Honestly this is the ranking - 1. Jiyoon (Supports) 2. Jungeun (Supports) Great wall of china 3. Sarang (inconsistent support) Big wall 4. Jeemin 5. Saebi Wall 6. Mai 7. Koko
SO TRUE. her vocal tone is so professional and stable. she can sing all the types of songs perfectly. we all see jiyoon singing bad when it weren’t slow and calm song.
@@lucas-z3g no lmao, it’s even so stupid to discuss) Jiyoon is very unstable, her vocal tone is beautiful but it’s only for singing slow, pretty songs. otherwise her vocals don't match the cute or fast songs, did you even watch the show? producers agree with this sentiment. while jungeun is so stable that during the entire show she only had one bad performance. she’s even not my bias, but her voice gives me goosebumps, so don’t doubt that she will be the main vocalist)
My vocal ranking 1.jungeun ( not being biased, my bias is jeemin , i just think jungeun is better in vocal imo) 2. Jiyoon ( her vocals so good !!!) 3.sarang ( all rounder sarang !!) 4. Jeemin ( not being biased) 5. Saebi ( born to be idol ) 6. Mai ( i actually love her voice m nasal or normal , she slayed in every performance) 7. Koko ( her dance skills and rap skills are no joke !!)
Off topic, but did you guys notice the way Koko hit the note of her line on the her clip??? I really repeated it cause it is really a music to my ears🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Jeemin should have more votes. Her lower register is impressive. Not as much as saebi’s but definitely good enough to be over Sarang who can’t stop having voice cracks for the life of her.
@Aida-gg3vn you mean her strained highnotes without any proper techniques? yeah that isnt impressive. She was already struggling hitting that note cause its so obviously out of her range, even after lowering the octaves.
💀 7 votes for Koko and 18 votes for Mai is insane. Yall obviously have no vocal training at ALL if you think those two are even remotely CLOSE to jungeun and jiyoon
Actual ranking 7. Mai F- (she improved a lot but still has a long way to go) 6. Koko F 5. Saebi E- 4. Sarang E 3. Jeemin E+ (if someone disagrees go watch her on runext first 😘) 2. Jungeun D-/D 1. Jiyoon D+
Jeemin is even worse in RU NEXT. Whenever the songs aren't heavily autotuned, her voice is shaky. She actually had seemed to improve a bit by Iland compared to RU NEXT, but she really isn't close to Sarang, nor can she support to a level of anything other than U-W at a push.
@@sapphire6806 she can, it's really shallow but somewhat consistent, sarang sounds a bit more grounded but tends to be pushy, jeemin overall has more freedom in her voice and better control. I think she sounded better or runext tho, especially in desperate her voice is soo good, even her Eb5 isn't shaky at all.
@@missbutterflyuwu5595 Literally everything you just said is incorrect. Jeemin can't sing into the 5th octave at all without heavily compromising her technique. You can hear it in LVeR and ITNW (if you listen carefully). Between the two, Sarang is the one who pushes far less as she has a far better understanding of how to change the placement of her mix to prevent pushing. Also, nether of them have great control, but Sarang can simply do more with her voice, so she's better than Jeemin there, too. Comparetively, one of the biggest issues Jeemin has is with always trying to force her chest voice up rather than allowing it to blend naturally with her head voice. Also, like I said, RU NEXT was autotuned to hell and back (most extreme I've ever seen in a survival show, just look at Illit in the shoe vs now). If you listen carefully, you'll be able to hear what I'm talking about in regards to her vocals in RU NEXT. It feels as though you're just making stuff up to suit the narrative of 'Jeemin is a better vocalist'. But she isnt. And that's OK.
