ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 เม.ย. 2022
- Unity in diversity is India's strength and any attempt at "language chauvinism" will boomerang, Telangana minister K T Rama Rao has said, joining the chorus from the south against Home Minister Amit Shah's pitch to propagate Hindi.
About NDTV: NDTV brings you unbiased and comprehensive coverage of news and entertainment programmes in India and abroad. NDTV delivers reliable information across all platforms: TV, Internet and Mobile.
Follow us on Social Media:
Like us on Facebook: / ndtv
Follow us on Twitter: / ndtv
Follow us on Koo: www.kooapp.com/profile/ndtv
Follow us on Instagram: / ndtv
Join NDTV on Telegram Messenger: t.me/NDTVbot/?start=hi
Follow us on Google News for Breaking and Latest News Updates:
NDTV: bit.ly/3e5ngbP
NDTV India (Hindi News): bit.ly/3mNVwMY
Download NDTV Mobile Apps: www.ndtv.com/page/apps
#HindiPitch #KTR #AmitShah
Im a native hindi speaker. I stand with our people in the south. You cant impose a language on anyone. India should celebrate its diversity rather than making it a tool to fight over. I also request the south Indian community to maintain peace over the issue and not discriminate among the north Indians studying, working in your states because they have nothing to do with what an ignorant man says.
@@nelly2503 a very long story.
I would recommend you to read the debates about the national language.
You'll find all your answers
Thankyou
@@nelly2503 Hindi Speaking People will Get a benefit here if Hindi is Made Compulsory from Academics to Official Work
❤️
Hindi has no value
Tamil is older than Hindi!! I’m a North Indian but will defend to death the right for the southerners to keep their own language!
Thanks mate. 👍
Tamil is the oldest language in the world with a rich culture and literature. we will never accept hindi imposition. if you want a unifying language other than English, then everyone can learn Tamil.
There Is no problem in keeping Your language But atleast Learn Hindi
@@daku7689 Would you learn Tamil ?
@@nisarabdulkader6436 Is Tamil the Official Language of the Nation according to Article 343(1) ? If yes, will learn Tamil. If not, No.
Learned Hindi in Childhood, started speaking by watching TV and movies. Stopped using it after being bullied over accent, comments about south Indians can't speak proper Hindi . For me it was another language, but for few others it was a tool to dominate.
Ignore them brother . You should learn whichever language you want to learn . if anyone makes fun of your accent just smile and curse them in your native language
Agree
I always used to say : " I can at least speak broken Hindi. How much of Telugu can you guys speak ? "
But i believe you speak Better Hindi. Then Delhi walas XD
@@danischannel you can always fake an accent. When speaking European languages speak with throat then mouth. When speaking asian languages use mouth.
Amitshah can't speak English doesn't mean every body should speak hindi. Instead of hiding his weakness should learn proper english.
get out of your colonial habit..you aren't a slave anymore
His mother tongue is Gujarati, and if he can speak Hindi for others' understanding, then why can't other regional leaders ?
Hey Ramakrishna up for any scam in SEBI🤣🤣
@@rohansharma3658 i am stressing same thing he learnt hindi. to penetrate hindi belt, now he is imposing hindi ( which he knows ) in non hindi speaking states. He learnt hindi with motto. What is the use of learning hindi for reginoal leaders. If required regional leaders also speaking hindi voluntarily but one should not impose.
@@gummuluriramakrishna1440 You are also forgetting how both Gujarati and Hindi are similar in both alphabet and pronunciation wise.
So after BJPs Hindu vs Muslim, now its time for North vs South.
North East and Punjab won't go with them too
@@probablynotzeus936 right
We need a separate south
South India will be a separate country
We are stupid, bjp still in power and wining
I think English is better option for people of inter-state so that they don't have to learn a new language for global communication.
Indeed. English is kinda already the lingua franca. And as you said, learning it also gives you the ability to communicate globally.
I agree
I agree! I see Hindi as one of the regional languages only as it's not the first language in other states except UP/MP!
Absolutely
even rural and less educated south indians don't talk in English....
Why should we adhere to such push when I love my mother tongue Telugu? I can speak in Telugu, Hindi and English. Though my second language was Hindi while studying and speak well in Hindi, I really regret not learning Telugu as this has caused a huge barrier in the level of Telugu I can speak in my state. As long as one can speak in their native language and English as global language that should suffice the requirement. What is one supposed to do by learning Hindi as I don’t see any benefit in learning that language. In the past 25 years since I learnt Hindi I have never once used this to read or write in Hindi other than speaking to few Hindi speaking people. So what good is that language when it is hardly any use. Now my kid has to learn 4 languages when he comes to 5th standard because of Hindi being made mandatory for CBSC syllabus. English as a mandatory first language , Spanish as international language, Hindi as mandatory language and his native language Telugu.
