Jin stoled Jimin’s jams I liked this era too, but these outfits 😭😭 I feel like they could be great if there was a small adjustment, like maybe a darker color jeans or something like that
They look so healthy in this live stage. I'm disappointed that people called them fat when, in reality, they are healthy and eating the right amount of foods
I'm pretty sure joy is more healthy nowadays and seulgi and irene. They all gained weight in this era and it wasn't necessarily healthy (probably due to stress) even wendy was yoyo dieting during this era (up until psycho too). The next comeback with all members will hopefully be their healthiest.
@@daheadbusta1553 yeah, I just like seeing the girls at a normal weight rather than a sickly skinny weight like the Asian beauty standards say they should be
Right. I was just thinking how most ppl seem to pretend this era never happened , prob bc of their "controversial" weight gain. Its depressing ...because they just like normal young women who arent starving themselves
Why do people judge people for weight? They are dancing perfectly, have a problem if they can’t dance because of it, that isnt the case. Stan RV, stan talent. They are so much smaller in Zimzalabim era, I feel so bad for them. Love all of them so much, one of the most talented groups
Tbh at the start of their debut they were so healthy and then they started loosing weight specially joy and because of the strict diet joy once collapsed on stage. Red velvet are beautiful girls with talented with beautiful voices it’s really annoying how people get criticized and disrespected for their weight. It’s not the the outside that matters it’s the inside they are all beautiful from the inside and out💗
K EVERYONE KEEPS TALKING ABOUT THE STOCKINGS BUT NO ONE CAN FUCKING SEE WHAT JOY'S FACE LOOKS LIKE AT THE END OF HER RAP???!!?!!?! DAYUM SHE WAS SICK MY POOR BABY
My Poor Joy. She looked like she was about to pass out. It's weird to see someone who is always bright and moodmaker of the group wasn' t not herself today. Get some rest Red Velvet babies.
Tbh wendy and joy weren't even overweight. I really think it's the awful outfits that make their legs look bigger. Even seulgi and irene look a little thicker in those outfits and they're the skinniest here.
lol yes wendy and joy are like below average in weight during dumb dumb era but this comment implies that they seem overweight which they seriously don’t sry if i sound hateful to you bc you have good intentions with ur comment but that is no where near overweight plus their thighs are all muscle you can see they’re rock hard when both of them dance they never move. but yes i agree these outfits suck.
September yes but this comment is almost in a way agreeing with those comments by taking into account their words and saying things like “even” and “bigger”
They're on television so they appear "bigger" than in person. Almost all Korean idols are extremely thin it's kind of unhealthy but it's the way the entertainment industry handles it.
I'm sorry but WHY YERI ISN'T IN PURPLE, JOY ISN'T IN GREEN AND WENDY ISN'T ALL IN BLUE? That was all that bothered me in the past, because when i started learning them, I learned their colors first, BUT THIS... made me confused
@@strawberene3724 watch this th-cam.com/video/hFMQ2kmnfKY/w-d-xo.html All of them are wearing their colors....Irene wears pink and red, ande she wears red in this performance. It's the same thing with seulgi with yellow and orange
Victor Martinez I thought those two colors are analogous colors. Those colors those colors provide more contrast. It’s supposed look rich and beautiful. But lowkey it’s okay.
2:24 that girl wearin blue shirt(joy i think?)looks like she was about to pass out...poor girl. Actually all of them looks so freakin tired...Im a YG stan and i feel really bad for sm artists.smh.
During the pre-recording, the jeans caused her leg to get caught(tho I'm not sure exactly how sorry), which made her almost trip during the last chorus >///< That's what I read haha
i love this, they look so comfortable here. the outfits are stylish and cute, while also being comfortable enough to dance in! and their vocals are amazing too. i wish more kpop was like this now instead of the fake/ plastic type of stage performances. :/
I don't know why everyone says Joy is the only one who has thick legs cause so does Wendy but not in the body shaming kinda way cause I think it's really good they are promoting their healthy body . I think Red velvet in general are look healthy , I might be wrong they might be stick skinny in real life but it makes me like them more and they look prettier(my opinion)
since the comeback I've been thinking how good Joy's body is looking and then we get these losers saying she doesn't look good........ if she loses weight/confidence over this I'll kill someone, her body is perfect right now!!!!!!
+Julia N in whose vision is she chubby? asian's beauty pattern is such nonsense..... she looks so skinny wth, even if she was chubby tho it doesn't mean she's ugly.... Joy looks amazing people are too mean imposing their nonsense in other's body >:c
baruka Its not my vision that she's chubby. I'm referring to the netizens who say that. When those in Korea actually meet her, they say she's really skinny.
People calling Wendy fat or chubby makes me really upset because that’s my current body type and that makes me even more sad and upset about my body. To me she looks very healthy in this.
