Yes I thought she had potential but they never gave her a chance to show what she could do. I was disappointed in the way she was treated. So sad, crush someones dream in one second flat. Nice going Simon
@@Jessica18010I didn't find it gold buzzer worthy. Guilt trip much Simon. Fkd up and then added salt to the wound by doing what he did. That was messed up
She is a good singer, but she is not a great singer. Perhaps with some vocal training she could be. I think she has potential, but Simon's critique was spot on. She just doesn't have commercial viability.
I love how much she supported her brother. There is a LOT of love there! And honestly, if given the chance, she would’ve done well. But we weren’t allowed to hear her. But I’m sure both she and her brother are doing well, because he doesn’t seem like the kind to leave her in the cold. I adore brother, sister, and mom!
They completely ripped Jade OFF. They didn't listen long enough, they didn't let US listen long enough, and she was not given a fair shake. They literally cut her off before she ever got a chance. Not just disappointed for her. She was RIPPED OFF.
I love Calum Scott - he's so genuine and you could feel his pain that he shared for his sister. I have a younger sister and I'd not have been so kind to the judges if they did to her that which they did to Calum's sister. He's doing so well now as an artist. One of these days I'd like to go to a concert of his. He's only gotten better!
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent. He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell. There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN. I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard. Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
@@Danzwme OK, but it just bothered me that she wasn‘t even given a proper chance to show what she‘s got. In my view, she made a number of tactical errors : firstly, she announced that her brother is waiting in the wings to sing, then especially the choice of her first song was catastrophic. When she started off with the second song, and Simon reacted negatively, the other judges just followed suit. It left a bad taste in my mouth.. Sorry !!!
I’ve seen Calum (opened for PTX yrs ago) He’s Amazing. Would be cool to see him & sister perform together!!! Wish we could have heard a whole song from her. Simon rocked her mojo at the beginning. Not fair.
I thought it was unfair for Jade.they did not give her long enough to even hear her. Its wrong. I thought the second song sounded good.I am so sorry Jade you were both good.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent. He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell. There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN. I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard. Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent. He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell. There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN. I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard. Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
Some people dream of being on that stage some took decades to overcome their fears so the least these judges could do is give her a chance to sing halfway or finish what she came to do😢
@@Danzwmei totally agreed with you. Simon may not be the nicest judge. But he does know when you have talent or not. Sister was ok. But the brother has an amazing voice.
@@Klickity-m3c I didn't single out Simon for anything, I actually believe he is the best judge as he is honest with a gift for finding talent, no where did I mention him. My comment was about not showing the sister sing which they most definitely did as I remember watching her. Nice voice but nothing special, him I remember being wowed by. Please read the comments correctly before commenting.
Wait, before she was on spotify and had two songs out called Dynamite and You Can Always Leave. I just looked her up after seeing your comment, and you’re right! Her profile is gone and when I try to add her songs to queue, it skipped over it like it had been removed. This is happening with a few songs I listen to. Wtf is going on with spotify?
@@k-06-11 I check every so often to see if she has any new songs but it's only these two. Unfortunately she turned off the comments so she can't hear from people who really do like her and support her. She's probably afraid of seeing the negative comments, which I don't blame her as she was humiliated in front of millions and millions of people by Simon. She has a great voice and I love her style. I felt she wasn't treated fairly because they cut her off after a couple of words.
She is pretty in her own way, but in all honesty, I think it came down to her look. Simon saw her and judged her before she opened her mouth to sing. It is a shame because I think she sounded great!
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent. He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell. There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN. I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard. Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
Simon and the judges were such jerks! I really liked Jade! They didn't even give her a chance! She was nervous. What a slap in the face to her. I couldn't tell if she was crying cuz she was hurt, devastated or proud or maybe all of them. I really hope she gets another fair chance and gets big.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent. He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell. There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN. I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard. Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
They're not jerks, they just need to be brutally honest and know if someone has it for a bigger stage and many types of songs and she wasn't quite there.
