There was no hope. Warsaw Ghetto Uprising 19th April 1943
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- "There was no hope" is an educational film about Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. It is produced by the POLIN Museum of the History of Polish Jews within the frame of the Jewish Cultural Heritage program.
"There was no hope" had its premiere on 19th April 2016 as a part The Daffodils social and educational campaign.
Supported from the Norway and EEA Grants by Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway.
***
Subscribe to our channel: / muzeumpolin_official
Visit POLIN Museum: www.polin.pl/en
Our Facebook profile: / polinmuseum
Check out POLIN Museum’s other channels:
Virtual Shtetl (history and culture of the Polish Jews): sztetl.org.pl/
Polish Righteous (stories of Polish Righteous): sprawiedliwi.o...
As long as you have breath... there is hope!!!!!
NEVER GIVE UP!
Unfortunately, this wasn't a battle to save themselves. They had no hope and knew they could not win. They fought so they could choose their time of death and as a last act of defiance against the Germans.
The British and Americans had turned their backs on the Jews. What kind of hope were they supposed to have
My Heart Breaks for these brave Jew/Pole Gladiators who have defined a generation for defiance against oppression from overwhelming state oppression against brave people. God bless the Pole supporters as well. They flew both pole and Jewish Flags during their epic battle for freedom.
th-cam.com/video/tZKQNGcT3Qg/w-d-xo.html
Alfred Lawrence • Mine does too I love the scenes when it shows the nazi scum being blown up and burned love those parts. GOD BLESS THOSE BRAVE MEN AND WOMEN.
As an American with strong Polish ancestry this saddens me deeply. My Great-Grandfather was a polish soldier early in the war. After Poland fell he fled to Norway, Fought in the Free Polish Army in North Africa, Sicily, Italy, Normandy, France, Rhine, Germany. He was wounded six times. Most of his family died from Nazi brutality. After the war he did not return to Poland because the USSR installed a puppet government. For years he lived in USA until 2004 when he visited Poland for the first time sense 1939. I was with him during that trip. He moved back to Poland in 2006 and in 2011 he died and was buried in his native country of Poland. So i may identify as an American but I am also deeply Polish.
My Polish-Jewish grandmother migrated (as a child) from Poland to The Netherlands, as her father worked for a shipping company in the mid 1920's. We lost all our relatives who lived in Poland, but my grandparents (and great grandparents) survived the war because they went on to the Dutch East Indies in 1931. My mother was actually born in a Japanese concentration camp but the whole family survived. After the war/Indonesian independence they went to Suriname and the Antilles for a while and eventually settling in Rotterdam. I can relate, Dominic Innecken, and I am pretty proud of my Polish-Jewish roots.
@Nir Hakimian Why Jews had escaped EVERY European country to Poland if there was so strong antisemitism in Poland? You high or what? Learn from history books, not from anti polish propaganda. It doesn't make any sense, does it?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsions_and_exoduses_of_Jews
@The Slavic World of Weles from Navia The film concerns the Polish Citizens of Judaic religion. You surely know, that Jews were part of Poland, and that Polish culture was, in part, Jewish !
@The Slavic World of Weles from Navia Of course, but : there were through the centuries mixied families, marriages, etc
@@halinamoulin6182 Only a jewish revisionist could write such nonsense. Jews were hated in Poland for centuries and used by kings as moneylenders which the jews gladly did and for hundreds of years they took advantage of the poor peasantry and serfs in Poland. Throughout history when given the opportunity they stabbed Poland in the back. People who are Polish living in Poland who take a DNA test almost never have jewish ancestry.
Very, very interesting although extremely upsetting. Those poor people, I can't begin to imagine how frightened they were. So brave.
I can't even imagine having their courage. Bless their souls.
+BytomGirl, nice to see that you are still on youtube... We had contacts on my old channel, which i closed 3 years ago. Please, see my video about Janina Dawidowicz in Warsaw ghetto. This tv-film in 8 parts made in Germany and probably unknown in other countries. Poczytaj moj reply do ciebie w twoim innym komentarze. Unfortunately, video is in german, i hadn't time to translate it to english and now is too late, cuz YT's annotations-function has gone away
Hi Nora, nice to see you. Too bad there is no translation, without it it's hard to know what is happening in the film. Many functions went away unfortunately :(
Leon Uris "Mila 18", likely the finest novel ever written on the Warsaw Ghetto and Uprising. Incredible but tragic story of human degradation and valiant struggle to survive.
@russell watking I read that book back in high school, but wasn't really mature enough to really appreciate it. Then a few years ago, I reread it and was blown away. There are scenes in it that left me in tears.
