Timestamps 00:00 The video begins with Zab Badawi welcoming viewers to Nobel Minds from the Royal Palace in Stockholm. He introduces the Nobel laureates and mentions the presence of Crown Princess Victoria and Prince Daniel. Princess Victoria gives a brief welcome and talks about the significance of the library in the palace. The focus of the discussion is on the lack of women in top positions in science and social sciences, and the laureates share their thoughts on the matter. 03:31 The discussion continues with the laureates discussing the progress and challenges for women in their respective fields. They talk about the importance of role models and the need for more women in science and technology. They also discuss the stereotypes and societal attitudes that discourage girls from pursuing careers in STEM fields. The laureates express optimism about the future and the potential for change. 06:48 Claudia Golden, the economics laureate, discusses the reasons for gender inequality in the workplace. She highlights the disproportionate burden of childcare and eldercare that falls on women, leading to lower-paying and less demanding positions. She also mentions the longer time it takes for women to achieve tenure in academia. The discussion emphasizes the need for greater parity in work and pay. 10:23 The laureates discuss potential solutions to achieve gender equality in the workplace. They mention the importance of teamwork and support among colleagues, as well as the need for flexible work arrangements. They also discuss the impact of technology and AI on jobs, noting both the potential benefits and challenges for women in fields like computer science. 13:49 The discussion concludes with a question from the audience for Claudia Golden about her research and the Nobel Prize. She shares that receiving the award was unexpected but meaningful, as it validated the work of many people. The video ends by highlighting the Nobel Prize in medicine or physiology, which recognized the groundbreaking work of Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman in developing mRNA vaccines. 17:21 The recipients of the mRNA vaccine were initially skeptical but became ecstatic and surprised when they saw the video of their success. They often had trouble sleeping and would communicate in the early hours of the morning. They faced challenges in their careers but eventually achieved success. They were celebrated as heroes in their native Hungary. They hope to inspire girls from all backgrounds to pursue their dreams. 20:35 Scientists acknowledge that they should have done more to promote the safety and efficacy of vaccines. They believe that social media played a significant role in spreading vaccine skepticism and conspiracy theories. Politicians also politicized the vaccine, further contributing to skepticism. Lack of scientific literacy among the public is another factor. Scientists have a responsibility to explain their work and address concerns. 23:50 The recipients' family members volunteered to be guinea pigs for the COVID-19 vaccine trials to encourage others to participate. Quantum dots, a result of the recipients' work, have various applications, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists is crucial for progress, even when working independently. Failure is a normal part of the scientific process, and aspiring scientists should not be discouraged by setbacks. 27:20 The chemistry laureates discuss the potential applications of quantum dots, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists from different fields, such as chemistry and physics, is essential for progress. Failure is a common occurrence in scientific research and should be embraced as a learning opportunity. 30:35 The recipients emphasize the importance of failure in the scientific process and encourage aspiring scientists not to be discouraged by setbacks. Collaboration and individuality both play a role in making groundbreaking discoveries. While the initial idea for an experiment may come from an individual, assembling a team with diverse expertise is necessary for success. 33:32 Claudia and Lawrence collaborated on a book about economic inequality, combining their expertise in economic history and labor economics. 36:49 Collaboration across disciplines is important, especially in the field of technology and AI, to consider the ethical implications of scientific discoveries. 40:18 The physics prize winners' work on capturing short-lived phenomena could lead to advancements in electron microscopes, electronics, and early disease diagnosis. 43:42 The Nobel laureates discuss the importance of perseverance and passion in research, and their plans to use their prize money for charitable causes and education. 47:08 The laureates express their desire to inspire and support young students in pursuing careers in science, and the power they now have to make a positive impact.
Can you guys for once let them talk about their research things they have done so we can peek into their minds and see how unique their thinking is with regards to scientific thinking instead of making it political? Is it possible to initiate a discussion about their work and how they interconnect? its like a news channel interview its not pleasing at all....
they did talk about their studies, but what is the point if they cant give a coherent and accessible deliberation of their studies in a timely manner? they talked about the political stuff (vaccines, environment, and social equality) because it is the main issue in society currently, they're all smart and they know these are important. if anyone are interested in their work, they can directly research about it. to see the interconnection of their work, it can be a very complex endeavour to be precise and fair, or else they can only say some things that might get misunderstood by most laymen.
Yeah, I came here to learn something but the anchor is Just biased towards specific topic For gathering or sucking knowledge from an y person x should let y to speak freely and peak their topics by themselves Rather then keep asking agenda based questions Anchor has literally wasted there time & mine to
I swear. We are being blasted with politics in every sector. Cant we just have researchers talk about research and the beauty of making new discoveries? Or how they came up with their ideas. Im sick and tired of everything being politicized.
