Prophet (ﷺ) said, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. (Sahih al-Bukhari 5590) Before making fun of Islam and consensus of Majority of the scholars, I repeat scholars, not laymen deriving conclusions they like, please think at least once. The scholars of all four schools of thought declared music haraam. Now if you're still in doubt then know that the famous scholar Imam Ibn Qayyim (May Allah be pleased with him) said: "Love of music and the love of the Quran cannot coexist in the same heart. One displaces the other."
I think they answered to this specific hadith in their talk. And for the quote of love of music and love of Quran, isn't rhyming and poetry music? All Qirat of Quran is in rhyming and many ayahs are in the peom form. Can you refute that music and musical instruments were used in the time of Prophet Muhammad PBUH and he didn't object to it (except the reference which is discussed in this debate)?
@@K_Shahzad Calling Quran a mere poetry was what the mushrikeen always did. Allah replies them in Surah Yasin: "We have not taught him poetry, nor is it fitting for him. This ˹Book˺ is only a Reminder and a clear Quran" (36:69). As far as the prohibition of musical instruments is concerned, I've already given you the evidence from the most authentic book after the Holy Quran which is being misinterpreted by a minority. You won't see musical instruments being played around Haram or in Masjid - e - Nabwi or in any Masjid around the world at all and for a good reason. If you consider just one man or few men as justifying musical instruments (that are considered Haraam by a considerable number of scholars) right, then I'm afraid your knowledge about Islam would be seriously restricted and biased. I'll sincerely advise you to take opinion of some other scholars too rather than just sticking to one. They aren't as irrational as you might think. Every prophecy of our Prophet PBUH has turned out to be true. No surprise, this too is turning out to be true.
@@muhammaddanish5317 you misunderstood my reasoning. Quran (of at least parts of it) is indeed in poetry form. Poetry is a part of Fine Arts. Poetry is also the basis of music, if poetry is not haram, how can music be haram in itself? Unless it is used in a wrong way which is prohibited. Tell me, isn't recitation a form of music? to a non-muslim layman it will be.
@@K_Shahzad Music is produced by Musical instruments. I've always used the word "Musical Instruments" and you know what I mean by music when I mention musical instruments. Quran must be recited in a beautiful and melodious voice. Voice that Allah (SWT) blessed us with. Not with musical instruments like flute or piano being played in the background. There's a difference. The word ma‘aazif (musical instruments) is the name used in the above Hadith and it covers flutes, drums etc. You might argue with the fact that Beatboxing and Acapella are also produced without musical instruments. For that, consider this from Ibn al-Qayyim (may Allah have mercy on him) who said: Islam does not differentiate between things that are similar at all, and it does not regard as equal things that are different. It does not forbid one thing because of its harmful effects then permit another thing that is equally harmful, or permit one thing because it serves a useful purpose and forbid another thing that could serve an equal purpose. He also said: "When the Shaytaan despaired of devoted worshippers ever listening to haram sounds such as flutes and drums, he looked at what results from these instruments, then he tried to make singing (without musical accompaniment) produce the same effect, and he made it attractive to those who lack understanding and have little knowledge. His aim is to mislead people step-by-step. But the one who has knowledge would look at what things may lead to and their likely results; he would look at the ultimate purpose behind things." I hope you get my point and may Allah (SWT) guide us both to the right path.
@@muhammaddanish5317 thank you brother. If I understood correctly, it is saying that shaytaan made singing voice similar to musical instruments and not the other way around??? I am sure that humans have been using their voice long long before invention of any musical instrument. Why are we trying to make it more complicated that it is. Fact is, music/singing is not prohibited in Quran. People have come up with these ideologies much later. If anything, it is the use or rather misuse of music and singing which is and should be prohibited. If it was truly prohibited, 99.99% of Muslims are living in hypocrisy.
Only about music I'll say that mery Nabi Kareem saw ny music ki awaz sun kr apny Dono kanoo m apni unglian daal did then..... Any debat ..... On act of Nabi Kareem saw....
Baat samajhne ke liye pehle apne zehen ko uluma ikram ki khiyadat ya parastish se nikal kar Qur'an ke mansha ki taraf tawajjo dena hoga.. Andhi aqidat se Allah ne Ehle kitab ke logo ko bhi roka lekin afsos aaj maximum musalman yehi karre... Isliye shayad Allah talah me sure baqra pehle rakha take uluma ki parastish se musalman nikle... Note kariye ki kabira gunah Allah talah Quran me waze alfaz me bayan karta hei... Koi dake chupe alfazo me nahi jise kisi sahabi ko kholke musalmano ko batana pade...
@@kubrab2617 dheken ikhtelaf E rai krne ka mtlb ye nh hoTa K huM baki uluma ki baten nikal Den or sirf kisi ik ki daal len zehn me ye to phir wohi bt agai na andhi aqidat ki. Sbki bate chOR KR. Kisi ik ki Maan leNa.
@@abdullahriazoffical4638 you are absolutely qayamat k nazdeel log bhut si Haram chezo ko Halal kar le khud se just bcz of their convenience wohi hu rha ha ajkal jahan Islam ata ha or unke kamo m raqawat biada hoti ha wo us ko Halal kar lete han
If you want to learn Islam do what Junaid Jamshed did. He spent considerable time with the Tablighi Jamaat. Allah gives guidance to those who strive for guidance. Junaid Jamshed made great sacrifices for guidance. He quit music. Tablighi Jamaat is an effort to learn Islam. Many celebrities have come into Islam through this effort all over the world.
