His voice is so warm and tender. You can hear the hurt in his voice and his eyes tearing up knowing he will never see her again. Brilliant acting. He wants to stay and she wants him to stay. Her tears in the end show him she loved him too.......
What I love about this comment section is that there are comments in nearly every possible language, showing that this film touches people around the world. The power of love ❤️
True love... Not even a kiss, just the depth of the soul... So differenf from what we are served nowadays... So pure and beautiful... I wish i had a man like him...
Бесподобный красивый фильм .Просто влюбленным не суждено быть вместе ! Печально очень ! Несколько раз посмотрела этот фильм хочется смотреть ещё и ещё ! Актёры сумели исполнять свои роли от души ! Просто Молодцы !
Brilhante atuação dos atores franceses. Pouco diálogo, mas conseguiram passar através da interpretação e dos olhares, todo sentimento e complexidade daquele momento histórico. O Ator é lindo demais! A atriz deu um show de interpretação.
Quel film magnifique. Que je viens de découvrir. Le vrai amour. La profondeur de l'âme et la connexion à travers la musique. Merci à lucifmello. Trop triste, la fin ...
Cái kết đúng ra không phải dừng ở đó mà còn dài và hay hơn nữa...cô gái Pháp có con với anh sĩ quan Đức và khi quân đồng minh Anh và Mỹ đổ bộ cứu nước Pháp ...một người lính Mỹ đã bắn chết anh lính Đức và cô gái vì mang thai với người Đức ...thời đó rất khắc nghiệt với phụ nữ có giao tình với lính Đức sẽ bị cạo đầu bôi vôi rêu rao khắp phố...nên cô ấy chấp nhận lấy người lính Mỹ và theo chồng về New york sống và có thêm một con gái nữa với anh lính Mỹ. Sau này cô ấy sống rất hạnh phúc sau khi đã hóa giải những hiểu lầm với chồng ❤
Great director, genius; great script writer, supremely masterful at their crafts. Amazing sound and music score. Did you hear the waves lulling and crashing while they said goodbye to each other by the car?
Nếu theo tiểu thuyết gốc ...Đừng bao giờ xa em... thì hay và xót xa hơn nữa...nguời Sĩ quan Đức đóng chiếm ở ngôi nhà cô gái Pháp mấy tháng đợi quân đồng minh cập bờ biển để đánh trả ...trong thời gian đó hai người yêu nhau và thường xuyên gặp nhau khi đêm về trên tòa tháp tại căn phòng nơi bà nội của cô gái ở khi xưa ...và rồi cô gái có thai ngay lúc viên sĩ quan đi ra trận...yêu trong đau khổ tuyệt vọng lắm...ngày quân đồng minh Anh và Mỹ đổ bộ vô bờ biển nước Pháp cô gái cứu được người lính Anh và chính người lính Anh đó bắn chết người sĩ quan Đức khi hiểu lầm là quân địch ...Sau cô gái lấy người lính Mỹ và sinh được đứa con trai của người lính Đức đó sau đám cưới ..anh ấy đem cô ấy qua Mỹ sống và cô ấy mỗi lần về Pháp lại ra nghĩa trang giá đình nơi chôn người lính Đức thăm mộ chàng...sau này đứa con trai cũng thích học tiếng Đức và tham quan nước Đức ...trong quá trình đó hôn nhân của cô ấy cũng gặp nhiều sóng gió... sau cùng tất cả được hóa giải hiểu lầm hạnh phúc viên Mãn bởi vì người chồng Mỹ rất yêu và hiểu cô ấy...❤
Una simple y gran pelicula.Llena de profundos sentimientos.Con silencios expresivos,pocas palabras,que dicen mucho.Cada vez que la veo,me emociono como la primera vez!!.-
Какой сюжет! Прекрасные исполнители , прекрасный дуэт! Фильм отличный, смотрю часто, как будто любимая книга - история вечного добра, надежды...Спасибо создателям фильма и автору этой истории!
She saved his life,she cried when he had to go.She loved him and he loved her.So beautiful and sad.May be they found each other again after the war and lived HEA.This is the way I want to hope the story ended.
Mon film favori, trés émouvant on ne s'en lasse pas. Le regard peut parfois en dire beaucoup mais pas asseé. Merci à la personne qui à mis en ligne ce film. Merci beaucoup.
I saw this film few years back but still I come every now and then to feel their purity, their depth, their values,why this happens? But definitely makes life beautiful n yes enriched.
I Agree with the lady after me. No Need for physical intimacy. One has to go much deeper than that. The Stares , the expressions. The Gentle movements. Says it all. Much better than sex. It goes way beyond. What did he say about the Sea ? Such beautiful Poetry. And so True about who She Was. The Best Movie I've ever seen. Thought the Thorn birds were really good. But than I saw this. Don't forget, this was War time. I think this happened much more than we Realize. Thank you for this Awesome movie. Makes me Cry every time.
This longing we get when we are in love, is the LOVE frequency. Romantic love is only one of many ways to tapping into this LOVE frequency. Even though the love frequency is everywhere, right with us, yet we have forgotten how to tap into it. There are also other ways to tap into it, like prayer, meditation, service to others, mindfulness, all require conscious diligence to practice (ask anyone who maintains a spiritual practice). Romantic love is one experience most everyone will have a chance to have in the course of one's life, it is effortless for most. That is why we only recognize it a romantic, not the universal frequency that is. We need to rediscover what LOVE really is....
Yeah the 3 main actors are amazing. I just wish I could understand them. lol However, their eyes and facial expressions are amazing and lets you know what is going on without words and they are so talented.