Same here. I have naturally thicc legs, like many people in my family. Honestly, they all looked great and healthy in this era if you ask me. What isn't healthy is people bodyshaming them to be skinnier while they looked fine to begin with. And then when they become skinny, people complain some more. The internet is unforgiving and it is very upsetting when people make comments like that. I'd say as long as you're making healthy choices, fuck the beauty standard. The people complaining behind their screens aren't all models either. Like Hwasa said: if I don't fit into this society's beauty standard, I'll have to make my own.
Wendy is beautiful in this body type and the same goes for you! We live in a judgmental world. But I bet you look as nice as Wendy does. ^~^ And yes this body type does look healthy. :D
Stop calling Joy fat She’s a woman.. she has hips he has chest and everything she’s an actual hour glass. 1 reason y I hate the “beauty” requirements in most part of asia
The fact that they were called fat, even though they were for once normal weight here. I bet they had lots of energy in this era. They shouldnt habe listened to the haters, they looked amazing
I feel like Joy and Wendy have a good weight on right now, in camera they probably look chubbier than they are so they must have a healthy weight. It's so good to finally see Idols on stage that are not super skinny which means they weight much lower than they should. I hope no hate or the company pressures them into losing weight if they are healthy. Hopefully soon they will rest too, all of them. Even though this concept and comeback is amazing, the choreography and the activities have been exhausting for the girls. I hope they all are in good health. RED VELVET FIGHTING!
+Ana María Castro thats cause during the pre recording, her leg got caught because of the ripped jeans and tripped during the part before the last chorus. according to fanaccounts.
Irene is a truly "Cabbage" ~ Seulgi looked so shine with the yellow ^^ My baby bear 😆 Wendy and Joy was switching their color's t-shirt. That really didn't feel right :( Yeri is adorable as always 🤘🏻
if u haven't watch all their performances, their doing mismatch. they put 3 concepts into one. if u can see shirt and stocking are different. and the pants (please dont buy them, not worth being a trend) different
Mya Jones no, you're talking about colour representations. you were wrong its not a mix matched concept because they still have thier original colours. :
난 저때 의상 개성있고 이쁘다고 생각했는데 다들 별로라고 하네. 춤추기도 편해보이고 덤덤이라는 곡과 잘 맞는 느낌의 의상임. 약간 삐삐의 정형화되지 않고 자유스러운 느낌을 잘 살렸다고 생각함. 그리고 하의를 과하게 입혔지만 상의와 헤어 메이크업은 무난하게 해서 너무 괴상하지 않을 만큼 적정선을 지켜줘서 딱 예쁨.
I can’t believe people were calling all of them “Fat” “Ugly” and other rude stuff like no They Looked extremely healthy and BEAUTIFUL ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Cravity : break all the rules Redvelvet : dumb dumb Alessia cara : scars to your beautiful IKON : killing me Blackpink : playing with fire Treasure : Mmm Straykids : Miroh Twice : Fancy Gfriend : mago CLC : hobgoblin Gidle : hwaa King and queen are slays
They are prettier as ever but the stylist should have thought twice about this outfit..this is giving haters a chance to criticize...I totally defend my girls
IS IT ONLY ME THAT ACTUALLY GETS AMAZED AT YERI GETTING SO GOOD OMG SHE SLAYS ME WITH THOSE MOVES. IF YOU FOCUS ON HER YOU CAN SEE HOW POWERFUL WITH HER MOVES SHE IS.
+Kyungsoo Is Watching You haha okey then,I was in love with them since I saw the MV *-* I was thinking about cosplaying it for the next con in my country :"33 but with the white t-shirt and stuff
![Red Velvet 2X FASTER - Dumb Dumb + Russian Roulette & Peek-A-Boo [WEEKLY IDOL]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9V_s_vQGTm8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet 2X FASTER - Dumb Dumb + Russian Roulette & Peek-A-Boo [WEEKLY IDOL]](/img/tr.png)
![[CLC - Black Dress] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 180222 EP.559](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fo6x-Nk4L54/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet - Dumb Dumb [2015 KBS Song Festival / 2016.01.23]](/img/n.gif)
지금쯤이면 옷을 이해할때가 됐다 생각해서 들어왔는데 섣부른 생각이었다 5년후에 와야지..
+5년후에 다시 올게요..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@루피-m7z 3시간전이라니... 와윶
전10년후 ㅜ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
나는 방탄이들을 위해존재하는 아미 5시간 전이라니 .. 와우
They called this Wendy’s chubby era, when I called this the cutest and most comfortable era.
Jin stoled Jimin’s jams I liked this era too, but these outfits 😭😭 I feel like they could be great if there was a small adjustment, like maybe a darker color jeans or something like that
TheGraceCraig
this song isn’t a dark song- what do you want-
jiminie lepabo i never said dark, I said darker.
TheGraceCraig ok 👋
@@jiminielepabo2878 you just proved of how stupid you are. Learn to read dumbass.
