Your guides are literally one of the best, if not THE best, of any Kpop groups’ I’ve ever seen as a multi stans. Thank you for your hard work and dedication 💕💘
Thank you so much for your guides! I’ve checked out dozens of groups over the past few years of enjoying kpop and I always like to start with a guide and a few compilation videos before listening to music, because I like to distinguish the members and know a little bit about them as it makes me feel more connected to the groups and the music I’m listening to. And I gotta say out of probably over 40+ groups and about a dozen soloists I’ve checked out, this is by far the most comprehensive guide I’ve ever seen. And it was really interesting and well-paced too, so I never felt bored watching almost 2,5-3 hours of these guides all together. I’ve put off checking out seventeen for so long, now I can’t wait to listen to their music because the guide already made me fall in love with them. I literally have no room in my life anymore for falling in love with more groups, what do I do?😩😩😩 oh well, what’s done is done
Thank you so much for your hard work on promoting Seventeen!! ❤🙏 Just in case you're looking for feedback, it would be great to include clips that showcase Seungkwan's singing better. Maybe even the 'Beautiful tomorrow' cover which was originally there or even newer good ones. You're already doing an amazing job though P.S: I love all SVT members equally 😁
Lol I'm here again. Caratline17 you make such amazing guides, so can I suggest you something? A lot of times when I see people react to this they just gloss over Jeonghan's section or talk about how pretty he is and move on, maybe because of the fact that there's not a lot of attributes in his section (like some others play an instrument, edit stuff, do writing, etc ) Can you add a section about his dancing? Because he is one of the finest dancer's in seventeen but not many people pay attention to it. His moves are very sharp and look effortless in one glance. One example I'd give is his Fear performance(s), during the line 'I know I can't take it no more', Jeonghan does a very specific shoulder movement that no one else does and that requires immense body control. So one thing as a vocal team member he does very well is dance exceptionally. I know this guide just came out but its a tiny suggestion for the next update, thank you for reading the long comment.
I am solely here to thank you for adding Seungkwan's The eve cover in his section. The reasons are: It's Seungkwan and people NEED to see how good of a dancer he is. 2. This performance was one of the major reasons I looked into EXO. 3. Seungkwan's The eve cover is THE best cover out there (yes I have seen all the 3rd, 4th gen dancer's covers).
Hi. I was thinking about making an updated version of 2024, but I couldn't do it alone. If you plan to update the guide I can help. Or if anyone else is interested in doing... They have achieved so many things since then, a lot has changed and there are so many people interested in getting to know them. I think it would be nice 🤗
Thank you for all your hard work and dedication! You make great guides. My only comment about something to add is including the titles of the songs you use for future viewers. I know you did it in the hiphop team video. But I think you must’ve been so worn out you forgot by the time you did this one. Lol
Dang you didn’t upload the clip of Joshua consoling Seungkwan in the part talking about Joshua noticing the other members! That was honestly when I first had a bias
Always thankful for this amazing job that u did!!! I wish this have spanish subs haha this guide is literally the best! Thanks for always actualize (idk if that's the word) the info and made it so entertain it to watch! Thanks for this Carat from Argentina🇦🇷💎
@@caratline en serio!!!?? Ay no sabia que hablabas español tambien 😱 seria genial que hubieran subs! Espero que puedas hacerlo a tu tiempo y tranquila, vamos a ser pacientes y esperar :) en cuanto esten voy a mostrarle la guia a mi mama, ya que ella es Carat tambien, y si bien ya los conoce a todos los chicos, no vendria mal mostrarle esta guia completísima y bien trabajada para que se siga encariñando mas con ellos jaja mil gracias de nuevo por tu trabajo!!!
@@caratline Thanks for the hard work. Hopefully now you can use these as templates for future edits for quicker release rather than starting from scratch. Cheers!
Hey can I say something if u don't mind Can you please make a documentary like film of SVT from the beginning of their journey as their new best album is coming I'm just saying.....
I’m not an akgae just because I think you did a poor job at portraying him. You mention he’s one of the funniest members and then only show two clips of him being scared and not of him actually saying/doing funny things. There are sooo many clips to choose from in GoSe. You mention he’s the “purest soul on earth” and could have left it at that, no need to add “maybe a bit too pure” and then show clips like the one of him in that vlive with Joshua because that really just makes him seem unintelligent in the eyes of people who don’t know him. How about the fact that he’s into photography and often carrying his camera around and sharing his pictures with carats, or the fact that he was basically one of the chefs of svt (along with mingyu, jun, and joshua) in the soop? Or how about how he’s almost always the first one to comfort his members? If you have to call him loud there are also way better clips than just him screaming in that interview. Like that clip from that show with his manager where he was rapping in the car at like five in be morning or his iconic yelling soju and beer comment after their concerts. I can keep going, but it’s not like it would change anything. I appreciate your hard work because I really did enjoy the rest of the members’ introductions, but DK’s part was always and still remains disappointing.
