Hello everybody! Many of you have pointed out several mistakes made by the archaeological team during their excavation. Let's open up the debate! What do you think they should be reproached for, and what alternatives should they have considered instead?
@SLICEDocumentary I would like to comment, but not as a criticism, but rather as a question. I will preface this question with I have no educated knowledge or experience of archeology. I have watched many documentaries on such things, some much better than others. So my experience is very limited. So my question is, why do I feel as if the finds from these digs were not handled with as much care as I normally observe? Why were all the bones being shoved in a bag that appeared much too small? When the gold covered wood was discovered and the gold was peeling off, it was being held up in windy conditions. Couldn't the gold have just blown away? It also seemed as if they didn't have any boxes to collect the finds. They kept on saying time was of the essence and that they had to wait 4 days for the refrigerated truck, then they were holding things up, leaving wood and bones exposed. Then, finally, when they were finished with the site, all the men started shoveling earth back into the hole. Much of the wood of the tomb was just left laying about and covered willy nilly (to my eyes) with the much and dust. I couldn't help feeling this was a dig to find items worth lots of money and to heck with the rest. Please tell me I am wrong. The second dig - Professor, "I think we should just go on, never mind the snow!" The lid is removed, "Wait wait, we must not let any moisture in! Cover it with a sheet!" Again, I just don't see the care and preparation.
This interesting documentary unfortunately fails to give some important information, to wit, the year of the excavation and the official designation of the site. Also, the "transcript" is full of errors, e.g., the lead archaeologist's name is garbled, and numbers and meters are messed up.
@@Britgirl58 you did observe correctly, it was more grave robbing than anything else, and what happened afterwards simply confirms that it was for wealth and fame not for knowledge or science.
The ancient (ethnic/genetic) Scots of Ireland and Scotland claimed descent from the Scythi. Their Goddess Skytti, or Skatta/Skatha, or scotta (The letters 'a' and 'o' are generally interchangeable in their tongues) was said to be their ancestor, who came from the Scythians. and apparently the name of the isle of skye originates with this legend. where woimen apparently trained warriors in her fashion. So, why wasn't this mentioned instead of the Amazons with regard to the warrior woman? Warrior women were common within some Celtic, Scots, and Pictish women. She apparently bore some relation to, or descent from Egypt's Pharoes.
It is so wonderful that the music was moderated to be turned down or OFF during lecture. Most youtubers think we need entertainment whilst trying to understand meaningful dialogue. Thankyou thankyou
@@jo-vf8jx You are more accurate, or it's something like that. 🔹There's a glitch that causes the background music to have a higher volume on countless TH-cam Uploads. It is overwhelmingly assumed the Producer made a Production or an edit mistake. I'm surprised TH-cam has yet to address and/or resolve the problem. Many of these documentaries with English overlay, experience the same with the original narrative being so loud it interferes with the English Overlay. .
@jo-vf8jx To be precise, Slice is a TH-cam channel run by a company that produces and distributes creative documentaries. So we're both creator and operator ;)
What beautiful, beautiful country. I’ve always found the Scythians fascinating and their art just exquisite. Sadly, it’s often the only the wealthy we know about in ancient burials. Incredible find and so many wooden artifacts!
@@MadMomma-kj9ks We learn about different ancient cultures by emptying tombs. Or how else will we learn about these cultures if they leave no written records? Being placed in museums ensures that knowledge is spread to others who can't join these expeditions. They are far safer in a museum than being left to tomb raiders and sold off to faraway places that are secret and private.
E̶x̶c̶e̶l̶l̶e̶n̶t̶ d̶o̶c̶u̶m̶e̶n̶t̶a̶r̶y̶. But one question that keeps coming back to me. If you are heading to a location to excavate a frozen tomb in the middle of summer. One of the last frozen tombs left on the planet , and you know that once opened and defrosting sets in you will quickly lose organic contents. Why would you not take the refrigerated vehicle with you? Waiting that 3 - 4 days once you have already dug down to depth and exposed the tomb strikes me as very poor judgement at best and idiocy at worst. Fortunately in this case it doesn't seem to have made a huge difference. But it could have been a disaster. *Edit* having had time to review it further I think the terms incompetent and amateurish spring to mind. This really was a half cocked effort that smacks more of grave robbing than proper archeology. Hence i've crossed out my original first comment.
Bumbling is the word that comes to mind. Blaming false 'climate change' has become a catch-all for all globalists, pushing their control narrative with themselves remaining at the top of the pyramid. Mankind was in danger of a new ice age when I was young. Anyway, one would consider much better planning for such an archeology endeaver. Still an extremely interesting report - maybe a lesson would be learned for the future.