Exactly. I wasted 1 hour every day for 10 days to learn Hindi which I still can't master. Even I deeply regret not learning much of Telugu. ఇప్పుడిప్పుడే
తెలుగు పుస్తకాలు చదవటం మొదలుపెడతున్నాను
I studied in National institutes for almost all my life. One thing, I have understood clearly is that NorthIndians are least interested to learn any south Indian language, although some exceptions exist. However, they speak to us in Hindi, even though many of us can't understand it. There are some good guys, who start speaking in English directly. The irony is when they are in south Indian states, they preach about us not learning Hindi and say that south Indians are not interested in learning other languages. Some guys even argue that Hindi is a national language. I mean when they are in South Indian states, don't you think that you have to learn the regional language rather than telling us to learn Hindi? Still, many south Indians are well accommodating and most of us tolerate them and even try to learn Hindi to not create a toxic environment. I hope India stands for its diversity.
Its like a hindi speaking guy go to france and blame them for not knowing hindi....no 1 do that in foreign country so y bully our own brothers' from other states
Perfect brotha
Yes now itself bad attitude is bad
We south indians condemn Shah's statement.
@R S than you brother love from a proud kannadiga ❤
then stop supporting BJP n MODI
@@technicalguy5668 👍
@@DoNotTrustAnATOM Take this...🖕
We North East Indians too condemned his statement
First of all, we must stop the term regional language. If so, then Hindi is also a regional language.
Hindi is regional language brother. Khadi boli bolte hain hai Hindi ko. Ye Urdu, sanskrit, farsi se milkar bana hai. Munshi Premchand ne UP se ise pure north India mein phailaya tha, taki vyapar karne me asaani ho. North India mein sirf Pehle Sanskrit, Urdu or farsi ye 3 language alag alag thi. Or bade leader or scholar ko teeno language sikhni hoti thi. Baki north regional language bhi in teeno se milta julta hai. Except for far east and far west.
which region's language is hindi ??
@@rohansharma3658 UP
@@CryneseCoronaPartyBot in UP we speak Bhojpuri, Awadhi, Braj, Bundeli and Urdu. Hindi is spoken when people of different languages are in same room.
Then speak in your regional. Who cares
We don't want HINDI.
We will learn it if we are interested
@@Rs-hu6zf ngo Miyak dete ne
@MC么SHINE so you mean to say hindi and hindu are two different words
@MC么SHINE Hindi came from hindustan only. Hindi means language spoken by hindustanis. And one more thing it's not a language of North. Every North State has their own language. Some are like Bengali and North east too they have different dialect too still they don't have issue with Hindi except south Indian states. I don't know why. Then south Indian people say that they are discriminated in cities like Mumbai and all. You chose to divide yourself not others.
@@Rs-hu6zf Who told you that our country name is Hindustan???
Does it write anywhere any gazette or in Indian constitution??? Our constitution it's clearly mentioned that our country name is India (भारत) ok.
@@Rs-hu6zf Hindustan not Hindi stan
The British imperialists never imposed English on the common folks in India. These Hindi imposers are worse than them.
Han bhai angrezi to tere purvajon ki bhasha hai na ☺️👍🏻
@@godofanectedote8575 நீ தான் டா ஐரோப்பிய ல இருந்து வந்த...ஆரிய கூட்டம்
@@godofanectedote8575 shut up brother..I think ur bjp persons. We don't need in our South.
It seems that we have replaced British Imperialism by Hindi imperialism.
Freedom movement by Bengali,Maharastrian ,punjabee Revolutionaries was not fought for this purpose.
Hindi speaking people are already taking lions' share of the pie with minimal input.
This is going to be a flash point much severe than Hindu muslim divide.
It won't be as easy as Shah and his hindi speaking coolies think
It's english imperialism being replaced by hindi imperialism
I don't support Shah and I am a Hindi speaker.
@@mskclasses8496 Gujju filth will be culled Publicly and thrashed naked all the way back to their gujju land..
Hindi sirf UP, MP, Bihar and Rajasthan mein chalti hai! Baki jagah nai
😂😂 you are speaking a British invader language hypocrisy
We will accept hindi but please make all north Indians learn and talk south Indian languages. If that happens then we will accept.
We Bengalis have shed our blood for the freedom , unity ,and integrity of this nation .The people who never did anything want to divide our great country .Their policy is always divide and rule. we should demand resignation of the home minister. So that no one tries to do such dirty politics at the cost of the country unity n integrity in future.
Absolutely...my exact sentiments!!!
Just van Hindi in West Bengal
@@freetamilnaduandsouthfromi2984 the problem lies with the '"HM" and his party's selfish unscrupulous propaganda..not with " Hindi" or any other language.
@@rakhi2238 we need Dravida Nadu doesn’t matter what the problem is
@@freetamilnaduandsouthfromi2984 Sorry bro you have come to the wrong place. You should go to the Huriyat and Khalistani fundamentalists .They can help you in your goal .😆😆😆😆
Joker !!!
My native language is hindi but I wouldn't want it imposed on anyone. India is a nation of diversities and those who can't respect diversity aren't fit to call themselves Indian.
India is not nation of diversities, its unity in diversity
@@aronblanche Unity in diversity would only be there if there is diversity in the first place. And my comment practically talks about the need of respecting diversity or unity in diversity. Don't correct what you don't even understand.
