So my idea for silent salt cookie is that he silenced anyone who dared even speak about it, especially those who already have evidence against him, and I do imagine him being silent and acts almost hostile to white lily, thinking that she's unworthy of the soul jam, and white lily would have a mental breakdown similar to pure vanilla cookie in the original, and I do imagine silent salt to be very deadly and dangerous, along with being very serious despite not speaking a word.
I think he would be the silent type even since he may have been the last to fall BUT in this AU you can be right since if Silent came out first he could even have his different outfit (like instead of being a knight he could have the outfit of a king) and this could also apply to Shadow Milk (I think he could be more serious and not so like a court jester).
I found this AU very interesting, and I don't know if you can think like me but you could elevate this idea of SWAP by doing this with everyone. What I thought was: Change who lost the kingdom in Dark Flour War (in this case instead of being Golden Cheese it could be Dark Cacao losing the kingdom and need to create a MATRIX to save his kingdom) and also who would lose the son would not be Cacao but HollyBerry since the corrupted sword could be taken to her kingdom and when Pitaya invaded the kingdom HollyBerry's son or granddaughter could have used it and ended up being banned for being on the bad side. And who would probably get on the heroes first without being Silent Salt could be Eternal Sugar instead of Mystic Flour. For now, I could only think of that.
So we would no longer have my mentally unstable son so early 😞 welp, small price to pay cuz this is great!!! I loved the little art of him in the coffin and it would justify PV getting a costume to go along with white Lily’s
@Krayzeeart Don’t worry, he still interacts with wind archer, so we’d still see him semi-early. I’m glad PV already has a fairy costume because I did NOT want to try to make him one, my hands hurt just thinking about it.
In my AU (the one thats like this) Shadow Milk is still the first one we meet, but when he tries to talk to Pure Vanilla he ends up being confused as to why hes talking to White Lily instead Omg I just realized I forgot to mention, but When White Lily took over as the ruler of the Vanilla kingdom she also took his souljam Also new subscriber!!!!! :D
@@XFromBfbisAwesome Oh boy do I have changes for if the gingerbrave team swapped. Gingerbrave -> Gingerbright Strawberry -> Skater Wizard -> Alchemist Chili Pepper -> Rye Custard III -> Pancake
@Athena_wisdom_godness nope, PV is still the simp. It actually translates into how Tainted Deity cookie interacts with her. Think of the song “meant to be yours” from heathers the musical and you’ve pretty much hit the mark.
@ Beast Yeast ep 1 is actually when they first meet. So I wouldn’t say so, but anyone could always use the love at first sight trope if they wanted, I wouldn’t stop them. Or feelings could develop during episode 1, honestly haven’t thought about it-
You inspired me to share all of my OC's, stories, AU's and angst's of cookie run OC's (I was doing them for 3 years)
So my idea for silent salt cookie is that he silenced anyone who dared even speak about it, especially those who already have evidence against him, and I do imagine him being silent and acts almost hostile to white lily, thinking that she's unworthy of the soul jam, and white lily would have a mental breakdown similar to pure vanilla cookie in the original, and I do imagine silent salt to be very deadly and dangerous, along with being very serious despite not speaking a word.
@@nikkigamer16 omg that’s a great idea!!! I really hope Silent Salt cookie is like that in his Beast Yeast episode when it comes out!
I think he would be the silent type even since he may have been the last to fall BUT in this AU you can be right since if Silent came out first he could even have his different outfit (like instead of being a knight he could have the outfit of a king) and this could also apply to Shadow Milk (I think he could be more serious and not so like a court jester).
i feel like silent salt wouldn't be based on actual silence, but the concept of death.
@@slimeyscratch really, like a grim reaper?
@@nikkigamer16maybe that guy who want everything DEAD to have silence in his life
I still find it hilarious that Lily, the SWEETEST and shyest of the Ancients, shares a Soul Jam with the most EDGY looking of the Beasts-
I found this AU very interesting, and I don't know if you can think like me but you could elevate this idea of SWAP by doing this with everyone. What I thought was:
Change who lost the kingdom in Dark Flour War (in this case instead of being Golden Cheese it could be Dark Cacao losing the kingdom and need to create a MATRIX to save his kingdom) and also who would lose the son would not be Cacao but HollyBerry since the corrupted sword could be taken to her kingdom and when Pitaya invaded the kingdom HollyBerry's son or granddaughter could have used it and ended up being banned for being on the bad side. And who would probably get on the heroes first without being Silent Salt could be Eternal Sugar instead of Mystic Flour.
For now, I could only think of that.
Also Instead Of Burning Spice It Will Be Mystic Flour Instead
I really like the au cause i had something similar in mind and also you deserved more recognition and subs
@@istarveforangst OMG thank you so much!!!!
Girl I was waiting for someone to finally make this au, I really happy I found your channel and keep up the good work and don't give up
@Levvinar I won’t! I’m glad you like it!
So we would no longer have my mentally unstable son so early 😞 welp, small price to pay cuz this is great!!! I loved the little art of him in the coffin and it would justify PV getting a costume to go along with white Lily’s
@Krayzeeart Don’t worry, he still interacts with wind archer, so we’d still see him semi-early. I’m glad PV already has a fairy costume because I did NOT want to try to make him one, my hands hurt just thinking about it.
@ lol, thank goodness cuz wind archer story is my fav Shadow Milk moments!!
@ same lol
In my AU (the one thats like this) Shadow Milk is still the first one we meet, but when he tries to talk to Pure Vanilla he ends up being confused as to why hes talking to White Lily instead
Omg I just realized I forgot to mention, but When White Lily took over as the ruler of the Vanilla kingdom she also took his souljam
Also new subscriber!!!!! :D
Wouldn't she be a little TOO POWERFUL for having two soul jams? Or would she only have two but couldn't use Pure Vanilla's?
@YKO-HYKRUZ She wouldn't really be able to use Pure Vanilla's but she can only use it for healing magic 👍
I'm so interested in seeing more of this! :D
I'm obsessed
If Gingerbrave was swapped in the swap au, would he be swapped with strawberry cookie or wizard cookie?
@@XFromBfbisAwesome Oh boy do I have changes for if the gingerbrave team swapped.
Gingerbrave -> Gingerbright
Strawberry -> Skater
Wizard -> Alchemist
Chili Pepper -> Rye
Custard III -> Pancake
@Golden_Egg_Cookie not me forgetting about the ovenbreak cookies 💀
@Golden_Egg_Cookie Wait- If Pancake takes Custard's role, DOES THAT MEAN PANCAKE AND LILY ARE RELATED-
@@SerialDesignationO not necessarily
YAAAAAY PART TWO IS HERE (AND MY HUSBAND GOT OUT YAYAYYAYAYYAYAYA)
@@tadeomartinezdiaz8607 Hoorah!!!
What about Choco Werehound Brute? :3 (he my favorite :3)
@@RodgerRaccoon he’s pretty much himself, but with a mild redesign
So is white lily simp for pv in this au?
@Athena_wisdom_godness nope, PV is still the simp. It actually translates into how Tainted Deity cookie interacts with her. Think of the song “meant to be yours” from heathers the musical and you’ve pretty much hit the mark.
@Golden_Egg_Cookieokay
@Golden_Egg_Cookieso does elder fearie still like white lily?
@ Beast Yeast ep 1 is actually when they first meet. So I wouldn’t say so, but anyone could always use the love at first sight trope if they wanted, I wouldn’t stop them.
Or feelings could develop during episode 1, honestly haven’t thought about it-
@Golden_Egg_Cookiewould be funny if elder faerie got feelings for pv too. New sub i guess .