ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ต.ค. 2024
- Scena tratta dal film "Whutering Heights" del 1992 con Juliette Binoche e Ralph Fiennes.
Catherine: «Nelly?»
Nelly: «Oh, Cathy! I thought you were Frances, risen from the dead.»
Catherine: «Nelly, will you keep a secret for me?»
Nelly: «Oh, is it worth keeping?»
Catherine: «Today, Edgar Linton asked me to marry him.»
Nelly: «Oh, well..»
Catherine: «How shouId I answer?»
Nelly: «Well, really, Miss Cathy, how shouId I know?»
Catherine: «I accepted him.»
Nelly: «Cathy...Do you Iove Mr. Edgar?»
Catherine: «Um, of course I do. Of course! I can't heIp it.»
Nelly: «Why do you Iove him, Cathy?»
Catherine: «Uh, because he's handsome and pIeasant to be with.»
Nelly: «Bad.»
Catherine: «Because, um... he's young and cheerfuI.»
Nelly: «Bad still.»
Catherine: «And because he'll be rich. And I shall be the greatest woman of the neighborhood.»
Nelly: «Cathy.. Is that what you really want? Well, marry Mr. Edgar then.Where's your obstacIe?»
Catherine: «Here. In my souI and in my heart, I'm convinced I'm wrong. And if my brother had not put Heathcliff so Iow, I shouIdn't have thought of it. It wouId degrade me to marry Heathcliff now. So he... he'll never know I Iove him. My great miseries in this world have been Heathcliff's miseries. And I watched and feIt each from the beginning. My Iove for Linton is like.. like foliage in the woods. Time will change it as winter changes the trees. I Iove Heathcliff. He's the... He's like the... eternaI rocks beneath. A... A source of literaI, visibIe delight... but necessary. Nelly... I am Heathcliff.»
Nelly: «Shh.. »
Catherine: «Why?»
Nelly: «It's Joseph and Heathcliff might be with him. In fact, I'm not sure he wasn't here earlier.»
Joseph: «Young deviI of a gypsy gets worse and worse. He's Ieft the gate open and took off across the moors.»
Catherine: «No.Go and Iook for him. Call him back.»
Joseph: «What??»
Catherine: «Now, go after him. Do you think he heard?»
Nelly: «I think he heard something.»
Catherine: «What? What did I say?»
Nelly: «I think he heard up untiI the bit where you said it wouId degrade you to marry him.»
Catherine: «Oh.. Heathcliff..»
Nelly: «Cathy!»
Catherine: «Heathcliff..»
Nelly: «PIease, come in, Miss Cathy..»
"'My great miseries in this world have been Heathcliff's miseries, and I watched and felt each from the beginning: my great thought in living is himself. If all else perished, and he remained, I should still continue to be; and if all else remained, and he were annihilated, the universe would turn to a mighty stranger: I should not seem a part of it.-My love for Linton is like the foliage in the woods: time will change it, I'm well aware, as winter changes the trees. My love for Heathcliff resembles the eternal rocks beneath: a source of little visible delight, but necessary. Nelly, I am Heathcliff! He's always, always in my mind: not as a pleasure, any more than I am always a pleasure to myself, but as my own being..."
I love this boo.
Her Cathy was not as wild as portrayed in the book....but she was the one with the most feeling when she talked about her love for Heathcliff..she acted that part deep from her soul...still makes me cry after watching so many times.
Not seen this version yet but when she describes her love for Heathcliff, it's utterly heartbreaking. The expression on her face.
Yes. Cathy was seduced by the glittering lifestyle of the Lintons, and ultimately it destroyed all of them. She married a man she did not really love...and her resulting unhappiness killed her. Heathcliff's heart was broken and all that was good in him died twice - once when she married Edgar, again when she died. Heathcliff took out his grief, his rage and his pain on the Lintons, all of whom suffered for that pain, including Cathy's daughter, his own son, Edgar and his sister. Even Hareton suffered for it.
What, I wonder, would the story have been like if she had never gone to Thrushcross Grange in the first place?
@@janesgems7 there would be no story if she hadn't ❤️
It's THE best version of this story. Popular opinion too.. not just my own.
This book changed my life. This version is my favourite adaptation of it.
This scene is a masterpiece. Juliette Binoche is perfection.
Wonderful , breathtakingly poignant. This is the best rendition in my opinion. She speaks from her very soul. I could watch this time and time again , like pressing a sweet painful ache. How little we change and such observations of the human heart remain timeless in their accuracy.
Beautifully said. Tragicly ethereal love like this is rare. I'm going to read it again.