I've watched this same video a hundred times. It never gets old. It's amazing how he took that song and made it his own. Just as Simon said that he is an artist not just a vocalist....and look at him now! SuperStar*****
When the producer says: „okay judges, we‘re going to have it so that the next singer gets rejected to bring suspense for the her brother singer’s audition.“ No one in their right mind should have stopped Jane‘s audition so early - she was building up the songs with a soft beginning on purpose - it’s called Artistry - thumbs down to the show on that decision.
They are professionals who have an ear for this. They know what they are doing and are highly successful at it. Believe it or not, sometimes the answer is no.
Well the winner of agt this year Richard goodall sang don't stop believe and he got the golden buzzer. He was off key and flat on a ton of notes and he literally won so they must not have had a great ear. Don't b get me wrong I think he sounded great but he still missed the notes sooo
Same mic, same stage, same theater, but a totally different sound filling it up! Calum was a part of a tribute band to Maroon 5, and I think you can hear all the extra hours and confidence behind his voice. And the fact that he put together this arrangement...? Yeah, I'm not knocking his sister, but you can really hear the difference between a decent singer and a phenomenal one with no tricks or edits.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent. He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell. There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN. I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard. Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
@@cynthiamahoney1015nobody is 100% correct in life, business choices, or finding talent. To say that Simon cant spot talent because he passed on this one person or 10 people out of hundreds and thousands of people he has seen is ridiculous.
Watched this so many times. Jade didn't get a fair shot by any stretch. I have listened to a few of her songs and she is Brilliant! I really felt for her in this, it must have been painful. I love Calum to pieces, he's awesome and a true honest artist and he even said Jade is the main reason for his singing. Their Mum is absolutely lovely.
@@pls6247 It is however his fault for not giving her a chance to prove him wrong. You can have talent and still be stopped within a second because they think they can see you have none already. You can't prove yourself if you don't get a chance to do so.
I think Jade was singing songs below her ideal key. She didn’t have control or power but might have if the key was raised. I once worked with an entertainment lawyer and producer. To illustrate tgat I had recorded a singer in the wrong key, he put on a Mick Jagger song that he had produced. It was by far the best recording of Jagger I ever heard. In addition to the rough voice there was a richness I had never heard. I asked the producer how he did tat. He replied, “I was illustrating how important but is to get the key right…down to the half step. No one had ever taken the time to get his key…down to the half step.” Like C# not C. That is what may have been the problem with Jade.
I initially only saw Calum's audition years ago. I wondered what happened to Jade prior to Calum taking the stage, and then it slipped my mind. Today, I was listening to one of Calum's songs and Jade came back to mind. Well, this made it all the more emotional seeing what happened to Jade.
Jade has a good/cool voice, but did need some training as she was pitchy at times. She has lots of potential and she's a pretty girl. I hope she kept going and hasn't given up on singing.
I always watch calum Scott .. Even this audition like 40/50 time. But Till this day I've never seen her sister sing. I always thought that was his wife😮
*Simon got it right, I see a bunch of comments below saying hey Jade was good and not given a fair chance, etc... That's the problem, she was only good, not fantastic, etc... You want to pass someone through who's going to have a real chance at making it to the finals. Jade would never get there based on her karaoke like singing. Her brother on the other hand, he made people cry and moved the whole place!! That's what they're looking for.*
I think you’re right. Simon even said something about her “ lounge singer” style or something close to that. It obviously was too ordinary to pass on and give her hopes that she would keep rising through all the stages. Her brother was under tremendous pressure after seeing her fail, so hats off to him for keeping his cool and doing so well..
Absolutely. Cause in the show they look at your ages, looks personality etc to determine how much potential you got. If you're young, pretty, got a fantastic voice you got the superstar quality
Simon was and still is a jerk. Look at his past appearances on these competitive shows. Don't believe how now he is seemingly a nice guy. He was told by the producers of these shows that he needed to step down...So he became nice..NOT because he is nice.
