I was raised a Muslim in Iran, and I only write one thing here.. everything this man says about Islam, the ideology and Jihad and stuff, they are all true, every last bit of it and even more.. I just wanted this here for anyone who dont know anything about Islam that think to themselves maybe he is lying or painting a dark picture about Islam and its teaching.. actually he is not, they are all true
Tech Master thank you for posting. But Mr. Spenser is talking more about Islamist not islam right? He is talking more about Salafists and extremists right? This isn't all muslims.
Isn't it funny how every single ex Muslim does not have any good things to say about Islam and you would think that one or two would say well there is nothing wrong with it but it is just not for me.. But they all say that Islam is oppressive etc and even when we have got people who have Escaped their own country from the heavy treatment of sharia law and people who have become apostates and we have people here in western countries saying that they are racist or biggots or anti Muslim etc and yet they are sat here in safety.. The fact of the matter is can you back up from Islamic sources the violence that has been committed in the name of Islam since it began and the answer is yes. But then people say but what about the Bible. Yes you can find some things in the old testament that are not exactly right however Jesus has been since the old testament and we now live under a new covenant of grace and can you back up any violent things that a Christian does from the new testament and the answer is no.. So sorry until they admit that there is a clear connection between Islam and terrorism and other things like stoning blasphemy law forced and child marriage etc then we can't even begin to address the issues. And yes we know that the majority of Muslims are lovely peaceful people who would never hurt anyone but that is because they are good people not because they are good people and not because of their religion.?
Best speech ever heard about Jihad, as ex-muslim from Middle east his talk was fully represented Islam. People who searching peace in Islam are stupid or leftist.
They are brainwashed. They do not understand that it is islam that is the source of their misery and problems - islam can not be reformed, it is false, man-made and it must be erased entirely. Otherwise we will have no peace with muslims.
@hypota6872 I've learned that merely "being from the Middle East, does NOT mean one knows and practices Islam any more than one who converted to al-Islam in the West. So, your intro doesn't impress me.....not to mention that you included the fact that you are no longer Muslim.
@Rob There is an ignorance in the US about Islam that is appalling. There is also ignorance about the truth to the Islamic Extremists, how violent they are.
@@galenmuhammad6910 your comments are entirely ridiculous and unfounded. Islam at its core is a satanic religion of hate. I’m not saying all muslims are this, but the religion is.
There is another book; Islamic Jihad by M. A. Khan that goes into a good bit of depth about Jihad in India. An Ex Muslim brought up in India which is why his concentration is on Islam in India.
I carefully study the his book history of jihad from mohamad to iss. It is very informative book on understanding of indoctrination of cruelty of Islam. In book all context of information about Islam history in india is 100% right. I recommend all indian hindus you must study this book with free of mind.
@@KD-ns1hn still defending Robbie the Islamaphobic robot, I see. Ye shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free. Once you learn the truth (which is obviously what you're currently lacking), you'll be as clear eyed as I am.
Dr. I request you to launch this book in India as it is expensive when we buy from india. I am willing to buy and spread 100 copies among my muslim freinds. That will only be possible if this book launch in India. India needs these books. Because we uave been hidden about the dirty islamic history since the last 70 years. Thank you 🙏
Mohd Saif Ali tell me , in Egypt in 19 century when Muslim were majority , what was need of Muslim brotherhood ? Who gave birth to Jawahiri ?why he joined Osama ? If ISIS creates by America as per good Muslim , who created Islamic state in Algeria in 1990 ..
Great talk, I'd like to add a little paraphrasing from the excellent text 'Jihad' by Paul Fregosi: After Mo died 632 his position was then filled by a series of Caliphs, they continued the expansionist policy of imperialism and colonialism as they spread Islam by the sword. I'll outline the history into Europe, but don't forget the expansionist policy also spread west into North Africa all the way to Morocco, and further East to China. I'll be brief in my outline: By 668 jihad manifested itself outside the walls of Constantinople 711 Islamic armies invaded Spain 800 years of fighting followed until 1492 The jihad engulfed more nations than the Palestine-bound Crusades (there were 8 of these between 1096 and 1270, less than 200 years, they wanted to establish themselves in the holy land which was formerly Christian) Far grander jihad continued as Muslims wanted to take and occupy Europe and Islamize it. Large parts of Europe were taken and occupied for centuries, sometimes devastated and some of it Islamized. Spain Portugal France Italy Sicily Austria Bosnia Serbia Croatia Hungary Romania Wallachia Albania Moldavia Bulgaria Greece Armenia Georgia Poland Ukraine Eastern and southern Russia All Jihad battlefields where Islam conquered or was conquered. Many of those lands were occupied by Muslims, in some cases by Arabs or Moors, in others by Ottoman Turks, usually for hundreds of years. Spain 800 years Portugal 600 (although maybe 106 depending on your perspective) Greece 500 Sicily 300 Serbia 400 Bulgaria 500 Romania 400 Hungary 150 years - a place particularly ruined/plundered and ravaged and it took 200 years to recover. Muslims came and occupied a huge part of Europe, the Turks besieged Vienna twice in 1529 and 1683. Their cavalry raided central Europe, riding into Bavaria almost as far as Nuremberg. They fought in Poland and the Ukraine, crushed Hungary, occupied Belgrade and Budapest for hundreds of years. The Moors and the Arabs took Spain and Portugal, invaded France through the Pyrenees, turned Sicily into an Islamic island, raided Rome, sacked St Peter's and obliged the pope to pay tribute. From their base near St Tropez they raided Switzerland as far as Lake Constance on the German border. The pirates of the Barbary coast raided England, Denmark, Ireland, Iceland and brought back thousands of slaves for the markets of Constantinople (after they had turned it into Istanbul) and North Africa. The Mongols threatened Moscow, occupied