I agree and find it hard to believe Russia didn’t know. At the risk of sounding like a “conspiracy theorist” or brilliant military strategist. I’m starting to believe it was a setup to entice a battle that would cost Ukraine dearly.
12:25 our lines of defense in the Kursk region were and are, the Ukrainians did not reach them at all. Ukrainians crossed the state border and fought with the border guards. You are a military man and you know that the main army is never located on the state border line, but is located further from the borders. Which helped lure the elite NATO forces of the PMCs of Ukraine to a part of the Kursk region, where there is a small population and a flat landscape. The aviation and artillery of Russia did a good job - 11,000 piglets, only in this area for 30 days. It is more convenient to work here than to lure them out of the NATO territories fortified over 10 years in densely populated Donetsk and Luhansk regions with industrial cities and mines. We Russians are not prone to emotional PR, the main thing for us is to achieve our goals while optimizing costs and human losses on our part. We are not really interested in the opinion of the world community, because other countries have not faced the full force of NATO economically, militarily, technologically and informationally, and they cannot even fully realize HOW our Russia is destroying NATO by devouring it piece by piece.
Sir, your analysis best, common man can easily understand the reality. Now I understood how the USA and west using Ukrain to defeat Russia. Here Ukrain has become scapegoat.
Very good diagnosis of what has been occurring across the entire front. I was aware of the various factors or pieces of the puzzle but you put them together very nicely into a coherent overall view of the war.
This is poor Russian propaganda. What is unbiased are the satellite views of emptying Russian equipment reserve bases. Do you not see that Russia has been forced to use T 54 tanks and artillery that was introduced. in WWII. If you go to the Oryx website, you will see why. Even the Russian orcs at Rybar will tell you Russia is not winning. The only ones that claim Russia is winning are the Russian MOD and propagandists.
@@Agent_Paul looks like you don't know the meaning of meditation. That's why you are ok with your mind scattered between background music and talking. You infact need medication not meditation.
Actually America thinks for itself as best strategist and this put Ukraine into the current state. Russia actually allowed the entry to make the donbas defense weak but smart Americans thought the kursk is weak and ordered to enter. The result is both places lost.
These tactical insights are very very valuable and right on target. As a USMC operations officer with both urban and desert warfare experience and training I could not agree with you more. As the Russians experience ECW over-watch it requires that the ground units move forward in a very conventional door to door manner. It is old school and expensive but the only other country that does this style of warfare as a primary approach is China. The USA fights over the horizon and far away so we can not typically mass in the numbers required to fight in this manner as our primary approach. We tend to believe in agility and high tech (look at out reformulation of our South China Sea defense). We spend way more high tech dollars, use fewer people and try to destroy less infrastructure (unless we have to). The IDF Iron Dome is an example of this approach in a defensive posture. But guess what, when your tech fails or is neutralized or over matched it always comes down to the infantry and armor going inch by inch. Desert Storm may be the last time a high tech Western force can soften the enemy to make the final assault a fast attack where the enemy surrenders in droves because they have been pounded into submission and really didn't want to fight. Today the fighters are duped into thinking it is as existential the end of the world if you do not die or win so they will fight too long (Hamas). They have no idea that they may be dying for media points and political currency. In the age of open source and cheap tech asymmetry will defeat superior spending and prolong conflict. Russia will win in the Ukraine because the Ukraine will run out of Ukrainian blood to shed and US dollars to be made and the world really doesn't care to fight with or for them. It was never existential, the Ukraine could have survived if they had taken the initial peace deal offered at the start of recent hostilities (as you noted). It is now existential at the hands of Ukrainian leaders who are buying villas as they romp around pretending they know how to fight a war. Where the West has High Tech superiority the Russians will use low tech indirect fire weapons, flatten the opposition and roll over them with frontal assault just like they have in every war, slow, unrelenting and expensive. Where there is tech parity or even some advantage Russia will be strategic and destroy at will. Low spend with greater mass will often win out unless you want to go WMD. The only real way to stand up to them is face to face, and that will be a fight the West does not want to have. A proxy war is always sub-optimal and just gets lots of people killed for Pyrrhic show until the sponsors get kicked out: see Vietnam, The Middle East, Afghanistan and now Ukraine..... Great job of analysis (you don't need the background music your voice is better :-) ) Be well...