The Nation which doesnt has one national language can never have akhand unity and can never become a Vishwa Guru ! 🙏🏼 Too much of anything is bad whether sugar or diversity! Indian suffered from it since ages, and suffering till now!
@@navneet2649 India has been showing the world since independence that diversities can co-exist and there can be even unity in diversity. If there is mutual love and respect, language will not be much of a barrier. That said, English is already the unofficial lingua franca in India. English can be made the official lingua franca of India and as an advantage its learners will be able to communicate globally as well. That aside, if you want India to break apart into pieces by shutting down people's preferences, cultures and languages, this particular Indian has no support for you whatsoever. India needs to combat its internal racism and not fuel it by doing things like promoting one regional language over others. India by its nature has the spirit of diversity. India can only thrive if diversity is respected and those who are against diversity should live on some remote island with their close minded friends and not disturb the India which can very well become the best amalgam of different cultures in future.
@@coolestdude321 If your bond is weak then outsiders can divide you even if the language spoken is same. And if your bond is strong then outsiders will have a tough time just planting a mere suspicion even if languages spoken are different. BJP is trying to tear down India by attacking its foundation of regional harmony. If we as a country aren't perfect in diversity then we should make it perfect in diversity and not darken the situation by giving value and power to destructive elements like BJP who are way more proficient in destroying things than building things.
Thank god I have filed my Visa.
What a beautiful country focusing on flags, religions, languages.
It's being run by clowns. They don't want people to be educated and successful because that would reduce their voter base of uneducated, illiterate fools.
The classical languages in india are Tamil, Malayalam, Telugu, Kannada and Sanskrit. Choose any of these 5 languages.
Don’t you watch sharukh s hindi films ,🧐🧐ar rahman composes music for hindi films also , why ? Even if he dislikes hindi.
@@soniab3731 There are crows everywhere then make the crow the national bird and make the dog the national animal.
Its not about number of speakers or frequency of use of a language, it's the history and heritage of a language that matters. Hindi has no heritage or value whatsoever. Hindi doesn't even have a script of its own. It's a language derived from hindustani, a language created by foreign muslim rulers by mixing persian and arabic. Hindi is no different from Urdu apart from a few sanskrit mixed here and there.
@@soniab3731 Whereas the south indian languages have rich history and heritage and tonnes of literary treasures to its name spanning centuries. That's why all 4 of the major south languages are considered Classical languages. There are 5 Classical languages, four of them from south india and one language sanskrit from north. You see the problem here, all south languages(except Tulu) are classical language but one language which doesn't even have script to call it's own is being given more importance.
Oriya is also a classical language of India.. how could you forget it
@@dudedude3335 Edit : who told you that Sanskrit is a north Indian language? Smoking weed?
It - idi (Sanskrit) - idi (Telugu) - idu (Tamil) - Yeh (Hindi) - Heh (Marathi)..
Yes - Aam (Sanskrit) - Aam (Tamizh) - Athe (Malayalam) - Avunu (Telugu) - Howdu (Kannada) - Ho (Marathi) - Haa (Hindi)..
Really?
that's not true, there are 1000s of south Indian languages that are not even regional languages.. let alone be classical..
Like someone rightly put it, this Hindi only is a diversion tactics from important issues as usual by the Politician.
I guess so, too. Or it could also be that they are testing the waters. Either way, we object to imposition of the will and wish of an individual or a section of the society on the rest. I should decide for myself what to eat, wear, which language to speak and learn; and which god to worship. This is the basic tenet and hallmark of a pluralistic, free and enlightened society.
@@temsulongkumer5357 it keeps coming every year. Beef ban, national anthem in theatres, now hindi imposition. What's next ? God help us all
And tomorrow he will say if ant two states people meet then they have to eat chapati or naan and north Indian curry and should where kurta and pajama to show unity.
Dude our country is very diverse. We eat rice, we wear lungis and pancha. And we speak different languages.
Now home minister will tell us what to eat , what to wear and in what language we should speak.
Singapore is made up of many different ethnic races but English is our connecting language. At the same time, equal opportunities are also given to learn our own Mother Tongue language, even though Mandarin is spoken by the majority. The far sightedness of Mr Lee Kuan Yew in the 1960s to have this bilingual policy in place is commendable. Learning a third language is by our choice only. We live peacefully, because no language is deemed "superior" to another with English being the connecting language, and yet preserving our own cultural heritage via our Mother Tongue.
If only we too had such visionary leaders 💔
You are cladwell
How many states constitute spore
@@radhakannan4010 You didn't get the point at all! 🤦
It's English that has bound the people in Singapore and also made it an internationally viable region.
Instead, if they had chosen Mandarin back in 1962, then it wouldn't have prospered so fast.
@@anujmchitale so
We the northeast strongly opposed this. Even some students may commit suicide if it comes compulsory because they would fail. We r not Hindi speaking people. India is a diverse country. We include to India after independence we r princely independent states but we accept as Indian but imposing without concern is like a dictatorship. Day by day India is becoming dictator under bjp. So sad.
Iam from South brought up in North the first language I learnt was hindi and absolutely love hindi more fluent than my mother tongue telugu,
but imposing will make people hate it.
