When Russia Annexed Siberia: What Happened to Natives?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- From Episode 151 of the #AskAbhijit Show.
🕉️🕉️ Join my Introductory Course on Indian History: Bharata: A Biography of the Oldest Civilization
🪔🪔 Start learning here - abhijitchavda7...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/Abhi...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOIN #AbhijitChavda
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
★Website:
★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijit #AskAbhijitChavda #AskAbhijitPodcast #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow #AbhijitChavdaClips
![[UNCUT] “อภิสิทธิ์” ครม.อุ๊งอิ๊ง แย่งเก้าอี้กันฝุ่นตลบ “ทักษิณ” บงการเอง Iคนดังนั่งเคลียร์I 21ส.ค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/a_b-kItw2jY/mqdefault.jpg)
Rudrajit is making worthy questions back to back.
@@relentlessfrags4914 sir that depends on Chavda sir by the way thats good idea
@@relentlessfrags4914 thats right
@@relentlessfrags4914 yes even my dumbest question got answered because I posted the question in the community post .lol
@@jihadihindu like your name 🤡
Plot twist: Rudrajit is Abhijit Chavda's fake ID
Also bear in mind some of the ethnic groups in Russia have their own Republics, nations within a nation, basically a federation. One example is the Chechnyan Rebuplic and the Tuva republic to name a few.
Čečenská republika NENÍ na Sibiři. Douč se zeměpis!
The Chechen Republic is NOT in Siberia. Learn your geography!
We do talk Russian yes, it’s like Esperanto, but know our own language also but still everyone has its own faith and habits, Buddhist, Muslim, Orthodox
Shri chingis khan 😂😂😂😂
Brilliant answer. Indian people also need to understand the difference between conquest and colonization.
@Science lover sanjeev i dont need it to be good. But its needed for Indias growth and balance of world order.
why is that your surname?
im just curious
@Anti comintern⚒ rightwing Nationalist we are living in reality. It’s not a book for kindergarten. There are no “good” or “bad” nations
Chavda sir is on fire.Back to back interesting videos
Love your explanation sir 👌👌
Please make a history on history of odisha and gajapati Dynasty and the khandayats, paikas, and odisha under Mughal rule and why Delhi sultanate can't capture odisha.
Love from odisha ❤️❤️
Jai Jagannath
jai jagannath
@@souventudubanned Yes. They had Different treaty with Odisha empire
#askabhijit
sir do you think bharatiya has now started to repect and practice its culture and dharm more? because I myself was once a secular and thouht that other coutries are better than our and also thought that britishers were bad but also done some good things like railways but after I got grow up I got to know about truth and start to respect our own culture and got more pride as a bharatiya. My brothers are also now becoming more confident and respect our culture. there is also so many youtubers who show about our history and culture, so do you think we are starting to change now?
You are not alone .same with me . Mai tilak lagya hua utar deta tha now I understand it was whole propoganda àgainst Hindus .same memes regrading Durga ma used to circulate that whole year we disrespect women and now we will respect for 9 days . Now you see holistic view .it's was so bad .
Oh, my! Russia annexed Siberia!!! Discovery of the century!!! I admire your imagination.
Hi Abhijit… it’s so nice to gain so much knowledge in such a short period of time.. thank you so much for your time, effort and dedication that you put in your videos!!
One request, if it’s possible, could you make a series of videos country wise covering their history, culture, heritage, economy, financials, geopolitics, business etc. in one video. It will be really clear and concise. I know you have covered a lot in your ask me sessions😅
It would really help someone like me who is starting to gain knowledge in economics and geopolitics😊
First View. Big fan of you sir ❤️❤️
What the Europeans did in the Americas is not often talked about enough. Spanish Conquistadors wiped out native civilizations in South America . We know what happened in North America.
What??? there is still plenty of natives in South America like Bolivia Peru Ecuador and Amazon rainforest Colombia
#AskAbhijit What will happen to the gulf oil fed economies after 2-3 decades, when importance of oil reduces significantly?
