If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like aespa's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
근데 진지하게 곡난이도 높고 곡 무대 완성도를 위해서면 그냥 이렇게 mr 깔린게 좋은건 맞음... 가끔한두번씩 해주는건 좋지만 활동의 대부분이 라이브아니라고 머라하기엔조금 그렇죠 회사측에서 좀더 깔끔하고 완벽한걸 추구한걸수도 있으니 에스파가 실력있는건 가끔보여주는걸로도 잘알자나요 모 ㅎㅎ
With many achievements that Savage has right now, I’m SURE we at least going to see the encore of Savage where the girls will finally fully sing live 1000%.
ㅇㅇ그냥 라이브 ar이 생기고나서부터 요즘 음악방송들 시스템이 라이브가 거의 아닌것들을 라이브로 둔갑시키는 쪽에 가깝게 변질된듯.. 그나마 그안에선 특이하게 스테이씨가 소속사부터 생라이브를 고집해서 시원하게 밀고나간것같고 에스파같은 경우는 이미 사석이나 다른 예능,라디오 등에서 이미 넷 다 실력이 잘 입증되서 큰 걱정은 전혀 없지만 ㅠ애들 잘못은 아니고 그저 에스엠측에서 라이브를 많이 안보여주는 편인 것 같음 지금 음원성적 너무 좋으니까 1위하면 라이브 시원하게하고 그동안 계속 말나오던 부분들까지 싹다 청산하면 좋을듯?
I love winter’s tone and voice so much y’all don’t understand. I’m emotionally attached to her voice like I wanna be able to hear her sing forever, this is unhealthy.
@@_.wxxdne yea people are dumb tho- not exactly dumb, they just are too toxic and trys to make their group look good, it isn't a crime to pre-record. Hell if I was a idol I'd do it too
@@blink_midzy5194 A SM NÃO OS DEIXA CANTAR, ENTENDA, TODOS ALI SÃO CAPAZES DE CANTAR MAIS ELES NÃO CANTAM POR CAUSA DA SM. NÃO JOGUE HATE PRA ELES POR CAUSA DISSO SEU ANORMAL
Whether it's live or pre-recorded, the thing we're sure is they can sing well, it's already given if you came from sm. I think they will sound the same as the studio version in live performances just like how their seniors when singing live.
@@Mother_mizrahi Hmmm I'm not going to clarify something. But even if it's pre-recorded it's still their real voices, the thing about pre-recording is you will record every part and if they are not satisfied you will retake it until they get the best version of that part. I think it's by part, or maybe it's half live because of how hard the choreography. It's just my opinion feel free to correct me if you know something.
시간 초 단위로 쪼개서 라이브 맞는지아닌지 확인하는거 진짜 ...에스파한테 레알 깐깐하게 구네 다들 말로는 실력이 궁금하다 하면서 어떻게든 평가하고 시비걸고싶어하는거 다 보이는데 ㅋㅋ 에이알이여도 본인들이 직접 녹음한거고 실력 다 알만한데 항상 ... 그렇게 생라이브 듣고싶으면 투표 좀 해주고 앨범 좀 사서 1등 라이브 시켜줘라
@@채연-y5d 스테이시처럼 생라이브를 하든가 라디오에서 라이브 한번 하든가 할 방법은 많은데?? 진짜 에스파 아티스트는 너무너무 좋은데 극성무뇌팬들때문에 짜증나네 튠으로 만질 수 있는것도 한계가 있어서 실력 좋은거 알고 백구는 내 폰 배경화면인데 솔직히 올라이브라고 생각되는 무대는 한번도 한적 없음 제발 얘들아 좋아하는건 같은 입장에서 이해하겠는데 합리적으로 생각좀 해 진짜 쪽팔려
This isn't live, you can see, their vocals are perfectly stable even after dancing hardly. I know aespa's vocals and raps are out of this world, I just hope sm allows aespa to sing live
@@lanhy9849 lol :) bạn nên đi xem lại fancam aespa hát ở coachella nhé, xem mấy vid fan đăng chứ đừng xem vid của SM đăng vì nó chỉnh giọng r, đi xem đi r quay lại đây coi stage này có p là aespa hát live k nhé :)
@Junjisblondestreak sm doesn't allow aespa, yeah breath control is a thing, but it doesn't mean ur voices can sound heavy or crack. Either way, the first time they actually sang live was in Coachella
I think they were singing live .Some of the tones were being varied if you listen to it carefully , it's different from the audio version in some parts . Such powerful singing !
whether they sing live during music show or not, it's easy to find videos of ningning singing live and she has an amazing voice!! she's been singing since she was a kid and deserves her spot as the main vocal ❤️
There's something about Winter's voice. The way she sings it's sounds so angelic, she is putting her own technique while singing that's why it doesn't sounds plain and boring.
저 춤 추면서 저 라이브가 가능하면 에스파>>>넘사>>>소향이지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 절대 라이브 아님. 랩부분에서 음정 피치 조금씩 엇나가는게 보이는데 이게 춤추면서 부르는거라 ㄹㅇ 라이브면 숨차서 헐떡이는 소리도 조금씩 들어가야한단 말이지? 핀마이크가 호흡은 걸러내고 음정만 잡아주는 신기술 마이크도 아니고 ㅋㅋㅋ 근데 들어보면 피치가 조금씩 떨어지는거지 호흡은 완벽 그자체임. 이런건 라이브일 수 가 없음. 라이브 ar이지.. 에스파가 다른 여돌과는 차원이 다르게 실력이나 비주얼로 압도적인거 알겠는데 이건 라이브ar이지 절대 라이브가 아님. 그렇다고 에스파한테 다른 여돌이 라이브 비빌 수 있느냐? 그것도 절대 아님. 나 얘네처럼 라이브 개쩌는애들 첨본다 ㄹㅇ..
