The Great Indian Rope Trick: The Actual Secret Revealed!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ม.ค. 2023
- In this video, I am going to look at the Great Indian Rope Trick - touted as the greatest illusion ever. You will learn its fascinating history, and the actual truth behind this trick and learn why this was just a big hoax.
#palebluethoughts #indianropetrick #magic
***********************************
Channel Info
TH-cam - / palebluethoughts
Facebook - palebluethoughts.fb
Instagram - pale_blue_thoughts
Twitter- @PaleBlueTweet
Email:thepalebluethoughts@gmail.com
Thumbnail Design by Krunal Solanki
**If you want thumbnails and translations please reach out to Krunal on krunalsolanki12304@gmail.com
*************************************
Sources & Credits:
1) Wiki - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_...
2) Unravelling the Indian Rope Trick ( Nature) - www.nature.com/articles/383212a0
3) Sceptic’s Dictionary - skepdic.com/indianrope.html
4) Lamont, Peter. (2005). The Rise of the Indian Rope Trick: How a Spectacular Hoax Became History. Abacus
5) Lieut. F.W. Holmes, V.C., M.M. (April 1919). "The Great Indian Rope-Trick. Photographed for the first time". The Strand Magazine. Vol. 57
6) Bertram, Charles (1911). A Magician in Many Lands. George Routledge & Sons.
7) Elliot, Robert Henry (1934). The Myth of the Mystical East. Wm. Blackwood & Sons
8) Huddleton’s article in Nature: www.nature.com/articles/102487a0
9) Life magazine article: books.google.co.uk/books?id=k...
Gopinath Muthukad’s performance - • Magician Muthukad - Th...
*************************************
• All images and video depicted in the video belong to the original websites. I claim no copyrights on them.
• Video developed using Wondershare Filmora 12
• Video thumbnail designed using Canva
*************************************
~-~~-~~~-~~-~
Please watch: "Were the Australians Disrespectful to the World Cup Trophy? | Pale Blue Thoughts"
• Did The Australians Di...
~-~~-~~~-~~-~ - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
The rope is an empty tube, the basket is placed on the top cover of a 4' empty hole. The assistant hidden underneath opens the bottom cover of the basket and sticks a rod inside the empty rope. The rod is like the (photo) selfie rod which can be shortened or extended (by twisted & locked the cross sections). Audiences are not allowed to examine the spot where the basket is put on.
When the title says "Revealed", I thought you'd be showing how the trick is performed, not explaining that it is a hoax which I assume most people are aware of.
@V - 😁 That’s not entirely true. I have mentioned how some magicians do it towards the end. I didn’t stress on it because it is unprofessional to reveal the secrets that magicians use to ply their trade. Magic is a cool art and knowing the trick makes the show uncool. Also from the other comments it is clear that most people did not know it was a hoax.
That means, believes are independent of reality... whether something is existing or not, but still we can believe in it....
Nice job... thanks & please go ahead....
💯! Thanks @Shanoj P. Hameed. Same goes with ghosts and god.
Very interesting. Thank You. Did not Queen Victoria offer a large sum of money for the secret of the Rope Trick?
@robertsansone1680 - I am not sure about that. couldnt find anything online about it. I think you are new to this channel. if so, please do subscribe and watch the other videos on the channel. I am sure you will find them interesting too ! Thanks for commenting ! ❤️
@@PaleBlueThoughts You have stimulated my curiosity. I have found the book where I read about the Rope Trick & Queen Victorias interest in it. The book is, Conquest By Man by Paul Herrmann, Copyright 1954, Harper & Brothers. On page 309 he basically repeats the Ibn Batuta claim. He then writes, "Queen Victoria is known to have offered L2,000 for the secret of this trick. The sum was later increased to L10,000; but it still lies in the vaults of the Bank of England, no one having come forward to claim it". Thank You again. I hope that my meager input has been of some help.
@robertsansone1680 - Thank you for that piece of info.❤️ I never got to know about it as it still lies in the vault of BOE 😉😜 Very helpful. Thanks 👍
Very good statement. I am a rofessional Magician.
The closest thing to this I have seen is a magician climbing the rope and then going inside some sort of box that is attached to the roof and then he came from behind the audience it was an amazing experience I knew the trick but I enjoyed it that's all that matters but people literally creating fake myths and stories is so wrong it puts a shadow on the real trick that the magician has done.