I have noticed many adjustments on his part. I guess it's probably true. His nature is very strongly opinionated & acts on impulse. I hope the best for this beautiful young woman! ❤️
Simon loves male singers. Always favored them Jades nerves got the best of her. She didn’t it make it that far to the tv show easily. There’s several several rounds
Simon shot her down twice how rude you can't make a judgment call on a few seconds of a song some people need to have time to shake tge nerves I believe Jade would have come out if given time to get halfway through the songs !
Jade and Calum ❤
Booboo u guys didn't give her a chance
@@karencharles3464I thought it was pretty awful. I didn’t like Calum’s one either tho
Yes I thought she had potential but they never gave her a chance to show what she could do. I was disappointed in the way she was treated. So sad, crush someones dream in one second flat. Nice going Simon
@@Jessica18010I didn't find it gold buzzer worthy. Guilt trip much Simon. Fkd up and then added salt to the wound by doing what he did. That was messed up
Suck up much Simon, he wasn't all that fr.
I LOVED her voice.. It's stunning!! I hope she keeps singing.. blessed with a beautiful voice and talent like that. Such a beautiful family ❤️
She is a good singer, but she is not a great singer. Perhaps with some vocal training she could be. I think she has potential, but Simon's critique was spot on. She just doesn't have commercial viability.
It’s just okay. Nothing “stunning about it”
she’s a good singer but like simon said it’s a bit club singer ish
Yh
Me too
I feel SO MUCH for Jade! Feeling so much devastation and then such pride and joy over her brother’s audition--gosh, you can see it in her face!
Not just you. She had no time to get comfy on stage.
Part of the business.
@@taylorrenee4880…What? Fakery and robbery?
Those guys in the wings are so supportive of most of the contestants, showing empathy and compassion.
they're great
Ant and Dec you mean.
Love em!
I love how much she supported her brother. There is a LOT of love there! And honestly, if given the chance, she would’ve done well. But we weren’t allowed to hear her. But I’m sure both she and her brother are doing well, because he doesn’t seem like the kind to leave her in the cold. I adore brother, sister, and mom!
She sucked, if you could not see the night and day difference between brother and sister, take a cold shower mate
❤❤❤
They completely ripped Jade OFF. They didn't listen long enough, they didn't let US listen long enough, and she was not given a fair shake. They literally cut her off before she ever got a chance. Not just disappointed for her. She was RIPPED OFF.
I agree, I was enjoying the second song and felt ripped off too. Poor darling.
A million people sing like jade but maybe a thousand sing like Callum. She just wasn’t very good.
Rubbish she was average
I wish I could have heard more of Jade’s song… she has a very unique voice❤
I preferred her voice tbf
I love Calum Scott - he's so genuine and you could feel his pain that he shared for his sister. I have a younger sister and I'd not have been so kind to the judges if they did to her that which they did to Calum's sister. He's doing so well now as an artist. One of these days I'd like to go to a concert of his. He's only gotten better!
I absolutely loved Calum Scotts audition... He's got a unbelievable voice ❤
For some reason this girl‘s audition was stopped TWICE before she really got started !!! Totally UNFAIR !!! 👎🤮😱
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent.
He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell.
There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN.
I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard.
Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
@@Danzwme OK, but it just bothered me that she wasn‘t even given a proper chance to show what she‘s got. In my view, she made a number of tactical errors : firstly, she announced that her brother is waiting in the wings to sing, then especially the choice of her first song was catastrophic. When she started off with the second song, and Simon reacted negatively, the other judges just followed suit. It left a bad taste in my mouth.. Sorry !!!
@@zeejimi4044she just isn’t very good. Thats all.
