Its a Marmite situation here folks. You either love it or hate it. I love Marmite and even though I love the original, The Manics do this song justice. For non Brits....Google Marmite to know what in the hell I am talking about.
For everyone complaining about this version, I recommend the original version that this band made in 1992. You can find it on their official channel on this site. It's a much better version. It had Richey Edwards playing guitar in it, so naturally it'll sound better. Plus, they only made it back then for charity, The Spastic Society, now called Scope. It was a mega hit, thus earning the charity a ton of money. Feel good about insulting this song now?
smegbug2 " It had Richey Edwards playing guitar in it, so naturally it'll sound better" - oh right you mean the guitarist that was *famously* never turned up ?
This is a cover, not the original. There are several other covers online. Most times covers are not as good as the original, but so what? This is good, anyway.
I love how the tempo changes for the solo and takes this song to a totally different level. Awesome.
This song moves me to tears . It’s so heavy
Its a Marmite situation here folks. You either love it or hate it. I love Marmite and even though I love the original, The Manics do this song justice. For non Brits....Google Marmite to know what in the hell I am talking about.
Painfully beatiful
For everyone complaining about this version, I recommend the original version that this band made in 1992. You can find it on their official channel on this site. It's a much better version. It had Richey Edwards playing guitar in it, so naturally it'll sound better. Plus, they only made it back then for charity, The Spastic Society, now called Scope. It was a mega hit, thus earning the charity a ton of money. Feel good about insulting this song now?
smegbug2 " It had Richey Edwards playing guitar in it, so naturally it'll sound better" - oh right you mean the guitarist that was *famously* never turned up ?
perhaps the more logical reason for it sounding better is that it's a studio recording
The Spastic Society? Seriously?
@@BlueAxeRacer yes
@@BlueAxeRacer before people woke up, that’s what it was called.
Good cover
Intetesting version of a great song
JDB is my f guitar hero
Quoting poetry to music
Nicky *choking*
JAMES Choking even more*
SEEEEAAAANNNN *falling dead of admiration*
Thank you, sorry for the short notice
I guess some people just don't like saying "please"
Nice. Great modern day twist. I love it. :)
Bin ein riesen Fan ,genial.
This is a cover, not the original. There are several other covers online. Most times covers are not as good as the original, but so what? This is good, anyway.
+Ana Luiza Brown This isn't the original? You mean they didn't play this in 1970? Weird.
Music cool
awesome.... Like innit mun.
like this,,,
Fuckin superb version
Class solo
Suicide might be painless, but listening to this bloke isn't.
Is that your advice?
Versão genial
the audience are dead zombie.
It doesn't half
Once in a while, a remake lives up to the original. This is NOT one of those times.
Not the best live version I've heard by the manics,amazing cover though when they released it back in 1992 for charity album ruby Trax
Doesn't get close to doing justice to the true feeling of the song. The singing is my gripe. The music was worth the listen.
This is not James' finest three minutes. I think Ill pop on the acoustic version of Pealed Apples so.
if you don't like it you know what to do.
Is this for Richie?
SURE
the original is way Better!!!!! the Mash!!!
torturing the song and ears of ppl who accidently hear this sht
OMG .what are trying do to the original theme !! this is CRAP not M*A*S*H*
this is a live performance -_- DUH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Marc Bolland actually it is good
Even Marilyn Manson was better
i hope he has another job. embarrassing this is what passes for a singer.
+WV591 Isn't there a pop idol competition you should be getting all teary-eyed over?
Manics are definitely marmite
horror performance..out of tune
terrible voice
this group should be forbidden
Pictish DaegOs get the wax out ya ears
Good cover