They achieved surprise because they attacked a point of no value that was weakly defended. The target was the nuclear facility in kirsk but they failed to reach it and now theyre stuck in bad terrain and surrounded. Last i heard theyve taken over 10k casualties.
You are a world 5 star retired general I must confess. Not America and British retired paper generals with no substance comments on Fox, CNN, Sky, BBC, etc. Thank you for your unbiased analysis.
Mr Bakshi Big respect from me I am Macedonian, and Macedonia was part of Yugoslavia . When I was child, I remember watching very friendly relationship between Mr Nehru and Tito. And since then I always had soft spot for Indian people, and always liked them. A country who has great history and culture. I will not comment about the front lines, but I want to share something with your followers, something only a few people know. - In 2013 , 3 western big energy companies wanted to buy the ukrainian Naftagas. Naftagas is ukrainian energy company. So those 3 companies( one British shell, and 2 american), wanted to invest more than 20 billions of dollars. The reason for that- Ukraine has the biggest gas deposits in Europe, many trillions of dollars worth. But, Yanukovic didn't want to sell. Remember, that happened in 2013. We all know what happened in 2014 at Maidan square in Kiev. When some chechen snipe_r men were shoo_ ting at the civilians and policemen from Ukraina hotel room. Around 100 people lost lives, of whom 17 policeman. Some western journalists were in the hotel, and knew what is happening, but kept quiet about it. The western politicians and weasel media were quick to accuse the police as guilty party. That is another story. But, there was a problem. Problem for the 3 western corporate energy companies. Those gas deposits ( also oil deposits, and various minerals) Are based in Donbas area, and around Crimea cost. So, Mr Bakshi, the rest is ONGOING history. All the best
That's a good point. The resources in Ukraine were part of the plan but just limited to businessmen's interests. The main point is this, the West strongly hold to their hegemony of petrol dollar. Every leader who tried to find an alternative option was murdered. Col. Gaddafi for example, tried to drop the dollar, and the rest was history. BRICS emerged with Russia taking the lead, and this was a huge challenge, but the West had no option other than to kill Putin, destroy Russia. Otherwise, it collapses the petrol dollar hegemony and creates a multipolar world, as opposed to the One World Order or NWO the West are aiming to establish.
@Mr goranmarko6205 , the only Macedonian most Indians remember in collective memory is Alexander the Great, for the battle with King Porus by the Beas(Hydaspes) river. Im glad to see another one who has a soft spot for India.
@@masumabid4883 Pardon.? He always gives a frank honest ex military opinion. Whether one agrees completely with his views is not the point. A propaganda free honest personal opinion founded upon decades of studying and observing conflict is what l look for. Emotional, Tribal thinkers too trapped in ideology to view things with a clear observant mindset l can do without. I hope that answers your question.
Най добрия анализ на сьбитията от началото на войната до днес. Винаги всичко което се представя от Индийските медии е толкова истинско и това което всички искат да чуят. Голям професионализм в лицето на истината. Поздрави и много здраве. Вие го можете. Продължавайте все така.
GOD BLESS YOU ABUNDANTLY. MAXIMUM RESPECT ❤FOR MILTARY EXPERTICE .. INTELLIGENT MILTARY EXPERT WITH FULL OF EXPERIENCE... GOSPEL TRUTH.. FACTS NOT FICTIONS ❤ THE WORLD NEEDS 🌎 WISE MILTARY EXPERT LIKE YOU SIR ..
