Because he would have been the fucking hero clearing the snow (which is the biggest problem for yaks) Which would have upset the Yacks by suggesting their lifestyle wasn't perfect, either that or Prince Rutherford would have felt overshadowed (that jerk isn't easy to deal with).
“28 pranks later” is an episode I hate endlessly! How Rainbow Dash doesn’t feel guilty at all for upsetting her friends with her pranking. Especially Fluttershy who she KNOWS has anxiety issues and even laughs at her crying in fear. They basically turned Rainbow Dash into an insensitive bully! Seriously, WTF??
Personally this or the test of g4 doesn't bother me also yes I like Rainbow dash I lot yes she's was rude and I was laughing because I think it's rube but funny except of scaring fluttershy because she's my second fave and pinkie is 3rd and to me she learned her lesson
I also thought it was a little over the top - RD wouldnt behave like that to this extreme extend - she would maybe play a few pranks here and there, but this episode went completely overboard and portrayed her as an asshat who isnt aware of anything around her
You seem like the type of person who hates "The Mysterious Mare Do Well". I mean, this episode is kinda meh to me. The fart joke in the beginning kinda got me, and many other things in this episode were pretty funny. So at least it was good in the humor department. 😭🤷
@@randomhandleRAH the 28 pranks later episode is better than that episode due to the fact that Twilight and her friends try to talk Rainbow Dash out of pulling pranks on others before they gave her a taste of her own medicine later on
Why I don't like newbie dash was the allegory to hazing, please note that making gun of someone new in a field or program, and expect them to be okay with it, is only going to end uo badly. Especially because the entire episode it has Rainbow reacting badly to a insult she was given as a child, that's now being repeated in her dream job.
@@alejandrootero8894 I agree with the episode's message itself (That people shouldn't brag too much about their accomplishments), it's just that the episode presented that message in a very hypocritical way. The hypocrisy is that the other members of the Mane 6, in their attempt to teach Rainbow Dash a lesson, were subtly doing the exact same thing they were mad at Rainbow for doing. SPOILERS! Early on, in praising Mare- Do- Well's accomplishments, Pinkie Pie praises how fast and agile Mare- Do- Well was when saving the construction workers from the falling bricks. Applejack then praises the great strength Mare- Do- Well showed when stopping the runaway bus. Rarity praises Mare- Do- Well's stylish costume. Lastly, Twilight praises Mare- Do- Well's apparent knowledge of magic shown when fixing the dam. In the end of the episode, when it's revealed that Mare- do- Well was actually each of the other members of the Mane 6 in disguise to get Rainbow to stop bragging, it turns out that they themselves were doing the things they were praising "Mare- do- Well" for doing. Pinkie was the one who saved the construction workers using her Pinkie- Sense so she was really bragging about her own speed/ agility, Applejack was the one who stopped the bus so she was really bragging about her own strength, Rarity designed the Mare- do- Well costumes so she was really bragging about her own skills as a fashion designer, and Twilight was the one who used her magic to fix the dam, so she was really bragging about her own magical knowledge. In short, while claiming to want to teach Rainbow Dash that bragging is wrong, they were themselves subtly bragging about their own skills! That's hypocritical.
@@Adamguy2003 Oh, I thought they were doing that on purpose to annoy Rainbow Dash even more. Which, although it wouldn't be so hypocritical anymore, I admit that it would be a bit rude on the part of the group of ponies, but hey, nobody is perfect, haha
The problem with the Mare do well episode is how dangerous Ponyville suddenly becomes, with its residents plunging down steep cliff-top roads at very turn & unsafe buildings. Makes you wonder what the average weekly death toll is.
Honestly, I hate every Applejack centered episode, despite AJ literally being my favorite character. First off, there’s not many episodes that actually center around HER alone. The only one I can think of is maybe Apple Family Reunion? Other than that it’s always AJ and another pony, or other ponies talking about AJ. And second off, AJ EPISODES ALWAYS MAKE HER OUT TO BE A COMPLETE IDIOT. Like usually, she’s smart, resourceful, caring, helpful. And in her own episodes, all that gets thrown out the window. I really wish we got more good episodes of my favorite character. I really miss her..
I totally agree. Applejack is a great character! I mean she has a great personality and she's a really likable character! She's great when she's more of a supporting character, but when it comes time to give her an episode that centers around her, it just comes out kinda meh. I also really wish we got better episodes in the end since the writers have shown time and again that they can give good episodes to the other mane six.
Well, but it is that if we talk about episodes where she is the only one we focus on, there are like 1 or 2. And the episodes where she is the co-star (which in fact happens to all the characters) are quite good in their most.
The episode where rainbow dash parents was fan girl and almost blew her team out of the air but somehow it's rainbow dash that neet to learn the lesson.
IMO, episodes like Non Compete Clause and Applejack's Day Off highlight how FiM was NOT intended for the direction it ultimately went into. Both of these feel like Season One episodes, where the girls were just flippant and learning about each other. So it made sense that they would be quicker to fight and beat on each other, the bond wasn't fully there. By Season 8, the girls are ambassadors of friendship, basically Equestria's guardians, and teachers of a new generation. If they're going to have fights _now,_ they need to have very strong reasoning behind them. When the Mane 6 have petty disagreements, it feels like selective amnesia. You KNOW Rainbow Dash and Rarity are better than being such bad examples for their students. You KNOW Applejack is smarter than that. If all of these episodes were still in the early age, they would be so much more forgivable. The ponies went from little girls needing to learn lessons to grown women who flip between emotionally mature and complete Karens.
_28 pranks later, the end in friend_ and _non-compete clause_ would've worked well in earlier seasons when the characters were more immature and still got on each others nerves
Surprised there was no mention of No Second Prances, honestly just a terrible way to reintroduce Trixie. The writers basically retconned the end of Magic Duel just to make this plot "work".
I personally thought Non-Compete Clause cuz it’s just Fall Weather Friends but wrong because in FWF they were only hindering each other and the friendship was still somewhat new. But in season 8 they were hurting students and themselves and they’re supposed to be really tight now.
It’s also the season before the two get together and one of the last times they were paired together. Nah these two are not married I don’t believe it.
The good thing with bad episodes is, at least it's quite fun to watch videos talking about them! For me the episodes I dislike are usually the ones where a character does a lot of harm and damage around them in the name of "funny slapstick" but somehow are still the ones who are "right" in the end. Mixing slapstick comedy and life lesson is possible indeed but they shouldn't contradict each other, and sometimes even the best writers fail at it...
The fact that Diamond Tiara didn't get any serious punishment when SHE was the one who forced CMC to exposed everyone secrets including Princess Celestia by black mailing them is beyond frustrating and we supposed to feel sorry for her because of her mother, F*ck off. It's also frustrating that Adults blame the CMC instead of Diamond Tiara and it was a adult who allow Diamond Tiara to be in charge.
@@robincrusoejrt1903Yeah, man, there's also another episode that I hate, which is when Apple Bloom's test arrives in Ponyville, intimidating the CMCs along with the Diamond Tiara, and at the end we have to feel sorry for her because she was afraid of being bullied, FUCK that character.
My personal head canon for Somepony to Watch Over Me is the reason Apple Jack was so overprotective and out of character could’ve had something to do with reminding of her parents’ death and she didn’t want to lose Apple Bloom too
Not to mention that Rockhoof wanting to turn himself to stone is inevitably an allegory for suicide. Suicide ISN’T reversible. The episode would still suck, but at least it wouldn’t undermine a serious topic.
That episode had a lot of dirty jokes! The writers had a field day with that episode lmaoo. Dragon quest was such a meh episode to me, I prefer Gauntlet of fire tbh!
I agree that Gauntlet of fire is great and one of the best overall, but that doesn't make Dragon Quest bad, it was written in an earlier stage and by the standards of the time, it was pretty rough and great.
I'm surprised you don't hate my favorite Pony, Rainbow Dash. Lots of people in the fandom sadly despise her and her bad episodes and it makes me sad... I never hate any of the Mane 6 or any Pony really (Besides Pinkamena from Cupcakes), but they hate Dash so much..
Wait, what, I thought Rainbow dash is fandom's favorite pony? Like, everywhere I go, people just says that Rainbow dash is best bcs of how cool she is. Idk, my fave is Twilight and Starlight
About 2,4,6 great, here’s the thing that many people aren’t realizing. There’s a HUGE difference between cheerleading and cheering. Rainbow dash wasn’t teaching Fluttershy CHEERLEADING, she was teaching her how to CHEER. Chearling doesn’t just involve just shouting, it involves acrobatics, tricks and pom-poms. HUGE DIFFERENCE!
I'm sorry, but the only correct answer for the worst episode is "Over a Barrel." You should not teach people, especially children, that the solution to colonialism and pushing Natives off their land is "well maybe we should just share." That epsiode goes beyond creating issues with characters' development and is just straight up problematic.
I can't believe I didn't think about FiM's anti-native aspects until Twitter spelled it out for me. 😣 The colonizers basically got their way in the end, and the natives just have to peacefully deal with it because "violence is bad!" The land gets used for apple trees and the buffalo now have to walk a longer path in the heat, how the fuck is that a compromise???? But my favorite part is how you NEVER see the buffalo again. FiM laid claim to every single other species with hooves and brought them to the school as representatives of different cultures, but to my memory, there wasn't one single buffalo. There was such a missed opportunity to at least bring Little Strongheart back. But no, instead spread the message that native Americans have no place in society's schools, great job.
Oh that episode gets on my nerves so much. It's one thing to resolve a conflict with "lets all just be friends", but invoking a specific issue from real life, and one that resulted in literal genocide no less, to make that message is just... it's just disgusting.
@@NebulaRanger real genocide and Native children being forced to live at residential schools where they had their cultures beat out of them by religious people and were often mass murdered 😬 definitely not a history that should be spun as "let's just get along"
Does anyone have any particular reason to love this god-awful episode? I thought it was first fine, but after rewatching it just leaves an icky feeling, and don't get me started on the lesson. The demographic for mlp is kids and something you shouldn't teach people (especially children), is that the solution to pushing Natives off their land is sharing! They could've used any other lesson on sharing. Not to mention the fact that Strongheart never appears + could've used that opportunity to put her in the friendship school?
With so many activists, this already looks like Twitter. The ponies didn't expel or colonize anyone, they just moved and planted their trees on land they had no idea was sacred. The conflict is resolved with the Buffaloes renting part of the land on the condition that they will have a path for their sacred journey and a daily supply of Apple Pies. A pretty fair deal if you ask me. If I were a native and watched the episode, I would be happy to see my people portrayed as brave warriors defending their land, as well as reasonable landowners willing to talk and negotiate. The problem for many is that continue to see the native people as wild, defenseless animals that live in the forest and pray to the trees. When the natives of the past were a glorious conglomeration of tribes that after the "conquest", participated in important historical events and stood out in many areas of the construction of this continent, and if we talk about the natives of the present, many of them have casinos and have more money than all of you agreed, I hope those natives do not read your comments, because it would give them immense embarrassment.
I've never seen anyone call A Rockhoof and a Hard Place this bad before, let alone the worst episode of the show. I do think Rockhoof basically wanting Twilight to "put him out of his misery" was really dark for this show, though. It's not my favorite episode, but I don't hate it, either.
I never thought of any episodes being that bad, but I will say there were quite a lot of shocking moments and reveals in the show, especially during Season 9 such as Celestia and Luna choosing to retire and put Twilight in charge of ruling Equestria as well as the reveal that Smolder and Garble are siblings.
Luna Eclipsed is one of my least favorites. Turning into Nightmare moon is later revealed to be Luna’s biggest fear, and in the episode she mentions that people still think of her like that. And the resolution is her changing into Nightmare to get the others to like her, which contrasts the moral of so many other episodes. And Pinkie Pie was so rude towards Luna, I know Pinkie didn’t know Luna was hurt but she should’ve apologized instead of Luna caving in.
Pinkie didn't want to be rude, she just thought that Luna was participating in Nightmare's night like everyone else, which is what she should have done, and in the end she did, that was the lesson, not to be so serious, get in the mood. without forcing others to love you, if not letting them do so over time while you integrate into their customs. That's what good leaders do.
I think “a royal problem” and “she talks to angel” are literally the same episode : Two characters argue, they don’t think their work is hard enough. Some pony break trough and switches their two roles. Then discover that their solemates role is pretty hard. And after that they forgive their self. I don’t even think “she talks to angel” was a new episode. It’s a total bust in my eyes
I hate the episode Applejack's Spa day because it made Applejack completely incompetent at her farmwork and stupid when before she just had stubborn tendencies
I like Rainbow Dash and Appejack, but every time there was an episode focused on them, the episode always portrayed them as IDIOTS??? Let me give you an example, in an episode of season 1 Appejack was responsible for picking apples from thousands of trees, but since she was doing this day and night, obviously her lack of sleep got in the way of her other activities, for example, she put the wrong ingredients in Pinkie Pie's cupcakes and that caused the population to get sick and when Twilight tries to solve this, she gets angry and thinks that Twilight is challenging her???, and also for me the worst episode of Appejack is in season 2 when she goes to travel to win the tournament, but she doesn't return, so the rest of the Mane Six go after her and when they get there, she gets angry and says that they wanted to go there on their own?, the rest of the episode is them trying to find out why she doesn't want to go back and this country girl never answers, she even tries to run away and in the end she was embarrassed for always taking second place, so basically because of her pride she wanted to return home only when she got first place (the ending of this episode is also bad, Pinkie Pie and Rarity are abandoned in the desert and no one noticed their absence????), speaking of Rainbow Dash, there is an episode where she ends up in the hospital and then she starts to love reading, but because she is discharged before finishing reading her book and as she was embarrassed to tell her friends that she was enjoying reading, SHE INVADES A HOSPITAL, STEALS A BOOK, SOMEONE BELONGING THERE AND IN THE END THEY DON'T SUFFER THE CONSEQUENCES, and another episode where her parents are introduced, she is RUDE to them just because they gave her a lot of attention, being that comparing them to Pinkie Pie's parents, there is no doubt that they are better, anyway, that's my opinion👆🏼👆🏼👆🏼
I’m not sure if anyone’s mentioned this episode, but it’s the one where Spike finds another friend to help out and Rarity starts getting jealous and possessive over him. I found this to be so badly written and out of character because of the age gap and the simple reason that Rarity doesn’t seem like the type to be jealous and controlling over someone she cares about. It was definitely weird.
For me,the worst episode is "Newbie Dash",the episode its fine until you discover the message of the episode is "Do bullying,bro",THATS THE LEAST FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC LESSON IVE SEEN,AHHHHHHHHH (sorry for my bad english)
@@alejandrootero8894 But rainbow was toatally uncomfortable with that,and it was noticeable,she said multiple times that she didn´t like that nickname,but wonderbolts didn´t stop
@@iszybrawl2466 Yeah, but that was because Rainbow spent the entire episode being stupid, out of character, looking more like a 15-year-old frustrated by her school traumas than a professional athlete/equestria hero. Taking that into account, the Wonderbolts were very kind to her.
I do hate the apple jack episodes were she is protective over apple bloom, I really wanted to punch or kick apple jack. And the fan service episode, that one really confused me and the episode ends with ponies still fighting after a song
@@alejandrootero8894 I see now, I thought it was called fan service (unsure what the real word is) but seeing that perspective makes sense by breaking the common episode format
Rockhuff is feeling down and he asks Twilight to send him back to purgatory. Rockhuff wants Twilight to kill him and she is alright. What morals is this teaching kids. My friend is sad and wants me to end there suffering. Don't cry Tim. I have got the knife 🔪 from the kitchen and I am ready to help you! No that is not a good message Hasbro!
If i'm being honest, While there are some things about these particular episodes that I don't like I personally wouldn't call them entirely bad because literally none of the episodes of mlp fim are perfect they all have ups and downs like the episodes of any tv show does but whether it's good or bad either way at the end of the day it's still mlp.
I must say you misunderstood the plot of Rockhoof episode. Twilight kept rejecting Rockhoof's "suicide" proposal, and even got angry because of it. Later, Twilight said sadly that she had a spell, and another quote said "Will you please reconsider ?" This is very different from Twilight just saying "OK" like you describe.
The issue here is that Twilight ave up on trying to help him and almost went along with it if the students didn't intervene. It is so out of character for Twilight to just give up that quickly on someone, compare what she did with Rockhoof to what she went through to convince Starlight in the 5 finale. This episode is bad.
I always hated Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000 because of Applejack's "I was right all along!". No Applejack, you were dumb and stupid and things only worked out in your favour because everyone else was even dumber and stupider. It felt like the writers just came up with the "I didn't learn anything!" gag and were so keen to use it that they just stuck it in whatever episode they were working on at the time rather than actually write an episode around it.
What are you talking about? The problem arose because Grandma Smith felt her pride was threatened and she accepted a ridiculous bet, which, knowing my grandmother, I totally believe. And just like Applejack, i would do whatever could to try and save her from that mess she got himself into (or in this case, she got her entire family into).