He is definitely one handsome actor playing his role to perfection, especially through his eyes. She also did the same. Hard to watch because you want them to touch, which I know iis impossible, still you want them to get together someday.
assisti ao filme por um mero acaso na tv... e fiquei estupefacta. mesmo não existindo qualquer declaração de amor verbal chega-se ao fim e é exactamente igual a se tal tivesse ocorrido! que explendida historia! sem palavras... o filme está muito bem conseguido e os actores sao muito, muito bons! adorei tudo!
Ma mère a été tondue en 1944 en public par une bande de "résistants "de la dernière heure.Elle avait 17 ans. Sa faute : avoir été jolie et serveuse dans l'hotel où les officiers allemands prenaient leurs repas.Le meneur des tondeurs était un amoureux éconduit.Elle m'a raconté cette histoire en 1994 et elle s'est mise à sangloter comme si ça s'était passé la veille.C'est pourquoi ce film me touche autant.
Beaucoup d entre eux étaient amoureuse des officiers allemands je pense mais s interdisant d aimer pour cause de représailles ....C une éprouvant e histoire et vie pour l époque..... .
@katarmor, I am speechless, what a terrible wound your mom has to bear all these years. I was thinking, now Werner is gone, Pascal might prey on Jeanne again. What an interesting contrast, the officer of the occupation shows impeccable code of conduct, a true gentleman, the cousin, Jeanne's own relative, behaves like a thug...
@@vivianedelage2504 How ironic, that the occupying force came to France with guns and tanks, but they also brought love on an individual level, knowing how many love stories have ensued during the four years of the occupation. The world is a brutal but also wondrous place, full of paradoxes, opportunities for souls to be creative, to make the best out of the worst. It really makes one think again about the intentions of the so called Collaborators, even during occupation, some one has to administer to the needs of the population, especially in large cities, towns, to minimize suffering, to maintain order. I think we are poised on massive disclosures of the many truth about the two great wars. Our history has not been honestly written.
C'est le plus beau film que j'ai jamais vu ! Les acteurs excellent chacun dans leur role. C'est à travers le silence que s'est imposée la famille jusqu'a la fin,ou presque, que l'on ressent la force incroyable des sentiments du capitaine allemand comme de la jeune fille ! A vrai dire j'avais peur que le film n'égale pas le livre, mais cette representation cinématographique du chef d'oeuvre de Vercors a dépassé toutes mes attentes ! Merci beaucoup pour ce film ! Il est splendide !
@@vHumboldt77 oui. Il le respecte et il sait que c'est l'amour de vie de sa petite-fille. Il a vu sa belle-fille perdre son amour de vie (son fils) dans la Grande Guerre et maintenant sa petite-fille vivra le même chagrin.
Очень трогательный крутой кино " молчание море" просто суппер .с играли актеры молодцы. какие красивые оригинальные парочки .молодцы абажаю .сколько повторно смотрю атарватся не могу . Ббббббаааааааааууууууууууу бомба !!!!!!
Чудесный фильм! Так хочется увидеть продолжение, но видимо его не будет...((( Такое ощущение, что я сама пережила все чувства героини. Потрясающая была бы пара ... Они были созданы друг для друга, но обстоятельства были против них.
I get the impression he was waiting for her to say more than farewell. I would have told him that someday this war will end and I will find you. Try to stay alive and know that I love you. But that is just me!
Esse filme apesar de ser de guerra é de uma delicadeza, que o olhar podia dizer muitas coisas disso não tinha dúvidas. São dois atores muito bons, faz com que a gente sinta tudo o que eles sentem, sem se falar 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻
What an amazing movie at its best, i love it, so powerful and intense, i love that the author & director didnt think it needed all the sexual nudity and bed scene to make the movie incredible to the audience, this is the best movie I have seen in a long while
Hell the movie had no subtitles and I watched the whole thing riveted and just followed without knowing all that was being said. That's how good it was.
Ce téléfilm est vraiment très beau. J’avais vu le version avec Howard Vernon peut-être plus fidèle au livre de Vercors. Mais je préfère la plus récente avec des acteurs formidables. Comment ne pas craquer sur le beau regard de ces deux êtres déchirés par cette guerre. J’ai pleuré à la fin.
look at her right hand after he leaves! she's nervously moving her fingers just like he did when he was waiting for her at the end of the bridge (the fish scene) когда он уезжает и она остается стоять одна, она нервно двигает пальцами правой руки -- прямо как вернер, когда он ждал ее на мосту (сцена с рыбой). движения идентичные
So beautiful 💞...the ending so sad.....I've watched it 11 times up to now but... It stays in your mind and you must think 🤔 a lot about it, all the metaphors and especially, the ending. True love in these times, the fate of two nations between them, they couldn't manage that...especially she was really patriotic (but he respected it) as the very end shows. But, so tragic😭
But can someone please explain that special kind of sad ending to me?? 🤔 She cries a lot because he is leaving, one word full of love 'Adieu", and then? 😯 She joins actively the resistance and is the happiest person in the world or what?? So, what' s the meaning of the very end? 🤔 Help, please🙏🏻
@@alexandrabrockmeyer3122 Yes. I found the ending strange. Despite her love for Werner, and despite the horrors of the bomb attack on her own family grounds by people she thought were her friends, and could have resulted in her and her grandfather's execution or being sent to a camp, she goes off to join the Resistance. I think the film tried to stay true to the original novel, which was a call to resistance against the German occupier. However, unlike the novel and the 1949 film version, this film veered off into a love story, so that made the ending harder to understand. I suppose they explained that away with Werner's statement that one has to stay loyal to one's duty and commitments.