The whole premise is off It was not a total surprise to Russia. A month earlier local officials & even Duma reps were openly wondering why Putin was ignoring the build-up, but then shrugged it off saying the top leadership knew best. What surprised and annoyed Putin & the Russian Security council was the breadth & depth of the incursion as well as the number of troops committed to the incursion. The plan was to allow a limited incursion to stretch the depleted troopa defending Pokorovsk. Additionally, this gambit backfired politically on Putin, as most Russians (like the rest of the world) who thought the Kremin was caught unaware, saw Putin as weak and unprepared, and worse dreaded a new mobilization to retake Kursk, when they saw Russia maintain its numbers inside Ukraine. So dear General, much as I respect most of your analysis, I have to say you were off on this one. Russia was NOT.taken by surprise. However the decision to allow Kiev to take Russian territory aided its push towards Pokorvsk (important logistics hub) but was a PR disaster with poor optics that made Putin & his Security Council look weak & vulnerable, apart from giving Kiev a boost in its pleas for weapons & lifting restrictions on the ones it has been gifted. PS: I am posting from Russia & this comment is based on reliable info on my local contacts.
That was the stupidest rant I've heard in a while. What the narcissistic west leaders think is irrelevant to most westerners let alone Russians. Get over yourself.
From your analysis we understand few things; firstly we have a reluctant Putin, secondly the western powers have much better battlefield intelligence, and lastly, the west has markedly better military command.
You have captured what I've been telling ignorant people for years. You captured it well. I'll begin following your channel keenly because I've subscribed.
Sir, Your Analysis of Ukraine - Kursk ...Great Kindly look at Our Borders 1 where our Soldiers are facing Terrorism every day 2 Operation Tunnel of Pak Chna J& K , Bangladesh, Mayanmar All regions are full of tunnels & Caves strategy to Hide & Kill enter the Hole Need your attention Regards
Add Sri Lanka too to the list. India is being encircled by detabilized and compromised states, Modi is following a disastrous policy by promoting Sajith Premadasa to the detriment of Sri Lanka. Just imagine Chine comes enemy of India and Sri Lanka becomes Marxist failed State under Anurak Kumara or Sajith. Like the Houthies Sri Lanka can attack the ships to and from India. Stability and mature leadership like Ranil is very very important for Indias future.
America did the same in Ethiopia, during the war between the Tigray rebels army and Ethiopia army, they supported the Tigray rebels by providing them information about the Ethiopian army positions by satellite tracking device which is supplied by UN and world food organization.
Maybe it was not a surprise and was this a convenient move for the Russians. They blocked the ukrain troops so the objective (Kursk NPP) was not reached. In the mean time the Eastern front became weaker so the Russians could move on.
If the Russians were preparing an attack on Sumy, where were these troops when the Ukrainians attacked?? Shouldn't have been close to the region and ready to react to this invasion.
I agree with all the positive comments on this gentleman's reporting. Absolutely brilliant & thorough. He explains in an unbiased way. He explains what's left out by so many others. I finally comprehend why Ukraine was able to launch an offensive into the Kursk region. I also now am aware of the history especially involving the British (Boris Johnson) typical isn't it the British yet again acting cloak & dagger
West duped Russia, perhaps, that defensive troops sent to Sumy, but duped themselves more, into believing that taking undeveloped land in Russia' s Kursk region, would change Russia troops deployment on the frontline. Russia did not divert troops from the frontline, instead it turned the tables on West and stepped up it's operations on the frontline. Now Ukraine has lost significantly more ground, and more importantly it had its best troops and NATO forces allowed to concentrate in Kursk, trapping them in a cauldron in Kursk and obliterating troops and equipment in Kursk in their confined area, without air cover, making them easy defenceless targets.once their equipment wiped out. Also since the Ukrainian terrorised the civilians who refused to be evacuated, Russia show how the West and specifically Ukraine's showed their Russophobia, in its ill treatment and terrorism of Russian civilians. Russia had evacuated most civilians at the beginning of the Kursk invasion. Most civilians were safe, Western Troops could be safely contained, their supplies cut off and then bombed, without fear of injuring it's own civilians and without risk to their own Aerial defence. After first three weeks in Kursk the NATO' s plan had already been foiled. Never interrupt the enemy when it is making a mistake. This mistake has cost NATO and Ukraine significantly. To try and make a PR statement of a failed offensive is just just pure comedy. But one side believes in comedy. The other, in reality.