If they don't act now, then they will be counted in poor states. But, they are now trying to transform their economy as UAE continuously investing and engaging with other economies especially India, Saudi Arabia too made a grand announcement about The Line City, Qatar' Fifa WC hosting was a medium to lure investors, that happens or not i don't know. All we know gulf countries are trying to divert their economy from Oil, how much they succeed only time will tell.
Pr0$titution! UAE earns most of its revenue from pr0stitution
@@souventudubanned I guess you haven't been to UAE
@@akt7522 u can’t earn tht money and dump in state coffers genius
@@xWarLegendx have you ever been to Dubai, indians and Pakistanis spend billions of dollars there each year on w#ores..and don't even ask about shieks..they spend mein in high end b@##d
#askabhijit
Sir what is the significance of ASEAN in today's rapidly changing geopolitics? How powerful are they?
ASEAN are just bootlickers of great powers during peace time & fence sitters during conflicts. Singapore is the financial & transport hub of ASEAN. Vietnam is the strongest military. Thailand is tourism hotspot.
#askabhijit
Sir, do you still do research in theoretical physics? What kind of research did you do in the past?
Thanks for all the knowledge 🙏
I haven't seen more truthful video about russian history on TH-cam. Thanks from Russia!
If someone is intrested in this topic read about Yermak Timofeyevich.
Прения между исследователями Сибири и народами её населявшими имели еденичный характер Сибирь это територия сурового климата и космос. И росияне знают цену помощи. Сибирь как космос человечество может действовать только сообща.
Abhijit sir please tell us something about 9/11 attack , many journalist claim that it was america itself who crashed their own plane in their own building and some people also claim that osama bin laden is still alive . Whats your opinion on that ???
Use #AskAbhijit
Good morning 🌞 big brother Abhijit sir💪
Awaiting the II & AMA's legend
So back then, fur was what oil is today to fight winters and Blizzard...lucky we in India ...here we are blessed by Sun
Cool
I'd love to read a speculative novel about what it'd look like if Russia,China, and India merged into an mega supranational state over a century or two.
"The Eastern Dawning"
"Pacific Reign"
"Heirs of the Khan"
"Of Destiny and Dharma "
I feel it would have been important to point out that within a few generations 90% of native Americans died because of epidemics.
A myslíš, že na Sibiři to bylo jinak?
And you think it was different in Siberia?
"Peoples" नहीं सर, "people". "People" itself is the plural meaning "many persons"
😲😱
Thank you sir , you are nominated for Nobel prize
@@vedadityaved538 😂😂😂😂 Sir!!! 😂😂😂😂😂
English speaking world don't care abt these things so why do Indians care so much.
@@gravewalker34 Depends on education. An average Indian is better educated than an average white from west
A question came to mind, yes colonization was destructive/murderous, yet now that America is settled (as in most major conflicts are over), should we not think how to get along and build together?
As a mostly European person (part native American) I've had people I know declare reparations must be paid. My response was, " Considering that there are no people in America that have pure bloodlines anymore, who gets walked and how much, and how will that help anything?". I honestly only see unity and cooperation as the sole means of progress over the whole of humanity.
Bigger challenges are coming and if we all don't cooperate I do honestly think the human race will sooner or later be wiped out by a natural or man made disaster be it nuclear war or excessive meteor strikes upon the Earth?
I think by-and-large focusing on past wrongs Has only created more division and sometimes I think it's on purpose.
No decent person of any religion should be advocating for revenge which is basically what reparations would be used as and I think that's a horrible thoubut and something humanity should discourage.
I know, but in India, there is currently a narrative of victimhood. And my countrymen want revenge. They see the European race as destructive evil people who have taken on a virtuous persona in the current times, but they still are the same imperialist people as before, or so the narrative goes. This is part of an effort to resurrect the Hindu culture in its past glory, and these people are in the process of recovering that past culture and they see the trend of westernisation as a threat. So that's why they intepret history in this manner. I would point out how Abhijit didn't even mention how much of the native americans were wiped out by small pox before the europeans reach them. Not to say the europeans are not to be blamed, they were definitely out to kill all the natives.