@KUNUxGaming - Yes. It does take the charm away from that wonderful art called magic 😬 Thanks mate ❤️
@@PaleBlueThoughts make exposing video on bageswar dham , it is becoming serious problem
@@chadWOLFbyNIGHT oh i didn't knew this incident, may you give me details
@@chadWOLFbyNIGHT thankyou, for telling me about incident
@@chadWOLFbyNIGHT except vikas divyakirti sir , majority teacher in upsc TH-cam community like avadh ojha also support illogical things
I have a version of the trick on early black and white 16 mm film around 1930s that I got from a relative my in a box and had transferred to VHS . It shows all of the trick but the boy disappears in the basket when he climbs down at the end .
Conclusion: Everything is science there is nothing like magic.
@KOUSHIkKUMAR GHOSH - Magic exists. It’s an art which often uses science. But there is nothing supernatural or mystical powers to magic. It’s all tricks ! Carefully done to amaze people. 😁
@@PaleBlueThoughts Yeah, here the magic I stated was actually superstition and misconceptions 🙃
Hahaha then you are 💯on the dot ! 👍🏼
అన్ని ఇద్రజాల విద్యలు వినొదంకొరకె నిజాలుకావు అదరికి తెలుసు
I have a question.Why someone become liberal,or conservative?what r the social reason,or factors behind it?which subject deal with this? could u Pls reply ,or make video on it.
@Please - I don’t think this comes under the purview of science does it ? I don’t generally deal with socioeconomic issues as my expertise lies elsewhere. I think this falls under sociology.
@@PaleBlueThoughts what about political science, and psychological? Does it have anything to do with it.
@Please - I don’t think the word science can be applied to something like Politics, economics etc. I really don’t know why we have subjects like “political science” in our schools. Do they follow the scientific method ? Yeah maybe at the start but as we go deeper it enters into another realm where universality and falsifiability ( two main pillars of science) crumbles. I am a person of science so if I don’t know about something, I would say I don’t know. Politics, psychology and economics are not my forte. I am really sorry that I am not able to give you what you seek. 😖
👍🔥
Thanks a lot @freedos ❤️❤️
Anand, "walking on the water surface" is another trick, that apostles of many religions claimed to have performed, probably to "prove" their supernatural powers in front of the potential followers who spread it later.
Good to analyse it scientifically and debunk this, explaining "how far" this can be true, and its (im)possibilities. Thanks.
make exposing video on bageswar dham , it is becoming serious problem
❤❤❤
Thank you Naveen നവീൻ ❤️❤️❤️
Hey Anand!
Just love your channel✨
Would also like you to do videos on
1) Meditation
2) Yoga
3) Veganism
The first two are topics that the Baba brigade boasts a lot as there genuinely seems to be some evidence of them.
The third topic is close to my heart as according to me as we should move on and enlarge our moral circle.
We should do away with animal killing as we did away with evil practices of slavery etc..
Also non-vegetarianism is one of the biggest cause of climate change.
Also in some video would like you to tell why some ayurvedic products actually work like ayurvedic soaps, toothpastes, balms, some pain relieving oils work.
Even though ayurveda as a whole is a pseudouscience but that products actually work...
Hello @Shyam Agrawal - Really glad that you love the channel. With regards to the video suggestions , I consider the first two doesn’t live up to the claims that people make about it. I have done a small video on Yoga ( headstands) where I have talked a bit about why it is not a very good exercise regime.
I am sorry but I don’t agree with the third suggestion 😀 There are plenty of evidence against it so maybe one day I shall do a video on it.
On the Ayurvedic external treatments. All the evidence that we have are anecdotal with no evidence for systemic reactions. Massaging with oils etc will give a temporary relief for a few hours and a lot of it is due to placebo. You should read the list of diseases that Charaka and Susrutha have claimed to cure using these oils. It’s hilarious.
But keep watching !
👍👍👍👍💯💯💯💯
Thanks a lot @Manoj Rambler ❤️❤️❤️
All smoke and mirrors 🤣
Complete smoke screen 😜
No trick revealed, just made us fool and sheer wastage of time
@deep_vashishta - The trick of that trick is that there is no trick ! 😂
I bet you have not witnessed real magic
Nobody has ever witnessed real magic, there is no such thing as magic, only sleight of hand and deception for entertainment.
اقول ليتك طاقع