They look so healthy in this live stage. I'm disappointed that people called them fat when, in reality, they are healthy and eating the right amount of foods
I'm pretty sure joy is more healthy nowadays and seulgi and irene. They all gained weight in this era and it wasn't necessarily healthy (probably due to stress) even wendy was yoyo dieting during this era (up until psycho too). The next comeback with all members will hopefully be their healthiest.
@@daheadbusta1553 yeah, I just like seeing the girls at a normal weight rather than a sickly skinny weight like the Asian beauty standards say they should be
ikr . even the one who called them ‘ fat ‘ definitely just a potato who gained weight 85kg lol
Right. I was just thinking how most ppl seem to pretend this era never happened , prob bc of their "controversial" weight gain. Its depressing ...because they just like normal young women who arent starving themselves
저때가 레벨 인기 한창 많을때라서 저 청바지 유행할까봐 사람들 걱정하던거 개 웃겼는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
세상에서 가장 쓸데없는걱정ㅋㄱㄱ
조동아리 뭔소리야 젊은애들은 레벨 덤덤 모르는애들 없엇음..
조동아리 저기욬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ저때 덤덤 모르는 사람 없었음;;;;;; 그리고 '오덕들이나' 라닠ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 레드벨벳 좋아한다고 일반인이랑 다른 사람이 됨? 하찮아짐? 왜 덕질하는 사람들을 하찮다는 듯이 얘기함?? 님은 뭘 얼마나 잘났길랭...^^?
근데 저같은 머글은 5년뒤에나 첨보는걸요ㅜ.
조동아리 이 때 덤덤 모르면 그냥 아싸 할배 아닌지ㅠ 이때 이 노래 거의 모든 축제에서 봐가지고 덤덤 음방 한번도 안봤었던 나도 노래들으면 대충 춤 따라 출 수 있을 정도 였음ㅠ 오히려 집밖안나오는 오덕들이나 못들어봤겠지 적어도 바깥공기 한번은 마셔본 사람은 들어봤을듯
2016: no
2017: no
2018: no
2019: no
2020: *Hey you must look at this amazing video!!!*
same -_-
Unrelated but where tf does the fan come from
????
Same
그건좀
네가 바보 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
전체적으로 살이 빠진 것도 맞는데 코디가 좀 더 부하게 만든 경향도 없잖아 있음. 특히 막내라인은 젖살이 빠진것도 있고.. 여튼 이 때도 다들 말랐었음
2배로 더 쪄보이게만드는 마법의 코디임.,.
마른건 아닌데?
저게 마른 게 아니라고? ㅋㅋ 🤦♀️
잠만보 마른거
@@카페라떼-d3b 방구석에서 여자 연예인들만 보지 말고 밖에 좀 나가봐 ㅋㅋ
There is a hardcore Joy fan girl in the crowd somewhere
+taeyeon saved music Your username 👌🏻
I like your picture 😏 Junior for life
Aren't we all hardcore Joy fans?
Velvet Yoongi True
Yeah that person who screams JOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOY
5 minutes before on air
Stylist: "Sorry, Wendy, Joy, I can't find the matching stocking" (sad face)
Wendy: "O...............kay"
Joy: "...."
It's a mix and match concept it was done on purpose
Mya Jones I know I know. It's humour, if you haven't known it :)
+Rangga Alam Purnama It looks like wendy is wearing joy's lmao
wait don't forget Irene haha
+RAEZOR omg ur comment made my day😂😂😂👍👍👍
웬디 조이 색은 또 왜 반대로 입힌 거야,,, 당최 이해할 수 없는,,,
초록색 스타킹을 못 구한거 아님? 티색깔은 빨주노초파 인데 스타킹은 빨주노파보임
심지어 예리는 보라색인데 갑자기 주황색...
알고보니 그냥 살색 스타킹 사다가 마카로 칠했는데 옷색이랑 달라서 걍 입혔다는 정설
@@폼폼이700년전 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그냥 노래제목값한거아님?
살을 많이 뺀것도 뺀건데..코디가 저렇게 입혀두니 당연히 살쪄보이고 부해보이지..
대체 왜 디테일 하나도없는 파워레인져옷을 입힌거야 아니 디자인이라도 이쁘면 몰라.. 진짜 코디가 안티 ㅠㅠ
스타킹같은 것만 안신었어도 예뻤을거임..
ㄹㅇ 아이린한테 갑질당해서 저렇게 입혔나ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그때 당시에 굉장히 충격이었는데 다시보니 여전히 충격적이군
저거 정말 레드벨벳이라서 저정도지 아마 듣보 그룹이 저거 입었으면 욕 오지게 먹었을 듯
? 욕하는게 이상하지 .. 그냥 레벨 입었을때처럼 당황스러울꺼같은데 ㅋㅋㅋ
Why do people judge people for weight? They are dancing perfectly, have a problem if they can’t dance because of it, that isnt the case. Stan RV, stan talent. They are so much smaller in Zimzalabim era, I feel so bad for them. Love all of them so much, one of the most talented groups
They are healthy
They are healthy
@@ellaandthecats6460 girl what- you do realize almost all kpop idols are put on starvation diets
What weight?