@@notu1529 but this topics paint a narrative, researçh topics are far more interesting and compelling. When we hear things from people like them it inspires the public to look deeper into this topics.
Always a great conversation. Only suggestion: if possible, a two hour discussion would be even better. It's not every day that you get a bunch of Nobel prize winners from different areas to sit on a roundtable and talk with each other.
Watching this, it's evident to me that each of the researchers are not only exceptional in their fields and in their abilities to glean truth from reality, but they each seem to be very good people who think in complicated ways trying to benefit society & others. Thank you to the Nobel committee, the Royal family of Sweden, and the awardees for this wonderful glimpse.
I strongly believe their ability to glean truth from reality lies in their unending curiosities which is a self-fuelling driving factor in their search for answers. You’re bound to stumble upon nuggets of knowledge and wisdom by continuously asking “why?” and “how?” about our world. It’s beautiful. I wish there were some kind of human HDMI cable to view inside peoples’ minds haha
It's great to see Nobel Minds tackling social issues. Tho it seems like a missed opportunity to have these brilliant minds gathered around the same table focusing solely on this topic for the entire hour. This episode would be much more interesting if they talked more about physics, chemistry, medicine and economic sciences, seeing intellectual exchanges among these great minds.
I agree with your statement. How to get all people to be treated equal? Dr. Weissman. It can't. people are created differently, besides cultural, environmental, and religious factors play a big rule. A dream but not reality.
While this conversation is among brilliant minds like you said yourself, the conversation is led to strike a general appeal to most people, who otherwise wouldn''t be reached if it got too technical. I'd love it as well, but this conversation is used to give the winners a megaphone to speak about what they think is important to bring into conversation on a platform like this, a platform they might not have the opportunity to attain again. This, in large part, is used to encourage future students, who maybe otherwise wouldn't be encouraged if they listened to someone talk about why quantum dots are coated in organic capping ligands for an hour, for example. There exists other avenues for those kinds of conversations.
I couldn’t agree more on this point. Although I understand the importance of tackling social issues that impede on human progress. In my opinion the most socially rectifiable way is to show these brilliant minds in action, talking more about the very breakthroughs that got them in that room in the first place. I think that point could’ve much better been used as a side point for panel discussion and not as a focus point.
"Success can be forged out of failure" "If you simply fail at an experiment and drop it and do something else you haven't learned anything" "Research is not about being patient, it's about passion and perseverance" Love this! 🤩😍😄👍
Being proud or ashamed is just a matter of perspective. Sorry to say but great physicists aren't even proud of themselves They challenge even reality how they Gonna except illusion of perspective😮
I think nobel laureates aren't much celebrated despite their huge contribution to mankind..and this is what saddens me the most. They are the ACTUAL heroes of the world. Their immense knowledge about specific fields is what makes them the greatest minds of all humanity. I hope their hardwork and contribution doesn't go unnoticed.❤
oh shoot, I took the Thermodynamics course by Moungi Bawendi online hosted by MIT-OCW about 4 years ago, and he was just amazing. Like total class. He has been my role model since then because it was at that time that I was in the process of getting out of the "rote memorization" shell of mine. I was just shy of 3 lectures of completing the course, but man, it was an amazing experience taking that course. Thanks Moungi, you deserve this!
The problem for the young is not that we don’t want to go into research. The real problem is that the research jobs available have extremely small intakes which look for people with experience. It’s difficult gaining experience when you have no opportunity to start.
Excellent discussion. Much appreciated! Added: Aside from encouraging participation in prospective students, it’s also important to find a way of increasing retention of students in STEM who may become discouraged and be on the precipice of dropping out during their studies in those fields.
As a medical student, I've realized the incredible impact biomedical engineering has on improving healthcare. From creating innovative instruments to tackle various diseases to enhancing patient care, it's fascinating how technology merges with medicine. I believe being part of the team that invents these cutting-edge tools is just as fulfilling as practicing medicine. Hope i get to study further in that field.
Few thoughts: 1. Most of them are really specific about what they want to say and humbly correct/add context whenever the question asked has a broad scope. 2. Anne was my favorite in this panel. Her childlike amusement and clarity of thought really pulled me in.
Those Laureates who successfully mastered there field of interests has contributed so much in our society and to the world, they deserved the award and the applause.
Congratulations to the Nobel laureates winners for their exceptional contributions to humanity! Your groundbreaking work has not only advanced knowledge in your respective fields but has also inspired countless individuals around the world. Your dedication, passion, and commitment to making a positive impact on society are truly commendable. May your achievements serve as a source of inspiration for future generations, motivating them to pursue excellence and contribute meaningfully to the betterment of our world. Your legacy will endure, shaping the future of science, literature, peace, and economic sciences. Once again, heartfelt congratulations on this well-deserved honor. Your accomplishments are a testament to the power of human ingenuity and the pursuit of knowledge for the benefit of all.
