The Mandela Effect in Star Wars
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- I feel so good talking about the original trilogy for once. Leave any suggestions for videos about episodes 4-6 because I want to talk about them more.
#starwars #mandelaeffect #darthvader #empirestrikesback
VICTORY CELEBRATION Nostalgic Orchestral Edition by snowray: • Star Wars - Victory Ce...
As of writing this description I have 9,714 subs
I upload every Friday
Shorts on Saturday too
feel free to leave a comment about the video or just asking me questions down below
Channel link: / @dabluebountyhunter
My business email: chadbane66blue@gmail.com
channel art and most background music by Da Blue Bounty Hunter
Duel Of The Fates Trap Remix by / @lowfeel03
Check out the merch: dbbhstore.com/
Join this channel to get access to rewards:
/ @dabluebountyhunter - บันเทิง
“So this is how liberty dies. With thunderous applause” that quote hits hard
Yeah it’s my favorite quote from Star Wars
@@B1_buddy One of the most masterful lines of George Lucas' career. His exploration of the complexities of politics in the prequels is quite interesting.
I always thought it was rather childish ngl.
@@alexandercorbett3095 How
r/ im14andthisisdeep
Aside of a Mandela Effect, I think C-3PO’s leg was caused by the toys (most of them is the whole golden body)
True, even a lot of "official" merch makes the same mistake.
He has a gold leg tho
I think that is exactly the reason, because as a kid there was no way to watch Star Wars over and over but you saw your action figures every day, and in the books it wasn't super clear that it was silver it clearly was metallic but the toys you have in your hands and spend so much time with is what cements those memories.
I have a toy with a silver leg
@@Jack_Stafford i did watch it over and over return of the jedi i never owned any star wars figures and i always saw the silver leg
id blame lego star wars for the c3po leg, cuz in the game and the actual minifigure for the longest time had both legs gold
That’s because Lego can’t put prints that low on the leg, so the only time it’s ever been right was the time when the make the Lego out of two different plastics, so that the silver part is actually entirely gray
@@Darth_B well the c3po fig from around 2014 did also have a bit of silver printing in his right knee to represent his silver leg, but yea the dual molded leg works much better for him
The original Kenner action figure from the 70s had him all gold.
It goes back WAY before then. The original Kenner figures were solid gold. Plus the relaunched 95 Star Wars Kenner line did the same thing.
Many of us were too young to have watched any of the originals in the theaters so our only options in the mid to late 80's were the pan and scan VHS tapes viewed on very small TV's. Most of that detail was lost in such low res plus having about 40% of the footage cropped out..
C3po does have a gold leg tho
The Mandela effect is just people with bad memories.
Not even, people are just dumb. Remember the game telephone? We can't even pass along a message and it still be the same at the end.
@@TildenCats it’s because some people try to be funny
Nah nah the Mandela effect exists? For example in your "humble" opinion when did Nelson Mandela Die?
Mandela was the first black President of South Africa, everyone knows that
Yup pretty much just people saying “oh you remember this extremely easy thing to misremember too? This is so crazy guys, must be the Mandela effect.”
it may not be spoken in RotJ, but in the credits, you see -
Ewok Warrior - Malcom Dixon
Ewok Warrior - Mike Cottrell
My name is Malcolm
My name is Mike
his name is robert paulson
i am sure that the "Luke I'm your father" was originally someone paraphrasing what happened only for people to start mistaking it for a direct quote.
Yes, primarily for merchandise like hats and t-shirts, having a t-shirt that just says "I am your father" is creepy, but one that says "Luke, I am your father" it clearly is referencing the huge international pop cultural impact of the movie at the time and no one would be confused which Luke you were talking about.
Just like the "I shot JR" t-shirts, if you wore a t-shirt that just said "I shot him" it wouldn't have made any sense lol
No I remember it in the theater.
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
Think about it, if someone just said "i am your father" it would be hard to take it as a Star wars quote. Adding the "Luke" before hand implies that you're referring to Luke Skywalker.
@@jennifernordlund2691 as an 80s kid I remember being weirded out because he didn't say it. I saw it on VHS sooo 🤷
When I saw the Phantom Menace in the theater when I was four, I remember Darth Maul bleeding sparks while falling down the shaft after getting cut in half. I remembered it so vividly that I was actually surprised the second time I saw it when I saw that he wasn't bleeding sparks. I think it's because there were sparks earlier in that scene when he was slashing the ground with his lightsaber, and my young mind put the two things together.