Exactly. I dont find any thing wrong with how its going on currently. Imposing a language will cause riots rather than solving some imaginary issue.
My case is also same. I was born and brought up in West Bengal and fluent in Hindi,English and Bengali,but had no knowledge of my mother tongue Telugu,which I learnt later. Still I express my thoughts in those above 03 languages and write in Hindi and English. But I am sorry to say,when non-speaking people are being pushed even though mildly as a starter, I feel pained, disturbed, alarmed and uneasy. There is a world beyond North India. Already many of the policies have created division on the Iines of caste,religion,region. So, further division between the brothers of South and North on linguistic basis is not desirable and would do no good to the nation.
I am fear on your saying that you are more fluent In Hindi than your native language, Telugu. Then how your future generation will speak their mother tongue fluently. Or else Hindi become their mother tongue as you use it inside your family communication and speaking Telugu will be eradicated from your family.
@@jerishdavid9680 yeah
Telugu s bad luck is that,telugu people once go out they forget Telugu language and they feel like non telugu s and even they don't make they kids to know that they belong to Telugu community
North states should have either telugu/tamil/kannada as their second language.. however they would end up in our states for work..this might be helpful
Yes learn Tamil/Telugu/Kannada/Malayalam and get better job in south.
దక్షిణ భారత భాషలను అవమానించే పార్టీకి ఓటు వేయవద్దు
Either speak in English or Hindi, don't speak in alien language in public
Either speak in English or Hindi, don't speak in alien language in public
ఎవ్వరూ అవమానించారూ
তরীপার এর সাংস্কৃতিক সন্ত্রাস। 😂😂😂
@@birupakshade448
ও তো ইরানের লোক..... নিজস্ব বলে কিছুই নেই.. কে কি খাবে কি পরবে কি ভাষায় কথা বলবে ও সব ঠিক করে দেবে....
বাজে লোক ....
If Amit shah says English is an alien language, then by same logic, why is his own son the chair person for BCCI cricket board? Well cricket is Britishers game and why is Jay Shah not part of Kabaddi games? Bloddy hypocrite bjp... I am a Tamil speaking proud 🇮🇳 Indian
I don't think Amith Shah thought that far!
@@lifethroughromans8295 i can't believe he thinks anything that has not thought by modi first
Hindi itself an alien language which doesn't exist more than 4 century at max and its combination of multiple languages
I can see BJP declare the crow as the National Bird
They asked the ministry to announce cow as national animal........so it's not surprising.........
They wud defend saying lord saneeswar's Vaahan is crow......
Illiterate barmies
పార్లమెంట్లో హిందీ, ఇంగ్లీషు కాకుండా ఇతర భారతీయ భాషల్లో మాట్లాడేందుకు ముందస్తు అనుమతి తీసుకోవాలన్న సిగ్గుచేటు నిబంధనను నిలిపివేయాలి.
భాషపై ఎక్కువ శ్రద్ధ కనబరుస్తున్న ప్రధాని మోడీకి, మరిన్ని సాంకేతిక సౌకర్యాలను చేర్చడం ద్వారా ఈ చట్టాన్ని, దృష్టాంతాన్ని విసిరివేయవచ్చని తెలుసు, కానీ అతను హిందీని విధించే ఉద్దేశ్యంతో దానిని ఉంచుతాడు, ఓటు వేయడానికి మాత్రమే శ్రద్ధ వహిస్తాడు మరియు వెనుక ఇప్పటికే విధించిన, హిందీని బలవంతం చేస్తాడు. అన్ని యూనియన్ ప్రభుత్వ సంబంధిత పనులు.
హిందీ బెల్ట్లో ఇంగ్లీష్ ఎందుకు బోధిస్తున్నారు.
అన్ని పాఠశాలల్లో అధికారిక భాషలన్నీ ఐచ్ఛికంగా ఉండాలి మరియు ప్రజలు తమ అదనపు భాషను ఎంచుకోవాలని నిర్ణయించుకోవాలి. దీన్ని అమలు చేయాలి.
ఒక భారతీయుడు భారతదేశంలోని అన్ని CBSE పాఠశాలల్లో జర్మన్, ఫ్రెంచ్ నేర్చుకోగలడు, కానీ హిందీ తప్ప ఇతర భారతీయుడు తన మాతృభాషను భారతదేశం అంతటా నేర్చుకోలేడు, కానీ వారి రాష్ట్రంలో మాత్రమే నేర్చుకోలేడు అనే సిగ్గుతో అమిత్ షాకు ఇబ్బంది లేదు.
PS: used google translator
అవును అన్న
సరిగ్గా చెప్పారు
బాగా చెప్పారు సోదర 👌👌
In 1970...Pakistan imposed urdu on the Bengali people of east Pakistan and you know they didn't fear to die.
BJP is doing the same.and I can assure if these type of things grow further Bengali people will come front along with obviously the other language people also in a large level movement.
So many tamilians in 1900s died when hindi was imposed in South
What a shameful statement from Tadipaar.
INDIA is well known for its diversity, yet united. BJP is dividing India and its states.