@@alejandrootero8894 If the Apples had partnered up with the Brothers, literally everyone would have been better off. The Brothers gain a lucrative business partnership. Keep in mind that despite being portrayed as con artists, the machine actually did exactly what it was advertised to do - create high quality cider at a much faster rate. It only stopped when they deliberately turned off the quality control for the purposes of the contest, something they wouldn't have to do during a normal business day. The customer base finally has the supply to match their demand, meaning fewer have to go without. And the Apples are finally able to keep up with the demand. Even taking into account the 75/25 split proposed by the Brothers; if using the machine quadruples their sales (a very real possibility from what we saw), they're breaking even on profit while gaining a more satisfied customer base. Anything more than that and they're actually making more than they used to. And even that's assuming they don't even try to bargain for a better deal; which, considering they control the raw supply, they have all the power in the world to do. If they had partnered, everyone involved would have benefited from it. Instead, they pull a "The old ways are always better because Reasons", only guaranteeing the problems will continue in the future.
Finally! Time to watch this video. I don't really get into these best worst episode debates (because if you put enough Bronies in a room there will be someone in there that will tell you that they hate whatever episode of the show you just mentioned), but I was curious to seen how you would do a video like this. The only opinion I can leave is: A lot of the later MLP:FIM episodes felt to me like season one episodes that just didn't got made back then and got repurposed later near the end of the show.
Is Ponyville confidential the worst episode with the whole town turning against the CMC when they're just children who are blackmailed? Or is it Twilight time since the other foals and fillies wanted to hangout with the CMC only because they're friends with Twilight Sparkle and Spike made so much nachos for nothing?
Ponyville Confidential had some bad aspects about it to me. For how the entire town went on the brink of a lockdown over 3 kids getting blackmailed, and diamond tiara practically got no punishment for her actions. Something I liked about it was how Rarity changed up so quickly after the gossip eventually happened to her. I also liked how it was pointed out that when a situation like this happens to someone else, it doesn't; really matter/pushed aside. But when it eventually happens to you, you start to understand why it might matter. While it isn't the worst episode to me, it's still pretty weird/meh. Maybe I should give twilight time a re-watch, I forgot basically everything that happened in it other than the plot. :/
The town didn't know the kids were being blackmailed, secondly I don't blame the town for getting upset, imagine someone spreading information about your personal life for everyone to see and read so they can laugh at you and then finding out it was one of your own, that would be unforgivable, and Diamond Tiara did get reprimanded and punished in the end she was forced to work on the printing press by the teacher.
That season 8 episode where Discord goes on a rampage, and puts a lot of students at risk because Starlight, who was subbing in as principal, forgot to consider his feelings, comes to mind. I think that episode is my least favourite, as it has the worst moral IMHO. Personally, I love FiM enough that I can enjoy at least 99% of episodes, even the worst of the worst, but that one is just awful.
To me A Matter of Principals is the worst episode. Discord is a complete jerk to Starlight and we’re supposed to side with him in it? Not to mention he endangers the students as well as the mane 6 just so that he can do all this BS. Then in the end Starlight was at fault? This is the episode that I’ll never understand why it got approved of. I consider it to be not just the worst episode of MLP, but the worst episode of any of my favorite shows. I’m genuinely shocked that isn’t the lowest rated episode instead of Non Compete Clause. (Although I do agree that that one sucked too)
@@randomhandleRAH I fully agree with both those statements. A Matter of Principals is just the worst in my opinion. I also felt like Non Compete Clause seemed more like something that would’ve come out of season one, which really doesn’t work when it’s in the second to last season of the show. I hate to sound like a broken record but it’s basically a worse version of Fall Weather Friends.
Over A Barrel is easily one of my least favorites, just for the fact that it was intended to be a weird allegory for when colonizers first came to what's now known as America and took the land from the people who already lived here. They tried teaching the lesson of sharing with this allegory and it's just insensitive and in terrible taste.
(Glad someone agrees with me! Everyone seem to praise that episode but I found the end totally unfair... Why should the bisons share THEIR land with the invaders?)
As someone who doesnt really know about U.S history (because im Argentinian),i love this episode,it is one of my favorites from season one,but at the same time i feel forced to dislike it because all of the racial insensitivity,so now im confused
People hate Newbie Dash because of the "cringe" scene? They should hate it because of the terrible moral. Apparently, bullying is fine actually! What a great lesson for the kids! My pick for the worst ones are Over a Barrel (for trying to "both sides" its subject matter), A Rockhoof and a Hard Place (I don't care if the writers wanna prove how "dark" or "edgy" the show can get, MY LITTLE PONY should not be talking about SUICIDE) and Dragon Dropped (it's an episode about Rarity grooming Spike...do I even need to say more?)
@@piperplimmyplymouth Talking about naturally occurring death isn't the same as talking about suicide though, and even then it had to be a metaphor. If A Rockhoof and a Hard Place is anything to go by, they wouldn't be able to handle the topic well, and that's ignoring the fact that suicide is just too dark for a show that, ultimately, is for 6 years olds. Also there's "Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?", where Luna's self-afflicted nightmares could be seen as self harm, and they resolve it by...essentially having Twilight go "Don't do that, bestie!" and that's enough to get Luna to stop. Just like that. They would not be able to handle it well. This franchise exists to sell toys of pastel coloured ponies to children, it should stay in its lane.
@@galacticglamourgirl The way that Hasbro was trying to be dark and edgy makes me want to throw my laptop out the window. I think that they went too far when they brought in Cozy Glow, the "twist villain"
You call it suicide, I call it euthanasia. I defend the right of human beings to leave with dignity when we no longer feel like continuing to exist. Why the hell would you want to force people to stay when they want to leave once and for all?
@@winter2716 woah, I've seen people defend this kinda stuff with relatively decent arguments before but that's a new one for me. I couldn't care less what some people may like for themselves but I'm glad the show made clear it wouldn't ever happen. Good night, and a good day for you.
@@silverkip2992whether this ship is Canon or not, I feel that Rarity is not the best main character of this show with her self-esteem issues which can cause problems for her friends. Imagine if someone like Fancy Pants replaced her as the Unicorn of the group and the element of generosity since he's snooty like her?
I STILL don’t understand why Mysterious Mare Do Well is hated at all. I don’t see it as mean spirited I see it as Dash getting humbled and not realizing that her friends have amazing talents too that she can’t understand at first.
I would love the in-depth review of worst MLP Episode. It's just one thing or two, what about the others? The episode I hate the most? Amending Fences. It goes against Twilight's backstory and character (she is destined to be a good friend as seen in the first episode, it doesn't make sense she is a bad friend), Moondancer is an hypocrite (she says that she friendship doesn't work to her while the three others friends shows up to the party and act like a victim while she cuts off her friendship to those who did nothing wrong), Twilight's "old circle" are actual bad friends (they are seen in Ponyville but doesn't interact to Twilight and how come Twilight doesn't learn anything about friendship with them until she meets the mane 5?) and is a bad love letter to Lauren Faust.
Funny you mention Honest Apple and that Rarity & AJ breaking up their freindship would be more realistic in S1. S1E8"Look Before you Sleep" did that exact thing and god what a terrible episode that was. Everyone is written to be an idiot and it's absolutely infuriating to watch. Lightning Round: S1E06 "Boast Busters" The Mane 6 get angry at a stage magician for showing off (wich is litteraly her job) and Snips, Snails and their single collective braincell put the whole town in danger. S1E08 "Look before you Sleep" Everyone in this episode is written like an idiot. S1E21 "Over a Barrel" Is one I don't like the implications of. S2E06 "The Cutie Pox" is boring filler. S2E15 "Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000" has the Apples being dumb. S2E23"Ponyville Confidental" has the CMC acting way too meanspirited in my opinion. S2E24 "MMMistery on the Freindship Express" is a Detective story where they don't show you the clues and Pinkie is an idiot. S3E04 "One Bad Apple" Is the worst episode of the show IMO. Babs gets away with being a bully for being bullied herself and the CMC get punished for standing up to her. S4E10 "Rainbow Falls" fails right out of the gate with a stupid setup (Why are Fluttershy & Bulk Biceps her teammates, It ruins the premise). S4E14 "Filli Vanilli" Has Pinkie being so unaware abut Fluttershy's anxiety she basically becomes the villain of the episode. S4E22 "Trade Ya!" RD gladly trades away Fluttershy... Yeah, that happend. S5E03 "Castle Sweet Castle" The Mane 6 are written as idiots again, learning a lesson they sould have learned in like S1. Song is mid too. S5E11 "Party Pooped" Yes, the one where the Yaks act like jerks. S6E14 "The Cart Before the Ponies" Where AJ, RD and Rarity act like jerks & idiots towards the CMC. S6E22 "P.P.O.V.(Pony Point Of View)" Has Rarity, AJ and Pinkie acting extremely vindictive against each other. S7E15 "Triple Threat" is another episode that does Spike dirty, JUST TALK TO THEM!!! S8E04 "Fake it 'Till you make it" Has Fluttershy just going off the rails for no reason. S8E17 "The End in Freind" has 2 of the mane 6 being childish idiots again (RD & Rarity this time). S9E03 "Uprooted" has a contrived conflict again. S9E16 "A Trivial Pusuit" is needless and boring filler. I remember NOTHING about this episode. S9E22 "Growing Up is Hard to Do" has the CMC revert back to their S1 personalities and it's INFURIATING. Still love the show tough, But not every episode can be perfect.
From what I've heard, people despised Dragon Dropped, not because of the sinking of Sparity, but because of how Rarity was portrayed. In other words, her behavior was being compared to an obsessive lover, if not a pedophile, considering the age difference between Rarity (an adult), and Spike (an adolescent). But I haven't seen Dragon Dropped; I've only HEARD things about it. I despise Yakitty Sax more because of it combining reverting Pinkie back to Season 1 and breaking the core of who she is, combined with what I'd consider an offensively bad take on depression. It's kind of like Rockhoof and a Hard Place, except for whatever reason, I don't recall despising that episode nearly as much.
I actually watched Dragon Dropped for the first time in a while just yesterday. I really wouldn't go far enough to use P3d0ph1l3 but do agree on the "obsessive friend" part. It's uncomfortable, I'm not a fan and considering the episode came out late into the show's lifespan you'd think they'd know better to write an episode going into the territory of stalking, love bombing (** love bombing is a manipulation tactic that involves constant compliments and gifts and attention to keep someone in a relationship.) and so on.
I agree with the choices in this video, but I'm surprised that Trade Ya! didn't get a mention. Fetch Quest episode (a variant of one where the main character has to trade a bunch of items to get what they want, and things either go super well or something happens to the item by the end of it) AND Dash trades Flutters away for a signed copy of Daring Do?!?! Our Element of Loyalty, folks!
Over A Barrel is really bad for obvious reasons. Even if I didn't see what was wrong with it as a kid, growing up and educating myself has made the episode EXTREMELY uncomfortable and insufferable to watch. They literally could have done ANYTHING ELSE for an episode about sharing. What About Discord hits too close to home for me due to trauma reasons and my fear of being left out. It's literally just Twilight being left out and sad for the entire episode and honestly Discord was a huge jerk for basically rubbing it in her face that she wasn't there to witness the inside jokes. Yakity-Sax is probably one of my least favorites ever because they completely DECIMATED Pinkie's character. And the moral is awful. Pinkie has many many things that make her happy and thrives off of making people smile,, but suddenly she finds this random instrument that makes others miserable and literally prevents them from sleeping and doing their jobs and apparently that's now more important to her than the happiness of others. The lesson shouldn't have been "Oh we were mean for saying you were bad at playing.". They should have come to some sort of compromise or have Pinkie stop playing the yovidophone because her friends' happiness is more important to her than some random instrument.
Agreed! When I first watched Over a Barrel, I didn't really notice what was wrong with it, but after rewatching mlp from s1 to s9, I can also agree with how it made me really uncomfortable. What About Discord was an okay episode to me. I liked the whole plot and how she felt left out and how they resolved it. I really liked the joke that Applejack made as well. I finished this show about 2 months ago and still remember it! It was like "What kind of fertilizer did you stick up your nose twilight?" or something like that. I disliked how it was so blatantly obvious that Discord was being a jerk, from the eye movements and word choices I'm surprised none of the characters except maybe Twilight noticed. The fact that you made a better lesson than the actual people who worked on the episode is just sad. Yakity-Sax is just an awful episode, there was an entire song about she likes to make people smile and the writers really thought 20 minutes of Pinkie making people miserable to the point where they can't do their jobs is just irritating to me. I really like pinkie pie, but episodes like this just ruin her for me. While I still really don't like newbie Dash because of the blatant bullying of rd, I gotta say this is a pretty bad episode!
@@alejandrootero8894 Biggest problem is how children were being taught that the solution to colonialism and pushing Natives off their land is to share. That is just straight-up problematic. And they could've used any other lesson on sharing..
@@randomhandleRAH The ponies didn't expel or colonize anyone, they just moved and planted their trees on land they had no idea was sacred. The conflict is resolved with the Buffaloes renting part of the land on the condition that they will have a path for their sacred journey and a daily supply of Apple Pies. A pretty fair deal if you ask me. If I were a native and watched the episode, I would be happy to see my people portrayed as brave warriors defending their land, as well as reasonable landowners willing to talk and negotiate.
@alejandrootero8894 ....except that they DID colonize the land. Whether you like it or not this is a 1 to 1 portrayal of Natives vs Colonizers and if you were a native maybe you'd be able to realize that this is NOT how it goes at all and how insensitive this really is. No, the ponies who decided to take the land that never belonged to them are not the "landowners" . The point is that the Buffalo were there first and the land is theirs. The ponies should've never settled there in the first place and this entire topic was never suited for a kids cartoon.
I feel like most people (including me) Didn't hate newbie dash for that one scene; it was because other characters completely ignored her childhood trauma of bullying because it was "just hazing". I know alot of autistic and ADHD people who resonate with RD and are used to constantly having their experiences weaponized against them as jokes. It's really gross and upsetting.
It wasn’t “hazing.” It was literally just a nickname & some light teasing, both of which are extremely common in the military (and regular friend groups, too). Y’all are just too sensitive sometimes…
I think what would've fixed the episode was Rainbow asking Spitfire about the nicknames and Spitfire explaining why it's a tradition and that whole there is a fine line between hazing bullying, she doesn't tolerate bullying.
@@cynicalsix Apparently you missed where I said “and regular friend groups, too.” Also, not every situation in MLP has to be directly applicable to the target demographic. Which 6-10 year-old girl manages boutiques all over the country? Which 6-10 year-old girl fights a giant red centaur?
@@winter2716 If I told my friends to stop calling me a nickname that was used by people who tormented me, they would listen and stop calling me that. Dash is treated as unreasonable for being uncomfortable and that it's just a joke.
About your point with Equestria Games, it was a good episode, but it shouldn’t have been the whole conclusion to the Equestria Games arc! Imo it would have been better if it was like a mini season in which there were multiple episodes focusing on each character and their role in the Equestria Games, all leading to a thrilling conclusion episode of the final day of the Games, rather than cramming it all in one episode that focused on Spike The current Equestria Games episode worked well as Spike’s part of the story, and it would have been nice if there were additional episodes focusing on the CMC, Fluttershy and Rainbow, and Twilight. There’s a lot of potential for a whole story arc of the characters at the Games! It really didn’t work well as a one part episode. Basically it had the same flaws as Magical Mystery Cure which was a good concept ruined by it being a one part episode, though Equestria Games was a much better episode imo I liked the episode, it just had some missed potential
Magical Mystery Cure was a great concept but not fleshed out enough, it would have been better as an hour long special than a one parter, so much was crammed into a normal length episode when such an important plot point should be told in an hour. I feel bad for Applejack and Spike, they’re great characters but tend to get the worst episodes- however when an episode about them is good, it’s REALLY good. The Perfect Pear is honestly one of the BEST episodes of the entire series, hooves down, with one of the best songs in the series as well. Minus Rainbow Dash bullying Spike at the beginning and Peewee never really appearing again, Dragon Quest was a pretty good episode that explored Spike’s character very well. Power Ponies and Gauntlet of Fire were excellent too.
Honestly, the only Episode that heavily focuses on Spike that is good is ‘The Times They Are A Changeling’, where we are introduced into one of the most adorable characters, Thorax. ‘Spike At Your Service’ annoyed me, just cause it didn’t really do anything for the characters and just felt like filler. Also, these two I don’t mind, because they shine new light on Garble and Ahuizotl, but I just wish we saw them grow to earn the redemptions in ‘Sweet and Smokey’ and ‘Daring Doubt’.
"applejack's day off" is one of the few episodes that has made me physically cower with cringe. spike honestly just felt very out of character. he was very stupid for some reason in this episode, as he couldn't even recognize that the timberwolves were fake. he's immature cuz' he's a kid, yes, but he's not a DUMB(BUTT) LIKE--
How come all the episodes of the Mane 6 are not on this list consisting about the only bad thing about them is how much they have fun without Spike and treats him like a slave since this show started with none of them showing any kind of sympathy for him? Spike should have either been returned to the Dragon land after being born or stayed back in Canterlot with the Princesses since they could make him feel more useful and more comfortable Don't forget Twilight who makes Spike feel so left out since she is so selfish not to include him on all the good times with her and her friends? And she's never really understands how Spike feels since she's supposed to be the princess of friendship
What an exaggeration, Spike is ignored for like 3 or 4 episodes, the series has more than 200 Spike is included in the vast majority of events, parties and adventures of the ponies, and even has the occasional solo.