I know people will only be convinced after the encore but IVE BEEN TELLING YOU!!! they sing like this while dancing. NO we don't hear the live track in the performance videos, but they are NOT lipsyncing. They have multiple takes and take whichever dance+camerawork+vocals worked best SEPERATELY. It wasn't so noticeable in Next level and Black mamba because those songs are not that vocally challenging and so aespa could perform it consistently, but you can already hear the differences for each stage of Savage.
@@jangerardo5070 i think that's the point of op's comment, they choose the best cuts of camerawork, dancing and singing separately then combine it for the final edited performance that's why it doesn't match bc diff takes but live vocals
i'm so tired can't we all just appreciate their raw vocals instead of fighting whether it's live or prerecorded? because either way it's aespa's vocals and the show of sheer talent is beyond impressive
@@purpleplanet888 they still have said Winter that is Royal(negative word for Chinese meaning of 皇族 and usually using by any auditions through tvs)🥲 as they have said that she has gotten the most parts but not stable when she live singing
앵콜도 듣고 왔고 실력 좋은 거 너무 알겠는데 이건 존나 ar인 거 앵콜 듣고 나니까 더 확실함. 춤 안 추면서 부른 앵콜이랑 춤 존나 빡쎄기 추면서 부르는 이 mr 제거 듣고서도 이게 라이브라고 우기는 애들은 그냥 귀 막고 에스파빠라는 거고. 춤 안 추면서도 닝닝이 저음역대 안 나와서 거의 안 들리게 부르고 고음역대도 반가성 처리 해서 힘 없이 들리는데 어떻게 춤 추면서 부르는데 이 정도로 목소리 퀄리티가 균일하게 나오냐고. 후보정이거나 노래따로 녹음해서 무대용 ar 깐거임. 이런 식으로 하는 애들은 mr 제거 해봤자 소용이 없지 뭐..ㅋㅋ 얘네 다 존나 잘 하고 실력 있는 건 알겠는데 영영 춤추면서 하는 쌩라이브는 못 들어볼 듯.
@@uglyhoobaes3695 they still sing it live. And ofc they need a pre-recorded background…if you don’t know how live performance work then I suggest you to stay silence cuz you’re showing how ignorant you are.
@@uglyhoobaes3695 whether it is pre-recorded or no they are stable, there are many videos where they sing live for example ningning and they are heard very stable, just say that you are jealous 🤷
Nobody seems to understand what pre-recorded even means. Everyone is saying they sound different from studio version so this is live. Please listen to someone or make some research since you always claim this. Pre-recorded singing is ALSO different from studio version. But when someone sings live, you can easily notice it. Even if they’re great vocalists, you can hear their HEAVY breathing and most importantly, their voices just don’t go perfectly smooth because of the dancing. This is impossible. Btw, look at Exo’s or Shinee’s facial expressions while hitting high notes. No one can hit that notes with a blank face. Being very stable and singing as if the dance moves weren't there are two different things. Aespa has a lot of potential and I KNOW they can sing live, but this performance is pre-recorded too. We’ll see their live singing soon. Let’s not push every single performance as live.
I agree that this is prerecorded but Ningning has sung Maria with a straight face(it probably had post production tweaks but its usually not far off), so I'm pretty sure she can hit these notes with a straight face still if they sing it live.
I feel like it’s half pre recorded half live. Cuz the high notes are rlly impossible to get that loud and powerful voice with their mouth opened so little.
Mys are gonna hate me for this but it needs to be said. They're clearly almost always lip syncing a pre recorded version. In the Black Mamba performance they're taking tiny and fast steps, during the chorus when the beat drops, they drop down, they're doing a literal workout and yet their voices aren't shaking one bit. if you say "oh that's normal for sm artists" no it's not. watch red velvet with bhk Mr removed you can still their voices are slightly shaky. aespa isn't even trying to hide the fact their lip syncing just look at their performances, they're barely moving their lips. watch videos on TH-cam, there's plenty that cover this topic.
They indeed sing it live but not when they performing this, they sing live and recording it, they use the recorded live on this stage, means they didn't sing while dancing/perform, they lipsync to their pre recorded-live. The recorded was live but this stage isn't live singing.
Sorry to disappoint a lot of y’all in these comments but they’re not singing live...they have good vocals so I don’t know why SM isn’t letting them singing live
I literally can't believe that many of you guys keep sayin' that they aren't able to sing live. In this stage we can clearly hear Giselle's little mistake, breaths on chorus and a voice crack on Ningning's high note. Aespa is for real a monster rookie.
*I'm in disbelief by the amount of delusional My's in the comment section. It's clearly pre-recorded, the irregularities are because they slightly sang to it at some parts during the performance. There's literally no breathing and everything's on beat. Now I'm convinced Aespa's fans are the most delusional, I even think they would even eat Aespa's poop if they were told that it's chocolate.*
This sounds more live than last stage. Also Giselle's little crack. I hope it's live. Edit: It's most likely pre recorded but let's wait for an Encore stage.
I think the live stage reserved only for their offline concert in the future… let’s admit that aespa rarely (or maybe never) singing live while dancing
@@AnnaBrown99 Yeah, that's why I'm hoping for an Encore. I know they can sing damn well but 80% (if not more) LMR stages is such a let down. Of course I'm not counting their radio preformances.
