ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- 1943. A young platoon commander refuses to follow an order of frontal attack; he doesn’t want to send his soldiers against the enemy machine-guns and get them killed. A battalion commander rips off his shoulder straps and sends him to the military tribunal. But the war is everywhere and the demoted officer and his escorts have to start an unequal fight with the enemy.
One correction: this film is NOT prohibited in Russia. It's featured on all Russian movie sites with tons of positive reviews. You shouldn't try to capitalize on cheap hype.
🎉🎉🎉🎉 praise someone with a brain
It's click bait.
Exactly brother
That’s just the world we live in today
@@johnferguson40at least the film was good.
The horror appears to be returning to Europe and Russia. Those who fail to learn their history are condemned to repeat it.
I do get tired of that trite cliche.
@@Doo_Doo_Patrol familiarize yourself with Nietze and get back with me.
Familiarize yourself with his name and get back to me. Also, I don't take Nietzsche as gospel truth, so to speak. What people actually learn from has little bearing on what happens in the future, in my opinion. So, hang out your weirdo friends in the Nietzsche club. I have found better.@@alandavis9644
Hey, I got that fortune cookie message too!
@@alandavis9644 Nietzsche is not the pinnacle of thinking. "Become what you are", he ended up completely nuts in a psy hospital, as an image of what he despised so much in humanity for his entire life ; a weak man.
I could sense the mix of fear, frustration, stubbornness, freezing, unfairness, loneliness, horrors to the cannibal dweller, respect, love, patriotism, professionalism and sorry . Now I hate wars
Over and over throughout this movie I couldn’t help being reminded of the fact I was so fortunate having been born a United States citizen. Thank You for uploading this!
You don’t think this happens in the US? 🤦♂️
@@beaujeste1 Due to my geographic location it's highly unlikely the U.S. is invaded by another aggressive country. Canada, Mexico, Central and South America are not a threat nor will be at least not in my lifetime. I'm not quite sure what you meant by your comment so please feel free to elaborate. Have a nice day!
You were so lucky to born after WW II. No other difference!
@@ChrisMooreorless-kj9ut You're a Marxist regime already and don't even know it. You don't think you've been invaded at both borders for years? Wake up bruh
Russia was doing this on its own people before Shartler ever had power.. and US allied with it ;)
A sad strange story. I don't know what else to say. Imagine being there, the anguish..!
Very well directed and great actors.
My eyes were watering at the end.
An incredibly powerful film. Thank you
Russian movies are like their writers and composers. Life, pain, loss, hardship but still a breath of humanity and kindness is all so clear.
Maybe you should watch some Soviet comedies first a change. Some were actually amusing.
@@pawelpap9yes...and painful, hard, and with loss.
Do you belive in fairy tales?
This is suitable for you:
Varlam Shalamov, "KOLYMA TALES".
Start from biography of the author.
NO WONDER THEY DRINK SO MUCH VODKA.
Like Country Western songs!😀
Outstanding movie, both intriguing and heartbreaking.
Thank you
And those who start wars are warm and cozy with a full belly.
all wars are bankers wars. and the head of the pack is the federal reserve. they started all wars in 20th and 21st century
Not with the citizens at their door,
Excellent.....sad but true in meaing . This film is poetic. Thank you
Powerfully emotional film. "I failed to save you boys". The sound of water being stired by an oar.
The Styx oarsman symbol.
This is the second time watching this film, several years apart, yet it still captivates me.
Get better internet .You may get to American made movies
@@peterkonitzer4410😳🙄🙄
A reality check for factual History of Warfare ! Hollywood sucks on the facts! I love the truth of those Russian movies !
Hollywood make dreams, not realities.
At the end of Liberty Valance the reporters say to Stewarts character after he explains " when it comes to the truth or the legend, PRINT THE LEGEND". That's USA through and through.
Kudos to the spectacular portrayl of the numerous conflicting themes and interactions that wars bring to the surface, conflics of patriotism and duty to country, comrades and self-preservation. It makes one wonder why so many of we, sapiens, are so anxious to start and engage in wars when it is so obvious that there are no real winners; every participant on both sides of the fence is a loser, as is every country and every family, personally involved and not involved. Here's hoping that we will soon see an end to all wars---we need more common sense and more social interactions and less anger, fear, envy and that insatiable thirst for control and power over others.