I gave up watching the show at S7 so this is from my memory and YT clips: -Trade Ya took itself literally and Twilight the Princess of f*ckin Friendship approved it had me in a dilemma for days. -Yakity Sax was dumb as hell. Everyone in Ponyville is annoyed by the yovidphone because it was loud and played for hours on end. Even if it was well played it would still be annoying. She should have learned to not take criticism deeply instead of her friends calling for an encore of bad tunes at the end. -A Matter of Principals cemented me not liking Discord. He sabotaged the other subs and goaded Starlight into losing her temper in front of the students just because he was jealous. That Kamehameha was deserved. Why he was offered a teaching position after all that bs is beyond me.
-Twilight never approved of it, I don't know what you're talking about. -Yakity Sax was indeed horrible in every way. -Here I will play as devil's advocate, but before, I agree that he had deserved it for a long time and just seeing him take that beating, this episode became one of my favorites. However, what was the deal that these ponies had with the master of chaos to have a truce and for him to stay away without spreading chaos as he always wanted? That they were his friends. Who fulfilled the deal? Discord and Fluttershy... and no one else. (We could count the time that Celestia invited him to the gala, but it was only to make it more interesting) Whenever the ponies planned something they avoided including Discord. they never write or call him except when they need his help. That's not a friend if you ask me. However, although Starlight enslaves a village of ponies and tries to destroy the friendship of the protagonists by traveling through time, she is forgiven (several times) made part of the group and invited to everything, including taking care of the school while they are traveling. If I were discord I would be jealous as hell too. Starlight broke the cycle of hate by inviting him to join.
@@alejandrootero8894 -Twilight literally said her hooves were tied while pony trafficking was in her face, it was until the safari pony was touched by Dash's speech that the deal was off. -It's because of Discord's pranks that barely anyone includes him. This episode practically played that out. I understand that he's jealous of Starlight getting picked over him since she's done eviler but Starlight didn't do it again and got nicer. He betrayed the Mane 6 for Tirek after seasons of being 'good'. He's consistently been pushy, annoying, and selfish so outside of Pinkie and Fluttershy I don't blame others for keeping him at a distance.
@@L0V3000 I saw the Spanish American version. That's why I got confused. I just saw the English version and I agree with you, she said that her hooves are tied. However, that was more of an exchange of services for a product, the condition being that Fluttershy stays alone until the dog is trained (which Fluttershy agreed to) she was not going to stay with Fluttershy as a slave.... It's true that discord was a jerk, but Starlight wasn't perfect either. -Enchanted all of Twi's friends as slave zombies -she endangered Thorax's hive -She deliberately missed the meeting with Celestia. -She changed the cutie marks of the princesses. It is true that discord betrayed them, but even before that moment, none (expt Flu) had made the slightest effort to get along with him.
@alejandrootero8894 -I never said slave as trafficking can include a work contract. I don't care if Fluttershy consented since Dash wanted to call off the trade and Twilight still took the safari pony's side. Ponies are above the worth of glued fiction and saying otherwise seems inhumane. I wish Twilight added a clause that only services can be traded with services and products with products. -Like I posted originally I left the show before S7 so I didn't see all the things Starlight did then. Yes I understand only Fluttershy hung out with him but she has the patience for him being pushy and annoying. Because Starlight is more kind and apologetic they can look past her mistakes while Discord always has something up his sleeve and won't hesitate to hold someone's flaws over them. I personally would've had Pinkie and him hang out sometimes since she finds him amusing.
@@L0V3000 Well, not with pinkie, but with Rainbow Dash, discord teamed up for Fluttershy's gift in the christmas special (and it was a very good job) It's a pity you stopped watching the series, missed some great moments like the one I just mentioned (including other great things Discord did) As for trade ya, it would look very ugly for the new princess to use her power to cancel an already closed deal, breaking decades of Rainbow Fall´s tradition for the benefit of her closest friends.
@@TheAeroAvatar I think it's an improvement that Twilight that she got wings, but I never heard of the mlp Fandom from fans of how they think of it What about you? I sorta wanna hear it from another person
Personally for me, I think the worst episode is Daring Doubt because of they turn Fluttershy into an utter idiot and the blatant Ass Pulls regarding Ahuizotl and lets not forget that given the ending, Daring Do's career as a whole is screwed thanks to the poor writing.
@@alejandrootero8894 I get what the writers were trying to do but it comes off as her being idiotic. Just what the hell, she is way more than that, she is responsible and smart, not stupid.
First time watching your channel, and I'll be honest you have some very points about these episodes, I can see that Seasons 8 & 9 weren't that likable considering the fact that there were a lot of bad changes compared to how they were in older seasons, I also do think that Spike is a bit overheated as I did think he was quite a funny and entertaining character, great video and I just subscribed.
I still think Spike at Your Service is the worst for retconing how good Spike is. He cooks very well in other episodes, but in this one he doesnt know how to cook? He cleans amazingly in other episodes, but in this one hes incompetent? And what the hell is this "dragon code"?
I hadn't thought about that before, but Spike hadn't even lived among dragons. Would he even know what codes that dragons live by? And even if he did he'd been living among ponies his whole life so they would probably be irrelevant to him.
@@58jharrishonestly Spike should have chosen to stay back in the Dragon Land with Ember so that he could learn more about his culture along with trying to be a couple with her
@@trexadvent4726 Yeah that probably would have been the best ending to his character arc. At that point though the show writers seemed to care more about making political statements about diversity than telling good stories.
@@trexadvent4726 Nah, he's a pony at heart, he already made that clear in several episodes (although he briefly forgot when his non-father visited him), he is a citizen of Equestria like anypony, his culture is the culture of Equestria.
Here's my personal picks for Top 5 Worst MLP: FIM Episodes with descriptions as to why I ranked them such: V. Putting Your Hoof Down AKA Everypony Be A D**K To Fluttershy: The majority of the characters were unbelievably mean spirited to Fluttershy in this episode for no reason then, when she goes to learn assertiveness, Fluttershy goes completely off the rails with how uncharacteristically aggressive she was towards others. This then leads up to her doing the most G-Rated version of an Eric Cartman burn against Pinkie and Rarity that was still hard for me to listen to the cruelty of the words behind it as I thought to myself "What the F**K were these writers thinking!?! How could they do this to my favorite character?" Worst Fluttershy episode ever and nearly made me question if I still liked her, but she at least redeemed herself in realizing she'd gone too far and experienced genuine remorse for her actions (which is more than I can say for certain other characters later on, but we'll get there). IV. Non-Compete Clause: Nice to see Fluttershy being as popular as she was with the students at the School Of Friendship to the point where she had 15-16 wins as Teacher Of The Month, but that's where any enjoyability ends. AJ and Rainbow being so obnoxiously competitive towards each other when they're supposed to be teaching the students about working as a group to the point where they're putting lives in danger is too much to have to suffer through for a 22 minute episode, but it just keeps going on and on and on and JUST SHUT UP ALREADY!!! III. A Matter Of Principals: Discord just assumes that he's gonna be put in charge of the School of Friendship in the Mane 6's absence when the Friendship Map summons all of them away despite never being given permission too then proceeds to insult Starlight Glimmer when she's put in charge and make her job a veritable hell. He acts like a jack**s with unfunny pranks that could potentially endanger students until Starlight finally agrees to let him work with her as head of the school, only for the Mane 6 to show up angrily talking about how Discord used the map to send them on a fake mission where they nearly got eaten by giant worms. This including Fluttershy who he "supposedly" "cares the most about" and he has no remorse for doing so. II. The Ending Of The End 2 Parter: This was not the strongest 2 Parter there could've been, but it's made worse by the fact that the villain of the whole season, Grogar, who was being built up as the ultimate threat was just Discord in disguise the whole time in a twist so mind numbingly braindead that it makes Shyamalan's worst twists look like philosophical deep dives into the human condition. It makes no sense from a story standpoint, was the worst decision the writers could've possibly made, and it retroactively makes the entire season terrible as every bad thing that happened didn't need to if Discord hadn't been an idiot and just done nothing. Not to mention the fact that after nearly destroying all of Equestria and nearly getting all the Mane 6 killed brcause of his stupidity, he gets absolutely no punishment for doing so and even gets to pass down judgement on those who he recruited for the dumb plan anyways. Though I don't agree with a lot of stuff he says, MisAnthro Pony went into better detail about how terrible the Grogar/Discord twist was than I could and they were wholeheartedly in the right with their analysis on the twist's idiocy so go check that out if you want to know my full thoughts on the matter. Ultimately, this was what ruined Discord as a character for me and made me lose any respect I might have had for the Fluttercord ship in general. I. Father Knows Beast: Oh sweet pony Jesus was this episode bad! Discord may have done some despicable things that he had no remorse for, but Sludge almost makes him look like a freakin saint in comparison... ALMOST! Sludge pretends to be Spike's father, exploiting the trust of a literal child in order to manipulate Spike into giving up his own luxuries for Sludge's own benefit. Then when Twilight expresses concern for Spike, he uncharacteristically lashes out at her, literally breaking the heart of the mare who's practically raised him his whole life, only to find out from a friend that HE was the one who was wrong the whole time. THEN when they confront Sludge, he admits that he lied to him, but tries to excuse his behavior as a "dragon stereotype" with no remorse for his actions and exploiting a child's trust. I didn't even finish watching the episode after that scene, I was just DONE! The episode was painfully predictable, Sludge was the worst... THING that has ever been in an MLP episode, and it's the only one I never bothered to watch all the way through out of the 200+ episode run of the series. People say Chancellor Neighsay was the worst character of Season 8 (or the whole series depending on who you ask), but I say Sludge is still worse. 1. Neighsay was voiced by legendary VA Maurice LaMarche and 2. Yes he was a racist, bigoted jackwagon, but he at least saw the error of his ways come the Season 8 finale and even came to the Mane 6's aid in the Battle for Equestria in The Ending Of The End. Where was Sludge in all of this? Nowhere. He has no redeemable qualities to him whatsoever and was a waste of an episode and character animation.
oh my god. i hate how theres so MANY EPISODES where people are just a dick to fluttershy and the SHOW paints it out that its HER FAULT, aDN THEY DONT ADDRESS THAT THEY WERE IN THE WRONG FOR BEING RUDE! ITS SO ANNOYIING..
@@lemonmeat i literally came here to say this, or like the episode where they have to make a tornado in cloudsdale and the moral is just like "well just dont be scared" as someone who grew up with severe social anxiety (and was a kid watching these episodes)seeing everyone treat it like its just fluttershys fault annoyed me as well as the stuff you mentioned, theyre always so nasty to her lol she was my favorite *because* of the stuff they were always chastising her for
Worst episode(s)? For me: Dragon Dropped, Yakity Sax, The Matter of Principals, Hard To Say Anything, Princess Spike Boring episodes: Viva Las Pegasus, Daring Doubt, The Parent Map, Where The Apple Lies, Heartswarming Eve
I literally had to relook up the episode name of this one, but Yakity Sax. S8 Ep18 Pinkie becomes obsessed w/ yak hoen instrument but is terrible at playing. So her friends all tell her to stop & it literally puts her in a depression. Why is this bad? Well because Pinkie is shown to have multiple passions + she literally turn into a whiny child over a new instrument when again l, this is PINKIE PIE. The mare who has multiple friends, passions, & hobbies. The episode ends with Pinkie getting her yak pipes or whatever they were back. Too me it's terrible bc it completely goes against her character to act this way.
This is true! I really don't like this episode, was even considering skipping it but decided to watch till the end. What a waste of my time! Firstly, I REALLY like Pinkie, she's the emotional support type of gal and does an awesome job at it! I don't want to see her being depressed for 20 minutes straight because the writers became too lazy in the writing department. She can sing an entire song about making people smile but then she has to make everyone miserable with the Yaxity sax to the point where people cannot do their jobs.. really guys? They really like going against her character, don't they! :/
Plus, she's a master at using multiple instruments, how can she not realize how terrible she sounds when she plays this one, with how talented she is at music and instruments, she should have mastered that damn thing. in less than a week.
I personally think the worst episodes are: *"Over a Barrel": Because the solution that the settlers/colonizers and the native buffaloes should SHARE the buffaloes sacred stompingrounds is BS! *"Amending Fences": because Moon Dancer's reasons to behave the way she does are pure BS. Seriously? ONE friend doesn't show up to your party ONE time and now you don't wanna have friends anymore?? Including the friends that came to your party?? *"The Cutie Re-Mark - Part 2". Starlight wants to destroy reality just because her friend moved away. Seriously? Yes, loosing a friend because they moved away sucks, but that's life! Some friendships don't last forever and it's no ones fault. That's just life, get use to it. That's not a reason to hurt others! It is completely normal to loose friends when you grow up. That's a BS-excuse to ENSLAVE an entire village! I also agree with "Non-compete Clause", "A Rockhoof and a Hard Place" and "Newbie Dash" as a choice. Poor RD was called the name that her childhood bullies gave her for the entire episode and in the end it's ok, because the other Wonderbolts have dumb nicknames too? What?? Edit: Grammar mistake.
As someone with ASD (Autism-Spectrum Disorder) who had a falling out with a long-time friend but didn't let it get to me, I'm actually very offended by "Amending Fences" and how it's story was presented. I will also never understand why so many call it a good episode.
@@SakicFan Holy shit I didn't think of it like that. I thought that the story was presented well with how they introduced Moondancer, someone who was just as reclusive as Twi but to a much worser degree. I'll give a rewatch, since I haven't seen it in about 6 months. I can totally see why you think that, thank you for letting me see it in a little bit of a diff way :)
I totally agree with all of that. I suppose sharing was a good conclusion because the Apples already had a whole farm set up on that land, but it did belong to the buffalo. I don’t know, I think that one was too.. political for kids. They probably wouldn’t get it, but we do, and it’s just awkward
Honestly any episode from season 8 that focused on those boring new school creatures were bad. I just couldn’t connect with them and skip most of them when rewatching. But I love the episode where starlight and sunburst go visit their parents. It’s one of my favorites
Not to sound rude but "conveniently" leaving out the part from Rockhoof and a Hard Place where Twilight was initially against turning Rockhoof into a statue but eventually caved because she saw how frustrated and left out he felt in the modern era because the rest of his peers and colleagues found careers similar to the ones they had in the past just because you personally didn't like the episode is odd. I'm sorry. He wouldn't have been "put out of his misery." Phrasing it like that sounds dramatic 😭😭 It would've been a situation similar to what Discord was in. Not dead, still alive, it be living life permanently on pause. I agree it's not the best episode but it's not the worst either.
Thank you! Im so glad I wasn’t the only bothered by that omission! Twilight wasn’t ‘perfectly fine’! She spent hours arguing with him and even when she relented not only did she ask him to reconsider, she EXPLICITLY said she was *only* doing it because it wasn’t permanent. And he even cut off the part where she asked him to reconsider.
theres probably a couple more out there i didnt like, but the only one i can think of currently (other than every equestria girls movies after rainbow rocks,) dragonshy comes to mind. the whole episode was just all of fluttershys friends treating her like shit for being scared instead of understanding her and being nice to her to help her cope. as an autistic person i heavily relate to fluttershy because. i mean.. dont even get me started on my ramble about autism rep, intentional or not, in the show. fluttershy is very clearly autistic, at least for me, wether it was intentional or not, and seeing how all her friends treated her in that episode (especially rainbow dash, but the many.. many... MANy.. other times theyre rude to her for no reason in other episodes..) just made me feel awful, having experienced the exact same things as her time and time again countlessly for being autistic and acting exactly like her because of being autistic. also, just how it just feels super out of character for the mane 6 to be so mean. like, THEY DIDNT EVEN ADDRESS IT AFTERWARDS AT THE END OF THE EPISODE!!! THIS IS THE SHOW ABOUT LEARNING ABOUT HOW FRIENDSHIP WORKS!!! AND IT WAS NEVER ADDRESSED THAT "HEY IF YOUR FRIEND IS SCARED, HELP THEM OVERCOME IT INSTEAD OF BEING A HUGE DICK AND SHAMING THEM AND SINGLING THEM OUT!!" sorry for that tangent i just really hate that episode
OH! another episode i hated was the episode where starlight and sunburst have to go see their parents, i forgot the title right now but i HATED IT. THEIR PARENTS LITERALLY JUST GUILT TRIP THEM WHEN THEY SHOW THEY WANT SPACE. THE PARENTS WERE GENUINELY BEING ANNOYING AND NOT RESPECTING THEIR KIDS, BUT BOOOOHOOOOO THEYRE YOUR FAMMMMILLLY SO SHAME ON YOU FOR WANTING SPACE. holy shit. the fact they didnt even address the parents behavior when they guilt tripped them. as someone with parents worse than that who use guilt tripping a LOT, IT WAS SO FUKCING ANNOYING AAAAHHHH okay again sorry for that tangent LOL
Bats. Always bats. Everyone loved it because flutterbat while ignoring that it villainized a MAIN CHARACTER for protecting their livelihood! “Can’t you just give up a few acres for a bay sanctuary-“ NO! No she can’t! It’s been established many times sweet apple acres has razor thin margins. This is like saying every farmer should just allow gophers to run rampant. They’re pest animals and it’s okay to not want them on your property! And it ends with AJ sacrificing part of her farm. Whyyyyyyy!!! If Fluttershy wants a bat sanctuary SHE can build one! Why is it up to AJ to feed pest critters? I hate bats.