They fought bravely to the end and some are still fighting today. I want to bless them all!
Well Polish Jews in Warsaw ghetto fought German regular army, Russian Jews in Palestine shot to Arab teenagers and women.
@@7210690 They fought the SS.
@@nattygsbord They were SS. Russian SS.
My heroes are the Jewish resistance fighters of WWII.
Janusz Korczak was the only person who had free ticket out of the Warsaw. He declined and was gassed in Treblinka along with his orphanage.
NEVER FORGET! NEVER AGAIN!
Naprawde to sie w glowie nie miesci jak to ludzie przetwali ten brutalny okres. It truly baffles the mind how these people survived those brutal times.
Right now same happening in Gaza, so your words mean nothing
They fought as heroes in a last stand without any possibilty of reinforcements. But some Brave young polish men helped and brought limited arms. For the best history please read the online Yale papers.
I wont forget you people... you were the hero of Poland
A very good film ! Also, it is so tragic, because of the hitler's "endlosung", where the polish-jewish community disappeared almost completely...And it was the end of this diverse and rich history through the 8 centuries of common life.
The act of resistance against the evil and the fight against horrifying injustice, itself defines victory.
Germany, not the Nazis because there was no Naziland, will never deserve forgiveness, never, never.
It is impossible to forgive such calculated evil of this magnitude. Even God cannot provide atonement.
Wow what a story...
I'm so amazed at what these survivors have been through... bless their souls...
Goosebumps !!! NEVER FORGET !!! NEVER AGAIN !!! 😢😢😢😢😢💜✡💜✡💜
There are many who fought back...let them be remembered
Well done ! Great video
Remember, and never forget.
These brave men and women represents the polish proud
I love your style, kept my full attention throughout the whole video:)
This documentary infuriates me. But then I saw another documentary on the bombing of Hamburg and I felt much much better.
I felt the same way when I saw a documentary about Dresden.
Newly born babies had so much responsability for what the reich did in Poland. And burning their mothers to death in thousand degrees hot flames and boiling asphalt on the streets is not uncivilized at all
🙄
barbecue
incredible bravery in the face of humanities worst atrocities. we will honor their memory forever. thank you for this documentary.
Proud to be Pole, we helped jews so much despite of fact we suffered terror from germans at that time
There sadly was as was to be expected in this horrendous war In all the nazi occupied countries none jews who helped us and others who betrayed us to the nazis or even murdered us themselves.That happened from Poles in Poland and with all nationalities of none jews across nazi europe.
You are heroes ! Blessings
chwala poleglym bohaterom obrony getta
Never Forget… NEVER AGAIN. BUT SHOULD HISTORY REPEAT … WE WILL FIGHT!!!
Thanks for the graphics. It allows freedom to think optically instead of in audio. EDit: It was the same in the days of Lot: People were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building.
Excellent...i have seen many Holocaust videos...this of the historic Warsaw Ghetto uprising..i couldnt take eyes away.. shalom, and thank tou so much who perhaps saved so many, and survivors... never forget.
Thanks for this video
This is so sad… I read many of the comments saying”never again” And I think at least humanity learned from that episode Then I ask myself are there any groups of people being identified by ethnicity and being forced into ghettos surrounded by walls and without freedom of movement and restrained by military force with ‘no hope’ and i think ….. no …. Anyone who witnessed this would never allow that to happen again ……….. then I look to the west ba nk and ghaza and think …. Oh maybe we would let it happen again after all ……… but how do we change peoples behaviour?……. I guess in another 50 years I’ll be watching a historical video about it ..
I'm SHOCKED that your comment has survived this long. Thank you for speaking the truth.
These people are true heroes Their bravery is beyond comprehension .The Polish nation suffered terribly under German occupation .Rest in Peace Heroes !!!!!
Interesting documentary. If you think the subtitles go a little bit too fast, than try slowing it down to 75%...
hold obroncom ghetta
Liberation of warsaw was two long years away still...
wyzwolenia ? co za brednie
@@joteres4583you're right. I've learned a lot since 4 years ago when I wrote that comment. Poland was never liberated.
LONG LIVE POLAND
The animations really help with the continuity of the presentation. Not sure why the one lead character has to look like the offspring of Simon Bar Sinister though.
The guy hitting the old lady with the whip,👺👺👺
Marek Edelman= the absolute hero, in the real sense of the word
You are right. Unfortunately he was not treated like one. I admire him.
@@isabellakerr2966 He was greatly esteemed, woked as doctor after the war.
My grandfather survived the Warsaw Ghetto uprising. Later he survived the Nuremburg trials and lived to an old age in Argentina.
