State Closing Argument in GA v. Hannah Payne | Car Crash Vigilante Trial
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ธ.ค. 2023
- "[Hannah Payne] should have minded her own business." Assistant D.A. Nigel Hunter delivers the State's closing argument saying that chasing Kenneth Herring and shooting him went against all common sense. There is no reason he shouldn't be alive today, she said.
#CourtTV What do YOU think? #CarCrashVigilanteTrial #VerdictWatch #HannahPayne
Catch up on the FACTS here: www.courttv.com/tag/hannah-pa...
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE www.courttv.com/trials/
WHERE-TO-WATCH www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.76[1/2] โจโฉเปิดป่าโหดรับโอ๊ต-ป๊อบ รอบนี้พี่เอาจริง!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pNg5O7Pf-a0/mqdefault.jpg)
#CourtTV What do YOU think? #HannahPayne #VerdictWatch
MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/hannah-payne/?
I hope they convict on all charges, but think they might pull back on the most serious one - malice murder.
Imo, this is one of the more obvious crimes of this nature that we've seen. Payne needs decades in prison.
Guilty AF
The defense attorney is pathetic from the law school of jokes
This guy has done one of the worst jobs as a defense attorney I've seen all year.@@sistermaat554
That man's death and the young ladies conviction is a direct result of the insane gun laws in Georgia. So many people in that state now feel they have the right to run around playing wild Bill Hickok and Wyatt Earp. That's what you get for electing inbred hicks for governor.
That defense attorney is so childish. Completely unprofessional. The way he shook his head and made faces while she made her closing arguments. Act like a dignified attorney. What a joke.
Agree. I e n3ver seen anything like it. He doesn’t respect his client or the process.
That's why I came to the comments. I'm seeing his expressions and thinking, man you can't sit there and just be quiet and still.. Sadly neither could his client.
Her attorney is more childish than professional .
@@hollyjasmine8172You already know
He’s over here acting like Donna Adelson!
'You dont get the death penalty for committing a traffic infraction'
That phrase Im sure hit the jury hard
@@shindles I’m clearly, LMAO!!!
@@shindlesthe point is they in prison…..not dead.
but we don't know what really happen in that truck, could it had been a accidental killing?
@@jrx2662 LMAO!!! Yes we clearly do KNOW what occurred at Kenneth Herrings truck. Hannah Payne approached his vehicle clearly AFTER blocking him with a loaded firearm, hysterically demanding that he return to the scene of the accident. However, I certainly suppose the actual “testimony” of those who WITNESSED this altercation, or official FORENSIC reports presented at trial that there was absolutely NO finger prints belonging to Mr. Herring found on the weapon used by Hannah Payne or, the actual toxicology report clearly confirming there were NO drugs or alcohol in his system prior to this “supposed” struggle YOU seem rather FIXATED on. Moreover, given the total gravity of this case, what “else” is there to KNOW???
A cruel inhuman sentence with no hope of redemption or rehabilitation. The INHUMANE AMERICAN INJUSTICE System. A nation that also sends children to jail for life after putting a gun into their hands from birth. A mad gun culture. An immoral godless nation of mentally screwed up nation of fatherless children. Look what your permissive society u bragged about in the 70s has brought u now. A nation with 2 geriatrics fighting for the presidency.
What on earth is wrong with the defendant’s attorney?? He is SO unprofessional. Rolling his eyes as the prosecutor says that Mr Herring should be here today with his family during the holidays. What on earth is so unacceptable about that statement? How could anyone roll their eyes at that? He clearly holds Mr Herring’s life in low regard just like Hannah did. Disgusting people.
He was horrrriiiible. One of the worst I’ve seen.
That defense attorney is definitely a weirdo!
Well female George Zimmerman didn't get to put the victim on trial and walk this time but I think we know why he was having that reaction when everyone was reminded that poor man had a family and was a human being.
The contempt that this Attorney and this defendant show for Mr. Kenneth did not just show up today. These two believe that they have rights that Mr. Kenneth did not.