the Crimea and became Tatars. The Persians marched into Georgia, so did the Turks, who also occupied Armenia. Some imagine that the sack of Jerusalem in 1099 was the start of the hostility between Islam and the West, they handily ignore the capture of Jerusalem from the Christians in 638, the invasion of Spain some 70 years later by the Arabs and Moors, and the subsequent 800 year occupation in whole or in part of the Iberian peninsula. The unbelievers were pressured to convert and the only reason why in later years it became 'jizya and dhimmitude' rather than 'islam or death' was because it was financially beneficial. It even got to a point in Europe where people were converting to Islam because it was the most practical thing to do, to avoid the second class citizen status, that some Caliph's became concerned about their taxes from Al Andalus, but a later more pious caliph said "Allah sent his Prophet to be and apostle, not a tax collector" but he was the exception. Dhimmis had a hard time in Umayyad caliphate of Al Andalus (elsewhere the Abassids were in charge, long story linked to the Shia/Sunni split and inheritance/bloodlines and Mohammed) Dhimmis could not carry a weapon or ride a horse, into a donkey. They were not allowed to wear shoes and had to walk barefoot. A Christian who claimed that Jesus was divine was automatically executed. A Muslim who became a Christian or Jew was treated likewise. The ringing of church bells was forbidden. Christian religious processions were banned. Non-muslims had to stand aside if a Muslim passed them in the street. They could not wear anything with green in it. If a Muslim assaulted them, they were not allowed to fight back but we're only permitted to ask their aggressor to stop hitting them. Their status in many ways was like the Untouchables of Hindu caste system, or slaves of the Deep South USA. They were the dregs, the bottom of the pile. If they failed to pay the tribute to their conquers, they were enslaved or executed. All that said they weren't in Al Andalus at least, forced to convert. £££££ brother... Practical reality. It is interesting that the west has by-and-large forgotten this history, but it hasn't been forgotten by orthodox muslims, those who see the eventual expulsion of the invading force as a shame, and who seek to take back the lands of Al Andalus etc. It is in quite stark contrast that western Europeans do not celebrate their colonialist past, yet there are significant numbers of those within dar-ul-Islam who consider their colonialism to be a glorious one.
An excellent and informative presentation... You eloquently convey the foundings of your research to educate many on the true ideologies of Islam and Jihadists .. I am an appreciative student.
@@johnmguzman7491"Peer reviewed scientific evidence"? It's a history book, not a science book. As for reviews, you obviously have access to the Internet. If you're interested, you can look them up yourself.
The worst thing can anybody believe when Bush or Hillary Clinton or other ignorance politicians say Islam is a religion of peace these people whether are stupid or they are designed Islam is a evil religion was never religion of peace and will never be as long this religion will exist
You are absolutely right about everything you said. This is taught throughout the arab world (of which I am from) and the Christian population took it and accepted it as history and never questioned it and the result was their demise in almost all these countries.
@cumarfarah6319I say the same thing about Christianity. But I won't kill you or force you into 2nd class of society for not doing so. If only Islam was so tolerant.
@cumarfarah6319: Muhammad the Muslim prophet was the worst human being ever on planet earth even wors than Hitler. Muhammad the Muslim prophet immediately went to hell after he died. Allah is not God but a disgusting pagan moon god. Allah is a second rank devil. Abraham David or Moses have got nothing to do with Islam or Mecca. Islam is from the devil.
@cumarfarah6319the religion of hate and ignorance, treating woman being like second hand meanwhile man can have 4 wifes.All Islamic countries are third world life standarts
The book ist outstanding: enough sources and a comprehensive summary without fishy speculations. A rare example of a clearly structured and readable overview of historical evolution.
When we are talking about the History of Jihad, there must be always mentioned about Georgians, who are the people, who suffered the most by Islamic Jihad.
Robert should NEVER have been banned from coming to Britain, my country. It seems like the ban was a first signpost of my country abandoning free speech. Since the ban, of Robert and probably others, we have seen some sort of gradual slide toward something I and my boomer generation could never have imagined when we were youthful and excited about the future. Instead, now hitting 70, I see something very disturbing coming for my lovely, lovely grandchildren. And the words of Thomas Payne, about ‘if there is to be trouble let it be in my day’, are lost on my people.
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
Robert Spencer is a brilliant writer and speaker with a serene and austere quality to his words. It’s as if he doesn’t like the sound of his own voice and avoids using a single, unnecessary word.
Excellent Extempore presentation by Mr.Robert Spencer. Congratuate him reg. three aspects 1. An in depth study and analysis on this subject. 2. His mentioning India in his talk ,wherein he explained how India has been affected by Jihad. 3. His boldness in calling a spade a spade.,unlike some of our Politicians My best wishes to him.
Everyone should listen to the lectures by Robert Spencer, about Islamic Jihad. As Thomas Jefferson has said about the Koran, "every American should read this book," (the Koran).
I've been saying this for years, people are letting their guards down. As someone who grow up as a Christian minority in the middle East, I assure you that what he said is 100% accurate.
@@MustafaMuhammed1981 Another religious fool, lying about the true history of one of the most hateful religions of this Earth: th-cam.com/video/FhgA42w1rKs/w-d-xo.html *
@rod of discipline "... because they are Muslim" no because they are academic unlike your gods (depressed anti-Muslim TH-camrs like AP and Robert Spencer), you believe them just because they tell you what you want to hear.
There were no atheists or agnostics in the 7th century. Jews and Christians lived on the Arabian Peninsula. The Arabians were mostly Christians. Muhammad's wife was also a Christian. There were no interfaith marriages. This means that before all his problems with mental health (visions, communication with spirits and angels) he was a Christian, albeit not the most righteous.