Wth excuse m!? Sarang over jeemin in vocals I get sarang is an all rounder but jeemin vocals a a chefs kiss And its akso youre opinion but c'mon geng we know our jeemin got a beautiful vocal which deserves higher ranking
Saebi is one of my favorite members But i dont think she deserves 3rd Imo its 1. Jungeun ( cause she is more stable than jiyoon while performing and dancing ) 2. Jiyoon 3. Sarang/Jeemin 4. Saebi 5. Koko 6. Mai
Being stable is what matters when you're trying to be an idol. You're a performer, what does it matter if you can't sing performing and can only sing while sitting down or standing still. No use in being an idol. Outside of K-pop, artists get clowned for not being able to sing live. The global standard shouldn't change bc y'all are used to mediocrity and ridiculous amounts of pitch correction and loud backtracks to make up for poor training.@@lucas-z3g
My ranking 1.jungeun is 1 because her singing is sounds better and she has a better technique and has a higher vocal range 2.jiyoon is 2 because she has a good technique and higher range then the others 3.sarang really nothing to say she has a good vocal range and sounds nice to listen to 4.jeemin even though her singing sounds a bit nasal to me her singing is still pretty nice to listen to 5.saebi she sounds good but it sounds like her throat is closed and she is nasal when she sings 6.Mai I always really liked her voice she would have been seven is she didn’t improve but with her vocal improvement she has become six and I like the way she sounds now 7.koko she still needs to work on her pronunciation and her nasal sound which is why she is last and when she sings she sounds airy and nasal (My opinion)
@@jinsoulsfriedhair5067 But! Jiyoon often sings with a forward and tense jaw. One of the most notorious and bad habits for singers to develop while they're still at a moderate level.
@sapphire6806 coming at their posture but she sings fine and has better foundation?? thats an odd thing to comment on, cause Jungeun strains more and thats more of a red flag then simply posture
@@jinsoulsfriedhair5067 It's not an odd thing to comment on as anyone who knows how to sing at a decent level would know. A forward jaw is a huge postural issue, just like singing slouched or not having your head up. A forward jaw causes tons of technique problems for vocalists and can even lead to degrading of the jaw joints. Jiyoon DOES engage her core muscles more, but Jungeun is better at open vowles and higher notes for a reason, and that is largely down to Jiyoon's tense jaw.
@@cayley.mai can actually, they are both same tier but due to mai s drama performance (not even bad,decent)people say she lacks ,this is from a vocal teachers opinion ,i saw a vid ,but i dont remember which one
Everyone is saying unbiased ranking and Jiyoon is second like💀. This is the actual ranking: (on what we’ve seen on iland2 not other survival shows) 1. Yoon Jiyoon 2. Choi Jungeun 3. Ryu Sarang 4. Jeong Saebi 5. Bang Jeemin 6. Mai 7. Koko
high notes doesnt make you a better vocalist, its actually the opposite. Lower notes are so much better because of the sheer complexity compared to highs. Jiyoon's low and upper registers are both more developed than Jungeun
@@memyselfandi169I understand what you want to say to her like “stop criticizing her when you can’t do half of what she does” but we’re not Idols that’s not our job so we can’t be judged on that on the other hand Koko is an idols that’s meant to sing (not saying she cannot sing but she’s really lacking in vocals)
Jiyoon: Emotional support Vocal support Low Register Mid Register Falsetto register Vocal technique: Vibrato Jungeun: Vocal range Vocal power High register Modal register Pitch Vocal technique: Belting Both are main vocalist material, and are equal in being great vocalists
How is Saebi higher than sarang tho🤨 take this with a grain of salt I hope I don’t come off as mean or something but this is my own ranking 😭😭 1. Jiyoon 2. Jungeun 3. Sarang 4. Jeemin = Saebi 5. Koko 6. Mai ❤❤
No ur bias ain’t jiyoon it’s clearly jungeun cuz the only think jungeun is better than jiyoon is highnote, and Jiyoon is better in terms of techniques and emotions
@@rainbow-yk8hq emotions is really important to, which helps u convey the message in the song to the audience, jungeun needs to work ok that, Jiyoon is also versatile when it comes to vocals she suit everything she had work on
@@bella39559 yeah, emotion is important but it can be polishes and improves. Jiyoon is lacking versatility compared to Jungeun. It can be seen from twice ohh-ahh and fls. Even producer 24 said Jiyoon voice not suitable for whole song, only selected phrase suits her. This proves as fls, and iwaly she's doing well bcuz she sang only selected phrase.