@@marip2323 okay, thanks for all the feedback. Honestly you could have left this comment instead of the passive agressive one. I know I can't make justice to everything, editing this is a lot of work even if it doesnt look like it does, and it's tiring to get to comments like that one.
Yes, you are right. My apologies for my initial comment, I could have definitely worded it better and been kinder about it but my frustration got the best of me. If you decide to make one for 2024, which I hope you do, I hope you take the things I mentioned into consideration.
![ฮักเทื่อสุดท้าย - บอย ศิริชัย [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-1PoPoQ-B-k/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG IT'S FINALLY HERE! THANK YOU FOR YOUR HARD WORK!!
Your guides are literally one of the best, if not THE best, of any Kpop groups’ I’ve ever seen as a multi stans. Thank you for your hard work and dedication 💕💘
i really wish the scene where dk gifts a camera and makes lunch box for a carat was put in because it really shows his very empathetic side
Thank you for what you do for Seventeen and Carats! You are amazing! You make amazing videos.
Thank you so much for your guides! I’ve checked out dozens of groups over the past few years of enjoying kpop and I always like to start with a guide and a few compilation videos before listening to music, because I like to distinguish the members and know a little bit about them as it makes me feel more connected to the groups and the music I’m listening to. And I gotta say out of probably over 40+ groups and about a dozen soloists I’ve checked out, this is by far the most comprehensive guide I’ve ever seen. And it was really interesting and well-paced too, so I never felt bored watching almost 2,5-3 hours of these guides all together. I’ve put off checking out seventeen for so long, now I can’t wait to listen to their music because the guide already made me fall in love with them. I literally have no room in my life anymore for falling in love with more groups, what do I do?😩😩😩 oh well, what’s done is done
You work so hard! ❤💪
the woozi shirtless pic just popping for sec there lmaaoo
🙏
OMG. This is so lovely. Thank you for your hard work.
Thank you for all your hard work and time you put into this guides!!
13:24 i see what u did there
BLESS YOU THANK YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME TO REFRESH ALL OF THESE. much love to you
THE WOOZI 1 SEC SHIRTLESS PIC SNUCK IN THERE I SEE YOU LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
@@lmf221
Thank you so much for your effort💎✨❤️
Thank you so much for your hard work on promoting Seventeen!! ❤🙏 Just in case you're looking for feedback, it would be great to include clips that showcase Seungkwan's singing better. Maybe even the 'Beautiful tomorrow' cover which was originally there or even newer good ones.
You're already doing an amazing job though
P.S: I love all SVT members equally 😁
yay! thanks for uploading, and for all your hard work!
Me watching this even tho I know everything about seventeen .. thank you for this !!!
You're doing God's work
Lol I'm here again. Caratline17 you make such amazing guides, so can I suggest you something? A lot of times when I see people react to this they just gloss over Jeonghan's section or talk about how pretty he is and move on, maybe because of the fact that there's not a lot of attributes in his section (like some others play an instrument, edit stuff, do writing, etc ) Can you add a section about his dancing? Because he is one of the finest dancer's in seventeen but not many people pay attention to it. His moves are very sharp and look effortless in one glance. One example I'd give is his Fear performance(s), during the line 'I know I can't take it no more', Jeonghan does a very specific shoulder movement that no one else does and that requires immense body control. So one thing as a vocal team member he does very well is dance exceptionally. I know this guide just came out but its a tiny suggestion for the next update, thank you for reading the long comment.
thank you
AHHHHHH DOKI's VOICE IS HEAVEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yay!!! Thank you for all your hard work and efforts. We'll keep recommending these to reactors. ❤❤❤
Thank you, you make new carats everyday♡
First. 🖐️ wow! How much effort you put for this! Good job! 👍
Thank you so much for watching!!
4:40 ehi, this is the opening song of my First Communion video! ahahah
Thank you so much for help me to know better the members
THANK U SM
I am solely here to thank you for adding Seungkwan's The eve cover in his section. The reasons are: It's Seungkwan and people NEED to see how good of a dancer he is. 2. This performance was one of the major reasons I looked into EXO. 3. Seungkwan's The eve cover is THE best cover out there (yes I have seen all the 3rd, 4th gen dancer's covers).
Hello!! Thank you for the best guides ever! What song was DK singing on 37:32 ?
Thank you so much. Been waiting for this🥰🥰🥰🥰
warm cup of milk is kinda old now his live series is let’s eat! and it’s also have it’s own logo song lol
Hi. I was thinking about making an updated version of 2024, but I couldn't do it alone. If you plan to update the guide I can help. Or if anyone else is interested in doing...
They have achieved so many things since then, a lot has changed and there are so many people interested in getting to know them. I think it would be nice 🤗
Thank you for your hard work and very helpful for the new/baby carat
Wow finally thank you sm
Yesss, it's here! =D
Edit: omg you put Woozi anime livestream! Yeeeesss, i was really hoping it would get added =D
Yes!! It was one of the things I wanted to add for a long time
Waaaaaaah, thank you so much >
Thank you for your great work
Thank you for all your hard work and dedication! You make great guides. My only comment about something to add is including the titles of the songs you use for future viewers. I know you did it in the hiphop team video. But I think you must’ve been so worn out you forgot by the time you did this one. Lol
finally!! the new version! thank you for your hardwork editor-nim
You've worked soo soooooo hard! Thank youuuu❤
Wowww❤❤❤❤
Omgggggg it has dropped!!!