Russia has always been inclined to suffer enemy incursions, only to close the trapdoor once the enemy has committed its forces beyond effective retreat.
most amazing realistic outlook. using modern language to share ideas and concepts. hope deaf could hear it and blind can see it. but being real probably not. like Zekensky said, "Until last Ukrainian." So very sad.
Most intelligent man regarding the current situation in ukraine. All other western so called experts are completely delusional about the real on ground situation.
Thank you Major General for the clear dissection of the Ukranean blunder of going in to the Russian territory and making Russian people to rally behind their leader.
Only a soldier can describe what war is not the people sitting in news reading rooms.
well said🙏🙏🙏🙏
I agree and find it hard to believe Russia didn’t know. At the risk of sounding like a “conspiracy theorist” or brilliant military strategist. I’m starting to believe it was a setup to entice a battle that would cost Ukraine dearly.
Thanks for the update and discussion around the context of truth.
12:25 our lines of defense in the Kursk region were and are, the Ukrainians did not reach them at all. Ukrainians crossed the state border and fought with the border guards. You are a military man and you know that the main army is never located on the state border line, but is located further from the borders. Which helped lure the elite NATO forces of the PMCs of Ukraine to a part of the Kursk region, where there is a small population and a flat landscape. The aviation and artillery of Russia did a good job - 11,000 piglets, only in this area for 30 days. It is more convenient to work here than to lure them out of the NATO territories fortified over 10 years in densely populated Donetsk and Luhansk regions with industrial cities and mines. We Russians are not prone to emotional PR, the main thing for us is to achieve our goals while optimizing costs and human losses on our part. We are not really interested in the opinion of the world community, because other countries have not faced the full force of NATO economically, militarily, technologically and informationally, and they cannot even fully realize HOW our Russia is destroying NATO by devouring it piece by piece.
God bless you.
Not to the same extent but we have also faced the wrath of NATO. Pakistan is to India what Ukraine is to Russia!!!
@@ЕлизаветкаБогданова hahahahhahahha 😂 the stupidity is very strong here.
@@satdiva don’t vote or procreate.
@@Lepocoloco toma guevos pa se loco. Tu eres solo pantala pa deci esso pana
Sir, your analysis best, common man can easily understand the reality. Now I understood how the USA and west using Ukrain to defeat Russia. Here Ukrain has become scapegoat.
It is called a proxy war.
Truthful presentation. Well done. Good effort.
Are you GD Bakshi in pseudo name ?
@@masumabid4883Why muslims hates army and nationalist?
You are certainly uninformed of Ukrainian history since 2014.
@@dorothymartin8557
Also 2005-2010 attacks on South and East settlements near Rus. border.
Very good diagnosis of what has been occurring across the entire front.
I was aware of the various factors or pieces of the puzzle but you put them together very nicely into a coherent overall view of the war.
Sir yours analysis is very rare.
Rare, but High in quality.
Other defence expert's analysis is not neutral।
Very rare to find someone so ignorant
and always wrong , everything he say that would happen with ukraine was wrong
@@Noodleanrgry what did he say in the past that was wrong?
Or , the Russians knew, also demine the area, and trapped the Ukrainian force, which are now being decimated.
that's a stretch too far in my view
@@taa-kz5unwhy? it is what we can observe.
This is the best unbiased analysis I have never heard on social media.
You haven't been on Social Media for long then? There's nothing here that hasn't been reported by various outlets throughout this conflict.
but you are biased and call bias opinion umbiased
This is poor Russian propaganda. What is unbiased are the satellite views of emptying Russian equipment reserve bases. Do you not see that Russia has been forced to use T 54 tanks and artillery that was introduced. in WWII. If you go to the Oryx website, you will see why. Even the Russian orcs at Rybar will tell you Russia is not winning. The only ones that claim Russia is winning are the Russian MOD and propagandists.
By far my favorite analyst
Beautiful presentation and analysis. Thank you. Please post more.
background music is very annoying. Focus should be on the voice of the person speaking. This is not a documentary to have background music.
Do some meditation 🧘♂️. Background sound can only be annoying if your mind is troubled.