These people also have a soft spot for Russia, because the Soviets helped my country when the Americans were against us. They are looking back into the past, trying to dig up old wounds and they don't want to forgive, even if the new generation of western people condemn the actions of their ancestors, they can't acknowledge that because it doesn't fit their narrative. But at least this is helping my country to rediscover its native culture and traditions and its helping us build an independant outlook, which is good. Also they do want to develop India to be a more prosperous nation than it is now. However it's unfortunate they are using hate and resentment to fuel this revolution. I would rather have this be fueled by ambition and rationalism alone. Hate breeds hate and someone has to forgive, to break the cycle, so that the world can become a better place.
@@ranguy1379 How can we Indians even attempt to forgive the West especially the Brits when they don't even feel the guilt about what they did to us till 1947 ? Has the British government even issued a formal apology to India for 90 years of illegitimate occupation ? The idea of breaking the cycle is truth, reconciliation and forgiveness instead what we get is lies and apathy. They don't seek forgiveness from us, they simply don't care because they do not see us as a threat.
And since the younger generation keeps forgetting the wretched acts of their forefathers, it is our duty to keep them reminding these nasty facts.
@@heatengine9283 well, there are many ways. First, most Britishers aren't educated properly about what their ancestors did here. Second, they do condemn such acts whenever they realise such things happened. Third, they are a different generation with a different worldview compared to the colonists before them. We shouldn't hold children accountable for the actions of their parents, it doesn't make sense. Even if they apologized, how does it matter? They are not the people who did the acts.
Personally, I don't think we need their apology. I don't care what they think. If they are racist and have something against us, then fuck them. Why should I care? I will just build my nation and provide for my children. But if they are willing to build relations and help each other, why would I block it by constantly yelling about their parents? Either way, to hate them, you have to care that much about them, and I think that's unnecessary and counter-productive. I would just try to build a good future for our people and if they want to co-operate on the project of life and it was beneficial to us then great. The parents wouldn't stop me from making friends with the children.
And it's not true that the west is apathetic. They have very much a group guilt about their past, although it's starting to go away. And imo, it should go away. Eventually, everyone has to move on from the past. We can't hold their colonial era over their heads forever. They are people like us, and they want to live guilt free and not be constantly held accountable for their parents.
imo, reparations are stupid
but, as a man to watch his race be murdered
this should not be acceptable
imo, natives will have their revenge
with thr fall of USA , which a few decades in time
past wrongs done to one's people are an act of dis honour
it is human nature to regain honour
"unity and co operation"
the only unity and co operation USA wants is soft imperialism and occupation
see, this is the nature of usa
once china is pushed back
usa's biggest threat would be... my motherland BHARAT, i.e, india
globalisation isnt the answer
It's quite easy to conquer large inhabitant areas.
You can say it was not genocide because most of the land has very few inhabitants. And they were mostly tribal and nomadic people so they did not have much cultural friction. Even now they have very low population density is most of the regions. That's what happened according to me.
Good points.
Sir give us idea about future of Qatar and it's controversies 🙏
It will be more or less stable country for a long while
This place is temple . ऊँ नमः शिवायः।
Annexed! What a word you use! Annexation, in international law, is the forcible acquisition and assertion of legal title over one state's territory by another state. How can you annex the territory which does not belong to any state, to any country? Did Americans annex their western territories? Did Canadians do that?
Crying Turkic noises
Actually they suffered but comparatively less than the native Americans or Aboriginals or Moans or Africans.
But they suffered a lot. Russians made a lot of lands empty to remove opposition.
Most significant genocide was made by the Spaniards.
No genocide was bigger than the genocide of Anglo saxons and the Spaniards were the first to give human rights to the natives infact the natives supported Spaniards against their own ruler
90% Native American people died from European diseases they lacked immunity to as individuals
There is one significant difference between colonization of Americas and colonization of Siberia. In America natives weren't used to diseases that Europeans brought with them, so most of natives actually died because of diseases, and not because of planned extermination. In Siberia they were used to diseases that Russian conquerors brought with them, so similar catastrophe didn't happen. Also there are some cases where Russians deliberately killed conquered natives, look for Circassian genocide.
Native American were also killed not all of them were killed by disease .