Tbh at the start of their debut they were so healthy and then they started loosing weight specially joy and because of the strict diet joy once collapsed on stage. Red velvet are beautiful girls with talented with beautiful voices it’s really annoying how people get criticized and disrespected for their weight. It’s not the the outside that matters it’s the inside they are all beautiful from the inside and out💗
Wendy and Joy's thighs are my aesthetic
Yesssss someone gets meeee
yeeessss!!!! ^-^
+Elle Gormley lol, I was about to comment that! It's like toned and full! it's not stick like xp
+Elle Gormley not to sound hungry (no pun intended), but it's like a perfect drumstick
Elle Gormley same
Girl in green has crazy good vocals!!
That's Wendy😍
That's Yeri 😍
Cheese Doggy12 ???
Cheese Doggy12 that’s Wendy 😂
@@kowsar570 oops sorry you're right 😅
와 춤 겁나 힘들겠다 동작은 단순해도 엄청 크게크게 힘줘서 해야되는게 많네.. 이걸 웃으면서 추면서 노래도 하고 대단하다..
I really hope that SM isn't making Joy go on diet because of those articles. She looks like she's going to pass out here. Please be healthy D:
Llamachords Do you think SM cruel?
Emperor Palpatine A lot of companies make their groups go on extreme diets for comebacks so yeah.
+Emperor Palpatine yes they are
+Llamachords You should see them this comeback, Joy has lost her mind xD especially on weekly idol and V app
truuu
K EVERYONE KEEPS TALKING ABOUT THE STOCKINGS BUT NO ONE CAN FUCKING SEE WHAT JOY'S FACE LOOKS LIKE AT THE END OF HER RAP???!!?!!?! DAYUM SHE WAS SICK MY POOR BABY
Jungkookismyhusband andsoistaehyung now that you mention it she does :((
She does
Molly Burgess this was like 3 years ago but okay
릴리카나이 I was replying to Molly not the original comment, idiot.
@@bumblebeepillowpet don't call others an idiot without knowing them
My Poor Joy. She looked like she was about to pass out. It's weird to see someone who is always bright and moodmaker of the group wasn' t not herself today. Get some rest Red Velvet babies.
Joy isn't the mood maker, although I would have thought she was at first because of her name.
1:23 Irene really loves this part 🤣👏👏
Shrimpster24 lmao ikr😂😂
They are enjoying and happy
I mean their like kids having fun its fun to see them like that
옛날에 코디 진짜 이상하다고 생각했는데 지금보니까 진짜 이상함
레벨이니까 소화했다
왜 난 유니크해서 좋은데
지금봐도 이상해
you Asians are boring. In the West we love VR
왜 이상하다 함? 난 재미있고 색다른 발상이여서 좋은데 와.. 이상하다고 한 사람 진짜 그 사람이 더 이상함!
의상 진짜 지금봐도 충격적이다
무슨 크레용팝도아니고..
지금 짐살라빔 의상보다 낫다...
스타킹엌ㅋ
@@멈뭄미미 ㄴㄴ.. 나도 ㄱㅊ다 생각했지만 완전 마른 애들인데 저 스타킹때매 다리가 뚱뚱해보임...
@@user-yeahyeah 그래서 좋은거임
오히려 평범하거나 밋밋한것보다 튀는게 낫다고 생각함 일반 길 걸어다닐때 입을때 이런옷입을것도아니고 무대인데 의상으로라도 튀어서 기억에 남는게 낫을듯 그리고 무대니까
저 스타킹은 왜 신기게했을까
마른 애들인데 다리가 겁나 두꺼워보여
저땐 두꺼웠을걸요 지금 엄청 노력해서 저거의 반이 된거고(안티아닙니다)
sat빅 아닌데요;ㅎㅎ저때쯤에 실제로 봤었는데 진짜 말랐었어요 이러니까 연예인들이 없던 살도 빼려하지요^^
@@킬링타임나를위한 ㅇㅎ 알겠줌다
킬링타임나를위한 물론 저때도 말랐겠는데 솔직히 살 많이 뺀건 맞잖아요
@@sat6593 저때 두꺼웠는지 어떻게 아냐!! 바보, 너는 딱봐도 나라도둑놈 이명박이처럼 밥도둑인 송어회뜨는영상이나 봐라!