@@Agent_Paul looks like you don't know the meaning of meditation. That's why you are ok with your mind scattered between background music and talking. You infact need medication not meditation.
All fact. and all is real true 👍🏻. Hi from Europe Croatia 🇭🇷🍀🇷🇺✌
Actually America thinks for itself as best strategist and this put Ukraine into the current state. Russia actually allowed the entry to make the donbas defense weak but smart Americans thought the kursk is weak and ordered to enter. The result is both places lost.
Extraordinary.
Wonderfully articulated.
These tactical insights are very very valuable and right on target.
As a USMC operations officer with both urban and desert warfare experience and training I could not agree with you more.
As the Russians experience ECW over-watch it requires that the ground units move forward in a very conventional door to door manner. It is old school and expensive but the only other country that does this style of warfare as a primary approach is China. The USA fights over the horizon and far away so we can not typically mass in the numbers required to fight in this manner as our primary approach. We tend to believe in agility and high tech (look at out reformulation of our South China Sea defense). We spend way more high tech dollars, use fewer people and try to destroy less infrastructure (unless we have to). The IDF Iron Dome is an example of this approach in a defensive posture. But guess what, when your tech fails or is neutralized or over matched it always comes down to the infantry and armor going inch by inch.
Desert Storm may be the last time a high tech Western force can soften the enemy to make the final assault a fast attack where the enemy surrenders in droves because they have been pounded into submission and really didn't want to fight. Today the fighters are duped into thinking it is as existential the end of the world if you do not die or win so they will fight too long (Hamas). They have no idea that they may be dying for media points and political currency. In the age of open source and cheap tech asymmetry will defeat superior spending and prolong conflict.
Russia will win in the Ukraine because the Ukraine will run out of Ukrainian blood to shed and US dollars to be made and the world really doesn't care to fight with or for them. It was never existential, the Ukraine could have survived if they had taken the initial peace deal offered at the start of recent hostilities (as you noted). It is now existential at the hands of Ukrainian leaders who are buying villas as they romp around pretending they know how to fight a war.
Where the West has High Tech superiority the Russians will use low tech indirect fire weapons, flatten the opposition and roll over them with frontal assault just like they have in every war, slow, unrelenting and expensive. Where there is tech parity or even some advantage Russia will be strategic and destroy at will. Low spend with greater mass will often win out unless you want to go WMD.
The only real way to stand up to them is face to face, and that will be a fight the West does not want to have. A proxy war is always sub-optimal and just gets lots of people killed for Pyrrhic show until the sponsors get kicked out: see Vietnam, The Middle East, Afghanistan and now Ukraine.....
Great job of analysis (you don't need the background music your voice is better :-) ) Be well...
Audenus Well stated !
very well understandable and explained the total scenario of this war.
I always wait expectantly for General Bakshi's podcasts. As a military man, he always knows what he is talking about, unlike a lot of pontificators.
He may know but his information are full of BS.
They achieved surprise because they attacked a point of no value that was weakly defended. The target was the nuclear facility in kirsk but they failed to reach it and now theyre stuck in bad terrain and surrounded. Last i heard theyve taken over 10k casualties.
Всё правильно. Так и есть.
Yeah but it panics Russia and ripples to Putin. You can't run away from that fact.
Chachan Commander
Mr Apti Aloudinov we love you and pray for you From Pakistan 🇵🇰
لا الہ الا اللہ محمد الرسول اللہ
Pak is gone. 😂
He doesn't even know you
Very unbiased thank you
You are a world 5 star retired general I must confess. Not America and British retired paper generals with no substance comments on Fox, CNN, Sky, BBC, etc. Thank you for your unbiased analysis.
Mr Bakshi
Big respect from me
I am Macedonian, and Macedonia was part of Yugoslavia .
When I was child, I remember watching very friendly relationship between Mr Nehru and Tito. And since then I always had soft spot for Indian people, and always liked them.
A country who has great history and culture.
I will not comment about the front lines, but I want to share something with your followers, something only a few people know.
- In 2013 , 3 western big energy companies wanted to buy the ukrainian Naftagas.
Naftagas is ukrainian energy company.