Congratulations to all the Nobel laureates... who spent their entire time working to help humanity. I enjoyed the discussion... But I really wish the organizers to have given them more time to talk maybe an episode each about their fields in depth and then as a conclusion connecting their fields to the social problems. the topics they discussed would have being more insightful.
2024, Make it the year of science communication! We cant keep letting ground breaking papers go ignored! We need real fixes, real pressure, and real outreach!
19:20 what a beautiful wholesome moment, sent goosebumps down my spine! it's moments like these that make us realise who the real heroes are, brilliant discussion
Guys, Do not expect praise from outside. pleasure through senses may lead to dissatisfaction over period of time. observe breathing whenever mind gets swing.
That is a prime example to why european countries are way ahead of third world countries. People celebrate scientists who made important contributions instead of cheering for rockstars and petty matters.
The most prestigious dialogue with the world's most brilliant minds. We all respectfully appreciate your lifelong dedication and groundbreaking innovation illuminating our once empty world.
In todays world as a teacher we need to look at our education systems as 1st to 12 grade need to look at each student there are students who show glimpses of excellance in particular subjects and need to be encouraged.
💯This is exactly why television broadcasting is slowly declining, while inexpensive, unrefined, provocative 'social media' or independent creators like TH-camrs are gaining more prominence. There's an inherent truthfulness about them-they don't adhere to a fixed narrative and simply showcase things as they are. At least most of the time
Very educational 🙏 Thank you , Her Royal Highness Victoria for the introduction and hosting this event Congratulations to all Noble Laureates A absolutely great idea to post this discussion on TH-cam Always eager to learn the world and mentality of brilliant Noble Laureates winners.
I'm watching this interview from Brazil, I'm a Brazilian sculptor and I want to be the first Nobel laureate in my country for my book La Chair de l'Univers. Thanks
Nobel minds are noble to their works, thoughts, insights because they invent great theories, principles, thoughts for the welfare of mankind making this beautiful planet more beautiful and shining. Hats off these nobel laurete.
Heartening to see that each of the Nobel Laureates recognized the need and agreed to give more and more talks at the high school level as we are growing to be a braindead society. In desperate need of another Fyneman.
Thank you for all dedication and time spend on those works, we thank you all, these Nobel minds and also feel very happy to see more women represeting and giving the meaningfull work done, there is a lot of young women and men out there with high potencial and that cannot be waste by prejudice
I thought 10 minutes had passed when I checked the timebar but the video was more than halfway through! Fascinating... wish there was more content like this... >.
Maria Skłodowska is a Polish physicist and chemist. She is a naturalised-French ciziten and not a born French woman. I`m sorry for the rant but the French are once again appropriating foreign accomplishments.
Mr. Nobel has left not only a huge amount of money but also a super quality idea to reward people for their extraordinary contributions towards humanity promotions. The idea he has advanced has undoubtedly proved that scientists never die, they just hand over their responsibilities generation by generation. If I could meet him by some way! Salute to honourable Mr. Nobel, greatest humanatirian of the greatest.
what ever especially when I was watching this conversation I have been find a peace of mind especially commentator the way how demonstrated each and every things interms of experiences.
THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS FOR THE EVOLUTION OF HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS, BREAKING OLD CONSTRAINTS, FOR BUILDING NEW EDGE FRONTIERS, INSPIRING, PAVING NEW IDEAS TO EMERGE. GOD BLESS YOU ALL! ❤ I WANT TO BE SOMEONE AS USEFUL AS YOU ALL IN THE ADVANCEMENT OF OUR WORLD. ✨💗✨
Wish this was longer and they had more time to ask each other questions and exchange in dialogue about current events cutting across their domains. Some of the past years were a bit less structured and longer and I think I prefer that format!
Congratulations and thank you to all Nobel laureates. Simply beautiful and i owe you all for what you all sacrificed. I'm emotional hearing and exchanging idea's but yet so humble all shared. Thank you for all your efforts to make the work invested for all human kinds
I enjoy this conversation so much. It's a propelling inspiration for me and I hope to always circle back to this when the ideas inspired by this start materializing. More!
It's wonderful am watching this for free educating myself my the best intellectual mind.. peace 🕊️🫂 and love ❤️ from somalia 🇸🇴 young academic in Uganda 🇺🇬... I like the dance on the table and the discussion I learn thanks 🙏 all
Congrats on all the brilliant minds winning in their esteemed categories 🎉💜💙 we need more of these people to do good for humanity in their various fields🙏🙏
These are the only people on the internet that know what they’re talking about. I wish more people would listen to things like this instead of random people online TikTok who think their opinions are facts.
