I've been fan of them since i was in 7th grade and i'm in college now, looking back to this video now i realized that every one of them has a great stage presence with no hole compared to newer groups now.
@@chisquare5501 well you kinda mentioned them by referring to them by their title, eitherways the new girl groups are okay, I just dont particularly think anyone has consistent good music like gfriend and noone has stage presence like soshi did
Uuuu3i37h3i3i3 úr OP u74l3i7⅞³uwk8ijh7ikwjh4ho29u4hhryk7ku74ko3u3wl84ulw 99 jrjrur nnwu38 99 55 hth 5u5i3 PL 4u75k4i93 u5 un k5934jyúhe8y5j4 9o k3 9o 4j92k35n8b b kll 20u5k203 PL u
Fjj tur un 5j78 Yu ii u54k74k4kj ki un 54 k4 8i 4k49u4 un re 4ko⁷rj Yu ehhh no i4u4 un 3o 9o bb 93j hi 3 lo h4i43j4 bu lo 9o h hi 593yy34o9u hi o393y47k uu 77 49 99 un hijo 99 uu4i3 99 8u 3h ii9 uu u
I miss music shows era when they didn't use too much background music, so we can identify if the singers were singing live or not, if u follow Kpop since long time ago you'd understand what I mean, the audio for music show these days is so different from back than 2008-2011
YoonYul's hairstyle :) Yoona is such a beautiful girl , she is so good in dancing and rapping .. Also in singing :D Sunny's kick tho ;) Yoona can hit low and deep notes the best in all members
Well back then her knees weren't acting up as it was in the 2014-2016... it's because of all the hard work & performances in heels that she almost lost her career and destroyed her health. The issue she had with her knees almost caused her everything she loved. But she did what she had to do (surgery) and was back working her ass off again. She didn't have enough time to recuperate because the show most go on. She once again continued to perform for us the fans not fully recovered because that's how much she loves us. But what we do in return talk shit & comment useless things. Her dancing was and still is amazing compare to some of the other members even during her off period. She's an exceptional dancer & vocalist. People need to learn the truth of the sacrifices she made to perform on the stage night after night day after day comebacks after comebacks just for the fans & group. She gives so much yet we aren't appreciative.
@@TimelessGap2 when I commented, I didn't mean to sound grumpy or even complaining. I mean, she's still my favorite soshi until nowadays. I was aiming more to a "lose of stamina as we get older" perspective (which is pretty much normal if you ask me). As we can see even in kpop or any other industry. It's part of our life cycle. However, I totally agree with the perspective you brought and in order to avoid other people getting my comment in the wrong way (and worse agreeing with it), I decided to edit my post. Sunny was and still is a hardworker and a talented person. She deserves to be recognized for that. :D
@@lovelucasperroniX When I commented I wasn't saying you thought any of those things you listed. Many have been commenting on Sunny's performances from 2015-2017 accusing her of everything from being lazy, looking bored, doesn't want to be there, worst dancer in Snsd, and then some. I was just making it clear to those who will see your comment and then make stupid comparison to her down period. As I've seen on other videos. This wasn't particularly aimed at you but for to those who feel the need to badmouth her for being the hardworker and professional she is. You didn't need to edit your comment as that was your opinion and observation on the performance. However, as you mentioned some will agree with your comment then use it in a negative way than what you intended. Some will make the comparison, while others who know better will agree with your intentions. Once again I'll say this wasn't aimed for you but for those who think they have the right to criticize Sunny without knowing the facts that led to the period of her career where she couldn't perform to the best of her abilities. I always refer them back to the days before her down period.
RDR is in my top3 SNSD songs, but I seriously don’t understand the outfits for the live stages. 😣 anyways, I miss my Queens. Love you Yoong!! ❤️ 2:10 Maknae making it rain 🌧 💵🤣
I don't care if the title of a video says live, If I don't hear the voices over the insanely abundant and loud MR, I would still consider it as not live. This is why the 2nd generation deserves so much respect.