@@rainbow-yk8hq jiyoon is really versatile in vocal from what I have seen, or maybe u taking abt ‘concept’ if that’s the case then I agree but with vocals she’s mired versatile than jungeun
close to the accurate ranking that's good here's the actual ranking according to multiple analysis account : 1. Jiyoon 2. Jungeun 3. Sarang 4. Jeemin 5. Saebi 6. Mai 7. Koko But mai and koko are probably interchangeable
Jungeun is better than Jiyoon. They’re extremely close but Jungeuns vocal stability when dancing is more impressive than Jiyoon’s ability to present emotions.
Its actually close to the actual unbiased ranking
Fr tho
Right, the only difference is sarang and saebi need to switch
@@yawnzzn1206 ye!
@@yawnzzn1206isn’t jeemin better than Saebi?
@@Sglossy1603she is
Honestly this is the ranking -
1. Jiyoon (Supports)
2. Jungeun (Supports)
Great wall of china
3. Sarang (inconsistent support)
Big wall
4. Jeemin
5. Saebi
Wall
6. Mai
7. Koko
LMAOO "great wall of China" 😭😭
This is so funny and true!😂
*great wall of china * Lmao some of kpop stans are way too funny😂
Koko > Mai and saebi
same
My ranking
1. Jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin
5. Saebi
6. Mai
7. Koko
Jungeun for sure.
SO TRUE. her vocal tone is so professional and stable. she can sing all the types of songs perfectly. we all see jiyoon singing bad when it weren’t slow and calm song.
no lmao. jiyoon is better. have your opinion though and dont reply to me if you want to jungeun is better because theres no point in arguing
@@lucas-z3g no lmao, it’s even so stupid to discuss) Jiyoon is very unstable, her vocal tone is beautiful but it’s only for singing slow, pretty songs. otherwise her vocals don't match the cute or fast songs, did you even watch the show? producers agree with this sentiment. while jungeun is so stable that during the entire show she only had one bad performance. she’s even not my bias, but her voice gives me goosebumps, so don’t doubt that she will be the main vocalist)
JIYOON
SARANG UNDER SAEBI DHJDNSUSHEU????
I think jungeun deserves the 1st place coz she can fit her voice to any concept but jiyoon can't. Jiyoon would get 2nd place for me.
LMAO. tell me you know nothing about singing without telling me you know nothing about singing
Honestly i think that Jungeun is a better vocalist than Jiyoon, because she is more versatile and has shown her great vocals since the very beginning…
shes not but have your opinion
i agreeee
Can’t wait for them to debut ☺️
Jiyoon is the best vocalist in IZNA
In my opinion the best vocalist is Jungeun ❤
My vocal ranking
1.jungeun ( not being biased, my bias is jeemin , i just think jungeun is better in vocal imo)
2. Jiyoon ( her vocals so good !!!)
3.sarang ( all rounder sarang !!)
4. Jeemin ( not being biased)
5. Saebi ( born to be idol )
6. Mai ( i actually love her voice m nasal or normal , she slayed in every performance)
7. Koko ( her dance skills and rap skills are no joke !!)
Imo
Vocal
1.jungeun/jiyoon
2.sarang
3.jeemin/saebi
4.koko
5.mai
Dance
1.koko
2.jeemin/jungeun
3.sarang/saebi
4.mai
5.jiyoon
Rap
1.koko
2.mai
3.sarang
4.jungeun/jiyoon
5.saebi/jeemin
My bias
1.jiyoon/jeemin
2.koko
3.jungeun
4.sarang
5.mai
6.saebi
Jeemin never rapped fast singing isn't rapping
jiyoon's vocals are best ❤ my favorite!