No no! Im certain i saw something like that too! I cant say it was blood but it was red and looked like exactly how you described it
@@Salieri01 you might be remembering that right when Obi-Wan slices him, you see a red mist fly up for a second, that being his vaporized blood. It is only there for a second though, not as he falls down the shaft.
😊
@@Icelandic_Sand oh yeah, my bad! Thanks!
Its possible it was edited out
for some reason i thought this really bad movie called “the rise of skywalker” existed and like palpatine returned or something. turns out it never existed
I like the touch of C-3PO having a silver leg. It’s like the original casing broke, but they couldn’t afford to fix it, or it was meant to be a placeholder that kept getting pushed to the backburner. It helped establish the idea of this being a “lived-in” universe, with patch-work repairs and tech that had corroded due to age.
Here is the thing, I remember C-3PO having a silver leg when the movie came out. My dad pointed it out because he liked how Lucas made the world look "lived in" and not perfect. We also discussed how it was a detail most people overlooked.
*The toy company was too cheap to make C3PO action figures with a silver leg*
*as it would have add additional, labor intensive steps to the manufacturing process.*
@@jsl151850b yeah and that's what mandela effect channels play on to fool people
me too
yep
1:18 i thought vaders helmet was a giant ship as well as a kid lmao
this is now the canon Lusankya
If you watched "Challenge of the Super Friends" on television in 1978, the Legion of Doom ship looked like Darth Vader's helmet.
It’s probably cause as a kid, the toys had all gold on the body, it wasn’t until recent C-3PO toys were made, it had the silver leg.
Not just toys, he was frequently drawn that way on posters and other material.
Personally I remember the "no. I am your father" because of the way he says no followed by I, he enunciates them in such a particular way that having it be Luke just doesn't carry the same vibe, so to speak.
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
I only said Luke because my classmates were uncultured heathers who wouldn't know what I was talking about if I just said I was their father lol
@@alakani as valid an excuse as any in my book :p
Between the original theater showings of “Star Wars” and “The Empire Strikes Back”, I had a middle school friend who swore that he had seen Darth Vader’s TIE fighter blow up in the Death Star explosion. No amount of arguing would convince him otherwise. And we couldn’t play back a VHS tape of the movie to prove him wrong, because it didn’t exist then! 😄
that no but the original edit of Star Wars showed Wedge Antilles x-wing blow up at least 3 times.
In a similar vein to the ewok thing, the Emperor doesn't get the name "Palpatine" until the prequel trilogy comes out, nor is his sith name Darth Sideous ever said.
Boba Fett also isn't named until RotJ. In ESB, he's just "the bounty hunter."
That's not true. The name Senator Palpatine is in the 1976 novelization of Star Wars and again in the 1983 novelization of Return of the Jedi.
Ironically Boba Fett was named... In the Star Wars Christmas Special.
That's because Darth wasn't a title when those movies were made. It was his name, Darth Vader.
It only became a title after the OT
I thought that there was a post-credits scene at the end of the Phantom Menace that showed Darth Maul had survived, but upon rewatching I realized that was utterly false.
Easy they removed it
So could be real
But we don’t know
SAME I COULDVE SWORN IT EXISTS
Interesting, how do you remember it playing out?
As a kid in the 80's, I certainly noticed Threepio had a silver leg in the movies, because I always pointed out they didn't give him one on the original toy.
Yoda figures, early style came with a orange snake. 🐍 no names or scenes in TESB. Kenner removes the snake in later versions.
every true star wars fan knows he had a silver leg
Its funny when people say madela effect isnt real and its just people misremembering something but mandela effect is just what you call something when a large group of people who just remember something wrong
You don't breathe, you just inhale and exhale
Mandela effect is the idea that something has changed from what it once was, e.g. “berenstein bears” vs. “berenstain bears” it’s when people think that something has changed even though it was always that way
I always remembered C-3PO’s entire leg being silver but now his leg is only silver from the knee down
I do too.
Understandable, florescent lighting on the set and old CRT TV screens.
It's silver in a few scenes. Knee. I took it to be a replaced part or C3POs age. There is a white, silver 3PO by him in the early scenes. K3PO is the "lead" droid Echo Base-Hoth. He's destroyed in the Empire raid. K3PO is briefly seen in a rubble scene.
