Just as Pandavas couldn’t choose relatives, India can't choose its neighbours:Jaishankar on Pakistan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ม.ค. 2023
- Union External Affairs Minister Dr S Jaishankar on 28 January during the launch of the Marathi version of his book 'Bharat Marg' in Pune, spoke about Pakistan, China and even gave a Mahabharata reference while responding to a question on India’s ‘unusual’ neighbours- He said, ‘Pandavas could not choose relatives, we can't choose our neighbours. Naturally, we hope good sense prevails.’ He further added,’At times there are challenges to national security requiring decisive steps. Obvious example of it is terrorism, we all know how much India has suffered due to terrorism as compared to other countries because other countries don't have a neighbour like the one we have.’
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
History will remember him as one of the greatest and best diplomats India was blessed with. I can already see his speeches and talks being discussed and studied for future diplomats and ministers of Indian politics.
आदर्श राजनेता 👑
For a Tamilian he speaks excellent Hindi. Sir you excel in many things. We are so proud of you 🙏🏽
Not only Hindi , he speaks 7 languages
Yes 👍🏼
A tamilian who was in IFS and educated in Delhi, is bound to be well versed in Hindi.
Yeah we Indians from the south make efforts to learn a language from the north of our mother land , yet the north never makes the effort in learning a south language to bridge the gaps even more , and the north and the south should make sincere efforts to learn a north east language and bring them in , we need unity more than ever now.
@@kishorevarma1951 well said
He was in my school auditorium yesterday !!.. we are proud of our EAM and our esteemed PM !!! They are taking our Nation to great heights !!
Madam, you mean, " esteemed PM", I guess
You guys are lucky
He also took adani to great heights
Me too from same school. Also got to witness this live
@shivarayakini6950 ... yes you r right ! Thank you for pointing out the mistake 🙏
He is simply gem , so proud to have such a superb external foreign minister
He should have another term post 2024 election.PM Modi should have another term to handle all the anti India forces within n outside. Public should understand the seriousness of these threats.
He learned a lot from reading many authors, lived in many other countries, knows many cultures, speak 7 different languages, still connected to the grassroots of Sanaatan Dharm!!
What a legend!
Jai Mahakaal!!
I am so happy indian youth fan zone is now around people like s jaishankar nitin gadkari ashwini vaishnav etc.
People are no longer idolizing boywood actors
Absolutely Correct!! In fact, Bollywood is quite toxic!! The actors/directors have not much to offer to the youth except those who can being real value to native art, culture & history!!
Golden era for India - Ministers of people
I'm glad I lived in sir jaishankars era
It's so pleasing to hear mahabharat extracts from Dr. Jaishankar. Even I remember all of these kavyas and am enthusiastic to grasp more and more knowledge of our precious indian epics!
If you really remember Mahabharata so lets take a simple test, 1. Why dronacharya cut eklavya thumb real answer plz? 2. Which side elavya fight? 3. Where is the sasural of krishna, 5. Where is krishna heart today now? 4. What happened to krishna 16008 wives after his... You know what
@@devkumar7115 lol who told you about 16000 wifes.... Seems like you yourself need to get some fact checking... He only loved one women dearly
@@devkumar7115keep dreaming
Jews and Hindus: The ones who suffered most due to peaceful religion.
Kitna muh me lega jews ka be?
Ricebag,katue aur jews teeno ek hi koodedan se nikle hai
@Kraken Thunder Ambedkar to Hindus was actually like Taslima nasreen/Salman rushdie to Muslims, but the difference is many Hindus accepted, even owned Ambedkar sooner or later and reformed their beliefs against casteism. So called bad upper caste Hindus had a choice not to give Ambedkar a chance considering his hateful views on Hinduism. Change is most of time gradual not abrupt.
@Kraken Thunder And, Upper Caste Hindus acknowledge that fact and are actively mending their ways to eradicate their discriminatory practice.. Because, Hindus despite their evils, accept criticisms and are open to reformation.
Unlike, Islam where they don't even accept accountability for all the suffering they have caused not only in India but the world over, nor do they accept criticism and refuse to mend their ways to accommodate the life of 21st Century Scientific World and anyone who tries to show them a mirror, they immediately start with "Sar Tan Se Zudaa" slogans..
@Kraken Thunder bhai agar itna suffer hote to bachte hi nahin ladai to jyada india mean invader ke time pe hui hai
@Kraken Thunder This is old dialogue bro.
I didn’t know Jaishankar spoke Hindi so well. Well done, minister. You are brilliant.
हिंदी में बोलते हुए भी कितने सुंदर शब्द चुनता है ये व्यक्ति!