Thank you sm for ur hard work 💖
I wish to put in DK cover songs such as Betel Gius and Wish me Luck.
Yes to all of this
Thanku ❤
Dang you didn’t upload the clip of Joshua consoling Seungkwan in the part talking about Joshua noticing the other members! That was honestly when I first had a bias
can you tell me where can I find the clip? Sometimes I remember some moments but I can't remember when and where it happened 😵
@@caratline it’s okay! I can’t find the full clip on TH-cam but it’s from In The Soop season 2. I think episode 3
@@Kpoplover1990 thank you so much! But if it is from In The soop I can't use them they get copyrighted 🥲
YES FINALLY!!!
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR HARD WORK I LOVE YOUR GUIDES SO MUCH THEY’RE SO HELPFUL TO OTHERS 😭😭😭🩷🩵
Thank you! I'm happy you find them helpful!
Thank you for the guide and your hardwork 🙂
49:55 What is this song and where can I find this clip?
you can find it here on youtube as wifi seungkwan cover in dingo music channel!
Always thankful for this amazing job that u did!!! I wish this have spanish subs haha this guide is literally the best! Thanks for always actualize (idk if that's the word) the info and made it so entertain it to watch!
Thanks for this Carat from Argentina🇦🇷💎
Hola! Mi idioma nativo es en realidad español 🤣ahora que la guía está un poco más actualizada me estoy dedicando a crearle los subtítulos!
@@caratline en serio!!!?? Ay no sabia que hablabas español tambien 😱 seria genial que hubieran subs! Espero que puedas hacerlo a tu tiempo y tranquila, vamos a ser pacientes y esperar :) en cuanto esten voy a mostrarle la guia a mi mama, ya que ella es Carat tambien, y si bien ya los conoce a todos los chicos, no vendria mal mostrarle esta guia completísima y bien trabajada para que se siga encariñando mas con ellos jaja mil gracias de nuevo por tu trabajo!!!
OMG THANK YOU SO MUCH
And.. it's time to work on 2024 version lol
😭😭😭
@@caratline Thanks for the hard work. Hopefully now you can use these as templates for future edits for quicker release rather than starting from scratch. Cheers!
Hey can I say something if u don't mind
Can you please make a documentary like film of SVT from the beginning of their journey as their new best album is coming
I'm just saying.....
oh well that was fast 13:24
hey why are some songs not labelled like in hhu and pfu? woozi's solo and same3?
hi do you mind to tell me which interview is that from 2:42 onwards
What's the name of song seungkwan singing in the second clip ?
where is the first clip of jeonghan singing from??
I don't know the exact clip but the song is called :Falling for U (by Jeoghan&Joshua)
13:24 RUDE
Guys what’s song is that on DK’s intro he is singing¿
It's his cover on "She Didn't Love Me" - it's on Seventeen's channel
thank you for all your hard work you absolute legend 🫶🫶🫶
Thank you so much!!
Ok so basically didn’t add anything new for DK and left all the dumb stuff
Why do you Dk akgaes have to be like this all the time
@beeshebee you're welcome to leave suggestions about what else I can add for him
I’m not an akgae just because I think you did a poor job at portraying him. You mention he’s one of the funniest members and then only show two clips of him being scared and not of him actually saying/doing funny things. There are sooo many clips to choose from in GoSe. You mention he’s the “purest soul on earth” and could have left it at that, no need to add “maybe a bit too pure” and then show clips like the one of him in that vlive with Joshua because that really just makes him seem unintelligent in the eyes of people who don’t know him. How about the fact that he’s into photography and often carrying his camera around and sharing his pictures with carats, or the fact that he was basically one of the chefs of svt (along with mingyu, jun, and joshua) in the soop? Or how about how he’s almost always the first one to comfort his members? If you have to call him loud there are also way better clips than just him screaming in that interview. Like that clip from that show with his manager where he was rapping in the car at like five in be morning or his iconic yelling soju and beer comment after their concerts. I can keep going, but it’s not like it would change anything. I appreciate your hard work because I really did enjoy the rest of the members’ introductions, but DK’s part was always and still remains disappointing.
@@marip2323 okay, thanks for all the feedback. Honestly you could have left this comment instead of the passive agressive one. I know I can't make justice to everything, editing this is a lot of work even if it doesnt look like it does, and it's tiring to get to comments like that one.
Yes, you are right. My apologies for my initial comment, I could have definitely worded it better and been kinder about it but my frustration got the best of me. If you decide to make one for 2024, which I hope you do, I hope you take the things I mentioned into consideration.
Thank you, you worked hard all this time 🫶
thank you!!
waaah thank u so muchie
thank you for your comment!