@@SPiderman-rh2zk Thank you for reminding me of such feasible activity, obwohl it is unnecessary. Shoudn't I refrain from the unnecessary feasible ? I think I should. How about you?
A Means To An End, Isolation, and Decades are my personal favorites off Closer, but this album is so immaculate that any picks would be understandable.
Joy division had the best bass licks in all there. Songs.the base is always pumping in the 4 ground.you can here it and it always leads the songs.that is one reason the joy division first album is the best first album ever
Esse ritmo da bateria de Steve e o baixo do Hooky já antecipavam muita coisa do que viria nos anos de New Order. Sem dúvida é uma antecipação sonora não só para o NO mas para muitos ouvintes que montaram suas bandas após Closer.
I'm a huge fan of the band, this is far Better way than the "reimagined" shitty Unknown Pleasure videos I'm sure There are a lot of people out there who could make amazing videos
Genres.. people try to label bands like Joy Division, Bauhaus, Love And Rockets, Sisters Of Mercy, others as Gothic. Mostly because of "Dark Lyrics, tones. Post Punk? Alternative? There is definitely a difference, but not sure where it falls. People love to compartmentalize things.. especially things that most don't understand.
The definitive version of this is the one on "Still" just a week or so before he unalived himself. You can hear the stress, despair & barely contained rage in his voice. This is a sanitised, McDonalds cheese version that lacks any of that. Still is why JD are considered dark & gothic, if only for that - but from a musicology POV we have tom-tom heavy drums & melodic bass, doomy vocals... What more do you need?
I have been a fan for over 20 years and only recently this one has begun to make its rise as one of my favourites. The Sound Of Music did this as well a few years ago and Novelty a few years before that. I wonder which one will be the next.
🛹🛹🛹 skating off a friend’s launch ramp in an alley , pacific beach ( San Diego ) California mid 80s , we would set it up next to his garage , he had a radio with a tape deck , this killer frickin’ tune would be pumping out of the over sized speakers , along with other new wave sounds 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🛹🛹🛹🦴
Loved them from the minute I heard their first song. The band played regularly around the clubs in Manchester, uk. They didn't live far from where I do, only about 10 miles. Ian's voice, the best and if you close your eyes, you'd think he was a soul singer. I introduced the band a couple of years ago to my teenage grandsons, who have played guitars, and are very good musians and the lads loved them. Even their friends love the band and most of them couldn't believe they had never heard of them.. Plus they also couldn't believe it that it was grandparents who put the music onto them. Don't know if you have seen the film which was only made a few years ago and joy division, it's called Control. You can get it through prime, Netflix or even u tube. R. I. P Ian and thanks for all the wonderful memories, love you xxxx xxxx
I Used To Play Drums In A Manchester Based Band Called A Means To An End In The Late 1980s/Early 1990s - We Were Heavily Influenced By Joy Division - We Recorded Our Own Material Plus Some Joy Division Covers - 🥁
A Means To An End Joy Division Um legado até agora removido Um dia será aperfeiçoado Direitos eternos deixados para trás A gente era do melhor tipo Dois iguais, ambos livres Eu sempre pareci com você Eu sempre pareci com você Eu sempre pareci com você Nós lutamos pelo bem, lado a lado Nossa amizade nunca morreu Sobre ondas estranhas, as baixas e as altas Nossa visão tocou os céus Imortalistas com argumentos para provar Eu confiei em você Eu confiei em você Eu confiei em você Uma casa em algum lugar em solo estrangeiro Onde antiquados amantes chamam É esse seu objetivo, suas necessidades finais? Onde cães e abutres comem Ainda comprometido, me viro para partir Eu confiei em você Eu confiei em você Eu confiei em você Eu confiei em você Em você, em você, em você Confiei em você Em você
in the new edition of Classic Pop Magazine, there's a piece on this where they say "It was us listening to Giorgio Moroder ... and not quite figuring out how to do it”.