Offered he sone water after he drank out of it🤦🏽♀️
The closing was excellent 👌. Yes, "he didn't know her, he didn't have to do anything she said". The audacity!
The prosecutor delivered a FANTASTIC closing. Well done Sis ❤
OMG her defence attorney is vile with those smirks and head shaking.
He turned red 😂
I saw that too. It was so unprofessional. Also when the State talked about Mr. Herring, he kept looking around the courthouse. Was he looking for Mr. Herring’s family?
Did not like the Defense attorney at all. Loved the witnesses and that they stood their ground with him.❤
Because this was the most racist trial I've seen.. yep, even dragging a boy wasn't this racist.. the State hung her out to dry??
She needs new attorneys!!
Yeah all his smirks, snake just like her.
@@evelyncaruso4441She actually looks sad for being responsible for this man's death....finally!
Cos she sure as he!! wasn't on the stand!
I love how she broke down all of the definitions of the charges with examples of the crime! She is so good!
You mean she is actually educated in the law, unlike the politically motivated. You know folks that come to exercise their racist agendas
@tonicuahubbard9126
Exactly!
Excellent Closing Argument
She should have minded her own business! That had to hurt!
Right, she definitely WOULD NOT be a defendant right now!!!
Right she had to mind her own business, what a mess!
the scary part.. she believes she's entitled to other peoples business, more even so when its minorities, taking another human life like just another day out hunting.
@@kangjhhaShe was reared to believe that she could be the authority.
They can ONLY mind their business when it's mirrored image and that's it ALL else is hunted.
The prosecutor put the nail in the coffin with that closing argument….GIRL BYE !😂
I'm so amazed in this time of my life to witness a black woman standing as a prosecutor in the courts of the US, when 100 years such a thing would never exist. 😮 how great it is that rights have moved forward. Prejudices will OUT for the betterment of equality. God bless.
I'm just saying
Amen!!
Bravo so well said!!! I agree
Tell the democrats that
Did her lawyer just offered her water out of the same bottle he just drank out of…yuck! Both defendant and her lawyer are out of order!
Time stamp?
He want that $$$$$$
I saw that too I was like wtf
@@kyliecakes92791:54
I think that was the last bit of freedom he was trying to tell her she will see lol I dont think they have water bottles in jail depending were she goes at nights she will be drinking toilet water. Maybe that was the moment he realize she is done.
I love this State's Attorney. She said, "She has the audacity to take the stand and blame everyone else" Priceless
in court when a person want to take the stand is because they believe there innocent! and they want to the truth to come out! attorneys frowned upon defendant to take the stand! because of cross examination! but in this case, it was not so! so it says a lot about this defendant! she might have gone over board in her assessment with this accident! but I have to believe that she had no ill intention to want to kill the guy! she just to try to stop him! the da's job is to make you look guilty at all cost! they are very heartless in there pursuit to win a case! that's how they become judges! and get a out standing winning record! they remind me of a doctor who does abortion! they don't feel anything for the baby while they are chopping that poor child! plus they like to lie a lot,, you know how? by adding more fake charges to you! to see if either the judge or jury will bite on it!
💯 I wholeheartedly “share” your sentiments. This very statement certainly left a lasting impression. Because this very observation, in itself, rather accurately describes Hannah Payne ENTIRE defense “strategy” during trial…
@@jrx2662 LMAO!!! Just simply SAY that you believe Hannah Payne was somehow “railroaded,” by the legal system WITHOUT actually saying it…🤣😂🤣
Entitlement
She's ok here but not too good, in closing arguments she shouldn't sound like she's still warming up or like she's fairly unfamiliar with the case but that's how she sounds through at least half of it with alot of pauses, it's not fluent and it makes it sound like she doesn't quite know what she's talking about...but it got the job done
When being above the law goes wrong, rest in peace, Kenneth🕊️
Indeed ❤
When white privilege goes wrong!