@@pangorban1 yeah, I already thought about Werner's sentence he explained to stay loyal to one's duties and so on... He gave the answer as to the ending, but did you or someone else notice, that there are red roses 🌹or maybe red cloves on her dress at the very end!? 🤔 I mean, come on that film is ful of metaphors... I'm pretty sure it has a meaning, too
@@alexandrabrockmeyer3122 The lilac flowers in the courtyard showed it to be spring. So she was wearing a pretty floral dress, as opposed to the drab grey colours she wore during winter. It was hard to tell if they were roses or not. The dress didn't appear to be one of Jeanne's mother's hand-me-downs, so perhaps she was finally moving on from the past. So much of the commentary about this film indicates that Jeanne and Werner were destiny's soul mates. But life's not like that. People fall in love, and if it doesn't work out, they move on. Jeanne was too practical a person to pine away for Werner. If he wanted to kill himself by transferring to the Russian Front, that was his business. She had an occupation to overthrow. That was her business.
@@alexandrabrockmeyer3122 When he returned home with his old friends and fellow German officers, they had an argument about Germany vanquished France, therefore they should be proud victors, and they were no longer poets and musicians(Werner was a Classical composer and pianist, one of his friend was a poet, who turned into an ardent National Socialist, whereas Werner seems more of a humanist)," the officer friend went on to say "(to hell with) respect France, they were German officers and should be loyal to their duty and the Fuhrer." Werner turned in exasperation: "Yeah right!" and walk back to the house. When he got inside he walked in the sitting room and wanted to tell the hosts "something serious", about his disillusion of the German Government's policy towards Occupied France, he ended up asking:"what should I do? Maybe you are right (refering to Jeanne), we should honor our duty and commitment." So after the car bomb killed his fellow officers, he might have arranged to have Jeanne and her grandpa interrogated by the SS who would certainly suspect that Jeanne might know about the bomb (and saved Werner), because the Germans are known for being punctual, the fact that Werner did not get in the car while his orderly and the two friend officers were in the car, is itself suspect. I think Werner requested to go to the Russian Front immediately with the intention (my guess here) to not be part of the investigation of the bombing assassination, remember Grandpa read the newspaper about the assassination of the two German officers brought about the reprisal of killing 99 French hostages. Werner was very scared for Jeanne I think (that scene of him walking out of the German command center and saw Jeanne from afar, and the grave look in his face and eyes). He got in the car and looked at her while driving away.
HELLO from Toronto Canada!!!!!!!! We are currently in Lockdown so I've been trying to watch a lot of movies and TV series that I have never had time to watch. I started with Suite Française (2014), then The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (2018) then The Exception (2016) then I found this incredible Foreign film! OMG the best of the best- so much better then anything Hollywood could produce! I fell in love with with Jeanne & Werner- so raw and incredible!!!! At first I was heartbroken with the ending- I wanted more but after watching it again I understood better {I also had to do a little research ;)}. For French women to have a relationship with a German Solider would result in shame - some would have their heads shaved following liberation, as punishment for an on-going relationship with a Nazi soldier during the occupation of France. This relationship between Jeanne & Werner was doomed but at least he left knowing that she loved him and he was loved! Flood of tears!
Hello from Florida. I stumbled upon this movie a couple days ago and I cannot get it out of my head. I must have watched different edits 50 times. Just started reading the (English) comments and got so much clarity. In the very last scene was there a slight smile in acknowledgement of her love?
@@ljones1295 YES - he was happy!!!!!!!!!! The movie ended the way it should have ended {sadly}- I'm sure they reconnected after the war if it was meant to be ;) but he left knowing she loved him and the only reaction she ever gave him was that of love and tears- he smiled- so raw- so good!
@@justmyopinion5099 thanks. I read a comment that he saved her from the SS. I did not pick up on that did you? how/where? I am watching again. Lord help me.
@@ljones1295 Yes he saved her and grandfather from questioning by the SS- after the truck exploded - I watch a version with English subtitles on TH-cam- one by Celina E Torres and another by Eichi. Such a powerful movie given the time!
@@justmyopinion5099 Ok going to check out those channels. That is why the grandfather was softer towards him at the end. Referring to when he invited him into the room when he was leaving. Thanks!
Il sourit car elle lui parle pour la première fois : c'est pour lui l'aveu des sentiments qu'elle ressent pour lui, presque un "je t'aime". He smiles because it's the first time she talks to him.For Werner "adieu" sounds like "je t'aime".
This movie is haunting in that it keeps you wanting more for both of them. It wasn’t possible unless she was willing to become involved with him and that was looked upon as criminal.. Her own people would have turned against her. By the end of the occupation, those women were persecuted without mercy. None of these events occurred in the original story but the message was that you could resist by simply not engaging with the enemy.
Sharyn Carr all of my relatives are German and I know from correspondence that all the men were forced to fight even though they hated Hitler and the Nazi regime. Most died fighting the Russians, some hoped to surrender to the Americans and some survived. War is horrible. It never brings peace, only suffering. This film was beautifully done.
Heidi Grover, I totally agree with you. The German Captain came from a military family and he had no choice but to do his duty. When he realized that the defeated people were not going to be respected and seen as worthy, his disillusionment was overwhelming. He couldn’t leave the military, he would have been tried as a deserter so he volunteered for the Russian front and he would accept whatever fate held for him. Most likely he faced death in combat or a Russian prison camp, if lucky he might survive. He was a better man than he knew, as were many others in Germany who were caught in a difficult situation.
Thank you Sharon Carr for your understanding. Every line the Captain speaks is poignant. He mentions the freezing temps in Russia etc. It’s heartbreaking for those soldiers, their families etc. The totalitarian regimes didn’t care about the people. I won’t say more. Just thanks.
Shayn not everyone could have resisted his manners and his genteel ways. Problem one needs to focus on whether he was doing this deliberately or was he genuine. She learned by hearing the discussion between his friends and him and how he stood up for the French people on not humiliating them. She realized he loved France as much as his country but had to make a commitment to his country which was first.