That's very true. When I was little though, I absolutely hated it because of the song where the Mane 6 were basically tearing Fluttershy apart. Pissed me the hell off, nowadays I understand why Applejack would not want the bats on her farm but Jesus.
Did you not listen to Fluttershy's argument at all? The fruit bats don't eat the seeds of the apples, they will make AJ's trees grow stronger faster. You can't apply real world logic to Equestrian logic. Also, vampire fruit bats vs gophers is not a fair comparison. Not even close. There are plenty of critters that farmers love because they control other pests. Also, also bats are adorable.
@@Black-Swan-007 Do you have any idea how long it takes an apple tree to mature to where they’re producing apples? Additionally the trees would grow at random instead of in proper lines, making them harder to harvest from. I sure as hell CAN apply real world logic to equestrian society when they want to tackle a real world problem like pest control.
@@forestgrump4723 Well, if we are going to apply the logic of the real world, you should listen to the opinion of the expert in zoology. What the strong and hardworking but uneducated farmer can identify as a pest, the forest biologist can identify as an important part of the ecosystem. Ask the Chinese what happened when they tried to get rid of the "plague of birds that ate their crops", it turned out that the birds ate only part of their crops and their main prey was the real pests, the result was a famine that I kill fucking millions of people. The trees on Applejack's farm never had an orderly distribution for harvesting (in fact, in one episode we see that her farm is quite optimizable). And in any case, Applejack always had the last word, Fluttershy never demanded anything, in fact, she was able to put aside her iron love for animals in order to help her friend, or have you already forgotten how she became Flutterbat in the first place?
Bats was annoying for me cause I couldn’t understand why they where so quick to try AJ’s ideas when they could’ve helped Fluttershy peacefully help the Vampire Bats Relocate and Flutterbat wouldn’t even have been brought into existence.
Newbie Dash will always be my most disliked episode. They took Dashie's biggest moment and made it into a low tier gag-humor episode with a really poor lesson at the end. It was the one episode that left me feeling crappy after watching it. That one and '28 pranks later' both felt like S1 rehashes but in turbo mode.
When I first watched it, it left me hating the episode. I even skipped it after rewatching every episode of s1 to s9, it was just awful. I don't plan of rewatching it either, the lesson was SO BAD. Isn't this show called "MLP Friendship Is Magic" why they bullyin poor rd? 🤦♂
I felt kinda the same on the "Newbie dash" when I watched it. It felt like RD worked throughtout all of her life to become a Wonderbolt and to get off that "Rainbow Crash" nickname she got in her childhood... Kinda sad and dissapointing at best
I'd quote the episode "Bats!", it's absolutely NOT a terrible episode, but the treatment of the characters beside AJ and Fluttershy was. That episode is one of my favourite and a good one because: 1) The song is catchy af (still remember every word😂) 2) Applejack and Fluttershy both show you the two sides of an important argument and both make really good points (Fluttershy talking about the fact that vampire fruitbats will help growing more trees with all the seeds they spit around and offering a real solution for example and AJ making her notice the fact that you don't have the luxury of time when you sell certain products for living and those are in danger), giving you an hard time choosing the one to agree with even if the episodes puts Fluttershy in the "She was right all along" position, something that's usually lacking in kids cartoon that will instead make one side appear just extremely negative and "evil" (I mean, AJ was even fine with letting Fluttershy talk to the vampire fruitbats first). 3) I still find the idea of a vampire pony extremely cool. What I didn't like, was how the other characters act and how it's never addressed. 1) Rainbow Dash tells most of the times that getting rid of the vampire bats is really important to her, not even AJ, she was enthusiastic about the "hunt" and all 'cause she freaked out about not having apple cider... I'm still waiting for an episode where she talks about her drinking problem, 'cause she clearly needs help. FUN FACT: here in Italy, they censored any mention and clip where apple cider is directly shown or mentioned, basically taking away the "drinker RD" clip and making it look like she just got up one day and decided to choose violence against animals for fun. 2) Rarity agrees with AJ's point of view but the only constructive criticism she can offer is that the vampire bats sounds dreadful and are ugly and drooling. They made her sound far too superficial in a context like this. 3) Twilight is there in her "I'm so morally superior"-pose most of the time, telling how she would have loved to find another solution and the only time she makes research is only for the animal-brainwashing spell and she actually search for it because she already knows the spell is there. Don't know... try a bit harder Twilight? Try to research for real? Maybe that could actually help? 4) Pinkie Pie doesn't even have an opinion, she just follows the group around and even during the song she just smiles like she doesn't even know why she's here, she's a party pony yes, often played the goofy and silly comic part, but is she dumb? No.
I really like your points! Dash having a drinking problem is just hilarious to think about, and my favorite part of this episode was probably the way they showed two sides of an argument that both are fairly important, and coming along with a solution to fix the problem!
EXACTLY! None of the other Mane 6 members had deep, legitimate reasons for siding with Applejack, instead just ganging up on Fluttershy who was left to defend herself all alone instead of having 1... JUST 1 pony side with her to show her ANY kind of support. I was half expecting this to turn into a "Kill The Beast" moment where Fluttershy, like Belle, is the only one to stand up against the angry mob, only for it to mean nothing when she tries to defend the innocent bats. I don't hate the episode, but Rainbow, Rarity, Twilight, and Pinkie's portrayals here REALLY irked me.
Well Pinkie and Rainbow want cider Twilight wants to put her spell into practice. Rarity hates ugly creatures like those bats. And even I sided with Applejack the first time I saw the episode. I love that the episode puts Fluttershy in a position where she must defend animals even if they aren't "cute and huggable". She's not like those PETA hypocrites Also, in this episode Twilight ask for the Fruit bats, establishing that they are separated in the west orchard. To which Applejack replies that those are just normal fruit bats, these invaders however are vampire bats.
@@alejandrootero8894 yeah... I already said the exactly same things about Twilight and the others being characterized in a shitty way with no real and justified reason to agree with AJ and that they were reduced only to: thirst for spells, alcoholism and being suddently far more superficial than Rarity used to be. At least alcoholism is a serious problem, they censored the apple cider in my country and made RD looks like she just wanted to hunt down animals for fun (doesn't help that the italian version of the "Stop the Bats" song changed far too many line from "send them away/they have to go" to "We must kill the bats") and made Pinkie looks like she didn't even have an opinion and was just hanging around like a puppet. But I agree with you with *everything,* as I already said the episode is one of my favourites especially for AJ and Fluttershy and their points of view. After all: AJ is realistic and has realistic worrys about the problems that could cause to have all your apple tree sucked dry when what you sell puts food in your family's table, but she still was ok with letting Fluttershy try and talk to the Vampire Bats first, showing that she was rightfully worried and protective of her orchard, but not the: "This character is wrong so they must be unnecessarily evil and aggressive" cliché; and Fluttershy proposed a real solution (the reserve) while many characters like her in cartoons are often made "all talk and no alternatives, 'cause they're already right" and still tried to make her point valid without becoming the "crazy animal lover" trophe. Those two were the best part of the episode and taught a really good lesson, it's hard to choose with who you should side when both parts are right (AJ needs her orchard and products and Fluttershy simply wants to defend animals and their nature) and simply want different solutions to the same problem.
@@alejandrootero8894 also, thank you for telling me about the details regarding the fruitbats being in a different place and not a threat, differently than the vampire fruitbats, it's been a while since I watched the episode and forgot about that dialogue. Thank you really much 👍🏻
I agree about season 8 that is easily the shows worst season. And I don't think season 9 is much better. I rarely watch any episodes from those two seasons these days with the exception of "Sounds of Silence", the only really good episode from those two seasons in my opinion.
Honestly i have no clue what my least favorite is I honestly love all the episodes but there ares ones i like less probably the episode were rarity gets jealous about spike hanging out with gabby because it just comes out of nowhere that she gets jealous even though she never liked him like that throughout the entire series
Putting your hoof down has done such damage to MY image of Fluttershy that everything she did after that episode made me dislike her so much cuz everything she did seemed fake to me and when she showed her assertive side of personality I just see it as her real personality, that she is my least favorite characther in this entire show till today.
I mean wasn't that the whole point? After around 15 minutes in she realizes what she has done and went to lock herself in her house, the assertive side of her personality was there only because finally realized she needs to be a little bit more of it. Her pet bunny bosses her around for god's sake! While out of the main six Fluttershy is my least favorite, I want to at least give her credit for what the writers have done with s4 + because her character was just 100% better. I can get your point though.
That isn’t her real personality, it was just very exaggerated. It was a little too much imo, but she IS very susceptible to being manipulated, or at least she was before she learned how to be assertive in a healthy way
When Fluttershy sets out with a role, she can exaggerate too much without realizing it, we've seen that flaw of hers in many episodes and I find that quite credible and adorable.
I really dislike "Fall Weather Friends" episode, particullary the moment when Rainbow Dash and Applejack started mocking Twilight Sparkle for participating in race. I understand that it is made to in the end teach them a lesson of that physical strenght is not the most importaint thing, yet I couldn't get it how Rainbow and AJ can be so mean to their friend.
Man, are you serious? If you're offended by that you must have very fragile skin (or think Twi has it), they laughed because she's a bookworm. If I see my agoraphobic otaku friend at a party, I would make jokes about it too (and if he later humiliates me with amazing dance steps, I'll eat my words with great pleasure), it's not about being mean, the teasing between friends are most common among groups of people who handle the comrade dynamic and are not autistic.
Thats strange. I personally liked some of these episodes such as the mare do well one, spike at your service, what about Discord, Applejacks day off, Honest Apple, Non Compete Clause (one of my favourites), a rockhoof and a hard place, but thats ur opinion and ur entitled to it
Im still working on my own retrospective, but I believe season 8 is pretty overhated. It has bad episodes, sure, but I dont think theyre as bad as, say, season 2 or season 7 episodes. Anyhow, Im glad that none of your worst episodes are Starlight Glimmer focused because shes basically the best character in the series.
@@ninak5645 I dislike the bad episodes in that season more than the bad ones in season 8. Even if season 7 doesnt have that much bad episodes, I tolerate the bad episode in season 8 better. Its all matters of opinions in the end
"No big loss there"😂😂😂 He's right, Yona, more specifically Yaks in general just annoy me every time they are on-screen! The most useless creatures with an ego so high Luna could see it from the moon. All they know is destroying things and does Twilight actually tolerate Yona's bad grammar in school? Seems really unfair on essays.
@@alejandrootero8894 may just be my personal bias since my favorite pony is rainbow dash, but ive watched that one episode multiple times n i still feel like she was rly out of character the entire episode. she was just very mean and selfish for no reason even tho she is meant to be the element of loyalty. i could go on abt how much i dislike that ep but that is basically the main reason for me:/ (also the multiple "20% cooler" jokes thru out the episode made it feel more like a mockery of the fandom than a nod to it and increasingly got more annoying the more they said it)
@@p1ll0w_53 I agree in part, but I didn't think these little flaws overshadowed the overall episode. Rainbow wasn't bad on purpose, she was just worried because being Wonderbolt was her life's dream, and all she had to do was listen to Fluttershy to calm her down. Although she was disrespectful to Twilight when she tried to teach her her way, but it's because she was so confident that she knew all the answers (typical RD arrogance). The only thing that escapes me is why do you think she was disloyal?
@@alejandrootero8894 idrk but it mainly just felt off especially since all of the cheer team had so much faith in her and so did twilight. if she rly was loyal to her team and to the people that believed in her, she would hav put more effort into training them, even if she didn't understand the importance of the cheer team. idk tho, everyone can hav their own opinion that's just how i felt while watching the episode
@@p1ll0w_53 LOL. I confused the title with Testing Testing 1, 2, 3. You're right, the episode you speak of does present Rainbow as unloyal to a certain extent. I don't really like that episode, but I don't hate it either.
You had some very good opinions! I just don't think the Rockhoof one was that bad...its actual similar to Troubleshoes aka the one episode the crusaders stumbled across the most wanted "criminal" in Appleloosa (sorry i cant spell in advance) Anyways, they both felt the feeling of being useless in society, BUT they were actually funny accidentally! Trouble balancing on the beach ball shenanigans, rockhoof massaging Bulk biceps too hard (LMAO) you get the idea The worst episode in my opinion was probably either The Last problem aka last episode or the whole spikes "father" the one you mentioned oorrrrr....Winter Wrap up 1 season...or one of the Hearths warming eve episodes with Starlight being a knock off grinch HAHA funny but not a good episode
actually, the starlight one isn't her being a "knock off" grinch, It's actually a real christmas story which I believe It's called "A christmas carol" or something like that, which is about some old guy called Scrooge who doesn't like christmas and gets visited by 3 ghosts that represent the past, present and future. Quite similar to the grinch, but the scrooge one was published around the 1840's, so If anything, the grinch could've taken inspo from it. And what's wrong with Winter wrap up? I thought It was liked among the community
I like all of g4 so I I'm not complainting theirs no bad or boring eps g4 is all great to me like the other mlp gens and me liking barbie as well also zepher breeze him and rd are both funny and annoying
Seriously, in Rockhoof in a Hard Place why didn’t they take him to see the Yaks?
Because he would have been the fucking hero clearing the snow (which is the biggest problem for yaks)
Which would have upset the Yacks by suggesting their lifestyle wasn't perfect, either that or Prince Rutherford would have felt overshadowed (that jerk isn't easy to deal with).
“28 pranks later” is an episode I hate endlessly!
How Rainbow Dash doesn’t feel guilty at all for upsetting her friends with her pranking.
Especially Fluttershy who she KNOWS has anxiety issues and even laughs at her crying in fear.
They basically turned Rainbow Dash into an insensitive bully!
Seriously, WTF??
Personally this or the test of g4 doesn't bother me also yes I like Rainbow dash I lot yes she's was rude and I was laughing because I think it's rube but funny except of scaring fluttershy because she's my second fave and pinkie is 3rd and to me she learned her lesson
I also thought it was a little over the top - RD wouldnt behave like that to this extreme extend - she would maybe play a few pranks here and there, but this episode went completely overboard and portrayed her as an asshat who isnt aware of anything around her
You seem like the type of person who hates "The Mysterious Mare Do Well". I mean, this episode is kinda meh to me. The fart joke in the beginning kinda got me, and many other things in this episode were pretty funny. So at least it was good in the humor department. 😭🤷
Thank you! Does anyone remember what Rainbow Dash said in Season 1?
@@randomhandleRAH the 28 pranks later episode is better than that episode due to the fact that Twilight and her friends try to talk Rainbow Dash out of pulling pranks on others before they gave her a taste of her own medicine later on
Why I don't like newbie dash was the allegory to hazing, please note that making gun of someone new in a field or program, and expect them to be okay with it, is only going to end uo badly. Especially because the entire episode it has Rainbow reacting badly to a insult she was given as a child, that's now being repeated in her dream job.
The worst episode is 'The Mysterious Mare- Do- Well,' for its horrifically hypocritical message.
You may not agree with the message, but what would be the hypocrisy with the message regarding the episode?
@@alejandrootero8894 I agree with the episode's message itself (That people shouldn't brag too much about their accomplishments), it's just that the episode presented that message in a very hypocritical way.
The hypocrisy is that the other members of the Mane 6, in their attempt to teach Rainbow Dash a lesson, were subtly doing the exact same thing they were mad at Rainbow for doing.
SPOILERS!
Early on, in praising Mare- Do- Well's accomplishments, Pinkie Pie praises how fast and agile Mare- Do- Well was when saving the construction workers from the falling bricks. Applejack then praises the great strength Mare- Do- Well showed when stopping the runaway bus. Rarity praises Mare- Do- Well's stylish costume. Lastly, Twilight praises Mare- Do- Well's apparent knowledge of magic shown when fixing the dam.
In the end of the episode, when it's revealed that Mare- do- Well was actually each of the other members of the Mane 6 in disguise to get Rainbow to stop bragging, it turns out that they themselves were doing the things they were praising "Mare- do- Well" for doing. Pinkie was the one who saved the construction workers using her Pinkie- Sense so she was really bragging about her own speed/ agility, Applejack was the one who stopped the bus so she was really bragging about her own strength, Rarity designed the Mare- do- Well costumes so she was really bragging about her own skills as a fashion designer, and Twilight was the one who used her magic to fix the dam, so she was really bragging about her own magical knowledge.
In short, while claiming to want to teach Rainbow Dash that bragging is wrong, they were themselves subtly bragging about their own skills! That's hypocritical.