Very glad they were not taken out of country. I would also likevto see the bodies returned to the earth. Museuums in the USA are full of bodies of indigenous people…many taken under dubious, unethical and cruel circumstances.
Why? they weren't Mongolian, you focus on the far east of the Scythians range why? His grave has been disturbed and looted and his remains are viewed as property, yet you say respect, again why? virtue signaling for your peers? Your peers are not his or mine or any warrior's peer. Until he is returned to where he was interred there is no respect or honor to be had by anyone.
Sedentary people don’t quite grasp what life on the steppes was like. They think of it as one huge grassland where groups of nomads wandered around and some even attacked towns and cities once in awhile. The real life for these nomadic peoples was very fluid. As one researcher who had lived and studied in Central Asia for over 30 years had said: if one tribe of nomads submitted to and joined a larger tribe, within FORTY YEARS they would have so integrated into the larger tribe that they no longer had their own culture nor language but had completely melded with the larger tribe. So, honestly, it’s useless to say they were Iranian or Turkic or Mongolian or whatever- in fact, this fluidity of movement and of integration is proven from this very dig where the woman and the child were “European “ but the man was “Asian “. In a harsh and sparsely habited area, survival was important not ethnicity. Central Asia has been the greatest melting pot for centuries.
That's rare Usually It is Indo European y dna With asian mtdna I can see hundreds of burials that prove that Men travelled on horse back Harder for women How did these "European " women get to Asia?
These were other Asians associated with Paleo-Siberian Altaic and Ancient Eurasian ancestry. Which broke off from the trunk in the Upper Paleolithic. Modern Central Asians are related to Far East Asians aka Mongols, Nanai or Ulchi ppl. And Scytho-Sarmat samples are always associated only with Tatar origin. Therefore they stand out easily. In general, it is now 60-80% a West Eurasian Europo ancestry.
@@joebloe4374 Women of the steppes are and have been excellent riders and were also capable of fighting and hunting on horseback if necessary. Among the descendants of the Scythians who still live in the area, women have their own horses and other livestock, as these are part of their dowry and in local marriage customs remain theirs.
@@joebloe4374 Did you watch the video? The second tomb is all about how egalitarian scythian culture was, and how women also partook on fighting, leading and most certainly horseback riding. Genetic archeology Is making amazing contributions to our understanding, but some of the obsessing over Y chromosomes and mitocondrial DNA as sole evidence for cultural practices and ethnic belonging is becoming damaging for the broader and multidisciplinary interpretation
About 20 years ago I started working on my family genealogy. After tracing back 7 generations on my dads side I hit a wall. I would get frustrated and put it down and forget about it. 3 years ago I finally found someone else that had been searching theirs and that we were distant relatives and they were able to fill in what I never expected. My line goes back to this area south to the border area of northern Iran. Its been a while since I've looked at it but maybe someone here will know what im trying to describe. There was an important pass where I think the name was Alani or something. I'm going to have to dig that back out and continue the project or just read. At some point going back of course you lose the father to son connection and turns to tribe, location and movement. That pass was the end of the line for myself and the person that helped me. I would've never guessed i had origins near iran/Persia and asia. Then again we are all connected somewhere down the line
I would like to comment, but not as a criticism, but rather as a question. I will preface this question with I have no educated knowledge or experience of archeology. I have watched many documentaries on such things, some much better than others. So my experience is very limited. So my question is, why do I feel as if the finds from these digs were not handled with as much care as I normally observe? Why were all the bones being shoved in a bag that appeared much too small? When the gold covered wood was discovered and the gold was peeling off, it was being held up in windy conditions. Couldn't the gold have just blown away? It also seemed as if they didn't have any boxes to collect the finds. They kept on saying time was of the essence and that they had to wait 4 days for the refrigerated truck, then they were holding things up, leaving wood and bones exposed. Then, finally, when they were finished with the site, all the men started shoveling earth back into the hole. Much of the wood of the tomb was just left laying about and covered willy nilly (to my eyes) with the much and dust. I couldn't help feeling this was a dig to find items worth lots of money and to heck with the rest. Please tell me I am wrong. The second dig - Professor, "I think we should just go on, never mind the snow!" The lid is removed, "Wait wait, we must not let any moisture in! Cover it with a sheet!" Again, I just don't see the care and preparation.
i think that you are being just a bit over critical of this effort. i think that working within the time constraints imposed upon them and the remoteness of the area these guys did a decent job of saving some of the history of the Scythian people before it was all gone. As far as waiting for the refrigerated truck goes- i think that you are ignoring the fact that these research expeditions usually run on a shoe-string budget and obviously did not have the funds to have this truck on stand-bye- though i wish that they had they had elaborated a little bit on their funding sources and their planning. Personally- i wish that they had taken
Absolutely right. I am sure they took photos of every layer of what they excavated, but from my participation in digs here in Germany I know that at least they used to make sketches with every relevant detail on it. Maybe that has changed. Btw, I was a bit surprised to find Kazakhs in Mongolia. Of course, national borders don't reflect ethnic barriers. On the Karakorum Hightway leading from Kashgar in China, I was hosted by Tajiks.