I saw the original Star Wars when I was 8 and clearly remember noticing his right leg being silver from the knee down, particularly because it made me wonder, "What, did he get it damaged and had to get a leg salvaged from a silver protocol droid?" I never did find out why his leg was a different color.
When I originally saw Return of the Jedi in the theater in 1983 (I was 12 going on 13), I distinctly remember during the Rancor scene Luke jumping and hanging onto the grating above, and Jawas and other creatures stomping on his hands to where he finally fell. I know people on the internet have said there is a rough work print of that scene, in black and white, but I saw it in full color, integrated into the film. I have NEVER seen that edit of ROTJ since on any released medium.
I also remember seeing that scene, and it was on the TV release version (UK release). But I havent seen it in any other version since, and the TV version's are now edits of the special editions.
@@telesian5143 it was the same with superman 3 the tv version had scenes that were never in the home video versions like at the start theres a child on a see saw who goes flying into a tree and superman saves her
I remember this!!! And I’m American!!!
I do remember the vader scene and i thought his helmet's neck was just blending into the background never confused me as a kid, and i never knew there were at-sts at hoth
Vader saying "Luke, I am your father" was never the mandela effect. Just people who didn't remember the scene, and incorrectly assumed that is what was said.
Mandela Effect is just an attempt to "mystify" people with bad memory.
The point of the effect though is that people seem to share these wrong memories. If they were all different memories that would be one thing, but the same?
isn't that just how the mandela effect works tho?
I assumed it was so people could just skip the whole citing Star Wars and make it converse easier
I don’t even thing it’s really “bad” memory, human beings just aren’t good at accurately remembering small details. Especially because most of these discrepancies are relatively small differences, there’s no need for us to remember them in the grand scheme of things. The “Mandela Effect” pretty much never happens with major plot points for example.
@@psykat777one person says something similar to how another remembers it, and it just latches on. So many people repeating the wrong quote that it just becomes the quote
Monopoly guy did have a monocle at one point
Yup pretty sure in Junior Monopoly he has one!
I remember Vader saying "No, Luke...I am your father."
I remember C 3p0's leg being silver but the foot being gold. Which is why I was confused when the Lego UCS C 3p0 one had a full silver bottom part of his leg. 😅
Okay okay i did actually think the last scene of empire was the galaxy shot idk why
Because that's likely what Lucas would've done if he was directing the cinematography for ESB but he didn't. That's also why ESB doesn't have the same intro opening where a ship enters the frame from the top.
He did an emergency edit when he saw what was done.
I don't know if this counts as Mandela Effect, but if it counts, it's probably one of the most craziest cases of such. As I have seen The Force Awakens for the first time, I thought for a longer while, that the Hosnian System was destroyed before the main characters went to Takodana. Then I read the comic-adaption of the movie and was really shocked to see the exact opposite.
I entered the Star Wars universe quite recently, just a few years ago. And when I started my marathon on the films from this universe, I was very surprised by one scene from The Phantom Menace.
Even in early childhood, I saw some moments from these films when my brother showed them to me or when I later saw them on TH-cam. So, in the scene where Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon are fighting the droidekas in the corridor, I clearly "remembered" that they threw shock grenades behind the droidekas’ shields (they rolled them along the floor and they were able to pass the shields). Reality really struck me then...
I have a hunch that I might have seen a moment from an animated series and thought it was in the movie, but I can't be sure since I didn't watched them.
@mikurowl4473 Yeah, you're thinking about in The Clone Wars during the Onderon arc (early season 5) where Anakin destroys a Droideka by rolling a droid popper under it.
Link here (at 2:30 in that video): th-cam.com/video/a987a4F612c/w-d-xo.htmlsi=wBR49O089FMsF__J
I never really noticed C3-PO's silver leg. I always thought it was gold, mainly bc of the Lego minifigures I grew up with at the time where he always had gold legs. Ig I never really noticed it bc the silver reflected the sand on Tatooine, thus making it look golden
There is an image of monopoly man with a monocle that was made by monopoly, on an old junior monopoly game, one of the bills has monopoly man with a monocle.