JIYOON is the best vocalist 🎉❤✨
for me saebi her voice is always stable
izna is a group with a lot of potential, almost all the members, like 5 of them, have good vocal stability
saebi deserves to be higher. that girl can SING alr
higher than jiyoon and jungeun?🤨
3rd is already a high rank and on the actual vocal ranking of izna saebi would be lower she’d be 5th
Off topic, but did you guys notice the way Koko hit the note of her line on the her clip??? I really repeated it cause it is really a music to my ears🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
ATEEE ❤
Jeemin should have more votes. Her lower register is impressive. Not as much as saebi’s but definitely good enough to be over Sarang who can’t stop having voice cracks for the life of her.
Finally SAEBI is getting some attention❤❤😊
But Jeemin is better than Sarang in my opinion❤😂
Koko's high note but mai and saebi better than her????
being able to make high notes doesn’t mean the best.
high notes don't define someones ability to be vocally better
Saebi is better. Koko and Mai are around the same level
@@its_tomtrn127 okay but have you ever heard saebi's high note?
@Aida-gg3vn you mean her strained highnotes without any proper techniques? yeah that isnt impressive. She was already struggling hitting that note cause its so obviously out of her range, even after lowering the octaves.
mine:
1 jungeun
2 jiyoon
3 jeemin
4 sarang
5 seabi
6 koko
7 mai
the correct order is jiyoon jungeun sarang=jeemin saebi koko then mai. sarang and jeemin are both u-w lol
Sarang sub vocal
Saebi vocalist
Jungeun y jiyoon main vocals or lead vocal
💀 7 votes for Koko and 18 votes for Mai is insane. Yall obviously have no vocal training at ALL if you think those two are even remotely CLOSE to jungeun and jiyoon
Idk y saebi didn’t go for a main vocal part
mai better vocals than koko is crazy😭
Koko is a better a vocalist in my opinion then mai
they're both underdeveloped in the end
@@its_tomtrn127 koko is still better I would put koko in nr 6 and mai 7 or both at 7
your opinion is hot trash
@@Chloexxgirlagreed
UNBIASED RANKING>>>
1 jiyoon
2 jungeun
3 sarang
4 jeemin
5 saebi
6 mai
7 koko
sarang is definitely third and saebi is fourth
Actual ranking
7. Mai F- (she improved a lot but still has a long way to go)
6. Koko F
5. Saebi E-
4. Sarang E
3. Jeemin E+ (if someone disagrees go watch her on runext first 😘)
2. Jungeun D-/D
1. Jiyoon D+
Jeemin is even worse in RU NEXT.
Whenever the songs aren't heavily autotuned, her voice is shaky.
She actually had seemed to improve a bit by Iland compared to RU NEXT, but she really isn't close to Sarang, nor can she support to a level of anything other than U-W at a push.
@@sapphire6806 she can, it's really shallow but somewhat consistent, sarang sounds a bit more grounded but tends to be pushy, jeemin overall has more freedom in her voice and better control.
I think she sounded better or runext tho, especially in desperate her voice is soo good, even her Eb5 isn't shaky at all.
@@missbutterflyuwu5595 Literally everything you just said is incorrect. Jeemin can't sing into the 5th octave at all without heavily compromising her technique.
You can hear it in LVeR and ITNW (if you listen carefully).
Between the two, Sarang is the one who pushes far less as she has a far better understanding of how to change the placement of her mix to prevent pushing.
Also, nether of them have great control, but Sarang can simply do more with her voice, so she's better than Jeemin there, too.
Comparetively, one of the biggest issues Jeemin has is with always trying to force her chest voice up rather than allowing it to blend naturally with her head voice.