I think for live performances they are probably going to use a mix between pre-recorded vocals for the most difficult parts such as the high notes and also live vocals for other parts like the raps and some verses of the song 🤔
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 211012 aespa (에스파) Savage | The Performance Stage #1 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SOwGcnJlp8w/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 211012 aespa (에스파) Savage | The Performance Stage #1 MR제거](/img/tr.png)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 230218 aespa (에스파) Girls | Live Vocals Circle Chart Music Awards 2022 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/twvniPxNu30/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 220303 NMIXX (엔믹스) O.O | Live Vocals MR제거](/img/n.gif)
If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any MR Removed like aespa's that I post! Thanks for watching!!
Is this pre record? Or they sing live?
@@multistanarchive6076 it's Def pre-recorded. I wish sm let them sing live so bad
@@multistanarchive6076 This track is different from the other one, I'll wait for other stages to make 100% sure
@@BHKMRRemoved okay love ur account
@@yuna2500 we can't be so sure let's wait
Winter and Ningning's vocal make me crazy 😭😭😭
Ain't this pre-recorded?
@@nayeon4191 it aint
@@nayeon4191 i mean it is nice that you think it is prerecorded bcs their voice really are stable
@@halimahjantan1777 no because i heard they never sing live bcoz sm doesn't allow them
@@nayeon4191 gurl where did you got this info from💀
에스엠은 왜 라이브무대 안해주는거임? 에스파가 실력이 없는것도 아니고 1년차 다되가는 그룹인데 라이브무대가 하나도 없는건 좀.... 한번은 해줄수 있잖아 에스파만 괜히 욕먹는다고....
앵콜무대 하나만 기다린다 진짜....
근데 진지하게 곡난이도 높고 곡 무대 완성도를 위해서면 그냥 이렇게 mr 깔린게 좋은건 맞음... 가끔한두번씩 해주는건 좋지만 활동의 대부분이 라이브아니라고 머라하기엔조금 그렇죠 회사측에서 좀더 깔끔하고 완벽한걸 추구한걸수도 있으니 에스파가 실력있는건 가끔보여주는걸로도 잘알자나요 모 ㅎㅎ
@@swagqian4240 가수가 무대에서 노래를 해야지 뭔소리예요 그게 그룹 색깔로 치부될건 아니라고 보는데
@@cdeng289 라이브 하긴 함… ar깔고 그 위에 라이브하거나 라이브하고 나서 후보정 떡칠해서 티가 안나는거지
앵콜무대보고 왔는데 ㅈㄴ 잘하는데 왜 안해줬던거였냐..... 스엠아 디질래?
Ar 이 조금 섞여있는거 같긴 한데 중간중간 들어보면 음이 정확하지 않고 살짝 낮은 부분들이 있어요. 대체적으로 라이브는 맞는듯한데요.
Yes. Most not fully live. But def consists of live singing. 👍
ㅇㅈ
@@Nnnllll-u2l 알아요. (라이브)Ar 이라적을걸 그랬네요.ㅎ
@@효연김-p1m 아뇨 .. 사전으로 녹음한걸 트는거예요 라이브가아니라
@@jkim4729 방송용ar깐 위에다가 방송할때 본인들 직접목소리인 라이브로 했다구요ㅠ 하아..
아니 다른 라이브잘한다는 가수 엠알제거랑 비교했을때 이건 너무 숨소리뿐 아니라 몸을 저리움직이는데 미세한 떨림조차 없음 에스파 잘하긴하지만 이건 라이브아닌거가튼데..? 발성이나 발음이 조금씩 다른건 사전녹음때문인거 같구
내말이.. 근데 댓글들ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
다른 그룹 다 똑같음 근데 얘네가 춤 추면서도 노래 잘하는 건 팩트
@Takeout Music 댓글 기록 어질어질 하누 니가 좋아하는 그룹만 칭찬해 와서 까지 말고ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 에스파 팬인데 진짜 앵콜무대 블맘때부터 기다리는 중이에요… 아니 근데 사람들은 저걸 에스파가 불렀으니까 쨋든 라이브하건 말건 ㅇㅈㄹ하는데 솔직히 이 말은 아닌듯함요
@Takeout Music 제자리서 부른 마리아도 삑사리인데 후반에 춤추면서 저렇게 ;;팩폭..
춤추면서 노래하면 모든부분 다 부를수가없습니다.. 자잘한애드립까지도 다들리는데;; 그리고 아무리잘해도 이렇게 음정 단하나도 안흔들릴수가 없어요 쌩라이브는아니죠
That giselle’s little mistake during “everybody looks at me” speaks the fact that they was singing this one live
Yess
Yess
Yesssssss
The backtrack was a little loud, but it is still LIVE!
0:23 she's sound different here too
With many achievements that Savage has right now,
I’m SURE we at least going to see the encore of Savage where the girls will finally fully sing live 1000%.
Will they attend this week's music core 🥺, they will for sure win there, I really hope we'll get encore soon 😭
@@true-mrremoved656 i think they will just perform at MCount only as ning said they weren't promote at music show..but we wait and see
@@ainifajar7112 they are confirmed to perform in music core
This coming 16th for music core. Theyve got high chance to win n they attending
@@user1-b2g Oh yeahhhhh, thanks for the info!!