Ngl, on Hoth, I feel like the At ST looks different on Hoth, could it be an AT DP? Or is that what it is now, but it was originally meant to be an AT ST. IDK, it was just a thought, probably not true
"Tantive IV" is pronounced"Tan-ta-vee 4" , if you have not listened to the Star Wars radio adaptation you are missing so much of the full Canon story of A New Hope, approved and produced by George lucas, that extends the first movie into 6 hours of extra content including how Darth Vader followed princess Leia through hyperspace at the beginning of the movie, what happened during her interrogation, Luke's runs through beggars canyon and interactions with his friends, all with original sound effects music, and dialogue supplied by Mark Hamill, Anthony Daniels and many other stars.
And they, with George Lucas's approval, pronounce Tantive as described above.
George also approves of different pronunciations of the names in Star Wars so there's that too.
In Revenge of the Sith C3P0 was all gold
I always remembered vader saying "no luke, i am your father"
If you had the empire strikes back story book record it sounds very much like that, there is a pause between when Vader says "no" and "I", and I believe it is Luke that makes a slight noise like a gasp so without the visuals it can sound like "no (and then kind of under his breath) Luke,, (and then emphasizing) *I* am your father!".
@@Jack_Stafford exactly sounds like hes saying luke under his breath
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
Keep in mind. I'm only 30. But, I still first watched the original Trilogy on my VHS tape...on a box tv. I can assure you...noticing the silver on c3p0 would have been much more difficult. 😂
yeah 4.3 tvs
Agreed! I somehow got ahold of a bootleg cam of Jedi about a year before it came out officially. Talk about washed out colors and blurry details! The scenes of tatooine outside jabba's palace looked like they were covered with snow
Ok but what about how all the Star Wars movies have a …. At the end of the scrolling yellow text at the start of the movie, that gives the intro and stuff.
Because in episode 6 it was only …
I mean they weren't really paying attention to what made it Star Wars anymore at that point.
I got a mandela effect the movie dantes peak. I remember the boat motor stalling halfway through the pond and grandma gets out and starts pushing the family through the corrosive lake to shore nearby and shes all screaming and its traumatic and when they finally get to shore her legs are all burnt up and she dies. The current version has them make it by paddling she gets out for some dumb reason walks through the corosive water and dies like 5 feet from shore.
That's not a Mandela effect they just edited the movie, I've not seen that movie I just saw the scene on tv before but I've definitely seen that before
I remember watching revenge of the sith in a hotel when I was young and genreal grievous’ death was much more violent, I’m pretty sure his heart was ripped out or crushed but it’s completely different, grievous did have organs removed in a deleted scene though
@lazerfrogstudios For a second, I thought you misremembered this for the unused version until I saw the end of your comment.
It's because Chester from fairly odd parents said "Luke, I am your father" as well as the clip you showed from whatever show that was. Whenever other media would reference the scene, they would start with Luke, so people would better understand what they're referencing
So did Tommy Boy, and every other show trying to be funny by referencing that moment. Lol. Fairly odd parents is probably one of the more recent uses of it.
@@nak3dxsnake Yes, but it's one from my generation, that I remember
@@Shashu_the_little_Voidling out of every reference you'd go with that?
Personally I think it was a merch thing because having a shirt that just says "I am your father" is kinda just asking to get into legal trouble
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
9:05 I remember watching an interview with Anthony Daniels (C3P0) and he said that the costume guy on set didn’t notice the silver leg into a week or so into filming (this was for A New Hope)
yep
I thought the AT-ST’s were pretty obvious in hoth
Me too. Not to mention, Kenner had an ATST hoth themed toy before ROTJ came out.
The "different ending" is not a mandela affect". Its an alternate ending.
Wait doesn’t Empire Strikes Back end with the main characters looking out the window? That’s the only one from this video that really got me.
It depends on which time you saw it which version stuck in your memory, it has been well established that they were not happy with the very end of that movie and did tack on an extended version showing where the millennium falcon was docked in relation to the hospital room to demonstrate that they were on the same ship and also the fleet flying off into the distance, it was still in theaters, like like the previous movies, there were prints that were slightly different depending on when they were made and when they were sent to different theaters so there were some variations as they continue to tinker with them even after they were being shown in theaters.
That's what I miss about DVDs the most is the secondary tracks from the creators and stars and producers that tell a lot of this that just isn't available on most streaming services.
i watched it on sky tv im sure you're right
I have a DVD of the movie and it DOES end like this. I legit rewatched it to see if I was right and yeah. Guess it is mostly a version difference
I could be wrong but I think the original release version ends that way while the special edition adds the rebellion fleet at the end.
