Having spent decades in the wind and solar fields and having made dozens of windmills mostly hawt my gut feel tells me that this bubble probably is 700 times more efficient than solar, as long as you don't use a solar panel bigger that 5mm x 5mm and the solar panel has to be in the shade. Rob I see you only pointed the hair dryer at one side of the bubble. A bit of an unfair test if you ask me.
Yeah, I was gonna say: what a waste of time presenting what should be an "omnidirectional" rotor and testing it with only 2 directions of airflow, not even opposite to eachother (blowing on horizontally opposite edges of the device for example). Even better would be to stop the rotation after every direction test, before trying the next direction.
@@rejiequimiguing3739 No. I am very much an engineer with a flare for looking at reality and real numbers. Like Rob, I have seen the bs going to around and the reality as well. Been on this planet for over 6 decades, travelled the world, spent millions on technology of all kinds. I figure I would know by now what is bs and what is not.
- It appears in Rob's model that there is little to no "directionality" in the "circumferential" ducts.... (could be an optical illusion hut the entry and exit appear balanced... - At the end of the day - IF there is little energy available, little will be captured. (Dynamic to static pressure conversion is probably the best use of "steady state turbulence" in the urban environment... For real random "turbulent streams (non steady state) flutter devices may be useful in micro applications - with no prospect for solar power.)..
Hi Robert I have seen your video regarding desalination lately. Where you said that reserchers found out that, when boiled, saltier water tends to go lower and fresh water rises. Well the thought i did have... when you take a 7 meter hose fill it with water an rise it. With the upper end closed, upwards so that vacuum holds the water up. In the top most part of the hose the water is boiling in ambient temperature due to the pressure differential. I wonder if the salt would settle down wards ... if that works a clamp could be used to seperate the water. I mean that would be a version using a lot less energy
I had this idea of wind turbine which would reduce its surface area with high speeds and essentially close itself when the wind speed is high. Now why would you want to do this. First, it will protect the generator from burning when the wind speed occasionally goes up. And second, the generator can be smaller so there would be less resistance to spin when the wind speed is low (as it usually is in built areas). The Harmony wind turbine does the fancy folding thing, but I was thinking something more robust. Perhaps a centrifugal mechanism that will make the wings travel on top of each other. Like savonius, which would turn into a barrel in high wind.
Hi Robert I wanted to see what would be the best way to send a video clip of a machine I built and if you'd be interested in giving me your opinion thanks
Hey Robert, Thanks for all your great videos. If I was to try and make a twisted serpent coil as in video 1869, what thickness copper wire would you suggest and approximately how long a roll is needed? I want to make one of your turbine/generator combos and was after a starting idea on other materials. Many thanks
Excellent! ... But it needs more development and linking up to a motor to generate electricity to see how efficient it really is in the real world over time in different locations ...
I would love to see a larger scale version made on a figur sheet metal forming machine. Fitted with one of your wind turbine cvt gear boxes and serpentine coil generators.
Comparing the power out put of a solar panel and the O-Wind would be quite difficult and they operate using totally different methods. A solar panel uses light operating on when light illuminates the panel. The O-Wind operates using wind. Operating only when moving atmosphere (breeze, wind, gale, vehicular traffic, a ship at see). So, how does one determine which of the two methods is most efficient? It could be 700% more efficient because the method/s used to makes those comparisons have not been published.
Maybe a new, salient measure would be *cost* efficiency. Cost over power produced over time. This too, however, would depend on the place where they are being implemented (e.g. low-wind sunshine vs dim and windy)
Hi Robert,
I'd like to give it a try but your 3D model doesn't seem to be on Thingiverse anymore. Is it available somewhere else?
Closing off the vents create buckets not only for wind but also for raindrops, it will spin in the rain.
Having spent decades in the wind and solar fields and having made dozens of windmills mostly hawt my gut feel tells me that this bubble probably is 700 times more efficient than solar, as long as you don't use a solar panel bigger that 5mm x 5mm and the solar panel has to be in the shade. Rob I see you only pointed the hair dryer at one side of the bubble. A bit of an unfair test if you ask me.
Yeah, I was gonna say: what a waste of time presenting what should be an "omnidirectional" rotor and testing it with only 2 directions of airflow, not even opposite to eachother (blowing on horizontally opposite edges of the device for example). Even better would be to stop the rotation after every direction test, before trying the next direction.
Are you a salesman
@@rejiequimiguing3739 No. I am very much an engineer with a flare for looking at reality and real numbers. Like Rob, I have seen the bs going to around and the reality as well. Been on this planet for over 6 decades, travelled the world, spent millions on technology of all kinds. I figure I would know by now what is bs and what is not.
Robert,
hows about we build one of these with tubicals and a toridal propellor with tubicals
regards
David
- It appears in Rob's model that there is little to no "directionality" in the "circumferential" ducts....
(could be an optical illusion hut the entry and exit appear balanced...
- At the end of the day - IF there is little energy available, little will be captured.