So those 3 companies( one British shell, and 2 american), wanted to invest more than 20 billions of dollars.
The reason for that- Ukraine has the biggest gas deposits in Europe, many trillions of dollars worth.
But, Yanukovic didn't want to sell.
Remember, that happened in 2013.
We all know what happened in 2014 at Maidan square in Kiev.
When some chechen snipe_r men were shoo_ ting at the civilians and policemen from Ukraina hotel room. Around 100 people lost lives, of whom 17 policeman.
Some western journalists were in the hotel, and knew what is happening, but kept quiet about it.
The western politicians and weasel media were quick to accuse the police as guilty party.
That is another story.
But, there was a problem.
Problem for the 3 western corporate energy companies.
Those gas deposits ( also oil deposits, and various minerals)
Are based in Donbas area, and around Crimea cost.
So, Mr Bakshi, the rest is ONGOING history.
All the best
you say it !
Nice to know
Greetings, I am Macedonian too. I would only add to your text: NEVER NORTH ONLY MACEDONIA!
That's a good point. The resources in Ukraine were part of the plan but just limited to businessmen's interests.
The main point is this, the West strongly hold to their hegemony of petrol dollar. Every leader who tried to find an alternative option was murdered. Col. Gaddafi for example, tried to drop the dollar, and the rest was history.
BRICS emerged with Russia taking the lead, and this was a huge challenge, but the West had no option other than to kill Putin, destroy Russia. Otherwise, it collapses the petrol dollar hegemony and creates a multipolar world, as opposed to the One World Order or NWO the West are aiming to establish.
@Mr goranmarko6205 , the only Macedonian most Indians remember in collective memory is Alexander the Great, for the battle with King Porus by the Beas(Hydaspes) river. Im glad to see another one who has a soft spot for India.
its the first time i hear a good explanation as to how Russia was caught off guard in Kursk
Bravo sir !!! Its explained for all us simple people !! RESPECT !!
What a fascinating presentation by a fascinating speaker!
Our rall is to pray for both Countries to come back to peace talks.
VERY INFORMATIVE ANALYSIS,THANK YOU!
Thank you u Major General of India for a very good well informed objective account of what happened at Kursk, Zellensky's major miscalculation.
This is the first India truly News without propaganda
Excellent Report as always. Thsnk you Sir. Most apprectiated each time you share your thoughts.
Are you GD Bakshi in pseudo name ?
@@masumabid4883 Pardon.?
He always gives a frank honest ex military opinion.
Whether one agrees completely with his views is not the point. A propaganda free honest personal opinion founded upon decades of studying and observing conflict is what l look for. Emotional, Tribal thinkers too trapped in ideology to view things with a clear observant mindset l can do without. I hope that answers your question.
Thanks for your comments and the truth
WHAT DANGEROUS OUTCOME WOULD IF MR PUTINS ANGRY BECOME HIGH THAN HIGH.
Always happy to hear from GD Bakshi
Най добрия анализ на сьбитията от началото на войната до днес. Винаги всичко което се представя от Индийските медии е толкова истинско и това което всички искат да чуят. Голям професионализм в лицето на истината. Поздрави и много здраве. Вие го можете. Продължавайте все така.
Another meaningful analysis of the war by the respected gen of india
Educative unbiased analysis I think.
Thank you very much for thorough analysis!
All the best from Russia!
Om Namah Shivaya 🕉️🙏
Maj Gen GD Bakshi was right about the War for NATO expansion in 2022. And is right now.
Ideal analysis Sir. Please accept my gratitude.
JH Sir
Thanks to you, from Dakar in Sénégal
Thank you and be blessed.. A lie can never overtake Truth. Thank you again.
Well analysed. You've been right since 2022.
@@Blessed-g8s hahahahhaa 😂 he predicted Kursk would be invaded?
GOD BLESS YOU ABUNDANTLY. MAXIMUM RESPECT ❤FOR MILTARY EXPERTICE ..
INTELLIGENT MILTARY EXPERT WITH FULL OF EXPERIENCE...
GOSPEL TRUTH..
