Colion Noir: Gun Nuts | Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 มิ.ย. 2018
- Subscribe to the Real Time TH-cam: itsh.bo/10r5A1B
NRA TV's Colion Noir joins Bill to discuss America's gun obsession.
Connect with Real Time Online:
Find Real Time on Facebook: / maher
Find Real Time on Twitter: / realtimers
Find Real Time with Bill Maher Official Site: itsh.bo/HttKcM.
Find Real Time with Bill Maher on HBO GO® itsh.bo/iioY87.
Find Real Time with Bill Maher on Connect: connect.hbo.com/real-time-bill...
Find Real Time on Instagram: / realtimers
The Real Time blog: www.real-time-with-bill-maher-...
It's HBO.
Connect with HBO Online
Find HBO on Facebook: / hbo
Follow @HBO on Twitter: / hbo
Find HBO on TH-cam: / hbo
Find HBO Official Site: HBO.com
Find HBO Connect: Connect.hbo.com
Find HBO GO: HBOGO.com
Find HBO on Instagram: / hbo
Find HBO on Foursquare: Foursquare.com/hbo
Check out other HBO Channels
HBO: / hbo
Game of Thrones: / gameofthrones
True Blood: / trueblood
HBO Sports: / hbosports
HBO Documentary Films: / hbodocs
Cinemax: / cinemax
HBO Latino: / hbolatino - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
I wish I could live in the US
Unfortunately I live in California
we moved here from the south and honestly the gun laws aren't near as bad as I thought. Don't get me wrong. They are all BS. But in CA it really depends on your county. I'm in Ventura county which is very conservative and gun friendly. Getting our CCW's was much easier than I thought. Our gun shop had a ton of cool guns including AR's I've found the gun owners of California are a really cool bunch. And they are on top of things because of the state's laws. I've said before CA is just the pioneer for laws. They eventually make their way around the country. So that's why gun owners need to be on our toes and ready to fight. The same libtards encouraging rioting and looting are the ones who want guns to be illegal.
Get out bro you can do it
Well I had been drinking a soda
I wish i could live in the US aswell. But Im stuck here in New York
Sorry I understand I’m in NY and it to was Beautiful Once ! God Bless ! 🙏🏼❤️🇺🇸✌🏼
“I don’t want me protecting my life to be a competition. I want it to be as lopsided as possible, because I am not the one threatening someone’s life.” One of my favorite quotes on this matter.
This is the same concept the police use when subduing a suspect but get vilified for it.
@@dd9354 true, but police often do abuse their power. this is the fault of their training though by federal regulations.
@@donsink It happens but rarely.
@@donsinknah. It's a failure in the screening process to identify the mentally unfit
@@dd9354 no it actually doesnt. It so happens criminals of a minority of the population commit multiple crimes that lead to violent interactions with police at some point and the police dont have a wide range of good training with deescalation and fitness. Nobody talks about the simple shit like how they are fat as fuck and ive watched a video of 4 officers taking 15 minutes to get a dude in handcuffs, the need to have mandatory jujitsu training that is good at control bodies so they want restort to punching kicking and shooting. Most of the population that owns guns LEGALLY are good people trying to have an advantage over criminals. I was lucky to have a mother who bought a 1911 and taught me how to use it and when i was about to head to the bus for school at someone tryna break in my house threw a pot at my window. They ran ocause the alarm went off and nothing happened it was wtv, but if he did decide to come in i was in my mama room with the gun pointed at the door till i heard my neighbor come over and yell my name carrying his shotgun. Texas is amazing.
The fact that Colion asks for clarification when being asked a vague question like about loopholes, shows his talent as not only an attorney but a spokesman aswell. I’ve seen countless debates where both sides don’t understand what is being asked and just start answering the question rather than ask for a clarification and getting a better understanding of the question to continue a peaceful debate.
Well done Colion
He didn’t ask for clarification because he didn’t know what bill meant. He asked for clarification, because bill doesn’t understand what he’s asking. He’s saying it as if there’s some loophole for commercial gun sales when in reality it’s person to person sales. The government will never be able to regulate the 400 million privately held guns in this country no more than they can collect the sales tax when you sell an old appliance to a friend for 50 bucks. He’s asking for clarification to win the argument, which is why bill backpedals and changes topic.
@@ringingsteel8729Looking at it from your standpoint it makes sense. I haven’t looked at that way. Just showing his ability to direct a debate/argument and his great debating skills
I could listen to Colion all day long. Not only is he smart, but he can get his point across without making the listener feel dumb. That’s a rare but valuable talent. Even Bill Maher learned something.
the best part about this - this interview is 4 years old. Bill has come out later to say he has new respect for gun owners after this interview sank in completely for him!!!
Bill has become one of the leading Democrats that ive grown some respect for!!! He has shown several times that he actually thinks and processes, albeit at a later date, what his interviews talk about!!! Even tho i dont agree with everything he stands for, i have respect for Bill!
I initially dismissed Bill as just another intolerant, close-minded lefty, but I discovered his actual personality when he was a guest on Joe Rogan. The guy is actually pretty open to hearing out people he disagrees with.
I don’t really care what people believe or support. You can be a hardcore lefty, radical right, or somewhere in between and I will harbor no hatred towards you for that alone. What I can’t respect is people who cover their ears when they hear something they disagree with and start yelling over them “I’M RIGHT YOU’RE WRONG I’M RIGHT YOU’RE WRONG…” Close-mindedness and intolerance are a cancer and stain on humanity, no matter what side of the spectrum you’re on.
Bill’s not like that. I respect him and like his personality because of that.
America, never give up your guns, never.
We're trying not to. Most of the people trying to get rid of guns are people who never had anything to do with them in the first place.
Oh, we won't.
As if....
yeah, brazil did that. just look up how it went for us
C.U. - "I think we just want pro gun people to keep them out the hands of crazy people."
You do that by arming everyone. People think twice about shooting at people when they KNOW that those same people can shoot back.
I love how a black lawyer has to be labeled provocative because he’s exercising the rights his ancestors didn’t have, your think liberals would be all for it?
Lebario Why do you think 🤔??? I feel better around & safer with conservatives than with liberals because I really hate it , how leftist liberals try to use me as a pawn for their own political or personal ideology/ gain.
BadHombre45 Patriot7.62x39 Conservatives just live and let live, for the most part liberals are just rich where people who have no resolve in life and need to go out of their way to show who is the least racist/sexist among them. It’s a paradox they all to well fail to realize that the ones who care the most about race and gender are the bigots themselves. The left has become uses fear and gross tactics to get people to follow, conservatives just offer individualism and morals.
Yea but you gotta remember...liberals are borderline tards
See THIS STATEMENT displays part of the PROBLEM. Lets me explain. Here in America because of VARIOUS racist, capitalist agendas, YOU/WE, DONT KNOW AMERICAN HISTORY. We get the whitewashed, revisionist version. Coming to what you see spealing before you is a "black man" talkijg about the 2nd Amendment and how his "ancestors" blah blah blah. Look, it needs to be understood that ALOT of the people you see (speaking for the "black" community) are NOT CONNECTED to the history, legacy, or lineage of the circumstances in which you referrenced with the whole "ancestors" thing. What do I mean? Colin Noir, Candace Owens, Joy Reid, Barack Obama, Shelia Jackson Lee (and MANY MEMBERS OF THE CONGRESSIONAL BLACK CAUCUS) the one guy from the reparations debate, Issa Raye (insecure) Cardi B, Nikki Minaj, Rhianna, Kamalah Harris etc etc these people are "black" but they are NOT the traditionally termed "African American) which should actually be known as American Descendants of Slavery (ADOS). It so it needs to be understood that when lots of these people speak, greater America (read white america) usually thinks these are African american people speaking in the sense of a group identity. Like "his ancestors", when in actuality, with him being 1st Gen American and hist family being from Nigeria, there is a STRONG possibility that his "ancestors" SOLD MY ANCESTORS into slavery. My ancestors, The non-immigrant descendant Enslaved Africans whose blood sweat, tears, labor, and wombs through which America was built, were the "ancestors" who were denied the rights. So it may sound crass, and pretty unpopular (especislly with liberal status quo) but just because we are black we are NOT the same. Which is one of the very reasons why all throught politics EVERYONE has an advocacy group that advocates SPECIFICALLY for them, EXCEPT BLACK AMERICANS, More specifically American Descendats of Slavery. Dont believe me? Research it for yourselves and you will see that I'm right. EVERYBODY thats black in the US falls into the "black" or African American, minorty, people of color, black and brown, etc" category but the actual black population that is tied to the history, legacy, lineage and building of the US is steadily being "recasted" by other "blacks". Who in MANY CASES shouldnt even be speaking "for" or as a "representative of" the "black community.