Unfortunately people don't tell us things based on evidence, they tell us things based on their own believes. That's why I don't like to ask people questions because I Know they will mix their opinions with evidence and present it to me. Thankyou so much for these conversations Hamza, you are my favorite and I believe you will never inculcate or convey a wrong message via any agenda, you just want to spread teachings through research, evidence and logic, and your research is based on verified Hadith and Quran ❤️
You are the great . Keep it up ☺️. Thanks for informing us . Actually I was so much worried about this . I'm girl .and I am thinking about this from my childhood . Thanks alot again.
Many of the facts were not discussed completely in the podcast. There are several perspectives about if music is haram/halal. A wise person cannot change his perspective by just listening to someone's perspective about a topic. Different perspectives + Quran and Hadees combined can alter the conscience and beliefs of people. This issue definitely needs attention for the welfare of youth!
I'm not convinced..May allah give you right company of knowledgeable people and May Allah guide you right path...please bro don't misguide people...please
Humza I saw an old set of four videos of Ghamdi sab on TH-cam. An hour long each. Where he is proving existence of God to some students through cross dialogues and discussion. My query is that is such session videos are available in English language. Ghamdi Sab’s Urdu language is very powerful but unfortunately most of the words don’t make sense to me because my lack of knowledge about the authentic Urdu hence it’s had to make sense of the subject. I would love to share these videos with my children as they have such questions. I’d like to have a solid command on the concept and questions raised by young mind before I open up a discussion with them. Hope I make sense
Hamza bhai thanku you are actually rising those questions jo kahin na kahin hum sab k dilo mai hain kindly is question ka b ans dain ( jahn tasveer lagi ho gi, us kamry mai namaz ni ho sakti ) plzzzz plzzzz reply
It was narrated from Abu Malik Ash’ari that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “People among my nation will drink wine, calling it by another name, and musical instruments will be played for them and singing girls (will sing for them). Allah will cause the earth to swallow them up, and will turn them into monkeys and pigs.”
Mash Allah, Allah bless you for your good contribution about Islam. I am an Indian. Please I know, some political problems are there between both of two countries. But I am a Muslim and you are my brother , that my belief. You know Urdu is not a international language, it is a language of Pak and several parts of India. But there are almost 20 language in only India. So, please makes your these great interview with English subtitles. Please please I know, it will be more problematic and somehow expensive. But, you can't believe how it is important in a non Muslim country and specially in this critical world. Thank you.
Hamza bhi halal aur Haram ka taaluq hmari Rooh aur nafs say hay.agr music say ap ki Rooh Allah ki tarf Parwaz karti hay to halal hay aur agr ye hi music apk ander nafs ko beqrar karti hay to Haram hay.Hazrat Dawood A.S Jo munajat sunaty thay wo Saroor Allah ki Muhabt sy milta tha...hmara maqsad Rooh ki takmeel hai Na k nafs ki..
Can someone mention the verse/ayat number in which Allah praises the statues in Prophet Salman's castle and praises the voice of Prophet Dawood? I can't seem to find it
Thank You very much Hamza Bhai , this was extremely enlightening for me. I myself want to adopt singing as a career , but was unsure about this aspect. Allah Bless You 🙏🏻
If you read the comments. Um i have an advice for the sake of Allah.Just read Qur'an and sahih hadees and develop your own understanding. After that if you don't understand, consult the authentic scholars please. People are fallible to mistakes. No one is perfect except Allah and his Rasool Muhammad sallalahoalayhewassalm.
"They made for him whatever he desired of sanctuaries, statues, basins as large as reservoirs, and cooking pots fixed ˹into the ground˺. ˹We ordered:˺ “Work gratefully, O family of David!” ˹Only˺ a few of My servants are ˹truly˺ grateful." - Qur'an-i Kerim (34 : 13) 💖
yeh deen ko bhi, in my opinion se explain kr rha ha.. gumrahi is on the peak. behayayei is haram in every aspect, & it is available free in music & film industry.
I understood the point but our younger generation and some of adults dont know their limits... Especially in Pakistan when there are events like mehndi people are woke up till 4 am doing RAQS and listening to MOSEEQUI and I want to ask how many of them go and pray their Isha and Fajr? Next day barat everyone found excuses to neglect their prayer I dont know a single person doing everything to reach to masjid or even pray at home ... When children and the young lot they say Sonu Nigam is my "idol" and Sonu Nigam is the one who is disturbed by Adhan.... I never heard a single one saying Dawood AS is the man that we like to follow as far as the vocals are concerned ! They further say our Idol is Shahrukh khan who is Shahrukh Khan a man that couldn't talk once about the muslims and other minorities being tortured and being murdered in India... Its ok there are limits even certain exceptions but the issue of dispute is not even its allowed or not ... the issue is what are the benefits of listening to music or dancing...regarding the society in which we live in....I live in Europe I know here our professor's don't suggest students to listen to music they rather tell you go and do a summer job or an internship that is how you can help yourself in your career... They say dont take every morning your car to come the university rather take transportation why because trains are ponctuel and you learn time management... I know Hamza bhai you aim to bring the religion to the society so is mine... but you can't give the sword to that person who even dont know how to use it.. what he or she is limited to... Im sad but its real
It is not fard to listen to music. If it deviate someone from doing its prime task like studying or praying namaz, then do not listen to it. But then there are some people who study better while listening to some calm music. Its personal choice. But as a rule, its not haram in Islam.
@@Zayn-op3pe That's incomplete information. Majority scholar have said music is haram and their are sahih Hadiths which support this. We should try to adhere to opinion accepted by majority of scholars. On the other hand, there is only one single Sahih Hadith narrated by Abdullah Ibn Jafar bin Abu Talib R. A that says music is permissible but that is overpowered by many other Hadiths that are Sahih and prohibit music. The four great imams do not accept music as permissible to and only Al-Ghazali permitted it, but he defined many conditions for what music is permissible. One of those conditions is that musical instruments iconic of evil people is Impermissible to listen to and hence even if you follow Al ghazali's minority accepted opinion, you cannot listen to modern music. It's better to be safe than sorry and so one should avoid it.