FACTS NOT FICTIONS ❤
THE WORLD NEEDS 🌎 WISE MILTARY EXPERT LIKE YOU SIR ..
You are absolutely right. Excellent observations and analysis. 🌺✍️💚🙏-bmd
The whole premise is off
It was not a total surprise to Russia. A month earlier local officials & even Duma reps were openly wondering why Putin was ignoring the build-up, but then shrugged it off saying the top leadership knew best.
What surprised and annoyed Putin & the Russian Security council was the breadth & depth of the incursion as well as the number of troops committed to the incursion.
The plan was to allow a limited incursion to stretch the depleted troopa defending Pokorovsk.
Additionally, this gambit backfired politically on Putin, as most Russians (like the rest of the world) who thought the Kremin was caught unaware, saw Putin as weak and unprepared, and worse dreaded a new mobilization to retake Kursk, when they saw Russia maintain its numbers inside Ukraine.
So dear General, much as I respect most of your analysis, I have to say you were off on this one.
Russia was NOT.taken by surprise. However the decision to allow Kiev to take Russian territory aided its push towards Pokorvsk (important logistics hub) but was a PR disaster with poor optics that made Putin & his Security Council look weak & vulnerable, apart from giving Kiev a boost in its pleas for weapons & lifting restrictions on the ones it has been gifted.
PS: I am posting from Russia & this comment is based on reliable info on my local contacts.
That was the stupidest rant I've heard in a while. What the narcissistic west leaders think is irrelevant to most westerners let alone Russians. Get over yourself.
🤥
What is the view of the elected opposition in Russia regarding the conflict?
But it was a superb tactics , Ukraine had entered only 1000 km and was halted and now Russia had retaken 350 km area . What's your take on it ?
@@kabzaify
The opposition (communists and Liberal Democrats) are much more belligerent than the ruling party.
From your analysis we understand few things; firstly we have a reluctant Putin, secondly the western powers have much better battlefield intelligence, and lastly, the west has markedly better military command.
It was obvious it would fail. The Ukrainian army is not powerful enough to maintain and exploit that.
Khalid from Lagos Nigeria Z, thanks for your insight on the matters
I`m very impressed of this man because he has the right analysis of this war. Thank You!
You have captured what I've been telling ignorant people for years. You captured it well. I'll begin following your channel keenly because I've subscribed.
This Indian General is the best. A real credit to India. Wow. Objective and unbiased. Refreshing.
Sir,
Your Analysis of Ukraine - Kursk ...Great
Kindly look at Our Borders
1 where our Soldiers are facing Terrorism every day
2
Operation Tunnel of Pak Chna
J& K , Bangladesh, Mayanmar
All regions are full of tunnels & Caves strategy to Hide & Kill enter the Hole
Need your attention
Regards
Add Sri Lanka too to the list. India is being encircled by detabilized and compromised states, Modi is following a disastrous policy by promoting Sajith Premadasa to the detriment of Sri Lanka. Just imagine Chine comes enemy of India and Sri Lanka becomes Marxist failed State under Anurak Kumara or Sajith. Like the Houthies Sri Lanka can attack the ships to and from India. Stability and mature leadership like Ranil is very very important for Indias future.
Every India nation's nation hates india. Lmao
great analysis. Thanks
America did the same in Ethiopia, during the war between the Tigray rebels army and Ethiopia army, they supported the Tigray rebels by providing them information about the Ethiopian army positions by satellite tracking device which is supplied by UN and world food organization.
Very Informative. Thank you General🙏👏👍
VERY AMATEURISH COMMENTRTY. THIS COMMENTATOR SHOULD VISIT KURSK
Respect to you sir. For telling as it is
100% the truth
This well be call or remember in the military annals as "the dumbest tactical mission".
Is it a surprise for your enemy to make you think they are weak in one direction to trick you into walking into a strategic blunder?
A very thoughtful analysis👍👍👍👍❤
Ji,,,,Good knowledge 🙏👍 explained well
Maybe it was not a surprise and was this a convenient move for the Russians. They blocked the ukrain troops so the objective (Kursk NPP) was not reached. In the mean time the Eastern front became weaker so the Russians could move on.