@jimmatthews5993 I understand about underfunding and not having the ice truck on stand by, but then again, they chose the time of year, and they made the plans. It just all appeared a bit unprepared or underplanned. As professionals in their field, they should know where to spend the money they had, and in my sparce knowledge, I felt their choices were poor ones.
Proper considerate and hugely respectful. As it ought to be, as long as the people possess adequate means by which to store, maintain, cherish and exhibit them in theie public domain.
Incredible! Kazakhs still have very similar ornaments on their traditional attires! We thought they are solely Kazakh, but now I see they are much more ancient
And these ornaments are the same in Europe. It is called “fleur-de-lis” ( lily flower). It is symbolic in ancient European culture and probably has connection to ancient pre-Christian religion.
@@proudbacteria1373 similarly to scyth-saka people, kazakhs ornaments are zoomorphic. At the same time each typical ornament has its name, examples include "ram horns", "fox/fenec head", "wolf's ears", "swallow wings" and so on. For instance one of the found wooden plaques has a shape of Kazakh ornament called "ram horns" and another one "geese neck"
@@diyartokmurzin7154 Skythian people had Proto-Vedic religion which had connection to European religions and religion of Indian people. If you noticed Mongols still have Celtic knot ornament which they consider as their own ornament. Mongols forgot that they borrowed symbols from European religions.
@@diyartokmurzin7154 Original fleur-de-lis ornament had nothing to do with animals. It is closely related to Indian and European Trident which in India is manifested by Trinity - Brahma, Shiva and Vishnu. Vishnu is equivalent to Birth, Brama is equivalent to Life and Shiva is Death.
I love Mongolian history and culture and I have a lot of respect for them. One of my favourite periods in Mongolian history is the Kublai Khan era when he started to grapple with modernity in the west but respected all faiths - a ruler way ahead of his time. I also love that Marco Polo served in his court for 24 years helping the great Khan understand European culture and trading with Europe. It’s a great read and fascinates me.
@@obxarms7685 See my reply below to @bruanlokissin8615. You'll find Scythian ancestry among the peoples of the Altai and eastern Mongolians. Very rarely will anyone from modern European nations have it outside of the western flanks of the Altai Mountains. Really, it shouldn't matter - their blood lives on in the people of the land and some parts of their culture still exist if precariously. As for where the finds of the excavations belong, the area is in Mongolia, not any country in Europe, so there is where they should be.
Kazakh people in Mongolia are our Qandas, bloodbrothers. By the way in medieval middle-mongolian, the kipchak-turkic "qandas" transformed into "anda" meaning "brother". And the Kipchak-turkic word for brother "Baurym", transformed to "baurchi" meaning "the most trusted/closest"
Amazing. So moving. Such a rich culture slowly dying out. How sad. I wish the remaining traditional Kazakhs all the best. We could probably learn a lot from them.
If my memory serves, Mithradates of Pontus (and thorn in Rome's side) had a Scythian woman warrior/lover/partner who fought side by side with him in battle.
I find it hilarious that even super remote nomadic tribes are also like “I hate all these Chinese imported dog shit products” 😂 does Temu or Amazon deliver to a Mongolian plateau?
Not necessarily. There is way over the technical ability to make sure all flesh ceases to exist. Mark 13:20 KJV - And except that the Lord had shortened those days, no flesh should be saved: but for the elect's sake, whom he hath chosen, he hath shortened the days. Luke 3:6 KJV - And all flesh shall see the salvation of God.
Wonderful documentary.. how great it would be to travel through that area - does seem like wonderful people! The archeology is super, and I dearly love archeology.. I'm so thankful to see these things being saved, because so much archeological evidence is being lost to time
@willowgreinke7964 we have SO many tents in hollywood. We would donate but our leadership forces it's taxpaying citizens to live in these things. I know I'm jumping topics, but what is "skibbiddy toilet" supposed to mean? And what do I do with all my free AOL minutes CD rom disks now that building 7 is gone?
The ancient (ethnic/genetic) Scots of Ireland and Scotland claimed descent from the Scythi. Their Goddess Skytti, or Skatta/Skatha, or scotta (The letters 'a' and 'o' are generally interchangeable in their tongues) was said to be their ancestor, who came from the Scythians. and apparently the name of the isle of skye originates with this legend. where woimen apparently trained warriors in her fashion. So, why wasn't this mentioned instead of the Amazons with regard to the warrior woman? Warrior women were common within some Celtic, Scots, and Pictish women. She apparently bore some relation to, or descent from Egypt's Pharoes.
