Good luck to the winner! I’m a patron but can’t enter as in the UK, but I have rugs years Llewelyn one and I love it. So highly recommend that to anyone
I love everyone of them. I think my favorite would be Llewellyn because they are great with tarot and my other favorite would be the biggest one that's pink. I have been watching your channel since I started my witchcraft journey and u have been my favorite to watch along the way. Keep doing great. #4 is my favorite. I tried joining
Let me start with saying I really enjoy your videos. Your voice is so calming and pleasant. As a person who recently restarted her spiritual journey, I would say the Llewellyn book would work best for me. It would really help me focus on daily tasks I need to practice my craft and learn. I like the fact that the appendix has corespondances about colors, srystals, etc. This would be very beneficial for me in my learning journey. Thank you again, and I think all the books are lovely!
I have purchased a Llewellyn witchy journal every year. I really do like it. But I’m very intrigued by the make my own magic planner by Selene Fayer. I’m really interested in that one. Good luck to me and thank you for doing this.
I really like the Year of the Witch planner, it looks like a great format to stick in a bag. It also corresponds most to how I tend to do my planning (not to mention the artwork is lovely)
Ooooo! I love the Year of the Witch if I have to pick a fav. All are great planners! I’ve used Llewellyn’s planner for a few years now and can attest to its value! 😊
A friend of mine presented me with The Witches' Datebook 2002, and I've bought one every year since. I've checked out other datebooks and planners, but I really enjoy the Llewellyn book and find it as entertaining as it is practical. :) Blessed Be, friends...and may all your plans come to joyous fruition!
Hello! I’m new here but have been watching your TH-cam for a couple of months. I really enjoy it. I was legit just looking at the Year of the Witch 2024 planner just a few days ago o online! So I’ll say that one. I really like the habit tracker! That’s a feature I know I’ll definitely use. It also looks nice and sturdy so I can toss it in my bag. I also really like the “Making My Own Planner”. I love the gratitude page. The info pages and layout looks great. I do enjoy the look and vibe of it. Thank you for doing a giveaway. Very cool to be part of your Patreon.
I love the Year of the Witch planner. I love the compact size, simplicity, and the moons & ravens. But they are all great. Thank you for the opportunity to possibly win one of these planners.💜
You have some of the coolest videos! I've been watching your videos for a few years and was happy to find you on Etsy! Your voice is always smooth and calming. Thanks for the giveaway! I like planner #4. Peace and blessings💜💥💫
I always used to get the Llewelyn planner but stopped years ago for no particular reason. This year, however, I won a book token, so treat myself! It’s a lovely planner but I always have to do maths to figure out the planetary times as I’m in the UK and it’s in EST.
Thank you for the giveaway! I've joined patreon to follow you there. I love books 2, 4, and 1. Love your channel even though I don't comment often. Caren
I always enjoy your videos, and your Patreon looks fun. Thank you! All of these look great, but my favorite is the Year of the Witch Weekly planner. I love the artwork and the size. My planners tend to be used for more than one year since I don't usually fill them up. I either ignore the dates or write new ones in. Or they might wind up as art journals. ✨Many Blessings✨
I love your planning vodeos, they inspire me, I love the Llewellyn planner because I think it would be perfect for how I plan. I have also never had one like that either. I like to make short notes on the month page and then more descriptions if needed in the note page.
Thank you Amy for reviewing all these planners. I have never done well with these types of planners. The one that I have been using consistently ever since I found your channel is the Weekly Planner that you created and is available on Amazon. I enjoy putting the planner stickers that as a patreon of yours I get for free, and the layout really works well for me. I have purchased so many planners in my lifetime that I only used for a few months, and that was not the case with yours. Thank you for ALL that you do for your patreons and for the excellent content you create. Sending you much love and appreciation.
thanks so much! I am changing the layout for 2024, but I will be leaving the original design available as well. So if you fell in love with it, it will still be around
Oooh! That sounds exciting and I look forward to seeing what the new layout will be. Happy that the original one will still be around just in case! 🌛🌕🌜
I admire how elegant the Year of the WItch one looks and the wall calendar would be a great addition. This planner is also informative and educational. I love this one!
I’ve used many of these planners in years past with varying levels of success. Last year I started using the one from Goddess Provisions and it is the first one which has actually worked for me. I did really love the Year of the Witch though. It seemed to use all the pages I’ve been successful with in the past.