Russia is no longer white nation. I noticed Chinese males married white Russian women than Chinese females married white Russian males.
@@ribos2762 People may argue whether it could be classified as genocide or not, but the fact is that more than 80% of Circassian population of Russia disappeared after these events.
No. Ethnic Sakha (Yakut) had lost 70% of total population in 1640-1680s due to smallpox and other diseases brought in by Russians. Even cockroaches, bed bugs and house mice were brought in by Russians.
@@vissarion3505 Thanks for the information, I wasn't aware of this.
We should start bharatefication of Pakistan
Guys plz support sanatan samiksha
#askabhijit 1are the people of of Iraq arabised indo iranians ?
What is the pre Islamic history of the levantine countries ?
jai hind
Shri changez Khan 😂🤣😂
#askabhijit sir what is your take on the current political scenario of Pakistan. Is there any chance of Pakistan facing a civil war in near future ?
Nowadays most people believe in what they were taught.
#AskAbhijit Sir can you shed some light on where the Native Americans originated and how they entered the Americas; also can you tell us about the origin of the aboriginals, the sentinelese, and other such islanders in the Indo Pacific ring? I hope to get a reply Sir, thank you.
#AskABHIJIT What happening in Europe and US after Russia cut oil supply.
Sir do a Hindi stream plz
sir can you make a discored server?
Is Tengrism an extension of Hinduism? #AskABHIJIT
#AskAbhijit When Hindu Constitution Placed ?
Imagine thinking that not every single ethnic group conquered someone in their past to keep their group going. People need to get over the past. You can try to change the future but quit whining about what got us here.
Sir is your course is still available
#askabhijit make a video on turk Russia war
2:00 Правда
Turtle Islanders no relative amerigo or vespucci
Btw screen marker map pl
Wait wait, I'm American and I don't consider Native Americans to be third rate citizens. I CAN speak for me and everyone I know. So Did you mean that Native Americans were third rate citizens 2, 3, 4, 5 hundred years ago? Because I can agree to that.
#AskAbhijit Dear Abhijit Chavada sir as in your video you define how bad western capitalism is and how they break society to earn profit by profit. According to you what should be the ideology of the world and how should human race develop as a civilization. Sir please make a video on this as this is very needed for the world of now and the human race.
#askabhijit what was army in Sikh empire like because some sources say they had guns and cannons and had the 2nd largest army in Asia and is this saying trur
Plz explain about the logic behind circumcision in Islam and Judaism. Some ppl say it’s unnecessary and unethical but some oppose their views.
17 century
From History russian economy is running on natural resources
What are your thoughts on this video th-cam.com/video/SKUtg-4BxMY/w-d-xo.html did nato expand to Russia or Russia expanded to nato???????⁉️
Watch his videos. Even a child knows nato expanded eastwards.
So the Russians were better than Europeans.... At least the natives survived
Wasn`t as bad as it was in USA? Really? Most of Native siberians (chukots, tunguses, yakuts and other turkic tribes, number of finno-ugric nations, chukchis, aleuts, nenets, etc) were wiped out as well vas Northern american tribes. The ones that somehow survive up until nowadays usually have no more that few hundrers or few thousands people left, in some cases even few dozens. And differently from USA or Mexico, where they have at least calm lives nowadays, Russia, has and still is using native siberians as meat infantry in modern warfare, recruiting them through mass propaganda and getting all the resources from their territories to metropolian areas, such as Moscow, leaving them with very poor work choice, which once again leads them to join russia`s expansionist warfare
5:09 jak jste dospěl k uvedenému číslu?
how did you arrive at that number?
5:26 Kdyby mělo během 300 roků přijít o život 100 milionů Indiánů, museli by se množit jako kobylky!
If 100 million Indians were to lose their lives in 300 years, they would have to breed like locusts!
Anglie kolonizovala Indii později, než Ruϟϟko Sibiř. Indii opustili v roce 1946. Kdy Ruϟϟko uvolní Sibiř?
England colonized India later than Ruϟϟia colonized Siberia. They left India in 1946. When will Ruϟϟia leave Siberia?