Dark
I think the hope came in just striking back
The Polish people hated the Jews. Many of the survivors talk about how they treated them. Heartbreaking.
Poland saved the most Jews during ww2
False statement! Polish people were considered by natzis as subhuman and they were murdered, tortured by the millions. Many died in concentration camps. Please educate yourself. It's embarrassing.
@@mona-qy9kf reread history. The Jews didn’t want to return to Poland because of the hate towards them. I’m sure it wasn’t all of them.
Pomoc Polaków NIE pominięta w dziesiatku innych filmow . One sa honorowane tez w Yad-Vashem - Centrum Badań nad Zagładą Żydów.
+
Dobry materiał.
Bardzo...
Pomoc Polaków standardowo pominięta.
To nie jest program o Polakach, ta pomoc jest wspomniana w wielu innych filmach. Ten jest na temat walki Zydow samym getcie, nie o tym kto im pomagal. Pomijasz filmy takie jak ZOO Keeper's Wife czy Irena Sandler, I wielu innych sie wspominalo ale wy wlasnie to pomijacie. Zawsze we wszystkim chcecie siebie widziec I zeby sie wam w pas klaniac ale oni pomagali ratowac Zydow z getta, nie walczyli w powstaniu w getcie. Zydzi byli sami.
Dziekje Nora.
Jaka pomoc? Członków ONR w donoszeniu na Żydów do Gestapo?
@@kazikowski1976 Brednia.
„W połowie kwietnia o 4 rano Niemcy przystąpili do likwidacji getta warszawskiego. Zamknęli resztki Żydów kordonem policji, wjechali do środka czołgami i samochodami pancernymi i prowadzą swe dzieło niszczycielskie. Od tego czasu walka trwa. Wybuchy bomb, strzały, pożary trwają dziań i noc. Dokonuje się największa zbrodnia w dziejach ludzkości. Wiemy, że pomagacie umęczonym Żydom jak możecie. Dziękuję Wam rodacy w imieniu własnym i rządu. Proszę Was o udzielenie im wszelkiej pomocy w imieniu własnym i rządu. Proszę Was o udzielenie im wszelkiej pomocy, a równocześnie tępienie tego strasznego okrucieństwa.” - Władysław Sikorski 5 maja 1943 roku w BBC.
Polski ruch oporu dostarczał Żydom w gettach żywność i broń. Okręg warszawski AK zaopatrzył powstańców w 60 pistoletów z dwoma magazynkami każdy oraz amunicją, 600 granatów ręcznych, 1 RKM, 1 pistolet maszynowy, oraz około 165 kg materiałów wybuchowych. Korpus Bezpieczeństwa powiązany z AK dostarczył 15 karabinów maszynowych, 20 pistoletów maszynowych, ponad 40 karabinów i 170 pistoletów, 1000 granatów oraz amunicję. Kedyw dokonał kilkunastu zbrojnych akcji na kordon otaczający getto ("Akcja Getto").
A skąd masz dane dotyczące ONRu to nie wiem. Chyba tylko z uprzedzeń.
@@jak00bspyr72 co do ONRu to informacje są z tego samego źródła z którego ty wziąłeś cytowaną odezwę Sikorskiego czyli z polskiej Wikipedii. Polacy pomagali wielokrotnie żydom, lecz wielu także ich wydawało. ONR był (i nadal jest) organizacją antysemicką.
aina vaan ihmiset,eläimet kuka heistä puhuu,,ihmiset aiheuttaa kaiken pahan
ihan totta
Cue the song *"Uprising"* by Sabaton.
This song is about Polish uprising on Warsaw 1944 not that
Jak to jest ze w ciągu 8 lat ludzie nadal nie odrózniaja powstnia w gettcie od powstania Warszawskiego?
Bardzo dobrze zrobiony film
Standartowo? To nie jest program o Polakach, ta pomoc jest wspomniana w wielu innych filmach. Ten jest na temat walki Zydow w samym getcie, nie o tym kto im pomagal.
FEW CASES OF GENOCIDE :
JEDWABNO MASSACRE WIKIPEDIA
KIELCE MASSACRE WIKIPEDIA
I wonder how the rest of the world views the current state of the US's southern border. We are warehousing human beings in nightmarish conditions and the corporatists are getting paid per head.
I kinda feel like a frog in a slowly boiling pot of fascism and it sucks.
You must have the brain of a frog to make such an idiotic statement.
Don't compare the democratic State with a fascist Germany !
Are you really asking this question? If you are then you need to go back and read more books on the treatment of Jews by nazis.
Or actually watch this documentary.