I remember finding myself attached by verbal communication so for her to detach herself from him she kept "silent" which really protects her from feelings - which became impossible to avoid since he was so magnificent as a vulnerable soul in her home.
Cookiey13 hat Recht! Jeane Pierre Melville hat seine unvergeßliche 1949er Version auf praktischen sowie künstlerischen Gründen sparsam und fast minimalistisch inszipiert und hätte vielleicht auch so ein Prachtwerk wie Boutrons gedreht. Die Überzeugungskraft der Schauspieler ist doch fantastisch! Vive la France 2! Merci You-Tube!
Cuantas cosas puede decir el amor sin una sola palabra, solo gestos, música, miradas. Es como el mar, que en apariencia es solo agua, pero que su profundidad alberga secretos impronunciables, sobrecogedores.
Продолжения не будет, вся суть фильма в том что они оба, каждый остался при своих интересах, он на русский фронт убивать наших, тогда же СССР был или его убьют а она в сопротивление, фильм не сказка где все неппи энд а здесь- реальность
me encanta como se desarrolla un amor tan puro en circunstancias tan adversas, amor puro que no es facil de encontrar. quisiera saber si alguien tiene esta pelicula con subtitulos en español y si es verdad que tiene una segunda parte para verla y apreciar si esta si tiene un final menos trajico pero igualmente romantico.........
It ends in this Farewell. It will remain a love that is pure, restraint and silent. Werner will survive the Russian front and he will be promoted to a higher rank in the military. Jeanne will be the greatest silent love of his life, and same for Jeane.
His voice is so warm and tender. You can hear the hurt in his voice and his eyes tearing up knowing he will never see her again. Brilliant acting. He wants to stay and she wants him to stay. Her tears in the end show him she loved him too.......
Not all German are nazi have humanity
Этот фильм восхищает !! Браво сценаристу, режисеру и великолепной, потрясающей игре актеров. Свою роль они не играют, они ею живут !
What I love about this comment section is that there are comments in nearly every possible language, showing that this film touches people around the world. The power of love ❤️
Mi ha fatto piangere
Film vero
Лучший фильм мира. Жуанне красавец. Сделайте 2 серию. Он должен быть Жив
True love... Not even a kiss, just the depth of the soul... So differenf from what we are served nowadays... So pure and beautiful... I wish i had a man like him...
Pure , deep soulful love story
I wish i had met a man lyke him when i was younger ,i wish i had a love story so beautiful.
I wish there were at least a peck on the cheek bloody hell
@@mingakinsgibayuxds7542 It wouldn't have stopped with that !! 😉
who was she with at the end?
Quel beau film Encore une fois quel bel homme ThomasJouannet
Et quel talent !!!
Бесподобный красивый фильм .Просто влюбленным не суждено быть вместе ! Печально очень ! Несколько раз посмотрела этот фильм хочется смотреть ещё и ещё ! Актёры сумели исполнять свои роли от души ! Просто Молодцы !
Гениальное исполнение актеров когда совсем не нужно лишних слов.Фильм остался во мне, спасибо,до новых встреч.
Brilhante atuação dos atores franceses.
Pouco diálogo, mas conseguiram passar através da interpretação e dos olhares, todo sentimento e complexidade daquele momento histórico.
O Ator é lindo demais!
A atriz deu um show de interpretação.
Quel film magnifique. Que je viens de découvrir. Le vrai amour. La profondeur de l'âme et la connexion à travers la musique. Merci à lucifmello.
Trop triste, la fin ...
any other word or touching or kissing would have made it just another WW2 movie. It is the absence of all that that makes this movie unique
Какой прекрасный фильм, актеры вообще отлично сыграли, вот это и есть настоящая любовь.Жаль только конец очень печальный))>)))
Cái kết đúng ra không phải dừng ở đó mà còn dài và hay hơn nữa...cô gái Pháp có con với anh sĩ quan Đức và khi quân đồng minh Anh và Mỹ đổ bộ cứu nước Pháp ...một người lính Mỹ đã bắn chết anh lính Đức và cô gái vì mang thai với người Đức ...thời đó rất khắc nghiệt với phụ nữ có giao tình với lính Đức sẽ bị cạo đầu bôi vôi rêu rao khắp phố...nên cô ấy chấp nhận lấy người lính Mỹ và theo chồng về New york sống và có thêm một con gái nữa với anh lính Mỹ. Sau này cô ấy sống rất hạnh phúc sau khi đã hóa giải những hiểu lầm với chồng ❤
Wow, that was powerful. Very little interaction, practical no communication, yet so sensual and intense.
The actors, played the German soldier, beautiful man with expressive eyes; the French girl sweet and expressive eyes.
9
They were perfect in playing each part.
Great director, genius; great script writer, supremely masterful at their crafts. Amazing sound and music score. Did you hear the waves lulling and crashing while they said goodbye to each other by the car?
The best romantic film of all time! Merci beaucoup !
Qui !! Beaucoup
Magnifique
Merci beaucoup pour ce beau et magnifique film.