@@ultimatealchemist9401 it was reworked during the original theatrical release so that it would be more clear what was happening.
" The Empire Strikes Back faced delays and changes behind the scenes, with George Lucas altering the ending three weeks into its release. Lucas felt the original ending was unclear, leading to added exterior shots by ILM to provide better pacing and clarity for audiences."
I have a Star Wars Mandela effect. I remember watching the Special Edition VHS tapes back in the 90's where before the movie even started there was a whole segment explaining what they changed from the original version and I remember George Lucas talking about how the Yoda puppet couldn't really emote that well and went in to add CGI to the face so he could have more realistic expressive emotions.
Apparently it was actually in the Phantom Menace where Yoda was a puppet with a CGI face but I always believed he was fully CGI in the prequels and that the special editions was where they blended CGI with the existing puppet.
It also seems the interview I remembered of George Lucas talking about Yoda was actually Steven Spielberg talking about E.T. And I knew there was also a special edition version of E.T. with updated special effects but I don't remember ever actually watching it. I just remember hearing about it. Mostly from the South Park episode making fun of it because they digitally replaced all the guns in that movie with walkie talkies.
I believed this for YEARS till someone told me that never happened in the special editions and pointed out all the things I was misremembering to lead me to believe that.
Memories are Memories, they are yours...do not deny them
Huh? Memories are incredible unreliable my guy, we don’t literally record in our heads what we experience, our brain tries to recollect it, and can fill in gaps with information that wasn’t present. And with things like the telephone game we can see the more information gets spread the more different it can become, and then from one false memory you create thousands.
*I'd totally agree with the conscientious that it's poor memory except... I've experienced it firsthand.*
*Late 1970s/early 1980s, west of Waltham, MA, in a convenience store/drug store/diner were 'World's Smallest Trinitron Portable TV'.*
*3.75" screen, electronic but not digital tuning. 15" x 5" x 5". 8 C batteries. Chrome monopole antenna. $250 or so 1980s dollars.*
*I saw it. I touched it. BUT..... No record of that particular model ever existing.*
1:00 I'm surprised you skipped over the fact that in Revenge of the Sith 3PO had a gold leg. Most people seem to think that 3PO always had a silver leg, and the gold leg appeared in toys, which is what caused the confusion. It's like a Mandela effect in a Mandela effect!
Makes a video about the Mandela Affect ... botches the C3PO silver legs bit at the very beginning.
They didn't jump him. He "fainted" during the attack and just broke. INSTANT loss of credibility and made me stop watching.
th-cam.com/video/oTV2tS4nRPE/w-d-xo.html
When I watched Return of the Jedi for the first time as a kid, I remember Luke literally transforming into Darth Vader. When he lifts his gloved hand after cutting off Vader's hand, I thought that he was actually becoming Vader, instead of just metaphorically. But the weird part is that I remembered that as the movie went on, Luke transformed more into Vader and by the end of the movie he basically had Vader's suit and everything on him. I think I just remembered that because I took the whole thing of Luke "suffering his father's fate" too literally, but it's still weird.
Strange, you somehow thought the alternative ending was the real one
Bro was in the wrong universe
@@TheRealSoftR For real bro, and this was before I even knew what the alternative ending to RoTJ was
I had an official Star Wars poster that I bought at the cinema on my bedroom wall for years, C3PO did not have a silver leg on that poster!
The star wars wiki contributors trying to patch all the plot holes: "PARKOUR!!"
I think the most iconic Mandela effect has to be the Moonraker one with Swiss Miss with braces versus no braces. Not only is it something that people remember visually but from a narrative and logical standpoint in the story it doesn't make sense unless she has braces. One character reacting to the other smiling with a mouthful of metal then the other one does and they both smile. It doesn't make sense unless she's got metal in her mouth not whatsoever. As a matter of fact I can't think of any Mandela effects where does logical fallacy crops up along with the differing memories. I couldn't believe that a handful of people would force this memory simply because of the logical fallacy but certainly not a billion people
Jesse what the fuck are you talking about
THEY DONT HAVE BRACES?!?!?
I remember a video my dad found before episode 2 had been announced or had any marketing or image reveals. The scene i remember was a blast door opening and there was multiple boba fetts, maybe 4 or 5. It must have been a fan video or something but have no other memory of this scene.
Yeah I remember this, it had Gabriel Byrne with white eyeballs in it. It was a fan video.