There's 9 of them.. but we always can remember their faces because each one of them oozing charisma and great face expressions. Idol nowadays??? always has a member with a lifeless or stoned face expression member
I feel like this was just yesterday :( the fact that it was released on 2010 was beyond imaginable. I was just 20 at that time huhuhu! I love this group so much
woah it's 2016!!! girls rlly had a hard time during the first live performaces of RDR, suddenly to harsh choreo, higher heels, many high notes for diff members
i miss this era, i miss old kpop
alisya pramesti it was more organized, more excited than now :(
alisya pramesti
you miss the suju vs sone fanwars? bruh thats so touching asf
Oh yeah, those were the times of my life. Especially as a diehard E.L.F and a supporter of Soshi! :-D
I love girls generation because their the one who always me smile then the BTS just cameout of nowhere
ME TOO I MISS JESSICA;TIFFANY;SEOHYUN;SOOYOUNG AND SNSD OT9 VERY MUCH😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😿😿😿😿😿😿😿😿😿💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
the era when you can really hear the groups real voice without so much MR's :(
Right, live performance with live song will really test the girl group how good they are but nowdays most girl group do lipsync most of the time
@@semdavidtimothysitanggang9491 boy groups too
@Perla Martinez_Morales I love how you included SM artists ;). Cube have some very good singers too.
@Perla Martinez_Morales I wish Kyuhyun can teach me how to sing haha.
@Perla Martinez_Morales I can relate haha
The most memorable part of this performance: Seohyun makes it rain at 2:09
Wow XD
seohyun, jo
i dont get it??
@@karishmaaswani4464 thehand gesture
omg. 3 years later, this gets me HAHAHAHA this moment should be a meme
during sunny's first part, her kick always surprise me
.
vdsaaagjkkoknvfgxaaaghjncqqtupollpppld at hkllkhdsaa ATV n cm Cl in OK in on icily
RIGHT!? She was feeling it!
im about to mention it 😃😂
She is the master of mimic ing song rightt
Great camera man. I hate other cameramen who zooms in to face. How are we able to appreciate they beautiful dance they all put effort in?
.
..
...
....
.....
요즘 소녀시대에 빠져버렸당... 영원히..소녀시대!
앞으로도 소녀시대!
L""""n,h
영원히 아이브!
2022년인 지금 난 빠짐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 과거에 젖는다ㅠㅠ
@@문옥순-y4e ㅜㅜ 관종.. 현실에서 멀쩡한척 하고 사시죠?..
They had a surprisingly nice line distribution in this song. Sooyoung, Yuri, Hyoyeon and Yoona all had three lines!
yoona only had 2
1:22 무슨 마법같다 미친동선
마지막에 v자 되는게 간지..
카메라 엄청 잘잡음 멋있다
I've been fan of them since i was in 7th grade and i'm in college now, looking back to this video now i realized that every one of them has a great stage presence with no hole compared to newer groups now.
Exactly! Like not even the most internationally famous ones *I'm not mentioning any names* have it! I miss this kpop era
@@najibahtahir9245 or the new nation gg
@@chisquare5501 not mentioning names*
@@najibahtahir9245 no , I dont
@@chisquare5501 well you kinda mentioned them by referring to them by their title, eitherways the new girl groups are okay, I just dont particularly think anyone has consistent good music like gfriend and noone has stage presence like soshi did
I like Yuri, Yoona, Jessica and Sooyoung
OiPlayz [Minecraft] same
I LIKE HYOYEON;TAEYEON;SEOHYUN;JESSICA;TIFFANY;SUNNY;YOONA VERY MUCH👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
런데빌런음악중심♥합
SNSD is still the best. Always the best.
This is really live I mean, u can clearly heard their voiceee btw, Jessica looks the beat during this era
라이브 존나다들려...요즘에도 이렇게해놓으면 실력없는애들이 끼지도않을텐데...모르겠고 사랑해소시
Uuuu3i37h3i3i3 úr OP u74l3i7⅞³uwk8ijh7ikwjh4ho29u4hhryk7ku74ko3u3wl84ulw 99 jrjrur nnwu38 99 55 hth 5u5i3 PL 4u75k4i93 u5 un k5934jyúhe8y5j4 9o k3 9o 4j92k35n8b b kll 20u5k203 PL u
Fjj tur un 5j78 Yu ii u54k74k4kj ki un 54 k4 8i 4k49u4 un re 4ko⁷rj Yu ehhh no i4u4 un 3o 9o bb 93j hi 3 lo h4i43j4 bu lo 9o h hi 593yy34o9u hi o393y47k uu 77 49 99 un hijo 99 uu4i3 99 8u 3h ii9 uu u
I miss music shows era when they didn't use too much background music, so we can identify if the singers were singing live or not, if u follow Kpop since long time ago you'd understand what I mean, the audio for music show these days is so different from back than 2008-2011
enny s agree
tiffany’s dance during the first chorus during taeyeon’s part is always hilarious.
better than jawssica
Seo and Sica did the best vocals
Same
uhmm... do you forget Tae and Tif or wat? 😒. especially Tae, she's like the queen of vocals
+Vivian Descham well in this performance these 2 (sica and seo) did better than taeyeon and tiff
Agree!