You're stupid ass saw Black and Attorney and thought he is special. Nothing about him is remarkable. And he's a gun speaker who can't shoot, I hear his gun fear in him. This person is barely even skilled enough to operate a mail room..
I like how the “arm teachers” idea is always perceived as a mandatory carry for all teachers. I don’t think anyone is proposing that idea. I think the idea is that if a teacher is trained and willing that they should be allowed to concealed carry in their classroom.
Absolutely maybe have a controlled safe operated by the main office in time of need to make people feel better about that
I am a retired police officer, who was a school resource officer for 7 years. While working in the schools, I crossed paths with hundreds of teachers and most of them did not have the proper mindset or desire to carry a firearm. A few of them had what it takes to be armed and trained to defend themselves and their students. With all the proper safeguards in place, there is no reason they shouldn't be allowed to do so.
@troylindsey1444 I'm in complete agreement. I'm a *_military veteran_* , and yet even though I'm allowed to carry a gun into a crowded movie theater (packed with women and children no less), I'm not allowed to conceal-carry into any school in my state. It's absurd!
Colion, you are a national treasure! Never stop fighting for our Constitutional rights!❤️🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
is it just me or is anyone else annoyed by the audience clapping to Bill Maher who didn't make any real valuable points?
All his videos have audiences filled with clapping seals
His audience agrees to applause when the "Applause" light comes on. They also agree to laugh when the "Laugh" light comes on. It is part of the price they pay for admission.
@@mikejohns3104 you serious?
@@Trendyrapslut Yes, what I said is very true.
His audience are morons, you didn't know that? That is how collectivism works....
That slave question was designed to throw him off but he didn't miss a beat.
The way liberals use his skin color pisses me off. And then they use a stacked audience when the liberal starts losing an argument.
And it’s the Democrats that started the KKK, showed the first ever movie at the White House “Birth of a nation” and they truly are racist! Everything the left accuses the right of.....they actually did it themselves.....hint, hint, Hitlary n her paid for Russian dossier and Ukrainians ACTUALLY ADMITTING THEY TRIED HELPING HER! That’s the only reason she even came close and why she won the popular vote! That’s why Dems wanna throw out the constitution and electoral college. Cuz Trump would have won in a LANDSLIDE if it weren’t for Ukraine and Russia helping Hitlary!
Bill doesn’t realize that the slave angle makes Colion’s point perfectly.
And he smashed that question out of the park
@@rb88dhb You can thank Lyndon B. Johnson for shifting the perception of the Democratic party by siding with the civil rights movement and backing the Civil Rights Act of 1964. He hoped it would help secure the black vote and get him re-elected but unfortunately for him said voters hated the Vietnam War more than they hated segregation.
I'm a former teacher. We once had a lock down. I did as I was trained, and had the kids (avg age of 6 years old) line up on the wall, pulled the curtains down, and put my back against the door. It felt like forever until the lock down was lifted, but as I sat there, my back the only thing between harm and some parent's worst nightmare, as a US Army veteran, I looked at each child's face and wished I had something beyond my life to make sure they would be okay. I was ready to go down fighting, fair fight or not. I'm a teacher, and I say, arm us. "This we'll defend"
“Forever”
But instead, the school policy is to be quiet and hide. In a classroom, where the shooter knows you will be. DUMB.
Colion is always spot on.
He had some good points. But, there are things that he said where I disagree with. However, overall, he made a pretty sound argument for owning guns. I was once a gun hater myself, until I listened to the other side of the argument.
Arming teachers is crazy, he even said the at-15 is scary. He won’t admit there is a gun violence problem. He is an nra pon. He wants no reasonable gun laws. Same narrative as the nra
This is peak American exceptionalism. Exceptionally regressive and barbaric. Just look at stats on gun deaths in developed countries. Kids in cities growing up with ptsd from gun violence as if they are war victims.
Even honoring your right to guns, you still refuse to have basic common sense control laws.
@@arkyudetoo9555 What is the other side of the argument. Most of Noir points don't make much sense to the educated individual.
@@handsometall28 I disagree, Noir has counter arguments to the left's argument about banning guns, although some are weak, most of it are really strong counter-arguments. If the left and democrats, wants to ban some or most guns, given that they control most of the government right now, why can't they just change the 2nd amendment?
"They're willing to die for this students. Why not put them in a position to fight for them?" I was on the fence. Consider my mind made up sir.
We've both been through middle school, so we both know how...testing some kids can be. It only takes one teacher who's having a REALLY bad day to have a kid make them snap, and that will lead to a massive backlash. We see this with cops that sometimes get trigger happy and gun people down because someone got nervous and made a sudden move. I am pro gun, but just looking at it from a logistical standpoint, it probably wouldn't work. Most school districts are massively underfunded and they sometimes don't even have enough money to buy up to date textbooks every year. So all of the training and buying a gun would have to come out of the teachers own pocket, and they are all ready underpaid.
That being said, I have no idea whatsoever on how to deal with school shootings. Maybe raise the age to buy any gun to 21, but that would only solve a niche case because they can always use someone else's gun, but it's at least an idea.
they should sit their and die by their blackboard bc they're teachers?
@@User71956 Sorry, not really interested in reading your book to nowhere. Honestly speaking, if the middle school teacher in question is willing to go through specialized training, then I feel it safe to assume a specific degree of patience. Your concern was also mine prior to this video.
Respectively, there is considerably zero difference in the decision making ability between 18 and 21. Both are idiots that believe they know everything, meanwhile knowing virtually nothing. Well trained and licensed teachers defending our kids may just be the best option.
I really don’t understand why people don’t understand that the NRA/GOA etc.. are the People. They aren’t some mythical entity, they are the American People. Oh wait a minute, they are leftists and facts don’t matter.😎
Seriously think about it. If the teachers gonna step up and take a bullet why the hell wouldn't they just put themselves in a position to take out the shooter rather then sacrifice their life and possibly not even accomplish anything other than killing themselves, that to me is stupid. Give me a fucking gun, fuck the shooter I like breathing, lol. 🤙😎
As a High School teacher, who has spent over $2000 of my own money on TRAINING with a firearm, and has had my concealed carry license for nearly a decade, I wish I was allowed to carry a firearm at work just like I do everywhere else in life.
@BAMFs Tactical
Why aren’t you utilizing your training and experience? Hopefully you’re just being carefully pc regarding the statement of allowed to carry at work. From what you said, who better to be in a position to carry at work and help educate those you work with/for? 🤝
We're "not allowed" either....we just do it anyway.