@@Chyronn haha awesome! I'm glad I'm not crazy 😂 I'd love to see it again, any idea where to find it or what it was called?
@@ryansumner5554 Sadly, I don't know what it's called or what to even search for. but to further tease you I saw it more recently than when I did before Ep 2 dropped
@@ryansumner5554 th-cam.com/video/VN-5n6rBcHM/w-d-xo.html
The biggest one for me is that when I watched Episode 6 with my dad at like 6 years old I strangely remember dying Vader having a mohawk...... Don't ask
Vader actually says “Luke I am your father” in the Audio Drama version of ESB that was on the radio.
Interesting.
I have this and another mandela effect after first time i watched the empire strikes back - i memorized bespin cloud city like being more bulb-shaped, than saucer structure and i was really suprised when i watched movie for second time, to the point i have started suspecting, that it was another version of movie.
things people thought were true about star wars (some of these are false rumors, others brain bugs, and some are just EU stuff that was retconned around the time of the Prequels and some still later) from memory (some of this is because of things Lucas said, stuff from the EU or just the way things were presented, and some is just pure imagination of fans, but usually it was based upon something): Lando was a clone from a planet of clones leftover from the clone wars. the clone wars involved cloning Jedi and impersonating people to sow chaos in the republic. boba fett killed jedi and he wasn't a clone (though one of his legs was) but somebody who wore mandalorian "supercommando" armor from a war between the mandalorians and the jedi where the mandalorians were "wiped out" by said jedi. stormtroopers were not clones- but one official source called them clones just kind of out of the blue. darth vader's armor was "empty" and his body disappeared on the funeral pyre when Luke burned it in ROTJ. Boba Fett crawled out of the sarlacc pit at the end of that movie and went on to have a career for many years, even decades after (made "canon" by the Mandalorian, but even before that in Dark Empire and a few other expanded universe sources). TIE Fighters have no shields or hyperdrive or even life support systems because the Empire doesn't care about its soldiers. building the Executor almost bankrupted the Empire. TIE fighters are mostly gray. "Darth" was Vader's first name before it was a sith title (actually this one is true). Yoda's species are called "Yiddles." Or maybe they are called "Whills." C3PO was 100 years old in the OT (I think that's from the EU, as is the idea that Chewbacca was 200 years old, or that the Old Republic lasted 25,000 years until the Empire was formed). the universe of StarWars and "E.T." (earth) are connected because we can see ET looking aliens in the background of a shot in Episode I (and E.T. seems to recognize a toy Yoda in that Spielberg movie rather than just being an easter egg it was intentional, also there's an image of R2D2 in one of the background shots of an Indiana Jones movie).. so Star Wars really does take place a long time ago in Earth's past, and Lucas was a guy who saw (through the force) the story of Star Wars. of course the biggest brain bug and false rumor of all is that Lucas thought up Star Wars all on his own back in the early 70's and wrote out 12 or so script drafts that later became the movies we saw on the big screen... rather than really it was an organic collaborative process based on many inspirations (not just "the hidden fortress" or "flash gordon") and he changed his mind many times and left proof of that process behind that people can examine for themselves whether they trust him (or disney) or not.