It's not we, sapiens that start wars. To insinuate that Politicians are humans is an insult to people everywhere. Wars are started by the elite for the benefit of the elite and only the elite.
Because is way more complicated.
One word, Equality. The first objective
Without God it isn't possible. The animalistic nature of man will keep rearing its head if the spiritual morality we were endowed with is not put to use.
@@smokeymoe842 amen brother, 100%
An excellent movie that I have seen several times. Thank You for sharing it with us.
That is not soviet made movie, movie made in Russian Federation in 2009
Near city of Rgev, a place where Red Army fighting German army for one year in 1942 and 1943 to stand still and red army lost over one million soldiers in bitter fighting to a point of
Stand still ,either side weren’t winning anything for one year and half.
Brilliant, simply brilliant.
This is certainly a movie worth-watching. There are several conflicts of interests among the characters, with each faced against the other, the director's labours are worth noticing. Each character has lived up to its nature. There are multiple ironies in the screenplay. The white ice depicted throughout has strong symbolic connotation, representing death. In the proximity of death, a few characters exhibit deeds of humanitarian compassion. In fine, it is human love and empathy that stays at the top as a predominating sentiment and the core theme of this moving drama. Hearty appreciation to the Russian actors and the film -crew......Srivilliputtur S Ramesh, SRIVILLIPUTTUR, TAMIL NADU, SOUTH INDIA.
I second that comment of yours.
Stupendo film è un grande errore considerare il popolo russo nemico dell'Europa
In European cultures, white more commonly symbolises innocence and purity. Death is generally connected with black.
Otherwise, I heartily agree with your remarks.
Sehr guter Film.Grüsse aus Deutschland
I seldom give high marks. This movie is very good. Thank you.
Uhhhhhhhhhh, thank you soooo much, your fucking gracious "I seldom give high marks" majesty.
Best movie I've seen in a long time, highly recommended👍
Fantastic movie. So glad i watched it and will recommend it to other's.
Once again i stumbled upon an excellent movie thank you for an exceptional upload
Excellent movie. Got me real emotional. Spasiba
Quite a good movie. Thanks for the subtitles.
Well made and really keeps your interest the whole way through.
Tears rolling down 😢😢. Heros are laid to eternal rest.
What a movie!
Being born Russian seems like the worst stroke of luck I can think of. Being Russian during Stalin's time seems as bad as being a North Korean. Between Lenin, Stalin, and then Hitler living just over the border, well, what could be worse?
You think Tsar Putrid is any better than those you listed?
Do you know Stalin killed much more Russian ppl than Hitler did?
I recommend you to google a biograpphy of Varlam Shalamov, great Ru. writer and to look at his "Kolyma Tales".
I think Elensky tops them all....@@Scaleyback317
Many were not Russian. This was the Soviet Union, composed of many separate nationalities.
Excellent movie! This is cinematographic art! 🙂
The Russian Soldier was fighting two enemies.
Bravo.. I'm so glad I came across this movie thnk u for this❤
Realy very good video. Thank you for uploading.
If you don't have a tear in your eye at the end you are not human, very good but sad movie.
Very good movie. Worth a watch.
Fantastic movie👍👍👍... Shows Stalinistic Casualties & the humanity of single men... So much better than Hollywood Stuff👍... Thks for uploading & btw who & where was this film forbidden???
What are the "victims of Stalinism"? Have you read Stalin's order No. 227? Well, read it to understand why they did it that way and why it was done. The Germans had it worse and acted more harshly there. Find out what the German "999" battalions were and what they did. Even in Great Britain at one time there were their own penal battalions...
Holy smokes! That was actually really good. Could've used a bit more of a budget for the battle scenes and the language barrier made some scenes feel awkward or less important. But, I really enjoyed the difference in film making.
You mean, a little bit more hollywood stile ?
No, thank you.
It's a sad yet good movie with great actors. Thank you. I can't see this movie being banned anywhere.
What an excellent film and what a deeply moving ending.
I'd love to know more about the events it was based upon.
It's based on Stalin's order 227
@@jimmyjimo1708
Ни шагу назад??