You're a clown!
The people on southern border come here voluntarily.
This is Oberfranken.
, heute
Free gaza ghetto !
Because you waited to long. Should have started fighting immediately
They were disarmed first.
Need it in English, can't understand anything said
There are english captions, you can adjust the video speed if the captions are too fast
Personnes n'a aidé personnes comme d habitude tous les monde savait ils n ont rien dis c'est une horreur
Ik vind de taal helaas vreselijk om te horen. Met een engelse voise over had ik wel willen kijken.
600 000 Poláků Německu rabotaju
The rise of Rebecca.
I wish I can read as fast as you speak..
This is pretty old but if you were still interested you can alter the speed of the video, that will keep the captions on longer
Byla nadzieja tylko trzeba było się postawić , na pewno więcej lud,i by przeżyło
ale nie było wystarczającej ilości broni, zeby kontynuować walkę
What was assumed they had done to deserve this treatment ?.
Growing up as #millenial or younger
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Pan M.Ederman o sobie stworzyl legende ktora daleka jest od praedy.
7:03 Do walk ulicznych potrzebne są pistolety maszynowe. Pojedynczy nisko lecący myśliwiec-bombowiec Mosquito mógł zrzucić 200+ działek stenowych z amunicją w kanistrach ze spadochronem. Miał zasięg i prędkość, by unikać wrogich myśliwców.
Dokładne miejsce upuszczenia nie jest problemem. Wypatrujesz flary lub światła dochodzącego z dachu Problem polega na tym, aby dokładnie wiedzieć, kiedy. Nawet ŻOB i ZZW nie wiedziały dokładnie, kiedy w kwietniu SS wkroczą do getta. Przypuszczam, że jedynym sposobem na szybkie poinformowanie Londynu i powiedzenie "przyślij broń teraz" byłoby nadanie wcześniej zaaranżowanego zakodowanego sygnału, jeśli nadajnik w ogóle istniał w getcie, ale jestem prawie pewien, że na 65 000 ludzi ktoś miał wiedzę techniczną i umiejętności, aby go wyprodukować.
Wymagałoby to pewnego rodzaju uprzedniej współpracy z Londynem, aby dokładnie uzgodnić, jakie będzie słowo kod. To wymaga, aby ktoś, kto ma dostęp do "aryjskiej" części Warszawy, ewentualnie współpracował z Armią Krajową (AK) w celu przekazywania wiadomości. Myślę, że można było to zrobić. Ale z perspektywy czasu jest to łatwe.
Myślę, że można było to zrobić. Ale z perspektywy czasu jest to łatwe.
ł: widać że nie masz najmniejszego pojęcia o czym mówisz kolego , świat zachodni miał w dupie zydów
🇵🇱♥️🇵🇸
Lol sounds like Gaza
25.04.2024. Lzy.
Pourquoi ils ne sont pas partis 😭
Cynthia, even if allowed to go, where could they go? But purely academic question as they were not able to travel anywhere.
@@MaryJane-pt4sn what do you say ? Jews were *forcibly* imprisoned into Warsaw ghetto It was out of the question to go out, it was prohoboted to leave ghetto, it wld be punished with death immediately. There was check-point with armed SS-soldiers who were ready to *shoot* anyone trying to go out
ils seraient fusillés immédiatement s'ils tentaient de sortir sans autorisation. Il y avait des soldats allemands armés avec entrée. L'autorisation ne pouvait obtenir que très peu de Juifs qui étaient contraints au travail forcé en dehors du ghetto. Ils ont été convoyés avec des Allemands armés
@@MaryJane-pt4sn You are old retarded grammar fascist with *empty channel and empty brains* . If Nina's comment makes zero sense to you - its your fault. I see only type error in her comment. This is *Polish* channel
type error - prohibited
jos yksikään sotilas olisi lapseni,veisin niskasta kotiin
7:03 For street fighting you need submachine guns. A single low flying mosquito fighter bomber could have dropped 200+ sten guns with ammo in parachute retarded canisters. It had the range and it had the speed to evade enemy fighters. Precisely where to drop is not the problem. You watch for a flare or a flashing light coming from a roof top The problem is knowing exactly when. Even the ZOB and ZZW didn't know exactly when in April the SS were going to enter the ghetto. I suppose the only way of quickly informing London and saying "send the weapons now" would have been by transmitting a pre arranged coded signal, if a transmitter even existed in the ghetto but I'm fairly sure out of 65,000 people someone had the technical knowledge and ability to make one. It would require some kind of prior liaison with London to agree exactly what the code word would be. That requires someone with access to the 'aryan' part of Warsaw possibly to work with the home army (AK) to relay messages. I think it could have been done. But it's easy in hindsight.