@Aarfeen Anees I respect all imams, but is there a verse in Quran which says music is haram? The hadith you refer to do you have proof yes they were said by Prophet Muhammad? Have you read about ameer khusro and how the Islam spread in subcontinent? Do you know about Prophet Daud and his relation to music? I respect what you are saying but i am just sharing what i found. Arent alot of things music e.g sound of rain? Music is also taught as a degree in many top universities. What about daff which was played when Prophet Muhammad visited madina. Doesn't Quran has a verse which says it is complete?
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم والسلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته @@scoobydooby4672 Daud Alaihi as Salam had nothing to do with music, that is a clear misunderstanding of the Arabic. Secondly the Daff is an exception and that ONLY in certain circumstances. The Hadith is clearly proven with Authentic chains. Rain is not music, here we are talking about musical instruments. When Abu Bakr RadiAllahu Anhu heard that Daff he called it the instrument of the shaitan but he was told that since IT IS EID, the girls should be left alone. This clearly proves what the Sahaba RahdiAllahuanhum thought of music, it was only an exception for a few occasions such as EID.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم Assalam u Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuhu@@aarfeenanees9147 Brother or Sister I am not completely familiar with your name and thus don't know. Would you be able to post this original comment of yours in the main comments in sha Allah
Please encourage Ghamidi sb to work together with Dr Hany Atchan , Engr Md Ali Mirza and Syed Abdullah Tariq. I have a strong feeling that if these 4 work together, they can change the world In sha Allah!
میرا حمزہ علی عباسی سے یہ سوال ہے کہ اسلام کی طرف وآپس آنے کے بعد آپ نے الف ڈرامہ بنایا اس کی آخری قسط میں آپ نے نامحرم لڑکی کو جو جھپھی ڈالی تھی اسکی شرعی حیثیت کیا ہے خدا کا دین اس بارے کیا کہتا ہے؟؟؟
According to this video i think Islam is so easy our religion is so easy but we are making it difficult our Aulma are making it difficult or hame jo bachpan se sikhaya jata hai actually ye sab kaafi zamane se chala araha hai jo hmare parents ke parents or unse phlay se ham tak pohancha hai . Agar is video ko dekhen to aisa lgta hai hame jo aj tak Islam ke baare mein pata tha wo sab Islam hai hi nahi hame lgta hai ke hamne Quran pak parh lia to hame Islam agaya but Quran ke meaning mein bhi meaning chupa hai usko smjhne ki zroorat hai
Please try to add english subtitle for listeners like me who doesn’t know Urdu much. 🥺 This conversation seemed really interesting to me but couldn’t understand the entire conversation since I don’t understand many of the urdu words 😢
Rohail hyatt is legend of todays industry he havent given any award and he dont go in public his music is beyound our imagination you can you can prefer his music.
Wasy nhi kehty log k ghamdi sahib munkar e hadees hain, jab nabi akram (s.aw) ne farmaya k jis ka mafhoom hai k akhri waqt ma log alaat e mousiqi ko halaal karlengy, to is ka kia matlab hai k haraam hai na..! Or ummat ka ijmaa hai pehly se ab tak kabhi bhi aisa nhi samjha gya k music ghana bajana halal hai.. aalaat e mousiqi haraam hai. Magar pata nhi kahan se lateef ahsasaat aagy or ahasas u jazbat ke nazar hogya sab kuch
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم Assalam u Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuhu @@osamaiqbal8253 its a clear fact, do you need a proof for the sun as well? -Rejecting the coming of Esa Alaihi as Salam and saying he passes away NaoudhubIllah in clear opposition to the belief of the Muslims. -He allows mortages of riba -he sees no isse in music as well as TOUCHING Non Mahrams like cousins, he agrees its best to avoid but days there is no issue if one touches since its not an Islamic issue. -he rejects the 10 Mutawaatir Qiraat of the Quran al Kareem -on and on and on
yaaar kon hain ya log quran pak mein wazih likha ha ka khud sa without any proof kissi cheez or halaal ya haraam na kaho ya Allah pak par jhoot baandhna ha..... phir bhi tum log ya sab kehta ha agar koi solid proof ha to btao
@@khattakproductions5680g bilkul inhi ka bara mein hamza abbasi na baat ki ha ka inka qool or amal mein farq ha.....agar waqae haram ha to sach mein qasam khao ka tum na kabhi suna hi nae music
Hamza bhai ne bht achy aur sensitive topic pe bt ki h.. hm log bgyr think kiye purane logo ko follow krne lg jaty hn.. naat prho tb musical instruments bhi halal aur sur aur taal bhi.. else than that sb haram? Doesn't make sense.
Assalam.O.Alaikum Hamza! Have you any info about marital rape. I want to know the point of view of Islam about marital rape. Kindly make video on this topic.
Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari: that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."
I happen u watch ur this topic, i must say the idea is superb and well thought out but the way u r solving this mystery could have been better if u conclude each ayah n talk fully... most of molana sahab’s talk re just go hay why....
سبحان اللہ مولوی تو دیکھیں اس قسم کے مولویوں نے تو ایسا ہی اسلام بیان کریں گے دم ہے تو پھر ثاقب مصطفائی ایسے بڑے علمائے کرام کو بٹھا کر ان سے پوچھا جائے
Hazrat Dawood Zabur sunate the jab sab ikhatay hote the.. Hazrat Suleman kay daur me statues bante the toh bante honge.. Deen mukammal toh Nabi Pak par Quran nazil hone k baad hova.