누가봐도 사녹이라 의미없음
팬들도 다알텐데
이걸보고 라이프판단하는건 오히려 악플러지
Can't wait for their encore stage, so it can slap to haters face that they really got a voice standard from SM
Yes can't wait too because there's so much people can't believe aespa singing live in this song. Hope aespa slap to haters when their win on MBC core
we will get their encore on saturday yass
@@zlftsn
I’m too, wait till their encore to slap to haters face:3
YESS, THEY ENCORE ON MUSIC CORE IN SATURDAY ❤❤🔥🔥
라이브 + ar인 것 같고 앵콜때 제대로 라이브 들릴 듯? 근데 에스파 실력 좋은 거 누가 몰라 ㅋㅋ 사녹 말고 제대로 라이브 느낌 나는 생방 같은 거 나오면 좋겠음 블랙맘바 때부터 항상 라이브로 말 많아서 에스파 속상하겠어
라이브로 말 나오는게 아니라 라이브를 한 적이 없는거 아님? 오늘 이것도 걍 녹음본이구만ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅇ그냥 라이브 ar이 생기고나서부터 요즘 음악방송들 시스템이 라이브가 거의 아닌것들을 라이브로 둔갑시키는 쪽에 가깝게 변질된듯.. 그나마 그안에선 특이하게 스테이씨가 소속사부터 생라이브를 고집해서 시원하게 밀고나간것같고 에스파같은 경우는 이미 사석이나 다른 예능,라디오 등에서 이미 넷 다 실력이 잘 입증되서 큰 걱정은 전혀 없지만 ㅠ애들 잘못은 아니고 그저 에스엠측에서 라이브를 많이 안보여주는 편인 것 같음 지금 음원성적 너무 좋으니까 1위하면 라이브 시원하게하고 그동안 계속 말나오던 부분들까지 싹다 청산하면 좋을듯?
@@meanon116 라이브 ar이 뭐임
애초에 지금까지 생 라이브로 한적이없음
에스파가 예전 무대 때 라이브라고 하긴했는데 음방이 후에 음원을 입히나?
Ningning’s low notes gave me goosebumps
음방에선 라이브 소리
절대 라이브 아님. 랩부분에서 음정 피치 조금씩 엇나가는게 보이는데 이게 춤추면서 부르는거라 숨 헐떡이는 소리도 조금씩 들어가야한단 말이지? 근데 피치가 떨어지는거지 호흡은 완벽 그자체임. 이런건 라이브일 수 가 없음. 라이브 ar이지
음방에 쓸 mr를 따로 녹음했을거같음..
원래 노래랑 다른건 확실히 알겠는데 노래하는데 표정이 너어무 그냥 말하는거처럼 잔잔한거같은데
평소에 프로그램 나와서 찐라이브하는거 보면 태연한 표정으로 노래부르진 않던디
앵콜무대라도 해야 뭐가 맞는질 알텐데 ,,
얘네 블맘부터 지금까지 다 그랬음 퍼포 위주라서 라이브 부담 안주려고 저러는건지
엥..
Why aespa always sing a pre-recorded song on the stage , I just wanna hear them live(live vocal) bcuz I love their voice .
カムバックする度にたくさんパフォーマンスを行うので、喉を痛めてしまわないようにしているのだと思います。
@@ちゃんらら-p6n でも一度も生歌ステージ観たことないです。。
It's not recorded
And if it is recorded prove it 😒
@@smadishahed2473 it is bro
@@blackpink2005 prove it then
I'm kinda looking forward to them singing the whole song without dancing to prove their haters wrong.
Nah, they just need to skip singing some part just to prove them singing live
@@veeday9822 to get scolded by SM, they are rookies, they do that and they are done for :(
They don't need to prove anything to the haters tho.
@@iamsedine9219 right??
@@iamsedine9219 we all know they're talented why prove it to haters huhu
I love winter’s tone and voice so much y’all don’t understand. I’m emotionally attached to her voice like I wanna be able to hear her sing forever, this is unhealthy.
honestly same
Same here ❤️🌸 pure bliss heavenly vocals 🤩 a true Ace indeed 😍
My bias
3:39 곡이 이정도 난도면 MR AR 상관없이 실력이 진짜 미친듯
트레이닝을 어떻게 시킨겨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이건 라이브 아닌것같기도한데..
@@pplaylist 네네 제가 말한건 라이브던 사녹이던 이정도 난도 애드립 소화하는거 자체를 말한거였어요!
어짜피 스튜디오용이고 튠만지고 하는건데 뭘또 미친 정도라고ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@pplaylist 근데 중간중간 라이브인 티가 나는부분이 꽤 있지 않나요?
@@ym45ify 요즘 걸그룹들 실력 비하면 월등한거 맞는데 에스파 잘하지 않음? 살짝쿵 꼬이셨는가
OMG Ningning's vocal just takes me to heaven. Her high notes are just so right and powerful.
*4th Gen Lip Sync Queens*
it's pre recorded tho 🌚
@@_.wxxdne yea people are dumb tho- not exactly dumb, they just are too toxic and trys to make their group look good, it isn't a crime to pre-record. Hell if I was a idol I'd do it too
@@blink_midzy5194 A SM NÃO OS DEIXA CANTAR, ENTENDA, TODOS ALI SÃO CAPAZES DE CANTAR MAIS ELES NÃO CANTAM POR CAUSA DA SM. NÃO JOGUE HATE PRA ELES POR CAUSA DISSO SEU ANORMAL
이번 음반이랑 음원만 보면 곧 앵콜직캠 볼 수있을 것같아요 ㅠㅠ 물론 춤추면서 라이브는 아니지만 그래도 어느정도 논란이 해소됬으면 좋겠네요 ㅠㅠ 에스파 화이팅!
이 무대 라이브인것같아요!
2:22
1:24
2:35
1:14
Whether it's live or pre-recorded, the thing we're sure is they can sing well, it's already given if you came from sm. I think they will sound the same as the studio version in live performances just like how their seniors when singing live.