He definitely won't be hitting anybody and fleeing anymore. Funny the common denominator of people coming to this man's defense. You would be nowhere to be found if his skin was a different color..
@Icarus.19 This was a "when white privilege, goes wrong" moment. 😂🤣
@@Icarus.19 🤡🤡🤡
That defense attorney never stopped playing to the cameras, juru and judge. Head shaking, dirty looks, hand raising. He didnt help the defendant at all. Both are arrogant and entitled.
His behavior was bizarre throughout the entire trial. Almost like he was drunk
@@JordanDiddy haha exactly, like a stroppy teenager
That's probably why she didn't show emotion and was aggressive to the prosecutor
He was doing everything he could to distract those jurors as she was giving her closing argument,he needs to be disbarred!!
He was so arrogant acting with his smug faces he was making. He was chewing his nails too. You know the type. You all do. Lol
The defense attorney's facial expressions, body gestures, shaking his head no, etc.. as the State spoke should have been reprimanded by the Judge. Decorum and basic respect should be enforced.
All of us must learn from this horrible incident, "we must mind our business" and allow law enforcement do their job.
The prosecutor's closing was actually pretty thorough
The closing was good. Linda Dunakowski (sp) is supreme, of course. Check any day of the Ahmed Arbrey trial - a master class in logic, ethics, brilliance, and irrefutability. But, the closing this Assistant DA is delivering is right up there.
Juan martinez is the master
She had me at entitlement
She made is concise and explained the charges to people who may not understand complex legal issues. I give her a A for that. I sat on a jury for Malice Murder once. She explained it precisely how it was explained to my jury years ago.
@electriclioness4607
Oh yes, very perfectly thorough. She nailed every point. It's no wonder why the jury unanimously agreed to vote guilty on all counts.
This was a great closing argument. Good job.
Imagine what she'll do if she had a Badge
WTF. does that mean? just like every person is not a bad apple just like every cop is not bad. gtfoohwts
Facts
@@barrywallace4415wooosh 🤦♂️
Pretty much what she did I imagine!
@@barrywallace4415an high IQ has never been your strong suit.
Is that lawyer on something? Does he not realize he is on TV?!!
How unprofessional is he making faces and rolling his eyes so disrespectful
@@jackiemcfarlane5320 It’s incredible how he looks. Have you ever seen napoleon dynamite? The scene where Napolean was dancing in the talent show, and Summers bf was making all those faces in the crowd. Haha. If you haven’t seen it, it is JUST LIKE THIS GUYS FACE!
I bet he does just so people believe him but didn't work
@@solomoon3083LOL!! You took me out with that flashback!!! Sometimes the comments restore my faith in humanity. Many thanks!!!😂😂😂
@@James_Doyle83 yes! Trying to sway the jury with his micro expressions! And it did NOT WORK!
"She should've minded her own business," said the prosecutor. BAM!
The attorney spent his time making faces and dozing off during the prosecutor's closing.
We dont know Hannah, but I bet she is a bully and has a bad temper.
She is out of her mind to think she could chase someone down and shoot them.
Justice was served.
I think she’s angry at the world…was never popular or accepted. There’s a reason she wanted to get a gun….
This attorney was incredible!!!
And the defense attorney making faces rolling his eyes should have been reprimanded
Absolutely terrible!
This prosecutor is the most thoroughly prepared person in this trial. Shevl schooled the pretender acting as defense council. Bravo!
Rebuttal closings is this prosecutor's calling. You go, girl. Lock her up!
'When trouble is running away from you as fast as it can, and you decide to chase down that trouble and make it part of your life."
She thought she was entitled to take the law in her own hands
Hannah Payne is done. Jury saw the video and it must have been a no brainer. She was found Guilty on all counts. Took 2 hours for the jury to decide. GG
My heart aches for him and his family
At one time in the 90s I was behind a commercial vehicle that was swerving all over the road. Left the road in front of the hospital and took out a small tree. I pulled over at a business (this was before everyone had a cell phone) and called 911. I told them he was either drunk or had a medical problem. Gave 911 his tag numbers and the name and number of the business in the vehicle. At no time did it ever cross my mind to follow, detain or kill him. Did my duty as a witness and moved on.