Le metteur en scene, merci
Yogini Akara 👍❤🌊
Nếu theo tiểu thuyết gốc ...Đừng bao giờ xa em... thì hay và xót xa hơn nữa...nguời Sĩ quan Đức đóng chiếm ở ngôi nhà cô gái Pháp mấy tháng đợi quân đồng minh cập bờ biển để đánh trả ...trong thời gian đó hai người yêu nhau và thường xuyên gặp nhau khi đêm về trên tòa tháp tại căn phòng nơi bà nội của cô gái ở khi xưa ...và rồi cô gái có thai ngay lúc viên sĩ quan đi ra trận...yêu trong đau khổ tuyệt vọng lắm...ngày quân đồng minh Anh và Mỹ đổ bộ vô bờ biển nước Pháp cô gái cứu được người lính Anh và chính người lính Anh đó bắn chết người sĩ quan Đức khi hiểu lầm là quân địch ...Sau cô gái lấy người lính Mỹ và sinh được đứa con trai của người lính Đức đó sau đám cưới ..anh ấy đem cô ấy qua Mỹ sống và cô ấy mỗi lần về Pháp lại ra nghĩa trang giá đình nơi chôn người lính Đức thăm mộ chàng...sau này đứa con trai cũng thích học tiếng Đức và tham quan nước Đức ...trong quá trình đó hôn nhân của cô ấy cũng gặp nhiều sóng gió... sau cùng tất cả được hóa giải hiểu lầm hạnh phúc viên Mãn bởi vì người chồng Mỹ rất yêu và hiểu cô ấy...❤
Una simple y gran pelicula.Llena de profundos sentimientos.Con silencios expresivos,pocas palabras,que dicen mucho.Cada vez que la veo,me emociono como la primera vez!!.-
Очень. Трогательный. Момент. Игра. Актёров. На. Высшем. Уровне. Спасибо. За. Фильм
Какой сюжет! Прекрасные исполнители , прекрасный дуэт! Фильм отличный, смотрю часто, как будто любимая книга - история вечного добра, надежды...Спасибо создателям фильма и автору этой истории!
She saved his life,she cried when he had to go.She loved him and he loved her.So beautiful and sad.May be they found each other again after the war and lived HEA.This is the way I want to hope the story ended.
C est poignant comme Romeo et Juliette
Ils s aiment !!!
in other circumstnces, they could have dived in love
It might not be possible because the french people hate germans. They have to wait until 1970s or even 1980s to accept to be friends with them...
Me too.
Anh ấy mất và để lại cho cô ấy một đứa con trai ❤
I cannot stop watching this beautiful film over and over again. Wonderful storyline depicting the true meaning of love in its purest form!!!!!!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Les regards entre Werner et Jeanne : pas de mots mais ils disent. Ce film est emouvant et magnifique! ♥️
Сильная и красивая сцена прощания.
Mon film favori, trés émouvant on ne s'en lasse pas. Le regard peut parfois en dire beaucoup mais pas asseé. Merci à la personne qui à mis en ligne ce film. Merci beaucoup.
I will wait for him forever, he will write to me and, after the war he'll find me. Gosh, this movie keeps me awake at nights!
Facinante esa película lo amo este hombre tan hermoso
I saw this film few years back but still I come every now and then to feel their purity, their depth, their values,why this happens? But definitely makes life beautiful n yes enriched.
I Agree with the lady after me. No Need for physical intimacy. One has to go much deeper than that. The Stares , the expressions. The Gentle movements. Says it all. Much better than sex. It goes way beyond. What did he say about the Sea ? Such beautiful Poetry. And so True about who She Was. The Best Movie I've ever seen. Thought the Thorn birds were really good. But than I saw this. Don't forget, this was War time. I think this happened much more than we Realize. Thank you for this Awesome movie. Makes me Cry every time.
Debra 🌊❤🌊
This longing we get when we are in love, is the LOVE frequency. Romantic love is only one of many ways to tapping into this LOVE frequency. Even though the love frequency is everywhere, right with us, yet we have forgotten how to tap into it. There are also other ways to tap into it, like prayer, meditation, service to others, mindfulness, all require conscious diligence to practice (ask anyone who maintains a spiritual practice). Romantic love is one experience most everyone will have a chance to have in the course of one's life, it is effortless for most. That is why we only recognize it a romantic, not the universal frequency that is. We need to rediscover what LOVE really is....
О да!!❤😘
Uno de los mejores films que he visto! que guion y actuación! y su Director ! 👌🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🌷
Silence can speak more than words.
De même, merci, c'est magnifique, j'en suis tombé amoureux, de cette façon d'attirer les âmes, malgré le silence amoureux,.. !♥️😘
They're so perfect for each other...only they can never be together. What a horrid situation. Thanks for posting this absolutely perfect film.
Un amour interdit "" Suivez son regard il est plein d'amour pour cette fille silencieuse "" j'adore ❣
Потрясающий фильм! Люблю Тома Жуанне! Красавчик! Обожаю!! Merci!!! 😍😘🌹
Que hombre tan lindo, y esa mirada habla por sí sola, hermosa película ❤
The actor playing the German officer is so handsome and he says so much with his eyes. Love this movie.
He is Swiss - Thomas Jouannet Yes he makes you fall in love with him and German Soldiers. He is an amazing actor.
You are right.It's a wonderful film, the actors are talented.
Yeah the 3 main actors are amazing. I just wish I could understand them. lol However, their eyes and facial expressions are amazing and lets you know what is going on without words and they are so talented.
He is definitely one handsome actor playing his role to perfection, especially through his eyes. She also did the same. Hard to watch because you want them to touch, which I know iis impossible, still you want them to get together someday.
lukeloveslauraalways just because he have blue eyes😂😂🤣🤣
Замечательный фильм. Жуанне просто красавчик и актёр хороший. Пересмотрела несколько фильмов с его участием. Но в этом фильме он бесподобен.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
My heart aches when I see this scene.
Un film magnifique pas de haine un amour pure et sincère
assisti ao filme por um mero acaso na tv... e fiquei estupefacta.
mesmo não existindo qualquer declaração de amor verbal chega-se ao fim e é exactamente igual a se tal tivesse ocorrido! que explendida historia! sem palavras...
o filme está muito bem conseguido e os actores sao muito, muito bons! adorei tudo!