Say what you want about Robert... history has proven him correct again and again. Here we are 6 years later and everything he focused on here is as relevent as it was the day it was written.
“Israel is mentioned 43 times in the Quran. On the other hand, Palestine is not mentioned even once” and archaeological findings like maps, documents, and coins prove Jews are Israel’s indigenous population. Muslims say Allah is the Best Deceiver (Qur'an 3:54); Jesus responds: You belong to your father, the devil. He was a murderer from the beginning, there is no truth in him for he is a liar and the father of lies.(John 8:44) If Trump wins Yahya Sinwar's days are numbered
Fam. Timmer nobody believes your British and missionary lies anymore ! I know you are ass burnt! After india stopped illegal missionary funds !! You keep your preaching to your church and pedo preachers.. Get a life!! We know how bad you people were and still are .. th-cam.com/video/WKwhansfZ4s/w-d-xo.html blood suckers!
When criticising the British .You forgot to mention they were fighting the Austrians ,the Germans and the Ottomans . So any help in defeating the enemy was welcome .How would they know oil was to be found across Arabia .
~9:10: "At the same time the Hindus in India did not even have that protection because they were not people of the book and consequently the choice that Muhammad and Qur'an give for the people of the book to convert or submit to the rule of Islamic law or be killed, for the Hindus it was only convert or be killed. And as I show in the book the history of jihad in India was especially bloody and especially violent. A certain point actually they had to grant them honorary people of the book status because it simply wasn't possible to kill them all but they were still nonetheless extraordinarily harsh toward especially the Hindu temples. The Quran speaks about protecting churches and synagogues because the name of Allah is spoken there...but there was no such protection afforded to the Hindu temples at all and thousands and tens of thousands of them were destroyed, a great patrimony of human culture lost forever." [almost verbatim; sic.]
@@vanditsingh925 Tell me? I am a kind gentle man that helps the homeless and assist the elderly. Yet multiple times i have been robbed of all i have by friends and even family? I recieved a 3rd degree burn for my 11th birthday. I have many stories of my plights throughout my life that are similar. So tell me why does Karma punish me?
I am personally acquainted with an elderly American (Lebanese Christian) financier who was very good friends with E. Said. He also helped finance the American School in Beirut, bank rolled Obama and the Dems including getting Biden elected and has personal ties to the Saudi royals. I challenged him once years ago about how awful Islam is........he vehemently told me that I was ignorant had no idea what I was talking about. Since we had a good professional relationship he continued hiring me but I never respected him after that.
I watched Robert Spencer's debate with Nadir Ahmed. Nadir Ahmed accepted that Quran(9:29) order to fight infidels but it does not order to fight infidels only because they are infidels. He was repeating only one thing that Robert Spencer should reply why? But Nadir Ahmed's acceptance shows that Quran orders to fight infidel because of some other reasons but he did not mention the reason. Therefore, it is aparent that the order is to fight the infidels without any reason, which itself means that the order is to fight the infidels because they are infidels.
Very difficult to hear questions. Sometimes you can figure out the question from the answer, but it would be good to hear the question repeated by the speaker, before the answer. Otherwise, great talk, as usual with Robert.
The violent text in Christian books is the irrelevant as we only think today of loving thy neighbour and peace and quiet. We don’t go around killing people because of what it says in the Bible
It all stems from here: Genesis 16:11-12 “And the angel also said, “You are now pregnant and will give birth to a son. You are to name him Ishmael (which means ‘God hears’), for the Lord has heard your cry of distress. This son of yours will be a wild man, as untamed as a wild donkey! He will raise his fist against everyone, and everyone will be against him. Yes, he will live in open hostility against all his relatives.”
The truth isn't being spoken by Robert Spencer. Not sure WHY you're posting Jefferson's quote here. Post that on DeSatan's, er Desantis' page where he's opposed to teaching ACTUAL history and removing Black Studies courses for all of Florida.
Suyash Pranay Tripathi THANK YOU FOR YOUR REPLY: Mike Johnson and by the virtue of hadiths whatever Muhammad did is considered good and followable and that's why everyone. 👍😊
Actually, Spencer may be incorrect now about what the FBI teaches in counter-terror training. I watched a video of a lecture given by Bill Warner about the same things Robert Spencer covers. In this lecture, there was a point when Warner mentioned that he had received requests by the current administration to once again give his lectures to military members and perhaps federal agents as well. Therefore, perhaps Trump might know more about this Islamic issue than we might think.
Al Andalus - when the Moors invaded Spain they had help from locals, from the Jews who were being so badly persecuted by the Catholic Church and ongoing waves of Inquisitions that they were safer under the Shari'a in humility and dhimmitude than left at the mercy of the Catholic Church. Some significant help also came from one or two local Counts for reasons I'll explain. The story goes that there was a woman, there always is. Florinda was the daughter of Count Julian who wasn't as much of a pussy as he sounds. Florinda was invited by King Rodrigo to learn the craft of a lady in waiting at the Visigothic court in Toledo. The randy king had seen her swimming, the rest you can work out.. so Florinda ended up telling her dad what happened, he could not do much because Rodrigo is king, despite the lack of honour and all that. Julian goes to Ceuta with Florinda and and seeks Musa the emir of North Africa, and tells Musa about the discontent in Rodrigo's Spain and about Witiza the son of the previous king that Rodrigo himself usurped. Musa goes for it and sends his army across the sea guided by Count Julian and let by Tarik a former slave who converted, he was tough and committed, swore by the Qur'an and the sword. Julian guides the invading colonising force to a safe landing site later called Jabel Tarik (Tariks Mountain) and later again Gibraltar. Tarik and his army won for Musa, Count Julian and Florinda, and Witiza got his revenge although he would never rule as Musa sends a son for that job.