![The Church - When You Were Mine [Live @ The Palais, St Kilda, VIC, AUS 28-Nov-2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hU6fKuvYBho/mqdefault.jpg)
Gotta luv that bass bridge! One of my favourites on Closer. This music is keeping me alive honestly!
Out of all of Joy Division's songs this gives me the most energy, you can get a fearsome pace listening to this
whatever "fearsome pace" means...
@@basic_level Go touch grass
@@SPiderman-rh2zk Thank you for reminding me of such feasible activity, obwohl it is unnecessary. Shoudn't I refrain from the unnecessary feasible ? I think I should. How about you?
Oh, yes! At my work, we cannot listen to any music, but this piece would be the soundtrack in my mind😊
It's hard to imagine a 23 young man being such a advanced poet and singer.
he was very intelligent
well... that explains@@Happyradio1234
Library 📚 card really helped
The guy was a genius. Great loss
Immortalists with points to proved. 40 years on your point is proved and you will remain immortal. RIP Ian Curtis..
The bass line!
One to rival even the Cure for sure
Peter Hook rules.
@237 they definitely can
@@gloo1884 the cure? more like the sickness
It’s a pain In The The ass but it rips once you’ve got it down to a science
The sting of a friend's betrayal so succinctly put to words.
What part makes you think it's about betrayal? Ian sings their friendship never died.
@@Nickname1234the way he says “i put my trust in you” makes it seem like that trust was broken
A Means To An End, Isolation, and Decades are my personal favorites off Closer, but this album is so immaculate that any picks would be understandable.
Heart and soul
division vision touched the sky.....simply art
My favorite song off Closer.
For sure
Mine too. This track and JD in general got me through some tough tough times
I remember going into my brothers room and listening to joy division and bowie records dam some really good memories
Me too. That’s how I got into them because of my big brother and I’m now almost 46 years old 😂😳
My fav of closer with decades.
Mine is heart and soul and twenty four hours
mine too. But recently I stopped the album before getting to Decades so as not to cry.
The live version of this on Still is amazing. The way Ian would scream "I PUT MY TRUST IN YOU" is soul piercing.
Great song my sister is deaf and I listen to this song all the time and interprets it in sign language and it’s pretty cool
Crank the volume until she can feel the beat, put on a music visualizer suited to the tone of the song, and sign the words.
You gotta do a Vid
This was the coolest thing ive read in a min - hope you do make a video!
I approve this message. ❤😮
Still sounds as new as it did 40 years ago 🤔🧐😎👍🏽
What a tune!
Crank it up I could listen to this foreverrrrrr.🤟🤟🤟🤟
Never heard anything like this song before yet it seems so familiar, it's incredible
Listen to Bowie's low album
@@Pazuzu82 What, Always Crashing In The Same Car?
Blue Monday by New order (basically all joy division members without ian) follows the same rythm
Brian Eno
That's the mystique of Joy Division. They seemed to find the songs within our souls and play them perfectly.
Priceless I put my TRUST in you😃😃
Dolor, tristeza y desolación bañadas en ira. Canción brutal.
What a great song!
i adore this song
I put my trust in you
Is this your goal you final needs where dogs and vultures eat🎵🎶
Love it!! Ian's suffering is so apparent
serious music
This lyric video is way better than those recent crappy videos made for other tracks..
ahahahha, plus those videos have nothing simillar with Curtis` texts
fax honestly
No
@@РоманГондз 667ûu77yuìû hi hi I guy hy HHV8666y6y
Nothing else is needed other than Ian's words
One of my favourite JD songs ❤
Joy division had the best bass licks in all there. Songs.the base is always pumping in the 4 ground.you can here it and it always leads the songs.that is one reason the joy division first album is the best first album ever
Bass is lead guitar for jd, often!
Hell yeah, drop that bass!!!
Love love that song. I listen it very often in my car🥰
Με tοο, even it is a dark song.
Stranger waves of lows and highs
Our vision touch the sky🎶🎵
El bajo y la bateria en esta canción son una cosa de locos...una maravilla absoluta
Unforgetablle.
From Portugal, i put my trust in you!