Scythians- Xoingnu- huns- mongols/ Turkic.They migrated towards west where the grass was abundant unlike the east dry steppes. The people in Mongolia, some central asia and Altia mountains still wear the hats and customs similar to the Scythians time.The DNA test said it was a europeon woman and Asian man of the bodies. That explains everything.
It's not impossible, but sadly, child sacrifice was practiced by various cultures in the ancient past. This is supported both by the historical records and by archeological evidence, including human remains and mummies. So, child sacrifice among the Scythians - especially with Herodotus's description - seems to be a likely explanation unless other evidence is unearthed to prove that this is incorrect.
@LaughtersMelody whilst child sacrifice seems to have occurred with South American peoples, such activity remains an instinctively unnatural act & would require some pressing psychological reason whereas child mortality is in current times unnaturally low, children were often seen as a precious resource in the survival of a people.
The way they lived and the lands they occupied seems like we Bulgarians were their descendants. The Old Great Bulgaria as we know it comes from the regions of Volga River and before that we have forgotten our history.
Right. So the theives are guaranteed a great haul, and will be digging there in droves. As if that will help anyone or anything. The land and the artifacts all belong to Mongolia, to do with them as they please. Get used to it.
They’re saving them to keep them from being degraded even more by the ice that’s melting. They have to preserve them for the Mongolian people and were taken to their museum after repairing and cleaning.
Spoken like someone who's afflicted with religious beliefs. The ppl they are SAVING from destruction and looting are almost 3,000 yrs old. They are not in any meaningful way related to the modern Mongolians. We all have a right to know the history of humanity.
It is my belief that off-shoots of the Scythians went beyond the Altai Mountains as far south as the Korean Peninsula. I have come to this hypothesis by research into the Art, Religions, and nomadic remnants of Scythian culture analog s that can be found in Korean Archaeology and Shamanistic religions.
I'm just glad that this documentary isn't centered, every time recently I watched a documentary it's heavily censored even if it's just a skeleton, it's ridiculous.
Very good indeed. I liked the way that certain info has been shielded, leaving plenty enough to gain a basic understanding. Nomadic warriors left a vast mark of their 'being'. They were the main cause of so-called civilisation taking to wall building. Perhaps read, 'Walls'. A History of Civilisation in Blood and Brick.
It's interesting that he said Alexander The Great lost to the Scythians. I was always taught that except for skirmishes, the lone battle was at the Battle of Jaxartes, which Macedonia won.
You're a "journalist" who's made a career out of publishing CCP propaganda for Western audiences. What would your grand Winnie the Pooh expect? Destroy everything.
All archeology is an act of destruction. That's why excruciating exact documentation of every day's work is so very important. Also, this seemed to be an act of rescue. All rules suspended in order to rescue delicate organic finds.
Scythians were incredibly fierce horse backed warriors and the steppes are noted in the Bibles descriptions of the last days as part of the coalition coming against Israel as Magog. Thank you for posting this incredible find.
@appaloosa42 can you provide the source document for your comment? I would really like to dive deeper into it. Thank you. May God bless you many times today!
Документарац почиње са Глобалистичком лажи о Глобалном загревању... Како да вам поверујемо остатак емисије? За чију агенду улажете новац у овај програм?
Adults who sacrificed their children were far from saving knowledge of God. Little did they know that it was only their sacrificed children that would make it into heaven. Children who die before their age of accountability go to heaven, by shear grace.
It's fascinating that the music at the end of the documentary has the same musical elements as old Scottish and Irish music! Some things transcend not only time, but culture. Is there any way to find out the name of the song at the end of the video?
I wish there was a centralized database of all ancient DNA found an archaeological sites.. just imagine the information that could be gained from that, as it relates to current population dispersions.
- This is NOT how an archaeology team should approach an ancient grave, no gloves, untrained construction workers etc. - The French fellow is biased, perhaps to satisfy his Mongolian team. Scythians were an Iranic People. They spoke Iranic Languages, not Iranian and many other languages. There is NO language as Iranian. - If you don’t know the difference between Iranic, Iranian, and Persian, don’t bother to comment! - Turkic People joined the party long after the Iranic People. Twisting facts, fabricating histories and trying to steal other nations’ histories will NEVER compensate their arriving late to the scene. Never!
True. Scythians were a group of Iranian peoples and they are even mentioned in the stone carvings of King Darius of the achaemenid dynasty and the holy book Avesta. Even in modern day Iran we have a province called Sistan. Which means the land of the scythians! So scythians were indeed Iranian and indo_european. PanTurks are trying to make a fake history for political reasons and gains.