The Inquisition did not exist when the Arabs invaded the Visigothic Kingdom. This would be created during the Reconquista. It is true that the Visigothic Kingdom and the Catholic Church did persecute the Jews before the Arab conquest. That story is a legend though, made up later on the the various Arab emirs and caliphs to legitimize their takeover of Al Andalus. Anyone can come up with a story to justify anything, but the point of contention is that the Arabs built their empire, their caliphate through conquering others, seizing their lands and their people by force and gradually, by imposing the dhimmi/jizya status/tax, these non-Muslim subjects would be incentivized to convert to Islam so that they would benefit from a more relaxed tax system (the zakat was lower than the jizya) and they would be able to climb the social ladder easier as a Muslim, at least in terms of the state bureaucracy.
![เปิดบ้าน นาราเครปกระเทย 1 ไร่ ขายขาดทุนหลัก10ล้าน เอามาใช้หนี้!!! l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0jz84VFWVP4/mqdefault.jpg)
I was raised a Muslim in Iran, and I only write one thing here.. everything this man says about Islam, the ideology and Jihad and stuff, they are all true, every last bit of it and even more.. I just wanted this here for anyone who dont know anything about Islam that think to themselves maybe he is lying or painting a dark picture about Islam and its teaching.. actually he is not, they are all true
Tech Master thank you for posting. But Mr. Spenser is talking more about Islamist not islam right? He is talking more about Salafists and extremists right? This isn't all muslims.
Isn't it funny how every single ex Muslim does not have any good things to say about Islam and you would think that one or two would say well there is nothing wrong with it but it is just not for me.. But they all say that Islam is oppressive etc and even when we have got people who have Escaped their own country from the heavy treatment of sharia law and people who have become apostates and we have people here in western countries saying that they are racist or biggots or anti Muslim etc and yet they are sat here in safety.. The fact of the matter is can you back up from Islamic sources the violence that has been committed in the name of Islam since it began and the answer is yes. But then people say but what about the Bible. Yes you can find some things in the old testament that are not exactly right however Jesus has been since the old testament and we now live under a new covenant of grace and can you back up any violent things that a Christian does from the new testament and the answer is no.. So sorry until they admit that there is a clear connection between Islam and terrorism and other things like stoning blasphemy law forced and child marriage etc then we can't even begin to address the issues. And yes we know that the majority of Muslims are lovely peaceful people who would never hurt anyone but that is because they are good people not because they are good people and not because of their religion.?
@Postmortem Colonoscopy
OK, keyboard Jihadist.
@Postmortem Colonoscopy you are a contemptible person who argues from your rotten soul.
@@postmortemcolonoscopy1825😂
Best speech ever heard about Jihad, as ex-muslim from Middle east his talk was fully represented Islam. People who searching peace in Islam are stupid or leftist.
Glad you enjoyed it!
They are brainwashed. They do not understand that it is islam that is the source of their misery and problems - islam can not be reformed, it is false, man-made and it must be erased entirely. Otherwise we will have no peace with muslims.
@hypota6872 I've learned that merely "being from the Middle East, does NOT mean one knows and practices Islam any more than one who converted to al-Islam in the West. So, your intro doesn't impress me.....not to mention that you included the fact that you are no longer Muslim.
@@George-iv1hi
Not man made but monster. Actually demonic
@user-gd8oe9uu3p
Thank you so much. Some ppl still don't get it. Plus Muslims lie to cover their subterfuge. Cannot trust them whatsoever!!
Thank you for speaking for hindus in India, finally someone said it 🙏
Glad you enjoyed it! Be sure to check out his Speaker Playlist for his other talks.
We have suffered more than anyone in the name of jihad
Biggest genocide in the history of mankind has been conducted against the Hindus
Buddhists, Christians, Jains, Zoroastrians and others also suffered tremendously under islam.
I’m a simple woman, I see Robert Spencer was invited to speak - I subscribe.
Yes you said it
You jew like him! SionisT Mafia help each other 24/7
@@ma55382uk To be clear, she should have typed "simple-minded".....
He's doing such important work and with so many qualifications too . . .
I learn so much from Robert, so glad he chose to do his own research and now publicly educate those in the West.
@Rob There is an ignorance in the US about Islam that is appalling. There is also ignorance about the truth to the Islamic Extremists, how violent they are.
Learn so much what besides anti-Islamic propaganda....??!! 🤔
Who goes to an Islamaphobe to learn about that which they have an inordinate fear and bias against....??
@@galenmuhammad6910 your comments are entirely ridiculous and unfounded. Islam at its core is a satanic religion of hate. I’m not saying all muslims are this, but the religion is.
There is another book; Islamic Jihad by M. A. Khan that goes into a good bit of depth about Jihad in India. An Ex Muslim brought up in India which is why his concentration is on Islam in India.
All politicians must listen to this speech
...and then they're free to laugh at him.
I've read some of his books. Excellent !!
Politicians won’t prosecute a Muslim when the politician wants the Muslim vote ! It’s that simple.
You have a crystal ball. Look at Biden selling Isreal down thw toilet for the Michigan and DEI vote!
He’s very articulate and educated, every word and sentence, he cracked the code.
I carefully study the his book history of jihad from mohamad to iss.
It is very informative book on understanding of indoctrination of cruelty of Islam.
In book all context of information about Islam history in india is 100% right.
I recommend all indian hindus you must study this book with free of mind.
Once you read Robert's book on Jihad, you will never think about Islam the same way you used to think
But if one KNOWS Islam, one would know that Spencer's book is FULL of literal HOGWASH!!
