[CLEAN MR Removed] 220828 aespa (에스파) Black Mamba + Next Level | Live Vocals MR제거
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2024
- SMTOWN 2022 in Tokyo CLEAN MR제거 220828 에스파 (aespa) Black Mamba + Next Level
-Live Vocals!!
-DO NOT REUP!
-BHK MR REMOVED
#LIVEVOCALS #CLEANMRREMOVED #AESPA #에스파 #MRREMOVED #MR제거 #AESPAMRREMOVED #에스파MR제거 #AESPABLACKMAMBA #AESPANEXTLEVEL #에스파BLACKMAMBA #에스파NEXTLEVEL #BLACKMAMBA #NEXTLEVEL #KARINA #GISELLE #WINTER #NINGNING #KPOP
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 230218 aespa (에스파) Girls | Live Vocals Circle Chart Music Awards 2022 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/twvniPxNu30/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 230218 aespa (에스파) Girls | Live Vocals Circle Chart Music Awards 2022 MR제거](/img/tr.png)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 220722 aespa (에스파) Girls | Music Bank MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6rl0G6dbgzE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] "บอสณวัฒน์" แฉ! แหล่งซุกเงินแก๊งบอส ขยันผิดที่ไม่กี่ปีก็เข้าคุก l คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ l17ต.ค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BL56qIfXYZM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 221129 NMIXX (엔믹스) O.O + DICE | Live Vocals 2022 MAMA MR제거](/img/n.gif)
I'm in love with their live vocals 😍🔥
Thanks to Pastel Mint who gave me the performances files!
If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like aespa's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
omoo pastel 😍😍
💗
We don’t need to feel depressed when we hear our recordings cuz even kpop ppl are same. In fact almost all singers(except some) sound like this live. Studio or lip syncing shudnt be the standard. One positive thing this channel spread this.
Stable rank:
1 Winter 11/10 queen
2 Ningning 10/10 queen
3 Karina 10/10 queen
4 Giselle 10/10 queen
Winter always *✨IMPRESSIVE✨*
Winter voice always powerfull
Yaaas! Ningning main vocalist!
Winter's vocals at 04:33 is one of the best live vocals I have heard in my entire life. This girl is so frickin' talented, and the other members are also incredibly good!
Winter slaying as always
The way winter can sing so loud, clear and stable, yet with vibrato too🥹🥹 but Ningning was also exceptional, theyre all so talented👏🏼
Winter is the best when they sing live, she's always so stable and you actually hear her.
Winter Vocals is really insane
Winter eating CDs as usual, OMG, she sounds literally like the studio version. And shout out to NingNing Queen, she is every tike getting more and more stable compared to their first live stage in Coachella💟
winter singing louder than backtrack omg
Winter is giving me Chenle vibes when live singing. They exactly sounded the same live or not 😭😭
I KNOW RIGHT, everytime i watch winter's live vocal, it reminds me of chenle
YES TRUEEEE
I HAVE A SAME OPINION WITH YOUU
Winter high note is amazing....
yess
Winter's voice really cut thru the music. NN with her high note. Karina and Gisella are not far behind. When they sounded good, haters are no where to be found. In this video's comment section is the good example. Haters are non existence haha
WINTER is the most stable when it comes to Live singing, I heard it.
I think it's because she really tones down her dancing more than the other members whenever they sing live.
And they hate on her for having a loud voice
@@raime3488 not really tho, she dances as hard as the others, she's just more stable
@@raime3488 필터 오지게 씌우넼ㅋㅋㅋ 그렇게 따지면 지젤은 뭐니
@@raime3488 girl---- shes literally dance as hard as other. do u even watch the fancam? all of them dance the same but manage to sing live
winter is so good.I love her.
man, winter sings like she swallowed a cd! karina's deep tone is very impressive, giselle's self-confidence should increase but she sings perfectly! ningning proves to us why she is the main vocalist!
It’s crazy to me that SM rarely lets them sing live. They sound amazing, particularly Winter and Ning Ning. These girls need and deserve more chances to shine ✨
They do sing live but on paid shows lol not on music shows
SM artists make vocally challenging music and it can be damaging too so yes sm is doing the right thing
@@satz9532 yapp that’s what I’ve been thinking..
It’s the way SM to maintain their health, especially in their earlier of their debut year is “corona season” and they have to promote a lot, which is really risk for them..