Quel beau film où l'acheter ...? Si vous savez aidez moi merci beaucoup
Ma mère a été tondue en 1944 en public par une bande de "résistants "de la dernière heure.Elle avait 17 ans. Sa faute : avoir été jolie et serveuse dans l'hotel où les officiers allemands prenaient leurs repas.Le meneur des tondeurs était un amoureux éconduit.Elle m'a raconté cette histoire en 1994 et elle s'est mise à sangloter comme si ça s'était passé la veille.C'est pourquoi ce film me touche autant.
Beaucoup d entre eux étaient amoureuse des officiers allemands je pense mais s interdisant d aimer pour cause de représailles ....C une éprouvant e histoire et vie pour l époque.....
.
Love is all we need
Quelle bande de lâche d idiots.. Oui résistant se la dernière heure c est à vomir et en plus dans votre cas une vengeance.
@katarmor, I am speechless, what a terrible wound your mom has to bear all these years. I was thinking, now Werner is gone, Pascal might prey on Jeanne again. What an interesting contrast, the officer of the occupation shows impeccable code of conduct, a true gentleman, the cousin, Jeanne's own relative, behaves like a thug...
@@vivianedelage2504 How ironic, that the occupying force came to France with guns and tanks, but they also brought love on an individual level, knowing how many love stories have ensued during the four years of the occupation. The world is a brutal but also wondrous place, full of paradoxes, opportunities for souls to be creative, to make the best out of the worst. It really makes one think again about the intentions of the so called Collaborators, even during occupation, some one has to administer to the needs of the population, especially in large cities, towns, to minimize suffering, to maintain order. I think we are poised on massive disclosures of the many truth about the two great wars. Our history has not been honestly written.
C'est le plus beau film que j'ai jamais vu ! Les acteurs excellent chacun dans leur role. C'est à travers le silence que s'est imposée la famille jusqu'a la fin,ou presque, que l'on ressent la force incroyable des sentiments du capitaine allemand comme de la jeune fille ! A vrai dire j'avais peur que le film n'égale pas le livre, mais cette representation cinématographique du chef d'oeuvre de Vercors a dépassé toutes mes attentes ! Merci beaucoup pour ce film ! Il est splendide !
magnifique ce film
Et même le grand-père semble regretter fortement le départ de von Ebbrenac.
Прекрасный фильм все настоящее никакой фальши.
@@vHumboldt77 oui. Il le respecte et il sait que c'est l'amour de vie de sa petite-fille. Il a vu sa belle-fille perdre son amour de vie (son fils) dans la Grande Guerre et maintenant sa petite-fille vivra le même chagrin.
Очень трогательный крутой кино " молчание море" просто суппер .с играли актеры молодцы. какие красивые оригинальные парочки .молодцы абажаю .сколько повторно смотрю атарватся не могу . Ббббббаааааааааууууууууууу бомба !!!!!!
" La mer est silencieuse mais il faut savoir l'écouter "
Magnifique ils s aiment beau triste
j'adore ce téléfilm, je l'ai vu je sais pas combien de fois, et pourtant, à la fin, je pleure comme une magdeleine
Trèsjoli filmée excellentes outores merci.
Film bellissimo, il finale è molto triste.
Their adieus are actually I love yous...
Alice - that is true. I just wish she had touched his arm as a way to express more of this love she felt for him before he departed.
yes , 💔
Knowing now where he is going and what he is facing, I don’t think I could have stopped myself from reaching for him!
Critical Catalyst Absolutely❤🌊❤
tellement beau ^purée à chaque fois que je vois ce film, je pleure...
I can't stop crying
Прекрасная работа! Спасибо.
Сколько раз смотришь,и не насмотришься,настолько завораживает этот фильм, тонкость чувств, двух сердец,
Чистая любовь.!❤
Фильм - чудо ! ❤
Чудесный фильм! Так хочется увидеть продолжение, но видимо его не будет...((( Такое ощущение, что я сама пережила все чувства героини. Потрясающая была бы пара ... Они были созданы друг для друга, но обстоятельства были против них.
I get the impression he was waiting for her to say more than farewell. I would have told him that someday this war will end and I will find you. Try to stay alive and know that I love you. But that is just me!
Most soldiers who went to the Russian front died. More died there than came back. So more tbsn liklely in reality he died.😶
Sharyn - I would have said the same.
I would have said something similar - to please stay safe and I will pray for you to come back to me.
Then that would not be a silent girl😂
yes, he slams the door every time he is upset.
Esse filme apesar de ser de guerra é de uma delicadeza, que o olhar podia dizer muitas coisas disso não tinha dúvidas. São dois atores muito bons, faz com que a gente sinta tudo o que eles sentem, sem se falar 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻
first time watched this movie. I love this movie so much. Beautiful love. Should they have a hug at the end. Thank you for sharing this video.
What an amazing movie at its best, i love it, so powerful and intense, i love that the author & director didnt think it needed all the sexual nudity and bed scene to make the movie incredible to the audience, this is the best movie I have seen in a long while
Hell the movie had no subtitles and I watched the whole thing riveted and just followed without knowing all that was being said. That's how good it was.
Beautiful ...just beautiful..!
@@jacijune 🙆♀️👍❤👍
@@jacijune There are two with English subtitles on TH-cam.
Ce téléfilm est vraiment très beau. J’avais vu le version avec Howard Vernon peut-être plus fidèle au livre de Vercors. Mais je préfère la plus récente avec des acteurs formidables. Comment ne pas craquer sur le beau regard de ces deux êtres déchirés par cette guerre. J’ai pleuré à la fin.
Now he knows she really cares for him
lovely...suttle...sexy....great story. my fav
look at her right hand after he leaves! she's nervously moving her fingers just like he did when he was waiting for her at the end of the bridge (the fish scene)
когда он уезжает и она остается стоять одна, она нервно двигает пальцами правой руки -- прямо как вернер, когда он ждал ее на мосту (сцена с рыбой). движения идентичные
Удивительное наблюдение, amazing observation.
the movie seriously shows the plot mostly in silence but meaningful like the unpredictable sea...the ice breaks simply by a short word...adieu...