@@Adamguy2003 Oh, I thought they were doing that on purpose to annoy Rainbow Dash even more. Which, although it wouldn't be so hypocritical anymore, I admit that it would be a bit rude on the part of the group of ponies, but hey, nobody is perfect, haha
I agree. Most hated episode ever in the history of episodes
The problem with the Mare do well episode is how dangerous Ponyville suddenly becomes, with its residents plunging down steep cliff-top roads at very turn & unsafe buildings. Makes you wonder what the average weekly death toll is.
I honestly feel like that's the only real problem with the episode. (and is not big deal)
Honestly, I hate every Applejack centered episode, despite AJ literally being my favorite character. First off, there’s not many episodes that actually center around HER alone. The only one I can think of is maybe Apple Family Reunion? Other than that it’s always AJ and another pony, or other ponies talking about AJ. And second off, AJ EPISODES ALWAYS MAKE HER OUT TO BE A COMPLETE IDIOT. Like usually, she’s smart, resourceful, caring, helpful. And in her own episodes, all that gets thrown out the window. I really wish we got more good episodes of my favorite character. I really miss her..
I totally agree. Applejack is a great character! I mean she has a great personality and she's a really likable character! She's great when she's more of a supporting character, but when it comes time to give her an episode that centers around her, it just comes out kinda meh. I also really wish we got better episodes in the end since the writers have shown time and again that they can give good episodes to the other mane six.
@@randomhandleRAH exactly, you get me!
Well, but it is that if we talk about episodes where she is the only one we focus on, there are like 1 or 2. And the episodes where she is the co-star (which in fact happens to all the characters) are quite good in their most.
The episode where rainbow dash parents was fan girl and almost blew her team out of the air but somehow it's rainbow dash that neet to learn the lesson.
I like rd and her parents like my opinion is none if g4 or any of the gens bother me to me they are perfect
IMO, episodes like Non Compete Clause and Applejack's Day Off highlight how FiM was NOT intended for the direction it ultimately went into.
Both of these feel like Season One episodes, where the girls were just flippant and learning about each other. So it made sense that they would be quicker to fight and beat on each other, the bond wasn't fully there.
By Season 8, the girls are ambassadors of friendship, basically Equestria's guardians, and teachers of a new generation. If they're going to have fights _now,_ they need to have very strong reasoning behind them. When the Mane 6 have petty disagreements, it feels like selective amnesia. You KNOW Rainbow Dash and Rarity are better than being such bad examples for their students. You KNOW Applejack is smarter than that. If all of these episodes were still in the early age, they would be so much more forgivable. The ponies went from little girls needing to learn lessons to grown women who flip between emotionally mature and complete Karens.
I can't disagree with one comma of what you said
_28 pranks later, the end in friend_ and _non-compete clause_ would've worked well in earlier seasons when the characters were more immature and still got on each others nerves
Exactly.
Totally agree 👍
indeed
Surprised there was no mention of No Second Prances, honestly just a terrible way to reintroduce Trixie. The writers basically retconned the end of Magic Duel just to make this plot "work".
Personally i love that episode
It’s not like Twilight still liked Trixie, the mare tried to enslave all of Ponyville to do her bidding and tried to banish Twilight.
I personally thought Non-Compete Clause cuz it’s just Fall Weather Friends but wrong because in FWF they were only hindering each other and the friendship was still somewhat new. But in season 8 they were hurting students and themselves and they’re supposed to be really tight now.
It’s also the season before the two get together and one of the last times they were paired together. Nah these two are not married I don’t believe it.
If by perfectly Ok you mean, Twilight tries everything to convince Rockhoof reconsider...
To be fair, Twilight was only "okay" with offing Rockhoof after much insistence from the latter. She initially was horrified and refused immediately.
Right?, They were also the whole chapter trying to help him adapt, it seemed to me that Tootsie didn't see the episode.
Fr
I hated that one racist Native American buffalo episode
Same I never rewatch that one But you have to admire the stamina of the stallions pulling the train.
The good thing with bad episodes is, at least it's quite fun to watch videos talking about them!
For me the episodes I dislike are usually the ones where a character does a lot of harm and damage around them in the name of "funny slapstick" but somehow are still the ones who are "right" in the end. Mixing slapstick comedy and life lesson is possible indeed but they shouldn't contradict each other, and sometimes even the best writers fail at it...
Ponyville Confidential Sucks.
The Way The CMC Was Treated Was Unnecessary. THEY’RE CHILDREN 😭🙏
The fact that Diamond Tiara didn't get any serious punishment when SHE was the one who forced CMC to exposed everyone secrets including Princess Celestia by black mailing them is beyond frustrating and we supposed to feel sorry for her because of her mother, F*ck off.
It's also frustrating that Adults blame the CMC instead of Diamond Tiara and it was a adult who allow Diamond Tiara to be in charge.
@@robincrusoejrt1903Yeah, man, there's also another episode that I hate, which is when Apple Bloom's test arrives in Ponyville, intimidating the CMCs along with the Diamond Tiara, and at the end we have to feel sorry for her because she was afraid of being bullied, FUCK that character.
Thanks you for the warm welcome, I won't stop making G4 content as I love FIM and plan on going 4ever. :3
My personal head canon for Somepony to Watch Over Me is the reason Apple Jack was so overprotective and out of character could’ve had something to do with reminding of her parents’ death and she didn’t want to lose Apple Bloom too
Not to mention that Rockhoof wanting to turn himself to stone is inevitably an allegory for suicide. Suicide ISN’T reversible. The episode would still suck, but at least it wouldn’t undermine a serious topic.
It is called Euthanasia, and it is a legitimate method of leaving with dignity when you no longer feel like staying here.
over a barrel genuinely needs to be hated more i cant believe such a poor episode came out of season 1
also everytime chancellor neighsay was on screen
Its not that bad
Honestly I KEEP forgetting that Season 7's Secret And Pies was a thing. It felt like such a nothing filler episode! Also no Dragon Quest?!
The Gauntlet of fire episode was way better than the Dragon Quest episode
That episode had a lot of dirty jokes! The writers had a field day with that episode lmaoo. Dragon quest was such a meh episode to me, I prefer Gauntlet of fire tbh!
I agree that Gauntlet of fire is great and one of the best overall, but that doesn't make Dragon Quest bad, it was written in an earlier stage and by the standards of the time, it was pretty rough and great.
I'm surprised you don't hate my favorite Pony, Rainbow Dash. Lots of people in the fandom sadly despise her and her bad episodes and it makes me sad... I never hate any of the Mane 6 or any Pony really (Besides Pinkamena from Cupcakes), but they hate Dash so much..
#JusticeForDash. Dash is Best Pony.
Fr, rainbow dash deserve better writing, the fandom could write better episodes for her that stays true to her character
Wait, what, I thought Rainbow dash is fandom's favorite pony? Like, everywhere I go, people just says that Rainbow dash is best bcs of how cool she is. Idk, my fave is Twilight and Starlight
About 2,4,6 great, here’s the thing that many people aren’t realizing. There’s a HUGE difference between cheerleading and cheering. Rainbow dash wasn’t teaching Fluttershy CHEERLEADING, she was teaching her how to CHEER. Chearling doesn’t just involve just shouting, it involves acrobatics, tricks and pom-poms.
HUGE DIFFERENCE!
I'm sorry, but the only correct answer for the worst episode is "Over a Barrel." You should not teach people, especially children, that the solution to colonialism and pushing Natives off their land is "well maybe we should just share." That epsiode goes beyond creating issues with characters' development and is just straight up problematic.
I can't believe I didn't think about FiM's anti-native aspects until Twitter spelled it out for me. 😣 The colonizers basically got their way in the end, and the natives just have to peacefully deal with it because "violence is bad!" The land gets used for apple trees and the buffalo now have to walk a longer path in the heat, how the fuck is that a compromise????
But my favorite part is how you NEVER see the buffalo again. FiM laid claim to every single other species with hooves and brought them to the school as representatives of different cultures, but to my memory, there wasn't one single buffalo. There was such a missed opportunity to at least bring Little Strongheart back. But no, instead spread the message that native Americans have no place in society's schools, great job.
Oh that episode gets on my nerves so much. It's one thing to resolve a conflict with "lets all just be friends", but invoking a specific issue from real life, and one that resulted in literal genocide no less, to make that message is just... it's just disgusting.
@@NebulaRanger real genocide and Native children being forced to live at residential schools where they had their cultures beat out of them by religious people and were often mass murdered 😬 definitely not a history that should be spun as "let's just get along"
Does anyone have any particular reason to love this god-awful episode? I thought it was first fine, but after rewatching it just leaves an icky feeling, and don't get me started on the lesson. The demographic for mlp is kids and something you shouldn't teach people (especially children), is that the solution to pushing Natives off their land is sharing! They could've used any other lesson on sharing. Not to mention the fact that Strongheart never appears + could've used that opportunity to put her in the friendship school?
With so many activists, this already looks like Twitter.
The ponies didn't expel or colonize anyone, they just moved and planted their trees on land they had no idea was sacred.
The conflict is resolved with the Buffaloes renting part of the land on the condition that they will have a path for their sacred journey and a daily supply of Apple Pies. A pretty fair deal if you ask me.
If I were a native and watched the episode, I would be happy to see my people portrayed as brave warriors defending their land, as well as reasonable landowners willing to talk and negotiate.
The problem for many is that continue to see the native people as wild, defenseless animals that live in the forest and pray to the trees. When the natives of the past were a glorious conglomeration of tribes that after the "conquest", participated in important historical events and stood out in many areas of the construction of this continent, and if we talk about the natives of the present, many of them have casinos and have more money than all of you agreed, I hope those natives do not read your comments, because it would give them immense embarrassment.
I've never seen anyone call A Rockhoof and a Hard Place this bad before, let alone the worst episode of the show. I do think Rockhoof basically wanting Twilight to "put him out of his misery" was really dark for this show, though. It's not my favorite episode, but I don't hate it, either.
Voice of Reason put it one his list of worst episodes for that season
The worst part twilight was ok with it !?
Also Twilight never was ok with that. And it was heartening to see RockHoof find his footing as a storyteller.
I never thought of any episodes being that bad, but I will say there were quite a lot of shocking moments and reveals in the show, especially during Season 9 such as Celestia and Luna choosing to retire and put Twilight in charge of ruling Equestria as well as the reveal that Smolder and Garble are siblings.
neat
Luna Eclipsed is one of my least favorites. Turning into Nightmare moon is later revealed to be Luna’s biggest fear, and in the episode she mentions that people still think of her like that. And the resolution is her changing into Nightmare to get the others to like her, which contrasts the moral of so many other episodes. And Pinkie Pie was so rude towards Luna, I know Pinkie didn’t know Luna was hurt but she should’ve apologized instead of Luna caving in.
Pinkie didn't want to be rude, she just thought that Luna was participating in Nightmare's night like everyone else, which is what she should have done, and in the end she did, that was the lesson, not to be so serious, get in the mood. without forcing others to love you, if not letting them do so over time while you integrate into their customs. That's what good leaders do.
I think “a royal problem” and “she talks to angel” are literally the same episode :
Two characters argue, they don’t think their work is hard enough. Some pony break trough and switches their two roles. Then discover that their solemates role is pretty hard. And after that they forgive their self.
I don’t even think “she talks to angel” was a new episode. It’s a total bust in my eyes
I hate the episode Applejack's Spa day because it made Applejack completely incompetent at her farmwork and stupid when before she just had stubborn tendencies
good lesson, very bad execution.
I like Rainbow Dash and Appejack, but every time there was an episode focused on them, the episode always portrayed them as IDIOTS??? Let me give you an example, in an episode of season 1 Appejack was responsible for picking apples from thousands of trees, but since she was doing this day and night, obviously her lack of sleep got in the way of her other activities, for example, she put the wrong ingredients in Pinkie Pie's cupcakes and that caused the population to get sick and when Twilight tries to solve this, she gets angry and thinks that Twilight is challenging her???, and also for me the worst episode of Appejack is in season 2 when she goes to travel to win the tournament, but she doesn't return, so the rest of the Mane Six go after her and when they get there, she gets angry and says that they wanted to go there on their own?, the rest of the episode is them trying to find out why she doesn't want to go back and this country girl never answers, she even tries to run away and in the end she was embarrassed for always taking second place, so basically because of her pride she wanted to return home only when she got first place (the ending of this episode is also bad, Pinkie Pie and Rarity are abandoned in the desert and no one noticed their absence????), speaking of Rainbow Dash, there is an episode where she ends up in the hospital and then she starts to love reading, but because she is discharged before finishing reading her book and as she was embarrassed to tell her friends that she was enjoying reading, SHE INVADES A HOSPITAL, STEALS A BOOK, SOMEONE BELONGING THERE AND IN THE END THEY DON'T SUFFER THE CONSEQUENCES, and another episode where her parents are introduced, she is RUDE to them just because they gave her a lot of attention, being that comparing them to Pinkie Pie's parents, there is no doubt that they are better, anyway, that's my opinion👆🏼👆🏼👆🏼
I’m not sure if anyone’s mentioned this episode, but it’s the one where Spike finds another friend to help out and Rarity starts getting jealous and possessive over him. I found this to be so badly written and out of character because of the age gap and the simple reason that Rarity doesn’t seem like the type to be jealous and controlling over someone she cares about. It was definitely weird.
For me,the worst episode is "Newbie Dash",the episode its fine until you discover the message of the episode is "Do bullying,bro",THATS THE LEAST FRIENDSHIP IS MAGIC LESSON IVE SEEN,AHHHHHHHHH (sorry for my bad english)
Although I also hate that episode, nicknames are not bullying, how would they know that Rainbow had a trauma with that name?
@@alejandrootero8894 But rainbow was toatally uncomfortable with that,and it was noticeable,she said multiple times that she didn´t like that nickname,but wonderbolts didn´t stop
@@iszybrawl2466 Yeah, but that was because Rainbow spent the entire episode being stupid, out of character, looking more like a 15-year-old frustrated by her school traumas than a professional athlete/equestria hero. Taking that into account, the Wonderbolts were very kind to her.
I do hate the apple jack episodes were she is protective over apple bloom, I really wanted to punch or kick apple jack. And the fan service episode, that one really confused me and the episode ends with ponies still fighting after a song
I wouldn't call that fan service, but I liked that they couldn't solve the problem of radical fans, they had to wait until they got bored and left.
@@alejandrootero8894 I see now, I thought it was called fan service (unsure what the real word is) but seeing that perspective makes sense by breaking the common episode format
Rockhuff is feeling down and he asks Twilight to send him back to purgatory.
Rockhuff wants Twilight to kill him and she is alright.
What morals is this teaching kids.
My friend is sad and wants me to end there suffering. Don't cry Tim. I have got the knife 🔪 from the kitchen and I am ready to help you!
No that is not a good message Hasbro!
If i'm being honest, While there are some things about these particular episodes that I don't like I personally wouldn't call them entirely bad because literally none of the episodes of mlp fim are perfect they all have ups and downs like the episodes of any tv show does but whether it's good or bad either way at the end of the day it's still mlp.
I must say you misunderstood the plot of Rockhoof episode. Twilight kept rejecting Rockhoof's "suicide" proposal, and even got angry because of it. Later, Twilight said sadly that she had a spell, and another quote said "Will you please reconsider ?" This is very different from Twilight just saying "OK" like you describe.
The issue here is that Twilight ave up on trying to help him and almost went along with it if the students didn't intervene. It is so out of character for Twilight to just give up that quickly on someone, compare what she did with Rockhoof to what she went through to convince Starlight in the 5 finale. This episode is bad.
@@Tootsie4ever wasn't she planning on freeing him later once she found a way to change his mind, or am I just making stuff up?
I always hated Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000 because of Applejack's "I was right all along!". No Applejack, you were dumb and stupid and things only worked out in your favour because everyone else was even dumber and stupider. It felt like the writers just came up with the "I didn't learn anything!" gag and were so keen to use it that they just stuck it in whatever episode they were working on at the time rather than actually write an episode around it.
What are you talking about? The problem arose because Grandma Smith felt her pride was threatened and she accepted a ridiculous bet, which, knowing my grandmother, I totally believe. And just like Applejack, i would do whatever could to try and save her from that mess she got himself into (or in this case, she got her entire family into).
@@alejandrootero8894 If the Apples had partnered up with the Brothers, literally everyone would have been better off.
The Brothers gain a lucrative business partnership. Keep in mind that despite being portrayed as con artists, the machine actually did exactly what it was advertised to do - create high quality cider at a much faster rate. It only stopped when they deliberately turned off the quality control for the purposes of the contest, something they wouldn't have to do during a normal business day.
The customer base finally has the supply to match their demand, meaning fewer have to go without.
And the Apples are finally able to keep up with the demand. Even taking into account the 75/25 split proposed by the Brothers; if using the machine quadruples their sales (a very real possibility from what we saw), they're breaking even on profit while gaining a more satisfied customer base. Anything more than that and they're actually making more than they used to. And even that's assuming they don't even try to bargain for a better deal; which, considering they control the raw supply, they have all the power in the world to do.
If they had partnered, everyone involved would have benefited from it. Instead, they pull a "The old ways are always better because Reasons", only guaranteeing the problems will continue in the future.
Finally! Time to watch this video.