At ~29 mins: _“…the Scythian were mounted archers. Their battle strategy was based on the use of highly mobile forces that could pursue the enemy for hours. The populations that inhabited the steppe, _*_and the people that live there today, employ the same combat tactics and rely on mounted archery.”_* There’s a lot of mounted archery combat going on today is there? _“Look out for the mounted archers…”_ _“Not _*_another_*_ group of mounted archers…”_ _“Someone really needs to do something about all those mounted archers…”_ Pretty sure that’s not a today thing.
Mounted archers hunt animals or do battle the same way. What he is referring to are the mounted animal hunters of today. They are really good at hunting and can shoot a rabbit or a marmot while on a galloping horse. This way of life is rapidly disappearing.
What kind of archeologist are those people? They touch the scythian objekts with bare fingers. Did not they hear yet that you have to wear gloves touching archeological finds?
You don't have to. In fact, the majority of times, archeologists don't wear gloves while excavating. Typically gloves are only worn when extremely rare or valuable objects are discovered.
@@dai-nippon_digger Oils and debris from your fingers may taint the objects, and there might be something poisonous like arsenic been used to treat the stuff. Think what kind of stuff oil from your hands could do to some specimens especially when they let them be unfrozen like this for a while, they could ruin them or make some marks on them which could make difference in what kind of observations are made about them.
Shocking how French scientists still can’t imagine a world where there is no distinction between different ethnicities, and they can’t understand that there was no concept of Europeans and Asians 2000 years ago, these people were different tribes living next to each others, friends sometimes and enemies at other times, true racism mentality hard to change
The end is spoiled by the grrl-boss mythology: better relegated to to the latest pestilential version of Star Wars. Anyone who can say with a straight face that women fought with men as equals using blade weapons has obviously never had a fist fight as an adult in their entire life. Laughable!
These videos are sooo building on things that I have been learning all my 75 yrs.. It's all beginning to come together, as the scriptures say it will. Bravo guys for starting this channel I've been with you since the beginning. I thought, for a long time, that I was the only Church member out there who was interested in all these disjointed things and was beginning to think that perhaps I wasn't on solid Church foundations although I always asked Heavenly Father to let me know if I was about to become one of the ones who would fall at the very end, as I had no intentions of doing so... and He never sent me feelings or words to say I was being misled, so I continued to research. I always wanted to be an archaeologist, but now I'm glad I didn't choose/wasn't allowed to follow that path ("There are no female archaeologists dear" - mid 60's downplaying of women's capabilities still). I was soo discouraged to follow my heart due to the closed mindedness of the "Professionals". But now I am glad andwas free to follow what research or researchers I chose who made more sense and were willing to stand alone like Graham Hancock, Joe Rogan, Brien Foerester etc and now yourselves and your guests like Chief Midegah & Lance. I love the exploration you're presenting of the BoM and happily subscribe to both N & S models that Lance is exploring, but lean more to the Heartland model. Can you get Wayne May on your show? He is soo interesting and another amazingly knowledgeable guy. Did (our BoM) man walk with the dinosaurs? Great question.. !
That was really interesting; Thank-You! Re the question You posed: The temporary conservation measures used for moving the items to the lab in France seemed appropriate to Me. We only see the immediate actions, and I didn’t hear Anyone say that the remains WOULDN’T be kept cool - so that equipment may have been beyond Our sight. It did sound to Me as though the flight of exhumed material would be immediate, so I don’t worry that damaged will occur. ‘Armchair Archeology’ is fun, but I think it’s important to remember that what We see has been edited; I don’t think We have all of the information necessary to make a judgement call regarding the actions of these Archeologists.
I remember in one of the readings from Edgar Cayce he mentioned there is more gold buried there than there is circulating in the entire world today... 😮
I remember reading about this in the National Geographic magazine a few years ago. The woman had tattoos on her upper arm. Shame they didn't show everything once it was cleaned up, otherwise very good documentary. I didn't know about the grave with the man and child.
When the narrator says mongolian invasions, he doesn't mean rhe actual Ghengizid Mongqol invasion. She means the hunnic/Xiongnu invasion, which was geographically linked to modern Mongolia. According to modern studies they were most probably predominantly proto-turkic
Earliest recorded use of marijuana is a Scythian fire pit. About 2 .5 metres across full plants and boughs of drug grade cannabis were heaped on coals, a large tent could accommodate a group of warriors, who would sit inside the tent and breathe in the fumes.
Nice show! Great fun , especially l the Woman's Suffrage History. My dear elder cousins grandmother was force fed at the same time. How far we have come. WE WON"T GO BACK!