If the Russians were preparing an attack on Sumy, where were these troops when the Ukrainians attacked?? Shouldn't have been close to the region and ready to react to this invasion.
Interesting and unbiased analysis! Thank you General!
Really a great analysis. Wonderful I'm delighted.
Capturing territory in itself is an exercise in futility. It serves no military purpose.
Very fair and concise information thanks!
I agree with all the positive comments on this gentleman's reporting. Absolutely brilliant & thorough. He explains in an unbiased way. He explains what's left out by so many others. I finally comprehend why Ukraine was able to launch an offensive into the Kursk region. I also now am aware of the history especially involving the British (Boris Johnson) typical isn't it the British yet again acting cloak & dagger
Thanks
What a great presentation of front reality
General bakshi is a war hero. Participated in 1971 bangladesh liberation war
First time seeing the general. Brilliant analysis.
West duped Russia, perhaps, that defensive troops sent to Sumy, but duped themselves more, into believing that taking undeveloped land in Russia' s Kursk region, would change Russia troops deployment on the frontline. Russia did not divert troops from the frontline, instead it turned the tables on West and stepped up it's operations on the frontline. Now Ukraine has lost significantly more ground, and more importantly it had its best troops and NATO forces allowed to concentrate in Kursk, trapping them in a cauldron in Kursk and obliterating troops and equipment in Kursk in their confined area, without air cover, making them easy defenceless targets.once their equipment wiped out. Also since the Ukrainian terrorised the civilians who refused to be evacuated, Russia show how the West and specifically Ukraine's showed their Russophobia, in its ill treatment and terrorism of Russian civilians. Russia had evacuated most civilians at the beginning of the Kursk invasion. Most civilians were safe, Western Troops could be safely contained, their supplies cut off and then bombed, without fear of injuring it's own civilians and without risk to their own Aerial defence. After first three weeks in Kursk the NATO' s plan had already been foiled. Never interrupt the enemy when it is making a mistake. This mistake has cost NATO and Ukraine significantly. To try and make a PR statement of a failed offensive is just just pure comedy. But one side believes in comedy. The other, in reality.
Excellently, explained, thank you
@@KingCarmel-y9d Jesus you’re brainwashed 😂
Surprise? Good point. You are in fine form, sir.
You are EXCELLENT, but the music is very intrusive.
Losing 600,000 Ukrainian soldiers to make the Military industrial complex even richer is horrendous. Ukraine is the fall guy.
excellent narration terrific analysis👌🏻
Russia has always been inclined to suffer enemy incursions, only to close the trapdoor once the enemy has committed its forces beyond effective retreat.
Analysis and Evaluation is great and very realistic- thanks General.you're really a officer and a gentleman General.
You are a wise man. My respect.
Excellent analysis.
Enlightened
NZRU-Z Uraaaaaaaaa 💪🏾🙏🏾🇳🇿🇷🇺
No other general has ever analysed about the Russia - Ukraine war.
Your analysis is what i thought long ago in 2014.
@@lalua2112 yes. That ten years later Kursk will be invaded and everything will be going exactly to the plan. You’re a predicting predicted.
Was waiting for you 🙏🙏🙏
most amazing realistic outlook. using modern language to share ideas and concepts. hope deaf could hear it and blind can see it. but being real probably not. like Zekensky said, "Until last Ukrainian." So very sad.
Trechreous western culture...expected...
😂😂
They have been advancing on Pokrovsk for a long time now - how many years will it take?
Pure military wisdom
And we're talking about the country with the biggest land mass on Earth, I don't know what uh trying to say
Thanks General ❤
Most intelligent man regarding the current situation in ukraine.
All other western so called experts are completely delusional about the real on ground situation.
Jai Mata Vaishno Devi ji
Peace may happen as soon as possible 100 percent...
Definitely the best analysis of the war thank you.
Very informative talk by General Bakshi .
Thank you Major General for the clear dissection of the Ukranean blunder of going in to the Russian territory and making Russian people to rally behind their leader.
Your sharing is 100% correct ❤❤❤