That’s the good question. As a Russian I might say thank you sir for being eye opened. We live now hand by hand in Russia will all nations and churches
when spanish french and english colonize americas what happenned to natives how many tens of millions have die..
wait wait wait Shri Genghis Khan 😶
Sri genghis khan...
IRAQ---KURDISTAN
#AskAbhijit
hey sir big fan
i have one question that see
when anything happen in india-
whole rightwing unite and says the same thing and tell benefits of it, where as whole left wing unite and tell bad side of it(even propoganda)
how a same bunch of people have same opinion, even their follower opinion also shaped like them
even i also get satisfy with right wing but not by left wing
what is the cause of it
in short: how a same bunch of people have same thought on all major things, why their is NO conversion in that??
#AskAbhijit what will happen if we will colonize United Kingdom?
The whole world will salute you . Privet 😂
Native Northern Russians are Originally are Tibetan People boz there Northern Russians now are same DNA with Tibetan People. They call Denisovan. Some archaeologists found Denisovan Bone in Russia cave . This Denisovan are found in North America and Ukraine Rae most of are same human species from Denisovan after that from Apes Evolution they called Neanderthal. Denisovan are mostly found in Northern parts. If you Notice those Denisovan people are less hairy on body , short heights and half beard, Neanderthal are more hairy and long legs. That’s a simple difference between these two types of humans species. That’s why Tibetan ,Himalayan people can surviving Highly mountains. Thank you sir for sharing your knowledge.I hope you will bring us more information about more information to us .
Were not native Americans, Indigenous people of the Americas. Turtle Island. Ugh!
Plz explain about the origin of baby tossing ritual in muslims of India. Since this has been mocked by the west and they include Hindus in it too.
Do you think our nation is moving towards saffronisation and polarisation ? If yes then dont you think it will be eventually cause stagnation and fall of India?
@Chavda You are wrong: There were a lot of genocides! Kazakhs, Tatars, Khanty-Mansis, Circassians, etc. See: "The Red Book of the Peoples of the Russian Empire" and other souces. And due to these Russian genocides and FORCED Russification the indigenous peoples became minorities where before no Russians lived.
You've forgotten Crimean Tatars and Circassian people of Caucasus..!, they were almost exterminated..
Obviously, Genocides did infact happen, and it's still continuing.
First of all, to clear up things, let's look at the ethnicities cause it's hard to picture which communities live there.
The region closer to Georgia & Turkey has Caucasian people, eg Ingush-Vainakh and other Dagestani communities. At one point, the region also had the Kalmyks (related to Oirat tribes) but we will talk about their fate later.
The region closer to Central Asia and Mongolia has various Mongolic people like Buryats and Tuvans (mostly Buddhists, and no, Russians are not at all Buddhists. I don't know where he got that data), and Tatars (Muslim Mongols. Due to their violent behaviour, Tatar became a pejorative for all Mongolic people later on amongst racists).
The region closer to Manchuria has Tungusic people, while region closer to Japan has Ainu people, and they have relatives in Northern Japan.
And the region known as Siberia, one of the most vast culturally & genetically related regions on the planet, has a plethora of ethnicities, mostly due to isolation in that terrain and climate. Most of them are related to native americans. Viz: In central region you have Yeniseian (only Ket survive today) and Evenki (including Dolgan) people. In the Far East you have various nomadic people like Yupik (commonly known as Eskimo), Koryak, Yukaghir, and Chukchi peoples. In the very North, close to Arctic circle, there are Nganasan, Nenet and Yakut people.
A brief timeline :
1) The Russian conquest of North Asia was neither about fur or defence against any invader, it was an imperialist motive just like other European colonizers. And various rulers imposed draconian laws over indigenous people to various degrees of cruelty.
2) Most of the tribes mentioned tried to rebel, but they were regularly deported and massacred and converted, which broke their traditions and numbers, and eventually paved way for Russification. Russian ultranationalists bost how such a vast land speaks one language, they don't speak it willingly, they were, and are still forced to. The white supremacist ideology in Russia actually is very much similar to Anglo-American white supremacy or Neo-nazism.