The introductory part reminds me of the ongoing research we have done for the last five years focusing on the experiences of women in STEM fields, esp mentorship, supervision, gender equality and women's progression in STEM in the five countries of East Africa.
First of all, greetings from Azerbaijan. I congratulate my colleagues who won the 2023 Nobel Prize. So far, I have watched all the Nobel laureates, each one has put forward different ideas and that is what makes them stand out from the rest. I think you should give the 2024 Nobel Prize to those who find the solution to Global Warming and other such problems, because this is the first problem. The world is in danger.
“In science, we must be interested in things, not in persons.” - Marie Curie I wonder what Marie curie would think about todays focus on gender and equality.
The crazy and manatory gender pay gap nonsense has failed. Strangely those who have been "affected", i.e. the women laureates answered truthfully without the pc nonsense. I can't believe this must be brought into this discussion and everywhere else. It's so incredibly frustrating and it's old already! Just focus on the FUTURE as Claudia Goldin suggested rightly so!
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 88 | คู่เอก "ป้อมเพชร vs อัสลามจอน"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1ZqTVVbMgbo/mqdefault.jpg)
Timestamps
00:00
The video begins with Zab Badawi welcoming viewers to Nobel Minds from the Royal Palace in Stockholm. He introduces the Nobel laureates and mentions the presence of Crown Princess Victoria and Prince Daniel. Princess Victoria gives a brief welcome and talks about the significance of the library in the palace. The focus of the discussion is on the lack of women in top positions in science and social sciences, and the laureates share their thoughts on the matter.
03:31
The discussion continues with the laureates discussing the progress and challenges for women in their respective fields. They talk about the importance of role models and the need for more women in science and technology. They also discuss the stereotypes and societal attitudes that discourage girls from pursuing careers in STEM fields. The laureates express optimism about the future and the potential for change.
06:48
Claudia Golden, the economics laureate, discusses the reasons for gender inequality in the workplace. She highlights the disproportionate burden of childcare and eldercare that falls on women, leading to lower-paying and less demanding positions. She also mentions the longer time it takes for women to achieve tenure in academia. The discussion emphasizes the need for greater parity in work and pay.
10:23
The laureates discuss potential solutions to achieve gender equality in the workplace. They mention the importance of teamwork and support among colleagues, as well as the need for flexible work arrangements. They also discuss the impact of technology and AI on jobs, noting both the potential benefits and challenges for women in fields like computer science.
13:49
The discussion concludes with a question from the audience for Claudia Golden about her research and the Nobel Prize. She shares that receiving the award was unexpected but meaningful, as it validated the work of many people. The video ends by highlighting the Nobel Prize in medicine or physiology, which recognized the groundbreaking work of Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman in developing mRNA vaccines.
17:21
The recipients of the mRNA vaccine were initially skeptical but became ecstatic and surprised when they saw the video of their success. They often had trouble sleeping and would communicate in the early hours of the morning. They faced challenges in their careers but eventually achieved success. They were celebrated as heroes in their native Hungary. They hope to inspire girls from all backgrounds to pursue their dreams.
20:35
Scientists acknowledge that they should have done more to promote the safety and efficacy of vaccines. They believe that social media played a significant role in spreading vaccine skepticism and conspiracy theories. Politicians also politicized the vaccine, further contributing to skepticism. Lack of scientific literacy among the public is another factor. Scientists have a responsibility to explain their work and address concerns.
23:50
The recipients' family members volunteered to be guinea pigs for the COVID-19 vaccine trials to encourage others to participate. Quantum dots, a result of the recipients' work, have various applications, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists is crucial for progress, even when working independently. Failure is a normal part of the scientific process, and aspiring scientists should not be discouraged by setbacks.
27:20
The chemistry laureates discuss the potential applications of quantum dots, including in QLED TVs, energy harvesting, and biomedicine. Collaboration between scientists from different fields, such as chemistry and physics, is essential for progress. Failure is a common occurrence in scientific research and should be embraced as a learning opportunity.
30:35
The recipients emphasize the importance of failure in the scientific process and encourage aspiring scientists not to be discouraged by setbacks. Collaboration and individuality both play a role in making groundbreaking discoveries. While the initial idea for an experiment may come from an individual, assembling a team with diverse expertise is necessary for success.
33:32
Claudia and Lawrence collaborated on a book about economic inequality, combining their expertise in economic history and labor economics.
36:49
Collaboration across disciplines is important, especially in the field of technology and AI, to consider the ethical implications of scientific discoveries.
40:18
The physics prize winners' work on capturing short-lived phenomena could lead to advancements in electron microscopes, electronics, and early disease diagnosis.