Also, like I said, RU NEXT was autotuned to hell and back (most extreme I've ever seen in a survival show, just look at Illit in the shoe vs now). If you listen carefully, you'll be able to hear what I'm talking about in regards to her vocals in RU NEXT.
It feels as though you're just making stuff up to suit the narrative of 'Jeemin is a better vocalist'. But she isnt. And that's OK.
oh wow
Mai and sarang shouldn't have been debuted, Yuju and Fuko are more talented
sarang is better than saebi
Wth excuse m!? Sarang over jeemin in vocals
I get sarang is an all rounder but jeemin vocals a a chefs kiss
And its akso youre opinion but c'mon geng we know our jeemin got a beautiful vocal which deserves higher ranking
Ew saebi haahhaha
You are probably a solo stan,izna doesn't need fans like you
Imo jeemin is better than sarang
( No hate)
And your opinion is incorrect!
You prefer Jeemin as a vocalist (totally ok), but Sarang is better :)
Jungeun on top
lmao yeah in stability. not in anything else
Got goosebumps over Jiyoon's vocals
Same
Her tone is just so beautiful
FRR
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN KOKO AND JIYOON IS CRAZY
LNFAO OMG
yall are so annoying, not everyone have to be a main vocal. there's not point of pointing that out when we all know the difference
that would also happen when the subject changes to best dancer
@@vin8260 yea
@@vin8260 fr koko would be at top then people would be silent
1.Jiyoon
2.Jungeun
3.Sarang?
4.Jeemin?
5.Saebi
6.Mai
7.Koko
I think Saebi is a little bit better than Jeemin,but everything else is good !!
@@Ronyyz123 saebi is not better than jeemin in vocals so she’s 5th
unbiased ranking
1. Jiyoon > Jungeun
2. Sarang
3. Jeemin
4.. Saebi
5.. Mai
6. Koko
I think unbiased is
4.Saebi
5.Jeemin
@@yeniiiii808 saebi and jeemin are interchangeable but ur probably right
Jeemin (U-W/E)>Sarang (U-W/E- *At best*)
@@Joohyunniee Jeemin doesn't have full support
Нет
My vocal ranking is
1. jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Saebi
5. Jeemin
6. mai
7. koko
Same ❤
Same
the correct one :)
jeemin so low? when her lower registers is the best after jungeun and jiyoon is crazy
@@jinsoulsfriedhair5067she is good but undeveloped and I think that sarang and saebi vocal is better than her
jungeun
The fact that they are all so talented 😆
This group is really ICONIC
they havent even debuted yet and ur calling them iconic
@@zehrapretty Sorry I misspoke, I said that they are iconic because I’ve never seen before a greatest lineup in a gg survival show
@@Nikisstrawberrywithchocolate ohh ok
@@zehrapretty Is there's a problem with calling them iconic? /genq
@@vsxxo no bro, I just said it because they have not even debuted yet, so they haven't done anything iconic yet
Saebi is one of my favorite members
But i dont think she deserves 3rd
Imo its
1. Jungeun ( cause she is more stable than jiyoon while performing and dancing )
2. Jiyoon
3. Sarang/Jeemin
4. Saebi
5. Koko
6. Mai
This ain’t based on stability.. it’s based on like, just singing which is why Jiyoon is first
@@_Kasa_Kun_ believe it or not stability is a valid point to be used in judgement of vocals
@@eleanwra I never said to wasn’t valid, I just said it’s not what the video was looking at
jiyoon>jungeun. being stable isnt the only thing that matters in vocals, and ur point also is debatable.
Being stable is what matters when you're trying to be an idol. You're a performer, what does it matter if you can't sing performing and can only sing while sitting down or standing still. No use in being an idol. Outside of K-pop, artists get clowned for not being able to sing live. The global standard shouldn't change bc y'all are used to mediocrity and ridiculous amounts of pitch correction and loud backtracks to make up for poor training.@@lucas-z3g
Putting saebi over sarang is a crime......