They are all so special in their own ways. I like the Year of the Witch, but the Modern- Day Witch speaks to me the most with the artworkand color. It matches one of my favorite magical books. 😊
The Making My Own Magic planner seems more of a journal for the year, which I think is a refreshing way to approach something categorized as a planner. I've been experimenting with different formats of planners for years but have yet to try something designed that way.
The Llewellyn Witches Date Book I have for 2024 I use to get quite awhile back, but stopped for awhile, but came back to them. The Year of the Witch Planner by Temperance Alden looks really BEAUTIFUL!!!! Such a variety of Witchy Planners for different people and tastes.
The Year of the Witch and The Witches Datebook felt best,but I liked them all for various reasons. Thank you for sharing and the generous giveaway. You always give me much inspiration and calm. Be safe
Thank You so much for doing this!!!❤ I have a couple of planners in a year. One a desktop and the other I carry. I would love if you look into other planners, if possible keep them all the same size in each video. Thank you Thank you Blessings to you
I've always liked Lewellyn's frst because there is so much information on the weekly pages. I never used one as a planner tho because I prefer ring-bounds that have Monday start dates for the month as well as week so I print them myself. As for witchy coloring book planners, I'm kinda surprised you didn't cover Amy Cesari's Coloring Book of Shadows PLanner 2024 in both their B&W for coloring and full-color version too.
I've always been a Lewellyn witch but I really like that first one - a lot. Thanks for introducing us to other planners. Blessed Be
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Same here. I have used the Llewellyn for years but I might have to try Year of the Witch next year.
I bought the year of the witch to use and love it. It is big enough to write in for what I need and small enough to carry in my purse.
All the planners are wonderful, but I prefer the Making My Own Magic Planner.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Thanks to all who entered. The giveaway ended on All Hallows Eve 2023 and is now complete.
I do like them but I still prefer the space given in your planners. I write a lot and don’t like things too cramped.
They’re all so nice, but I prefer the first one the most. 😊
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I like the art in the Year of the Witch, and its smaller size makes it great to take anywhere.
I've been using the Year of the Witch planner for about 5 years now. Nothing else really compares, it's just perfection.
As a "newer" witch, the Modern-Day Witch Planner seems to be most helpful to me because it IS like a spell book as well. ;)
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I love the year of the witch planner the best. Fits my style perfectly
Year if the witch is lovely! I love the smallness 😊 That's exactly what I need for my magical work.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Honestly i think they all have a great purpose but for me the Year of the Witch would be most beneficial. Thank you for the giveaway and your channel!
They all have their own appeal, but I especially like the traditional Llewelyn’s 2024 datebook.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Shard, I liked them all, but I think I have to say the last one. It felt like a workbook almost.... with lots of space to work in.
Thank you for walking through these planners. I really liked the Llewellyn.
Good luck to the winner! I’m a patron but can’t enter as in the UK, but I have rugs years Llewelyn one and I love it. So highly recommend that to anyone
If I win though... I would appreciate the Lewellyn one. 😀😁😉🎃🌛🌕🌜
I really liked the Make Your Magic Planner/Calendar.
I loved the final planner - Making my own magical planner the best but they are all fantastic! Thank you for doing this give away!
The Witches' Datebook isy fvaorite
I'm going to change my mind 😂. I love the last one!! 😊❤
They all look interesting - but I've always wanted to get a Llewellyn planner but never have.. Thanks for the video
Hey MC. I’m catching up on your videos. ❤. Beautiful planner.
I love everyone of them. I think my favorite would be Llewellyn because they are great with tarot and my other favorite would be the biggest one that's pink. I have been watching your channel since I started my witchcraft journey and u have been my favorite to watch along the way. Keep doing great. #4 is my favorite. I tried joining
I watch you all the time
The Witches’ Datebook 2024 would be most beneficial for learning.
I like the year of witch very pretty especially the planner part ,I actually like all of the planners very nice giveaway thank you 😊
I love bigger books so the Make Your Own is my favorite!
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I think I like the year of the witch planner
Let me start with saying I really enjoy your videos. Your voice is so calming and pleasant. As a person who recently restarted her spiritual journey, I would say the Llewellyn book would work best for me. It would really help me focus on daily tasks I need to practice my craft and learn. I like the fact that the appendix has corespondances about colors, srystals, etc. This would be very beneficial for me in my learning journey. Thank you again, and I think all the books are lovely!