43:42
The Nobel laureates discuss the importance of perseverance and passion in research, and their plans to use their prize money for charitable causes and education.
47:08
The laureates express their desire to inspire and support young students in pursuing careers in science, and the power they now have to make a positive impact.
Thanks!
Great work, thanks.
Thanks for the time
Did you use AI for this? If so please tell how.
Thank you!
Can you guys for once let them talk about their research things they have done so we can peek into their minds and see how unique their thinking is with regards to scientific thinking instead of making it political? Is it possible to initiate a discussion about their work and how they interconnect? its like a news channel interview its not pleasing at all....
they did talk about their studies, but what is the point if they cant give a coherent and accessible deliberation of their studies in a timely manner? they talked about the political stuff (vaccines, environment, and social equality) because it is the main issue in society currently, they're all smart and they know these are important. if anyone are interested in their work, they can directly research about it. to see the interconnection of their work, it can be a very complex endeavour to be precise and fair, or else they can only say some things that might get misunderstood by most laymen.
Yeah, I came here to learn something but the anchor is Just biased towards specific topic
For gathering or sucking knowledge from an y person x should let y to speak freely and peak their topics by themselves
Rather then keep asking agenda based questions
Anchor has literally wasted there time & mine to
I swear. We are being blasted with politics in every sector. Cant we just have researchers talk about research and the beauty of making new discoveries? Or how they came up with their ideas. Im sick and tired of everything being politicized.
@@notu1529 but this topics paint a narrative, researçh topics are far more interesting and compelling.
When we hear things from people like them it inspires the public to look deeper into this topics.
You kidding me right? That's super easy to get ahold of. Just do a Google search. This is far more interesting.
Always a great conversation. Only suggestion: if possible, a two hour discussion would be even better. It's not every day that you get a bunch of Nobel prize winners from different areas to sit on a roundtable and talk with each other.
agree
Indeed
The reason the conversation was so short was because the disciplines were relegated to mostly hard sciences.
somehow it felt fast forward talk by the host
I agree. I would have loved to hear more conversation. Maybe ask a few more pressing questions
Watching this, it's evident to me that each of the researchers are not only exceptional in their fields and in their abilities to glean truth from reality, but they each seem to be very good people who think in complicated ways trying to benefit society & others. Thank you to the Nobel committee, the Royal family of Sweden, and the awardees for this wonderful glimpse.
I strongly believe their ability to glean truth from reality lies in their unending curiosities which is a self-fuelling driving factor in their search for answers. You’re bound to stumble upon nuggets of knowledge and wisdom by continuously asking “why?” and “how?” about our world. It’s beautiful. I wish there were some kind of human HDMI cable to view inside peoples’ minds haha
It's great to see Nobel Minds tackling social issues. Tho it seems like a missed opportunity to have these brilliant minds gathered around the same table focusing solely on this topic for the entire hour. This episode would be much more interesting if they talked more about physics, chemistry, medicine and economic sciences, seeing intellectual exchanges among these great minds.
yes I agree likewise, a separate episode would have been more appropriate.
Too bad kid, social issues are needed now more than ever over any sciences at the moment
I agree with your statement.
How to get all people to be treated equal? Dr. Weissman.
It can't. people are created differently, besides cultural, environmental, and religious factors play a big rule.
A dream but not reality.
While this conversation is among brilliant minds like you said yourself, the conversation is led to strike a general appeal to most people, who otherwise wouldn''t be reached if it got too technical.
I'd love it as well, but this conversation is used to give the winners a megaphone to speak about what they think is important to bring into conversation on a platform like this, a platform they might not have the opportunity to attain again. This, in large part, is used to encourage future students, who maybe otherwise wouldn't be encouraged if they listened to someone talk about why quantum dots are coated in organic capping ligands for an hour, for example. There exists other avenues for those kinds of conversations.
I couldn’t agree more on this point. Although I understand the importance of tackling social issues that impede on human progress. In my opinion the most socially rectifiable way is to show these brilliant minds in action, talking more about the very breakthroughs that got them in that room in the first place. I think that point could’ve much better been used as a side point for panel discussion and not as a focus point.
"Success can be forged out of failure"
"If you simply fail at an experiment and drop it and do something else you haven't learned anything"
"Research is not about being patient, it's about passion and perseverance"
Love this! 🤩😍😄👍
I am very proud and it is encouraging to see 2 hungarians to sit at the table. :)
Hungarians have always had brilliant minds, Von Neumann the greatest in my opinion
Dr kariko saved the world even u
Congratulations to all Nobel laureates... We are proud of you all
Yes we are !
Yes, very proud of your brilliance and perseverance and contribution. I must add that I am happy to see women have come so far in recent history.