I'm a Pars(Persian) and one of my friends is a 6 6 red-headed Scythian originally from Ossetia(Ossetians are one of the Iraninc people and the Aryan cousins of the Persians). If you visit the Perspolis(Parseh) in Shiraz and Bisotun in Kermanshah(both are very historical cities in Iran) you'll see the petroglyph of Scythians with pointy helmets. Interestingly, while on the Perspolis walls, they're seen hand in hand with their Persian cousins, on the Bisotun wall their leader is captured and captivated amongst others because they rebelled against King Dariush The Great(a lesson for some of the Kurds and Azaris who are making the same mistake thinking this time somehow it would be different). Anyways, as a Pars, I love my Scythian cousins especially those who live in Ossetia, I think about you every once in a while and I hope one day I get the chance to visit and I highly encourage you to come and visit Iran; after all, we're all Iranic people.
There is nothing to see here, the Hungarians are Scythians, Huns and Avars, the Sons and Daughters of Nimrod, the Grandchildren of Hunor and Magor... the high culture of these peoples is already manifested in the extraordinary language of the Magyars, this is where everything comes from, the linguistic expression, as well as the ancient runic writing of the Hungarians the basis of their high culture. ❤🤍💚
The information gained from these tombs is invaluable but they were not dug with best archaeological practice. If these were really the last two untouched ice tombs then they really messed up. Intact tombs of the kind with hollow chambers or mummified remains will degrade in the presence of oxygen in a very short time. They needed proper climate controlled isolation tents and full PPE to avoid genetic contamination. They just lifted artifacts with bare hands instead of block-lifting. Nowadays we do photogrammetry every few centimeters but this seems to be at least decade old footage so that's excusable, but having great big spoil heaps unsorted and unsifted is not. That arm was quite possibly not detached before the excavation as seen by the adipocere and dried tissues. That clip of picking the beads off of the hat remnants irks me because now we won't know how they were sewn on. The way the stones of the cairns were thrown about is a huge no-no because they all have to be documented exactly. The tools used throughout were not exactly delicate; you don't use pickaxes and shovels and trowels in a grave. This is the time for brushes, spatulas, toothpicks, and pipettes. I could go on but it will just make me angry. I'm glad the graves were documented but my goodness was it botched.
Hello everybody! Many of you have pointed out several mistakes made by the archaeological team during their excavation. Let's open up the debate! What do you think they should be reproached for, and what alternatives should they have considered instead?
@SLICEDocumentary I would like to comment, but not as a criticism, but rather as a question. I will preface this question with I have no educated knowledge or experience of archeology. I have watched many documentaries on such things, some much better than others. So my experience is very limited. So my question is, why do I feel as if the finds from these digs were not handled with as much care as I normally observe? Why were all the bones being shoved in a bag that appeared much too small? When the gold covered wood was discovered and the gold was peeling off, it was being held up in windy conditions. Couldn't the gold have just blown away? It also seemed as if they didn't have any boxes to collect the finds. They kept on saying time was of the essence and that they had to wait 4 days for the refrigerated truck, then they were holding things up, leaving wood and bones exposed. Then, finally, when they were finished with the site, all the men started shoveling earth back into the hole. Much of the wood of the tomb was just left laying about and covered willy nilly (to my eyes) with the much and dust. I couldn't help feeling this was a dig to find items worth lots of money and to heck with the rest. Please tell me I am wrong. The second dig - Professor, "I think we should just go on, never mind the snow!" The lid is removed, "Wait wait, we must not let any moisture in! Cover it with a sheet!" Again, I just don't see the care and preparation.
This interesting documentary unfortunately fails to give some important information, to wit, the year of the excavation and the official designation of the site. Also, the "transcript" is full of errors, e.g., the lead archaeologist's name is garbled, and numbers and meters are messed up.
@@Britgirl58 you did observe correctly, it was more grave robbing than anything else, and what happened afterwards simply confirms that it was for wealth and fame not for knowledge or science.
They originated from there so not a big deal
The ancient (ethnic/genetic) Scots of Ireland and Scotland claimed descent from the Scythi. Their Goddess Skytti, or Skatta/Skatha, or scotta (The letters 'a' and 'o' are generally interchangeable in their tongues) was said to be their ancestor, who came from the Scythians. and apparently the name of the isle of skye originates with this legend. where woimen apparently trained warriors in her fashion.
So, why wasn't this mentioned instead of the Amazons with regard to the warrior woman?
Warrior women were common within some Celtic, Scots, and Pictish women.
She apparently bore some relation to, or descent from Egypt's Pharoes.
It is so wonderful that the music was moderated to be turned down or OFF during lecture. Most youtubers think we need entertainment whilst trying to understand meaningful dialogue.