THIS!!
Its live giselle's mistake at pronouncing really prove it plus u can hear them breathing especially winter
@@Mother_mizrahi Hmmm I'm not going to clarify something. But even if it's pre-recorded it's still their real voices, the thing about pre-recording is you will record every part and if they are not satisfied you will retake it until they get the best version of that part. I think it's by part, or maybe it's half live because of how hard the choreography. It's just my opinion feel free to correct me if you know something.
Exactly. But i hope sm will give them performance without any backtracks or pre recorded :( i mean that’s SM idols strength especially Girls Gen
@@primordialjade6807 I really hope that too..
진짜 에스파 잘하는거 알겠는데 라이브 무대 1번만 해주지 ㅋㅋ... 그러니까 팬들도 닝닝 말듣고 피의 쉴드치지 ㅋㅋ 라이브는 무슨... 에스파 진짜 좋아하는데 라이브 딱 1번만 했음 좋겠다 ㅋㅋ 레벨도 했는데 왜 못해...
시간 초 단위로 쪼개서 라이브 맞는지아닌지 확인하는거 진짜 ...에스파한테 레알 깐깐하게 구네 다들 말로는 실력이 궁금하다 하면서 어떻게든 평가하고 시비걸고싶어하는거 다 보이는데 ㅋㅋ 에이알이여도 본인들이 직접 녹음한거고 실력 다 알만한데 항상 ... 그렇게 생라이브 듣고싶으면 투표 좀 해주고 앨범 좀 사서 1등 라이브 시켜줘라
존나인정..
ㄹㅇㅋㅋㅋ진짜...영상 몇개만 찾아봐도 에스파 노래 ㅈㄴ 잘한다는거 알텐데ㅋ비하인드 영상 때 닝닝이 라이브 하고 마이크 켜져있다고 말도 했었고...다른 아이돌들도 첫주 때는 ar까는 경우가 대부분인데 에스파한테만 시비 오지게 걸음
아니 그리고 다들 대체 어떤 라이브를 원하는거임 무대에서 숨소리 다 들어가고 발음 다 씹히면서 까지 하는 걸 원하는 거임... ? 무대 하나를 완성하는건데 당연히 에이알 엠알도 깔겠지...
@@채연-y5d 스테이시처럼 생라이브를 하든가 라디오에서 라이브 한번 하든가 할 방법은 많은데?? 진짜 에스파 아티스트는 너무너무 좋은데 극성무뇌팬들때문에 짜증나네 튠으로 만질 수 있는것도 한계가 있어서 실력 좋은거 알고 백구는 내 폰 배경화면인데 솔직히 올라이브라고 생각되는 무대는 한번도 한적 없음 제발 얘들아 좋아하는건 같은 입장에서 이해하겠는데 합리적으로 생각좀 해 진짜 쪽팔려
Ningning Voice 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
그냥 유스케 출연하면 라이브냐 ar이냐 논란 싹다 없어질것을 솔직히 라이브같지않음 ㅠ 그노래잘한다는 아이유도 음원이랑 라이브랑 다른데ㅜ 에스파는 너무 똑같음… 이게 진짜 라이브면 (목소리 깔린거 말고) 진짜 사기캐다
유스케도 후보정인데..
원래 아이유는 음색이 뛰어나고 다채로운 장르가 소화 가능하면서 테크닉도 다재다능한 가수지 기본기에 충실하다거나 발성적으로 훌륭한 가수가 아님.. 아이유 라이브 피치 엄청 와리가리침. 작년부터 피치 와리가리 치는 기복이 좀 줄어들긴 했는데 ㅋㅋ
유스케도 보정해서 ㄴㄴ 음방 1위 앵콜무대나 라디오 라이브로 부르는 것 밖에는..ㅜㅜ
@@ffmm3717 ?? 유스케도 보정해요..? 거기 엠알제거하면 쌩라이브라고 유명하지 않았나
@@성이름-c5j6q 보정을 아예 안하는 음악 방송은 없죠 조금씩이라도 튠 만집니다
이렇게 너무 잘해버리면 사람들이 라이브니 아니니 말이 많아져버리잖아~~
This isn't live, you can see, their vocals are perfectly stable even after dancing hardly. I know aespa's vocals and raps are out of this world, I just hope sm allows aespa to sing live
this is live bro
@@lanhy9849 it's not, sm hasn't allowed aespa to live sing until the coachella concert happened
@@lanhy9849 lol :) bạn nên đi xem lại fancam aespa hát ở coachella nhé, xem mấy vid fan đăng chứ đừng xem vid của SM đăng vì nó chỉnh giọng r, đi xem đi r quay lại đây coi stage này có p là aespa hát live k nhé :)
@@lanhy9849 it's not
@Junjisblondestreak sm doesn't allow aespa, yeah breath control is a thing, but it doesn't mean ur voices can sound heavy or crack. Either way, the first time they actually sang live was in Coachella
이것도 라이브는 아닌 듯.
고음 파트는 다 사전 녹음 티가 너무 나네.
아직 에스파가 라디오에서도 쌩라이브를 보여준 적이 없는 거 같아서 아쉽..
I think they were singing live .Some of the tones were being varied if you listen to it carefully , it's different from the audio version in some parts . Such powerful singing !
It's pre-recorded, but we should vote and work hard so they can have their encore.. I know they can sing live..❤️
Ikr i've heard some differences from their performance stage on their own yt acc
@@leopaleracio1316 how and where can we vote?