Let’s gooooo tens alguma recomendação para me dar? Alguma banda ou álbum? A minha playlist está bue estagnada
@@aspiloboos três primeiros álbuns de Dead Can Dance
Bring on more of these lyric videos ! Those re-imagined videos are a distant past.
Why do I love this so much???
Because it’s life changing. That beat…..
When Music becomes art!
40 Jahre her und immer noch absolut geil🤘🤘🤘
Классика.
This song is so simplistic in production but damn does it work.
This guy was different man RIP to a legend
After all these years, you can still ways of interpretation- Perfection
Son brut,rien d'inutile,on va à l'essentiel,ce morceau est intemporel.
Imortalists with points to prove.🎶one day will be Improved
A masterpiece of precision.
My top 3 songs on Closer:
1. Means to an End
2. Isolation
3. 24 hours
1.means to an end
2.the kill
3.exercise one
4.all for you
RIP Ian curtis😥
Ian will always stay in our hearts 😍😍😍😥😥😢😢😢
😢😢😢 yes i m sad.
I think it was a Nice man 🙂🙂
Esse ritmo da bateria de Steve e o baixo do Hooky já antecipavam muita coisa do que viria nos anos de New Order. Sem dúvida é uma antecipação sonora não só para o NO mas para muitos ouvintes que montaram suas bandas após Closer.
Best dance song crazy in a very good way song # 4 in lifetime compilation
I'm a huge fan of the band, this is far Better way than the "reimagined" shitty Unknown Pleasure videos
I'm sure There are a lot of people out there who could make amazing videos
yes...reimagined was a desecration of UP
THE DEFINITION OF POST PUNK FROM THE GREATEST BAND EVER WALKED THE EARTH!!!
EVRYTHING ELSE IS SECOND DIVISION!!!!
The only band that mattered
I would not consider this music as dark or gothic, it just speaks about life! I put my trust in you...
Genres.. people try to label bands like Joy Division, Bauhaus, Love And Rockets, Sisters Of Mercy, others as Gothic. Mostly because of "Dark Lyrics, tones. Post Punk? Alternative? There is definitely a difference, but not sure where it falls. People love to compartmentalize things.. especially things that most don't understand.
The definitive version of this is the one on "Still" just a week or so before he unalived himself. You can hear the stress, despair & barely contained rage in his voice. This is a sanitised, McDonalds cheese version that lacks any of that. Still is why JD are considered dark & gothic, if only for that - but from a musicology POV we have tom-tom heavy drums & melodic bass, doomy vocals... What more do you need?
@@Pazuzu82 yeah, you're right. "Still". Fixed it.
One of my favourites
To think those guys were only in their early 20s writing this music ..... pretty incredible
Favorite song of theirs
timeless
É muita banda. Peter Hook é um grande baixista.👏👏👏👏
Hypnotic.
“Is this your goal, your final needs, where dogs and vultures eat?”. A question for society, in general
Canción indispensable,magnífica.La quinta esencia de Joy División.Cancion infravalorada.Underrated song.
Great way to finish the album (if you listen to it the way I’ve always listened to it)
MASTERPIEZE!
The song where Ian Curtis resembles his idol Jim Morrison to the fullest.
I have been a fan for over 20 years and only recently this one has begun to make its rise as one of my favourites. The Sound Of Music did this as well a few years ago and Novelty a few years before that. I wonder which one will be the next.
Que linda obra! Essa musica serviu de inspiração para Ainda é cedo, da Legião Urbana
*Plagio*
I normally prefer the original video and no lyrics, but I like that there are no try-hard images. Just that particle-wave effect and the lyrics.