What a fentastic speech and reply by our great EAM , Jayashankarji.
He is humble and crystal clear in his thoughts and optimistic.
Proud of you Sir.
God bless you with good health
A complete different Dr. I saw today. Speaking in hindi eloquently and he used the word 'Jug' for 'Yug', this is a traditional Hindi accent! कमाल!
Sumedh
Your praise sounds so fake.
Jug Jug Jiyo.......is very commonly said.
"Since this is suggestion you don't require reply " good reply 👌
Salute to Dr. S Jaishankar sir🙏🙏🙏 The way he speaks softly and smoothly answers all questions
He is next level! As a tamilian he speaks decent hindi.
For reference sake...we may call him - A-Tamil .. but this child of his Dad..Subramanyam...He
He has knows the entire GUPTA-MAURYA empire history too...
Something great 👍 blessings
Dt. S. Jaishankar ji, You are doing a great job. Thanks for explaining the facts so nicely and awakening the people. We need such a people like you who thinks how to make the India superpower. May God bless you and fulfil your dreams. Jai Hind🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️❤️🙏🙏
Simply superb gentleman 👌👌👌👌👌👏👏👏👏
India is very fortunate to have Sri Jaishankar as our EAM. India will certainly make it’s mark in the global arena with the current leadership
Destined to be best EAF India ever produced or Have.
We salute 🙏 him and his honest effort
need full video of this Q and A. Missed the last bits of his speech.
We can change our friends but not our neighbours - Atal Bihari Vajpayee.
First clean yourself and then talk about others..
@@thebradlad6215 😂.im sorry for letting u misunderstand. We can change our friends not neighbours. So befriend them. Have good relations with them without any skirmishes. Because we can't change our neighbours as like we change friends. 😂
@@DG-nd9ui whatever
Pakistan to Bangladesh 🇧🇩 change neighbor.. example...
Because of leaders like him, we have a sense of pride in our leadership. He choose his words so carefully and presented the whole concept on foreign relations and way forward for india in such a fantastic way. Big fan of him 😊
A true indian example for every Indian
India's main problems of the past was Jawaharlal Nehru, because he studied in UK from the childhood and very little knowledge and experience of Indian history, Culture and spirituality (Hindu, Muslim, Buddhism, Jainism etc). He born with sliver spoon and his step father Motilal Nehru wants him or pushed him into India politics and freedom struggle. Jawaharlal Nehru lived Play boy and he had no knowledge or respect for Indian holiscripts and rich cultural traditions.
1. Nehru may have used Pandit in his name but one doubts whether he was a Hindu or possibly a Muslim!!
He was also a quasi communist & almost a traitor to this nation & Dharma as evident from his offering food to the communist Chinese while they were invading poor Tibetan Buddhists!!
2. Indic native philosophies or Dharma are way beyond religion as theorized & practiced by Islam or Christianity!!
The difference is like day & night!!
What an Inspiration to youth! Thank you Dr S Jaishankar.
First time got something valuable on the print.
You are the best diplomat and foreign minister may I say of modern India🙏
Listen from 51:15 what a reply from Jaishankar sir.A TRUE diplomat🤣
The way he is progressing as foreign minister is unparalleled. I wish him well. Let him successfully move the country forward.
Jay Shankar gi is from Tamil nadu and still he is fluent in hindi.
He is the best EAM we ever had.
Proud that India has Jaishankar at the helm of MEA
Jaishankar for PM ! 😊
Bhut sahi kaha aapne sir hum world labels pr bhut pechhe hr sector me.abhi hme bhut research make in India .ko bahut motivate krne ki jarurat hai.hr sector me research ki jarurat hai research pr bhut jyada dhyan dena hai aur saari facilities niche lavel tk phuche iski bahut jarurat hai.
Dr jaishankar sir 🇮🇳💪
Finally full video 🔥
He explains very beautifully. 🙏
Proud of you sir God bless you
You are great sir we need you like father or metro man as post your administrative services you both contributing and teaching next set of IAS
One of finest EAM Minister India have now. Hope his wisdom and Modi Ji guidance will take India to another level in next 10 years and when India become 💯 we will be country to reckon with
Jayshankar ji jse mahaan karm yogi ko mera shat shat naman🙏
Mahabharat reference 1:01:20
He is the gem of india . ❣
He is the best🇮🇳💕👍
👍 You are correct, keep going
He is love 💖
You r so good Sir,🙏🙏🙏🙏
Modi should groom Jaishankar as his successor, it will cement Modi's legacy.