ہمزا علی عبا سی صاحب آپ کو قرآن سے بہت کچھ سیکھنا با قی ہے درود شریف جو نماز میں پڑھا جا تا ہے یعنی درود ابراحیمی کا ترجمہ یہ ہے کہ آیے اللہ جو رحمتیں اور بر کتیں تو نے حضرت ابراحیم علیہ آ سلام اور انکی آل پر پر نازل فرمائ ہیں وہی رحمتیں اور برکتیں حضرت نبی پاک صل اللہ علیہ و سلم پر بھی نازل فرما قرآن مجید سے پتہ چلتا ہے کہ ابراحیم علیہ اسلام پر اللہ تعالٰی نے جو رحمتیں اور برکتیں نازل فرمائ تھیں کہ اللہ تعالیٰ نے آپ کی نسل میں پہ درپہ نبی مبعوث فرمائے یہی دعا خود آنحضرت صلی اللہ علیہ و سلم ساری زندگی مانگتے رہے یہی دعااپنی امت کو بھی مانگ نے کی حدایت جاری کردی اور نمازوں میں بھی اسکو پڑھنا فرض قرار دے دیا سوال یہ ہےکہ اگر اس دعا کا فائیدہ نہیں تھا اور رسول پاک کی آل میں یہ رحمت اور برکت نہیں ہو نی تھی تو اس درود شریف کا کیا فا ئیدہ کیا ہے یقیناً اس دعا کا فائیدہ ہے اور رسول صلی اللہ علیہ و سلم کی یہ دعا قبول ہو ئ ہے (امتی نبی کے لیحا ظ سے) جو آپ کی شریعت کے تا بع اور آپکے فیض سے فیضیا ب ہو کر آپ کی غلا می میں کسی کو تو آنا تھا گو یا امتی نبی کے آنے دروازا قطعاً بند نہیں ہوا اور حدیث بھی مسلم میں آنے والے امام مہدی کو نبی آ للہ کہا گیا ہے چار مرتبہ اس نام سے یا دکیا گیاہے
Music is not allowed in Islam..... Read Islamic history esp early times of Hazrat Adam !! Follow hadith and read quran with translation rather than following Hamza Abbasi views. May Allah guide us all
@Hamza ali abbasi
Allah apko is pe Consist rakhy...
Pta nh kitne Apky Followers apko dekh Kr Islam Pr aayn Hon Gy..
Allah Apko Consistent Rakhy❤
Prophet (ﷺ) said, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. (Sahih al-Bukhari 5590)
Before making fun of Islam and consensus of Majority of the scholars, I repeat scholars, not laymen deriving conclusions they like, please think at least once. The scholars of all four schools of thought declared music haraam. Now if you're still in doubt then know that the famous scholar Imam Ibn Qayyim (May Allah be pleased with him) said:
"Love of music and the love of the Quran cannot coexist in the same heart. One displaces the other."
I think they answered to this specific hadith in their talk. And for the quote of love of music and love of Quran, isn't rhyming and poetry music? All Qirat of Quran is in rhyming and many ayahs are in the peom form. Can you refute that music and musical instruments were used in the time of Prophet Muhammad PBUH and he didn't object to it (except the reference which is discussed in this debate)?
@@K_Shahzad Calling Quran a mere poetry was what the mushrikeen always did. Allah replies them in Surah Yasin:
"We have not taught him poetry, nor is it fitting for him. This ˹Book˺ is only a Reminder and a clear Quran" (36:69).
As far as the prohibition of musical instruments is concerned, I've already given you the evidence from the most authentic book after the Holy Quran which is being misinterpreted by a minority. You won't see musical instruments being played around Haram or in Masjid - e - Nabwi or in any Masjid around the world at all and for a good reason. If you consider just one man or few men as justifying musical instruments (that are considered Haraam by a considerable number of scholars) right, then I'm afraid your knowledge about Islam would be seriously restricted and biased. I'll sincerely advise you to take opinion of some other scholars too rather than just sticking to one. They aren't as irrational as you might think. Every prophecy of our Prophet PBUH has turned out to be true. No surprise, this too is turning out to be true.
@@muhammaddanish5317 you misunderstood my reasoning. Quran (of at least parts of it) is indeed in poetry form. Poetry is a part of Fine Arts. Poetry is also the basis of music, if poetry is not haram, how can music be haram in itself? Unless it is used in a wrong way which is prohibited. Tell me, isn't recitation a form of music? to a non-muslim layman it will be.
@@K_Shahzad Music is produced by Musical instruments. I've always used the word "Musical Instruments" and you know what I mean by music when I mention musical instruments. Quran must be recited in a beautiful and melodious voice. Voice that Allah (SWT) blessed us with. Not with musical instruments like flute or piano being played in the background. There's a difference. The word ma‘aazif (musical instruments) is the name used in the above Hadith and it covers flutes, drums etc. You might argue with the fact that Beatboxing and Acapella are also produced without musical instruments. For that, consider this from Ibn al-Qayyim (may Allah have mercy on him) who said: Islam does not differentiate between things that are similar at all, and it does not regard as equal things that are different. It does not forbid one thing because of its harmful effects then permit another thing that is equally harmful, or permit one thing because it serves a useful purpose and forbid another thing that could serve an equal purpose.
