Very well done! For those interested, another example of this piece played very well is a recording by Alexander Borovsky. In my opinion, Borovsky has few peers in Bach on the piano, but recordings are very hard to find.
fabulous performance! - re the comment on a "circus act" - it obviously takes all sorts to make a world - to me it seems like a double act of homage, by performer and transcriber.....
I like hearing it on both (not at the same time, of course). Each instrument has unique things to offer. Generally, the piano allows for more expression and fine detail. A pianist can play a chord in one hand and make one note or series of notes stand out. A supreme example of this piece and of bringing out hidden detail is the recording by the pianist Alexander Borovsky.
@@7Jaegermeister while very true, this work is so dense that without a pedal board it loses an essential feeling, the performer has to compensate with pedal, non uniform articulation and octave shifting. But nevertheless sounds great. Would recommend vikingur olafssons performance of one of the organ sonatas adagio, its better for me on piano than organ!
Fugue: Good speed, but too much pedal. Compare to performances by Borovsky, and by Kit Armstrong: th-cam.com/video/Mi2Hr6-4Zeo/w-d-xo.html who takes it fast, with the right amount of pedal, and perfect touch.
@Franz Liszt Ah, don't mind. Just one of these guys claiming that Bach only works on instruments of his time. So Bach is never meant to be played on the piano - how dare you Glenn Gould, Andras Schiff and Tatiana Nikolayeva! Please get yourself a Harpsichord.
Bach transcribed works of other contemporary composers especially Vivaldi. I believe he would be delighted to see his works transcribed to other instruments. I prefer the organ version, but this transcription has merit and is extremely difficult to play as expected from Liszt. But for his harpsichord works I prefer them on the harpsichord.
Stefan Schmalhaus I completely agree. It was a serious lapse in his judgement. We really didn't need this. I'm shocked any pianist even plays it, with all the repertoire pianists have.
darren motise We don't "need" any music then, by that reasoning. What if a pianist wants to play an organ piece, but cannot play the organ? I see no reason why they should be denied the pleasure.
I find piano arrangements of Bach's organ works problematic, but they do allow the concert-going public to hear repertoire that they might not have access to otherwise. And there is nothing wrong with reading Bach's organ music at the piano for private meditation.
![ไม่ต้องมีที่ที่ให้ฉันอยู่ แต่ขอแค่มีฉันอยู่ก็พอ (Spaceless) - getsunova [SHORT FILM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MuT0d_cvJkc/mqdefault.jpg)
This is a fantastic performance. What a soulful pianist.
Astonishing!!!!! What amazing playing. That fugue is just breathtaking 😮 Bravo!!!!!! 🎊 🎉 👏 👏 👏
Magnificent! Thanks for posting! 🥰🌹🐝🦘💐🎈🦋🎶🎹💃🏻🕺🏻🍀🌷🍒😝👍😀
Beautifully played! Cohesive and does justice to the arrangement for piano. Majestic!
Все оценки от слова очень: очень сильно, в одном порыве, очень пропущено через себя, очень по-своему и очень артистично. Браво!
6:25 for the start of the fugue.
6:25
本当に素敵な演奏で、この動画は1日5回は視聴しています。
ピアノでパイプオルガンのような壮大な表現で、聴いていると、幸せな気持ちになります。
Brilliant performance of both parts!
Amazing performance. That has to be one of the best pianos I’ve ever heard.
this is just too brilliant
Very well done! For those interested, another example of this piece played very well is a recording by Alexander Borovsky. In my opinion, Borovsky has few peers in Bach on the piano, but recordings are very hard to find.
6:25 for the fugue.
fantastic sound
Sublime.
supereb amazing
Bravo.
Amazing!
Thanks for the upload.
Organ players observing all the rolled rubato: "look what they need to mimic a fraction of our power!"
In some pieces but piano is a better instrument
fabulous performance! - re the comment on a "circus act" - it obviously takes all sorts to make a world - to me it seems like a double act of homage, by performer and transcriber.....
WOW
Stefan , can i see you compose a btter piece ?
この曲を弾きたくて楽譜を購入したが、難しすぎる。
Correct tempo of the fugue. Thank you. just a tad too fast though.
So which is it?
Self contradiction isn’t inconsistent
It's great but nothing will ever compare to hearing it on an organ.
I like hearing it on both (not at the same time, of course). Each instrument has unique things to offer. Generally, the piano allows for more expression and fine detail. A pianist can play a chord in one hand and make one note or series of notes stand out. A supreme example of this piece and of bringing out hidden detail is the recording by the pianist Alexander Borovsky.
7Jaegermeister Thank you, i'll check that out.
@@7Jaegermeister while very true, this work is so dense that without a pedal board it loses an essential feeling, the performer has to compensate with pedal, non uniform articulation and octave shifting. But nevertheless sounds great. Would recommend vikingur olafssons performance of one of the organ sonatas adagio, its better for me on piano than organ!
she can't stand herself on playing those liszt and rakhmaninov styles,. if anyone knows reference of Gould playing this, please share the link
I don’t think Gould ever performed any Bach transcriptions
Fugue: Good speed, but too much pedal. Compare to performances by Borovsky, and by Kit Armstrong:
th-cam.com/video/Mi2Hr6-4Zeo/w-d-xo.html
who takes it fast, with the right amount of pedal, and perfect touch.
Absurdly fast Fantasia…
too fast
Too fast!!!!!!!!!!!
The fugue is too slow and quiet))
To the contrary, it’s faster than usual, but it’s supposed to be allegro, so it’s actually quite accurate
@@thereyougoagain1280 It was a joke, you don't understand me. I like this performance very much.
I know it's a fantasia, but this really meant to be played on an organ...
I'm sure Bach would have disagreed with the notion of certain music being "meant" for one instrument over the others.
@Franz Liszt Ah, don't mind. Just one of these guys claiming that Bach only works on instruments of his time. So Bach is never meant to be played on the piano - how dare you Glenn Gould, Andras Schiff and Tatiana Nikolayeva! Please get yourself a Harpsichord.
organ = boring
Bach transcribed works of other contemporary composers especially Vivaldi. I believe he would be delighted to see his works transcribed to other instruments. I prefer the organ version, but this transcription has merit and is extremely difficult to play as expected from Liszt. But for his harpsichord works I prefer them on the harpsichord.
слишком эксцентричное исполнение, особенно Фантазии. Мне не понравилось.
Liszt turned this great piece of music into a pathetic circus act.
Zzzzzzz...
Stefan Schmalhaus I completely agree. It was a serious lapse in his judgement. We really didn't need this. I'm shocked any pianist even plays it, with all the repertoire pianists have.
darren motise We don't "need" any music then, by that reasoning. What if a pianist wants to play an organ piece, but cannot play the organ? I see no reason why they should be denied the pleasure.
I find piano arrangements of Bach's organ works problematic, but they do allow the concert-going public to hear repertoire that they might not have access to otherwise. And there is nothing wrong with reading Bach's organ music at the piano for private meditation.
So none of you can listen to this and perhaps get a better understanding of Liszt and the way he saw others’ music. Complete lack of insight it seems.