Shit i dnt even have a liscens an i still carry cause fuck the law my life an other peoples lives come first period
@@test-zg4hv if its my life then fuck the law
@@NODAK9 I agree with what you are saying, but BAMF's is not allowed to carry at work for a couple of reasons. One it is against the rules. Remember schools af
e gun free s\zones (Victims rich areas). Two if caught with his weapon the lest that could happen is he will lose his job. Most likely he would go to jail. And of course the media would have a grand old time reporting about the crazy teacher who came to school to shoot his students ect ect ect.
That last question of Bill's about the slave revolts, I think Colion's response was one of the most elegant responses to an interview question I have ever seen. Like silk. Goddamn.
Funny how no one clapped for the guest’s point of view .
Until 5 guys kick you door down and see how your attitude changes...with your kids freaking out crying and you are standing there armed with the fully loaded rationale....
At least Two times I thought " this has to be the time!!!" Cricket cricket Cricket 🤯Unbelievable!!
Not even the point he made about single Mothers protecting herself and her babies!! Unbelievable
A stacked deck....LIBERAL audience! I would have been standing and clapping for Noir thru the ENTIRE show!
Y’all are correct
Probably because most of the people in the audience didn't go there to hear both sides of the argument, only Bill's 🙄
Bill Maher; ''I'm not strapped all the time.''
Colion Noir; ''I'm sure your armed security guards are.''
Do you know that Bill Maher has armed guards.
If he does it is because the GUN GOONS are out of control.
The only real way to "end Gun violence in schools" is the same thing that the Government did immediately after 9/11 (METAL DETECTORS IN EVERY AIRPORT). NO Guns in airports anymore!!! No Guns in Courthouses anymore!!
If we can raise Trillions of American Dollars to giveaway to Ukrainian War Efforts to try and save their lives? WHY CAN'T WE DO THE SAME FOR OUR OWN CHILDREN??? HERE IN OUR OWN COUNTRY??? WHAT'S MORE IMPORTANT? "(CHARITY
BEGINS AT HOME)" These are our children!!! OK Let's take a New approach. How about we SUE THE BUILDERS OF THESE NEW UNSAFE SCHOOLS? BECAUSE THEY AREN'T SAFE ENOUGH FOR OUR CHILDREN TO ATTEND? AND SUE THE
GOVERNMENT THAT FORCES THE PARENT'S TO PLACE THEIR CHILDREN IN AN UNSAFE ENVIRONMENT IN HARMS WAY EACH AND EVERY DAY BY SENDING THIER CHILDREN TO THESE UNSAFE SCHOOLS??? --> LIKE THE GOVERNMENT IS
ALLOWING SANDIE HOOK PARENT'S TO SUE AR15 GUN MAKERS??? MAKING THE MANUFACTURER'S BUILDERS? OF THESE AR15 RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DEATHS OF THEIR CHILDREN? AND THE GUN MAUFACTURES NEVER HELD
THE GUNS!!! OR PULLED THE TRIGGER THE DAY THOSE CHILDREN WERE KILLED!!! THE GUN COMPANY'S ARE THE "SCAPEGOAT" WE ALL KNOW THIS. BUT WE NEED THE PARENT'S OF EACH AND EVERY CHILD TO CALL FOR IMMEDIATE
(METAL DETECTORS) IN EACH AND EVERY SCHOOL EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY!!! THAT'S THE ONLY WAY WE CAN WIN THIS DEMOCRATIC WAR CAMPAIGN AGAINST GUNS. THEY ARE TRYING TO DISARM ALL AMERICANS FOR THEIR NWO
TAKEOVER. AND THESE PARENT'S NEED TO GET ON SOCIAL MEDIA WEBSITE TWITTER REDDIT FACEBOOK WHAT'SUP TH-cam...etc... AND PROTEST RALLYS MAKE THEIR VOICES HEARD ON THE NEWS EVERYDAY. ONLY THE PARENT'S
CAN SAVE THERE OWN CHILDREN. IF THEY JUST PEACEFUL PROTEST MARCH IN THE STREETS.... UNTIL WE GET THESE (METAL DETECTOR'S) IN EACH AND EVERY SCHOOL EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY... THEY SAVE JUDGES LIVES
EVERYDAY... AND PEOPLE AT THE AIRPORTS LIVES EVERYDAY.... IT'S SIMPLE COMMON SENSE PEOPLE!!! DON'T ALLOW THE DEMOCRATS LIBERALS TO BRAINWASH YOU.
PLEASE MENTION THIS TO ALL TOUR LOYAL LISTENERS FANS
FRIENDS...etc... AND HAVE THEM PUT THE PRESSURE ON Joe Biden. Mitch McConnell. Joe Manchin...etc... And all of these other politicians that think it would be easier to get in bed with the Democrat's and just give in, Please Understand This is the
road to the end of civilization as we know it... If they give in it's the road to the end of civilization here in America!!! We are being systematically stripped of all of our freedom's and Constitutional Rights, soon they will all be gone!!! We cannot allow this to
happen! Please get out the word. The voters are the only ones that can stop this, it's an election year coming up. Thank you for all of your help and support with this Simple Life Saving Approach To Combating Guns Getting Into Our SCHOOLS. These Metal
Detectors will keep the guns out. And our children SAFE... DON'T LET THE DEMOCRATS LIBERALS TELL YOU THE METAL DETECTORS ARE TO EXPLETIVE... ASK THE WHAT ARE OUR CHILDRENS LIVES ARE WORTH TO THEM??? ANSWER
THAT QUESTION. President Biden? Nancy Pelosi? Chuck Schumer? Mitch McConnell? Joe Manchin?...etc... And all the rest of these Political WIND BAGS that are in it for their own agendas to wipe out guns instead of saving OUR Children's
Lives!!! PARENT'S DON'T TAKE NO FOR AN ANSWER!!! FIGHT HARD FOR YOUR CHILDREN!!! BRING THE FIGHT TO THE SENATE FLOOR IF NEED BE... GET YOUR 15 MINUTES OF FAME... SAVING THE LIVES OF YOUR CHILDREN. BECOME
OUTRAGED BEFORE THE NEXT SCHOOL SHOOTING HAPPENS.... REMEMBER THIS IS THE LAND OF THE FREE AND THE HOME OF THE BRAVE!!! WE THE PEOPLE MADE IT THIS WAY. AND WITH GOD'S HELP WILL KEEP IT THIS WAY FOR THE NEXT GENERATION...
At least Maher actually listened instead of tweeting from a gated community. That logic is Kryptonite to anti-gun celebrities.
@@thatguy22441 Gated Community? you might want to check to see where the powers that be in the NRA live, I am sure they all live in VERY SAFE GATED COMMUNITIES as well.
While you are at it, see if you can find out why the NRA BANNED ALL GUNS FROM THEIR RECENT CONVENTION.
Yes, the NRA BANNED GUNS AT THEIR BIG MEETING.
I WONDER WHY.
You might want to look up the meaning of the word HYPOCRISY.
@@thatguy22441 WHAT LOGIC? I heard NO LOGIC from the gun freak, all I heard was the usual mind numbing twisted fairy tales that pass for reason from the NRA.
Why did the NRA BAN all guns from their recent convention, surely they would want everyone to be loaded with guns and ammo.
But it would seem that when it comes to their own personal safety, the powers that be at the NRA join ranks with those of us who can THINK.
Bill Maher: *interrupts with no factual point*
Croud: *Claps and cheers
Just like the View! Lol
NPCs in a nutshell
Maher's crowd cheer because they want to be cool, hip, and in with the pot smokers.
They are sheep
@@TyreII th-cam.com/video/ocO4zJboTT8/w-d-xo.html
"I now sit before you as a gun advocate with the ability to carry guns" - How to tell Bill that the "slave" narrative is a bunch of bullshit without saying it's a bunch of bullshit.
But that doesn't actually refute it.