@@jelegance7415 lol what ethereal love? She never loved him in first place. All she cared about is money and lavish lifestyle rather than being with him.
lmao
"Here in my heart... in my my soul... I'm convinced that I am wrong"
Spectacular. I have seen this scene done by many, but these two actors take it to another level This is my favorite version too. Dream casting
The way she touches her heart. "Here." That gesture alone was its own dialogue. God she owned this scene so damn hard. Makes grown men cry. ❤
From Darcy to Heathcliff, I thought they were fools. That love was something fictional, only found in worn pages of a book. That it was just made up to keep humans full of hope, that it was a lie. But all that changed since I met my Elizabeth Bennett... ❤️
YES ❤️❤️❤️❤️
from after??
@@jonathannolan8948 yessss❤️
Omg yess
Sai daí machokkkkkk
All credit to Emily...what incredible words she wrote in just this one scene alone. If I could be a fly on the wall during a moment in history it would be to witness the moment Emily or her sister Charlotte wrote such breathtaking lines to be delivered time and time again for hundreds of years. Each time just as touching. I would just scream and cheer her on, like, "YESSSS!!!! YOU NAILED IT !!!!!!!!!!! THATS IT!"
Once again have to comment; after about a year? Or so... that line delivery is amazing. She makes me tear up. You can feel the emotion in her voice and see it in her eyes. That’s true talent. It’s so natural. Timed with the music perfectly. Her face suddenly changes. “My love for Heathcliffe....”
Oh you said it perfectly! She takes my breath away.
@@kristinstrickland1038 ❤️
He's more myself that I am.Whatever our souls are made of...his and mine are the same.
Hi umm can you try to explain this quote to me in detail ? If possible because it's urgent
@@just-being-aryan It’s talking about being a twin flame type of love. If you look up twin flame it will explain it in greater detail.
Amazing how the lightning at the beginning makes Catherine look like a ghost, foreshadowing that she will haunt Heathcliff.
I had given up on any movie ever being faithful in heart, soul, and character to Emily Bronte's story, or of any filmmaker coming even close to my own imaginings of Cathy, Heathcliff, the moors, and the mood of the story - until I saw this version with Juliette and Ralph Fiennes. It met all my hopes and exceeded them, right down to the powerful, deeply haunting score. Kudos all around to everybody. It makes Merle Oberon's and Olivier's performances look like pale, Hollywoodized, polite nonsense. I now own the movie.
Have you seen the British TV version starring a young Tom Hardy as Heathcliff and his now real life wife as Cathy ? I think it's definetly one of the best
It's the best version. Ralph is absolutely mesmerizing as the tortured Heathcliff. The scene where he says haunt me. Oh my god. CHILLS!!!!
@@WimpyV3 Yes, it's a great version and the actors are all terrific...but Ralph Fiennes will always be the most memorable Heathcliff for me.
Not to mention the score.....the score for this movie was brilliant!
Juliette's finest moment in her roller-coaster interpretation of Cathy. This is what she does so well. She doesn't entirely convince me as Cathy due to the lack of wild capriciousness in the interpretation. But here she's all open soul, and very deep. She gives my favorite performance of this important part of the story.
the best version ever. Amazing cast and perfomances. Could anyone upload full movie ?
Painfully beautiful yet heart breaking
Lovely video, lovely film, passion story, lovely actors, great performaneces !!
Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!! :)
Really a very passionate story!!! :)
Thank you, Arlaune!
Buone Feste a te e famiglia! :)
캐시가 두사람에 대한 사랑을 비유로 들며 진솔하게 이야기하는 이 부분이 제일 인상깊었어요ㅜㅜㅎㅎ 브금도 최고였공...
The book was amazing! I love it so much, that my grandma got me a book with the complete works of Emily and Charlotte Bronte for my 18th birthday. Wuthering Heights is my all-time favorite novel and I have to say that this is my favorite version of the movie. "I love my murderer, but yours, how can I?" "I CANNOT live without my life! I CANNOT live without my soul!" 3
I keep tissues close for this scene... i understand marrying for the wrong reasons, but i'll forever dream of knowing love at such depth ... ~ sighs ....
It never gets old this...
My love for Linton is like the foliage in the woods: time will change it, I’m well aware, as winter changes the trees. My love for Heathcliff resembles the eternal rocks beneath: a source of little visible delight, but necessary. Nelly, I am Heathcliff!’
Oh my gosh, the sadness!
Aint seen all the other versions..but i LOVE this film.
obcessed years ago...???
mum was worried!! Me too...
I believe this a "TWINFLAME "story.
Years later..I understood it..
36+ full/twisted/corrupted life..
Then ONE soul .pathetic scenario 😖
.fucking wont leave me ..😢🤬🙄❤.
❤❤❤❤
The English Patient and the Canadian Nurse... :)
Priceless ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
Best version
Infiniment belle Juliette Binoche, belle Antigone , belle Cathy ,..............