He himself a gujrati then also pushing for Hindi
@@amanpal7487 lol
@@ShahzadAhmad-cu3kk first teach assuddin Owais to speak in telugu
@SUDIPTA SARKAR Hindu desh ko kaat ke do bana chuke hain. Nazariya galat ho to ghatiya baat hi karoge, apna photo lagane ki aukaat nhi chale gyan pelne. Sanghi bhakt tum ho desh bhakti na hi kro, nafrat je pujari. Chale jao dono desh me se kisi ek me. Itna dard hai to, Bharat wasi nhi ho tum
@SUDIPTA SARKAR jin Muslims ne desh ke tukdr kiye the woh pak aur Bangladesh mein hain. Tune kya kar liya desh ke liye jo usko bol rha hai. Naam aur religion se judge mat kar, agar muslim terrorists hota hai toh muslim abdul kalam bhi hota hai.
RIP BJP.
RIP Modi
RIP Shah.
Jai bjp
Jai modi
Jai shah
Jai BJP
JAI MODIJI
JAI SHAHJI
Rip NDTV VIEWERS. BEEN ALWAYS NEGATIVTY.
@@rajkumark397 it's the same negative input that helps to stay alarmed.Feel good factor takes us back to pre 1970s.
Except for ultra rich people, most people have loans and other expenses and increasing rates.
Government not empowering people. If they cannot do it the worst thing they can do it is boasting.
RIP matlab rest in peace !
Then i wish NO peace for BJP from this moment......let them rot in wars, disasters & riots......& that too becoz of their Nazi superior behaviour
I'm from TAMILNADU, initially I didn't kniw Hindi, but since my Job was in Pune required Hindi I learned it in 6 months, same way when I worked in Karnataka i learned Kannada in 3 months.
Don't get me wrong but I have seen south Indians who work in other states learn some basic communication of the native language but I've seen north indians forcefully converse in Hindi to a lady in a flower stall who doesn't even know english, i had to intervene. This is the problem. They don't resoect regional languages, rather they like a language which is of primarily foreign persian origin derived from the invading nughals, basically from urdu, from muslims, ironically the same community which has clashes with BJP 🤣🤣🤣 what a jokeland we are in.
Persians even now have problem with Arabs. Prophet muhammad said Satan will come from Iran 😂
Abe madrasi Pune me tha to Marathi sikhna chahiye Naa ki hindi ... Khud dusre state me jaate ho hindi bolte ho Marathi Gujarati Bengali Punjabi Assamese bolne me tumko sharam aati hai
Time has come for South Indian states to go as separate countries.
Very true
Kashmir supplies huge jobs free road tunnel etc by Delhi free protection cheap canteen special status states of hp utharkand etc special funded states of up etc. Delhi jobs faje ias jobs etc etc. Maharashtra plus south indians 70 percent of total nri remmitence
Seriously? No one from the opposition called his bluff? The government will find a way to distract us from raising questions about the state of the Indian economy in its present form. 🤦🏻♂️
Time to fight for independent South India.. We have always been used by the center to feed the North states.. Due to this our people are not getting a good life. We are not interested to pay tax to center nor we want union budget.. Independently South can be more prosperous and we can build our own army we have lots of potential
Go try it, the subcontinent will be reduced to civil war because of people like you
There is no unity in south india...there is so much ego in us
I am a Telugu person don't want an independent south India , if you need it go and demand in the court or at the parliament , i am sick with Dravidian party idiots
Then Tamilians will dominate all south India saying that theirs is the oldest language and others will have to face tamil domination and oppression. Not a good idea for rest of us...
@@sravaniyadavalli1359 what? Telugu is the most spoken language in South India
Very good!
Hindi can never, NEVER EVER be the national language of this country.
It should always be Regional language and English as a common language for communication.
North India has Bhojpuri, Punjabi, Haryanvi, Awadhi, Pahari, Bundeli, Gujarati, Marathi, Assamese and many more languages. So if each state's leader starts speaking their mother tongue then how will this parliament function ? Hindi is no one's mother tongue here, even we have been speaking different languages in our hometown and a different one in cities.
So now why are we promoting a language of a country which ruled us for around 250 years, looted us, left our children malnourished, kept us like their slaves. Why can't everybody speak Hindi if we North Indians also tried it by leaving our comfort zones.
SO a TAMIL can accept an outer language OVER an indigenous language which is understood by majority of ppl we INDIANS know u TAMILS hate INDIA but GOOD LUCK TAMILS and get well soon
@@rohansharma3658 lol mazak achha kar lete ho practically bhi sochna chahiye tumhare akao ne jo keh diya wohi antim satya nahi ho sakta na respect others culture too and choice too!! And also not practically possible
@@rohansharma3658 You are using the same language right now which ruled us for around 250 years, looted us, left our children malnourished, kept us like their slaves 😑
Lick the foreign language.