I don't really get into these best worst episode debates (because if you put enough Bronies in a room there will be someone in there that will tell you that they hate whatever episode of the show you just mentioned), but I was curious to seen how you would do a video like this.
The only opinion I can leave is: A lot of the later MLP:FIM episodes felt to me like season one episodes that just didn't got made back then and got repurposed later near the end of the show.
Never in my life have I seen so much truth in so few words.
Is Ponyville confidential the worst episode with the whole town turning against the CMC when they're just children who are blackmailed? Or is it Twilight time since the other foals and fillies wanted to hangout with the CMC only because they're friends with Twilight Sparkle and Spike made so much nachos for nothing?
Ponyville Confidential had some bad aspects about it to me. For how the entire town went on the brink of a lockdown over 3 kids getting blackmailed, and diamond tiara practically got no punishment for her actions. Something I liked about it was how Rarity changed up so quickly after the gossip eventually happened to her. I also liked how it was pointed out that when a situation like this happens to someone else, it doesn't; really matter/pushed aside. But when it eventually happens to you, you start to understand why it might matter. While it isn't the worst episode to me, it's still pretty weird/meh. Maybe I should give twilight time a re-watch, I forgot basically everything that happened in it other than the plot. :/
The town didn't know the kids were being blackmailed, secondly I don't blame the town for getting upset, imagine someone spreading information about your personal life for everyone to see and read so they can laugh at you and then finding out it was one of your own, that would be unforgivable, and Diamond Tiara did get reprimanded and punished in the end she was forced to work on the printing press by the teacher.
@@urmom6701 You stole the words from my mouth
That season 8 episode where Discord goes on a rampage, and puts a lot of students at risk because Starlight, who was subbing in as principal, forgot to consider his feelings, comes to mind. I think that episode is my least favourite, as it has the worst moral IMHO. Personally, I love FiM enough that I can enjoy at least 99% of episodes, even the worst of the worst, but that one is just awful.
To me A Matter of Principals is the worst episode. Discord is a complete jerk to Starlight and we’re supposed to side with him in it? Not to mention he endangers the students as well as the mane 6 just so that he can do all this BS. Then in the end Starlight was at fault? This is the episode that I’ll never understand why it got approved of. I consider it to be not just the worst episode of MLP, but the worst episode of any of my favorite shows. I’m genuinely shocked that isn’t the lowest rated episode instead of Non Compete Clause. (Although I do agree that that one sucked too)
Indeed
A Matter of Principals is just awful, and Non Compete Clause had the plot of something that should've been made in s1..
@@randomhandleRAH I fully agree with both those statements. A Matter of Principals is just the worst in my opinion. I also felt like Non Compete Clause seemed more like something that would’ve come out of season one, which really doesn’t work when it’s in the second to last season of the show. I hate to sound like a broken record but it’s basically a worse version of Fall Weather Friends.
@@princessstar512 Agreed!
Over A Barrel is easily one of my least favorites, just for the fact that it was intended to be a weird allegory for when colonizers first came to what's now known as America and took the land from the people who already lived here. They tried teaching the lesson of sharing with this allegory and it's just insensitive and in terrible taste.
(Glad someone agrees with me! Everyone seem to praise that episode but I found the end totally unfair... Why should the bisons share THEIR land with the invaders?)
As someone who doesnt really know about U.S history (because im Argentinian),i love this episode,it is one of my favorites from season one,but at the same time i feel forced to dislike it because all of the racial insensitivity,so now im confused
People hate Newbie Dash because of the "cringe" scene? They should hate it because of the terrible moral. Apparently, bullying is fine actually! What a great lesson for the kids!
My pick for the worst ones are Over a Barrel (for trying to "both sides" its subject matter), A Rockhoof and a Hard Place (I don't care if the writers wanna prove how "dark" or "edgy" the show can get, MY LITTLE PONY should not be talking about SUICIDE) and Dragon Dropped (it's an episode about Rarity grooming Spike...do I even need to say more?)
i actually loved Newbie Dash 😭
I can see suicide as a theme working in MLP if they handled it, like, well?? Like tanks for the memories where hibernation symbolised death.
@@piperplimmyplymouth Talking about naturally occurring death isn't the same as talking about suicide though, and even then it had to be a metaphor. If A Rockhoof and a Hard Place is anything to go by, they wouldn't be able to handle the topic well, and that's ignoring the fact that suicide is just too dark for a show that, ultimately, is for 6 years olds.
Also there's "Do Princesses Dream of Magic Sheep?", where Luna's self-afflicted nightmares could be seen as self harm, and they resolve it by...essentially having Twilight go "Don't do that, bestie!" and that's enough to get Luna to stop. Just like that.
They would not be able to handle it well.
This franchise exists to sell toys of pastel coloured ponies to children, it should stay in its lane.
@@galacticglamourgirl The way that Hasbro was trying to be dark and edgy makes me want to throw my laptop out the window. I think that they went too far when they brought in Cozy Glow, the "twist villain"
You call it suicide, I call it euthanasia.
I defend the right of human beings to leave with dignity when we no longer feel like continuing to exist. Why the hell would you want to force people to stay when they want to leave once and for all?
"unfortunately it sinks all the spike/rarity ships leaving fans really upset" good
@@winter2716 Spike is a child, Rarity is an adult. I think it's self explanatory
@@winter2716 woah, I've seen people defend this kinda stuff with relatively decent arguments before but that's a new one for me. I couldn't care less what some people may like for themselves but I'm glad the show made clear it wouldn't ever happen. Good night, and a good day for you.
@@silverkip2992whether this ship is Canon or not, I feel that Rarity is not the best main character of this show with her self-esteem issues which can cause problems for her friends. Imagine if someone like Fancy Pants replaced her as the Unicorn of the group and the element of generosity since he's snooty like her?
I STILL don’t understand why Mysterious Mare Do Well is hated at all.
I don’t see it as mean spirited I see it as Dash getting humbled and not realizing that her friends have amazing talents too that she can’t understand at first.
In addition to the fact that nobody does anything particularly bad or unpleasant, like in other episodes.
I would love the in-depth review of worst MLP Episode. It's just one thing or two, what about the others?
The episode I hate the most? Amending Fences. It goes against Twilight's backstory and character (she is destined to be a good friend as seen in the first episode, it doesn't make sense she is a bad friend), Moondancer is an hypocrite (she says that she friendship doesn't work to her while the three others friends shows up to the party and act like a victim while she cuts off her friendship to those who did nothing wrong), Twilight's "old circle" are actual bad friends (they are seen in Ponyville but doesn't interact to Twilight and how come Twilight doesn't learn anything about friendship with them until she meets the mane 5?) and is a bad love letter to Lauren Faust.
Funny you mention Honest Apple and that Rarity & AJ breaking up their freindship would be more realistic in S1. S1E8"Look Before you Sleep" did that exact thing and god what a terrible episode that was. Everyone is written to be an idiot and it's absolutely infuriating to watch.
Lightning Round:
S1E06 "Boast Busters" The Mane 6 get angry at a stage magician for showing off (wich is litteraly her job) and Snips, Snails and their single collective braincell put the whole town in danger.
S1E08 "Look before you Sleep" Everyone in this episode is written like an idiot.
S1E21 "Over a Barrel" Is one I don't like the implications of.
S2E06 "The Cutie Pox" is boring filler.
S2E15 "Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000" has the Apples being dumb.
S2E23"Ponyville Confidental" has the CMC acting way too meanspirited in my opinion.
S2E24 "MMMistery on the Freindship Express" is a Detective story where they don't show you the clues and Pinkie is an idiot.
S3E04 "One Bad Apple" Is the worst episode of the show IMO. Babs gets away with being a bully for being bullied herself and the CMC get punished for standing up to her.
S4E10 "Rainbow Falls" fails right out of the gate with a stupid setup (Why are Fluttershy & Bulk Biceps her teammates, It ruins the premise).
S4E14 "Filli Vanilli" Has Pinkie being so unaware abut Fluttershy's anxiety she basically becomes the villain of the episode.
S4E22 "Trade Ya!" RD gladly trades away Fluttershy... Yeah, that happend.
S5E03 "Castle Sweet Castle" The Mane 6 are written as idiots again, learning a lesson they sould have learned in like S1. Song is mid too.
S5E11 "Party Pooped" Yes, the one where the Yaks act like jerks.
S6E14 "The Cart Before the Ponies" Where AJ, RD and Rarity act like jerks & idiots towards the CMC.
S6E22 "P.P.O.V.(Pony Point Of View)" Has Rarity, AJ and Pinkie acting extremely vindictive against each other.
S7E15 "Triple Threat" is another episode that does Spike dirty, JUST TALK TO THEM!!!
S8E04 "Fake it 'Till you make it" Has Fluttershy just going off the rails for no reason.
S8E17 "The End in Freind" has 2 of the mane 6 being childish idiots again (RD & Rarity this time).
S9E03 "Uprooted" has a contrived conflict again.
S9E16 "A Trivial Pusuit" is needless and boring filler. I remember NOTHING about this episode.
S9E22 "Growing Up is Hard to Do" has the CMC revert back to their S1 personalities and it's INFURIATING.
Still love the show tough, But not every episode can be perfect.
tbf rarity and aj barely knew each other in look before you sleep
From what I've heard, people despised Dragon Dropped, not because of the sinking of Sparity, but because of how Rarity was portrayed. In other words, her behavior was being compared to an obsessive lover, if not a pedophile, considering the age difference between Rarity (an adult), and Spike (an adolescent).
But I haven't seen Dragon Dropped; I've only HEARD things about it. I despise Yakitty Sax more because of it combining reverting Pinkie back to Season 1 and breaking the core of who she is, combined with what I'd consider an offensively bad take on depression. It's kind of like Rockhoof and a Hard Place, except for whatever reason, I don't recall despising that episode nearly as much.
I actually watched Dragon Dropped for the first time in a while just yesterday. I really wouldn't go far enough to use P3d0ph1l3 but do agree on the "obsessive friend" part. It's uncomfortable, I'm not a fan and considering the episode came out late into the show's lifespan you'd think they'd know better to write an episode going into the territory of stalking, love bombing (** love bombing is a manipulation tactic that involves constant compliments and gifts and attention to keep someone in a relationship.) and so on.
Rarity wasn't a obsessive libre,she was an obsessive friend
I agree with the rockhoof in a hard place it's just so BAD!
meh, i like it
I agree with the choices in this video, but I'm surprised that Trade Ya! didn't get a mention. Fetch Quest episode (a variant of one where the main character has to trade a bunch of items to get what they want, and things either go super well or something happens to the item by the end of it) AND Dash trades Flutters away for a signed copy of Daring Do?!?! Our Element of Loyalty, folks!
Screw off! I'm not gonna let people harass my waifu! She's already been bullied SO MUCH IN THE FUCKING FANDOM!! JUST GIVE HER A BREAK FFS!
Over A Barrel is really bad for obvious reasons. Even if I didn't see what was wrong with it as a kid, growing up and educating myself has made the episode EXTREMELY uncomfortable and insufferable to watch. They literally could have done ANYTHING ELSE for an episode about sharing.
What About Discord hits too close to home for me due to trauma reasons and my fear of being left out. It's literally just Twilight being left out and sad for the entire episode and honestly Discord was a huge jerk for basically rubbing it in her face that she wasn't there to witness the inside jokes.
Yakity-Sax is probably one of my least favorites ever because they completely DECIMATED Pinkie's character. And the moral is awful. Pinkie has many many things that make her happy and thrives off of making people smile,, but suddenly she finds this random instrument that makes others miserable and literally prevents them from sleeping and doing their jobs and apparently that's now more important to her than the happiness of others.
The lesson shouldn't have been "Oh we were mean for saying you were bad at playing.". They should have come to some sort of compromise or have Pinkie stop playing the yovidophone because her friends' happiness is more important to her than some random instrument.
Agreed! When I first watched Over a Barrel, I didn't really notice what was wrong with it, but after rewatching mlp from s1 to s9, I can also agree with how it made me really uncomfortable.
What About Discord was an okay episode to me. I liked the whole plot and how she felt left out and how they resolved it. I really liked the joke that Applejack made as well. I finished this show about 2 months ago and still remember it! It was like "What kind of fertilizer did you stick up your nose twilight?" or something like that. I disliked how it was so blatantly obvious that Discord was being a jerk, from the eye movements and word choices I'm surprised none of the characters except maybe Twilight noticed.
The fact that you made a better lesson than the actual people who worked on the episode is just sad. Yakity-Sax is just an awful episode, there was an entire song about she likes to make people smile and the writers really thought 20 minutes of Pinkie making people miserable to the point where they can't do their jobs is just irritating to me. I really like pinkie pie, but episodes like this just ruin her for me. While I still really don't like newbie Dash because of the blatant bullying of rd, I gotta say this is a pretty bad episode!
@@randomhandleRAHWhat is the problem with Over A Barrel?
@@alejandrootero8894 Biggest problem is how children were being taught that the solution to colonialism and pushing Natives off their land is to share. That is just straight-up problematic. And they could've used any other lesson on sharing..
@@randomhandleRAH The ponies didn't expel or colonize anyone, they just moved and planted their trees on land they had no idea was sacred.
The conflict is resolved with the Buffaloes renting part of the land on the condition that they will have a path for their sacred journey and a daily supply of Apple Pies. A pretty fair deal if you ask me.
If I were a native and watched the episode, I would be happy to see my people portrayed as brave warriors defending their land, as well as reasonable landowners willing to talk and negotiate.
@alejandrootero8894 ....except that they DID colonize the land. Whether you like it or not this is a 1 to 1 portrayal of Natives vs Colonizers and if you were a native maybe you'd be able to realize that this is NOT how it goes at all and how insensitive this really is.
No, the ponies who decided to take the land that never belonged to them are not the "landowners" . The point is that the Buffalo were there first and the land is theirs. The ponies should've never settled there in the first place and this entire topic was never suited for a kids cartoon.
I feel like most people (including me) Didn't hate newbie dash for that one scene; it was because other characters completely ignored her childhood trauma of bullying because it was "just hazing". I know alot of autistic and ADHD people who resonate with RD and are used to constantly having their experiences weaponized against them as jokes. It's really gross and upsetting.
It wasn’t “hazing.” It was literally just a nickname & some light teasing, both of which are extremely common in the military (and regular friend groups, too). Y’all are just too sensitive sometimes…
@@winter2716 Which 6-10 Little Girl is in the miltiary
I think what would've fixed the episode was Rainbow asking Spitfire about the nicknames and Spitfire explaining why it's a tradition and that whole there is a fine line between hazing bullying, she doesn't tolerate bullying.
@@cynicalsix Apparently you missed where I said “and regular friend groups, too.” Also, not every situation in MLP has to be directly applicable to the target demographic. Which 6-10 year-old girl manages boutiques all over the country? Which 6-10 year-old girl fights a giant red centaur?
@@winter2716 If I told my friends to stop calling me a nickname that was used by people who tormented me, they would listen and stop calling me that. Dash is treated as unreasonable for being uncomfortable and that it's just a joke.
About your point with Equestria Games, it was a good episode, but it shouldn’t have been the whole conclusion to the Equestria Games arc! Imo it would have been better if it was like a mini season in which there were multiple episodes focusing on each character and their role in the Equestria Games, all leading to a thrilling conclusion episode of the final day of the Games, rather than cramming it all in one episode that focused on Spike
The current Equestria Games episode worked well as Spike’s part of the story, and it would have been nice if there were additional episodes focusing on the CMC, Fluttershy and Rainbow, and Twilight. There’s a lot of potential for a whole story arc of the characters at the Games! It really didn’t work well as a one part episode. Basically it had the same flaws as Magical Mystery Cure which was a good concept ruined by it being a one part episode, though Equestria Games was a much better episode imo
I liked the episode, it just had some missed potential
Magical Mystery Cure was a great concept but not fleshed out enough, it would have been better as an hour long special than a one parter, so much was crammed into a normal length episode when such an important plot point should be told in an hour.
I feel bad for Applejack and Spike, they’re great characters but tend to get the worst episodes- however when an episode about them is good, it’s REALLY good. The Perfect Pear is honestly one of the BEST episodes of the entire series, hooves down, with one of the best songs in the series as well.
Minus Rainbow Dash bullying Spike at the beginning and Peewee never really appearing again, Dragon Quest was a pretty good episode that explored Spike’s character very well. Power Ponies and Gauntlet of Fire were excellent too.
Honestly, the only Episode that heavily focuses on Spike that is good is ‘The Times They Are A Changeling’, where we are introduced into one of the most adorable characters, Thorax.
‘Spike At Your Service’ annoyed me, just cause it didn’t really do anything for the characters and just felt like filler.
Also, these two I don’t mind, because they shine new light on Garble and Ahuizotl, but I just wish we saw them grow to earn the redemptions in ‘Sweet and Smokey’ and ‘Daring Doubt’.
"applejack's day off" is one of the few episodes that has made me physically cower with cringe. spike honestly just felt very out of character. he was very stupid for some reason in this episode, as he couldn't even recognize that the timberwolves were fake. he's immature cuz' he's a kid, yes, but he's not a DUMB(BUTT) LIKE--
Don’t you mean spike at your service?