@@leopaleracio1316 it's not but you do you
There are differences cause they pre-record different versions, everyone does it.
whether they sing live during music show or not, it's easy to find videos of ningning singing live and she has an amazing voice!! she's been singing since she was a kid and deserves her spot as the main vocal ❤️
She is.. There's no doubt
Don't get me wrong, It's seems to be a pre-recorded performance.
It is
There's something about Winter's voice. The way she sings it's sounds so angelic, she is putting her own technique while singing that's why it doesn't sounds plain and boring.
Before they were removed, I know they always sing live. especially Giselle's second rap part. it looks so different from the mv
that's what i was thinking
Yes and also ningning's highnote in the bridge part
Yas i hear too giselle second rap part
Winter part too
It's pre recorded :') they use tracks because of their concept.
i love winter's growl the most 💘 and also, listen to how they emphasized 'savage' 🔥
نم
라이브 기대하고 왔더니 사녹 무엇..? ㅋㅋㅋ 상상속의 라이브네 잘하는 것 같더만 왜 자꾸 감추나
저 춤 추면서 저 라이브가 가능하면 에스파>>>넘사>>>소향이지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
절대 라이브 아님. 랩부분에서 음정 피치 조금씩 엇나가는게 보이는데 이게 춤추면서 부르는거라
ㄹㅇ 라이브면 숨차서 헐떡이는 소리도 조금씩 들어가야한단 말이지? 핀마이크가 호흡은 걸러내고 음정만 잡아주는 신기술 마이크도 아니고 ㅋㅋㅋ 근데 들어보면 피치가 조금씩 떨어지는거지 호흡은 완벽 그자체임. 이런건 라이브일 수 가 없음. 라이브 ar이지..
에스파가 다른 여돌과는 차원이 다르게 실력이나 비주얼로 압도적인거 알겠는데 이건 라이브ar이지 절대 라이브가 아님. 그렇다고 에스파한테 다른 여돌이 라이브 비빌 수 있느냐? 그것도 절대 아님. 나 얘네처럼 라이브 개쩌는애들 첨본다 ㄹㅇ..
@산타클로스메리크리스마스 네 귀는 있고? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I know people will only be convinced after the encore but IVE BEEN TELLING YOU!!! they sing like this while dancing. NO we don't hear the live track in the performance videos, but they are NOT lipsyncing. They have multiple takes and take whichever dance+camerawork+vocals worked best SEPERATELY. It wasn't so noticeable in Next level and Black mamba because those songs are not that vocally challenging and so aespa could perform it consistently, but you can already hear the differences for each stage of Savage.
Yessssss
I can't wait for their encore stages to prove the haters wrong🥰💖
That doesn't make any sense to do that
It's obvious that it's pre-recorded, it's not live. look at their mouths for god, they don't even move
@@jangerardo5070 i think that's the point of op's comment, they choose the best cuts of camerawork, dancing and singing separately then combine it for the final edited performance that's why it doesn't match bc diff takes but live vocals
Ningning really... her voice are so beautiful, she is so talented really, MAIN VOCAL SHE IS !
if it's pre recorded or not they still had to sing this song:) stable queen !! Purr 💅🏻🔥
Periodt
에이 sm 소시 레벨 샤이니 엑소 다 라이브 장인들인데 이번에 ㅈㄴ열심히 만든 에스파가 못하겠냐마는..논란이라고 이때라고 물어뜯는애들 웃기기도하고ㅋㅋ
レベル高すぎ……👏😭
ごめんだけどこれは先に録音したやつです💦
이건 사전녹음 맞음
Honestly ningning and winter voice suit for disney tbb. Meanwhile giselle and karina voice suit for ost.
SM 트릭은 너무 잘 되는 것 같았는데, 그들의 아티스트들은 뛰어난 재능을 가지고 있기 때문에 언제 라이브로 노래를 부를지 궁금하네요…
i'm so tired can't we all just appreciate their raw vocals instead of fighting whether it's live or prerecorded? because either way it's aespa's vocals and the show of sheer talent is beyond impressive
아니 근데 숨소리가 어떻게 하나도 안들림??ㄷㄷ 라이브 잘한다는 스테이씨도 중간중간에 숨소리 많이 들리던데 이게 가능한가?
스테이시는 그냥 작정하고 생 라이브하는거고 이거랑 그거는 경우가 다른듯 조정은 팀마다 다르니까
@@dahlia2687 그러는 에스파는 라이브 제대로 한 적도 없는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-uu4wr1pc3j 라이브가 아니라서 그럽니다
This is perfect. (I’m not their fan by the way)
WINTER's voice is captivating 😭
winter's low notes are so on point ✨
라이브는 맞지만 ar이 섞여잇는거지 닝닝 저거 고음 백퍼 ar임 근대 에스파 실력은 좋은듯
이거지 ar은 맞지만 실력을 부정하진 않
내가 이걸 말하고 싶었다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 아니 아이돌알못들 답답해죽겠음 걍 얘네 잘하는 거 부정하고 싶은가봄
에스파 라이브 잘하는건 아는형님이랑 에스파 공식 유투브 보면 알수 있는데 이건 누가봐도 ar이거나 사전녹음인데 라이브라고 그만 우겼으면 좋겠음...라이브라고 우길수록 에스파랑 마이들만 욕 먹는거임.. 라이브 잘하는건 맞는데 저건 사녹/ar인거는 맞지
LOVE NING NING’S VOCAL 🥰🥰🥰
Haters gonna hate, aespa still aespa and they're talented in their own way. PROUD MY GIRLS
yes
and some of Chinese netizens(akgaes most) still hate Winter smh OMG
@@Agnes_4746 why even
@@purpleplanet888 they still have said Winter that is Royal(negative word for Chinese meaning of 皇族 and usually using by any auditions through tvs)🥲 as they have said that she has gotten the most parts but not stable when she live singing
이거 라이브 맞을수도 있지 않냐는 분들은 같은 채널에 있지랑 스테이씨 영상들이 쌩라이브니 그거 보고오면 됨
이거 걍 live ar 깐거 아닌가
무대용 녹음자체를 따로 한건데 이거 보고 음원이랑 다르니까 라이브야 하는거 좀 웃기다ㅋㅋ
Okay i love aespa but sm we're not a dumb it's pre-recorded , sm just let them sing live
これ歌ってんのまじで音源すぎてやばい
ジゼルのとこで歌ってんだってわかって他完璧すぎてびびった
코로나 이후로 몇몇 아이돌들 무대 보면 라이브 ar 쓴거 너무 티남.. 방송사마다 라이브 ar이 똑같애..
