MikroTik CRS354-48P-4S+2Q+RM Review Best Value 48x PoE+ On Market Today?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 เม.ย. 2020
- As always, check out Rohit's main site review for more in-depth analysis and some bits we could not cover in this video: www.servethehome.com/mikrotik...
With 48x PoE+ ports, over 700W of PoE power, 4x SFP+ 10GbE, and 2x QSFP+ 40GbE ports for under $750, the MikroTik CRS354-48P-4S+2Q+RM is an incredible value. It may be the best 48-port 802.3af/at PoE switch value on the market today. We found SMB-friendly management options including GUIs and integration with PoE monitoring, fault detection, and power cycling. We see if this may be the best value today for a new 48x 1GbE PoE+ port switch with 10GbE and 40GbE capabilities.
Other STH articles discussed in this video:
- MikroTik CRS354-48G-4S+2Q+RM review (non-PoE version): www.servethehome.com/mikrotik...
- MikroTik CRS305-1G-4S+IN review: www.servethehome.com/mikrotik...
- SFP+ to 10Gbase-T converter guide: www.servethehome.com/sfp-to-1... - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
We use CRS 328 24 port poe 500w as access switches all over the place and they switches are rock solid. As soon you get all configuration done , plug and forget. The switch OS is match more then just access port or trunk in term of traffic handling. Right now mikrotik added MC-LAG which will allow integration for compute level into spine/leaf design. Passive Poe goes well with IoT devices.
the ~800W don't get dissipated in the switch, only maybe 100W. Of course, you still need to move a lot of air because there's no heatsinks on all the PoE ICs.
At long last, this European brand get some credit for its products :) Can we hope to see reviews for their 60GHz line of systems ?
Great video as always but for @ 10:10 - Its not really a 800W box as most of the power gets send through the poe and is not converted to heat inside the box itself. True you have more heat to move caused by converstion losses for poe power but nothing close to 800W.
Totally right. Should have been more clear. Can only film in the late evening (10PM and later) these days :-/
Its finally here !!!!
Thanks for the review, I was in doubt between the Ubiquiti Networks EdgeSwitch 48 750W and the Mikrotik CRS354-48P-4S+2Q+RM
But this video convinced me to go and buy the Mikrotik. If not the 40Gbe ports ;-)
Great Thanks. So this MikroTik switch has 2 QSFP ports. What would you consider for 40GbE routing?
Can't decide between this and the 24P switch, but can't find either on the market, so ... any idea where to buy them?
i've tossed all my CISCO stuff and gone full Mikrotik. never looked back. don't miss anything from CISCO. i have smoother performance, easier configurations, and my wallet is MUCH happier. and given that Mikrotik gives you the ENTIRE suite of tools on ANY and EVERY product... game over. Mikrotik FTW.
Certainly the best alphabet soup on the market.
Wich 1-hop security features does it have? Does it support access lists?
yes, port forwarding, port isolation, mac filtering.
Any chance that you would review the RB4011iGS+RM
from Mikrotik?
Can you review the CRS328-24P-4S+RM?
Will see what we can do on that. Thanks for the suggestion.
ServeTheHomeVideo Also, I find the RB1100AHx4 Dude Edition fascinating, would love to see a review of that.
As an owner of this switch for 2 years now, I can say it is quiet, solid, and absolutely reliable. Great managed switch features and I can run all my Unifi access points and Raspberry Pi devices from POE. Don't regret buying it at all!
Sounds so fun to connect a bunch of rpis to run some absurd computing cluster poe style...
Not saying it makes sense, just saying it'd be fun
Those types of clusters are more common than you would think. PoE makes remote power cycle easy as well. We talked a bit about why they are used in www.servethehome.com/aoa-analysis-marvell-thunderx2-equals-190-raspberry-pi-4/
Is it only me that puts this video at fast forward to 1.25 ?
Can these guys be stacked ? I guess using the 40gbe
I wish... Mikrotik and stacking aren't exactly the word combination that can be used together... You can still daisy chain them, but, yeah... No control-plane redundancy here...
yes in the garbage when they burn out.
Does it auto detect ethernet and POE connection
Yes
For me I don't see the need for a 48 port POE switch at home, but maybe somebody need it. I do really like having the option though, and having the 40Gig uplinks is pretty cool
These are more for the SMB market, but there are those with larger homes with multiple Wi-Fi APs and cameras plus networking to each room.
Yeah... 48 PoE ports for home is a bit too much... Too bad that CRS354-48G-4S+2Q+RM doesn't have, say, 4 PoE ports... With 12 10G ports, 44 1G standard ports and 4 1G PoE ports, I'd be set.
Cameras are something I had not considered, that would make it made understandable for larger "mansion" style homes
@@ServeTheHomeVideo Still... 48 ports... I can see those homes using CRS328-24P-4S+RM for APs an IPCs, but you'd need a lot of Mikrotik GPER things to cover the house and fill this switch :)
@@kharkin0 If you use breakout cables it works. QSFP+ to SFP+ Breakouts!
Patrick, plz stop comparing MT to ES, the ubiquiti junk can not handle half the throuput or PPS that MT's can, MT's can near match the Junipers, which incidentally beat the cisco.
The only thing MT and ES's have is price similarity, thast where it ends
I'd go for used Brocade ICX6610 over this one any day. It has 4 QSFP ports, 8 SFP+ and 48 POE+
Yes anyone with half a brain would do this and not use Microtik crap.
Price wise it's twice this much...
@@MartijnPet Got one off of eBay for 225 for a POE model. This is used enterprise gear that performs so much better than any new Mikrotik stuff. Plus Mikrotitk is really only good as a L2 device. Anything above that it slows down to a crawl.
Normally with MT devices there's a place for an argument about price/performance/noise ratio, but these larger switches do take out noise part of it. And with that gone, yeah, used enterprise gear would be better and more tolerant (if you want to swap stock fans for some Noctuas to make it less noisy)
@Another Language you can mix and match them as you need. It's all in the config.
That sounds like a massive single point of failure.
All of their products are a failure...buy one and find out.
@@xephael3485
I have to agree, bought ccs326 and have to keep rebooting every couple of days :(
forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?t=142969
We have over 200 mikrotik devices in field and the worked very good.
But be careful with vervy new product. As always from any vendor.
@@christophh9377 If you'll get both net and power from one non-redundant device, I'll see quite large risk there...
@@luukkuwet Thats true, but 24/7 is not always necessary. :)
mikrotik team is dead, no response, complet low, i`m complet disapoined but ubiquity, fast, team witch whants to help...etc
I think why this switch so cheap because that cant handle so much troughput like any other swhitch from another vendor
mikrotik switches suck
Microtik devices should be thrown in trash where they belong.
@xephael
why the hate?
Someone finds router OS too hard.
@@andljoy I could mop the floor with you and a CCIE single handedly.
xephael dude... leave the hate elsewhere
@@xephael3485 btw, I meant it, why are you calling mikrotik equipment pieces of trash?