How come all the episodes of the Mane 6 are not on this list consisting about the only bad thing about them is how much they have fun without Spike and treats him like a slave since this show started with none of them showing any kind of sympathy for him? Spike should have either been returned to the Dragon land after being born or stayed back in Canterlot with the Princesses since they could make him feel more useful and more comfortable
Don't forget Twilight who makes Spike feel so left out since she is so selfish not to include him on all the good times with her and her friends? And she's never really understands how Spike feels since she's supposed to be the princess of friendship
What an exaggeration, Spike is ignored for like 3 or 4 episodes, the series has more than 200
Spike is included in the vast majority of events, parties and adventures of the ponies, and even has the occasional solo.
I gave up watching the show at S7 so this is from my memory and YT clips:
-Trade Ya took itself literally and Twilight the Princess of f*ckin Friendship approved it had me in a dilemma for days.
-Yakity Sax was dumb as hell. Everyone in Ponyville is annoyed by the yovidphone because it was loud and played for hours on end. Even if it was well played it would still be annoying. She should have learned to not take criticism deeply instead of her friends calling for an encore of bad tunes at the end.
-A Matter of Principals cemented me not liking Discord. He sabotaged the other subs and goaded Starlight into losing her temper in front of the students just because he was jealous. That Kamehameha was deserved. Why he was offered a teaching position after all that bs is beyond me.
-Twilight never approved of it, I don't know what you're talking about.
-Yakity Sax was indeed horrible in every way.
-Here I will play as devil's advocate, but before, I agree that he had deserved it for a long time and just seeing him take that beating, this episode became one of my favorites.
However, what was the deal that these ponies had with the master of chaos to have a truce and for him to stay away without spreading chaos as he always wanted? That they were his friends. Who fulfilled the deal? Discord and Fluttershy... and no one else. (We could count the time that Celestia invited him to the gala, but it was only to make it more interesting)
Whenever the ponies planned something they avoided including Discord. they never write or call him except when they need his help. That's not a friend if you ask me.
However, although Starlight enslaves a village of ponies and tries to destroy the friendship of the protagonists by traveling through time, she is forgiven (several times) made part of the group and invited to everything, including taking care of the school while they are traveling. If I were discord I would be jealous as hell too. Starlight broke the cycle of hate by inviting him to join.
@@alejandrootero8894
-Twilight literally said her hooves were tied while pony trafficking was in her face, it was until the safari pony was touched by Dash's speech that the deal was off.
-It's because of Discord's pranks that barely anyone includes him. This episode practically played that out. I understand that he's jealous of Starlight getting picked over him since she's done eviler but Starlight didn't do it again and got nicer. He betrayed the Mane 6 for Tirek after seasons of being 'good'. He's consistently been pushy, annoying, and selfish so outside of Pinkie and Fluttershy I don't blame others for keeping him at a distance.
@@L0V3000 I saw the Spanish American version. That's why I got confused.
I just saw the English version and I agree with you, she said that her hooves are tied. However, that was more of an exchange of services for a product, the condition being that Fluttershy stays alone until the dog is trained (which Fluttershy agreed to) she was not going to stay with Fluttershy as a slave....
It's true that discord was a jerk, but Starlight wasn't perfect either.
-Enchanted all of Twi's friends as slave zombies
-she endangered Thorax's hive
-She deliberately missed the meeting with Celestia.
-She changed the cutie marks of the princesses.
It is true that discord betrayed them, but even before that moment, none (expt Flu) had made the slightest effort to get along with him.
@alejandrootero8894
-I never said slave as trafficking can include a work contract. I don't care if Fluttershy consented since Dash wanted to call off the trade and Twilight still took the safari pony's side. Ponies are above the worth of glued fiction and saying otherwise seems inhumane. I wish Twilight added a clause that only services can be traded with services and products with products.
-Like I posted originally I left the show before S7 so I didn't see all the things Starlight did then. Yes I understand only Fluttershy hung out with him but she has the patience for him being pushy and annoying. Because Starlight is more kind and apologetic they can look past her mistakes while Discord always has something up his sleeve and won't hesitate to hold someone's flaws over them. I personally would've had Pinkie and him hang out sometimes since she finds him amusing.
@@L0V3000 Well, not with pinkie, but with Rainbow Dash, discord teamed up for Fluttershy's gift in the christmas special (and it was a very good job)
It's a pity you stopped watching the series, missed some great moments like the one I just mentioned (including other great things Discord did)
As for trade ya, it would look very ugly for the new princess to use her power to cancel an already closed deal, breaking decades of Rainbow Fall´s tradition for the benefit of her closest friends.
No love still for Magical Mystery Cure. The whole Alicorn Princess thing felt beyond forced back then, and it still does now.
Well, that reminded me of "Fame and Misfortune"
In one line:
"Twilight was better before she got wings!"
@@GarciaGamer1000 did a character actually say that
@TheAeroAvatar well, you might have to watch that episode to find out, and listen to all the comments that all the ponies gave to the mane 6
@@GarciaGamer1000 What are your feelings on Magical Mystery Cure?
@@TheAeroAvatar I think it's an improvement that Twilight that she got wings, but I never heard of the mlp Fandom from fans of how they think of it
What about you? I sorta wanna hear it from another person
He shared his opinion! BURN HIM AT THE STAKE!!!
For me, Yakity-sax is the WORST ever made.
@@corgiconsombrerito same
@@corgiconsombrerito agreed
I’m surprised you didn’t mention the worse episode without mentioning the episode “Ponyville Confidential.”
what's wrong with that episode?
@@alejandrootero8894The Rudeness and it having a mean spirited tone.
Hated that episode as a Kid and I still hate it now.
the episode A Bird in the Hoof makes me really frustrated for some reason, it's the only episode I willingly skip besides listening to the song.
Personally for me, I think the worst episode is Daring Doubt because of they turn Fluttershy into an utter idiot and the blatant Ass Pulls regarding Ahuizotl and lets not forget that given the ending, Daring Do's career as a whole is screwed thanks to the poor writing.
If by utter idiot, you mean the most reasonable and perfect for resolving conflicts and reforming villains, I agree with you.
@@alejandrootero8894 I get what the writers were trying to do but it comes off as her being idiotic. Just what the hell, she is way more than that, she is responsible and smart, not stupid.
@@crsproductions2003 I have a hard time remembering which part of that episode gave you the idea that Fluttershy was being stupid.
It's great to see you back Tootsie
Worst episode is 90% of the fanfiction
First time watching your channel, and I'll be honest you have some very points about these episodes, I can see that Seasons 8 & 9 weren't that likable considering the fact that there were a lot of bad changes compared to how they were in older seasons, I also do think that Spike is a bit overheated as I did think he was quite a funny and entertaining character, great video and I just subscribed.
I still think Spike at Your Service is the worst for retconing how good Spike is. He cooks very well in other episodes, but in this one he doesnt know how to cook? He cleans amazingly in other episodes, but in this one hes incompetent? And what the hell is this "dragon code"?
I hadn't thought about that before, but Spike hadn't even lived among dragons. Would he even know what codes that dragons live by? And even if he did he'd been living among ponies his whole life so they would probably be irrelevant to him.
@@58jharrishonestly Spike should have chosen to stay back in the Dragon Land with Ember so that he could learn more about his culture along with trying to be a couple with her
@@trexadvent4726 Yeah that probably would have been the best ending to his character arc. At that point though the show writers seemed to care more about making political statements about diversity than telling good stories.
@@trexadvent4726 Nah, he's a pony at heart, he already made that clear in several episodes (although he briefly forgot when his non-father visited him), he is a citizen of Equestria like anypony, his culture is the culture of Equestria.
Here's my personal picks for Top 5 Worst MLP: FIM Episodes with descriptions as to why I ranked them such:
V. Putting Your Hoof Down AKA Everypony Be A D**K To Fluttershy: The majority of the characters were unbelievably mean spirited to Fluttershy in this episode for no reason then, when she goes to learn assertiveness, Fluttershy goes completely off the rails with how uncharacteristically aggressive she was towards others. This then leads up to her doing the most G-Rated version of an Eric Cartman burn against Pinkie and Rarity that was still hard for me to listen to the cruelty of the words behind it as I thought to myself "What the F**K were these writers thinking!?! How could they do this to my favorite character?" Worst Fluttershy episode ever and nearly made me question if I still liked her, but she at least redeemed herself in realizing she'd gone too far and experienced genuine remorse for her actions (which is more than I can say for certain other characters later on, but we'll get there).
IV. Non-Compete Clause: Nice to see Fluttershy being as popular as she was with the students at the School Of Friendship to the point where she had 15-16 wins as Teacher Of The Month, but that's where any enjoyability ends. AJ and Rainbow being so obnoxiously competitive towards each other when they're supposed to be teaching the students about working as a group to the point where they're putting lives in danger is too much to have to suffer through for a 22 minute episode, but it just keeps going on and on and on and JUST SHUT UP ALREADY!!!
III. A Matter Of Principals: Discord just assumes that he's gonna be put in charge of the School of Friendship in the Mane 6's absence when the Friendship Map summons all of them away despite never being given permission too then proceeds to insult Starlight Glimmer when she's put in charge and make her job a veritable hell. He acts like a jack**s with unfunny pranks that could potentially endanger students until Starlight finally agrees to let him work with her as head of the school, only for the Mane 6 to show up angrily talking about how Discord used the map to send them on a fake mission where they nearly got eaten by giant worms. This including Fluttershy who he "supposedly" "cares the most about" and he has no remorse for doing so.
II. The Ending Of The End 2 Parter: This was not the strongest 2 Parter there could've been, but it's made worse by the fact that the villain of the whole season, Grogar, who was being built up as the ultimate threat was just Discord in disguise the whole time in a twist so mind numbingly braindead that it makes Shyamalan's worst twists look like philosophical deep dives into the human condition. It makes no sense from a story standpoint, was the worst decision the writers could've possibly made, and it retroactively makes the entire season terrible as every bad thing that happened didn't need to if Discord hadn't been an idiot and just done nothing. Not to mention the fact that after nearly destroying all of Equestria and nearly getting all the Mane 6 killed brcause of his stupidity, he gets absolutely no punishment for doing so and even gets to pass down judgement on those who he recruited for the dumb plan anyways. Though I don't agree with a lot of stuff he says, MisAnthro Pony went into better detail about how terrible the Grogar/Discord twist was than I could and they were wholeheartedly in the right with their analysis on the twist's idiocy so go check that out if you want to know my full thoughts on the matter. Ultimately, this was what ruined Discord as a character for me and made me lose any respect I might have had for the Fluttercord ship in general.
I. Father Knows Beast: Oh sweet pony Jesus was this episode bad! Discord may have done some despicable things that he had no remorse for, but Sludge almost makes him look like a freakin saint in comparison... ALMOST! Sludge pretends to be Spike's father, exploiting the trust of a literal child in order to manipulate Spike into giving up his own luxuries for Sludge's own benefit. Then when Twilight expresses concern for Spike, he uncharacteristically lashes out at her, literally breaking the heart of the mare who's practically raised him his whole life, only to find out from a friend that HE was the one who was wrong the whole time. THEN when they confront Sludge, he admits that he lied to him, but tries to excuse his behavior as a "dragon stereotype" with no remorse for his actions and exploiting a child's trust. I didn't even finish watching the episode after that scene, I was just DONE! The episode was painfully predictable, Sludge was the worst... THING that has ever been in an MLP episode, and it's the only one I never bothered to watch all the way through out of the 200+ episode run of the series. People say Chancellor Neighsay was the worst character of Season 8 (or the whole series depending on who you ask), but I say Sludge is still worse. 1. Neighsay was voiced by legendary VA Maurice LaMarche and 2. Yes he was a racist, bigoted jackwagon, but he at least saw the error of his ways come the Season 8 finale and even came to the Mane 6's aid in the Battle for Equestria in The Ending Of The End. Where was Sludge in all of this? Nowhere. He has no redeemable qualities to him whatsoever and was a waste of an episode and character animation.
oh my god. i hate how theres so MANY EPISODES where people are just a dick to fluttershy and the SHOW paints it out that its HER FAULT, aDN THEY DONT ADDRESS THAT THEY WERE IN THE WRONG FOR BEING RUDE! ITS SO ANNOYIING..
@@lemonmeat i literally came here to say this, or like the episode where they have to make a tornado in cloudsdale and the moral is just like "well just dont be scared" as someone who grew up with severe social anxiety (and was a kid watching these episodes)seeing everyone treat it like its just fluttershys fault annoyed me as well as the stuff you mentioned, theyre always so nasty to her lol
she was my favorite *because* of the stuff they were always chastising her for
Worst episode(s)? For me: Dragon Dropped, Yakity Sax, The Matter of Principals, Hard To Say Anything, Princess Spike
Boring episodes: Viva Las Pegasus, Daring Doubt, The Parent Map, Where The Apple Lies, Heartswarming Eve
Worst episode? Easy, yakity sax, what an awful episode that was
agree
We do like Yona, how dare
Yona is love, Yona is life
I literally had to relook up the episode name of this one, but Yakity Sax. S8 Ep18
Pinkie becomes obsessed w/ yak hoen instrument but is terrible at playing. So her friends all tell her to stop & it literally puts her in a depression. Why is this bad? Well because Pinkie is shown to have multiple passions + she literally turn into a whiny child over a new instrument when again l, this is PINKIE PIE. The mare who has multiple friends, passions, & hobbies.
The episode ends with Pinkie getting her yak pipes or whatever they were back.
Too me it's terrible bc it completely goes against her character to act this way.
This is true! I really don't like this episode, was even considering skipping it but decided to watch till the end. What a waste of my time! Firstly, I REALLY like Pinkie, she's the emotional support type of gal and does an awesome job at it! I don't want to see her being depressed for 20 minutes straight because the writers became too lazy in the writing department. She can sing an entire song about making people smile but then she has to make everyone miserable with the Yaxity sax to the point where people cannot do their jobs.. really guys? They really like going against her character, don't they! :/
Plus, she's a master at using multiple instruments, how can she not realize how terrible she sounds when she plays this one, with how talented she is at music and instruments, she should have mastered that damn thing. in less than a week.
toobsie alive
I personally think the worst episodes are:
*"Over a Barrel": Because the solution that the settlers/colonizers and the native buffaloes should SHARE the buffaloes sacred stompingrounds is BS!
*"Amending Fences": because Moon Dancer's reasons to behave the way she does are pure BS. Seriously? ONE friend doesn't show up to your party ONE time and now you don't wanna have friends anymore?? Including the friends that came to your party??
*"The Cutie Re-Mark - Part 2". Starlight wants to destroy reality just because her friend moved away. Seriously? Yes, loosing a friend because they moved away sucks, but that's life! Some friendships don't last forever and it's no ones fault. That's just life, get use to it. That's not a reason to hurt others! It is completely normal to loose friends when you grow up. That's a BS-excuse to ENSLAVE an entire village!
I also agree with "Non-compete Clause", "A Rockhoof and a Hard Place" and "Newbie Dash" as a choice. Poor RD was called the name that her childhood bullies gave her for the entire episode and in the end it's ok, because the other Wonderbolts have dumb nicknames too? What??
Edit: Grammar mistake.
Yes, half of the episodes from the whole MLP FIM show are giving the audiences all kinds of bad moral lessons
As someone with ASD (Autism-Spectrum Disorder) who had a falling out with a long-time friend but didn't let it get to me, I'm actually very offended by "Amending Fences" and how it's story was presented. I will also never understand why so many call it a good episode.
@@SakicFan Holy shit I didn't think of it like that. I thought that the story was presented well with how they introduced Moondancer, someone who was just as reclusive as Twi but to a much worser degree. I'll give a rewatch, since I haven't seen it in about 6 months. I can totally see why you think that, thank you for letting me see it in a little bit of a diff way :)
@@randomhandleRAHWell, you're welcome I guess. I think I should've said "Handled" instead of "Presented".
I totally agree with all of that. I suppose sharing was a good conclusion because the Apples already had a whole farm set up on that land, but it did belong to the buffalo. I don’t know, I think that one was too.. political for kids. They probably wouldn’t get it, but we do, and it’s just awkward
Honestly any episode from season 8 that focused on those boring new school creatures were bad. I just couldn’t connect with them and skip most of them when rewatching. But I love the episode where starlight and sunburst go visit their parents. It’s one of my favorites
Not to sound rude but "conveniently" leaving out the part from Rockhoof and a Hard Place where Twilight was initially against turning Rockhoof into a statue but eventually caved because she saw how frustrated and left out he felt in the modern era because the rest of his peers and colleagues found careers similar to the ones they had in the past just because you personally didn't like the episode is odd. I'm sorry. He wouldn't have been "put out of his misery." Phrasing it like that sounds dramatic 😭😭 It would've been a situation similar to what Discord was in. Not dead, still alive, it be living life permanently on pause. I agree it's not the best episode but it's not the worst either.
Thank you! Im so glad I wasn’t the only bothered by that omission! Twilight wasn’t ‘perfectly fine’! She spent hours arguing with him and even when she relented not only did she ask him to reconsider, she EXPLICITLY said she was *only* doing it because it wasn’t permanent. And he even cut off the part where she asked him to reconsider.