And Grateful too🙌🏿
It's only Prize... That's all...
Being proud or ashamed is just a matter of perspective.
Sorry to say but great physicists aren't even proud of themselves
They challenge even reality how they Gonna except illusion of perspective😮
I think nobel laureates aren't much celebrated despite their huge contribution to mankind..and this is what saddens me the most. They are the ACTUAL heroes of the world. Their immense knowledge about specific fields is what makes them the greatest minds of all humanity. I hope their hardwork and contribution doesn't go unnoticed.❤
Yes.. they need more recognition
I will definitely come to watch this after I am done with my exams.
Did you come back to watch it?
spamming motivation, but working backwards, well my case atleast.
oh shoot, I took the Thermodynamics course by Moungi Bawendi online hosted by MIT-OCW about 4 years ago, and he was just amazing. Like total class. He has been my role model since then because it was at that time that I was in the process of getting out of the "rote memorization" shell of mine. I was just shy of 3 lectures of completing the course, but man, it was an amazing experience taking that course. Thanks Moungi, you deserve this!
Thanks for telling, I will check it out too
The problem for the young is not that we don’t want to go into research. The real problem is that the research jobs available have extremely small intakes which look for people with experience. It’s difficult gaining experience when you have no opportunity to start.
Excellent discussion. Much appreciated!
Added: Aside from encouraging participation in prospective students, it’s also important to find a way of increasing retention of students in STEM who may become discouraged and be on the precipice of dropping out during their studies in those fields.
As a medical student, I've realized the incredible impact biomedical engineering has on improving healthcare. From creating innovative instruments to tackle various diseases to enhancing patient care, it's fascinating how technology merges with medicine. I believe being part of the team that invents these cutting-edge tools is just as fulfilling as practicing medicine. Hope i get to study further in that field.
Thank you to all of you for your contribution to our species knowledge and capabilities :D congratulations.
Few thoughts:
1. Most of them are really specific about what they want to say and humbly correct/add context whenever the question asked has a broad scope.
2. Anne was my favorite in this panel. Her childlike amusement and clarity of thought really pulled me in.
Ye I thought the same about Anne. She works in my town!
Those Laureates who successfully mastered there field of interests has contributed so much in our society and to the world, they deserved the award and the applause.
Always enjoy and look forward to each year ... Zeinab Badawi's delivery of this unique event and the rich thoughts and conversation .
Congratulations to the Nobel laureates winners for their exceptional contributions to humanity! Your groundbreaking work has not only advanced knowledge in your respective fields but has also inspired countless individuals around the world. Your dedication, passion, and commitment to making a positive impact on society are truly commendable.
May your achievements serve as a source of inspiration for future generations, motivating them to pursue excellence and contribute meaningfully to the betterment of our world. Your legacy will endure, shaping the future of science, literature, peace, and economic sciences.
Once again, heartfelt congratulations on this well-deserved honor. Your accomplishments are a testament to the power of human ingenuity and the pursuit of knowledge for the benefit of all.
Congratulations to all the Nobel laureates... who spent their entire time working to help humanity. I enjoyed the discussion...
But I really wish the organizers to have given them more time to talk maybe an episode each about their fields in depth and then as a conclusion connecting their fields to the social problems. the topics they discussed would have being more insightful.
Yes! Agreed
Great minds think alike. You can tell from the way they listen to each other.
2024, Make it the year of science communication! We cant keep letting ground breaking papers go ignored! We need real fixes, real pressure, and real outreach!
What a nice idea to get these great scientists together.
Its wonderful that humanity can come together, to celebrate as one our curiosity and exploration, and how these can be used to benefit all of Mankind.
19:20 what a beautiful wholesome moment, sent goosebumps down my spine! it's moments like these that make us realise who the real heroes are, brilliant discussion
Guys, Do not expect praise from outside. pleasure through senses may lead to dissatisfaction over period of time. observe breathing whenever mind gets swing.
That is a prime example to why european countries are way ahead of third world countries. People celebrate scientists who made important contributions instead of cheering for rockstars and petty matters.
Indeed
I come from a third world country and I agree with you. The wrong people are always celebrated which is sad😢@@frogindisguise8231
Congratulations to all Nobel laureates! And it's great to see 2 hungarians at the table, I'm very proud of Karikó Katalin and Krausz Ferenc too☺
Congratulations to all The Nobel Laureates and their noble thoughts. Hope, their noble thoughts will make a radical change in the society ♥
It is very inspiring to see one of the laureates from my country Tunisia. Congratulations Pr. Mongi Bawendi and thank you for inspiring people!
These are also one of the most humble people. It's rare in any other field.
Agreed. Admirable. Maybe I will be able to restore myself somehow.