Many of us have seen one of the Star Wars movies more than the others (for me that's ROTJ). it's actually true that each movie has differences from the others. there's no "imperial march" played for Darth Vader in the first movie and the way JEJ's voice is modulated in the first film is different than the others (this was adjusted in later "special editions"). TIE fighters in the first movie are universally gray, while they appear blue in ESB (and a mixture of blue and green in ROTJ though some of this is due to very poor digital restoration). Vader's chest lights don't blink in the first movie, and his mask actually has gray "shadows" painted on it (the TIE fighters had to be painted gray so they would show up in the blue screen shots and Vader's mask lacked detail in the lighting without the gray). Obi-Wan's saber "shorted out" because of the optical effects not being completed in a few shots (Vader's appears white as well for the same reason, originally it was a physical effect that didn't work very well so they painted the glowing blades on later) this was corrected piecemeal in later special editions. Lightsabers change color... Luke swings a blue lightsaber in ben's hut, then on the millennium falcon it appears white. then it's blue in the next movie. poor restoration on the dvds and blu-rays made luke's saber appear alternately green or blue. Vader's saber was more of an orange color in the first movie (they even had toys that showed it orange, though that's no proof because they toys showed Luke's saber as yellow! then again remember it was white in most of the shots in the movie... and the comics portrayed all the sabers in the first movie as RED originally, while Ralph McQuarrie paintings showed them white, just like the physical special effects intended). yes, the stormtrooper bonks his head but the "bonk" special effect was added later. there is a coincidental "tap" sound but its just the foley of the armor moving around that was added in post production. C3pO's silver leg was something I never noticed in the films, though it was pretty much there in most of the supplemental material. I guess a trick of the light or restoration similar to Han Solo's "jacket" in ESB in the carbon freeze scene (it's just shadows in one shot but Lucas retouched it to "remove" the jacket in one of the special editions). blaster shots look different in the first star wars than they do in the later movies (basically just red lines rather than having a white/orange core similar to the lightsabers). R2D2's lights do appear different in the first movie compared to others like having a half red and half blue dot on him, and in some of the outer space scenes (not just in the first movie iirc, see the trip to dagobah) show R2's panels in black and white (again, problems with the blue screen effects, they switched to green screen in ROTJ for most of those SFX shots). yes, the special editions create kind of a mess tracking all these changes, but you can see the laserdisc versions that are identical to the theatrical versions (other than the fact that the original star wars lacked "Episode IV: A New Hope" in the crawl, that was first added in "the art of starwars" in 1979 but didn't appear in theaters until 1981; and of course the sound track... there were at least 3 theatrical soundtracks with different dialog takes, sound effects and such though most probably heard the "mono" track... and the home video releases were Ben Burt's re-engineering of the whole thing, a kind of remix or "best of" from the theatrical versions... and this changed at least slightly with each special edition).
There was a fairly prominent shot of an AT-ST at Hoth which wasn't in the theatrical cut, but was added in the '97 special editions.
Not really a Mandela effect, but as a kid, I somehow missed the scene in Phantom Menace when Anakin gives Padme that pendant and Jar Jar is sleeping.
I watched the prequels religiously as a kid, yet somehow when I went to the Cinema to watch TPM3D in 2011, I thought that scene was new for that release.
Oh i thought that you were about to tell me that c3p0 DIDN'T have a silver leg. I was about to say WHAT
People didn’t think Darth Vader Said “Luke I am your father.” It’s just if your going to say that line to someone your not going to just say “ I am your father.” Your going to say Luke first to let the person know what your referencing it’s just the way people speak.
I think the C3PO is totally understandable because not only is R2D2 silver, but R2D2 is also at the exact height to block his leg, Meaning if you're looking at that point on the screen your attention unless you know otherwise will always be on R2D2.
The silver leg thing, the funny part is I remember it being gold till 3po was blown apart in Cloud City and got it when Chewie put him back together, I assumed it was Chewie finding A leg because he couldn't find his original leg.
And for anyone who's ever painted or plated or otherwise finished a C3PO model or replica... His color is actually brass, which is much lighter/brighter than gold
In the old Lego Star Wars games, C-3PO didn't have the silver leg. Neither did the physical Lego sets for decades.
I'm gonna blame that for why I never noticed the leg in the movies.
Mumle-bumml, bumldlmbldldlmbl.
To understand for non-native speaker very hard it is.
We need en subtitles to understand english bmblmumbl, but then why its a video if you have to read ?
The Mandela effect on C-3PO shouldn’t even exist. Many ppl know he was turned to chrome then to gold. That’s why his leg remains silver.
I could have sworn esb cuts to credits in the moment when we see c3p0 luke and leia. Thats always how i remembered it
C3P0's silver leg is a no-brainer. I remember it very well because it always bothered me that his whole body is this nice golden shiny color and the damn ugly silver leg just stuck out like a sore thumb.
People remember C3P0 being all gold, because the toy action figure was all gold.
Plus there are many scenes in the 1st trilogy were the silver leg looks gold, because of how it reflects the gold color of the rest of C3P0.
Yeahbut the C3PO one is not really a mandela effect. I think back then you couldn't really tell because of the quality of the film. And even know you almost don't notice.
For the longest time I thought Yoda was cgi on the old phantom menace dvd
Which was I think my brain combining tpm and aotc together and the HD version actually making Yoda cgi
I literally saw two different old recordings from the empire reveal and one said no luke, I am your father and the other said no I am your father
Could just be the way the human mind divulges, like we all know certain things, who says memory can't fail people in the same way as others?