@@soopahsoopah He's literally an attorney. There are more slaves than there has ever been (due to higher population), and I never seen BLM actually care about that. They are too hurt by the past, rightfully so, but there is a huge element of SELF-ACCOUNTABILITY that is required to make it big. Blacks are more successful now than they have ever been in the history of man because there are historically more jobs and money to be made than in the 1860's. So as a free, grown ass man.... how are you poor and ignorant. I'm black myself, joined the Marine Corps, got my college benefits and now I'm all good and comfy with a tech job making $65g a year starting in Houston with a low cost of living. I still save, there is a META to making money and being successful. Use everything the system offers, it ain't against blacks, it's against poor people and it's the politicians fault with their bloated net worth and stock portfolios
.
@@BaconEatingRAIDBoss That's great that you and him are successful but that doesn't refute Bill's point that a big part of the original need for militias and 2A was to maintain slavery. History yo. No ones asking to you to play the victim, but don't close your eyes to the victimization that occurred.
Provide some evidence that the 2A was written to keep slaves. The burden of proof is on Bill and you because the language of the 2A says no such thing.
@@soopahsoopah I feel like the biggest issue is that you're all too concerned of the past. no one is "closing their eyes" to anything, we're simply realizing how society has evolved and so too has the 2A. yes, in the past the 2A was utilized to maintain slavery, but is that relevant in modern-day America where that doesn't occur? where instead, modern-day Americans are the militia? where Black Americans like Colion Noir can own a gun?? because if you didn't catch it, that was kinda Noir's whole point by saying that...
He said the most honest and amazing thing: people get into their emotions when they don't know much about something. He just described conspiracy theorists and people who exist on the fringes of the far right and far left. And politicians and the media are exploiting this fact too.
Just for future reference : "People like me who don't like guns don't know much about guns" - Bill Maher, 2018
This sums up the anti gun narrative in a nutshell.
So if you want stricter background checks Bill's statement sums up the whole gun debate.. whaaaa Are you even saying ??
Same dildo's saying "No one should be allowed to walk into a Gun Store and purchase a Full Auto Assault Rifle", yet if they did their research, they'd know that no one has been able to purchase Full Auto Assault Rifles legally since 1934.
These fucking idiots don't know anything about guns, they regurgitate whatever bullshit the news tells them.
Best response I have seen in this thread. I agree with arming teachers whom are comfortable with using a fire arm and have training.
@@emperorpalpatine1228 Yea and we all know how 'hard' it is to convert it to fully automatic.... But hey, you need that for hunting/protection right?
@@kristenjameson7839 every transaction DOES NOT require any kind of background check. there are multiple states where person-to-person sales require absolutely NOTHING. I would of thought you knkw that but I guess you deny that for some reason. If you'd like in my neck comment I can give you a link to multiple videos of people buying guns with no background check
1/2 the guns in the world with only 4% of the worlds population? We gotta bump those numbers up 💪
This is why I scrool down the comment section and see if anyone had the same thought as I did. Jesse was right on point. My Q to his is how do you qualify the question? We can site statistics about the amount of guns in US but how do you do that for other countries? I doubt that anyone knows how many guns those countries have except their government. Will they be truthful is giving that info out? And on a side note, why the conversation about the AR when the majority of gun deaths are caused by handguns?
I hope you mean the guns and not the population
I'm trying to dammit
@@mitchellbarlow8779 The majority of deaths are not caused by handguns. They are caused by bad guys using handguns.
@@baja1988_Texas ...and bad toddlers with guns.
They don’t want the poor to arm themselves. They would threaten their stronghold. Big props to all the poor people who used stimulus money to arm themselves!! This is how we keep our RIGHTS.
Uncle Sam was kind enough to level up my collection : )
Who is 'they' exactly?
@@HaloJumpmaster you already know who they are. Call them what you want. The elite, the Illuminati, the GOVERNMENT. Those who call the shots
Absolute hogwash! Two countries where firearm ownership is widespread are AFGHANISTAN and SAUDI ARABIA. Neither of these countries are bastions of liberty or of individual rights.
@Frank Hoffman my right to defend myself with a gun supersedes your ignorance and irrational fear of guns. Don't like it? Come and take it pendejo.
Oh my goodness he did a wonderful job staying calm, cool, and collected while being completely condensended too. (excuse my spelling)
No one claps when Colion makes a very valid point. Everyone claps when host makes a joke
Consider the source of the audience...
They didn't come for thoughtful conversation. They came for the circus.
He never made a point, the part with the teachers is shifting views..why concentrate on the teacher why not the shooter?how did he get the gun?the single mother..how did the area have a high crime rate? the problem with people like him they don't talk the source of the problem but they just rant about what is happening.. No real solutions and sometimes the get rid of problem you have to go back to the beginning.
@@isimioyekunlemarktaiwo3643 In a perfect world with maybe some supernatural powers, you could freeze time and do what you suggested in your comment.
In the real world, you defend against an attack THEN investigate what the reason was for the event.
All these celebrities against guns their body guards have guns what hypocrites
"Why is it called a gun show?"
I don't know, Bill; why is it called a car show?
I thought boat show, but same thing lol.
NOOOO, IT'S TACTICAL MASTURBATION. 😉😉🤣🤣
Antique show. Ban em!! No one just looks..
@@bradharvy13 Only if it a "Tactical" antique show! I guess if their are any old Curio and Antique guns, they should be banned for they were the "Black rifle" of their day!
TXLionHeart they were hoping it would be more of a one-sided conversation and I'm sure the audience was probably cued at gunpoint to respond as they did or mindless followers
Never heard of Colion Noir until this but man he is amazingly intelligent ! My hats off to you sir ! Total respect for you sir !
“But they’re teachers, they don’t want to do that” But they already have. And they have died, trying to literally shield children. Imagine instead of being a human shield they were able to fight back.
Bill Maher: “I can’t imagine anyone trying to take away peoples’ guns.”
Commonwealth of Virginia: "Hold my beer..."
EOD on day 1 of confiscation in VA. Governor, "I think we f&*&ed up!"
RIGHT!
I can't believe these morons are not backing down. The elected asshats should be forced to enforce it personally!
98% of the localities have signed provisions declaring that they will not enforce the governors laws. Annnnd as a resident of Virginia, I don't have any weapons officers.
@@rcintro1489 no.they should be prosecuted for violating the citizens rights.and when maher makes stupid jokes about having sex with guns he needs to be exposed as a pervert
So, according to Maher, because you are a teacher, you don't have the right to defend yourself.
Or others. When you signed up to be a teacher, you implicitly stated that you didn't want to fight or stand up against evil. And if a shooter ends up on your campus, remember that you're a teacher. You signed up for this so you didn't have to fight. And if that shooter enters your room, remember you're a teacher. You don't want a gun to fight back. That's not what you do, right?
I'm a teacher and this line of argument infuriates me. The idea that parents will trust me to shape, mold, and prepare their youth for the real world, but automatically assume I am not fit to defend the lives of their children is mind-boggling. The assumption that, since I'm a teacher I do not want that responsibility is utterly absurd and even insulting.
I would die for my students, but in a nightmare situation like an active shooter, I'd much rather have the option to kill another person to keep my students safe. Hands down, no contest.
"Idiotic clapping"
Margo Channing - correct. If you are a teacher, you only have the right to block bullets with your body.
Yep, Maher made no sense on that,... if you're going to likely die, why not at least have options. No one is saying all teachers should be armed, the beauty is that no one would know who is armed. Notice police stations are not attacked, a criminal would assume someone there would be armed. The facts are, gun control increases crime wherever it has been tried.
I think what Bill misunderstood is that nobody wants to force teachers to carry firearms only give them the option to do so. I agree we need trained security/police personnel to do that job regularly.