On my business trip to Haryana (very nice ppl, excellent hospitality) I found that even doctors and engineers were struggling to communicate their ideas in a clear sense using English where as in my office in Karnataka my office tea boy spoke better English.. So no wonder many people in the North feel that Hindi should be spoken throughout the country for their own 'benefit' but fail to realize that Hindi can only give them Bimaru states, cow politics and other useless things where as English will give them access to becoming an IT/Tech superpower, better job opportunities etc like in the south...
Same situation when I went Gurgaon for 4weeks and interacted with a multi speciality hospital department heads as a it professional.
Go listen to Kavita Seth's Album 'Trance with Khusrow' to experience the real beauty of Hindi as a language.
@@godofanectedote8575 hindi is not language itself, there is no question of beauty.
Listen any telugu speaking people, you understand the real beauty of earth.
@@srijagadeeshc3056 first listen to that album . If you are not willing to, there is no need to engage in further conversation. Thank you !
(Also I've not questioned the beauty of any other language, to every their mother tongue is the most beautiful, but hindi is not mine )
@@godofanectedote8575 if hindi is not yours then don't talk about it.
Sorry dude I don't want to get headache listening to it.
All the best.
All pilots should be made to speak in shudh Hindi and Mr.Shah should travel in those flights.
Did anybody ask you keep your suggestions for Pakistan govt
@@akashbose9253 same batee Sri Lanka ke nationallist bhee bolte thee ajj Kya hal hae dekh Liya apne desh kee chinta kar bangali dada
@@tariqanwaranwar2678 Modiji ne tum jaeso ko samaj me apna jagah dikha ke phla step lelia h
@@akashbose9253 Mae to Chahta hu modi ji 20years tak Rahe desh no 1 ho Sri Lanka kee Tarah hamare bare me fiker mat karo desh ke bare me fikr karo andh bakti ko chodo
@@akashbose9253 pls go to central Asia
BJP's actions as the ruling government of India is only gonna lead India into regional Separatist tendencies.. India is a Union of States, not some subordinate association of lands. Federalism is fundamental to the basic doctrine of Indian Constitution! The Centre should know to respect the choice of the States when it comes to alternate language besides their mother tongue.
Local language is our mother tongue ...
Few states speaking hindi cant b d national language ...
Bjp must understand that india is not England or european or Arabic country ....😉😉
JAI SRIRAM JAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAMJAI SRIRAM
Speaking Hindi is one way to achieve unity in diversity, you dont need to ignore your regional language but learn extra language for Indians.
People of Wales has to learn English for England.
Speaking Hindi is one way to achieve unity in diversity, you dont need to ignore your regional language but learn extra language for Indians.
People of Wales has to learn English for England.
@@aronblanche why? Why you want others to learn Hindi? Has anyone asked a Bihari or Up guy to learn Odiya, Tamil or Telugu or Bengali.
@@aronblanche this is neither England nor your daddy's India. This is India and India belongs to all people of India doesn't matter what colour, state or language they speak. Our constitution gives us right to express freedom of speech in any language we want. So take a chill pill we don't need your Hindi love agenda here lol . Delhi se hu bc par maki chut, kisi ko zabardasti hindi bolne ke liye force nahi karunga. Jiski mazri jo chahe wese baat kare
Jay karnataka only kannada
I am from karnataka state
I speak in 5 languages including my state language kannada besides telugu tamil hindi n English.
So keep talking n it becomes easier for south people when they travel out of their respective states.
In hyderabad they have remixes versions.
Telugu mixed with hindi urdu.
Talking in more than 3 to 4 language's is good for health also.
If Motoo dumma shah wants hindi as administration language to replace then he is wrong.
I am game for talking purpose only .
Keep Talking
David Gilmour track will refresh anyway.
I speak tulu, shall I say kannada language is imposed on me....?... Love all languages please
@@naturalnaturetm780 but they imposing other state languages its that right I respect all languages but don't force talk hindi whol india they forget mother tongue
@@k.govardhansingh1278 I respect all languages but don't force to talk other state languages in my state
Proud kannadiga... Only kannada 😍
In Kerala Hindi taught as second language in all schools and Arts and Science colleges its enough for us that's it.
Good. Stop learning English!
@@hrk4475
Why the fk should we stop learning english nd learn Hindi while Hindi ppl are enoying privilege.
Hindi ppl need to learn English. Not teach others Hindi.
It should be cancelled
No as third language
I as a indian will never want any indian to loose his or her cultural roots. They should always have rights to speak in language they want. I don't think there is a need to have 3 language policy.. It should not be imposed but if accepted it can be given as option.. I myself had learned 3 language in school so this should not be any problem
3 langauges is huge burden on kids. They can learn something useful instead of Hindi
Hey are you from Hubli Karnataka?
@@danny-fu2zd no. From AP
@@shaidanwheel6199 not you idiot, I am asking Me. Abhishek Dubey
@@danny-fu2zd asking to whom?
As far as the Language war and Hindi push is concerned... English remains the most important language of the world in the field of Science, Aviation, Defence and Administration in the Country and should remain that way...Else it will be a huge disservice for generations to come.
English was chosen by the people. Hidni was imposed. So I'd prefer English!
Hindi*
No one is speaking about the petrol and lpg hike!!!!