Thankyou thankyou
This is a TH-cam channel not a TH-cam Content creator. There is a difference, this channel posts documentaries. It does not create its own content.
th-cam.com/video/zYk0GH5iFYI/w-d-xo.htmlsi=EnZruSxE1KNjEiK8
@@jo-vf8jx
You are more accurate, or it's something like that. 🔹There's a glitch that causes the background music to have a higher volume on countless TH-cam Uploads.
It is overwhelmingly assumed the Producer made a Production or an edit mistake.
I'm surprised TH-cam has yet to address and/or resolve the problem.
Many of these documentaries with English overlay, experience the same with the original narrative being so loud it interferes with the English Overlay.
.
@jo-vf8jx To be precise, Slice is a TH-cam channel run by a company that produces and distributes creative documentaries. So we're both creator and operator ;)
For a documentary like this you absolutely need background music to set the mood and transport you that world
What beautiful, beautiful country. I’ve always found the Scythians fascinating and their art just exquisite. Sadly, it’s often the only the wealthy we know about in ancient burials. Incredible find and so many wooden artifacts!
Thank you for posting this video.
Excelent doc, as usual! Very good soundscore and narration!
The Kazakh lady saying "it wouldve sucked if the tomb was empty lol" had me rolling
Now that these tomb raiders emptied it, it does suck.
@@MadMomma-kj9ks We learn about different ancient cultures by emptying tombs. Or how else will we learn about these cultures if they leave no written records? Being placed in museums ensures that knowledge is spread to others who can't join these expeditions. They are far safer in a museum than being left to tomb raiders and sold off to faraway places that are secret and private.
@@MadMomma-kj9ks
It will all rot & that's best in your mindset?
@@MadMomma-kj9ks boohoo
@allypally, even funnier had she said " it would be whack if the tomb was empty" 😊😅😂
E̶x̶c̶e̶l̶l̶e̶n̶t̶ d̶o̶c̶u̶m̶e̶n̶t̶a̶r̶y̶. But one question that keeps coming back to me. If you are heading to a location to excavate a frozen tomb in the middle of summer. One of the last frozen tombs left on the planet , and you know that once opened and defrosting sets in you will quickly lose organic contents. Why would you not take the refrigerated vehicle with you? Waiting that 3 - 4 days once you have already dug down to depth and exposed the tomb strikes me as very poor judgement at best and idiocy at worst. Fortunately in this case it doesn't seem to have made a huge difference. But it could have been a disaster. *Edit* having had time to review it further I think the terms incompetent and amateurish spring to mind. This really was a half cocked effort that smacks more of grave robbing than proper archeology. Hence i've crossed out my original first comment.
Bumbling is the word that comes to mind. Blaming false 'climate change' has become a catch-all for all globalists, pushing their control narrative with themselves remaining at the top of the pyramid. Mankind was in danger of a new ice age when I was young. Anyway, one would consider much better planning for such an archeology endeaver. Still an extremely interesting report - maybe a lesson would be learned for the future.
Funding?
My question too!
@@Rusty-GB people STILL SEARCH FOR TOMB OF GHENGIS Khan...
2 words. Minimize expenditure.
Absolutely Awesome documentary. Thanks so much, Slice. ❤❤❤
Respect for returning them to Museum IN MONGOLIA.
They should return them to the ground... STUDY then return to rest where they were.
Very glad they were not taken out of country. I would also likevto see the bodies returned to the earth. Museuums in the USA are full of bodies of indigenous people…many taken under dubious, unethical and cruel circumstances.
Who in the world think anyone will see the museum in Mongolia
Almost nobody
Why? they weren't Mongolian, you focus on the far east of the Scythians range why? His grave has been disturbed and looted and his remains are viewed as property, yet you say respect, again why? virtue signaling for your peers? Your peers are not his or mine or any warrior's peer. Until he is returned to where he was interred there is no respect or honor to be had by anyone.
Sedentary people don’t quite grasp what life on the steppes was like. They think of it as one huge grassland where groups of nomads wandered around and some even attacked towns and cities once in awhile.
The real life for these nomadic peoples was very fluid. As one researcher who had lived and studied in Central Asia for over 30 years had said: if one tribe of nomads submitted to and joined a larger tribe, within FORTY YEARS they would have so integrated into the larger tribe that they no longer had their own culture nor language but had completely melded with the larger tribe. So, honestly, it’s useless to say they were Iranian or Turkic or Mongolian or whatever- in fact, this fluidity of movement and of integration is proven from this very dig where the woman and the child were “European “ but the man was “Asian “. In a harsh and sparsely habited area, survival was important not ethnicity. Central Asia has been the greatest melting pot for centuries.