@@galenmuhammad6910Care to expand?
@@galenmuhammad6910 you are so blinded
@@KD-ns1hn still defending Robbie the Islamaphobic robot, I see.
Ye shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free.
Once you learn the truth (which is obviously what you're currently lacking), you'll be as clear eyed as I am.
@@galenmuhammad6910 the more you comment, the more you show your ignorance
Dr. I request you to launch this book in India as it is expensive when we buy from india. I am willing to buy and spread 100 copies among my muslim freinds. That will only be possible if this book launch in India. India needs these books. Because we uave been hidden about the dirty islamic history since the last 70 years. Thank you 🙏
@Husain Ali eat shit
All books of Robert spencer are available on amazon.
At least you must study book on jihad.
Mohd Saif Ali tell me , in Egypt in 19 century when Muslim were majority , what was need of Muslim brotherhood ?
Who gave birth to Jawahiri ?why he joined Osama ?
If ISIS creates by America as per good Muslim , who created Islamic state in Algeria in 1990 ..
Mohd Saif Ali what Mugal was ? Not Islamic ?
Mohd Saif Ali biggest Joke
I have recently started watching Mr. Spence who, in my humble opinion, is very informative, thruthful and help full in my exploration of Islam
Great talk, I'd like to add a little paraphrasing from the excellent text 'Jihad' by Paul Fregosi:
After Mo died 632 his position was then filled by a series of Caliphs, they continued the expansionist policy of imperialism and colonialism as they spread Islam by the sword. I'll outline the history into Europe, but don't forget the expansionist policy also spread west into North Africa all the way to Morocco, and further East to China. I'll be brief in my outline:
By 668 jihad manifested itself outside the walls of Constantinople
711 Islamic armies invaded Spain
800 years of fighting followed until 1492
The jihad engulfed more nations than the Palestine-bound Crusades (there were 8 of these between 1096 and 1270, less than 200 years, they wanted to establish themselves in the holy land which was formerly Christian)
Far grander jihad continued as Muslims wanted to take and occupy Europe and Islamize it. Large parts of Europe were taken and occupied for centuries, sometimes devastated and some of it Islamized.
Spain
Portugal
France
Italy
Sicily
Austria
Bosnia
Serbia
Croatia
Hungary
Romania
Wallachia
Albania
Moldavia
Bulgaria
Greece
Armenia
Georgia
Poland
Ukraine
Eastern and southern Russia
All Jihad battlefields where Islam conquered or was conquered. Many of those lands were occupied by Muslims, in some cases by Arabs or Moors, in others by Ottoman Turks, usually for hundreds of years.
Spain 800 years
Portugal 600 (although maybe 106 depending on your perspective)
Greece 500
Sicily 300
Serbia 400
Bulgaria 500
Romania 400
Hungary 150 years - a place particularly ruined/plundered and ravaged and it took 200 years to recover.
Muslims came and occupied a huge part of Europe, the Turks besieged Vienna twice in 1529 and 1683. Their cavalry raided central Europe, riding into Bavaria almost as far as Nuremberg. They fought in Poland and the Ukraine, crushed Hungary, occupied Belgrade and Budapest for hundreds of years.
The Moors and the Arabs took Spain and Portugal, invaded France through the Pyrenees, turned Sicily into an Islamic island, raided Rome, sacked St Peter's and obliged the pope to pay tribute. From their base near St Tropez they raided Switzerland as far as Lake Constance on the German border. The pirates of the Barbary coast raided England, Denmark, Ireland, Iceland and brought back thousands of slaves for the markets of Constantinople (after they had turned it into Istanbul) and North Africa. The Mongols threatened Moscow, occupied the Crimea and became Tatars. The Persians marched into Georgia, so did the Turks, who also occupied Armenia.
Some imagine that the sack of Jerusalem in 1099 was the start of the hostility between Islam and the West, they handily ignore the capture of Jerusalem from the Christians in 638, the invasion of Spain some 70 years later by the Arabs and Moors, and the subsequent 800 year occupation in whole or in part of the Iberian peninsula.
The unbelievers were pressured to convert and the only reason why in later years it became 'jizya and dhimmitude' rather than 'islam or death' was because it was financially beneficial. It even got to a point in Europe where people were converting to Islam because it was the most practical thing to do, to avoid the second class citizen status, that some Caliph's became concerned about their taxes from Al Andalus, but a later more pious caliph said "Allah sent his Prophet to be and apostle, not a tax collector" but he was the exception.
Dhimmis had a hard time in Umayyad caliphate of Al Andalus (elsewhere the Abassids were in charge, long story linked to the Shia/Sunni split and inheritance/bloodlines and Mohammed)
Dhimmis could not carry a weapon or ride a horse, into a donkey. They were not allowed to wear shoes and had to walk barefoot. A Christian who claimed that Jesus was divine was automatically executed. A Muslim who became a Christian or Jew was treated likewise. The ringing of church bells was forbidden. Christian religious processions were banned. Non-muslims had to stand aside if a Muslim passed them in the street. They could not wear anything with green in it. If a Muslim assaulted them, they were not allowed to fight back but we're only permitted to ask their aggressor to stop hitting them.
Their status in many ways was like the Untouchables of Hindu caste system, or slaves of the Deep South USA. They were the dregs, the bottom of the pile. If they failed to pay the tribute to their conquers, they were enslaved or executed.
All that said they weren't in Al Andalus at least, forced to convert. £££££ brother... Practical reality.
It is interesting that the west has by-and-large forgotten this history, but it hasn't been forgotten by orthodox muslims, those who see the eventual expulsion of the invading force as a shame, and who seek to take back the lands of Al Andalus etc.