@@satz9532 yeah but I think they should sing live at least once or twice during promos on music shows...sometimes it's discouraging to fans that they don't.
@@katgreer6113 I agree at least once specially on music shows with good mic quality like inkigayo
@@satz9532 i never really get why don’t they just lipsync the high notes instead of the whole performance
Winter's voice is so clear. You can clearly hear the words she spit. Yet she is so stable too.
4:32 omg this D5 from Winter canes from her soul.
This is why Winter deserves her lines people
Yess🔥🔥🔥 winter slayed 😍
winter is just so amazing.. her stability her tension her tone im in love
They are stable
Specially winter and Ning2!!!
yes，winter is so great.
ikrr ningning kills it
yes Ningning 😍😍
Winter is so stable! amazing vocal!
honestly impressed, cause unlike other idol groups' songs, their songs require more technique when singing. it's not just about the high notes, it's the amount of notes in one line... if I'm making sense.
Thats the thing that people missed..Aespa songs are not that simple to sing to..not just simple shouting nots here and here.
Winter is so stable omggg
Ini adalah alasan kenap winter keliatan sebel kalau di suruh lipsync. Karna dia tahu di bisa live sebagus ini ❤
Ningning sounds so good!!!
Winter's stability is on another level, I can't say something about other members but Winter is best
Yeah!
you can nothing on the others members because you solo stan lol its easy to know lmao
@@lisaseokjinbts2901 Yes I'm not my because I can't love Ningning but I'm listening their songs they are so talented but not in stability and Stage presence, Winter has'nt got Stage presence too
@@trtaekookistherevolution3253 actually i not mys i just follow them when i'm boring lol
@@lisaseokjinbts2901 I folow them since their pre-debut but I can't love Ningning, I'm notr for Giselle and Karina. I think Winter is very very talented I like her but not stan
winter is literally insane for this
Winter so stable
Winter is always the most stable when it comes to live singing! ❤
Ini alasan gua ngebiasin winter🤍 gak cuma visual yang menonjol, tapi vocal nya pas live keren parah
Wow winter stable voice😧🔥
Winter's so talented
I'm impressed by winter's vocal resonance
No resonance here but I believe she can produce resonance one day cuz her 4th octave is chef’s kiss🥺
If she would produce resonance then she would have been better than ning2
But she has potential to produce it i believe
@@Pearlyyy0 Don't be delusional, every sound has resonance.
@@moonlightespt3818 not you again💀💀
@@moonlightespt3818 resonance in vocal pedagogy is not the resonance you mean dumbass
Ningning slayed 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️
1:34 ningning😍😍😍So stable
Winter slayed 😍
winter is probably one of the most stable vocalists of all time kpop😭💙💙💙💙
Ningning ❤️🔥
Ningning and winter slayy vocal!
i was hesitant on them singing live, bc alot of idols sometimes struggle especiallly rookies but winter and ningning sounding like pros here
Ningning high note is sooooo good
winter and ningning so damn good
I love Ningning’s voice😩
Winter is so stable that it seems like the studio version
They are all amazing
They deserve the biggest apologize for being called lipsyincing quen by haters. Their voal literally can outshine most of idols in the industry (realistically speaking)
Especially winter, damn that gurl can literally sing
@@kandanara980 that's why people called her an ace
Why they need to apologize? Because it's true they lip sync many times. But now SM let them sing live they don't doubt their capability it's just most of the time they lipsync
@@smdv5958 stating that aespa lipsyncs (mostly) is true, but calling the group "lipsync queens" is rude (cause it's not even their choice)
@@smdv5958 they should apologize because they were the biggest targets yet now hardly anyone sings live and get no criticism even tho their songs require no vocal technique
They're too good so people keep saying they are lip-syncing 😭😭😭
Because on this real live vocal, you will hear they missing some words and hear their breath against the mic also little struggling and that is acceptable cuz they dance too. I would say Winter is the one really got impressive for her live vocal. But when they do lipsyn or use pre records(a lot) and loud backtrack(a lot) Mys still believe and say it is LIVE. 😅🥲 Aespa looks more fun on stage when they sing live.
@@judyju9244 So many idol ever done lipsync and used loud backtrack.. So many fans idol praise and called their idol singing live with still used loud backtrack, but it's okay and not a big deal..