He also said:
"When the Shaytaan despaired of devoted worshippers ever listening to haram sounds such as flutes and drums, he looked at what results from these instruments, then he tried to make singing (without musical accompaniment) produce the same effect, and he made it attractive to those who lack understanding and have little knowledge. His aim is to mislead people step-by-step. But the one who has knowledge would look at what things may lead to and their likely results; he would look at the ultimate purpose behind things."
I hope you get my point and may Allah (SWT) guide us both to the right path.
@@muhammaddanish5317 thank you brother. If I understood correctly, it is saying that shaytaan made singing voice similar to musical instruments and not the other way around??? I am sure that humans have been using their voice long long before invention of any musical instrument.
Why are we trying to make it more complicated that it is. Fact is, music/singing is not prohibited in Quran. People have come up with these ideologies much later. If anything, it is the use or rather misuse of music and singing which is and should be prohibited.
If it was truly prohibited, 99.99% of Muslims are living in hypocrisy.
Only about music I'll say that mery Nabi Kareem saw ny music ki awaz sun kr apny Dono kanoo m apni unglian daal did then..... Any debat ..... On act of Nabi Kareem saw....
I m not convinced, May Allah guide us all...Ameen...
Baat samajhne ke liye pehle apne zehen ko uluma ikram ki khiyadat ya parastish se nikal kar Qur'an ke mansha ki taraf tawajjo dena hoga.. Andhi aqidat se Allah ne Ehle kitab ke logo ko bhi roka lekin afsos aaj maximum musalman yehi karre... Isliye shayad Allah talah me sure baqra pehle rakha take uluma ki parastish se musalman nikle... Note kariye ki kabira gunah Allah talah Quran me waze alfaz me bayan karta hei... Koi dake chupe alfazo me nahi jise kisi sahabi ko kholke musalmano ko batana pade...
baat samajhnay say pehle apnay fiqh or babo ko chorna paray ga
@@kubrab2617 dheken ikhtelaf E rai krne ka mtlb ye nh hoTa K huM baki uluma ki baten nikal Den or sirf kisi ik ki daal len zehn me ye to phir wohi bt agai na andhi aqidat ki. Sbki bate chOR KR. Kisi ik ki Maan leNa.
@@abdullahriazoffical4638 you are absolutely qayamat k nazdeel log bhut si Haram chezo ko Halal kar le khud se just bcz of their convenience wohi hu rha ha ajkal jahan Islam ata ha or unke kamo m raqawat biada hoti ha wo us ko Halal kar lete han
I've shared this video with ali e and told him to make a response video on this
If you want to learn Islam do what Junaid Jamshed did. He spent considerable time with the Tablighi Jamaat. Allah gives guidance to those who strive for guidance. Junaid Jamshed made great sacrifices for guidance. He quit music.
Tablighi Jamaat is an effort to learn Islam. Many celebrities have come into Islam through this effort all over the world.
Jazak ALLAH both of you ❤️
Hamza Really Love This Conversation ❤️👏
Normalizing haram things doesn't change the truth....
Unfortunately people don't tell us things based on evidence, they tell us things based on their own believes. That's why I don't like to ask people questions because I Know they will mix their opinions with evidence and present it to me.
Thankyou so much for these conversations Hamza, you are my favorite and I believe you will never inculcate or convey a wrong message via any agenda, you just want to spread teachings through research, evidence and logic, and your research is based on verified Hadith and Quran ❤️
You are the great . Keep it up ☺️. Thanks for informing us . Actually I was so much worried about this . I'm girl .and I am thinking about this from my childhood . Thanks alot again.
یعنی قرآن کریم پڑھنے سے انسان کی وحشت اور درشتگی دور نہیں ھو سکتی موسیقی سے اب انسان اپنی وحشتوں کو دور کرے عجب بوالعجبی ھے
Many of the facts were not discussed completely in the podcast. There are several perspectives about if music is haram/halal. A wise person cannot change his perspective by just listening to someone's perspective about a topic. Different perspectives + Quran and Hadees combined can alter the conscience and beliefs of people.
This issue definitely needs attention for the welfare of youth!
Very fine conversation for open minded Muslims and valid logical points, mashaAllah!
Jazak Allah qer to both of you.. Very informative..
Masha Allah BarakAllahu Fikum good job Guys, You are trying to spread true Understanding of Islaam, May Allah S W accept your efforts towards Islaam.
Ameen
I'm not convinced..May allah give you right company of knowledgeable people and May Allah guide you right path...please bro don't misguide people...please
I came here after watching Alif ... Thank you Hamza Sir for this knowledgeable session 🌹
Humza I saw an old set of four videos of Ghamdi sab on TH-cam. An hour long each. Where he is proving existence of God to some students through cross dialogues and discussion. My query is that is such session videos are available in English language. Ghamdi Sab’s Urdu language is very powerful but unfortunately most of the words don’t make sense to me because my lack of knowledge about the authentic Urdu hence it’s had to make sense of the subject. I would love to share these videos with my children as they have such questions. I’d like to have a solid command on the concept and questions raised by young mind before I open up a discussion with them. Hope I make sense
Hamza bhai thanku you are actually rising those questions jo kahin na kahin hum sab k dilo mai hain kindly is question ka b ans dain ( jahn tasveer lagi ho gi, us kamry mai namaz ni ho sakti ) plzzzz plzzzz reply
It was narrated from Abu Malik Ash’ari that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
“People among my nation will drink wine, calling it by another name, and musical instruments will be played for them and singing girls (will sing for them). Allah will cause the earth to swallow them up, and will turn them into monkeys and pigs.”
Hadith no ?
Mash Allah, Allah bless you for your good contribution about Islam.
I am an Indian. Please I know, some political problems are there between both of two countries. But I am a Muslim and you are my brother , that my belief.