It is in quite stark contrast that western Europeans do not celebrate their colonialist past, yet there are significant numbers of those within dar-ul-Islam who consider their colonialism to be a glorious one.
An excellent and informative presentation... You eloquently convey the foundings of your research to educate many on the true ideologies of Islam and Jihadists .. I am an appreciative student.
Lydia, have you found any peer reviewed scientific evidence studies that proves Spencer's assertions?
@@johnmguzman7491"Peer reviewed scientific evidence"? It's a history book, not a science book. As for reviews, you obviously have access to the Internet. If you're interested, you can look them up yourself.
Focus on india. There is very brutal history about non Muslims
And what about those the 60,000 hindu that killed without defending themselves In the hands of jihadies
You are the smartest Professor of history ... I Am Albanian Catholic and I know it as well.
th-cam.com/video/8vxbN2jZL6M/w-d-xo.html
hang in there man!!! Just a lazy western Catholic here who has had it easy...UNTIL NOW....
ps I met the "Mother" one time...in 1997 on Mother Teresa's visit to DC...I was a volunteer at Gift of Peace...
I totally agree on his understanding of history of jihad. It is very convincing for me as i am studying the islamic movement nowdays.
@Postmortem Colonoscopy
👆Look guys, a butt-hurt Jihadi!
The worst thing can anybody believe when Bush or Hillary Clinton or other ignorance politicians say Islam is a religion of peace these people whether are stupid or they are designed Islam is a evil religion was never religion of peace and will never be as long this religion will exist
Hilarious comment from Hindutva fascist
This is eye opening. I wish more people would watch this and learn.
God bless Robert Spencer for speaking the truth on Islam.
God bless you Robert Spencer please stay safe.
You are absolutely right about everything you said. This is taught throughout the arab world (of which I am from) and the Christian population took it and accepted it as history and never questioned it and the result was their demise in almost all these countries.
Robert Spencer is an American hero
Just another jewish brat
All Muslims should denounce Islam for betterment of humanity
@cumarfarah6319I say the same thing about Christianity. But I won't kill you or force you into 2nd class of society for not doing so. If only Islam was so tolerant.
@cumarfarah6319: Muhammad the Muslim prophet was the worst human being ever on planet earth even wors than Hitler. Muhammad the Muslim prophet immediately went to hell after he died. Allah is not God but a disgusting pagan moon god. Allah is a second rank devil. Abraham David or Moses have got nothing to do with Islam or Mecca. Islam is from the devil.
@cumarfarah6319😂😂😂😂dreams
@cumarfarah6319the religion of hate and ignorance, treating woman being like second hand meanwhile man can have 4 wifes.All Islamic countries are third world life standarts
Sam goes for Jews like Spencer
The book ist outstanding: enough sources and a comprehensive summary without fishy speculations. A rare example of a clearly structured and readable overview of historical evolution.
Thank you for your work, Robert 🙏
No better speaker on the subject. In my eyes, a great man.
Spencer was humiliated very bad ib debate
Dr bill warner good
@@nadirahmed4224You wish he’s telling Islam as it truely is a demonic religion.
@@nadirahmed4224Your satanic beards says it all, Abdul. I reserve my comments.
Yeah and your eyes are blind
Robert Spencer is my favourite critic of Islam.
@@postmortemcolonoscopy1825hello Muhammademon
When we are talking about the History of Jihad, there must be always mentioned about Georgians, who are the people, who suffered the most by Islamic Jihad.
Robert should NEVER have been banned from coming to Britain, my country. It seems like the ban was a first signpost of my country abandoning free speech. Since the ban, of Robert and probably others, we have seen some sort of gradual slide toward something I and my boomer generation could never have imagined when we were youthful and excited about the future. Instead, now hitting 70, I see something very disturbing coming for my lovely, lovely grandchildren. And the words of Thomas Payne, about ‘if there is to be trouble let it be in my day’, are lost on my people.
Couldn't agree more....Spenser desperately needed here in the UK...
I think it was Christopher Hitchens who said something like: "No barbarians conquered a city without someone holding open the door."
An outstanding and informative presentation from Robert Spencer.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Enforce our own laws.” So simple! Such an simple, elegant idea for the start of a solution. So tragic that it is not done!
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
True that. You kno who also enforces their laws muslim countries, they'll never compromise on their beliefs like we do in the west. What else is left to do to accommodate them even better, bent down over and take it like a man?
Thank you for posting! Re watching these videos multiple times ! Oldie but a Goldie
Glad you enjoyed it! Please share with friends.
Very revealing of the true nature and agenda of Islam.
Robert Spencer is a brilliant writer and speaker with a serene and austere quality to his words. It’s as if he doesn’t like the sound of his own voice and avoids using a single, unnecessary word.
God bless you and people will understand your value in future
Very important to know for everyone
Better to know as soon as possible for our children
Robert is a hero in our day. Brave truth-teller. God bless him.
🐂💩
I am a Hindu my jew brotjher
Rajputs defended Hindus
Sikhs did a great job in saving Hindu
May God protect Robert and all brave people who are interested in truth and exposing the world's biggest lie .
Excellent The lord bless you abundantly and keep you safe sir (in Jesus name)
Please republish this book in India. We will be thankful to you.
Book available on amazon.
But cost approx 1000 rupees.
@@PAWANKUMAR-fm7ym great
Please stop attacking Indian Christians and let them proselytise
@@ma55382uk why don't you ask a indian Christians about the treatment from majority.
Robert Spencer very interest guy, I need to know more about this...
If you look at our playlists, you will see a nearly comprehensive list of his public commentary. You can also check out his work on Jihad Watch.
Thanks Robert for telling the truth.