"That's very good Jack, because, uh, for some people, solitude and isolation can, of itself become a problem." -Stuart Ullman, Kubrick's "The Shining"
Well rest usured Mr Ullman thats not gonna happen with me😂
🛹🛹🛹 skating off a friend’s launch ramp in an alley , pacific beach ( San Diego ) California mid 80s , we would set it up next to his garage , he had a radio with a tape deck , this killer frickin’ tune would be pumping out of the over sized speakers , along with other new wave sounds 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🛹🛹🛹🦴
Loved them from the minute I heard their first song. The band played regularly around the clubs in Manchester, uk. They didn't live far from where I do, only about 10 miles. Ian's voice, the best and if you close your eyes, you'd think he was a soul singer. I introduced the band a couple of years ago to my teenage grandsons, who have played guitars, and are very good musians and the lads loved them. Even their friends love the band and most of them couldn't believe they had never heard of them.. Plus they also couldn't believe it that it was grandparents who put the music onto them.
Don't know if you have seen the film which was only made a few years ago and joy division, it's called Control. You can get it through prime, Netflix or even u tube. R. I. P
Ian and thanks for all the wonderful memories, love you xxxx xxxx
Something magical in Manchester.
Our Vision Touched the Sky...
Makes me feel real when I listen to this
Grandiose
Mi banda favorita
Thanks I love this
They perfected the sound of depression.
True!
Betrayal. ''Committed still, I turn to go'' Damn.
Industrial drum love it 🖤
This slaps!
1:58 - 2:27. Class
Much agreed... ✌🏽
Key change from heaven.
What can you say about JD "Unknown Pleasures" "Closer" "Still" 3 classic LPs .... "A means to an end" one of their many classics 😎👍.
I love this group❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I love you Ian Curtis. 💕
Peter Hook is the greatest bassist that ever lived
This isn't even opinions, it's facts, long live Hooky
Gianni maroccolo from litfiba
100000% agree
I put my trust in you.
thanks for the lyrics...i always thought the "stranger waves" line was "a stranger waits with lows and highs"
Such a weary soul
Hermosa canción 💜💀
I'll just sit and grin. The money will roll right in!😂
J'écoute ian curtis depuis que j'ai 13ans et j'en ai maintenant 41 toujours aussi accro j'aurais aimé le voir au moins une fois 😢rip❤
Me gustó mucho
I Used To Play Drums In A Manchester Based Band Called A Means To An End In The Late 1980s/Early 1990s - We Were Heavily Influenced By Joy Division - We Recorded Our Own Material Plus Some Joy Division Covers - 🥁
Στην λευκη με αγαπη αλεξανδρος 1991 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Music for people that actually think
Merci Ian Curtis ♥
⌛ immortal song ⏳
Forever love,💘💖💔😭
A life with no meaning or truth and an endless labor. Those are the true riches of the world. It shall have no true court but Jesus.
This is beautiful like a little Lilly..
Ainda é cedo do Legião urbana teve inspiração aqui.
🖤
💜🥂
‘I put my trust in you’, a passive-aggressive dig that contradicts one’s own inevitable suicide.
As reluctant as I am to agree with that, I completely agree with your logic.
A Means To An End
Joy Division
Um legado até agora removido
Um dia será aperfeiçoado
Direitos eternos deixados para trás
A gente era do melhor tipo
Dois iguais, ambos livres
Eu sempre pareci com você
Eu sempre pareci com você
Eu sempre pareci com você
Nós lutamos pelo bem, lado a lado
Nossa amizade nunca morreu
Sobre ondas estranhas, as baixas e as altas
Nossa visão tocou os céus
Imortalistas com argumentos para provar
Eu confiei em você
Eu confiei em você
Eu confiei em você
Uma casa em algum lugar em solo estrangeiro
Onde antiquados amantes chamam
É esse seu objetivo, suas necessidades finais?
Onde cães e abutres comem
Ainda comprometido, me viro para partir
Eu confiei em você
Eu confiei em você
Eu confiei em você
Eu confiei em você
Em você, em você, em você
Confiei em você
Em você
new joy division song =O
???????
in the new edition of Classic Pop Magazine, there's a piece on this where they say "It was us listening to Giorgio Moroder ... and not quite figuring out how to do it”.
Peter Hook criminally underrated.
not in his own eyes
@@Hope2Health 🤣🤣
Hooky sorts it again 👊