@@Arizona_Stonah OK, maybe you’re right, but she wasn’t given a fair chance at the audition..🤷🏼♂️
Agree. Not fair.
I’ve seen Calum (opened for PTX yrs ago) He’s Amazing.
Would be cool to see him & sister perform together!!!
Wish we could have heard a whole song from her. Simon rocked her mojo at the beginning. Not fair.
Yes I think exactly the same thing
I also saw him open for PTX in Bangor years ago, he sited in our hotel & we saw him twice!
❤true🎉❤😊
I thought it was unfair for Jade.they did not give her long enough to even hear her. Its wrong. I thought the second song sounded good.I am so sorry Jade you were both good.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent.
He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell.
There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN.
I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard.
Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent.
He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell.
There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN.
I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard.
Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
@@Danzwme he still should have given her a chance to sing more than a few bars.
Some people dream of being on that stage some took decades to overcome their fears so the least these judges could do is give her a chance to sing halfway or finish what she came to do😢
@@Danzwmei totally agreed with you. Simon may not be the nicest judge. But he does know when you have talent or not. Sister was ok. But the brother has an amazing voice.
He didn't even give her a chance! Wtf?
Jade...I liked what I was allowed to hear!😂
This has been edited, it has always been seen
All four judges gave her a no so just don’t single out Simon. He has an ear for talent, he is good what he does.
@@Klickity-m3c I didn't single out Simon for anything, I actually believe he is the best judge as he is honest with a gift for finding talent, no where did I mention him. My comment was about not showing the sister sing which they most definitely did as I remember watching her. Nice voice but nothing special, him I remember being wowed by. Please read the comments correctly before commenting.
@@debbiecagliarini4421 yes read the comments HE didn’t give her a chance maybe she should have said THEY. HE is referring to one person as in Simon.
@@Klickity-m3c…The show is rigged. Her voice was amazing!
Looked her up on spotify...Sadly couldn't find anything there. Keep singing Jade! U have a beautiful voice!
Wait, before she was on spotify and had two songs out called Dynamite and You Can Always Leave. I just looked her up after seeing your comment, and you’re right! Her profile is gone and when I try to add her songs to queue, it skipped over it like it had been removed. This is happening with a few songs I listen to. Wtf is going on with spotify?
@@k-06-11 I check every so often to see if she has any new songs but it's only these two. Unfortunately she turned off the comments so she can't hear from people who really do like her and support her. She's probably afraid of seeing the negative comments, which I don't blame her as she was humiliated in front of millions and millions of people by Simon. She has a great voice and I love her style. I felt she wasn't treated fairly because they cut her off after a couple of words.
Clearly Simon didn’t give Jade a fair shot.
Unusual and touchy
She is pretty in her own way, but in all honesty, I think it came down to her look. Simon saw her and judged her before she opened her mouth to sing. It is a shame because I think she sounded great!
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent.
He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell.
There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN.
I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard.
Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
@@MrMcGribbleshe's great for a small town pub. Hopefully she can get some training.
She was at least as good as some of the goofballs they put thru.
Simon and the judges were such jerks! I really liked Jade! They didn't even give her a chance! She was nervous. What a slap in the face to her. I couldn't tell if she was crying cuz she was hurt, devastated or proud or maybe all of them. I really hope she gets another fair chance and gets big.
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent.
He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell.
There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN.
I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard.
Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
I agree
She had talent, yes, but needed a lot more work on her voice quality. Sorry Simon was right.
They're not jerks, they just need to be brutally honest and know if someone has it for a bigger stage and many types of songs and she wasn't quite there.
Simon and the rest of them never gave her a chance, can't stand Amanda Holden
I've watched this same video a hundred times. It never gets old. It's amazing how he took that song and made it his own. Just as Simon said that he is an artist not just a vocalist....and look at him now! SuperStar*****
She has a beautiful voice 💗💗💗
When the producer says: „okay judges, we‘re going to have it so that the next singer gets rejected to bring suspense for the her brother singer’s audition.“ No one in their right mind should have stopped Jane‘s audition so early - she was building up the songs with a soft beginning on purpose - it’s called Artistry - thumbs down to the show on that decision.