Listen to what this man said at 7:30. The Polish govt in exile in London sent to the Jews in the ghetto 50 revolvers, and 4 kg of explosives. I wonder why ? Was it because they were NOT CATHOLICS. For naive readers in the US who don't know much about european politics. I'm surprised the the Poles in London didn't blame the Russians for this too, as they usually do. When a govt leaves it's people then it is not good to rule them. How many Poles outside the ghetto helped the jewish uprising ? Very few, and they were getting money for it. There were some exceptions. But generally they let them suffer. So when Poles don't care about their own citizens then they should SHUT UP ABOUT RUSSIANS NOT HELPING THEM IN 1944.
Actually Polish Army even tried to destroy the Ghetto wall's but they were caught and killed. I'll remind you that it's Russians who attacked Poland along with Nazi Germany.
@@vladimirlenin693 exactly
You should shut up . You offening my people who were dying helping them! What a lying snake!
@@dumnylach i said the truth about the Poles who were anti semites just as much as the Germans. The Polish people suffered a lot and one reason was due to their governments belief in false promises from Britain. That's the truth that many don't like.
@@a.p.3004 So you are puting poles and germans on the same level with antisemitism? Guess in which country was the death penalty for hiding jews and which nation saved them most..
J'ai beau tourner et retourner cette " question juive " dans ma tête, dans tous les sens, consulter toutes les documentations à ce sujet, je ne comprends pas cet acharnement et je pense en ma Foi chrétienne, humblement, que seule la Parole de Dieu pourrait enfin m'éclairer là-dessus. Ce à condition peut-être qu'à l'inverse de cette quête rationnelle j'ignore totalement au quotidien tous les rejetons de grimaces qui manifesteraient encore ces horreurs racistes quelles qu'elles soient ... Je n'ai donc pas, ou plus, de message ni autre conclusion personnelle là-dessus !
Je retiendrai seulement que le chargé de police des "quartiers réservés aux juifs" en système allemand s'appelait le " Burgmeister " : c'est en premier lieu celui-ci qui trahissait ses charges et fonctions légales en ce domaine d'Etat dans ces cas de "pogroms" ...
I only wished that from the begining the churches of Europe had been really Christian instead of what they turned out to be Churchianity the counterfeit of the devil.Jesus Mary Joseph the apostles disciples and all the first followers of Jesus were observant jews.
Armia Krajowa did not give weapons to the Jews because Poles are anti-Semitic... later the Poles also received the punishment...
If Poles were / are anti semitic why do you think Poles are the nation that saved biggest numbers of jews during ww2? Poland had more citizens decorated as Righteous among the nations than any other . Drop this ridicilous propaganda and seek facts . Poles did not provide weapons becouse they could not at that time and later on when Poles staged uprising they freed jews who fought side by side with Poles against Germans . Its easy to repeat bullshit , than to do simple reserch ...
you are a liar...an antisemitic brainless liar......
No brai no pain fool
Warrior Angel Fuck You !
Arek, you have some terms mixed up, Zionists are not leftist, the term just means they fight for Jews to have their own country and for it's independence, like Poles did for their country. And Zionists are anything but leftist, leftists hate Zionist so maybe you are a leftist yourself and have some respect here, don't call people what you don't want them to call you and I would gladly do it right towards you if I wanted to lower myself to your level.
The Polish did it to their own people.
Nazist Germans did it with the help of bad people from other nations (Polish, Jews, Ukrainians, Hungarians etc.) to be correct. Remember that 1/4 of Poland citizens died during the war. Polish people were poor and luted by Germans. Any help given to Jews was punished by death unlike any other country ocupied by Germans. Nevertheless Polish people were hiding Jews, many of them died becouse of it. I personalny knew one woman who helped Jews to servive the war. Your comment just antagonize people. Germans and Russians are always trying to antagonize nations of previous Polish-Lithuenian Comonwelth. But now Poland help the Ukrainians brothers to defeat new born naZist country. 🇵🇱🇮🇱🇺🇦. Do you help to fight against "Z" swastica?
@@pawegalla-milewski8950kiedy to NAZISTAMI ZE SWASTYKAMI OD ADOLFA SĄ UKRAIŃCY ! ! !
Ach mein gott , when all this did happened ?! ...lol
stupid comment. No respect for the victims.
Evil of this magnitude cannot possibly be forgiven, till eternity.
No God could possibly forgive this. Watch out - as they say: Karma's a bitch!
0:48 he looks so cute the guy with glassess probably died.. rip