@@saraprva4172 Yes, and also that Partisans dressed in the uniforms of Germans they'd killed. They then shot Russian peasants and Russian soldiers they'd captured. This was filmed for propaganda value, they received extra pay and a special medal. That's why the partisan who took him prisoner was wearing an SS jacket under his coat
WWII
@@jimmyjimo1708 Nonsense. He was not a partisan, but a collaborator who served the Germans and just went crazy and became an ogre. The Soviet lieutenant, out of inexperience, takes him for a partisan. Although in reality there were partisans who fought against everyone or against Stalin. It was a very difficult time. It doesn't fit into your black and white agenda.
Great film loved it thankyou for sharing this brilliant piece of art.
Prohibited where, when, by whom? I would like some information on this intriguing movie.
On TH-cam. As you can see you cannot see it.
It's called 'click bait'.
Excellent film....story telling poetry
If someone told me that this was a film by Stanley Kubrik, I would almost have believed them, except perhaps for the subtitles.
Wow, great story and movie. Enjoyed it very much.
excellent film. respect for posting.
Brilliant film. Thanks.
Good movie ---- Thanks for sharing
Thank you for sharing this. Excellent movie.
Great. Very well filmed
What a brilliant film
The ground would have been frozen many feet down: no way of digging a grave. Superb filming
It was most probably early winter so no frost yet.
That's not so. Aren't you surprised by the unfrozen river? Do you really think that the Russians don't know? If there was a lot of snow, then the ground could keep warm. If there is little snow and severe frost, then the ground will freeze. Besides, didn't you see that he was actually digging this ground? There was also a way to make a fire first, and then dig. There can be many ways and conditions. This does not mean that today it is autumn and it is possible to dig, and tomorrow it is winter and it is impossible to dig.
Thank you to our Russian brothers and sisters who gave so much. Until we meet, our hat is forever off to you.....
On behalf of my departed grandparents, thank you for honouring their memory.
They were Soviets, of a multitude of nationalities. Look at the faces.
Yes, very good movie. But it portrays Russians as noble men. From our (polish) point of view: 1938 Polish operation - more then 110000 Poles living in Soviet Union were murdered. Others were sent to lagier camps with high sentences. The children were transported to Soviet child care homes - they were lessen version of labor camps. 17.09.1939 Soviet Union crosses polish borders and participates with Germany in Poland's division. By July 22nd 1 500 000 polish citizens were sent to gulags and a lot of them were already dead. This is just a little history about how Soviets were acted against Poles.
Dostoyevski described you very well in his novels (poles) where there always was a pole looking at russians down his noble nose. now, after watching this movie and reading positive comments about russians, you act as a pole from dostoyevski's novels, putting down russians as lower breed of human. i see you talk about stalin dividing poland with hitler....i just want to remind you that poles rushed to take a chunk of checkoslovakia right after hitler took sudetenland which was before hitler invaded poland in sept of 1941.
I was triggered by your hatred clearly stated in "portrays russians as noble man" whereas "we all know they are beasts" and then you prove it by giving some history lessons on suffering of noble poles under beastly russians.
People like you, haters, are not able to see simple things....like the fact that those characters in this movie are human beings, and no, they are not noble, they are just behaving like almost every human being would have, regardless of their ethnic background, in given circumstances where death is all around, treason, fear, chaos, suffering...
@@sinisasimic70 Zaolzie was part of Poland and was taken from us by Czechs in 1920. Poland was unable to protect it becsuse was defending it's freedom from attacking bolshevick's hordes.
You didn't show me facts just story of a writer who has polish roots by the way. Please, answer and comment the facts I gave to you. You may also add other atrocities bolshevics did to russian nation, ukrainian nation baltic nations, caucas nations, Tatars. .... etc. Just I wrote. The movie is good. But you still live in communism country. There is no God in inhuman land , that is, today's Russian Federation and former Soviet Union. You falsify history to your needs.
@@sinisasimic70 so, no answer.
@@vigigejmer9813 I don't think he saw the point in answering someone so clearly irrational. As to God ...
@@sinclairwhitbourne2090 what is irrational? Just the given truth. And correction of his lies.
The atmosphere in both the Russian and German armies had to be horrible to endure. If German lost any gear during a retreat he was punished for it. They were expected to stay with a truck until someone brought them gas or die defending it when the soviet advance got to it.