Perfect! Good job.
Unlike Hannah, U got sense.
Great closing argument, she made everything very clear, there is no doubt she is so guilty and should get the max possible sentence, he should not be dead she had no right to kill him.
Good closing, 'the audacity to come here, take the stand, and blame everyone else'
I once herd a story of a 105 y/o man crediting his longevity to minding his own business. Payne could learn some things from him.
I think the prosecutor did a good job explaining the facts of the matter clearly and in terms that the jury can understand and use in applying justice for this case and they did a fine job at that as well.
Indeed. She's really good.
It's not only minding her own business BUT disregarding the instructions from 911 dispatchers. I'm sure dispatchers are trained by materials that are based OFF EXPERIENCE and LAWS. For her to proceed anyway without complying just proves her level of INTENT. She was adamant that she was going to get him no matter what, so no "fear for her life". Even her ability to drive RECKLESSLY demonstrates that she cared little for anyone's life, while trying to stop the deceased. Most likely, her actions were influenced by the fact that she was "carrying".
Omg....I want to shout out....has anyone heard of "fight or flight"
If indeed that poor man grabbed her, he was desperately trying to get medical help. Bless this man
Yeah, it’s sad to think his life ended the way it did. Glad the jury put her right where she belonged. Still surprised she was initally given bond.
She wanted to be a police officer, she wanted to act like a rogue cop, no boundaries.... she can explain that to the inmates too as I am sure someone has watched this trial and will see her on the inside.
This case was insanely crazy😮 Acting out the role of a police officer with NO credentials. Just a citizen with the possession of a gun.😮
The judge should have reprimanded the defence counsel. His reactions were uncalled for, unprofessional and not good courtroom decorum. Fortunately, it didn’t hold any sway with the jury. In fact the eye rolls, head shakes and shrugs probably did the opposite. If I was on the jury I would be disgusted by him.
The prosecution didn’t object. The. The judge could have addressed it. It worked in the State’s favor in my view, so they let him.
Yes, the defense lawyer was unprofessional during closing. He should be reprimanded for that 😮😮😮
@@vucat don’t think the prosecution really looked at the defence lawyer much… most of it was while her back was turned. But I agree it worked in the prosecutions favour. Still think the judge should have a word afterwards.
As soon as I seen the PowerPoint presentation I knew she wasn’t playing on the closing 😅💯‼️
Prosecution was thorough. Great job.
Her lawyer offered her some of the water he just drunk from!... 😂🤣😂 Now that's nasty.
I thought this was a great closing argument!
The audacity is right. To tell a man in his vehicle what to do after you approached with a weapon but have no authority. However, she couldn't hear the 911 operator/law enforcement or authority telling her not to chase this man.
The defense lawyer is so unprofessionalsional, his mannerism is appalling. She is being judged by her actions and your representation sir😒
Very much. He is now forever etched in stone with this behavior.
That's exactly what I was thinking, about his mannerisms
He reminded me of a drunk uncle
Yes!!💯
In her mind she thought she was going to get interviewed for stopping a vigilante driver when she's the vigilante. Now i bet she knows better
She couldn't even look at him on the screen. Just put her head down. What a coward. And her lawyer is just as much a joke. So unprofessional
Can you imagine if this woman had actually become a cop? The harm she would have caused to people so she could feel powerful.... fortunately her lack of self control extended to her love for food or she may have passed the academy.
Her lawyer's body language and facial expression's said it all! He don't care either.
She don’t either she tryna look mad she thought bc she was white that she would get a pass no sir lock her ass up 😂
He tried to offer her his water he been sipping on like they been knowing each other lol
thats so nasty lol
It seems like her and her attorney are very familiar with each other
Well they are. This is going to be a reason down the line for her for a possible reason for new trial bad legal counsel.