Thank you all! This is too general but I just can't put the right words on how greatful I am for everything you all have done! 💛
The most prestigious dialogue with the world's most brilliant minds. We all respectfully appreciate your lifelong dedication and groundbreaking innovation illuminating our once empty world.
Nobel minds bring great ideas.
Congratulations to all the great scientists. Thank you for the wonderful contributions.
In todays world as a teacher we need to look at our education systems as 1st to 12 grade need to look at each student there are students who show glimpses of excellance in particular subjects and need to be encouraged.
I gave Luis Brus a lab tour at the University of Georgia a decade ago....My mind is fully blown!!!!
38:01 As good as Zeinab is, I would have loved to see the Laureates discussing things like this, rather than so much directed interviewing.
It’s the same every year with her lol😂
💯This is exactly why television broadcasting is slowly declining, while inexpensive, unrefined, provocative 'social media' or independent creators like TH-camrs are gaining more prominence. There's an inherent truthfulness about them-they don't adhere to a fixed narrative and simply showcase things as they are. At least most of the time
Agreed! Wish this thread was able to go on longer
Very educational 🙏
Thank you , Her Royal Highness Victoria for the introduction and hosting this event
Congratulations to all Noble Laureates
A absolutely great idea to post this discussion on TH-cam
Always eager to learn the world and mentality of brilliant Noble Laureates winners.
I'm watching this interview from Brazil, I'm a Brazilian sculptor and I want to be the first Nobel laureate in my country for my book La Chair de l'Univers. Thanks
I pray to Allah SWT to fulfill your wish . Aameen 🤲🤲
Excellent program !!! Congratulations to all at this round table for your work and insignts !!!
Glad that the show is on YTb. Once a year for me it's a must-watch program.
We give award to actor that is why world have no comparison with us and we don't try to think to honor to such innovative minds.
Words spoken like music to my ears. Time has passed so smooth that I didn't realise almost an hour has passed. ❤
Nobel minds are noble to their works, thoughts, insights because they invent great theories, principles, thoughts for the welfare of mankind making this beautiful planet more beautiful and shining. Hats off these nobel laurete.
Heartening to see that each of the Nobel Laureates recognized the need and agreed to give more and more talks at the high school level as we are growing to be a braindead society. In desperate need of another Fyneman.
The production quality on this has gone up. Much easier to watch.
Thank you all! This is too general but I just can't put the right words on how greatful I am for everything you all have done!
My respect and admiration are all to you! Thanks for your contribution to the human civilization. You are great role models for young generation
Its crazy that videos like this don't get 100m views in 24 hours...it shows the state of the human race as a whole.
Thank you for all dedication and time spend on those works, we thank you all, these Nobel minds and also feel very happy to see more women represeting and giving the meaningfull work done, there is a lot of young women and men out there with high potencial and that cannot be waste by prejudice
What a great opportunity to listen a life experiences and advises from those peoples.
I thought 10 minutes had passed when I checked the timebar but the video was more than halfway through! Fascinating... wish there was more content like this... >.
Thank you all for these wonderful ideas 🙏💡
Enlightened me listening in the very morning, volumes of Hard work been overflowing on the table in the smoothest sense of ideas!!
Thanks so much! Love you ALL.
We really missed this humble intelligent minds being their authentic selves with this expert narrator Abbie great charm and wit - we love her.
Congratulations all laureate’s. I wish one day to be one of the nobel laureate’s
You can❤❤
Amazing.
All the best ahead to all the Nobel Laureates.
Very inspiring minds.
Preparing for Govt. Exam in Indian 🇮🇳 state of Assam😊 TH-cam recommended me this video
Its nice to hear from such an amazing minds and these are the real heros of the world. Respect and love for them.
imagine, nobel laurates speaking only about gender equality for straight 15 min/50 min
Loved it ❤
Fascinating. They all indeed did help humankind further in so many ways. Truly inspirational.
My favorite discussion, I enjoy and always look forward to the wonderful talk each year.
Many more congratulations to all Nobel laureates.
It is nice to see that these great scientists are also down to earth on their thoughts. Congratulations!
Hello and thanks for this precious meeting.
Maria Skłodowska is a Polish physicist and chemist. She is a naturalised-French ciziten and not a born French woman. I`m sorry for the rant but the French are once again appropriating foreign accomplishments.
Also thanks to Sir Alfred Nobel for introducing these prizes so that all the future generations get inspired by the knowledge of these briliant people
Thx. Well done to all of you. The Idea of such Open - Disccusion is " Nobel " per se. So many thanks to Lady Viktoria & Nobel Committe for Efforts 👏🙏🍻
Thank you for your brilliant and invaluable contributions to mankind. Cheers🥂🙏
Any Algerians here 😊 !