One thing for sure, Modi or Amit shah can’t defeat us by forcing Hindi, we South Indians are pretty rigid in it, we take challenges if at all there is a need to learn Hindi, hope the Hindi speakers do the same too, we are far better and well off without Hindi now .
they already won by diverting entire nation to language issue by passing the Fuel price , unemployment, growth etc
i am native of South Indian. i have learnt Hindi and Tamil because i am interested in it. india is beautiful country with cultural diversity and unity. each state has its own culture. i don't understand why these these people creating cultural war between people for getting vote banking.......
Every one is talking about diversity and unity ,when politicians want to change the subjects very seriously they divert and divide the people of our country so this is simple as to divert and diversify peoples minds to forget the nonsense that's going on with out solving petrol and diesel rates , our inflation stands where is our question ?
You spoke my mind dude.
@@rehaninamdar3208 thanks bhaiya
Then what about international economical issues then ?
@@rajkumark397 You do realise that there was gradual downfall of GDP from 2019 before covid or war?
@@rajkumark397 international issues R always there in this world of economics, let's not bother about international issues let's bother about ourselves that's important
I'm from Chennai and we speak Tamil but none can break unity of our country 🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
Bharat Mata ki Jai 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
Marathi is our soul .
Hindi is useless .
Then why you're speaking in English🤣🤣
Then why you're speaking in English🤣🤣
@@aronblanche very right 👍👍 answer
It's better to speak in English, rather than hindi. As we can communicate with India, as well as whole world.
@@birupakshade448 1.4 billon indian people me se kitane log honge jo dosare country me jana chahte honge 100 million maximum ..
App ka kahane ka matalab hai ki ham 100 miillion ke liye 1300 millions people ko bhi Inglis padaye na ..
Wah kya sochh hai
Contrary to the claims of Amit shah the North Eastern States are all opposing Hindi imposition. Hindi imposition will destroy a state's language and culture.
Bjp govt is behaving like North Indian Brahmincal mindset, as they were did during medieval period
80% of the BJP govt is people who are brahmins what did you expect.
@@CryneseCoronaPartyBot it's above vindyas ranges Central Asian origin rulers kids party
United States of dravidanadu ❤️
Jai dravidanadu
South India has rich culture, tradition & values and languages.North Indians must learn Tamil Telugu,kannad & Malayalam.
nothing like this is going to happen... bjp just wants to cook spicy news everytime to stay in limelight
Telugu zindhabad!!!!
జై తెలుగు తల్లీ ..
జై తెలుగు తల్లి 🙏
Why using Arabic word , use Telugu word na !!
English knowledge has given Indians an opportunity to work anywhere in the world that's why Learning English is important along with your mother tongue
I'm from the South part of India i strongly condem the statement and view of Amit Shah ji
Just ignore this debate and move on.... Talk about basic issues of common men... Language debate is just meaningless
We love English and our mother tongue same we respect Hindi not because of BJP,as other language.
When you did nothing to solve real issue then give people bogus language nationalism...Why right wing extremist impose Hindi on me ???
Hindustan doesn't mean hindistan.... We love our own language..after regional language english is better option for all of us.... Love from northeast india
Hindi cannot be imposed on states which has regional languages. We have to maintain our cultural diversity and still stand united. Hindi is only dividing and not uniting.
Jai dravidanadu support from telangana 💪🔥
Let's look back and see what happened back in 1952 in East Pakistan (Current Bangladesh). Pakistan government forcefully tried to make 'Urdu' the state language and language movement took place, students died for protecting Bengali. Following that east Pakistan got separated and became Bangladesh. Language is a sensitive issue. If this situation is not resolved properly, India will face same kind of situation in future.
Support the south india move against Amit shah from northeast India
Stop Kashmir supplies huge jobs
No one never give up his mother language. It is our human rights.
Can you tell me..??
Why we have to learn Hindi...???
Go South!!✊✊
Ye Banda civil war chahta hai.
Is bande ke paas experience bhi hai.
జై తెలుగు తల్లి జై తెలంగాణ
How many a common man can learn
..let be as it is and make life easy
Inflation is at 6%
I see English as empowerment and Hindi is used to dominate. Be it south or north we all are being educated in English so stop expecting us from south to speak your language.
English connects but Hindi divides.
The last line was true.
we south Indians never allow imposition of Hindi. Regional language is important to us.
If they want to impose Hindi then let them divide India as North India, south india and west India. Let them speak hindi in North India and rest will speak their mother tounge.
KTR encourages Urdu but not Hindi. He is simply against everything bjp proposes. He is in a hallucination stage
Why should we telugu people learn hindi and regarding urdu nobody is forcing us to study urdu like this shitty panparag guys are doing.
Hyderabad is almost like a Hindi City. Why KTR or KCR has not put any effort in protecting and promoting Telugu the language of the land. I sincerely appreciate the way Tamils fight for their language and culture.
It's Urdu 😅
@@sasidharvivek5817 Old city alone is not Hyderabad 🤷
@@Surya-pq5ww hindi is spoken less compared to Urdu. Not just old city. We do not need to oppose speaking in Hindi. We need to oppose Hindi imposition. U understand the difference?