She has 4 years to get rid of him. His antics kept delaying her trial.
Fantastic prosecuting attorney. Well done.
She was out to kill, and no one and nothing was going to stand in her way! Guilty as charged! Good job, Mdm prosecutor 💪💪👏👏👏👏 RIP Mr. Herring 💔💔💔💔😭😭😭😭😭
I hope this reminds us ALL to “mind our business!”
Beginning closing arguments with the defendents own words is priceless
She really thought she was the police for real😳😳😳😳😳😳
Some of these people think that they have the right to coral blk people as if it's 1806.
@@lemonaid13😂😂😂😂😂rascist!!
Oh she knew she wasn’t a cop, alright. She thought she had authority over black people.
They finna make a example outta ha ass too 😂😂 justice for that man she killed ❗️
Amazing well spoken Lady , a Concise closing does everything so much easier.
Rest in Peace Mr. Hering🎍🪻🍃
Hannah otw to the slammah. RIP Kenneth Herring, this was all senseless & avoidable.
Most closing arguments are 2-3 hours long, sometimes going into the next day. She only took 33 minutes, wow! This is the most methodical and eeffective closing argument ive heard from a prosecutor. I give this a solid 9. Only point i take away is her not putting the jurors in the victim's shoes to add that empathetic viewpoint. But based on evidence, she did her thing, man.
She didn't need to because she was going off of facts. If she had used emotion during closing arguments the jury may not have found her guilty on all counts.
@@toniciahubbard9126 why do you assume I mean to “replace” facts with emotions when I praised her using facts. I said ADD emotion. My comment was literally praise. Are you upset a stranger online didn’t give her a perfect 10?
@@johnrhynes13you took her comment the wrong way, she was only kindly responding to your opinion with her opinion lol
@@kilaa3417 her opinion misrepresented what I said if she responds saying that she would’ve been wrong to use emotions over facts when my comment didn’t exclude facts.
@@johnrhynes13 that's fine, I'm not disagreeing with your point. But there was no anger or upset in her comment, i.e your response was a bit strange.
Love how the prosecute broke down the case in simple facts. Explained all the charges, had evidence to back it up etc. This man lost his life in a tragic way. Pray justice gets served.
She is amazing!!!
That defense lawyer and defendant made a good team... both smug, defensive, and unrepentant.
amazing closing argument from prosecutor
so easy to understand each of the charges for me since English is not my first language
That defense attorney's theatric facial expressions during the States closing argument are grounds for contempt of court.
And the State rest their case👏 Outstanding job - Justice will be served 🤔
I love the DA’s hairstyle, she sure looks beautiful and sharp
Right before he offered some of his water he moved the tissue box towards her trying to make it seem like she was crying it’s all an act I hope they make an example out of her!!
Hannah Payne got life in prison. 30 years is a life term in Georga. Those who committed serious violent felonies on or after July 1, 2006, must serve 30 years before being eligible for parole. Life in prison is mandatory for murder in Georgia. She got 30 years plus 13 years. That is 43 years. She will be eligible for parole when she is 68 if she does the 30 + 8+ 5.
Unfortunately the victim will never be able to tell his side of the story.... Always pay attention to 911 calls in all cases... It can solve a case!
Well Done!!!
Funny how her Lawyer and her face turned red with her opening statements. Well said, this woman did feel entitled to do what she did.
A+ closing argument from prosecution!
Now held acting like he sleepy that guy ain't right I don't even want call him a lawyer
Exactly I could not have said it better
That’s so she can get a new trial because he knows he lost her case! 😡
It's unusual to see a lawyer sharing water with their client in court…what a creeper,🤮 lol
The sad part is she had no remorse whatsoever. She tried really hard to CRY. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢that's funny not a tear in site. Girl 🛑!
Very clear smart and direct closing 🙏🏼
Her attorney was so unprofessional.
Y’all noticed @ 1:50 her attorney sitting by her drinker out of his water then had the nasty gall to try to hand it over to her?