Colion is one of the most important figures when it comes to 2A/firearms, no other "Gun-tuber" goes out of their way to advocate this particular right and talk about this topic like he does, partly understandable because they're not an attorney like him who's patient and well spoken/knowledgeable and also probably because it's just to much of a hassle to do so and requires a certain amount of dedication within your life that might have to be taken away from other focuses, but that just solidifies how important he is even more. I just got into him and his videos for only a couple weeks now but I'm glad I did because he's done more towards shifting my views on this topic than anyone
We are very lucky to have you as a spokesman for our rights! Thank you for all you do sir!
“The cops may never show up” - and here we are with the cops showing up to a school shooter and not doing anything
Same Profile Every Time:
Known to be Low status at school
-Known history of Mental Illness
-Know to have been on psychotropic drugs
-Know to have violent ideations and intentions - told someone or posted on Social Media
-Known to Law Enforcement
This is not a gun problem. This is a mental illness problem. Instead of sending billions to Ukraine, Democrats should invest in Mental Health Programs.
@ERRATAS 0202 You have no freedom of Speech, and the cops pay you a visit for sending mean tweets. Don't tell us you are fine.
@ERRATAS 0202 according to politicians and media. Not those involved in the actual problem
@ERRATAS 0202 thank you for self electing yourself to represent the rest of the world.
@ERRATAS 0202 you haven't traveled much
The teacher argument always misses the point. Nobody is planning on handing every teacher a Glock. It would only be those who WANT to carry and who can qualify.
Exactly...and with specialized training. I wish he had expanded on that when asked.
What scares me is that i know the teachers that deserve the guns and i know the ones that want them
@@doug5354 schools could easily make a shooter risk program for teachers
Michael Morouney not only that, if you apply for a CPL. Why the fuck can’t you bring it to work? I can. But I’m an engineer.... how does that make sense?
Just taking down the "Gun free zone " signs and replacing them with a sign saying teachers and faculty may be armed could make a difference in the amount of school shootings. Even if only a few teachers actually carried, the fact that anyone thinking of entering the school wouldn't know which ones and how many.
i carry a gun not to impose my will on others but to keep others from imposeing their will on me
It is a testament to the greatness of these two men's minds that they could have this conversation. If only more Americans did the same.
Whatever side of the debate you are on…this is a great example of two people with differing opinions having a civil and reasonable discussion. We need more of this type of interactions.
This comment should be near the top! Bring civil discourse back!! 👏👏
Joe Rogan does it everyday
Good comment! 👍
@@lloyddobler2227 w comment
This comment should be pinned
I really wish he would have let Mr Noir actually answer half the questions he was asked.
No one ever does it seems
Way too deep for Bill's shallow mind.
S*** at least he gave him the time of day
Noir is an idiot so are you
Yeah really just glad with how well he handled himself. It’s always annoying watching these where they ask a question sway it in there argument let the audience support that idea then give the person 20 second to combat a 2 minute argument.
Remember when we could have conversations about stuff like this without screaming?
Pepperidge Farm remembers...
Colion Noir is INCREDIBLE. I HIGHLY suggest each and every Californian, and American, watch his content.
“I can’t imagine anyone trying to take away peoples’ guns.”
*Beto O’Rourke has entered the chat*
well he is gone now.
@@SuCKeRPunCH187 Bloomberg is here taking over Virginia starting another civil war
*Bloomberg has entered the server*
@@MADSLAYER47 Kentucky now has a bill one week ago for an assault weapons ban, and that's a pro-gun state.
The state of Virginia has entered the chat
lol he quickly stoped that interview when he schooled him with that last statement.
It was an exceptionally insensitive comment Bill made that caused a more visceral reaction from Noir. To suggest to a person who clearly loves the letter of the amendment down to every word, that such language only existed to keep his ancestors enslaved... It's taking an issue he cares very deeply about and tokenizing it. I'm impressed Noir was that composed, and it's fortunate Bill realized the territory he had just tread on.
@@eudaimonistic yea so true
Bill you don't carry a gun but ur security does. The hypocrisy
Maybe he trusts the people who are trained with one and knows he would be useless with one in his hand… nowhere did he say he wants guns abolished, so no, no hypocrisy
Bill has said before he owns a gun. He just doesn't need to carry one to feel like a real man
Not one of the women I've trained to handle guns has ever told me that she wants to carry a gun so that she could feel like a real man.
You have to respect that these two had a conversation about this topic instead of just yelling at each other
Bill Maher is very sharp. He knows exactly when to cut in and interrupt just as the other person is beginning to lay down very logical view points.
Lol this is most of the Leftist Extremist.
That just ends civil debate.
@@squizzlor this is everyone in the public eye, Politicians, talk show hosts, etc. It's all of them.
@Proverbs 17-18 just like a jew
Mr. R our society has been having this debate. Guess you’ve been living under a rock for the past 20 or 30 years
"When tyranny becomes law, rebellion becomes duty!"
-Thomas Jefferson
Booker DeWitt good point brother
give me liberty or give me death
Jesus, look at all of these right-wing bumper sticker quotes...
Bullshit fake quotes
Mate, if the government has become so corrupt and evil that you have to rebel, your guns won't do shit. They'll look like paper toys in comparison with what the government has. Instead of thinking about how to work in the system and make it better by being educated and informed, you're thinking of rebellion, gotta love Americans, always taking stupid to the next level.
🇺🇸🇺🇸Colton Noir, great interview, w common sense and real American answers/conversation. Thanks for standing for truth!🇺🇸🇺🇸
A prime instance of civil discussion on a controversial topic. We need this to happen way more often.
"Bill Maher: “I can’t imagine anyone trying to take away peoples’ guns.”
Then you aren't paying attention to your own party.
Brandon Comer the one thing I will say that I think bill said. The people that would be taking the gun are cops, who love guns. 90% of the military would revolt and refuse to “participate” in an unlawful order as such. Now that is an immediate interpretation. In 50 years, the military will be a new generation who doesn’t know better. Most service member are truly fighting for your right. So it’s interesting to see “the government” taking guns. If it’s not military and police. That is a new perspective that has just popped into my mind watching this video
That was my initial thought... then how do you explain your own desire to further regulate who owns what guns?
Or you are listening to the propaganda from yours
@@blinkwire01 such as?
That...or he's lying. Which do you think is more likely?
I love how Bill immediately ends the interview when he has no response.
Dirty Harry_502 Bill Is a douche canoe that is right way more than his Douche canoe hohorts.... But He's actually conducting this interview very well,. Admittedly, i've only watched the first 5 minutes. But in the first 5 minutes, He is basically agreeing with him and Speaking out against his deepstate handlers. So perhaps he fucks it up in the last 5 minutes.
It was a 12 minute interview
-That way he does not make a fool out of himself.
My eighth grade history, teacher was strapped and he was the only person I would feel safe with during a school shooting
I am a teacher who wouldn’t trust other teachers with guns around my children. However, as a gun owner who has experienced a lock down, I sure wish I had my gun with me.
Bring it with you~ no one has to know but you.
The teachers would be selected based on their level of competence.
Optional teacher carry: regulated by the school board (I’m not familiar with how a school board is elected or held accountable, so maybe this is already a bad idea) with training requirements and continued learning, as well as bi-annual psych evaluations; all of that incentivized by a salary premium.
If no one ever knew which teachers had them then the idea that all of them could be armed could serve as deterrent. In theory anyway. For those that do plan it out. If someone is mentally unstable, as has been yet another debated question , they likely wouldn’t think it through in that manner.
Also you’d have to be sure that if the worst case scenario occurred that teacher wouldn’t hesitate to use it & drop a student/ kid. Also what would be rules of Engagement? Would they have to wait to be fired at , and then could only return fire in self defense of them and the students. What if someone pulls a gun out & threatens everyone but hasn’t fired it ? It’s 1 of of 100 or 1000 questions the whole idea creates.