Speechless, it is such a beautiful film.
Extraordinaria película!!! 👏👏👏👏👏❤️♥️💘💘
Piekna historia o milosci dziekuje bardzo
So beautiful 💞...the ending so sad.....I've watched it 11 times up to now but... It stays in your mind and you must think 🤔 a lot about it, all the metaphors and especially, the ending. True love in these times, the fate of two nations between them, they couldn't manage that...especially she was really patriotic (but he respected it) as the very end shows. But, so tragic😭
But can someone please explain that special kind of sad ending to me?? 🤔 She cries a lot because he is leaving, one word full of love 'Adieu", and then? 😯 She joins actively the resistance and is the happiest person in the world or what?? So, what' s the meaning of the very end? 🤔 Help, please🙏🏻
@@alexandrabrockmeyer3122 Yes. I found the ending strange. Despite her love for Werner, and despite the horrors of the bomb attack on her own family grounds by people she thought were her friends, and could have resulted in her and her grandfather's execution or being sent to a camp, she goes off to join the Resistance.
I think the film tried to stay true to the original novel, which was a call to resistance against the German occupier. However, unlike the novel and the 1949 film version, this film veered off into a love story, so that made the ending harder to understand.
I suppose they explained that away with Werner's statement that one has to stay loyal to one's duty and commitments.
@@pangorban1 yeah, I already thought about Werner's sentence he explained to stay loyal to one's duties and so on... He gave the answer as to the ending, but did you or someone else notice, that there are red roses 🌹or maybe red cloves on her dress at the very end!? 🤔 I mean, come on that film is ful of metaphors... I'm pretty sure it has a meaning, too
@@alexandrabrockmeyer3122 The lilac flowers in the courtyard showed it to be spring. So she was wearing a pretty floral dress, as opposed to the drab grey colours she wore during winter. It was hard to tell if they were roses or not. The dress didn't appear to be one of Jeanne's mother's hand-me-downs, so perhaps she was finally moving on from the past.
So much of the commentary about this film indicates that Jeanne and Werner were destiny's soul mates. But life's not like that. People fall in love, and if it doesn't work out, they move on. Jeanne was too practical a person to pine away for Werner. If he wanted to kill himself by transferring to the Russian Front, that was his business. She had an occupation to overthrow. That was her business.
@@alexandrabrockmeyer3122 When he returned home with his old friends and fellow German officers, they had an argument about Germany vanquished France, therefore they should be proud victors, and they were no longer poets and musicians(Werner was a Classical composer and pianist, one of his friend was a poet, who turned into an ardent National Socialist, whereas Werner seems more of a humanist)," the officer friend went on to say "(to hell with) respect France, they were German officers and should be loyal to their duty and the Fuhrer." Werner turned in exasperation: "Yeah right!" and walk back to the house. When he got inside he walked in the sitting room and wanted to tell the hosts "something serious", about his disillusion of the German Government's policy towards Occupied France, he ended up asking:"what should I do? Maybe you are right (refering to Jeanne), we should honor our duty and commitment." So after the car bomb killed his fellow officers, he might have arranged to have Jeanne and her grandpa interrogated by the SS who would certainly suspect that Jeanne might know about the bomb (and saved Werner), because the Germans are known for being punctual, the fact that Werner did not get in the car while his orderly and the two friend officers were in the car, is itself suspect. I think Werner requested to go to the Russian Front immediately with the intention (my guess here) to not be part of the investigation of the bombing assassination, remember Grandpa read the newspaper about the assassination of the two German officers brought about the reprisal of killing 99 French hostages. Werner was very scared for Jeanne I think (that scene of him walking out of the German command center and saw Jeanne from afar, and the grave look in his face and eyes). He got in the car and looked at her while driving away.
c'est une film fantastique. merci beaucoup pour monter cette film.
Красива любов! Дори и невъзможна! Благодаря!
HELLO from Toronto Canada!!!!!!!! We are currently in Lockdown so I've been trying to watch a lot of movies and TV series that I have never had time to watch. I started with Suite Française (2014), then The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (2018) then The Exception (2016) then I found this incredible Foreign film! OMG the best of the best- so much better then anything Hollywood could produce! I fell in love with with Jeanne & Werner- so raw and incredible!!!! At first I was heartbroken with the ending- I wanted more but after watching it again I understood better {I also had to do a little research ;)}. For French women to have a relationship with a German Solider would result in shame - some would have their heads shaved following liberation, as punishment for an on-going relationship with a Nazi soldier during the occupation of France. This relationship between Jeanne & Werner was doomed but at least he left knowing that she loved him and he was loved! Flood of tears!
Hello from Florida. I stumbled upon this movie a couple days ago and I cannot get it out of my head. I must have watched different edits 50 times. Just started reading the (English) comments and got so much clarity. In the very last scene was there a slight smile in acknowledgement of her love?
@@ljones1295 YES - he was happy!!!!!!!!!! The movie ended the way it should have ended {sadly}- I'm sure they reconnected after the war if it was meant to be ;) but he left knowing she loved him and the only reaction she ever gave him was that of love and tears- he smiled- so raw- so good!
@@justmyopinion5099 thanks. I read a comment that he saved her from the SS. I did not pick up on that did you? how/where? I am watching again. Lord help me.
@@ljones1295 Yes he saved her and grandfather from questioning by the SS- after the truck exploded - I watch a version with English subtitles on TH-cam- one by Celina E Torres and another by Eichi. Such a powerful movie given the time!
@@justmyopinion5099 Ok going to check out those channels. That is why the grandfather was softer towards him at the end. Referring to when he invited him into the room when he was leaving. Thanks!