They all sound very tired
The generation of bangs hahahahahahaI like sunny's hairdo here
YoonYul's hairstyle :) Yoona is such a beautiful girl , she is so good in dancing and rapping .. Also in singing :D Sunny's kick tho ;) Yoona can hit low and deep notes the best in all members
They've come a long way. Their dancing and singing is much better now
와 한국인 댓글 드럽게 찾기 힘드네
그ren 기념으ro 외국in들 못 읽게 he봐야g
이 명곡에 한국인 댓글이 없다니 ㅠ
퓨
난 외국인인데 다 이해했어... 이러지마요 ㅜㅜ
@@everybeautifulday 외국인이신데 다 이해 하셨다니 대단 하세요👏 이해 하는데 오래 걸리셔서 그렇게 답변 하셨나봐요🤣
@@BJ전국구 ㅎㅎ 맞아요 근de 이런 쓴 bang법은 웃겼어yo :) (그렇게 말하는g 잘 mo르겠어... 한국어를 jal못해서 미an해요! 더 공bu 할게요)
@@everybeautifulday e미 han국어 jal하시는 거 같아yo~ a닌ga yo?
Sunny was serving in this perfomance
Well back then her knees weren't acting up as it was in the 2014-2016... it's because of all the hard work & performances in heels that she almost lost her career and destroyed her health. The issue she had with her knees almost caused her everything she loved. But she did what she had to do (surgery) and was back working her ass off again. She didn't have enough time to recuperate because the show most go on. She once again continued to perform for us the fans not fully recovered because that's how much she loves us. But what we do in return talk shit & comment useless things. Her dancing was and still is amazing compare to some of the other members even during her off period. She's an exceptional dancer & vocalist. People need to learn the truth of the sacrifices she made to perform on the stage night after night day after day comebacks after comebacks just for the fans & group. She gives so much yet we aren't appreciative.
@@TimelessGap2 when I commented, I didn't mean to sound grumpy or even complaining. I mean, she's still my favorite soshi until nowadays. I was aiming more to a "lose of stamina as we get older" perspective (which is pretty much normal if you ask me). As we can see even in kpop or any other industry. It's part of our life cycle.
However, I totally agree with the perspective you brought and in order to avoid other people getting my comment in the wrong way (and worse agreeing with it), I decided to edit my post.
Sunny was and still is a hardworker and a talented person. She deserves to be recognized for that. :D
@@lovelucasperroniX When I commented I wasn't saying you thought any of those things you listed. Many have been commenting on Sunny's performances from 2015-2017 accusing her of everything from being lazy, looking bored, doesn't want to be there, worst dancer in Snsd, and then some. I was just making it clear to those who will see your comment and then make stupid comparison to her down period. As I've seen on other videos. This wasn't particularly aimed at you but for to those who feel the need to badmouth her for being the hardworker and professional she is. You didn't need to edit your comment as that was your opinion and observation on the performance. However, as you mentioned some will agree with your comment then use it in a negative way than what you intended. Some will make the comparison, while others who know better will agree with your intentions. Once again I'll say this wasn't aimed for you but for those who think they have the right to criticize Sunny without knowing the facts that led to the period of her career where she couldn't perform to the best of her abilities. I always refer them back to the days before her down period.
라이브 미쳤다…..
소시는 역시 9명이 좋네
Taeyeon,Jessica,Seohyun highnote bless my ears
다른건 다 까먹어도 2절 후렴 제시카는 진짜 못잊겠다,,,,이때가 그리워
Jessica is so cool here😘😘😘😘
Taeyeon vocals always shining. Seohyun always consistently stable.
So energetic and powerful! I literally cannot find Girl groups that can beat this one!
Don't forget it's pure live singing, no backtracks, no cracks and no dodging of lines. Queens only
They all improved so much vocally now. Seohyun did the best here imo
She's always very consistent.
Their stage presence and facial expressions are unbeatable. SNSD makes every performance sexy without needing to show skin. Queens only
hyoyeon dance is always the coolest
라이브도 그렇고 춤동선도 미쳤어~너무잘해👍😍💗역시 갓소시
Hyoyeon was so into it that she almost slipped at 2:48 omg 😂😂❤️❤️❤️
Hyoyeon is sooo into it. Overflowing energy
I miss this era of Kpop. Like u really can hear their voices. I miss these queens. Truely a legendary group from 2nd generation.
Jessica and Yuri fighting
I'm living for their live vocals and breathtaking stage presence.