So true
Exactly
this happens every kprofile ranking for sarang 😭 ppl still hate her sadly
the creator didnt, its k profiles
My ranking
1Jungeun
2Jiyoon
3Sarang
4Jeemin
5Mai/Saebi
6Koko
Sameee
Imo jiyoon is the best !
@@Ellaumin our opinion, jungeun is the best
@shin.v14 ok cool ! I'm glad to know .
@@shin.v14if we talking facts then it’s jiyoon, but y’all can feed ur delusions
Mai's improvement in such a short time is so crazy
Yeah !!!
for me :
1 - jungeun
2 - jiyoom
3 - sarang
4 - saebi
5 - jeemin
6 - mai / koko
switch jiyoon and jungeun and that is the correct ranking technically
Jiyoon is better than jungeun
@@caliparisgirl it’s our opinion. wtf
@@bella39559girl f off. it’s literally her opinion
@@bella39559it's her opinion
Ryu sarang is better than saebi
Finally and unbiased ranking. We all know jiyoon is best vocalist, but sarang is better than saebi tho
My ranking
1.jungeun is 1 because her singing is sounds better and she has a better technique and has a higher vocal range
2.jiyoon is 2 because she has a good technique and higher range then the others
3.sarang really nothing to say she has a good vocal range and sounds nice to listen to
4.jeemin even though her singing sounds a bit nasal to me her singing is still pretty nice to listen to
5.saebi she sounds good but it sounds like her throat is closed and she is nasal when she sings
6.Mai I always really liked her voice she would have been seven is she didn’t improve but with her vocal improvement she has become six and I like the way she sounds now
7.koko she still needs to work on her pronunciation and her nasal sound which is why she is last and when she sings she sounds airy and nasal
(My opinion)
jungeun doesnt have better technique. her placement already restricts her from having better clarity and openness and sm unnecessary nasality
@@jinsoulsfriedhair5067 But! Jiyoon often sings with a forward and tense jaw.
One of the most notorious and bad habits for singers to develop while they're still at a moderate level.
@@sapphire6806sometimes jungeun sounds like she sings from her nose and sound kinda nasal which is not good
@sapphire6806 coming at their posture but she sings fine and has better foundation?? thats an odd thing to comment on, cause Jungeun strains more and thats more of a red flag then simply posture
@@jinsoulsfriedhair5067 It's not an odd thing to comment on as anyone who knows how to sing at a decent level would know.
A forward jaw is a huge postural issue, just like singing slouched or not having your head up.
A forward jaw causes tons of technique problems for vocalists and can even lead to degrading of the jaw joints.
Jiyoon DOES engage her core muscles more, but Jungeun is better at open vowles and higher notes for a reason, and that is largely down to Jiyoon's tense jaw.
jiyoon>jungeun>>>>sarang>jeemin>>saebi>>>koko/mai
Totally right! (Imo)
Mai and saebi are f+ or e-(inconsistent)
@@Kpop_lover-02 where did u get this from mai can't support but the saebi part is true
@@cayley.mai can actually, they are both same tier but due to mai s drama performance (not even bad,decent)people say she lacks ,this is from a vocal teachers opinion ,i saw a vid ,but i dont remember which one
For me:-
1. Jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin
5. Saebi
6. Mai
7. Koko
the fact that the last place is also amazing 😍😍😍
se le quebraba la voz, de qué hablas?
@@aabbcc099lmao its good
@@jinii-u9s sordo
Honestly if Koko can do some really good vocal training, she is the most powerful all rounder to exist
Everyone is saying unbiased ranking and Jiyoon is second like💀.