They are all lovely! The first one is my favorite.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I have purchased a Llewellyn witchy journal every year. I really do like it. But I’m very intrigued by the make my own magic planner by Selene Fayer. I’m really interested in that one. Good luck to me and thank you for doing this.
I like the first one because its so portable.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Your coffee looks delish, by the way!
Ooh this is really hard. But i will go for the modern day witch !! ☺️ i will definitely use this for sure!
I really like the Year of the Witch planner, it looks like a great format to stick in a bag. It also corresponds most to how I tend to do my planning (not to mention the artwork is lovely)
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I really appreciate you and your channel, thank you.
Ooooo! I love the Year of the Witch if I have to pick a fav. All are great planners! I’ve used Llewellyn’s planner for a few years now and can attest to its value! 😊
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I would love to win the modern-day witch. Personally I love the symbols in the 4 corners of earth, air, fire, and water beautiful design
A friend of mine presented me with The Witches' Datebook 2002, and I've bought one every year since. I've checked out other datebooks and planners, but I really enjoy the Llewellyn book and find it as entertaining as it is practical. :)
Blessed Be, friends...and may all your plans come to joyous fruition!
Yes, Llewellyn is my favorite. And I like knowing that so many other witches use it, makes me feel more connected.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I have always liked the Llewellyn's Witches' Datebook and have purchased a few times but I haven’t recently.
Thank you for sharing your video.
The witches date book seems perfect. Alot of information, things to try and if you haven't done it before.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
@@MagicalCrafting i did I put my real name I need to see if I can change it.
Your planners are lovely! My favorite that I'd love to win is the Witchy Planner #4😍
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Planner #1 would be awesome! Thank you so much! ❤❤❤
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I think I like Making My Own Magic Planner the best, I love coloring ❤ thank you for the opportunity
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Hello! I’m new here but have been watching your TH-cam for a couple of months. I really enjoy it.
I was legit just looking at the Year of the Witch 2024 planner just a few days ago o online! So I’ll say that one. I really like the habit tracker! That’s a feature I know I’ll definitely use. It also looks nice and sturdy so I can toss it in my bag.
I also really like the “Making My Own Planner”. I love the gratitude page. The info pages and layout looks great. I do enjoy the look and vibe of it.
Thank you for doing a giveaway. Very cool to be part of your Patreon.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I love the Year of the Witch planner. I love the compact size, simplicity, and the moons & ravens. But they are all great. Thank you for the opportunity to possibly win one of these planners.💜
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
@@MagicalCrafting I did. 😊
You have some of the coolest videos! I've been watching your videos for a few years and was happy to find you on Etsy! Your voice is always smooth and calming. Thanks for the giveaway!
I like planner #4. Peace and blessings💜💥💫
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
i love the Year of the Witch planner-thank you for the opportunity
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
All planners are beautiful. I would love the making my own magic planner. ❤
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
❤ very hard to choose I love them all but modern day is great
Love this video! I enjoyed the flip-through and review on these planners. I really like the Year of the Witch Planner the most!
I love them all, but the last one is kind of cool!
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I like the last one
Thank you for sharing! Its hard to choose but i think i like #2 the most, but #4 is a close second! ❤
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I always used to get the Llewelyn planner but stopped years ago for no particular reason. This year, however, I won a book token, so treat myself! It’s a lovely planner but I always have to do maths to figure out the planetary times as I’m in the UK and it’s in EST.
These are beautiful!
Joined! Making my own magic planner by Selene Fayir. Thank for hosting a giveaway, very kind of you❤ love your videos!
Thank you for the giveaway! I've joined patreon to follow you there. I love books 2, 4, and 1. Love your channel even though I don't comment often.
Caren
I like the make your own magic planner
Wow, I love the Making My Own Magick planner! To be honest though, the Year of the Witch planner is nice too.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
@@MagicalCrafting I'm already a patron. Do I need to do anything else?
This was a timely video! I was planning on getting a planner. Thank you for this review 😊
I always enjoy your videos, and your Patreon looks fun. Thank you! All of these look great, but my favorite is the Year of the Witch Weekly planner. I love the artwork and the size. My planners tend to be used for more than one year since I don't usually fill them up. I either ignore the dates or write new ones in. Or they might wind up as art journals.