She wasn't in tune at all. It was a different key she was in. That's why he stopped her.
They are professionals who have an ear for this. They know what they are doing and are highly successful at it. Believe it or not, sometimes the answer is no.
This! They don’t let her get to the bridge…. TWICE! I looked her up on Instagram years ago, she’s a good singer! A shame.
Well the winner of agt this year Richard goodall sang don't stop believe and he got the golden buzzer. He was off key and flat on a ton of notes and he literally won so they must not have had a great ear. Don't b get me wrong I think he sounded great but he still missed the notes sooo
@@idontkknowyou9518let's hear simon sing
Now it's so clear how much pressure was on him! 🥺
Same mic, same stage, same theater, but a totally different sound filling it up! Calum was a part of a tribute band to Maroon 5, and I think you can hear all the extra hours and confidence behind his voice. And the fact that he put together this arrangement...? Yeah, I'm not knocking his sister, but you can really hear the difference between a decent singer and a phenomenal one with no tricks or edits.
It’s amazing they found this gem. All his new songs are so beautiful as well.
Hope someone gives Jade a chance. Maybe her brother can sing a duet with her on his next album 💿
How could she get into the song when she was cut off every time?😂😂😂
Exactly!
Simon was 100% correct. He has been in the music biz for decades & has an ear for talent or non-talent.
He was absolutely correct that she has a 'singing in my bedroom in front of the mirror voice'. She's continued in music due to her family & friends encouragement; doesn't mean she has a commercial voice that would sell.
There was nothing exceptional or even good about her voice. Her brother on the other hand has pure talent, is able to capture the essence of a song & relays that to the listener in a way that makes the listener LISTEN.
I could listen to Callum sing this over & over every day for the rest of my life. I couldn't wait for his sister to stop singing. That's what Simon & David heard.
Simon & David knew what they heard from her & what just wasn't there. Amanda did the sheep thing & just followed their input.
@@Danzwme My point was the unfair brevity.
Moreover ,far from a perfect record,Simon has turned down many ie Tori kelly
@@cynthiamahoney1015nobody is 100% correct in life, business choices, or finding talent. To say that Simon cant spot talent because he passed on this one person or 10 people out of hundreds and thousands of people he has seen is ridiculous.
Exactly
I think Jade's voice is really cool. With some vocal training and stage presence training, she'd be amazing.
nothing unseen about this, it's always been out there. I watched her, then Calum years ago.
i’ve seen calum’s audition countless times but have never seen his sister’s tbh
I've seen the sisters audition many times. Pretty much anytime I search for his videos hers has always popped up too.
The videos I have seen just showed the part where Simon reprimands her,not her actually singing.
Already seen this months or maybe even years ago
correct his audition was straight after her i remember
Watched this so many times. Jade didn't get a fair shot by any stretch. I have listened to a few of her songs and she is Brilliant! I really felt for her in this, it must have been painful.
I love Calum to pieces, he's awesome and a true honest artist and he even said Jade is the main reason for his singing. Their Mum is absolutely lovely.
I love Callum sisters voice. I think nerves got her. I hope she keeps singing.
Jade's voice is beautiful! Simon was so wrong for rejecting her. I'm still in shock they didn't absolutely love her
Is it just me or did Simon just stop Jade almost immediately every time?
He had no interest in giving her a chance at all.
Yes! He's such a jerk!
It's not you. He was a jerk and didn't let her get into the songs.
Her talent and ability or lack there of is NOT Simon's fault. She's just not that good.
@@pls6247 It is however his fault for not giving her a chance to prove him wrong. You can have talent and still be stopped within a second because they think they can see you have none already. You can't prove yourself if you don't get a chance to do so.