저 노래를 저만큼 흥하게 만든 것도 대단하고 저 춤에 라이브를 한 것도 대단하고 저 높은 노래를 삑사리 안낸것도 대단하고,,, 그냥 레벨 사랑해ㅠㅠ
Tbh wendy and joy weren't even overweight. I really think it's the awful outfits that make their legs look bigger. Even seulgi and irene look a little thicker in those outfits and they're the skinniest here.
lol yes wendy and joy are like below average in weight during dumb dumb era but this comment implies that they seem overweight which they seriously don’t sry if i sound hateful to you bc you have good intentions with ur comment but that is no where near overweight plus their thighs are all muscle you can see they’re rock hard when both of them dance they never move. but yes i agree these outfits suck.
lucy a ton of people in the comments were talking about how they're "too fat" and that's what they were referring to
September yes but this comment is almost in a way agreeing with those comments by taking into account their words and saying things like “even” and “bigger”
Agree the outfits is suck
Anyway who approved the pants lmao
이거 보니까 지금의 조이랑 웬디가 살을 얼마나 뺐는지 알거같다..
(전 그냥 살을 많이 뺐다고 했을뿐인데 왜 제 댓글에서 싸우세요....)
저때도 전혀 통통하다는 생각 안들고 건강미뿜뿜 겁나 좋은데ㅠㅠ
지금이 좋죠... 아무래도 티비에 나와야되는데 티비는 원래보다 더 뚱뚱해보여서 어쩔수가없음..
@@차이-x9o 살을 찌워도 뚱뚱하다고 욕먹고 살을 빼도 너무 말라보이니깐 먹으라고 하는 연예계에서 뭘 어쩔 수 있을까요 ㅜㅜㅜ
지금 많이 마른 건 맞지만 객관적으로는 뺀 게 훨씬 잘한듯...
지금은 솔직히 너어어어무 심각사게 말랐음 특히 슬기 .....
I love how their all not super skinny like other girl groups! Joy has an amazing body!
truu
yes fat Korean....but skinny in American
+미아영 보 she's not skinny in America...
They're on television so they appear "bigger" than in person. Almost all Korean idols are extremely thin it's kind of unhealthy but it's the way the entertainment industry handles it.
sonya well from looks she wouldn't be as fat here in Korea than in America 👌 most Americans aren't that thin but okay
I love their legs
Yah that not good
yes thighs on point
their thighs are so yummy uwu 💓💝💕💞💓💝💖💗💕💘💞💓💘💘💕💝💓💗
They seem to be quite healthy.
Taehyung's Giggle agreed
I'm sorry but WHY YERI ISN'T IN PURPLE, JOY ISN'T IN GREEN AND WENDY ISN'T ALL IN BLUE? That was all that bothered me in the past, because when i started learning them, I learned their colors first, BUT THIS... made me confused
And irene isnt in pink*
Chile there just outfits
@@strawberene3724 her color is red and pink
@@callingyuqiland that's their official colors tho....
@@strawberene3724 watch this
th-cam.com/video/hFMQ2kmnfKY/w-d-xo.html
All of them are wearing their colors....Irene wears pink and red, ande she wears red in this performance. It's the same thing with seulgi with yellow and orange
i’ve never been more annoyed about the fact that green shirt is wearing a bLUE legging bUT NOT A GREEN ONE HHHHHHHH
That’s the thing. Wendy always gets the worst clothes.
But if you look to the red shirt is wearing a pink legging not a red one
@@jessf4994 yeah but it's not the same. Red and pink really look-alike so that's fine
And joy is wearing a purple one , when they gave the blue one to wendy
Victor Martinez I thought those two colors are analogous colors. Those colors those colors provide more contrast. It’s supposed look rich and beautiful. But lowkey it’s okay.
2:24 that girl wearin blue shirt(joy i think?)looks like she was about to pass out...poor girl. Actually all of them looks so freakin tired...Im a YG stan and i feel really bad for sm artists.smh.
CLaire Qwheein Dance and sing is her work ;)
Loli ?
Loli wdym
Loli yes everyone need work hard but not like slaves,joy was sick and her leg was injured
Sorry for asking but what does smh stand for? Shake my head or so much hate?
에휴 아이돌은 참 피곤하겠다... 마른 건데도 불구하고 통통하다 소리 듣고 표정 좀만 안 좋아보여도 피곤해보인다 기운 없어보인다 소리 들어서 항상 밝게 웃어야되고
이대승 등신
@Erin Cha 욕함 한국 탓 하지말고 살좀빼라 좀
내엉덩이탄탄쓰 ㅋ
내엉덩이탄탄쓰 왜 유튜브엔 열등감에 찌는 애들이 많은가.. ㅠ 니 거울 보고 놀란 살 안 빼도 ㄱㅊ으니까 남한테 뭐라고 하지 마
@@차이-x9o 살은 빼야지 뚱뚱한건 죄악이다 건강애도 안좋고~ 살 빼라 비계덩어리야
이거보면 애들 전부 다 살 오지게 뺀 게 보여... 지금 거의 절반임
슬기는 진짜 원래부터 몸매가 너무 예쁨.슬기는 솔직히 그대로인듯.