Excellent Extempore presentation by Mr.Robert Spencer.
Congratuate him reg. three aspects
1. An in depth study and analysis on this subject.
2. His mentioning India in his talk ,wherein he explained how India has been affected by Jihad.
3. His boldness in calling a spade a spade.,unlike some of our Politicians
My best wishes to him.
If only we could hear the questions.
Thank you Robert Spencer
Everyone should listen to the lectures by Robert Spencer, about Islamic Jihad. As Thomas Jefferson has said about the Koran, "every American should read this book," (the Koran).
You must know and understand your enemy to defeat them.
I've been saying this for years, people are letting their guards down. As someone who grow up as a Christian minority in the middle East, I assure you that what he said is 100% accurate.
What do you think? What can we learn from the history of Jihad? Read the transcript: westminster-institute.org/events/robert-spencer/
ban islam
@@MustafaMuhammed1981 Another religious fool, lying about the true history of one of the most hateful religions of this Earth:
th-cam.com/video/FhgA42w1rKs/w-d-xo.html *
@@JohnStopman AP was exposed so badly by the Andalusian Project, "EFDwawah" and "Durkastan" channels.th-cam.com/video/J7PoU795MJs/w-d-xo.html
@rod of discipline "... because they are Muslim" no because they are academic unlike your gods (depressed anti-Muslim TH-camrs like AP and Robert Spencer), you believe them just because they tell you what you want to hear.
One of the most manipulated concepts in Islam. www.quran-islam.org/articles/part_3/the_concept_of_jihad_%28P1360%29.html
I'm Spanish, to this day, instead of saying "the coast is clear!" It's said "there are no Moores in the coast!"
this is very informative.
God bless America
Thank you for the kind comment!
Good to Know Historical Facts...
"My brother against my brother, but both of us against our cousin."
The greatest trick the devil every played was to make the world believe it never existed
There were no atheists or agnostics in the 7th century. Jews and Christians lived on the Arabian Peninsula. The Arabians were mostly Christians. Muhammad's wife was also a Christian. There were no interfaith marriages. This means that before all his problems with mental health (visions, communication with spirits and angels) he was a Christian, albeit not the most righteous.
Blessed are the peacemakers
Bro. No way Obama was gonna start teaching Islam. People still call him Osama and call him a Muslim!!🤦🏽♀️
Superb speech from a front line warrior.
Say what you want about Robert... history has proven him correct again and again. Here we are 6 years later and everything he focused on here is as relevent as it was the day it was written.
“Israel is mentioned 43 times in the Quran. On the other hand, Palestine is not mentioned even once” and archaeological findings like maps, documents, and coins prove Jews are Israel’s indigenous population.
Muslims say Allah is the Best Deceiver (Qur'an 3:54); Jesus responds: You belong to your father, the devil. He was a murderer from the beginning, there is no truth in him for he is a liar and the father of lies.(John 8:44)
If Trump wins Yahya Sinwar's days are numbered
Thanks for speaking the unsaid truth about Hindu persecution by Jihadis.. which is million times harsher than Jew persecution!!
Hindus are persecuting christians too. Christians in India have the lowest cast/dalith. The cast system itself is ungodly.
Fam. Timmer nobody believes your British and missionary lies anymore ! I know you are ass burnt! After india stopped illegal missionary funds !! You keep your preaching to your church and pedo preachers.. Get a life!! We know how bad you people were and still are .. th-cam.com/video/WKwhansfZ4s/w-d-xo.html blood suckers!
17:25 me as a jew i know islamic spain as the spain that told the jews "either leave or convert"
Im a big fan of Robert
The man is legend, calling spade a spade
When criticising the British .You forgot to mention they were fighting the Austrians ,the Germans and the Ottomans . So any help in defeating the enemy was welcome .How would they know oil was to be found across Arabia .
~9:10: "At the same time the Hindus in India did not even have that protection because they were not people of the book and consequently the choice that Muhammad and Qur'an give for the people of the book to convert or submit to the rule of Islamic law or be killed, for the Hindus it was only convert or be killed. And as I show in the book the history of jihad in India was especially bloody and especially violent. A certain point actually they had to grant them honorary people of the book status because it simply wasn't possible to kill them all but they were still nonetheless extraordinarily harsh toward especially the Hindu temples. The Quran speaks about protecting churches and synagogues because the name of Allah is spoken there...but there was no such protection afforded to the Hindu temples at all and thousands and tens of thousands of them were destroyed, a great patrimony of human culture lost forever." [almost verbatim; sic.]
Karna will punish everyone who goes against the concept of shaanti and dharma
Karma*
@@vanditsingh925 Tell me? I am a kind gentle man that helps the homeless and assist the elderly. Yet multiple times i have been robbed of all i have by friends and even family? I recieved a 3rd degree burn for my 11th birthday. I have many stories of my plights throughout my life that are similar. So tell me why does Karma punish me?
I agree with everything he says. Do you think I could post this on social media in England in 2024 without being arrested and imprisoned.
You and Christian Prince are the brave ones to tell the truth.👍
Yet he got exposed in the PBD podcast 😂😂😂
@@humzanafees9348 Christian Prince would shut them all down.
I am personally acquainted with an elderly American (Lebanese Christian) financier who was very good friends with E. Said. He also helped finance the American School in Beirut, bank rolled Obama and the Dems including getting Biden elected and has personal ties to the Saudi royals. I challenged him once years ago about how awful Islam is........he vehemently told me that I was ignorant had no idea what I was talking about. Since we had a good professional relationship he continued hiring me but I never respected him after that.
Thanks for your great work, Robert!!!
You’re so amazing Sir!!
Waoww! Very brilliant!