She's so sweet 😢
I think Jade was singing songs below her ideal key. She didn’t have control or power but might have if the key was raised. I once worked with an entertainment lawyer and producer. To illustrate tgat I had recorded a singer in the wrong key, he put on a Mick Jagger song that he had produced. It was by far the best recording of Jagger I ever heard. In addition to the rough voice there was a richness I had never heard. I asked the producer how he did tat. He replied, “I was illustrating how important but is to get the key right…down to the half step. No one had ever taken the time to get his key…down to the half step.” Like C# not C. That is what may have been the problem with Jade.
She also lacked confidence which Callum has.
I initially only saw Calum's audition years ago. I wondered what happened to Jade prior to Calum taking the stage, and then it slipped my mind. Today, I was listening to one of Calum's songs and Jade came back to mind. Well, this made it all the more emotional seeing what happened to Jade.
How did the moms heart must have been conflcted ,happy for the one child and breaking for the other ❤.
Jade has a good/cool voice, but did need some training as she was pitchy at times. She has lots of potential and she's a pretty girl. I hope she kept going and hasn't given up on singing.
Her audition was not unseen and she did a really good job, get your facts straight
just more proof that the music industry is about looks
She was average. Not a strong singer. She was ok. Sweet girl but its a No.
Acting like youre a judge 💀 stfu @@tracym31
I never ever tire watching this!!! 08/2024!!!!! ❤❤❤❤🇨🇦
So tough for the mum to watch. One child rejected and the other praised to the hilt. I thought they both had good voices but Calum was amazing
Callums voice is beautiful ❤
Crazy emotional feelings going through him all the way and he pulls that out!!!! Incredible ❤
Just because Simon doesn't like something doesn't mean ALL the judges have to hate it to....
Went and saw him live in a great venue. Good show!!
Thank you! I looked for this when he won.
I listen to Calum's new material and he's still got it.
The song your singing travels so well as any Pro. God bless your sister don't let her give 😅up!!🙏🏻
Absolutely beautiful ❤❤ so was he's sister thankyou ❤❤
I really liked her.
As a stepmom, this would have broken my heart. It’s so hard to see one succeed and the other bulldozed.
I hope that she continued with music? Her brother became so famous that I hope 🎉she wasn't left behind
I thought Jade could be the next Stevie Nicks. Great voice, very different. Hang onin there Jade.❤
This has always sat weird with me because they’ve let plenty of people through who didn’t sound good at all. She actually sounds good.
Jade sounds like a young Sally Oldfield. Loved it. ❤
I love your voice Jade. You can be proud of yourself. ❤
Man what a beautiful voice...I'd pay to hear her sing that song ❤
She sounded excellent and Simon didn’t let her have a chance wow
Sarahjohnson805---don't listen to polski. I agree with you👍
Ah the second she started she had me. She is intresting have a beautiful and amazing voice. She id special for sure ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
What a humble guy. Hope he remains humble because he has a wonderful rare gift. ❤️🇵🇱🇨🇦
Simon has always been unfair. Have seen him press the red buzzer and the act ends up with a golden buzzer from another judge.
I thought she was very good too. I dont feel like she got a fair vote
I am speechless to witness the love between brother and sister ❤️
They should have listened to her full song so unfare 😮😢
Simon didn't give her a chance... I like her voice.. & her brothers
She’s precious x beautiful soul x
Simon was impatient. The other judges should have objected.
He has a beautiful voice oh wow I'm in awe........!!!
I've always felt that Jade should try again
She needs to go on THE VOICE
I saw this YEARS ago on youtube; it was not unseen.
She didn't get into the song because the judges didn't let her, so judgmental so quickly. Out of order
In 5 measures of music, a professional can tell if the one singing has out or not…
Its also edited to give a look. Were much of what happens realy
It takes very little for a professional to know if it’s good or not
When i hear his voice and sing the dancing on my own at the time that i like the song until now 😯😯😯😯❤️❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍😍😍
I'm glad you got the golden buzzer but that had to hurt her.