Thanks for posting
This is is one of my fave scenes from my fave adaption :)
The other one I adore, is when heathcliff smashes the glass to get into Cathy´s coffin and breaks down
I love the Brontes too.Esp.Jane Eyre by Charlotte and Wuthering Heights by Emily.They both are my favourite novels.In my early teens i read Jane Eyre for the first time and in my early twenties Wuthering Heights and i think that they both share the same passion and wild romance of real,pure love and that is definately the reason we like them so much.
This is actually my favourite of the films of Wuthering Heights. So mant believe Heathcliff was the villain...but it was actually Cathy.
Classic Leo and Scorpio... Sigh
Omg yes I never thought Cathy was a Leo until now. And I agree, Heath is obviously a Scorpio.
Ahahahahaha 😅😅
French Cathy
She should have married Heathcliff, always thought so...SMH
She knew he was listening and let it go off her chest
Is nobody bothered by the fact that Juliette Binoche is french? It's pretty obvious in the way she speaks...
No.
Nora yes
Should we be? I think after years watching this she's still the best Cathy, accent never bothered me, however slight it is.
Believe me you arent missing anything 2009 is ok, thanks to Tom Hardy who did a decent job, but tbh the reason I couldnt enjoy it was because of Charlotte Riley
Too sweet in my opinion, this Cathy has much more fire Plus this scene is so much more heartfelt
This also captures the darkness of the book the best
Ralph Fiennes was outstanding in this
Hello from the future!
I completely agree!!
If only she noticed him sooner 😭😭😭
i am heathcliff >>> dam u cathy u killd hem alife
A algumas horas pensei em você , pude sentir sua presença, estou mal mais uma vez , porque tenho consciência do quanto errado tenho andado, sou seu pertenço a você , me perdoe por tudo que tenho feito de errado, esse mundo é chato de se viver , não vejo a hora de te reencontrar , sei que será breve , que não ficaremos eternamente juntos , mas será eu e você novamente, Deus nos proporcionará isso mais uma vez. Te amo , te amo te amo, não desista do nosso plano por favor. Tenho vergonha que descubram o quanto sofro até hoje, e isso me perturba, isso me tira sono , pq não tenho que me envergonhar disso, senti seu cheiro esses dias ,em segundos pude ver seu sorriso sumindo no seu rosto de dor de quando estava doente, isso me causa dor , amor quero deixar esse mundo mas jamais adiantaria as coisas para que isso acontecesse, você sabe, porque nossa história é uma história com final feliz independente do quanto vc sofreu antes de partir, amor pq você sumiu dos meus sonhos não me deixe sozinho não, escolhi aqui para falar de você, porque viver isso só pra mim é grande e pesado DEMAIS, hoje a noite será longa mas vai passar , alguns dias serão normais até que eu caia de novo nessa depressão que é viver longe de vc, fique com Deus e até breve.
😔💔
P.M.S
R.I.P
I know how she feels...
I cant understand man its ber quite-.-
😢
@lovetolovefairytales Sorry but I didn't see Charlotte Riley's performace.
@MademoiselleArlaune You should. It's amazing. It's in the 2009 version.
Ryuichi Sakamoto
Why they kept laughing! , it opposes the book where Nelly was mad at Catherine before this conversation
It's called nervous laughter.
La_Trolette in the book , Nelly was mad at Catherine and acted very strict and neutral , neither laughing nor giggling (it's not a nervous laugh ,)
It's obviously not the same Nelly. It's called an adaptation for a reason. Personally, I never cared for Nelly in the book but I liked her in this and in the 1939 version.
Another misinterpretation of the book's true villain. That old harridan Dean who falsely accuses Heathcliffe of murder. Lockwood's narration is there for a reason in the book.
Everybody has various opinions of the film and TV versions, the actors, the story itself, but there's one thing I can't remember anyone mentioning, but it's been my thought no matter which "Wuthering Heights" I've seen: that was one UGLY house!!! If I were Cathy, I'd marry Edgar just to get the hell out of that eyesore and live at lovely Thrush Cross Grange (in spite of its stupid name; makes "Peter Piper Picked..." roll right off your tongue.
Cathy needed to get over her obsession with Heathcliff. Edgar Linton was a decent honest guy, and she treated him like garbage. Edgar loved Cathy as she described her obsession for Heathcliff.
I think Charlotte Riley did this scene better. Not that Juliette didn't do good, she's just not the Catherine I pictured from the book; Charlotte's much closer to that.
Women: Friendzoning men since the 1800s.
Nonsense
i dont like this version, i like Hardy s version
I actually fucking despised this book. Its the worst peice of literature ive ever had the displeasure of laying my eyes on. Every single copy should be put on a space ship and launched into the sun