This is the actual ranking: (on what we’ve seen on iland2 not other survival shows)
1. Yoon Jiyoon
2. Choi Jungeun
3. Ryu Sarang
4. Jeong Saebi
5. Bang Jeemin
6. Mai
7. Koko
Jungeun stans don’t wanna believe that jiyoon is better lol😊
Gurl saebi is f+ and jeemin is e -/e
From where did you get from tt?@@Kpop_lover-02
@@Kpop_lover-02unless you're their vocal coach you can't get their ranges
@@longlive_thegreatwar gurl thats facts ,
jungeun is best vocalist, see this high notes
high notes doesnt make you a better vocalist, its actually the opposite. Lower notes are so much better because of the sheer complexity compared to highs. Jiyoon's low and upper registers are both more developed than Jungeun
Lmaoooo high note don’t mean she’s better, jiyoon is way better than jungeun
For my
1-Jungeun-Jiyoon
2-Jeemin-Sarang
3-Saebi
4-Koko
5-Mia
The fact that koko still sounds very good
the bar is on the floor that girl cannot sing at all
@@ditto-dy7sp geez calm down your tits, don't need to attack me
@@ditto-dy7sp still sounds much better than u
@@ditto-dy7sp she can sing obviously are u deaf
@@memyselfandi169I understand what you want to say to her like “stop criticizing her when you can’t do half of what she does” but we’re not Idols that’s not our job so we can’t be judged on that on the other hand Koko is an idols that’s meant to sing (not saying she cannot sing but she’s really lacking in vocals)
Main Vocal>>Jungeun ❤❤
Jungeun of course 🫶🏻🫶🏻
jungeun❤❤❤❤ is the best
1. Jiyoon 👑
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin
5. Mai/Saebi
6. Koko
Actual vocal ranking since some of you are so biased !!
1 Jiyoon
2 Jungeun
3 Sarang
4 Saebi
5 Jeemin
6 Koko
7 Mai
I think jungeun best jiyoon
Jiyoon is better than jungeun
My vocal ranking is
1. Jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin
5. Saebi
6. Koko
7. Mai
All accurate but switch saebi w/ sarang
Okay so kprofiles is not a trustable source. Noted
why. because jungeun isnt first? 😂
Idk why but jeemin chest voice is so addicting to listen i still can't get over her drama performance.
My ranking
1.Jungeun
2.Jiyoon
3.Sarang
4.Saebi
5.Mai
6.Koko
Jiyoon:
Emotional support
Vocal support
Low Register
Mid Register
Falsetto register
Vocal technique: Vibrato
Jungeun:
Vocal range
Vocal power
High register
Modal register
Pitch
Vocal technique: Belting
Both are main vocalist material, and are equal in being great vocalists
My opinion
power vocal ballade
1:jungeun 1:jiyoon
2:jiyoon 2:jungeun
3:sarang 3:sarang
4:saebi 4:jeemin
5:jeemin 5:saebi
6:mai 6:mai
7:koko 7:koko
saebi is definitely better in ballad than jeemin
Power jeemin is 4 saebi is 5
Ballad saebi 4 jeemin is 5
Saebi sings some and leaves some that's my issue
1 - jungeun
2 - Jiyoon
3 - Sarang
4 - Jeemin
5 - mai
6 - saebi
7 - koko
How is Saebi higher than sarang tho🤨 take this with a grain of salt I hope I don’t come off as mean or something but this is my own ranking 😭😭
1. Jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin = Saebi
5. Koko
6. Mai
❤❤
1. Jungeun
2. Jiyoon
3. Saebi
4. Sarang
5. Koko
6. Jeemin
7. Mai
no
very incorrect only sarang and Mai places on vocals are right
@@elevatorkid4814 it's very correct.