Il sourit car elle lui parle pour la première fois : c'est pour lui l'aveu des sentiments qu'elle ressent pour lui, presque un "je t'aime". He smiles because it's the first time she talks to him.For Werner "adieu" sounds like "je t'aime".
😭😭😭😭
This movie is haunting in that it keeps you wanting more for both of them. It wasn’t possible unless she was willing to become involved with him and that was looked upon as criminal.. Her own people would have turned against her. By the end of the occupation, those women were persecuted without mercy.
None of these events occurred in the original story but the message was that you could resist by simply not engaging with the enemy.
Sharyn Carr all of my relatives are German and I know from correspondence that all the men were forced to fight even though they hated Hitler and the Nazi regime. Most died fighting the Russians, some hoped to surrender to the Americans and some survived. War is horrible. It never brings peace, only suffering.
This film was beautifully done.
Heidi Grover, I totally agree with you. The German Captain came from a military family and he had no choice but to do his duty. When he realized that the defeated people were not going to be respected and seen as worthy, his disillusionment was overwhelming. He couldn’t leave the military, he would have been tried as a deserter so he volunteered for the Russian front and he would accept whatever fate held for him. Most likely he faced death in combat or a Russian prison camp, if lucky he might survive. He was a better man than he knew, as were many others in Germany who were caught in a difficult situation.
Thank you Sharon Carr for your understanding. Every line the Captain speaks is poignant. He mentions the freezing temps in Russia etc. It’s heartbreaking for those soldiers, their families etc. The totalitarian regimes didn’t care about the people. I won’t say more. Just thanks.
Shayn not everyone could have resisted his manners and his genteel ways. Problem one needs to focus on whether he was doing this deliberately or was he genuine. She learned by hearing the discussion between his friends and him and how he stood up for the French people on not humiliating them. She realized he loved France as much as his country but had to make a commitment to his country which was first.
I remember finding myself attached by verbal communication so for her to detach herself from him she kept "silent" which really protects her from feelings - which became impossible to avoid since he was so magnificent as a vulnerable soul in her home.
Thank you for this great movie 🤗
Magnifiquement joué, merci pour ce partage 💖
This one is better than earlier versions.
Cookiey13 hat Recht! Jeane Pierre Melville hat seine unvergeßliche 1949er Version auf praktischen sowie künstlerischen Gründen sparsam und fast minimalistisch inszipiert und hätte vielleicht auch so ein Prachtwerk wie Boutrons gedreht. Die Überzeugungskraft der Schauspieler ist doch fantastisch! Vive la France 2! Merci You-Tube!
Cuantas cosas puede decir el amor sin una sola palabra, solo gestos, música, miradas. Es como el mar, que en apariencia es solo agua, pero que su profundidad alberga secretos impronunciables, sobrecogedores.
Ένας αληθινός ιππότης με αριστοκρατικη καταγωγή, ρομαντική ψυχή και εκλεπτυσμένους τρόπους.
La France est pleine de ses amours là...😉
Продолжение!!!!!! Очень хочется продолжение фильма...
Продолжения не будет, вся суть фильма в том что они оба, каждый остался при своих интересах, он на русский фронт убивать наших, тогда же СССР был или его убьют а она в сопротивление, фильм не сказка где все неппи энд а здесь- реальность
This made my heart ache in a very weird way.... True love I guess.
Yes, but, unfulfilled !!! That's distressing!
The biggest love never wear a wedding dress 😢.
@@ib3609 Wow, never thought about it that way.
O filme é lindo do início ao fim. Parabéns a tdos q contacenaram nesta obras esplêndida.
His eyes
Les yeux amoureux , les yeux du capitaine ....
怎麼這麼快就播完 看不過癮啊啊啊啊
Merci d'avoir posté ce film ... il est si beau ... et tellement frustrant!!
DrawY37 Mais oui tellement...
😂
Que lindo 😢😢sou brasileira mas me tocou a alma. Que triste😍😢 será que terá continuação 🇧🇷😢queria que eles se encontrassem de novo🇧🇷😢❤️💔💔
BEAUTIFUL ♥️WONDERFUL
me encanta como se desarrolla un amor tan puro en circunstancias tan adversas, amor puro que no es facil de encontrar.
quisiera saber si alguien tiene esta pelicula con subtitulos en español y si es verdad que tiene una segunda parte para verla y apreciar si esta si tiene un final menos trajico pero igualmente romantico.........
Eu filme emocionante e inesperado! MARAVILHOSO!
She let him go, First saving his Life,then with certainty of a Grest love.....!!!!
It ends in this Farewell. It will remain a love that is pure, restraint and silent.
Werner will survive the Russian front and he will be promoted to a higher
rank in the military. Jeanne will be the greatest silent love of his life, and same for Jeane.
The story was perfection. The 3 main Characters, almost have equal screen time, and each actor did well. They can all win recognition award.
Quand la raison l emporte sur le coeur.il fallait une sacrée dose de courage .un amour meurtrie .
Très beau film, merci :)
That officer is freaking gorgeous! I’m in love 🥰
Me. Encanto. Esta. Gran. Seríe. Tan. Dramática. Cómo. Profundamente. Romantica. Gracias
El. Cilence. De la. Mer. . gracias
..perdonado. No. Escribí correcto
Как больно ,когда они прощаются 😥.
Ce est est simplement splendide !!!!!!
Этот фильм, разбили моё сердце
Muchas gracias katarmor .
Great film, with love from Russia!
какой красивый мужчина！
Merci , merci🙏❤️
Elle s'engage a son tour dans la resistance. Elle met le geranium comme la mere de pierre.
MAGNIFIQUE !!! Merci pour ce partage.
VERY GOOD !!! Thanks!!! Klase film .....😘😘😘😚
Ce film est super mais la fin est trop triste