You know Urdu is not a international language, it is a language of Pak and several parts of India. But there are almost 20 language in only India. So, please makes your these great interview with English subtitles. Please please I know, it will be more problematic and somehow expensive. But, you can't believe how it is important in a non Muslim country and specially in this critical world. Thank you.
Saalaa deshdrohi
@@Parikshit_3000 thank you for your appreciation. Almighty bless you. 👍👍
Absolutely right kaash musalmaan ayyat ko smjh Kay imaan wslay ban janainy ki koshish krain Aameen
Amazing Hamza bhai ! U r doing the best job! Stay blessed
Hamza bhi halal aur Haram ka taaluq hmari Rooh aur nafs say hay.agr music say ap ki Rooh Allah ki tarf Parwaz karti hay to halal hay aur agr ye hi music apk ander nafs ko beqrar karti hay to Haram hay.Hazrat Dawood A.S Jo munajat sunaty thay wo Saroor Allah ki Muhabt sy milta tha...hmara maqsad Rooh ki takmeel hai Na k nafs ki..
Apny Rooh aur nafs ko samjhna bht zrori hai wrna Allah k halal aur Haram k hukam ko kabhi b nai smjha ja skta.
Can someone mention the verse/ayat number in which Allah praises the statues in Prophet Salman's castle and praises the voice of Prophet Dawood? I can't seem to find it
mashallah brother you are doing a great job ..love from Bangladesh
write it as Ma Sha Allah is the correct spelling
A petition for tv to broadcast this type of content so that more people can get educated 🙏💜
Well said 👍
Yes
Thank You very much Hamza Bhai , this was extremely enlightening for me. I myself want to adopt singing as a career , but was unsure about this aspect. Allah Bless You 🙏🏻
If you read the comments. Um i have an advice for the sake of Allah.Just read Qur'an and sahih hadees and develop your own understanding. After that if you don't understand, consult the authentic scholars please. People are fallible to mistakes. No one is perfect except Allah and his Rasool Muhammad sallalahoalayhewassalm.
"They made for him whatever he desired of sanctuaries, statues, basins as large as reservoirs, and cooking pots fixed ˹into the ground˺. ˹We ordered:˺ “Work gratefully, O family of David!” ˹Only˺ a few of My servants are ˹truly˺ grateful." - Qur'an-i Kerim (34 : 13) 💖
yeh deen ko bhi, in my opinion se explain kr rha ha.. gumrahi is on the peak. behayayei is haram in every aspect, & it is available free in music & film industry.
I understood the point but our younger generation and some of adults dont know their limits...
Especially in Pakistan when there are events like mehndi people are woke up till 4 am doing RAQS and listening to MOSEEQUI and I want to ask how many of them go and pray their Isha and Fajr? Next day barat everyone found excuses to neglect their prayer I dont know a single person doing everything to reach to masjid or even pray at home ...
When children and the young lot they say Sonu Nigam is my "idol" and Sonu Nigam is the one who is disturbed by Adhan.... I never heard a single one saying Dawood AS is the man that we like to follow as far as the vocals are concerned !
They further say our Idol is Shahrukh khan who is Shahrukh Khan a man that couldn't talk once about the muslims and other minorities being tortured and being murdered in India...
Its ok there are limits even certain exceptions but the issue of dispute is not even its allowed or not ... the issue is what are the benefits of listening to music or dancing...regarding the society in which we live in....I live in Europe I know here our professor's don't suggest students to listen to music they rather tell you go and do a summer job or an internship that is how you can help yourself in your career... They say dont take every morning your car to come the university rather take transportation why because trains are ponctuel and you learn time management...
I know Hamza bhai you aim to bring the religion to the society so is mine... but you can't give the sword to that person who even dont know how to use it.. what he or she is limited to... Im sad but its real
It is not fard to listen to music. If it deviate someone from doing its prime task like studying or praying namaz, then do not listen to it. But then there are some people who study better while listening to some calm music. Its personal choice. But as a rule, its not haram in Islam.
@@Zayn-op3pe That's incomplete information. Majority scholar have said music is haram and their are sahih Hadiths which support this. We should try to adhere to opinion accepted by majority of scholars.
On the other hand, there is only one single Sahih Hadith narrated by Abdullah Ibn Jafar bin Abu Talib R. A that says music is permissible but that is overpowered by many other Hadiths that are Sahih and prohibit music. The four great imams do not accept music as permissible to and only Al-Ghazali permitted it, but he defined many conditions for what music is permissible. One of those conditions is that musical instruments iconic of evil people is Impermissible to listen to and hence even if you follow Al ghazali's minority accepted opinion, you cannot listen to modern music.
It's better to be safe than sorry and so one should avoid it.
@Aarfeen Anees I respect all imams, but is there a verse in Quran which says music is haram? The hadith you refer to do you have proof yes they were said by Prophet Muhammad? Have you read about ameer khusro and how the Islam spread in subcontinent? Do you know about Prophet Daud and his relation to music? I respect what you are saying but i am just sharing what i found. Arent alot of things music e.g sound of rain? Music is also taught as a degree in many top universities. What about daff which was played when Prophet Muhammad visited madina. Doesn't Quran has a verse which says it is complete?
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم والسلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته
@@scoobydooby4672 Daud Alaihi as Salam had nothing to do with music, that is a clear misunderstanding of the Arabic. Secondly the Daff is an exception and that ONLY in certain circumstances. The Hadith is clearly proven with Authentic chains.
Rain is not music, here we are talking about musical instruments. When Abu Bakr RadiAllahu Anhu heard that Daff he called it the instrument of the shaitan but he was told that since IT IS EID, the girls should be left alone. This clearly proves what the Sahaba RahdiAllahuanhum thought of music, it was only an exception for a few occasions such as EID.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
Assalam u Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuhu@@aarfeenanees9147 Brother or Sister I am not completely familiar with your name and thus don't know.