Thank you for your speech!!👏👏👏👏👏👏
I watched Robert Spencer's debate with Nadir Ahmed. Nadir Ahmed accepted that Quran(9:29) order to fight infidels but it does not order to fight infidels only because they are infidels. He was repeating only one thing that Robert Spencer should reply why? But Nadir Ahmed's acceptance shows that Quran orders to fight infidel because of some other reasons but he did not mention the reason. Therefore, it is aparent that the order is to fight the infidels without any reason, which itself means that the order is to fight the infidels because they are infidels.
Thanks sir telling truth n exposing cult Islam
What a bummer that the Q&A was not a pro effort.
Lecturers should repeat the questions so that the folks at home are in the picture.
Very difficult to hear questions. Sometimes you can figure out the question from the answer, but it would be good to hear the question repeated by the speaker, before the answer. Otherwise, great talk, as usual with Robert.
Good point. Will advise speakers to do so in the future.
RC is the Best 👍👍👍
Truth revealed. Eye opener .
You’re right. Robert is a very adjunct fellow.
Why should we not be islamophobic ? There are all the reasons of the world to be so.
The violent text in Christian books is the irrelevant as we only think today of loving thy neighbour and peace and quiet. We don’t go around killing people because of what it says in the Bible
Amen
It all stems from here:
Genesis 16:11-12
“And the angel also said, “You are now pregnant and will give birth to a son. You are to name him Ishmael (which means ‘God hears’), for the Lord has heard your cry of distress. This son of yours will be a wild man, as untamed as a wild donkey! He will raise his fist against everyone, and everyone will be against him. Yes, he will live in open hostility against all his relatives.”
You can’t reform Islam flushing it down the toilet is the only option
Shared numerous times.
Thank you!
i support you Robert from India
Never be afraid of the truth, and where it may lead.
Thomas Jefferson
The truth isn't being spoken by Robert Spencer. Not sure WHY you're posting Jefferson's quote here. Post that on DeSatan's, er Desantis' page where he's opposed to teaching ACTUAL history and removing Black Studies courses for all of Florida.
maybe he's tired of black people hating on whites
Thanks Robert for your scholarship.
What he say is very accurate now look at harvard university in 2023.
Suyash Pranay Tripathi THANK YOU FOR YOUR REPLY:
Mike Johnson and by the virtue of hadiths whatever Muhammad did is considered good and followable and that's why everyone. 👍😊
Buy his book! I have it and are going through it again m, 5 years after buying it! 🏴✝️🇬🇧✡️🇮🇱 Standing with Israel 🙏🏼✝️
2:27 - beginning of speech
the Man
the Legend
I'd still watch if he wasn't so funny and charming
This explains the Hamas attack on Israel Oct 7, 2023
👏👏👏👏👏🎉
Mr Spencer you should receive a PhD in Islâmic Studies. I doubt anyone knows more,maybe just as much But not more,
Robert Spence is knowledgeable but no one knows more about Islam and Muhammad then the Christian Prince.
Brilliant scholar. May god bless you Mr Spencer, and protect you from the evil of Islam and Muslims who wish you evil
Thank you Mr Spencer! Thank you Westminster Institute!
Actually, Spencer may be incorrect now about what the FBI teaches in counter-terror training. I watched a video of a lecture given by Bill Warner about the same things Robert Spencer covers. In this lecture, there was a point when Warner mentioned that he had received requests by the current administration to once again give his lectures to military members and perhaps federal agents as well. Therefore, perhaps Trump might know more about this Islamic issue than we might think.
Dodgelover1929 Thank God!
Check out this latest debate with Dr Bill Warren th-cam.com/video/qbeBR2AMZV0/w-d-xo.html
Al Andalus - when the Moors invaded Spain they had help from locals, from the Jews who were being so badly persecuted by the Catholic Church and ongoing waves of Inquisitions that they were safer under the Shari'a in humility and dhimmitude than left at the mercy of the Catholic Church. Some significant help also came from one or two local Counts for reasons I'll explain.
The story goes that there was a woman, there always is. Florinda was the daughter of Count Julian who wasn't as much of a pussy as he sounds. Florinda was invited by King Rodrigo to learn the craft of a lady in waiting at the Visigothic court in Toledo. The randy king had seen her swimming, the rest you can work out.. so Florinda ended up telling her dad what happened, he could not do much because Rodrigo is king, despite the lack of honour and all that. Julian goes to Ceuta with Florinda and and seeks Musa the emir of North Africa, and tells Musa about the discontent in Rodrigo's Spain and about Witiza the son of the previous king that Rodrigo himself usurped. Musa goes for it and sends his army across the sea guided by Count Julian and let by Tarik a former slave who converted, he was tough and committed, swore by the Qur'an and the sword. Julian guides the invading colonising force to a safe landing site later called Jabel Tarik (Tariks Mountain) and later again Gibraltar.
Tarik and his army won for Musa, Count Julian and Florinda, and Witiza got his revenge although he would never rule as Musa sends a son for that job.
The Inquisition did not exist when the Arabs invaded the Visigothic Kingdom. This would be created during the Reconquista. It is true that the Visigothic Kingdom and the Catholic Church did persecute the Jews before the Arab conquest.
That story is a legend though, made up later on the the various Arab emirs and caliphs to legitimize their takeover of Al Andalus. Anyone can come up with a story to justify anything, but the point of contention is that the Arabs built their empire, their caliphate through conquering others, seizing their lands and their people by force and gradually, by imposing the dhimmi/jizya status/tax, these non-Muslim subjects would be incentivized to convert to Islam so that they would benefit from a more relaxed tax system (the zakat was lower than the jizya) and they would be able to climb the social ladder easier as a Muslim, at least in terms of the state bureaucracy.