But the worst thing is the fact we are even having this idea & discussion! Which can lead to more thoughts about arming cashiers/workers at Walmart, grocery stores, McDonald’s, etc… everywhere because these tragedies are occurring everywhere. And if it’s not many that were killed, it just makes local news as another murder(s), particularly in major cities where unfortunately most people have become so used to seeing it on news it’s as normal as watching the traffic & weather reports before going to work.
Yet you trust the teacher to teach your child.... C'mon dude, if you trust them to teach your child and keep them safe without a pewpew, you should feel safer knowing now they have the opportunity to save your child if they did have one.
I also love how much smarter and more eloquent Colion is than everyone in that room.
Agreed!
I live the big word wow factor he uses to blow their minds
@@marythomas1198 Simple, you hear "a lot of NRA excuses", because you refuse to actually accept the logic of what he is saying. You don't think gun enthusiasts hear a lot of "libtard excuses" when they pose their argument? Here, specifically his way of expressing his opinions is clearer and more focused than his opponents. I suggest you approach this from a logical argument perspective rather than a preconceived political view.
Huh? Bill wiped the floor with this guy.
@@marythomas1198 it's smarter because you got to figure like this if you're a kid in a classroom someone steps in with a gun wouldn't you want the person that has to defend you to have the most advantage as much as possible if someone is meeting you with violence sometimes the only way to try to come out on top is to meet them back with the same type of force or at least something close to it rather than just being in the position of vulnerability it's all about survival of the fittest
Seems like everytime Noir brings up a good point Maher just changes the topic.
That is a strategy he uses.
There were several times in the interview where I internally said "Noir was halfway through answering your question(s), just let him finish the answer please!"
That’s the Democrat’s and the media’s (but I repeat myself) M.O. That’s exactly where I’d like to see people like Noir call it out when they pivot. Something as simple as, “are you ceding that last point to me?”
Agreed. Especially his very last point regarding the great irony concerning the 2nd Amendment (and slavery). I would’ve liked him to complete his point.
But of course, Bill ended the segment.
Right as soon as bill Maher tried to bring up no background check at a gun show nonsense, he changed the subject when he was going to hear that you have to have one, even at a gun show.
See Columbia v Heller, dont have to have a militia or anything of the sort to be able to own a firearm for home protection.
Colion was amazing, very level headed and really he should be a spokesperson for the firearm industry. And great job Bill Maher, loved the questions and your level headedness.
Go, Colion!
"The government is always going to out gun you."
They also said the British Army was the best and unbeatable
Look what happened
Look at Afghanistan. 35 yrs against 2 superpowers. Outside help helps a lot, of course, but so it did in the American Revolution with great help from France. People too quickly assume that any gov v citizens would be only that, and not face the fact that the gov attrition rate would be staggering, as much as 50% would refuse to fight. Most likely scenario would either be a slow burn to stalemate, or quick military coup in a matter of hrs.
@@ts89540 a terrorist organization in countries is not fighting that country, if we were at war with the afghan government it would be no contest. Just like North Korea with all their empty threats, if it came to war with a third world countries government that war wouldn't last more than one day.
There are 125 million gun owners in this country. The Posse Comitatus act of 1878 forbids the Federal government from using the US Military against the citizens of this country for any reason. But given the current lack respect for the Constitution and Bill of Rights that exists at the federal government level, who knows? But I'd put my money on the 125 million.
Maybe outgunned, but never outnumbered. Interesting scenerio.
Colion is a great American. Thank you for what you do.
👍👍👍
Until he brings up issues of police brutality towards black people again, then the NRA and the rest of the 2A community will distance themselves from him...again... LMAO
I did not know that he's an attorney, I think a major consensus of many people would be that a huge percentage of lawyers are self serving, that only take advantage of the victims &/or people they supposedly represent (especially those being in a position to need representation.) The saying that the only ones who win in a court battle is the lawyers rings true.
Alternately, and I've said before after watching Colion's videos, being well educated, spoken and exposing truth in these arguments, that I highly regard and respect Mr. Noir for his position, stance, etc, and fiercely representing our freedoms and gun rights!
I agree with you
MrSmokelife well that 2nd amendment clearly done the total opposite of what it’s suppose to do😂😂
It's better to be a warrior in a garden than a gardener in a war. - Bruce Lee
Gun nut is a compliment to me 😆. I've come out of the womb around guns. My grandfather had me cleaning and handling guns before I was even old enough to hunt. There is background checks conducted at gun shows.
This man is so well spoken- and I’m not talking about Bill!
He’s got a TH-cam channel. 👍
Thanks dude. I know who he is😎
Chris Federoff Bill made several arguments as well
Chris Federoff he let one argument go. There have already been several attempts of the government to take Americans guns! Hell it happened during Hurricane Katrina under the Bush administration
Tre' Roney yup. They won’t ever stop trying because they don’t want a population that can defend themselves. That is exactly why the authors of the constitution created the second amendment. It’s is the law yet here we are defending our right!
Jesus christ this is frustrating! The whole point about teachers is not that we would *force* them to be armed. Rather, the point is that we should *allow* teachers to be armed if they want to be. After being trained.
And they should be allowed to be armed if they wish it. Whether they are at school, or church or the supermarket. What is the difference? A right to protect oneself shall not be infringed. Every person has the right to defend themselves because no one else will, as we see when cops and guards don't go into the building or are ten minutes away from helping.
@@robertbennett848 its funny cause steven segull made a good point we allow guns to protect our banks and money and jewelry but not to protect schools? we need to put a wall up on califonia and new york as well cause there retardedness is spreading
I was disappointed he didn’t make that point too.
@@robertbennett848 exactly
@@robertbennett848 Sad to say, but some of those teachers that wish to be armed, are not good people. It's concerning that conservative media outlets clamor about liberal school systems and teachers filling kids with progressive ideas, but these same conservative outlets support arming those teachers?
As someone from the UK where we can't carry any form of self deffence, from a baseball bat to a knife we get serious jail time if found to be carrying anything for the purpose of self deffence. The criminals obviously don't care and carry knives, guns and whatever else they want. So we are put in a position where we are helpless to defend ourselves. We have to pray that when we are in a life threatening situation that we can call the police and explain where we are and what's going on. Them survive until police arrive and save us. Am I the only person that thinks that is completely unfair and stupid?
Colion is the Ben Shipiro of gun rights advocates. Nobody beats him in a debate when it comes to 2A arguments. God bless you Colion.
Compared to Colion, Shapiro is a hack!
Shapiro is a total douche 😂
Mad respect that Bill asked this gentleman to be on his show.
He did it to try and humiliate him though...
@@ThePlantedTankTV I disagree. It’s a comedy show so of course he will have his jabs but Bill was actually pretty respectful here
So far i haven't heard any digs yet
It’s not very respectful to say to your guest, admit it you wanna have sex with your guns don’t you! Naw, I think you went a little too far on giving props there.
He is a troll, making money off of professionals. No respect necessary
Colion Noir opened my eyes...I am getting my first gun. With all this craziness about defunding the police, I realized now why I need a gun for home defense.
Good for you. If you can, get a concealed carry permit too, so you can defend yourself outside the home if need be.
A gun and a republican president
welcome to the enlightened side my friend now take this for what you will if everyone had guns we could spend less money on police, defunding could possibly work only in the mind that if everyone was willing to be their own first responder the funny thing is the people who want to defund are the same cowards that dont like guns SMH...the irony
@@bmxkidsmorehouse3283 or libertarian we need people to quickly stop voting democrat all together!! but republicans will always need an opposition to keep power from becoming tyrannical like the forefathers intended it would still be a grave danger to society if 1 party won all the time
make sure to get plenty of training
"Willing" and Trained armed teachers makes more sense than 1 or 2 security guards.