imo：jungeun≥jiyoon＞sarang＞jeemin≥saebi＞koko≥mai
Fact:
1) Jiyoon > or = Jungeun
2) Sarang
3) Jeemin
4) Saebi
5) Mai
6) Koko
이즈나 노래 어여 나와라 이즈나 대박나라 나의 최애 지윤 꾳길만 걷자
I think
1:jiyoon
2:jungeun
3:jeemin
4:sarang
5:saebi
6:mai/koko 😊
Sarang>>>jeemin
Saebi>>>jeemin
this is accurate but I’d say koko > Mai
My bias is jiyoon but i think juengun vocals are more stable n high then jiyoon she need more practice❤❤❤❤
No ur bias ain’t jiyoon it’s clearly jungeun cuz the only think jungeun is better than jiyoon is highnote, and Jiyoon is better in terms of techniques and emotions
@@bella39559emotion can be polishes tho. Jiyoon is best in terms of tone, Jungeun have more versatility and stability. Both have their pros and cons.
@@rainbow-yk8hq emotions is really important to, which helps u convey the message in the song to the audience, jungeun needs to work ok that, Jiyoon is also versatile when it comes to vocals she suit everything she had work on
@@bella39559 yeah, emotion is important but it can be polishes and improves. Jiyoon is lacking versatility compared to Jungeun. It can be seen from twice ohh-ahh and fls. Even producer 24 said Jiyoon voice not suitable for whole song, only selected phrase suits her. This proves as fls, and iwaly she's doing well bcuz she sang only selected phrase.
@@rainbow-yk8hq jiyoon is really versatile in vocal from what I have seen, or maybe u taking abt ‘concept’ if that’s the case then I agree but with vocals she’s mired versatile than jungeun
My vocal rank
Jiyoon
Jungeun
Sarang
Jeemin
Saebi
Koko
Mai
My best vocalist in my opinion
1.jungeun
2.jiyoon
3.sarang
4.jeemin
5.saebi
6.mai
7.koko
Jiyoon ma guuuurlll 💅🏼
My ranking would be:
1) jungeun(versatile)
2) Jiyoon(emotional)
3) Sarang
4) Saebi
5) jeemin
6) koko
3) mai
It’s actually Jiyoon, Jungeun, Sarang, Jeemin, Saebi, mai and Koko.
Accurate rankings
1. Jiyoon (Mid W-A/D)
2. Jungeun (Low W-A/D- *At best*)
3. Jeemin (U-W/E)
4. Sarang (U-W/E- *Af best*)
5. Saebi (Underdeveloped)
6. Koko (Underdeveloped)
7. Mai (Underdeveloped)
finally the correct ranking
1.Jiyoon
2.Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Saebi
5.Koko
6.Mai
7.Jaemin
My opinion:
1 - Jiyoon
2 - Jungeun
3 - Sarang
4 - Saebi
5 - Jeemin
6 - Koko
7 - Mai
my ranking
1. jiyoon
2. jungeun
3. sarang
4. jeemin
5. saebi
6. mai
7. koko
My ranking
1jungeun
2jiyoon
3mai
4sarang
5jeemin
6saebi
7koko
Sarang,Saebi,Jeemin >>> Mai
1. Jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin
5. Saebi
6. Koko
7. Mai
Saebi is not a top 3
My rank
1.jiyoon
2.jungeun
3.sarang
4.saebi
5.jeemin
6.koko
7.mai
I think it's
1.jiyoon
2.jungeun
3.sarang
4.saebi
5.jeemin
6.mai
7.koko
close to the accurate ranking that's good here's the actual ranking according to multiple analysis account :
1. Jiyoon
2. Jungeun
3. Sarang
4. Jeemin
5. Saebi
6. Mai
7. Koko
But mai and koko are probably interchangeable
Jungeun is better than Jiyoon. They’re extremely close but Jungeuns vocal stability when dancing is more impressive than Jiyoon’s ability to present emotions.
Kim vvup padahal bgus bgt nyanyinya gak lurus aja ada keriting2nya😂
1.Yoon Jiyoon
2.Choi Jeongeun
3. Jeong Saebi
4. Ryu Sarang
5.Koko
6.Bang Jeemin
7. Mai