@@shaidanwheel6199 Hope you read and understand my text well. I’m talking about promoting and protecting Telugu language.
@@Surya-pq5ww I love Telugu. Hyderabad is not like a Hindi city. Most speak urdu and telugu. Yes, ktr and kcr should promote Telugu.
North East don't need hindi . It must be optional.
I see a future where there will be an Indian union with countries that speak languages of their own.
One must learn from history.
Amit Shah Pitches Hindi as Alternative To "English", meanwhile Politicians of south Indian states, Eastern states (non NDA states) - It is an insult to Tamil, we will not stop speaking Bengali, Malayali is our pride... 🤷♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🙏🏼 thats why education is very important!
And these politicians are illiterate, ironically they are telling us what we should learn. 😭😭
@@Anonymous-nt4sz 😁😆
They can't speak English so they want all to follow bade sab 🤣
It is backdoor entry for Hindi, even if Amit shah backed down from Hindi replacing mother tongue, he wants to replace English as link language & bring Hindi.. it will make easy for BJP to campaign in non Hindi states, it's for votes.. English is a global language, medium of education whether v like it or not.. can't study law, science, in non English & suceed
Anpar gawar
Jai KCR
Jai Telangana
These foolish leaders repeating mistakes of Pakistan!! 😏😓😓😩😡
Learning and being able to communicate in hindi is important but not at the cost of ignoring one mother tongue. It's just not a South Indian issue, east, west and North states have their own languages and dialects. And that's the root of multi faceted indian society. We should protect the rich native heritage of ours. It's funny when I see kids learning French now a daysborin schools as third language. Mother tongue is as important as mother milk to a new born
Defeat BJP. Don't give a single vote for cunning BJP. I am a BJP liker, but realised it is a poison to kill our culture and mother language. We want separate South Indian country.
Separate country's formula is correct
In our opinion hindi is also like a regional language like all other languages..
👍👍👍👍👍, yes 100% we dont want North Indias culture or langauage
For Jalikattu we shaken up TN.
For Tamil, we will shake up the whole world...
Tamilanda 🙏
China and remaining India can together co-operate to make Tamil Nadu a Chinese colony LOL. Tamil Nadu on it's own is ZERO without rest of India.
How offensive one can be and the cinema hall in Chennai are housefull on weekends to watch bollywood movies।
Will meet Prabhakaran's fate...
@@silverghost5752 you will meet the fate of Rajiv
@@RamaChandran-zl9zd 🤣🤣🤣🤣😜😜😜😜
It's the natural course of ultra nationalism, same thing happened across Europe. First religious assimilation, followed by language assimilation. Countries like France lost many regional languages during that process. Same with Scottish , English divide.
Guys, I think there are many bigger issues to deal with, why dont you leaders concentrate on them and not surface such language barriers now. This is 2022, age of technology advancements. When I travelled out of India even not knowing their language I was able to communicate and got all what I want along with love and affection of those country people. Let's work on real big issues please!
punjabi till last breath
Let HM first learn every regional languages and English if he wants to impose Hindi as national language.
Why should one Minister bring up such ideology.... There is lots of communal hatred and tensions created because of like these one sided idea... India itself is a pluralistic nation.. Everyone has the right to protect its own cultural identity and language... Is it there right to impose unwanted ideas on the public in every aspect of life!!? Let the people choose what to wear and eat .. Please free us from communal hatred and tensions..
tu pakka pagal hai
@@shresthishigwcivpadt9713 Kuch b
Yes sir you are absolutly correct. The honble minister has said rightly.We the tamils speak hindi but 1960s hindi was second lang in AP state but the.govt not imposed onus either you can opt hindi or.mother tongue.or any other lang. I strongly condemn imposition of hindi in our state. I thank minister of IT and Municipal admn for rejecting hindi imposition. Thankyou sir. Ours is south india AAPKA DAAL IDAR NAYI GALEGA.
Perfect logic by PTR
Telugu 💜
माय मराठी .♥️😍♥️
आम्ही हिंदी ला बिनकामाचा मानतो.😡🤬😡
We cannot loose our identity or stop talking our beautiful language just because of some individual or party wishes to do it, Again if there is a need we will learn it don’t try to force
Speaking about development, education, progress in any language is the need of the country right now
People dont understand having a single language to communicate will save a lot of country's money. I feel there should be voting between sanskrit and Tamil
Y? Tamil in South India Telugu speakers are more than the Tamil speakers
Then learn Tamil Or Bengali or Telugu. Why Hindi? Just cause Modi wants a Hindu Rastra?
@@TON-vz3pe First you decide one language. you yourself are confused
If India give right to self-determination to Tamils then Tamils can save a lot of money and live a very good life
@@RamaChandran-zl9zd please dont comment anti national
Why use language of britishers who ruled us is the most illogical argument ever !!
By that logic we should stop playing cricket and so many other sports. Stop using android & ios mobiles / computers because these are also invented by english speaking people.
Are these North Indians okay to learn any one Dravidian language in their syllabus... then we start thinking of Hindi !!!
By this logic whole world should speak English or Mandarin