Great interview. That guy is a legend and I love Mr. Noir's closing statement! So spot on.
He tried race baiting him not once, but twice. Lol.
Hey he invited the guy on and was very respectful
zombiewack
Respectful? A number of times he attempted to paint the guys views into the most horrible interpretation to make him seem like a stereotype of the horrible NRA supporting person.
Respectful is the wrong word, if I invite you onto a show in order to speak softly and constantly call everything you believe idiotic. I’m not being nice, i’m being manipulative asshole. That’s what was being done.
I hope people of color see this is the tactics of the democrats.....racebating
Why should his skin color manner he's American.bill you are a jack ass
three times
me: Why can't I have a gun
Bill: because your an electrician
Crowd: cheers
Bill: **says anything against guns**
Audience: **CHEER**
Yeah exactly I was thinking the same thing, like uh that's their occupation... what does that have to do with protecting lives?
The audience was the worst.
The audience is a bunch of bobblehead NPCs. I'll admit that I agree with Maher at least as often as not. For example, I think drugs should be legal and I can see that radical Islam is a serious threat. On the other hand, his views on guns and his constant genuflecting to any and all black people who come on his show get annoying.
I'm an electrician.... FUCK! Just bought a gun couple days ago muahahahahaha!
Great interview. Feel like a lot of people, including Bill, learned a few things.
I'm a teacher, and I'd feel much better if I were allowed to carry on campus. Don't put your assumptions on me, Bill Maher!
I pray you are never put in a situation where you would have to defend yourself or your students. Thank you for your service as a teacher.
@@askedofgod9067 thank you!
@@askedofgod9067 Me too. A good prayer to pray. But I also would pray that if that unfortunate circumstance ever did arise, Ms. Glenn would have the tools, the training and the wherewithal to save herself and her students from the ultimate evil of a mass school shooter!
I don't blame you I would too.
Totally agree, I know several teachers who have plenty of firearms training from military, police and sportsman that would totally be comfortable carrying a concealed or having a gun safe in their desks.
Colion is a good guy. Thanks for being there for us.
What makes him a good guy?
@@judethaddeus9856 Christian, strong work ethic (see personal accomplishments/education), embraces the American Constitution, promotes gun safety, and based on what I've witnessed, he's a civil guy who can carry on a civil conversation. As far as I can tell, we're like-minded with a shared value system. This makes him a "good guy" in my book.
@@badgerbait8351 Great logic and arguments, great character, very articulate
@@judethaddeus9856 What makes him a bad guy?
@@jimmydesperado2936 He's a troll. You won't get an anwer to your question from him.
I've bought several firearms from gun shows in Louisiana. Every time, I had a background check done. I went to a gun show in TX and could not buy a firearm because I did not have a TX ID. Mine was Louisiana.
You are so incredibly well versed it's scary. I love seeing you interact live with other well known personalities. I thought this interview was very civil and refreshing. Kudos to Mr. Maher for being civil despite his personal views. Well done both of you!
Colion: I'm sure there are some guns around here.
Bill: There are.
Audience: pisses their pants
defiantwarrior76 Colion was hinting at the fact he was concealing
@@arthurmorgan6087 think he was packing on stage? if so, that's awesome. i just think Maher's producer/security wouldn't have allowed it.
No Arthur, he would not be allowed to carry during the interview. He was making the very valid point that there are armed security guards at every television studio, including that one. Also the point that it's very easy to say "I'm not armed" when you have armed security literally guarding the doors to where you live or work.
@Tartarus Fallen one people that can afford others to carry a gun for them, don't want citizens to carry guns
@Tartarus Fallen one Or they still hate guns while they feel forced to buy one. A few month ago I read about a Liberal in Texas who go so scared by his Conservatives neighbors that he bought an AR-15. Does he really love guns now?
Maybe it's a fake account but that would be the best way to be hated by both side right?
"You can't beat the military". That is assuming the military is even for this. Soldiers are American citizens too.
Exactly if there would be tyranical government in the US I can imagine one or two branches of military going against that government.
Yeah they act like this is North Korea or China where the military would turn on it's own citizens. Most of the military and law enforcement are pro 2nd amendment. Most people join the military to protect our freedoms, not to help take them away. 'Murica!
That's another good point that gets lost in these arguments. Soldiers would have divided loyalties in the event of a rebellion against the government. It's not certain all, or even most, will choose the government.
so if the military will not fight against its population why does the population need guns?
You are playing chicken vs egg.
The guns stay.
I'm impressed that Bill allowed him to answer.
Thanks Colion, I've been a follower and listener long before finding this older video, but even then, your thinking is clear, concise, and on target. Thanks, and keep pushing the loons to think about it.
Label me a gun nut because I like the idea of having the chance of surviving an attack? Yeah, I can see the logic in that.
Bro i love your profile picture
I think it's for the gun lovers who get a shit load of guns just to shoot random shit for fun , I don't think he's referring to you sir 😅
@@angeldejesus7977 I'm both, and what's wrong with shooting shit?
I’m actually a woman and there’s nothing wrong with collecting guns either. Guns does not equal violence. My family has a collective of dozens of guns, they go to the range on the weekend. None of them are violent. They all have highly respected jobs. I think Maher’s attempt to make all gun advocates into nuts is deplorable.
Vermillion Bear Thanks.
I am a teacher and a former Marine, I am definitely capable of being armed if my school division were to allow such things.
1stVARifleman it would be nice for teachers to have guns obviously with training. No need for mental checkups because that should be the first step in being a teacher.my school has “security guards” and these people don’t have guns and can be be over ran by a shooter. If teachers had guns, school shooting rates will drop
Most non-gun people are terrified of guns. They think teachers would need months of training just to keep from shooting themselves or some poor kid. They need to go to a range or with a friend and do some shooting under the eye of an experienced shoot with a small powered weapon like an AR. They need to go to a gun show and try and buy a gun. I guarantee the NRA would provide the guns and the training for teachers, free of charge.
Thank you for your service. As a teacher, I would feel more safe if I knew a "good guy with a gun" were on campus.
Here is why it will never happen. All the multitudes of weak, touchy feely teachers, board members and education leaders are scared to death that if Teachers were allowed to be armed in todays youth society and the lack of respect the youth has for its teachers would see a time when a youth got up in a teachers face and drove that teacher to such anger that he/she pulled out the gun and shot the kid. This of course is the most extreme of scenario but I can promise you this has crossed every one of those in charges minds. They figure its not worth the risk of even one incident vs the benefits of being able to stop an active shooter. Because of this I fear arming teachers in schools will never happen.
Jimbo B. If some teacher with a gun decides to shoot a kid, you best believe that teacher would’ve killed that kid or those kids with or without a gun. Just because someone has a gun doesn’t automatically make them a psychopath who wants to go on a killing spree. This is the filth that people like you spread. Keep watching Colion. You’ll learn more and probably change your mind. I’m assuming this was the only video of him you’ve seen.
I love that these are civil conversations happening. Here is where I get frustrated: I am a concealed carrier, and have a degree in the education field. When he made the comment that the reason they shouldn’t be armed is simply because they’re teachers, I got a sour taste in my mouth. It is the same sour taste in my mouth from every moment a male has told me I shouldn’t be carrying a full frame pistol, simply because I’m a small frame female. It implies that teachers are ONLY teachers, and are incapable of being sufficiently trained in other facets of life. I homeschool my children, and choose not to utilize my degree, as there are too many politics in school curriculum (from both sides of politics). I am more than just a teacher. I am a mother, a teacher, an amateur chef, a live in maid, a first aid provider to my family, an amateur dog trainer to my pets, and a protector. I am trained to conceal carry a firearm, and I also have a degree to teach. The implication that the two facets can’t coexist is close minded and contributes to the problem. Does that mean that a champion boxer is incapable of being gentle with his wife, or that a police officer runs their home like a prison, or a doctor is incapable of being a good cook? When it’s put into perspective the implied ideal that he provided can become obviously ridiculous.