Would you be able to post this original comment of yours in the main comments in sha Allah
These things can change our society completely ,if promoted!
aik baat mein clear karna chahti hu ka hazrat daud A.S ki tilawat sa cheezain, pahar or parinda jhooomta tha musawari sa nahi.....
Astukhfurallah!
Every one is 1st until they refresh
You have presented a very comprehensive research here. You are a breath of fresh air
@@talhaahmed2042 😂😂
Am I the only one who have been feeling anxious all the time because he had his back to maaraf-al Quran and other Islamic books.
Watching mann mayal 5th time in love with you both again and again ❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍
nice drama
"Islamic perspective on Islam by Syed baqer al qazwini" in English. A MUST WATCH🔺
Please encourage Ghamidi sb to work together with Dr Hany Atchan , Engr Md Ali Mirza and Syed Abdullah Tariq. I have a strong feeling that if these 4 work together, they can change the world In sha Allah!
Very important topic u r discussing
Great discussion sir 👍
Hasanbhai is a truly wise person. Insightful
میرا حمزہ علی عباسی سے یہ سوال ہے کہ اسلام کی طرف وآپس آنے کے بعد آپ نے الف ڈرامہ بنایا اس کی آخری قسط میں آپ نے نامحرم لڑکی کو جو جھپھی ڈالی تھی اسکی شرعی حیثیت کیا ہے خدا کا دین اس بارے کیا کہتا ہے؟؟؟
According to this video i think Islam is so easy our religion is so easy but we are making it difficult our Aulma are making it difficult or hame jo bachpan se sikhaya jata hai actually ye sab kaafi zamane se chala araha hai jo hmare parents ke parents or unse phlay se ham tak pohancha hai .
Agar is video ko dekhen to aisa lgta hai hame jo aj tak Islam ke baare mein pata tha wo sab Islam hai hi nahi hame lgta hai ke hamne Quran pak parh lia to hame Islam agaya but Quran ke meaning mein bhi meaning chupa hai usko smjhne ki zroorat hai
It totally makes sense. And I don’t think there could be anything in Islam which doesn’t make sense.
Why these types of contents don't come on trending in our country???.... although Pakistan is Islamic country.......
It would be very useful to give English subtitles in your lecture.
Sir please , provide us any platform to put our questions about Islam , that surely reach you
May Allah bless you for your efforts.
Hamza sir...........👍
Please try to add english subtitle for listeners like me who doesn’t know Urdu much. 🥺
This conversation seemed really interesting to me but couldn’t understand the entire conversation since I don’t understand many of the urdu words 😢
Masha'Allah
Rohail hyatt is legend of todays industry he havent given any award and he dont go in public his music is beyound our imagination you can you can prefer his music.
Wasy nhi kehty log k ghamdi sahib munkar e hadees hain, jab nabi akram (s.aw) ne farmaya k jis ka mafhoom hai k akhri waqt ma log alaat e mousiqi ko halaal karlengy, to is ka kia matlab hai k haraam hai na..! Or ummat ka ijmaa hai pehly se ab tak kabhi bhi aisa nhi samjha gya k music ghana bajana halal hai.. aalaat e mousiqi haraam hai. Magar pata nhi kahan se lateef ahsasaat aagy or ahasas u jazbat ke nazar hogya sab kuch
Please have a conversation with Mufti Tariq Masood on many of he differences between Dr. Ghamdi's ideology.
He is a joker!
@@obaidsiddiqui5638 who?
@@shairsko9360 tariq masood
@@obaidsiddiqui5638 why? He is actually quite grounded tbh!
GHAMIDI IS A FITNAAAAAA
And how is that.... Can you elaborate
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
Assalam u Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuhu
@@osamaiqbal8253 its a clear fact, do you need a proof for the sun as well?
-Rejecting the coming of Esa Alaihi as Salam and saying he passes away NaoudhubIllah in clear opposition to the belief of the Muslims.
-He allows mortages of riba
-he sees no isse in music as well as TOUCHING Non Mahrams like cousins, he agrees its best to avoid but days there is no issue if one touches since its not an Islamic issue.
-he rejects the 10 Mutawaatir Qiraat of the Quran al Kareem
-on and on and on
Ghamdi Sahab ka favorite song konsa hai k hum bhi sune?😤
میوزک کل بھی حرام تھا میوزک آج بھی حرام ہے
To Qasam kha ke bata ke too sunta hai music kai nhi ??
yaaar kon hain ya log quran pak mein wazih likha ha ka khud sa without any proof kissi cheez or halaal ya haraam na kaho ya Allah pak par jhoot baandhna ha..... phir bhi tum log ya sab kehta ha agar koi solid proof ha to btao
@@khattakproductions5680g bilkul inhi ka bara mein hamza abbasi na baat ki ha ka inka qool or amal mein farq ha.....agar waqae haram ha to sach mein qasam khao ka tum na kabhi suna hi nae music
tera wajood bhi haram hai
@@beautyzone999
شکریہ
Plz man islam is not a cycle that can change in any direction
Please provide counter argument if you have any.
Very important topic all the best hamza ali abbasi 🖒🤗
Thankyou Hamza i am waiting for it .😊
Bhut shandaar 😇
Hamza bhai ne bht achy aur sensitive topic pe bt ki h.. hm log bgyr think kiye purane logo ko follow krne lg jaty hn.. naat prho tb musical instruments bhi halal aur sur aur taal bhi.. else than that sb haram? Doesn't make sense.