3) The Russians introduced diseases like Smallpox which lead to heavy deaths, some to the point of 70% loss in population eg Yakuts
4) The Tsars regularly used the Cossacks to subjugate and massacre various indigenous population, reducing their numbers to a miniscule eg the Koryaks.
5) Some of the rebellions were very successful eg the Chukchi who many times defeated the Russian armies.
6) Yasak tax system imposed on indigenous people who couldn't afford to pay it. The tax was one of the motives which regularly sparked rebellions. Some of them were purged so mercilessly, eg the Yakuts, on whom religion was used as a tool of subjugation (just like in Africa) which resulted in loss of their identity.
7) Collectivization of reindeer ownership affecting lifestyle of tribes eg Nganasan and Nenets.
8) The Soviets regularly deported indigenous people to break their morale (they were separated just like in Tsarist Russia, and made to live in new oblasts which separated them from their culture and even families), and contrary to what tankies believe, most Russians didn't even believe in communism. Most of them just carried on with their white supremacist and pro-Russian ideology. It's a myth that Soviets defeated Nazis. Cause Russians themselves believed in Nazi ideology, the idea of White race being superior. Hence Soviets actually helped Germany in invading Czechoslovakia. Sadly for them, the Germans considered the Slavs to be an inferior race, and hence they retaliated. This white supremacist legacy is the reason, Russia invaded (eg Hungary) and imposed their Language and Script over all the neighbouring Soviet nations, hence you'll notice that most post-Soviet nations use Cryllic alphabet and minority languages are not given a damn about in the beuracracy. And it's not just cultural but racial subjugation. Russians forcibly migrated to other nations for controlling them, hence you'll also notice that most post-Soviet nations have Russians as second largest minority, who are very well-to-do.
The Soviets did not do much damage to the Orthodox church (since it was their religion), but heavily persecuted the Buddhists, Animists and Muslim people. The number of Monks that were merciless executed is horrific to even imagine. Almost all the monasteries broken. Eg in Mongolia, when PM Peljidiin Genden refused to destroy Buddhist institutions and Russify Mongolia, since Buddhism was easily compatible with atheism and he was an arduent nationalist, the Soviets purged him, and the NKVD went on to kill tens of thousands of Buddhists, with public harrasment/torture of the monks and with almost every monastery in Ulaanbatar destroyed.
The Soviets regularly deported minorities like Kalmyks (so much for minority appeasement) and collectivized the ancestral land of Siberians (like Kets) and put them under State control (you know the reason! it's just indirectly justifying the control of indigenous lands by white supremacists. communism is just white man's burden disguised in red clothing).
9) When any indigenous tribe neglected Soviet policies, the secret police purged them like animals. Eg the Buryats, whose Mongolian warlike nature and Buddhist traditions, made them oppose the collectivist (it's actually lawful stealing let's be honest) policies. The Red Army merciless killed their people and clergy.
10) And you may think currently under Putin things are just fine. Nope, Russia is a literal dictatorship that imposes their hegemony over the indigestion people and suppresses any call for self-rule. And it's not that these people hate living together. The communities have always been neglected, so much that the only way to get recognition in moscow is to adapt the religion, language, attire and most minute of detail of the white man. Russian populace still believes in white supremacy, both right and even leftist wings, eg Alexei Nvalny, the famous Putin dissident, made many racist remarks in the past, including nuking Georgia. As for Putin, he literally came to power by spewing hatred against Chechens, and most of his diehard followers are christian fundamentalist white supremacists:
For further learning on Russian racism, watch these:
th-cam.com/video/GV4v31azgQM/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/SnYFTVM5di8/w-d-xo.html
Do not fall trap to the whitewashed history of Russian colonialism. They are literally a settler-coloniak state like USA, Canada, Australia, Brazil and Israel.
Nope. You are full
I can tell you to what happened to us eastern eauropeans under russian:oppression and death till we did not beheve as thy wanted
Brother I'm an ardent viewer of your podcast..a humble suggestion is to rid the podcast of the Italian accent.. It's really turning off
#askabhijit 1are the people of of Iraq arabised indo iranians ?
What is the pre Islamic history of the levantine countries ?