That defense attorney needs to be called out for his horrible antics during that trial,the face gestures,non stop moving and other attention grabbing antics were a clear distraction tactic aimed at the jurors,did anyone see him shaking his head yes at the jurors when the Prosecuting attorney said Mr Herring had no escape route once Hannah blocked his truck with her Jeep, it's as tho he was telling the jurors ,yes he did with that head shake.... I've never seen an Attorney act so blatantly disrespectful in court!!
Move over Ben Crump! 'NEW PROSECUTOR IN TOWN " CONGRATULATIONS 👏 you did a marvelous JOB!
Yes!
Ben Crump won’t be moving over for nobody! This prosecutor is good in her own right! Stop dividing us!
A true Queen educated the public on the law! If you go in front of her, you're going to be convicted and sent to prison! I bet her conviction rate is 99% or higher.
lol
I hope she never sees the light of day ever. Straight to jail.
Its 2023. Everyone knows you dont involve yourself in a vehicle pursuit as YOU could also be the one to cause an accident amd also be charged.
Shes guilty af. Glad shes getting prison time.
The prosecution did a great job!!
Guilty on all 8 charges! Verdict just read
YES
What?! YES!!!
Hallelujah!
DANG!! I wanted to be surprised!
🤷🏾♀️🤷🏾♀️🤷🏾♀️
Did she really think the jury would believe her "self defense" claim? I mean how does she explain all the crap she caused that day? And it's crazy because I think she truly believes in her head that she didn't do anything wrong! It's like the one witness said, that after she shot him she looked all proud like she did something right. She's been playing the victim! She has some nerve acting like she was in fear for HER life! But she definitely thought she had a chance at trial to make it seem that way. And for her to think she was gonna win is just preposterous! The jury would never be able to overlook ALL the bad decisions she made that day. And what's ABSOLUTELY crazy about it all.... It wasn't even an accident she was involved in! She seriously acted like a road rager who was mad because THEY were in an accident! That's seriously how she acted towards him! I mean that's pretty much what she was.... A road rager! And all over NOTHING that had to do with her! But she turned it into HER problem.... How ludicrous. Look where it got her! And a poor guy killed. So unnecessary.... So senseless...
One word “Stupid” it’s ok to say it , that’s what she was/is. 😊
Great job on closing!
This Prosecutor called ot RIGHT when she used the term" ENTITLEMENT" Congratulations for a job WELL done Madame Prosecutor.
Imagine the uncalled for shootings this woman would be in if her dream of becoming a police officer had come through.
Prosecutor did amazing
Opening and closing statements on point🎯
Guilty as charged. Thank you justice system
He’s playing in the background and the defendant is looking at him like “this is my life!!” Smh
I can’t believe that she was sober and did something like that. You have to be really messed up in the head to make such decisions.
You have to be really entitled in her view like the prosecutor said. That was a straight sense of entitlement.
@@vucatThat's it!
Truth
Her lawyers is disgusting acts just like miss Karen sitting g there knowing she's screwed
I feel bad that I thought this attorney wouldn't do a good job during closings! She was the BOSS!!
Respectfully I ask , why you thought she wouldn’t do a good job?
I wonna know too, I didn't doubt her once @@bernardriggs2079
@@bernardriggs2079 because her cross examination of Hannah appeared weak to me. That's why.
One of the best and organized closing arguments I’ve seen.
This young lawyer is amazing, calm and professional.
Omg!! What is her defense attorney doing ! I have literally never seen this before. Shaking his head?making faces?
Why the lawyer took a sip of water then try to offer his defendant water 💧?? 🤣 why drink it form his mouth ?? 😂
The defense attorney fell asleep multiple times. He was comfortable because he knew his client was guilty. His prior theatrics were juvenile.
He was in it for the money he knew she was gonna be guilty. It’s all a business. I don’t think he was can cared enough for this case 😂😂 cause he knew the defendant was guilty
Her lawyer is sitting over there with a smug look on his face and making all these weird Expressions give me a break