Mr Sreedharan set ways of working and SOP for metro and you on foreign policy
Too good explaining by him on China & diff of thinking on China as threat by Sardar Patel & PM Jawaharlal Nehru.
Real Indian ✍️✍️
Good brief data, each Indian should share with one goal to up lift Bharath
*Who voted for partition? Here are the Results for 1946 Election for partition and you Judge it:*
*Assam:*
Muslim Seats: 34
Muslim League(For partition): 31
Win Percentage: 91%
*Bengal:*
Muslim Seats: 119
Muslim League(For partition): 113
Win Percentage: 95%
*Bihar:*
Muslim Seats: 40
Muslim League(For partition): 34
Win Percentage: 85%
*Bombay:*
Muslim Seats: 30
Muslim League(For partition): 30
Win Percentage: 100%
*Central Provinces:*
Muslim Seats: 14
Muslim League(For partition): 13
Win Percentage: 93%
*Madras:*
Muslim Seats: 29
Muslim League(For partition): 29
Win Percentage: 100%
*NWFP:*
Muslim Seats: 36
Muslim League(For partition): 17
Win Percentage: 47%
*Orissa:*
Muslim Seats: 4
Muslim League(For partition): 4
Win Percentage: 100%
*Punjab:*
Muslim Seats: 86
Muslim League(For partition): 74
Win Percentage: 86%
*Sind:*
Muslim Seats: 34
Muslim League(For partition): 28
Win Percentage: 82%
*United Provinces:*
Muslim Seats: 66
Muslim League(For partition): 54
Win Percentage: 82%
*Total Win Percentage:* 87%
- Source: Wikipedia 1946 Indian Provincial Elections
*Sardar Vallabhai Patel:* Most of the Muslims who have stayed back in India, helped in creating Pakistan. Now, I do not understand what has changed in one night that they are asking us not to doubt their loyalty
*Dr. B.R. Ambedkar:* The allegiance of a Muslim does not rest on his domicile in the country which is his but on the faith to which he belongs. To the Muslim, Where it is well with me there is my country is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. *In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin*
-Source: "pakistan or partition of India" Book by Ambedkar
*1st Education minister of India maulana Abdul Kalam Azad:* Be extremely hard against kafirs (nonmuslims) but extremely kind among ourselves (muslims). All relationships in the world can break down, father can turn against son, brother against brother, mother can shun her child but the relationship of a Muslim with a Muslim can never be severed. And then we ask why our Education System is bad
Speech at 1920
That was thought provoking ..
Recently SC held that Wikipedia cannot be held as a source of evidence because it can be edited by anyone.
Also, 100% of the muslims voted for it ok, what happened to the other communities? How did they respond? That's equally important to know right? Without that, there won't be objectivity in arriving at a conclusion.
@@DarkKnight-kx6vl Means you are trying to say that the upper-class people wanted a secular republic of India while the lower class people who didn't get the chance to cast the vote could have opted for a Hindurastra, I mean it is also a strong possibility. A majority of hindus didn't get to cast their votes so their will was not represented there, secular republic of India was the will of the some Upper class rich people not the majority of Hindus.
Bruh forgot that there was no universal adult franchise in 1946 😂 u are talking about 8-10% of the population who were elites with urban landholdings and properties.. 👍
@@debabratabhattacharya6069 u should check out who was the proponent of the Two-nation theory on the Hindutva side.. Name starts with S and ends with R
What a wise person.
Amazing personality
This man is a Gem ❤️
Where is the end?
Hanumanji was not diplomat, he was on intelligence mission
Thanks to non aligned policy of Nehru ji ? That Doval has criticized so much in his speeches ?
Polished diplomat, I listen to his talks from time to time. Although, it would be nice if he pronounced the names of Marathi attendees ('Aphale and Athawale') correctly 😁
KEDAR SHETE
........Most people are NOT ATTENTIVE to notice mispronunciation.
........They just clap or say gem.
Current batch of ifs(s) and bureucrats in foreign ministry are so blessed to b working under an senior ifs officer who can actually connect with his colleagues and knows very well how the foreign affairs of a country works rather than a politician..
NO!! The ONLY criteria has to be people of MERIT who can best serve the nation!! Period!!
No one remembers who was our FM for the last 10 or 20 years---- we ARE very lucky to have superb Fm
Dont you remember Sushma swaraj ?
@@sivag2032
NO. They are HAPPY to give FAKE PRAISE to Jaishankar
Great speech
Just like the pandavas could not choose their relatives, India's neighbours also did not get the opportunity whether to choose her as their neighbour.