The German penal battalions were worse than the Russians. The Germans did not have the concept of “paying for a mistake with blood” - only your command could decide whether you corrected yourself or not. For the Russians, it was enough to be wounded in the very first battle or to commit a brave act in order for your military rank, awards to be returned, and your position to be restored, returning you to your previous place of service.
@@amare_naturam For that the Russians had to be ´severely´ wounded. If they could still walk, it was not severe enough. Most died.
@@juanita9270 That's not so. Any injury, even a slight one, was enough.
@@colmcmillan173 You are wrong.
What a soul crushing, hopeless movie.
Very interesting and good movie of historical documentaries it was brilliant film thank you 😖🦂🙂...
just so horrible its happening today. stupid mankind
Sin nature.
very good movie...its interesting that the russians make the best films about that desaster 1939-45
Brilliant film. Fantastic storyline . Thanks for bringing it to us.
An incredibly powerful film. Thank you!
Good to see some cultures still have a soul. Protray humanity instead of vanity n glory. ❤
Keep a copper for the Boatman. A brillant film
Your outfit almost gets wiped out so they shoot you---doing the enemy's job for them.
Court martialed lieutenant looks like John Malkovich when he was younger.
yes -- their thing in common is slavic DNA.
I ❤ russian movies. Though I don’t understand the language, I’m glad & thanks for the english subtitles 😘😘😘
I thoroughly enjoyed this.
An excellent movie.
Yes that was a good movie. thank you.
Well if it's prohibited I won' watch it. Thanks for letting me know.
This movie isn’t prohibited anywhere 😂
Excellent movie ❤
Fantastic film, Thanks
Movie starts pixellating three quarters of the way through.
@MovieIn are there any links to the "true events?" I'd like to read more. Thanks.
Excellent film, thoroughly enjoyed it,id love to know the title of it!
Usually i preferred to watch second ww movies, mainly true stories. Brutality, dedication, courage, patriotism , among humanity, good and proven lessons to mankind..
best movie I have watched in years
Never and no nation in the history of mankind has eaten its own flesh like Stalinist Russia. Amazing tension with top actress mad woman.
Before Stalin's death, there were no Russians in the government of the USSR. and there was a genocide of ethnic Russians. It was only when ethnic Russians gained power that the regime was softened and the Gulag was closed.
Would have been nice of you to include the movie date of '2009'.
It's a Classic so the date is safe to show.
Thnx 4-upld, found it intense, interesting with good actors/actresses.
Superb,a poignant and marvellous movie.
Excellent movie. Turns out the old man is a general. No wonder he is so competent.
Apparently not prohibited, because you put it up on TH-cam... It is a good movie though.
I felt as if I was there sharing their plight. Great film and acting.
Good film. Good story.
That's what u call a movie ...enough motivation to be a soldier who wud lay down his life for his motherland
HOLLYWOOD, take note, this is how it is done,
Nice movie....tks
We all must pay the Ferryman.
Extraordinary.
Depressing as hell. Watch at your own discretion.
If Dostoevsky was alive today right now at this moment... I would have believed this movie was based on a chapter in one of his novels.
AT THE END WHEN HE LOOKED UP INTO THE SKY HE NEW BETTER NOT TO ASK WHY
Good film!
Excellent movie
Top notch - a rollercoaster of feelings that only can be procced by the best.
You know its good when you hate a character so much that you have to turn of the vid several times. That Lt.. OMFG!!
What a film. Compare this to hollywood bullshit. You get a idea of the state the world is in today. And why.
bro is the only survivor
Because he hang back and sent the young chumps to die, while he stays and gets the woman and all the loot. Those Germans had some nice gear. PIMP
Great film.
They should never give Karens power and weapons.
I know this is stupid..but in this time to feel much of anything for Russia..it was good to be reminded that the commen man of all nations rest the same..good film for alot of reasons.
Except for the simple fact it is the common man carrying out Tsar Putrid's orders - most of them just for the money.
@@Scaleyback317 my friend..the simple man dosn't have much of a choice..if you or l were called up, there's not much we could do about it...and l would say that yes, there are those making money on wars...certainly not you and l, relatively speaking, few are making money but of course it gives them a disporportional amount of sway. Anyway, wherever you are, l wish you and your's good health and Happy Holidays.
if its prohibited why has it been on your youtube channel for at least 6 months????
PROHIBITED means NOT AVAILABLE…. Which means you shouldnt have it!!!!
FALSE TITLE