Alif drama change your life i love you
I love you hamza bhai ❤
Each video in this series has been amazing, Hamza bhai.
Walaikkumsalaam..
I ❤️ Your acting, I ❤️ Your. smile, I ❤️
Your all. I LOVE U so much from Bangladesh 🇧🇩.
I will meet you one day . Inshallah. Because you done a well done work . I will be in showbiz industry Inshallah .
what type of music we can listen means normally music is full of love songs in which they say the things ,words (with joy) which are forbidden
Lol hamza ko bolo playlist send kar day jo halal hain 🤣🤣🤣🤣
This man is making no sense kuch halal hain kuch haram hain
May Allah guide him
Hamza ali abbasi is the best person ever huge faan
Hamza Bhai AAP Sy milna chahta hu , dua hy Allah milwa dain
Assalam.O.Alaikum Hamza!
Have you any info about marital rape.
I want to know the point of view of Islam about marital rape. Kindly make video on this topic.
Keep going brothers!
Good question u are asking
Narrated Abu 'Amir or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari:
that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will destroy them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection."
Hadith no.?
@@thinkingdom8727 Sahih Al Bukharin 5590
Perfect bro
Well said really thought provoking conversation 👏👏❤💕😊😎
This is most important topic
Which version of Islam do you specifically follow?
Makes complete sense , and so true about contradictions, so sad
I happen u watch ur this topic, i must say the idea is superb and well thought out but the way u r solving this mystery could have been better if u conclude each ayah n talk fully... most of molana sahab’s talk re just go hay why....
Good Efforts
I am your big fan bro from IOK
سبحان اللہ مولوی تو دیکھیں اس قسم کے مولویوں نے تو ایسا ہی اسلام بیان کریں گے دم ہے تو پھر ثاقب مصطفائی ایسے بڑے علمائے کرام کو بٹھا کر ان سے پوچھا جائے
Ghamidi sahb ka favorite song konsa hai?
Bohot khoob sawaal 😁
بلو ٹھمکا لگا
😅 I love old songs
Thanks alot hamza💞
Obviously this is very sensitive topic after listening this i really changed my point of view yes v show hypocrisy in this topic
Mr abbassi, I have a question about mr Gamidi ! Why most Islamic scholars are against mr Gamidi s thought? Please explain. Thanks
Watch initial videos of this channel
That’s right. But in my eyes, no scholar came better after Dr. Israr Ahmed and he said that Ghamidi misquotes.
Keep making these videos! Much needed in these times.
Hazrat Dawood Zabur sunate the jab sab ikhatay hote the..
Hazrat Suleman kay daur me statues bante the toh bante honge.. Deen mukammal toh Nabi Pak par Quran nazil hone k baad hova.
ہمزا علی عبا سی صاحب آپ کو
قرآن سے بہت کچھ سیکھنا
با قی ہے
درود شریف جو نماز میں پڑھا جا تا ہے یعنی درود ابراحیمی
کا ترجمہ یہ ہے کہ آیے اللہ جو رحمتیں اور بر کتیں تو نے حضرت ابراحیم علیہ آ سلام اور انکی آل پر پر نازل فرمائ ہیں وہی رحمتیں اور برکتیں حضرت نبی پاک صل اللہ علیہ و سلم پر بھی نازل فرما قرآن مجید سے پتہ چلتا ہے کہ ابراحیم علیہ اسلام پر اللہ تعالٰی نے جو رحمتیں اور برکتیں نازل فرمائ تھیں کہ اللہ تعالیٰ نے آپ کی نسل میں پہ درپہ نبی مبعوث فرمائے یہی دعا خود آنحضرت
صلی اللہ علیہ و سلم ساری زندگی مانگتے رہے یہی دعااپنی امت کو بھی مانگ نے کی حدایت جاری کردی اور نمازوں
میں بھی اسکو پڑھنا فرض
قرار دے دیا
سوال یہ ہےکہ اگر اس دعا کا
فائیدہ نہیں تھا اور رسول پاک کی آل میں یہ رحمت اور برکت نہیں ہو نی تھی تو اس درود
شریف کا کیا فا ئیدہ کیا ہے یقیناً
اس دعا کا فائیدہ ہے اور رسول
صلی اللہ علیہ و سلم کی یہ دعا قبول ہو ئ ہے (امتی نبی کے لیحا ظ سے) جو آپ کی شریعت کے تا بع اور آپکے فیض سے فیضیا ب ہو کر آپ کی غلا می
میں کسی کو تو آنا تھا گو یا
امتی نبی کے آنے دروازا قطعاً بند نہیں ہوا اور حدیث بھی
مسلم میں آنے والے امام مہدی کو نبی آ للہ کہا گیا ہے چار مرتبہ
اس نام سے یا دکیا گیاہے
ASLAAM O ALAIKUM WA REHMATULLAH. HAMZA ALI BHAI I WANT TO TALK WITH YOU ABOUT PEACE UNITY FAITH PLEASE 🇵🇰
Dekho dekho kon aya
Gadar aya gadar aya.
Asalam o alikum
I appreciate u . I am from India. I like your acting also in Mann Mayal. Please reply me.
if we see in islamic tradition music is not haram according to all of the ulama.imam ghazali is one of them.
Agree
Music is not allowed in Islam..... Read Islamic history esp early times of Hazrat Adam !! Follow hadith and read quran with translation rather than following Hamza Abbasi views. May Allah guide us all
V want to see u with Ali ehtsham bhai tuaha ibn jaleel Muhammad Ali bhai youth club that would b best time of my life
Yes ye bt sochny ki h k trana r medam noor jahan wali bt sb like krty hn