Rewatched the scene right now, and how did I not notice that?? Seems like my brain just erased that part out, or the entire episode tbh..
this
theres probably a couple more out there i didnt like, but the only one i can think of currently (other than every equestria girls movies after rainbow rocks,) dragonshy comes to mind. the whole episode was just all of fluttershys friends treating her like shit for being scared instead of understanding her and being nice to her to help her cope.
as an autistic person i heavily relate to fluttershy because. i mean.. dont even get me started on my ramble about autism rep, intentional or not, in the show. fluttershy is very clearly autistic, at least for me, wether it was intentional or not, and seeing how all her friends treated her in that episode (especially rainbow dash, but the many.. many... MANy.. other times theyre rude to her for no reason in other episodes..) just made me feel awful, having experienced the exact same things as her time and time again countlessly for being autistic and acting exactly like her because of being autistic.
also, just how it just feels super out of character for the mane 6 to be so mean. like, THEY DIDNT EVEN ADDRESS IT AFTERWARDS AT THE END OF THE EPISODE!!! THIS IS THE SHOW ABOUT LEARNING ABOUT HOW FRIENDSHIP WORKS!!! AND IT WAS NEVER ADDRESSED THAT "HEY IF YOUR FRIEND IS SCARED, HELP THEM OVERCOME IT INSTEAD OF BEING A HUGE DICK AND SHAMING THEM AND SINGLING THEM OUT!!"
sorry for that tangent i just really hate that episode
OH! another episode i hated was the episode where starlight and sunburst have to go see their parents, i forgot the title right now but i HATED IT. THEIR PARENTS LITERALLY JUST GUILT TRIP THEM WHEN THEY SHOW THEY WANT SPACE. THE PARENTS WERE GENUINELY BEING ANNOYING AND NOT RESPECTING THEIR KIDS, BUT BOOOOHOOOOO THEYRE YOUR FAMMMMILLLY SO SHAME ON YOU FOR WANTING SPACE. holy shit. the fact they didnt even address the parents behavior when they guilt tripped them. as someone with parents worse than that who use guilt tripping a LOT, IT WAS SO FUKCING ANNOYING AAAAHHHH
okay again sorry for that tangent LOL
Bats. Always bats. Everyone loved it because flutterbat while ignoring that it villainized a MAIN CHARACTER for protecting their livelihood! “Can’t you just give up a few acres for a bay sanctuary-“ NO! No she can’t! It’s been established many times sweet apple acres has razor thin margins. This is like saying every farmer should just allow gophers to run rampant. They’re pest animals and it’s okay to not want them on your property! And it ends with AJ sacrificing part of her farm. Whyyyyyyy!!! If Fluttershy wants a bat sanctuary SHE can build one! Why is it up to AJ to feed pest critters? I hate bats.
That's very true. When I was little though, I absolutely hated it because of the song where the Mane 6 were basically tearing Fluttershy apart. Pissed me the hell off, nowadays I understand why Applejack would not want the bats on her farm but Jesus.
Did you not listen to Fluttershy's argument at all? The fruit bats don't eat the seeds of the apples, they will make AJ's trees grow stronger faster. You can't apply real world logic to Equestrian logic.
Also, vampire fruit bats vs gophers is not a fair comparison. Not even close. There are plenty of critters that farmers love because they control other pests.
Also, also bats are adorable.
@@Black-Swan-007 Do you have any idea how long it takes an apple tree to mature to where they’re producing apples? Additionally the trees would grow at random instead of in proper lines, making them harder to harvest from. I sure as hell CAN apply real world logic to equestrian society when they want to tackle a real world problem like pest control.
@@forestgrump4723 Well, if we are going to apply the logic of the real world, you should listen to the opinion of the expert in zoology. What the strong and hardworking but uneducated farmer can identify as a pest, the forest biologist can identify as an important part of the ecosystem. Ask the Chinese what happened when they tried to get rid of the "plague of birds that ate their crops", it turned out that the birds ate only part of their crops and their main prey was the real pests, the result was a famine that I kill fucking millions of people.
The trees on Applejack's farm never had an orderly distribution for harvesting (in fact, in one episode we see that her farm is quite optimizable).
And in any case, Applejack always had the last word, Fluttershy never demanded anything, in fact, she was able to put aside her iron love for animals in order to help her friend, or have you already forgotten how she became Flutterbat in the first place?
Bats was annoying for me cause I couldn’t understand why they where so quick to try AJ’s ideas when they could’ve helped Fluttershy peacefully help the Vampire Bats Relocate and Flutterbat wouldn’t even have been brought into existence.
over a barrel : (
not a bad episode, episode wise but allegory wise...awful.
Newbie Dash will always be my most disliked episode. They took Dashie's biggest moment and made it into a low tier gag-humor episode with a really poor lesson at the end. It was the one episode that left me feeling crappy after watching it. That one and '28 pranks later' both felt like S1 rehashes but in turbo mode.
When I first watched it, it left me hating the episode. I even skipped it after rewatching every episode of s1 to s9, it was just awful. I don't plan of rewatching it either, the lesson was SO BAD. Isn't this show called "MLP Friendship Is Magic" why they bullyin poor rd? 🤦♂
@@randomhandleRAH Although I defend most episodes, this one is simply indefensible, it's bad, and I don't even mind the "bullying" part.
I felt kinda the same on the "Newbie dash" when I watched it. It felt like RD worked throughtout all of her life to become a Wonderbolt and to get off that "Rainbow Crash" nickname she got in her childhood... Kinda sad and dissapointing at best
I'd quote the episode "Bats!", it's absolutely NOT a terrible episode, but the treatment of the characters beside AJ and Fluttershy was.
That episode is one of my favourite and a good one because:
1) The song is catchy af (still remember every word😂)
2) Applejack and Fluttershy both show you the two sides of an important argument and both make really good points (Fluttershy talking about the fact that vampire fruitbats will help growing more trees with all the seeds they spit around and offering a real solution for example and AJ making her notice the fact that you don't have the luxury of time when you sell certain products for living and those are in danger), giving you an hard time choosing the one to agree with even if the episodes puts Fluttershy in the "She was right all along" position, something that's usually lacking in kids cartoon that will instead make one side appear just extremely negative and "evil" (I mean, AJ was even fine with letting Fluttershy talk to the vampire fruitbats first).
3) I still find the idea of a vampire pony extremely cool.
What I didn't like, was how the other characters act and how it's never addressed.
1) Rainbow Dash tells most of the times that getting rid of the vampire bats is really important to her, not even AJ, she was enthusiastic about the "hunt" and all 'cause she freaked out about not having apple cider... I'm still waiting for an episode where she talks about her drinking problem, 'cause she clearly needs help.
FUN FACT: here in Italy, they censored any mention and clip where apple cider is directly shown or mentioned, basically taking away the "drinker RD" clip and making it look like she just got up one day and decided to choose violence against animals for fun.
2) Rarity agrees with AJ's point of view but the only constructive criticism she can offer is that the vampire bats sounds dreadful and are ugly and drooling.
They made her sound far too superficial in a context like this.
3) Twilight is there in her "I'm so morally superior"-pose most of the time, telling how she would have loved to find another solution and the only time she makes research is only for the animal-brainwashing spell and she actually search for it because she already knows the spell is there.
Don't know... try a bit harder Twilight? Try to research for real? Maybe that could actually help?
4) Pinkie Pie doesn't even have an opinion, she just follows the group around and even during the song she just smiles like she doesn't even know why she's here, she's a party pony yes, often played the goofy and silly comic part, but is she dumb? No.
I really like your points! Dash having a drinking problem is just hilarious to think about, and my favorite part of this episode was probably the way they showed two sides of an argument that both are fairly important, and coming along with a solution to fix the problem!
EXACTLY! None of the other Mane 6 members had deep, legitimate reasons for siding with Applejack, instead just ganging up on Fluttershy who was left to defend herself all alone instead of having 1... JUST 1 pony side with her to show her ANY kind of support. I was half expecting this to turn into a "Kill The Beast" moment where Fluttershy, like Belle, is the only one to stand up against the angry mob, only for it to mean nothing when she tries to defend the innocent bats. I don't hate the episode, but Rainbow, Rarity, Twilight, and Pinkie's portrayals here REALLY irked me.
Well Pinkie and Rainbow want cider
Twilight wants to put her spell into practice.
Rarity hates ugly creatures like those bats.
And even I sided with Applejack the first time I saw the episode.
I love that the episode puts Fluttershy in a position where she must defend animals even if they aren't "cute and huggable". She's not like those PETA hypocrites
Also, in this episode Twilight ask for the Fruit bats, establishing that they are separated in the west orchard. To which Applejack replies that those are just normal fruit bats, these invaders however are vampire bats.
@@alejandrootero8894 yeah... I already said the exactly same things about Twilight and the others being characterized in a shitty way with no real and justified reason to agree with AJ and that they were reduced only to: thirst for spells, alcoholism and being suddently far more superficial than Rarity used to be.
At least alcoholism is a serious problem, they censored the apple cider in my country and made RD looks like she just wanted to hunt down animals for fun (doesn't help that the italian version of the "Stop the Bats" song changed far too many line from "send them away/they have to go" to "We must kill the bats") and made Pinkie looks like she didn't even have an opinion and was just hanging around like a puppet.
But I agree with you with *everything,* as I already said the episode is one of my favourites especially for AJ and Fluttershy and their points of view.
After all: AJ is realistic and has realistic worrys about the problems that could cause to have all your apple tree sucked dry when what you sell puts food in your family's table, but she still was ok with letting Fluttershy try and talk to the Vampire Bats first, showing that she was rightfully worried and protective of her orchard, but not the: "This character is wrong so they must be unnecessarily evil and aggressive" cliché; and Fluttershy proposed a real solution (the reserve) while many characters like her in cartoons are often made "all talk and no alternatives, 'cause they're already right" and still tried to make her point valid without becoming the "crazy animal lover" trophe.
Those two were the best part of the episode and taught a really good lesson, it's hard to choose with who you should side when both parts are right (AJ needs her orchard and products and Fluttershy simply wants to defend animals and their nature) and simply want different solutions to the same problem.
@@alejandrootero8894 also, thank you for telling me about the details regarding the fruitbats being in a different place and not a threat, differently than the vampire fruitbats, it's been a while since I watched the episode and forgot about that dialogue.
Thank you really much 👍🏻
Incomplete Clause was my least favorite episode.
6:14 🥺 But…I like Yona! I bet a lot of people like Yona!
Worst episode for me is The Last Crusade
YES! That one is in my bottom 5 as well.
I agree about season 8 that is easily the shows worst season. And I don't think season 9 is much better. I rarely watch any episodes from those two seasons these days with the exception of "Sounds of Silence", the only really good episode from those two seasons in my opinion.
Honestly i have no clue what my least favorite is I honestly love all the episodes but there ares ones i like less probably the episode were rarity gets jealous about spike hanging out with gabby because it just comes out of nowhere that she gets jealous even though she never liked him like that throughout the entire series
Great, I envy you.
Where did u get the thorax and pharnx shirt? It's so cool :3
Putting your hoof down has done such damage to MY image of
Fluttershy that everything she did after that episode made me dislike her so much cuz everything she did seemed fake to me and when she showed her assertive side of personality I just see it as her real personality, that she is my least favorite characther in this entire show till today.
I mean wasn't that the whole point? After around 15 minutes in she realizes what she has done and went to lock herself in her house, the assertive side of her personality was there only because finally realized she needs to be a little bit more of it. Her pet bunny bosses her around for god's sake! While out of the main six Fluttershy is my least favorite, I want to at least give her credit for what the writers have done with s4 + because her character was just 100% better. I can get your point though.
That isn’t her real personality, it was just very exaggerated. It was a little too much imo, but she IS very susceptible to being manipulated, or at least she was before she learned how to be assertive in a healthy way
When Fluttershy sets out with a role, she can exaggerate too much without realizing it, we've seen that flaw of hers in many episodes and I find that quite credible and adorable.
I really dislike "Fall Weather Friends" episode, particullary the moment when Rainbow Dash and Applejack started mocking Twilight Sparkle for participating in race. I understand that it is made to in the end teach them a lesson of that physical strenght is not the most importaint thing, yet I couldn't get it how Rainbow and AJ can be so mean to their friend.
Man, are you serious? If you're offended by that you must have very fragile skin (or think Twi has it), they laughed because she's a bookworm. If I see my agoraphobic otaku friend at a party, I would make jokes about it too (and if he later humiliates me with amazing dance steps, I'll eat my words with great pleasure), it's not about being mean, the teasing between friends are most common among groups of people who handle the comrade dynamic and are not autistic.
The episode where Discord was Grogar was disappointing...
I was really looking forward to Grogar as a villain.
Agreed. They also ruined all of Discord’s development for the sake of subverting our expectations
5:34 - 5:43 Aww, that was so cute
Thats strange. I personally liked some of these episodes such as the mare do well one, spike at your service, what about Discord, Applejacks day off, Honest Apple, Non Compete Clause (one of my favourites), a rockhoof and a hard place, but thats ur opinion and ur entitled to it
Im still working on my own retrospective, but I believe season 8 is pretty overhated. It has bad episodes, sure, but I dont think theyre as bad as, say, season 2 or season 7 episodes.
Anyhow, Im glad that none of your worst episodes are Starlight Glimmer focused because shes basically the best character in the series.
S7 episodes have been phenomenal, what do u mean?
@@ninak5645 I dislike the bad episodes in that season more than the bad ones in season 8.
Even if season 7 doesnt have that much bad episodes, I tolerate the bad episode in season 8 better. Its all matters of opinions in the end
Season 2?! bro that's wild
@@LeDerpChris I dislike the bad episodes of season 2 more than the bad ones of season 8. Quality over quantity.
Why aren't there anymore Rap Battles with Regular Show vs MLP?
"No big loss there"😂😂😂 He's right, Yona, more specifically Yaks in general just annoy me every time they are on-screen! The most useless creatures with an ego so high Luna could see it from the moon. All they know is destroying things and does Twilight actually tolerate Yona's bad grammar in school? Seems really unfair on essays.
Over a Barrel for me, only thing enjoyable about that episode was the iconic "Fluttershy tree" scene
2 4 6 greaaat is my personal "worst episode" but tbh everyone will call any episode the "worst" knowing this fandom
why that episode?
@@alejandrootero8894 may just be my personal bias since my favorite pony is rainbow dash, but ive watched that one episode multiple times n i still feel like she was rly out of character the entire episode. she was just very mean and selfish for no reason even tho she is meant to be the element of loyalty. i could go on abt how much i dislike that ep but that is basically the main reason for me:/ (also the multiple "20% cooler" jokes thru out the episode made it feel more like a mockery of the fandom than a nod to it and increasingly got more annoying the more they said it)
@@p1ll0w_53 I agree in part, but I didn't think these little flaws overshadowed the overall episode. Rainbow wasn't bad on purpose, she was just worried because being Wonderbolt was her life's dream, and all she had to do was listen to Fluttershy to calm her down. Although she was disrespectful to Twilight when she tried to teach her her way, but it's because she was so confident that she knew all the answers (typical RD arrogance). The only thing that escapes me is why do you think she was disloyal?
@@alejandrootero8894 idrk but it mainly just felt off especially since all of the cheer team had so much faith in her and so did twilight. if she rly was loyal to her team and to the people that believed in her, she would hav put more effort into training them, even if she didn't understand the importance of the cheer team. idk tho, everyone can hav their own opinion that's just how i felt while watching the episode
@@p1ll0w_53 LOL. I confused the title with Testing Testing 1, 2, 3. You're right, the episode you speak of does present Rainbow as unloyal to a certain extent.
I don't really like that episode, but I don't hate it either.
My least favorite episode is possibly mystery mare do well. Don’t do my girl Rainbow like that
Ikr. She gets so much hate in the fandom ;-;
You had some very good opinions! I just don't think the Rockhoof one was that bad...its actual similar to Troubleshoes aka the one episode the crusaders stumbled across the most wanted "criminal" in Appleloosa (sorry i cant spell in advance) Anyways, they both felt the feeling of being useless in society, BUT they were actually funny accidentally! Trouble balancing on the beach ball shenanigans, rockhoof massaging Bulk biceps too hard (LMAO) you get the idea
The worst episode in my opinion was probably either The Last problem aka last episode or the whole spikes "father" the one you mentioned oorrrrr....Winter Wrap up 1 season...or one of the Hearths warming eve episodes with Starlight being a knock off grinch HAHA funny but not a good episode
actually, the starlight one isn't her being a "knock off" grinch, It's actually a real christmas story which I believe It's called "A christmas carol" or something like that, which is about some old guy called Scrooge who doesn't like christmas and gets visited by 3 ghosts that represent the past, present and future. Quite similar to the grinch, but the scrooge one was published around the 1840's, so If anything, the grinch could've taken inspo from it. And what's wrong with Winter wrap up? I thought It was liked among the community
I like all of g4 so I I'm not complainting theirs no bad or boring eps g4 is all great to me like the other mlp gens and me liking barbie as well also zepher breeze him and rd are both funny and annoying
yea