I always watch calum Scott .. Even this audition like 40/50 time.
But Till this day I've never seen her sister sing.
I always thought that was his wife😮
I liked her singing!
*Simon got it right, I see a bunch of comments below saying hey Jade was good and not given a fair chance, etc... That's the problem, she was only good, not fantastic, etc... You want to pass someone through who's going to have a real chance at making it to the finals. Jade would never get there based on her karaoke like singing. Her brother on the other hand, he made people cry and moved the whole place!! That's what they're looking for.*
I think you’re right. Simon even said something about her “ lounge singer” style or something close to that. It obviously was too ordinary to pass on and give her hopes that she would keep rising through all the stages. Her brother was under tremendous pressure after seeing her fail, so hats off to him for keeping his cool and doing so well..
💯💯💯 she was out of tune
Simon should wait a bit then reject them, hear them out then critique
@@specialist4luciek425 *Remember, this is show biz, they're always going for the most dramatic effects.*
Absolutely. Cause in the show they look at your ages, looks personality etc to determine how much potential you got. If you're young, pretty, got a fantastic voice you got the superstar quality
Awwwww, she sings so beautiful! ❤ how sad.
БРАВО!!! ЭТО ИСТИННОЕ СЧАСТЬЕ!!! 😥❤❤❤👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏
Everyone sees you standing there, WOW CALUM....
Simon hears something Jade don’t give up baby girl reach for the stars ⭐️
Calum jusst for that you and your Sister should make a Duett
They didn't give her a chance, imo.
Jade has the most amazing voice, ❤
My fav male artist❤
Oh my goodness, that is so very true... He's just amazing 😊🤩
when calum looks to check his sister is ok 6.52
He must've been very mad at Simon! He truly did a GREAT JOB AFTER ALL & DESERVED THE GOLDEN BUZZER!! SIMON YOU'RE A PIECE OF 💩 SOMETIMES!! 💯☝️🎤🌟🎶🔥🥰
@@lifesabitch8012 the problem is simon is often to honest and that can hurt, is that better than giving someone false hope of stardom ?
@@alanc2k1 That's true!
All those people that hate on Simon be glad there are people that dare to be honest in a world full of lies
Calum already sounded like a pro here ,love u calum ❤
Jade wasn't given a fair chance period her brothers voice is something else
I liked Jades voice!
I love their story !!!❤❤🎉🎉
I don't think the judges allowed Jade to sing either song long enough for us to get a good feel for her voice range, tone, etc. What a shame!
Jade Keep Practicing. Don't Give Up. 👍👍👍
Simon was and still is a jerk. Look at his past appearances on these competitive shows. Don't believe how now he is seemingly a nice guy. He was told by the producers of these shows that he needed to step down...So he became nice..NOT because he is nice.
Damn right. The man is a waste of space and full of himself.
I have noticed many adjustments on his part. I guess it's probably true. His nature is very strongly opinionated & acts on impulse. I hope the best for this beautiful young woman! ❤️
Simon has a very mean side to him!🤬🤯👎💔
@Polski_Kabaret You're the ignorant one
STAGED FOR HER BROTHER, CALUM
Simon loves male singers. Always favored them
Jades nerves got the best of her. She didn’t it make it that far to the tv show easily. There’s several several rounds
She’s good! Definitely a lot better than me 😂
One or 2 lines of jade singing was definitely not enough.. she had a sweet voice, i would have loved to heard more from her..
I dont think simon gave her a chance but now i love caliums voice
Jade needs allowed to sing a whole song.
Simon shot her down twice how rude you can't make a judgment call on a few seconds of a song some people need to have time to shake tge nerves I believe Jade would have come out if given time to get halfway through the songs !
Simon didn't even give Jade a chance!!!!!!!!!!!!