The first clip with Darth Vader and Luke both are correct they just made the change from theatre to disc
I knew I was right about the C3P0 figures & dolls being completely gold. Thank you for that. 😊
I think the Silver Leg on C3PO thing is cuz of the Lego version of him. Since older versions never had printed legs they could only do solid gold
"Final design in Return of the Jedi"... Bro, they're two completely different variants of the same vehicle
Empire strikes back did end on a shot of Luke and Leia. It could be that it was a TV version that has shortened it a little. Or it could be that some shots were added in later. But it definitely did end that way in the version I saw first. Fact.
The Mortis one isn't really a Mandela Effect. It's just a bad plot hole.
In the original back in 1980 theaters vader does say luke but in the every version since he doesnt
Since the Kenner 3PO figurine was fully golden... Merchandising sometimes contributes in creating a Mandala effect...
I literally said that in the video bro 🥱
@@DaBlueBountyHunter I know, I was impulsive... Typed before reaching that point...
Kenner, execs screwed up the Han Solo Hoth figure, jacket. ILM & Lucasfilm gave Kenner set pics, costumes. They confused Han's Cloud City, scene blue jacket & his (set) black-brown parka. The 1980s Han figure has a navy blue parka. If you look close, as a gag: Solo wears the same type dark blue cold weather jacket as a toss back to TESB.
Some constructive criticism I hope you notice... The bass on your voice is way too muffled. I thought it was me, then my speakers, then I turned close-captioning on, and even that wasn't able to clearly decipher the words you're speaking. It might be that there's too much echo in whatever room you're recording in? It's... REALLY bugging me, probably others, having to rewind.
I was on vacation when recording this video so I didn't have the best setup, lol. I probably should have put a disclaimer at the beginning.
Uhhh… no, no. All of these are weird if you don’t just know the truth. Anyone that believes any of these things is just… weird.
I thought it was "no Luke, I am your father" because that's what they said in Toy Story 2 "No buzz, I am your father"
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
The AT-ST on hoth is actually an AT-DP, with more prominent appearances in rebels
I awleys remember when vader says No...I... am your father. I never heard (Luke I'm your father)
*Why is it so hard for you to speak?*
6:16 there's no such thing as not cannon anymore. if that's a different canon, what we have now is a different timeline... thus not the original
The only reason why we want to believe in the Mandela effect is because we're living in the worst possible timeline
De echo la palabra Ewok aparece en los créditos Finales del Retorno Del Jedi, aunque no se pronuncia en la pelicula, si fue creada para la misma, igual que el apellido de Leia, aunque no se menciona en ningún momento de la trilogía, aparece en los créditos Finales del Episodio IV
I remember C3P0's whole leg being silver and Vader saying, I am your father.
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
We took our C3PO action figures and tried to take the gold off of the leg. Ruined a few doing that.
0:05 “Nuke! I am you’re father” is all I heard.
Absolute video proof that there is no Mandela Effect and that Vader actually said, "No, Luke, I am your father." Everyone is wrong, and this example has been broadcasted wrongness around the world since the revised version was released on VHS.
th-cam.com/video/eZCo_hZLyh0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4RAdndIEOT7neW43
The empire strikes back ending actually isnt the mandela effect. They added the extra scene at the end a few qeeka after release.
Actually I always thought C3PO leg was red 🤯
He said Luke and if you out there reading this simply took less than an hour of critical thinking and examined the whole situation you would see how completely absurd the idea of mass miss remembering is especially things in old movies, books, paintings, and of course the thing that makes it obvious the freaking KJV Bible!!
Think about it now ... Just think about it.
It's a pretty obvious thing that you would have to overlook to believe in the mass misremembering narrative.
Why is a dimensional shift more probable than misremembering?
The Mandela effect was inevitable at this stage of technology we are in. The fact that all those old arguments, eg; "Mandela died in prison" vs. "no he didn't he was president blah blah" are being instantly settled by google and the internet in general so there's a human need to feel like they're correct even though wrong as hell and so, feeling dumb and embarrassed the retort becomes a half joking "parallel universe bro, I'm not wrong about Mandela I'm from that other universe... Wooooaaahh!!" We made up the Mandela effect to save face really when U look at it. We as in humans in general. Even named it after the most popular one of the arguments and most often 'googled'
C3P0 has always had a silver part to his leg in the A New Hope movie.