But Why it's a big deal when it's comes to aespa and mys?
Netizen always set the standar so high to aespa, but their idol..
If they want to be fussy about aespa, they need give that vibe to their idol too
Can they?
Anyways aespa have performed with NO LOUD BACKTRACK like on coachella/gma, where is no many idol can do :))
@@xxxdamngurlxxx yes ur right
@@xxxdamngurlxxx they like to hate on aespa soo much their favs can't even sing properly while standing 😂
Lol only 2 members sound okay
Idk why but i love when Karina does this Line live 1:54 !!
These songs are hard even you’re singing standing still and not dancing. And they did amazing while dancing, the dance moves the abdomen area a lot (sorry idk how to say it) which will make your voice shake bcs you know that’s where the breathing comes from, sorry i really don’t know how to explain it lmao 😭💜
Lol at least you tried
diaphragm？
@@qr-eh9es ah yess!
Ningning her voice is really clear she is the queen of sound
2:06 WinNing Bridge part is the best
So stable
as expected aespa vocal line is always amazing 🔥
winter ommmmmg
NingNing is coming thru with this excellent support and placement, whew
wow winter 😭😭😭
sm should let them sing live more often so they'll improve more ❤️
Winter como sempre a mais estável cantando ao vivo!!!
All the people saying SM should let them sing live often, they don't let because the notes in their songs if done regularly like during promotions, strain their voices and could even harm their vocal cords , that's why they do that less to not strain their cords. SM is doing their job well.
Then they could prerecord the hard parts and let them sing the rest of the song live
It’ll be good for them to improve themselves throughout their career and for fans to enjoy the performances
@@xMoOlzx I agree on that but I also trust SM, they do care for their artist's skills.
They sang ' hey ' is so powerful
Winter
This is so crazy when the actual live vocal sound exactly the same as audio vocal. That's why everyone can't distinguish.
good job girls ❤️
winter loveee youu
Stan powerful vocalists WinNing y’all
NINGNINGS HIGH NOTE was so good
the fact that winter is always so stable💙😭💅🏻
SM indeed, they r stable as always❤️
NingNing 🛐🛐🛐
2:28 Ningning🔥
Ningning highnote is so smooth and strong... cool
Most of their songs need good vocal techniques, and I love it, they can sing well
winter, main slayer, main vocalist, the one and only star
She's lead not main👍
@@myab866 NO!!! There is no fixed position in Aespa.
@@boyyyo yea but according to their k profiles they have
@@myab866 So what? It is not real tho. Stop commenting under my comment.
@@boyyyo you absolutely can praise her vocally as she is solid but vocal technique and capabilities are objective and ningning’s simply the superior and more rounded vocalist.
Giselle is so stable
She's a queen
ningnings vocal is on the next level
Ningning queen
Omg they all sound the same as the studio version.. as usual
NINGNING IS SO STABLE her high note in black mamba 😍😵💫
Ningning live vocals 😍
so impressive omg... they seemed to really have fun too :,)
YAY! AESPA LIVE VOCALS
NINGNING SLAYYY
who said Aespa lipsyncing? Their lives vocal is too good to be true, I’m MY and all of this time I even thought they were lipsyncing😂 esp Winter, she is unbelievably stable😣
SM should let them sing live often. i mean there's no problem with LAR (Live All Recorded) vocals..alot of idols are doing that as well.. but aespa can enjoy more performing if they are able sing live than just lipsyncing with LAR.
Winter really said 🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊🔊
WinNing OMG
This is true live and I appreciate it!! This was so exciting to hear. The girls are very stable
Even though they kind of struggling but their breathing control is amazing. It does sound airy but not too much like most of other idols.
No group could actually have the perfect sounding live since they're dancing while singing so this is still very good
Wow amazing. Stable clean and very powerful. Love them. This comming from a blink.
SM songs have difficult notes even stay stand. Aespa proved why they're debuted
omg ningning is amazing
Maybe you can do their Tokyo collection performance mr removed too they’re also quite stable there!
Karina and giselle rap is the next level!
Kim Minjeong slay
The vocal OMG so pretty
ningning ❤️
Ningning slayed!
4:31 sarap sa ears ng vocals ni winter😌
Sa true lang mhiee
legit :>
SM needs to seriously let them sing live more often.
i love that they are singing live! most idols these days use pre recorded 😢