Winter and Ningning; their voices made me speechless and love their voices the most
I love Karina's voice
I love the way Giselle rapped her part
im so glad that my girls singing live powerfully and confidently. they're so talented and they knew it.
this is clearly prerecorded, it's so crazy that people really believe people can sing like this while dancing
Ikr
Iri bgt lu jelas2 live
*4th Gen Lip Sync Queens*
aespa is insane~
근데 이런 기술 중에 mr제거가 진짜 어려운거라했음 그래서 유튜브에 엠알제거라고 나와있는거 대부분 진짜아니라고
겟미겟미나우 이거 음원ㄹ랑 음정 살짝 다른게 라이브인듯 발음도 그렇고 넥레떼 립싱크 오해받은거 빡쳐서 이갈앗나..
ar도 들리긴하는데 라이브랑 확실히 구분되서 들림 이정도면 우리가 평가할수준이 아님 ㄹㅇ 아이돌중에서 탑3안에듬 앵콜때 라이브듣고 좀 안좋다하는데 그건 놀면서 부른거고 이거 자세히들어보면 ar이랑 발음이나 바이브레이션 꺾는거나 포르타멘토 넣는거나 박자타는게 확실히 다름
앵콜도 듣고 왔고 실력 좋은 거 너무 알겠는데 이건 존나 ar인 거 앵콜 듣고 나니까 더 확실함. 춤 안 추면서 부른 앵콜이랑 춤 존나 빡쎄기 추면서 부르는 이 mr 제거 듣고서도 이게 라이브라고 우기는 애들은 그냥 귀 막고 에스파빠라는 거고.
춤 안 추면서도 닝닝이 저음역대 안 나와서 거의 안 들리게 부르고 고음역대도 반가성 처리 해서 힘 없이 들리는데 어떻게 춤 추면서 부르는데 이 정도로 목소리 퀄리티가 균일하게 나오냐고. 후보정이거나 노래따로 녹음해서 무대용 ar 깐거임. 이런 식으로 하는 애들은 mr 제거 해봤자 소용이 없지 뭐..ㅋㅋ
얘네 다 존나 잘 하고 실력 있는 건 알겠는데 영영 춤추면서 하는 쌩라이브는 못 들어볼 듯.
*Aespa = Queens of outstanding vocals!*
If you think this is live , you need to come back down to reality
😂😂 these people live in their kwangya
lol istg
이거 mr녹음하고 틀어놓는거임 숨소리도 잘 안들리잖아. 애초에 음이 이렇게 깔끔할 수 없음.
They’re so stable wtf. They’re absolute SM stars.
it’s pre- recorded WTF
@@uglyhoobaes3695 they still sing it live. And ofc they need a pre-recorded background…if you don’t know how live performance work then I suggest you to stay silence cuz you’re showing how ignorant you are.
@@Anonymous-qj4wp omg i’m not hating them chill okay?
@@uglyhoobaes3695 if you had a good sense of pitch you would know not the whole thing is pre recorded
@@uglyhoobaes3695 whether it is pre-recorded or no they are stable, there are many videos where they sing live for example ningning and they are heard very stable, just say that you are jealous 🤷
Stanning SM artists get blessed with gorgeous vocals like this
라이브 절대 아닌 거 같은데여;;;
에스파 실력은 의심지 않지만
아무리 실력이 좋아도 이 곡을 댄스와 더불어 이렇게 부르는 건 불가능하지 않나요?
소녀시대도 이건 불가능
그 라이브잘하는 태연 전소연같은애도 라이브바로 티나는데 ㅋㅋ 진짜믿고싶은대로믿네
Their vocals are insane
Nobody seems to understand what pre-recorded even means. Everyone is saying they sound different from studio version so this is live. Please listen to someone or make some research since you always claim this. Pre-recorded singing is ALSO different from studio version. But when someone sings live, you can easily notice it. Even if they’re great vocalists, you can hear their HEAVY breathing and most importantly, their voices just don’t go perfectly smooth because of the dancing. This is impossible. Btw, look at Exo’s or Shinee’s facial expressions while hitting high notes. No one can hit that notes with a blank face.
Being very stable and singing as if the dance moves weren't there are two different things.
Aespa has a lot of potential and I KNOW they can sing live, but this performance is pre-recorded too. We’ll see their live singing soon. Let’s not push every single performance as live.
Exactly! Slap them with that reality!
this one needs to be pinned
I have yet to see them perform with LIVE vocals and not pre-recorded ones.
I agree that this is prerecorded but Ningning has sung Maria with a straight face(it probably had post production tweaks but its usually not far off), so I'm pretty sure she can hit these notes with a straight face still if they sing it live.