소녀시대쨩💛💛
i just realized the dance line gets sooo many lines in this song!! omggg yess
miss these days... soshi is the best :)
PureJoy +1
Hi
I like how they kick it with force. It really looks like they're bad ass.
런데빌 뮤비에서 윤아 처음 앞머리 내린걸로 엄청 화제됐었는데
보이는 라디오인가 거기서 웃다가 앞머리 가발 뒤집어지곸ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
전설의 임뚜껑
임뚜껑사건 그당시 짤로도 유명했죠 ㅎㅎㅎ
YOONA REALLY SERVED DURING THIS ERA YOU CANNOT DENY IT
What does served means?
0:11 one of the most iconic dance poses
Remember when kpop idols used to sing live? I miss those times
I love Hyoyeon!!
they need a song like this in 2017's come back ;-;
This is the hardest choreo according to them right? That's way I understand them if they feel tired. This is the best
jamongmongmongmong it's nt RDR it is "catch me if u can"
jamongmongmongmong it's actually Hoot lol
Its IGAB lol
Not the hardest choreo but the hardest formation
the hardest choreo is ITNW
Sunny's kick is everything
I feel like seohyun face never change because of her eye brow
RDR is in my top3 SNSD songs, but I seriously don’t understand the outfits for the live stages. 😣 anyways, I miss my Queens. Love you Yoong!! ❤️
2:10 Maknae making it rain 🌧 💵🤣
Seohyun is the star in this song please❤
i love how they’re actually singing and not lip syncing like other idols do
I don't care if the title of a video says live, If I don't hear the voices over the insanely abundant and loud MR, I would still consider it as not live. This is why the 2nd generation deserves so much respect.
Yoona , Jessica , Soo jeong , Yuri las mas Lindas de GG
Feliz 2022
Sunny and Tiffany 😍 they slay this song good!
진짜 대박이야
jessica's singing is damn stable asf
There's 9 of them.. but we always can remember their faces because each one of them oozing charisma and great face expressions. Idol nowadays??? always has a member with a lifeless or stoned face expression member
They were so smol and adorable omg i love my bias sunny
HYOYEON ENERGY AND HER VOCAL 😍😍😍😍
Hoxy 이렇게 nam기면 nae 댓글도 올려주nee?? Korea 걸그룹인데 영어 댓글만 gae많잖아 소녀시대 zzang
My first kpop favorite girls ❤
OLD KPOP IS THE BEST CRAZY EVER.... ALMOST SNSD AKA GIRLS GENERATION.... THEY ARE NUMBER 1 FOREVER...
its 2020 and i’m here to find videos of seohyun wearing her yongseo ring haha!
Girl the way hyoyoen dance omg. She's so good
The girl group who really can sing well..
This song was written by Kesha
It’s so phenomenal
This Korean live version is also one of the best!
Hyoyeon was so energetic on this performance
Watching this is 2020. Fanny has come such a long way!! She used to look so stiff dancing but now she is sooo good.
SNSD STILL THE BEST GIRL GROUP FOREVER
추억이다 진짜 ㅠㅠ 영원히 소녀시대 ㅠㅠ
Honestly,SNSD is still the best
I feel like this was just yesterday :( the fact that it was released on 2010 was beyond imaginable. I was just 20 at that time huhuhu! I love this group so much
2018, and here I am fangirling over Hyoyeon and Taeyeon. Huh.
Jessica !! u just make everything better :) this was lit!
Love to hear their voices so clearly, not like idols today that have MR louder than their voices
Girl Generation/SNSD Queen of K-Pop
Non-stop SNSD during quarantine. I miss them SO BADLY.
#2009S
so stable voice
Yoona❤❤
Tiffany so pretty😍😍
woah it's 2016!!! girls rlly had a hard time during the first live performaces of RDR, suddenly to harsh choreo, higher heels, many high notes for diff members
Missing the living legend SNSD so much
Jessica 💝💞
Really love SNSD formations
Taeyeon and Tiffany have eternal beauty🧡
Yoona and Yuri twinning 😌💕
i miss my girls🥹
Their live performances is just 💓
Jessica introis the best
Their voice are perfect just love their voice.They are my queen ❤️
I can't get over Yuri :((( she's still my bias then, now and forever
Gotta appreciate legend who don't lipsync
내 최애 곡이였는데 ㅋㅋㅋ런데빌런 진짜 안질렸음
Yoona is so cute ..
2020 and still into SNSD
Tiffany beautiful❤
jessica
I love this choreo so much. All the sharp and smooth movements 😍