(Dynamic to static pressure conversion is probably the best use of "steady state turbulence" in the urban environment... For real random "turbulent streams (non steady state) flutter devices may be useful in micro applications - with no prospect for solar power.)..
I made the model and it only works with a narrow stream of air tangentially directed. Normal, wide based wind, resulted in no movement at all!
His "testing" with the hair dryer seems a bit biased for placing the "wind" in just the right location.
Hi,
Where did you find the model? It disappeared from Thingiverse?
@@marcdevriendt8419 do you have it now？
@@xiekeyun unfortunately not...
Hi Robert I have seen your video regarding desalination lately. Where you said that reserchers found out that, when boiled, saltier water tends to go lower and fresh water rises. Well the thought i did have... when you take a 7 meter hose fill it with water an rise it. With the upper end closed, upwards so that vacuum holds the water up. In the top most part of the hose the water is boiling in ambient temperature due to the pressure differential. I wonder if the salt would settle down wards ... if that works a clamp could be used to seperate the water. I mean that would be a version using a lot less energy
I had this idea of wind turbine which would reduce its surface area with high speeds and essentially close itself when the wind speed is high. Now why would you want to do this. First, it will protect the generator from burning when the wind speed occasionally goes up. And second, the generator can be smaller so there would be less resistance to spin when the wind speed is low (as it usually is in built areas). The Harmony wind turbine does the fancy folding thing, but I was thinking something more robust. Perhaps a centrifugal mechanism that will make the wings travel on top of each other. Like savonius, which would turn into a barrel in high wind.
Is it possible to get the file for 3d printing
Hi Robert I wanted to see what would be the best way to send a video clip of a machine I built and if you'd be interested in giving me your opinion thanks
A whirlly bird roof vent would work way better
Conditioning the wind before it enters any turbine usually works (such as the Darwin turbine or turbines with ducts or flat surfaces all around them).
@@Jon-fs2zj got numbers to back it up?
Hey Robert, Thanks for all your great videos. If I was to try and make a twisted serpent coil as in video 1869, what thickness copper wire would you suggest and approximately how long a roll is needed? I want to make one of your turbine/generator combos and was after a starting idea on other materials. Many thanks
Same question!
Excellent! ... But it needs more development and linking up to a motor to generate electricity to see how efficient it really is in the real world over time in different locations ...
I printed that turbine and it don't turn a bit with a blower on it. I got the files from thing verse from your page.
I wonder how it would perform as a fan blade connected to Seebeck generator/Stirling engine on a wood stove?
Will not generate too much wind power. However, it may manage to generate money through crowd and grant funding. In RMS case click funding.
Great! Would love to hear you discuss our debunk the neutrino voltaic company and concept I saw a friend share recently neutrino-science site
I would love to see a larger scale version made on a figur sheet metal forming machine. Fitted with one of your wind turbine cvt gear boxes and serpentine coil generators.
I imagine that with the same amount of wind that it captures less force.
can you post the file you used to make that 3d print? would be curious to see others test it and also try it out myself. TY
It looks cool, would it be better if you hung it upside-down as there's probably more air moving straight up compared to straight down?
Comparing the power out put of a solar panel and the O-Wind would be quite difficult and they operate using totally different methods. A solar panel uses light operating on when light illuminates the panel. The O-Wind operates using wind. Operating only when moving atmosphere (breeze, wind, gale, vehicular traffic, a ship at see). So, how does one determine which of the two methods is most efficient? It could be 700% more efficient because the method/s used to makes those comparisons have not been published.
Maybe a new, salient measure would be *cost* efficiency. Cost over power produced over time. This too, however, would depend on the place where they are being implemented (e.g. low-wind sunshine vs dim and windy)
Use both? I am.
An elegant object, but how does its mass affect efficiency, instinctively it looks comparatively negative?
Is the updated model available? Searching all the usual places and nowhere to be found.
Places likely best used in, Darwin wind turbines
Hi , will need your professional advice on wind turbine , how should i contact u?
How does it act in different flows of water fully or partially submerged? If at all
was fascinated with this concept, instead of generator, could it be used as anemometer?
Hi Robert, any chance of sharing thew tinkercad files or the STL files??
Isn't this patented?
It's not being sold @@marcfruchtman9473
Google : Sci Tech Daily Scientists Develop New Dirt-Powered Fuel Cell That Runs Forever
Excellent video
Were you forced to take down the STL files on Thingiverse?
Same question?😢
Hello sir can you please provide the diagram pdf I want to make a diy project for college plz sir
Would you please give a link to your Tinkercad file?
The best wind generator is the Wing Generator, by MS James Mccanney 🤘🏿👹
Where could we find a video on that 😅
@@CraigLandsberg-lk1ep Google wing generator by james mccanney
@@CraigLandsberg-lk1ep or jmccwing
Sir Please share 3d model file in the link
Still a very poor test. You aimed the air at one side and avoided the other side.
Sure looked that way to me as well...
I saw ur old video u r positive about it and again ur where negative about it and again ur positive about it now.
First
Is it possible to get a 3d model somewhere?