특히 웬디
님들좀 제발 빼샘
김치볶음밥 님은 빠지셈
@@barcode6283 라임ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
i love how everytime joy sings someone causually gets murdered in the crowd
요즘은 명품으로 치장하는게 유행이 되버린듯... 물론 협찬이겠지만. 예전처럼 저렴하거나 기본템으로도 그룹의 색을 낸게 더 좋은것같음 ㅎ 아이돌을 보고 영향을 받는게 10-20대이니만큼 너무 어린나이부터 명품에 눈을 떠버린것같음 ㅜㅜ
Joy looks so tired
It's true
hope my baby is okay :(
right man
Yau Mok she had a cold and her leg was injured. Poor baby :(
Also Wendy😫
Is Joy seriously okay? :(
+GFriend Part is it? I thought she stumbled bcs she feel dizzy or sick. when are they Gonna stop with that ripped jeans aigoo. >
During the pre-recording, the jeans caused her leg to get caught(tho I'm not sure exactly how sorry), which made her almost trip during the last chorus >///<
That's what I read haha
+GFriend Part can you tell me where the fan account is or something so I can rread it
GFriend Part aww okie then xD
Abby Stermer blue
Seulgi is forever yellow HAHHAA
CHEESEburger!
Irene is forever pink and red
cheeseburger is seulgi's lifeee lolol
cus pringles are her favourite
taebugi it suits her very well
레벨노래 다 어려워보이는데 진심 이 노래 개빡세보임ㅋㅋ 춤도 어렵고 템포도 빠른데 노래도 계속 힘주면서 지르듯이 불러야됨 지금봐도 진짜 애들 고생함ㅠㅠ
i love this, they look so comfortable here. the outfits are stylish and cute, while also being comfortable enough to dance in! and their vocals are amazing too. i wish more kpop was like this now instead of the fake/ plastic type of stage performances. :/
Oh jooooy oh jooooy ❤️😭
k k she's just 12/10
Louyd Louyd more like infinity
I don't know why everyone says Joy is the only one who has thick legs cause so does Wendy but not in the body shaming kinda way cause I think it's really good they are promoting their healthy body . I think Red velvet in general are look healthy , I might be wrong they might be stick skinny in real life but it makes me like them more and they look prettier(my opinion)
Roseanne L Not anymore, they're kinda stick thin now
but wendy put her weight back on and joy looks great! the rest were naturally thin. but i think sm overworked them way too much this 2018
Unfortunately I think they got a lot of backlash over their weight in this performance :c and they all lots a crapton of weight afterwards
since the comeback I've been thinking how good Joy's body is looking and then we get these losers saying she doesn't look good........ if she loses weight/confidence over this I'll kill someone, her body is perfect right now!!!!!!
yup even i m not thier fan when i was watching mc live i just lover body 😢
+Nada Nadoi her*
It's just in videos that she seems chubby, fans who see her in real life say she's really skinny so yeaah
+Julia N in whose vision is she chubby? asian's beauty pattern is such nonsense..... she looks so skinny wth, even if she was chubby tho it doesn't mean she's ugly.... Joy looks amazing people are too mean imposing their nonsense in other's body >:c
baruka Its not my vision that she's chubby. I'm referring to the netizens who say that. When those in Korea actually meet her, they say she's really skinny.
i don't think yall understand i'm truly obsessed with these outfits
Me too 😭
I'm obsessed too
I can’t believe this song was made 4 years ago feels like it was yesterday
People calling Wendy fat or chubby makes me really upset because that’s my current body type and that makes me even more sad and upset about my body. To me she looks very healthy in this.
I’m so sorry :(( people are mean, I think this body type is super beautiful!!
Same here. I have naturally thicc legs, like many people in my family. Honestly, they all looked great and healthy in this era if you ask me. What isn't healthy is people bodyshaming them to be skinnier while they looked fine to begin with. And then when they become skinny, people complain some more.
The internet is unforgiving and it is very upsetting when people make comments like that. I'd say as long as you're making healthy choices, fuck the beauty standard. The people complaining behind their screens aren't all models either.
Like Hwasa said: if I don't fit into this society's beauty standard, I'll have to make my own.
Wendy is beautiful in this body type and the same goes for you! We live in a judgmental world. But I bet you look as nice as Wendy does. ^~^
And yes this body type does look healthy. :D
Stop calling Joy fat She’s a woman.. she has hips he has chest and everything she’s an actual hour glass. 1 reason y I hate the “beauty” requirements in most part of asia
um who's calling her fat? cause they must be crazy
She’s a rectangle
@@heartless3633 that shape dosnt exist lmao
@@JaskHuma in this comeback knetz bullied her because she was "fat"
@@Luna-re3gn oh ok
2020
Anybody
If you are coment who is the cutest member in this era
Joy
Joy and Wendy fitted the styling on this stage the best, idk who owned the era as a whole though.
Joy
Wendyy
WENDY!!!!
Irene's hair was so beautiful and Yeri's braids were so cute 🥹
The fact that they were called fat, even though they were for once normal weight here. I bet they had lots of energy in this era. They shouldnt habe listened to the haters, they looked amazing
Is it just me or are they all looking tired, lost and out of energy? Especially Joy! Seriously I'm worried about these girls!!
