ron 97 Primax with pro-race if you do really wanna take good care of your car engine
this new version ron 97 formulated with the world's first Advanced Dual Friction Modifier, which is 25% more efficient in reducing friction than the previous fuel.. Simply to say, that's mean It saved fuel XD
Is protan a chines brand?
You live in a cave bro?
X 70 bh
X 70 is far better !
Boys drives X50..Man drives X70...Legend Drives Wira!
X70 is better but the aftersales service is an issue
just a matter of time before x50 gets the same problem
How so?
@@kinluke if proton can't even deal with customers issue with the x70 you think x50 will fare better meh? common sense la bro
@@robertson2730 I think you should read my comment properly before replying. I was asking "how so? ". Pretty obvious I wanted to know what kind of issues regarding the aftersales service was he actually referring to. Read properly la bro.
@@robertson2730 in case you didn't know la bro, issues pertaining to aftersales service can be broken down into different types. What kind of issues? Incompetent service? Lack of spare parts? Long waiting period? Etc etc. It's common sense.
x70
x70
Yeah... That boss seat function is actually a terrible thing if you wanna consider it as a family suv. I don't know why Adrian did not address this issue when considering that in a family suv 👎👎👎
Yep, kids in the back seat gonna have a field day with it.
No worries about that, because the kids who are safely strapped onto their seat won't be able to reach the boss switch 😃
@@WapCar errr, they can still reach it using their long legs.. 😂.. maybe what they can do is create a kill switch under the seat or hidden somewhere..
@@WapCar I'm guessing your children are the most obedient children in the world lmao
@@einstein9901 lemah
4 pistons is way much better than 3 pistons ✌
2
x70x50
x50x50
#Proton..ni baru proton..ni proton saga kereta kebal..mnde laa proton...
Ni kereta 🇨🇳 bang
camera focus is out
Apologies on that!
proton banyak makan duit oooooo..#Proton..
WAP Car ????
Hi 😃
X50 for sure. X70 only when they bring in pro. Else it looks damn boring
X50
for me