Un algérien passionné par la science est passé par là.
On est laaa
Mr. Nobel has left not only a huge amount of money but also a super quality idea to reward people for their extraordinary contributions towards humanity promotions. The idea he has advanced has undoubtedly proved that scientists never die, they just hand over their responsibilities generation by generation. If I could meet him by some way! Salute to honourable Mr. Nobel, greatest humanatirian of the greatest.
what ever especially when I was watching this conversation I have been find a peace of mind especially commentator the way how demonstrated each and every things interms of experiences.
THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS FOR THE EVOLUTION OF HUMAN CONSCIOUSNESS, BREAKING OLD CONSTRAINTS, FOR BUILDING NEW EDGE FRONTIERS, INSPIRING, PAVING NEW IDEAS TO EMERGE. GOD BLESS YOU ALL! ❤ I WANT TO BE SOMEONE AS USEFUL AS YOU ALL IN THE ADVANCEMENT OF OUR WORLD. ✨💗✨
Wish this was longer and they had more time to ask each other questions and exchange in dialogue about current events cutting across their domains. Some of the past years were a bit less structured and longer and I think I prefer that format!
I wait for this discussion.. ❤
same
Very good discussion
Thank you dear Zeinab and dear audience and dear professors for clarifying little bit the subjects of discussion
❤ ZB, such clarity in her voice. Never disappoints as a host.
These are Global citizens and Leaders in their most authentic passionate selves. You inspire us. Thank you.
Congratulations and thank you to all Nobel laureates. Simply beautiful and i owe you all for what you all sacrificed. I'm emotional hearing and exchanging idea's but yet so humble all shared. Thank you for all your efforts to make the work invested for all human kinds
I enjoy this conversation so much. It's a propelling inspiration for me and I hope to always circle back to this when the ideas inspired by this start materializing.
More!
Lovely to start a conversation about minds and their academic brilliance with Gender
It's wonderful am watching this for free educating myself my the best intellectual mind.. peace 🕊️🫂 and love ❤️ from somalia 🇸🇴 young academic in Uganda 🇺🇬... I like the dance on the table and the discussion I learn thanks 🙏 all
Me 2
Thanks to the gentle men and women for the exceptional work they have done.
Congratulations to all Nobel Laureates!
been waiting on this to drop, let's go! Shout out to all my laureates
Congrats on all the brilliant minds winning in their esteemed categories 🎉💜💙 we need more of these people to do good for humanity in their various fields🙏🙏
Also Victoria speaks good English!! Never heard speaking English before 💖👸
@@Peirithous Helping the west get advanced technologically is not helping the world, it is preparing emperilism
Love these round table discussions and I fully agree that as women, our carer progression stalls when we start families
Lets admit it's hard in this time of all centuries to debate a bout this kind of topics but with big brains it will flow just as this conversation.
These are the only people on the internet that know what they’re talking about. I wish more people would listen to things like this instead of random people online TikTok who think their opinions are facts.
I'm truly grateful for their contributions to humankind . I hope their lives are truly blessed ❤
The introductory part reminds me of the ongoing research we have done for the last five years focusing on the experiences of women in STEM fields, esp mentorship, supervision, gender equality and women's progression in STEM in the five countries of East Africa.
Wow you have some of the best minds in the world right now for an hour and make them converse about woke talking points
Geat intervw and privelege and hounor to listen to the noble laureates and thier great achevements and vewes
Great Personalities in one room. I believe in Thinking outside the Box. ..
Inspiring and educational to get a snapshot of a group of amazing people. Thank you.
Thank you so much!
First of all, greetings from Azerbaijan. I congratulate my colleagues who won the 2023 Nobel Prize. So far, I have watched all the Nobel laureates, each one has put forward different ideas and that is what makes them stand out from the rest. I think you should give the 2024 Nobel Prize to those who find the solution to Global Warming and other such problems, because this is the first problem. The world is in danger.
Good news. Well! Thank you to Nobel-Minds respected, honourable and beloved Sir/Mam. I m from INDIA.
I wanna be your student, I deeply want to have like these people to teaching!
“In science, we must be interested in things, not in persons.”
- Marie Curie
I wonder what Marie curie would think about todays focus on gender and equality.
As a science driven woman this is my dream.
Congratulations to you all...
I wish you will achieve your dream 🙂
Fascinating. Live long and prosper. 🖖😎♾
The crazy and manatory gender pay gap nonsense has failed. Strangely those who have been "affected", i.e. the women laureates answered truthfully without the pc nonsense. I can't believe this must be brought into this discussion and everywhere else. It's so incredibly frustrating and it's old already! Just focus on the FUTURE as Claudia Goldin suggested rightly so!