+Sugamasta You're right! I immediately noticed in this performance that they are lacking energy, probably tired from all the promotions
Philip Dempster hope they will be okay!
+Sugamasta Same! Sm better be treating them well lol
Maybe because of We got married.
Their promotion are going to finish soon so don't worry
아니 무슨 영어 댓글밖에 없어
The way Joy and Wendy look healthy and stunning here and people still felt the need to comment on their weight...
I said "this is red velvet healthiest era"
Yeah at least their not dangerously skinny
I've never seen Joy and Wendy's body look so beautiful 😍😍😍😍
I feel like Joy and Wendy have a good weight on right now, in camera they probably look chubbier than they are so they must have a healthy weight. It's so good to finally see Idols on stage that are not super skinny which means they weight much lower than they should. I hope no hate or the company pressures them into losing weight if they are healthy.
Hopefully soon they will rest too, all of them. Even though this concept and comeback is amazing, the choreography and the activities have been exhausting for the girls. I hope they all are in good health. RED VELVET FIGHTING!
Man I wished that happened. Wendy got so skinny at one point 😭 I just want idols to be healthy too.
내가 레벨에 처음 관심 가지게 된 곡.곡 너무 재밌고 좋아. 예리가 너무 이뻤음.와 근데 다시봐도 절대 라이브를 할 수 없는 안무다...
Red velvet : There is one Impostor among us
Giana G. PERIODT
One of the best song of RV
I feel like this dance routine is heavily underrated. More people should be talking about it imo
Its me or all of them look a little bit off? specially Joy, she looks like is about to pass out at 2:24 :/
Our Poor Joy
Hi girls and boys
+Ana María Castro thats cause during the pre recording, her leg got caught because of the ripped jeans and tripped during the part before the last chorus. according to fanaccounts.
Joy is the one in purple right?? Yeah she looks sick kinda...
Cinthia Arguelles YOUR COMMENT IS 2 YEARS LATE HAHA
Can anyone see? I wear glasses i can BARLEY see the whole performance even on 720p😭😂😭
SAME OMG
I think it's the lights from the stage it makes it too distracting
I wear glasses and I relate..
Irene is a truly "Cabbage" ~
Seulgi looked so shine with the yellow ^^ My baby bear 😆
Wendy and Joy was switching their color's t-shirt. That really didn't feel right :(
Yeri is adorable as always 🤘🏻
レドベルって昔から今も体型変わってる人いないと思ってた！
今と比べたらこの頃は少しぽっちゃり気味なのかもだけど全然可愛いよな〜！
たくさん努力したのがわかるから今もめちゃくちゃ綺麗だけど！
나만 예뻐...보여....? 단색 면티에 구멍뚫린 연청 안에 원색 스타킹 한쪽만 신긴거,,,, 졸라 유니크하고 멋진서 같은데,,,,,
Wow...
김이별 나만 그렇게 생각한게 아니여서ㅓ ㅠㅠ
덤덤 연청의 시대가 열리길 기원하겠음,,,,^^
ㅇㅈ 내 최애 레벨 코디임
취향존중합니다..특이한만큼 호불호가 엄청 갈리네요;
they look like a bowl of fruit loops but I ain't mad that's my cereal
FATHER LOUIS WILLIAMS SUGA ADAMS THE lll lmao 😂
Seulgis and Irene's dance moves are always on point
Wendy looked so much happier before the antis made her lose weight:(
Back when SM actually allowed their artists to sing instead of lipsync 😌
멤버 구별은 잘 되서 좋은데 파워레인저 같애
are they can't get green stocking for wendy? or maybe change her shirt to be blue? her outfit look awkward for me 😑
if u haven't watch all their performances, their doing mismatch. they put 3 concepts into one. if u can see shirt and stocking are different. and the pants (please dont buy them, not worth being a trend) different
+kiki sangpemimpi Because their concept is being "AWKWARD" And their costumes are effective :D
And because wendy's color is blue
Kiki They don't give anything right to wendy...😭😭
Jhopefirsthixtapemademyday but yeri is purple and joy is green but thry don't have those colors on
They looking like the girl version of the wiggles!! And I love it. Red Velvet Fighting!!
Forever disturbed by the "wrong" colors... :/
No they are doing a mix matched concept rn
+Jenny Nguyen
Their colours are shown on their wristbands
+Mya Jones their colours are still shown via thier wristbands
I know that obviously, we're talking about the tights...not the wristbands
Mya Jones no, you're talking about colour representations.
you were wrong its not a mix matched concept because they still have thier original colours. :
For haters :
This is the best era and they look is so cute💞
I just can't understand with why does they have to look like a FREAKING STICK to look beautiful, can't they just be HEALTHY??