@@leonardodavinny421 maybe, but add dancing and then she can’t anymore
Winter❤
1:14 1:16 닝닝은 음이 좀 낮았고 윈터는 음이 좀 높았는데 ㄹㅇ 이거 라이브임..???
라이브 맞는듯 음정 좀 틀렸네
2:35 부터도 음정 약간 흔들림 라이브 맞음
두번째껀 진짜네 에브리바디할때도 앞에 약간 삑남
미리 녹음한 라이브음원이라구여.. 저 무대에서 라이브하면서 춤춘게 아니구요
@@ffmm3717 2:08 2:49처럼 바이브레이션이나 저음을 춤추며 하기 힘들 것 같긴해요.. 숨소리도 거의 없고 .. 완전 리얼하게 녹음한건가..
*I'm convinced they don't just eat CD's but whole studio!* QUEENS OF VOCALS
Hahaha yeah
I think it's pre-recorded
Keep fooling yourself 💀
i finally found someone with an actual brain
이게 무슨 라이브야
This is the only mr removed channel which i believe💜
I feel like it’s half pre recorded half live. Cuz the high notes are rlly impossible to get that loud and powerful voice with their mouth opened so little.
Mys are gonna hate me for this but it needs to be said. They're clearly almost always lip syncing a pre recorded version. In the Black Mamba performance they're taking tiny and fast steps, during the chorus when the beat drops, they drop down, they're doing a literal workout and yet their voices aren't shaking one bit. if you say "oh that's normal for sm artists" no it's not. watch red velvet with bhk Mr removed you can still their voices are slightly shaky. aespa isn't even trying to hide the fact their lip syncing just look at their performances, they're barely moving their lips. watch videos on TH-cam, there's plenty that cover this topic.
이렇게 하니깐 립싱크라하지ㅋㅋㅋ
ㅈㄴ 잘하네 ㄹㅇ
너무 잘해도 문제야..
NINGNINGGGGGG
They indeed sing it live but not when they performing this, they sing live and recording it, they use the recorded live on this stage, means they didn't sing while dancing/perform, they lipsync to their pre recorded-live. The recorded was live but this stage isn't live singing.
이건 라이브여도 ar 틀고 한 것 같은데...첫방이니까... 음방 1위할 거니까 앵콜무대에서 제대로 된 라이브 보면 될 것 같슴다
Sorry to disappoint a lot of y’all in these comments but they’re not singing live...they have good vocals so I don’t know why SM isn’t letting them singing live
eh but they singing live tho, you can hear their aspiration especially when Giselle did her part
SM artist : nyanyilah sejernih mungkin sampe dibilang lip sync😉
I literally can't believe that many of you guys keep sayin' that they aren't able to sing live. In this stage we can clearly hear Giselle's little mistake, breaths on chorus and a voice crack on Ningning's high note.
Aespa is for real a monster rookie.
Ningning sang the bridge perfectly. And giselle didn't make a mistake she just change that part. Stop saying those things
@@crystalcastle660 that little off key on "everybody"? thats not "just change that part"
@@crystalcastle660 And why tf you get mad bc of my comment? It's a normal thing, they're not robots.
@@crystalcastle660 Stop acting like idols do everything perfectly. They are not robots they can make mistakes and it's ok
@@paulamarian644 i'm not mad i just don't hear it
Winter is so stable omg
Oh my gosh, don't you know I'm a savage? 🙄💅🏼
Saveege
*I'm in disbelief by the amount of delusional My's in the comment section. It's clearly pre-recorded, the irregularities are because they slightly sang to it at some parts during the performance. There's literally no breathing and everything's on beat. Now I'm convinced Aespa's fans are the most delusional, I even think they would even eat Aespa's poop if they were told that it's chocolate.*
Bruh you have made 20 comments hating on Aespa its not even constructive criticisim it's just blatant hate LMAOAOAOAO you're embarassing
They're literally jumping how are they not losing breath this is not live
This sounds more live than last stage. Also Giselle's little crack. I hope it's live.
Edit: It's most likely pre recorded but let's wait for an Encore stage.
THIS IS LIVE, HEAR IT CAREFULLY
@@drax369 There's a fine line between LMR and actual live. But I don't doubt their skills, I'm sure they will do well on Encore.
I think the live stage reserved only for their offline concert in the future… let’s admit that aespa rarely (or maybe never) singing live while dancing
@@AnnaBrown99 Yeah, that's why I'm hoping for an Encore. I know they can sing damn well but 80% (if not more) LMR stages is such a let down. Of course I'm not counting their radio preformances.
@@AB-yk2pq Idol usually not dancing while doing encore… It’s pretty much the same with radio performances
I think for live performances they are probably going to use a mix between pre-recorded vocals for the most difficult parts such as the high notes and also live vocals for other parts like the raps and some verses of the song 🤔
사전 녹음한걸로 립싱크 하는거같은데... 에스파는 솔직히 이제까지 모든 무대를 이렇게 한거같음
1:14 1:24 2:35 2:22
너무 잘해서 립싱크 논란 뜨는 게 사실이었네요
이번에 첫주부터 라이브해서 제대로 인증하려나봅니다🥰
Just remember guys 4th gen is a generation where the idols are very versatile.
음방용을 녹음실에서 따로 녹음합니다! 아예 생 라이브는 1위 앵콜때 들을 수 있어요
지젤랩말고 노래도 들어보고싶다♡
@@user-mj7wf9mk7g 아! 넵♡
지젤 이곡도 애드립 있어요!
그 머야 수록곡에서 노래 불러요!!!!!