Does he not realize there are many teachers who grew up with firearms.
So in this conversation Bill never allows him to finish a point, redirects when he tries to answer Bill's question, and then multiple times tries to race bait with some of his commentary. Colion gets two thumbs up, Bill gets none for this.
Agreed!😊👍🏾
Seriously man, Bill never let him finish a single point
This seems to be typical of all these taking heads. Colion is a class act.
Surely right Tyler Duzan👍
Agreed. Gotta cut a lawyer off. Bill should've said, "I object."
Bill Maher: asks question
Colin Noir: begins answering question
Bill Maher: interrupts and moved onto next point.
Rinse and repeat
I watched it, I didn't see bill interrupting and just moving on.
This is actually one of the few time's I've seen Bill be reasonable in his conversation with guests
@@nopenope1510 you obviously didn't watch it mate
Bill a pot-head that is guilty of asking all the questions his stream of conciousness has, in an amount of time that his patience doesnt.
Bill can be dishonest in his questioning at times, but hes terrible at disingenuous interviews and you can see when he does it from a mile away. Sometimes it's simply that west coast ivory tower bubble.
He may be a liberal and a hard one on some things, but hes still one of the last few that will still engage in conversation without sheiking like a banshee when people disagree.
When they finally force him out at HBO, you're gonna see the real change of left-right dialogue come to fruition.
The next 10 years are not going to be easy for America.
@@nopenope1510 not only did he interrupt not allowing him to have a complete thought and the reason bill did that (not saying it was his choice) is because he knows noir knows what he's talking about
Pretty much. Noticed that too.
God bless you, Colion Noir.
He is such a smart black man, very articulate and well educated!
Bill Maher is a master of asking a question and then immediately interrupting you before you can answer.
I think that's Ben Shapiro's title. In any case, Maher is a close second.
@@tass2001
Ben Shapiro gives people a fair chance, but he usually has a lot more to say than most people.
Tucker is above and beyond either of them as far as not letting people talk, IMO.
Golgometh Layceon He learned that from Sean Hannity!! Lol
Dtyler171 because He BS is FOS and like Diarrhea can be explosive!! Lol... BS is a Hypocrite too
@@Jessiejam-44
What language are you speaking?
I can't believe Maher had someone on his show that actually knows what he's talking about. Great job as always Mr. Noir.
A black guy too, so he can't even play the race card. Crazy straight white christian males and their love for guns. Bill damaging all the narratives here.
6000 homicide each year from gun homicide in USA. Yeah its really something to be proud of.
@@kejiri3593 By your name alone it sounds like you're a real dumbass.
@@bubbadano1508 Ok, .let me use another example. Do you think every country in the world should have nukes? Because hey its not the weapon that kills, its the person behind it.
@@kejiri3593 Stupidest thing I've heard in a year.
Great interview. Fan of this guy and props to Bill for making a reasonable effort to resist hiding in the echo chambers unlike 90% of media figures today
Great dialogue!!!
Bill Maher sounded like he was actually listening at first, then he went to his script and sounded like the fool that he is.
I was thinking the exact same thing. I enjoyed watching the conversation between the two which started out very amicably, and then he forgot he has an audience to pander to and quickly flipped the script. Sad.
Bill: the government is always going to out gun you.
George Washington: hold my beer.
Good thing there's no difference between fighting a failing empire an ocean away and fighting the massive military complex you've paid for that lives right on top of you. Yeah, that's a real good thing.
Nick Name cool argument bro. Doesn’t really hold up when you consider that at the time the colonists had less power than the American citizens have today. Considering the sheer numbers we have as well as the guns. But if you want to think that way go ahead. You can be a “British sympathizer” if you want. There were many back then making the same argument you’re making now. :)
I guess Nick doesn't realize that at a minimum there are 100 million gun owners in the US, a large percentage of them are either law enforcement or ex-military. In contrast, if you count the various reserve forces available, the US military is at best 2 million strong... most of those stationed overseas. Our military does not believe it could suppress the population successfully, even if it wanted to (which it does not).
Nick Name “I realize that I’m dealing with” I’m going to shut you down right there. Scarecrow arguments will get you nowhere friend. You lost. Now move along sir.
Nick Name and again large scale consensus to rebel has happened numerous times across history, despite the efforts to turn people against each other via divide and conquer strats that the left employ and you consume.
Colion, you definitely are amazing at articulating your great values!
Well said. Well delivered. Spot on.
Bill literally wouldn’t let him answer about gun shows not having a loophole.
He knew the answer wasn't going to help confirm his narrative and had to pivot away as quick as possible.
Liberals love their delusion, they do not like to have their cognitive dissonance triggered.
Yes! This grinded my gears
Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmnn
Pain
They don't seem to understand the definition of a "loophole"
“Teachers don’t want to fight”
I don’t think anyone wants to fight💀😂 but you have to.
I think Bill was being unreasonable and Colion missed an opportunity.
He should have countered that if a teacher wants to bring a firearm to school and use it on children, there is nothing that will stop that. Having armed teachers, adds 0 to the risk factor. It should not be required of teachers but if a teacher WANTS to carry, and wants to be armed, there should be no problem. And yes, some will not want to, but that will wither as the shootings continue.
And once enough people have had enough and the majority of teachers are armed, the shooters will pick some place else. Mass shootings always occur at soft targets. If you harden the school system with guards, metal detectors and armed teachers, they will fuck off to somewhere else (concerts, movie theaters, restuarants, etc)
Arming teachers is a viable solution to protecting the youth.
What about the teachers who step in front of students during school shootings
@Bridget Walker right? Lol more like albino Obama
@@pubghandguns8960
...and if disturbed students, who ordinarily would not have access to a firearm, take it off the teacher or from the desk?
@@naywahn you dont leave a gun on or in the desk. You have it in a secured holster. Something like an omnivore which we made to prevent other people from taking the gun of of your waist
Finally a competent debate of two differing opinions that never lacks in respect to each other
2 things I see here. 1) 2 adults with different opinions being able to discuss it like grown-ass men. This is how it's done people. 2) I am damn proud to have Noir on the front lines. Nobody I would rather have out there defending 2A.
Love how all the comments are so positive towards Colion. Was really expecting a lot more gun haters since it is on Bill Maher's channel.
andrewf0784 “liberals lose in a proper debate scenario” I could turn that around and point you to everyone on say...Twitter...who as soon as a “liberal” as you call them, suddenly starts winning the argument the other guy suddenly, either ignores them or blocks them...
Ember Arashi Twitter is not a proper debate scenario. Have you seen a debate?
"Why is it called a gun show?"
I dunno Bill, why is a RV show called a RV show...?
The funniest part about that was how quickly bill changed the subject when he was presented with the obvious answer. My man barely got out, "It's an aggregation of firearms" before Bill was cutting him off and changing the subject.
The bit about teachers being armed from Bill being absurd was pretty cheesy too. When colion have him a legitimate answer, Bill said it's because "Teachers don't want to be that!" How would you know, Bill? Have you asked any teachers explicitly? Performed any studies of polls? I guarantee you two things if you had. Some teachers would refuse while others would absolutely say yes. I also guarantee that if teachers did start packing, random acts of school shootings would immediately trickle to a stop.
A these celebrities against guns their body guards have guns what hypocrites
or a gem show, or an art show...
@@jeffreystayman375 or a car show. they have common guns for sale and concept guns for show
I'll show you a gun show:💪....... I'll show myself out 🤦🏼♂️