Fadhilah R.P.N preach 😔✊
Everyone is talking about Wendy, Joy, and healthy thighs. I agree with all that...but SEULGI IS SHININGGGGG
Wendy is literally so cute and beautiful this era (slaying every era)
난 저때 의상 개성있고 이쁘다고 생각했는데 다들 별로라고 하네. 춤추기도 편해보이고 덤덤이라는 곡과 잘 맞는 느낌의 의상임. 약간 삐삐의 정형화되지 않고 자유스러운 느낌을 잘 살렸다고 생각함. 그리고 하의를 과하게 입혔지만 상의와 헤어 메이크업은 무난하게 해서 너무 괴상하지 않을 만큼 적정선을 지켜줘서 딱 예쁨.
この頃のレドベルと比べると今すごく痩せてるよね
a k わかりみが深いです😂イェリムは特にこの頃と比べて今は痩せて可愛くなってますよね！努力が伝ってきます、、🥺🥺
썸넬보고 놀라서 들어왔다.... 맨날 뮤비만 봐서 의상 이런줄 몰랐어... 레벨이라 저정도지 와우 아니 왜 저 스타킹을... 나도 5년 뒤에 와야지...
I can’t believe people were calling all of them “Fat” “Ugly” and other rude stuff like no They Looked extremely healthy and BEAUTIFUL ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
옷 나만 괜찮나 귀엽고 노래랑 잘 어울리는데..
ㄱㅊ은데 말랐는데 뚱뚱해보이게 하자나
저 스타킹만 안입혔어도 훨 나았을듯..
신기합니다. 마치 아이폰11pro같이 뇌이징 되고있어요. 저 스타킹이 없었다면 심심했을거같습니다..
스타킹ㅋㅋㅋㅋ졸라기여운데 안입었우면 심심했을듯
진짜 컨셉에 맞는 디자인이라고 생각했는데 사람들 반응 진짜 당황스러워ㅠㅠ
am i the only one who love their outfits? they slay omg and seulgi😍
yea you are the only one
no one:
youtube: lemme recommend this vid after literally 5 years to u peeps
Wendy looks beautiful... And I just miss her...
The amount of weight they lost is crazy... They weren’t even overweight
この時からしたら今みんな凄い痩せててすごい努力したんだなってほんと改めて思う。
この時からするとほんとに痩せたな…
8년전 노래인데 지금 들어도 노래가 정말 좋네요. 신나요.
저때 생방으로 봤을때도 알록달록한 스타킹이 너무 시강이라 멤버들 얼굴에 집중 못했는데 지금 봐도 똑같은 생각만 듦ㅋㅋㅋ 어쩌다가 저걸 입힐 생각을 했을까...🙃
There's an impostor among us
Hi~ My name is Yeri!
HAH
저 옷 당시에는 충격이었는데 지금보니깐 진짜 노래랑 잘 맞음 코디 괜찮은듯
근데 왜 전 아직 충격이져........
지금도 충격적인데,,,
지금도 별로..
지금도 별로임
아 님들 님들이 충격이든 말든 하나도 안궁금함.. 댓글 달지마세요... 나는 그냥 괜찮아보인다고 한건데,,
Cravity : break all the rules
Redvelvet : dumb dumb
Alessia cara : scars to your beautiful
IKON : killing me
Blackpink : playing with fire
Treasure : Mmm
Straykids : Miroh
Twice : Fancy
Gfriend : mago
CLC : hobgoblin
Gidle : hwaa
King and queen are slays
근데 덤덤 때 코디 ㄹㅇ이뻤는데... 솔직히 난 이것도 유니크하고 나쁘지않았다고봄. 무대의상이 평소에 입는 그런 무난한 옷들이면 무대의상이라 안하지. 뭐 호불호갈릴 스타일이긴하지만 다른음방들보면 덤덤때 코디 ㄹㅇ이뻤음ㅠㅜㅠ
Everyone talking about the outfits...
I'm not even a stan but WHY ISN'T ANYONE TALKING ABOUT THE LIVE VOCALS
They are prettier as ever but the stylist should have thought twice about this outfit..this is giving haters a chance to criticize...I totally defend my girls
IS IT ONLY ME THAT ACTUALLY GETS AMAZED AT YERI GETTING SO GOOD OMG SHE SLAYS ME WITH THOSE MOVES. IF YOU FOCUS ON HER YOU CAN SEE HOW POWERFUL WITH HER MOVES SHE IS.
I'm the only one who freaking loves these jeans? .-.
+Kyungsoo Is Watching You haha okey then,I was in love with them since I saw the MV *-* I was thinking about cosplaying it for the next con in my country :"33 but with the white t-shirt and stuff
+nsunnygirl I'm a fan of those jeans. I tend to stare at their thighs when they wear those jeans for some reason...
2023년에도 들으시는 분 있으신가요? 이 노래는 언제 들어도 신나네요 ㅎㅎ
joy and wendy being best friends for 3 minutes and 21 seconds