✨Many Blessings✨
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Joined 🎉 these are some great picks! I am most interested in the Making my Own Magic. It's innovative and I love the large size. 🎃
I would love to have making a new planner. But I would love any one of them
i liked the first or the last planner all very cute
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
The witches date book. They are all lovely though! 💖
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I love your planning vodeos, they inspire me, I love the Llewellyn planner because I think it would be perfect for how I plan. I have also never had one like that either. I like to make short notes on the month page and then more descriptions if needed in the note page.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I love all of the planners I am more interested in the last one if I have to pick one I love them all
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I like the first one. It's more practical. Smaller than the rest, yet packed with goodies. I don't have a US address 😢
Very pretty 😀
Thank you Amy for reviewing all these planners. I have never done well with these types of planners. The one that I have been using consistently ever since I found your channel is the Weekly Planner that you created and is available on Amazon. I enjoy putting the planner stickers that as a patreon of yours I get for free, and the layout really works well for me. I have purchased so many planners in my lifetime that I only used for a few months, and that was not the case with yours. Thank you for ALL that you do for your patreons and for the excellent content you create. Sending you much love and appreciation.
thanks so much! I am changing the layout for 2024, but I will be leaving the original design available as well. So if you fell in love with it, it will still be around
Oooh! That sounds exciting and I look forward to seeing what the new layout will be. Happy that the original one will still be around just in case! 🌛🌕🌜
I admire how elegant the Year of the WItch one looks and the wall calendar would be a great addition. This planner is also informative and educational. I love this one!
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Thank you 💗
Nice! I like the Llewelyn and the last one- magickal year
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
@@MagicalCrafting I did thanks!
I’ve used many of these planners in years past with varying levels of success. Last year I started using the one from Goddess Provisions and it is the first one which has actually worked for me. I did really love the Year of the Witch though. It seemed to use all the pages I’ve been successful with in the past.
Excelent review!
They are all so special in their own ways. I like the Year of the Witch, but the Modern- Day Witch speaks to me the most with the artworkand color. It matches one of my favorite magical books. 😊
I live in Alpine, Ca it's nice to know your close by
oh another SD local! yay!
The Making My Own Magic planner seems more of a journal for the year, which I think is a refreshing way to approach something categorized as a planner. I've been experimenting with different formats of planners for years but have yet to try something designed that way.
The Llewellyn Witches Date Book I have for 2024 I use to get quite awhile back, but stopped for awhile, but came back to them. The Year of the Witch Planner by Temperance Alden looks really BEAUTIFUL!!!!
Such a variety of Witchy Planners for different people and tastes.
I really liked looking through other planners! I love the Llewellyn one though. Their annual guides etc are the best!
Making my own magic planner please!
The Year of the Witch and The Witches Datebook felt best,but I liked them all for various reasons. Thank you for sharing and the generous giveaway. You always give me much inspiration and calm. Be safe
Planners are a fantastic idea. Loved all of them.
I love them all! Year of the Witch, big pink planner, modern day witch.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Year of the witch and Llewellyn planners are great. I enjoyed used them both.
That first one Year of the Witch is so cute but TBH all of them are lovely!
Thank you for this giveaway opportunity. I would like to receive the "Making My Own Magic Planner". I am already a Patreon member.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I have.@@MagicalCrafting
Thank You so much for doing this!!!❤
I have a couple of planners in a year. One a desktop and the other I carry.
I would love if you look into other planners, if possible keep them all the same size in each video.
Thank you Thank you
Blessings to you
🤦 I like Year of the witch 2024 weekly planner
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Thank you! All the planners are so beautiful. I especially love the modern witch planner. Thank you for the opportunity.
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I really like the year of the witch! Thank you for this giveaway! Blessed Samhain and Blessed Be!
I'm a complete planner addict, this is terrible, I need all of them and yet I have very little to plan!
I've always liked Lewellyn's frst because there is so much information on the weekly pages. I never used one as a planner tho because I prefer ring-bounds that have Monday start dates for the month as well as week so I print them myself. As for witchy coloring book planners, I'm kinda surprised you didn't cover Amy Cesari's Coloring Book of Shadows PLanner 2024 in both their B&W for coloring and full-color version too.
I’m surprised too!
Love love them all how can t get for each if I ever get money
Love your voice ❤
Loving gratitude 🙏💜💜💜💜 Planner #4
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
Planner #4
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034
I find it hard to decide between the ‘year of the witch’ or the ‘making my own magic’ one.
I like aspects of all four planners. So if I were lucky enough to win I would appreciate if someone would choose intuitively for me
💜 Make sure to enter on Patreon. Link to Enter the giveaway:
www.patreon.com/posts/91199034