Because they always affiliate themselves as Arabic not part of Indian ethos and culture. It is very evident in their hollow character.
Correct but if division of India was not happen... Certainly the situation for today is different and better...
And still if we compare today with respect to there growth rate with ours, decision to establish new country is not correct, two nations theory is absolutely failure.
Real video starts from 40:00 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Par excellence!!
🙏🙏🌼🌼
Sir in my opinion we make more strong relationship with Russia to aquire modern wapons before china.
Bharat Ratna 🏅💎
Wish this book is also translated in Bengali Kannada apart from Hindi and English languages
🙏
Sir, Please take diplomatic lessons based on your IFS training.
Great sir
Sir.aap.pm.bno.plz.apna.desh.bahut.uapar.jayega
By giving "the Print" this interview (bringing examples from Indic civilization, instead of Europe & China) EAM has set fire on Lanka..... I mean it
It's a prestige to have him in the Modi Government.
🙏🙏🙏👍
Thanks sir1💕💕💕
I think he should stop quoting form our religious texts. It might come back to haunt him.
@@solo.108
RENT A Bheja
Jaish is NOT quoting correctly.
Bjpees DO FAKE PRAISE...........GEM...... PM
.....
That's why it's a golden era of our foreign policy ..
S. Jayshankar sir is real gem 💎
S Jaishankar and Amit Shah are the best Ministers of Modi cabinet.
South is facing shortage
Gem of India
Since independence best foreign minister Bharath ever had, Jai Hind🇮🇳
Make him PM after Modi retires.
Agree !!
FM bahut acha heii wo position is best for him....
PM banega toh utna image nhi rahega.....
@@cytonas3zara yes..... Apna apna sab log best kaam kre toh best hoga
@@cytonas3zara It also doesn't mean that he cannot. He was a diplomat, and he is one of the prime contenders to fill in that position after Modi. He is way better face than what oppositions are offering. There are many good faces in both opposition and current government who are a good choice, but the opposition definitely isn't planning to give a push to their good contenders for PM.
@@cytonas3zara In your earlier comment, you questioned whether he can be a good statesman or not and if he is capable to take tough decisions, so in my reply, I highlighted that he is more than capable to take those decisions and keep our image high on the international stage. I completely agree with getting votes part. So is he a good PM material, yes; can he attract votes, maybe.
Hmare scientists ko jo facilities foreighn me mil rha hai usse jyada facilities unko dena chahiye.hmari army bahut chhoti hai isme bhartiya do guni honi chahiye km se km hona to char guna chahiye.aur sari latest facilities milni chahiye hmare jvan aaj bhi achche khane ke liye trsate hai jo hamare liye sharmnaak hai.aaj hme achchai siksha aur achchi chiktsa ke liye bahar daudana padtaa hai.hmare ayurved aur homeopathy ko bahut aage le jana chahiye.mbbs ki seate bahut bdani chahiye.eske liye hme medical Colleges ki sankhya bdani chahiye jisse achhi siksha aur achchi chiktsa facilities mil sake.ager hum aam janta aur sarkar sab milkar Kam kare toh aage badne se koi nhi roke sakta.agr ek mjdur se lekr hr tbke ka nagrik apne ek din ka mjdur Desh hit ke liye hr mah chode de aur isse pure ek saal ka jo bhi amt hr sector se ikktha ho usse hr saal ek bahut bda plant lgaya jay to bahut logo ko rojgar mil sakega.aur koi Sarkar 5saal rhti hai is trh paise janta ke aur help sarkar ka..5saal me 5plant mil sakega aur hum desh ki bhut badi berojgari door kr sakenge.
We want our honorable EAM Dr. S Jaishankar to be our next PM after Modiji, he will take our country to new heights
Jai jai shankar 🙏🙏🙏
After his retirement, GoI should begin 'Jaishankar Award' for diplomacy to honour international diplomats contributing to improve relations of India with their respective countries.
Bar bar aap badey desh kyom kahthe hai, apna bhi badey Desh hi hai.
Karna and duryodhna reference was top notch 👌
9:10
🚩🕉️🇮🇳🙏
Great man.....
Wow! Nice Hindi !
ham sare desho ko madat karte hai par badle me kiya milta hai shirf dokha .e daridil bharat ko kam karna hoga.deshhit Jada.e nehi garme me khane kai liye nehi khilane chale dunia ko.
But we shouldn't put bans and boycotts or sanctions on any nation but try to use diplomacy to its fullest
I am going to request that the USA stop interfering in the east, remove this whole terrorism deal with Pakistan. RFK jr is for world peace, that is why I am hopeful.
Till usa exists war will continue in the world