That's rare
Usually
It is Indo European y dna
With asian mtdna
I can see hundreds of burials that prove that
Men travelled on horse back
Harder for women
How did these "European " women get to Asia?
These were other Asians associated with Paleo-Siberian Altaic and Ancient Eurasian ancestry. Which broke off from the trunk in the Upper Paleolithic. Modern Central Asians are related to Far East Asians aka Mongols, Nanai or Ulchi ppl. And Scytho-Sarmat samples are always associated only with Tatar origin. Therefore they stand out easily. In general, it is now 60-80% a West Eurasian Europo ancestry.
@@joebloe4374 Women of the steppes are and have been excellent riders and were also capable of fighting and hunting on horseback if necessary. Among the descendants of the Scythians who still live in the area, women have their own horses and other livestock, as these are part of their dowry and in local marriage customs remain theirs.
@@allisonshaw9341 yes I know
I'm kyrgyz
But most kyrgyz women today prefer iPhone 15 to archery and Mercedes benz to horse😆💯👍
@@joebloe4374 Did you watch the video? The second tomb is all about how egalitarian scythian culture was, and how women also partook on fighting, leading and most certainly horseback riding.
Genetic archeology Is making amazing contributions to our understanding, but some of the obsessing over Y chromosomes and mitocondrial DNA as sole evidence for cultural practices and ethnic belonging is becoming damaging for the broader and multidisciplinary interpretation
About 20 years ago I started working on my family genealogy. After tracing back 7 generations on my dads side I hit a wall. I would get frustrated and put it down and forget about it. 3 years ago I finally found someone else that had been searching theirs and that we were distant relatives and they were able to fill in what I never expected. My line goes back to this area south to the border area of northern Iran. Its been a while since I've looked at it but maybe someone here will know what im trying to describe. There was an important pass where I think the name was Alani or something.
I'm going to have to dig that back out and continue the project or just read. At some point going back of course you lose the father to son connection and turns to tribe, location and movement. That pass was the end of the line for myself and the person that helped me. I would've never guessed i had origins near iran/Persia and asia. Then again we are all connected somewhere down the line
So what? We all came from somewhere, where is actually pointless,we are here now nothing else matters.
A whole group of people around 500 BC were called Alens. They were in central Europe
B+ blood type?
@@jujujudiowhere does the B+ blood type is mostly found?
@@iriecedricjamaican4075 Asia and Africa. But any ethnic group can have it. I’m Caucasian and B positive.
I love Documentaries like this. Very interesting, Thank you 👍😁
I would like to comment, but not as a criticism, but rather as a question. I will preface this question with I have no educated knowledge or experience of archeology. I have watched many documentaries on such things, some much better than others. So my experience is very limited. So my question is, why do I feel as if the finds from these digs were not handled with as much care as I normally observe? Why were all the bones being shoved in a bag that appeared much too small? When the gold covered wood was discovered and the gold was peeling off, it was being held up in windy conditions. Couldn't the gold have just blown away? It also seemed as if they didn't have any boxes to collect the finds. They kept on saying time was of the essence and that they had to wait 4 days for the refrigerated truck, then they were holding things up, leaving wood and bones exposed. Then, finally, when they were finished with the site, all the men started shoveling earth back into the hole. Much of the wood of the tomb was just left laying about and covered willy nilly (to my eyes) with the much and dust. I couldn't help feeling this was a dig to find items worth lots of money and to heck with the rest. Please tell me I am wrong. The second dig - Professor, "I think we should just go on, never mind the snow!" The lid is removed, "Wait wait, we must not let any moisture in! Cover it with a sheet!" Again, I just don't see the care and preparation.
i think that you are being just a bit over critical of this effort. i think that working within the time constraints imposed upon them and the remoteness of the area these guys did a decent job of saving some of the history of the Scythian people before it was all gone. As far as waiting for the refrigerated truck goes- i think that you are ignoring the fact that these research expeditions usually run on a shoe-string budget and obviously did not have the funds to have this truck on stand-bye- though i wish that they had they had elaborated a little bit on their funding sources and their planning. Personally- i wish that they had taken
Absolutely right. I am sure they took photos of every layer of what they excavated, but from my participation in digs here in Germany I know that at least they used to make sketches with every relevant detail on it. Maybe that has changed.
Btw, I was a bit surprised to find Kazakhs in Mongolia. Of course, national borders don't reflect ethnic barriers. On the Karakorum Hightway leading from Kashgar in China, I was hosted by Tajiks.
@jimmatthews5993 I understand about underfunding and not having the ice truck on stand by, but then again, they chose the time of year, and they made the plans. It just all appeared a bit unprepared or underplanned. As professionals in their field, they should know where to spend the money they had, and in my sparce knowledge, I felt their choices were poor ones.
Wonderful that artifacts to be returned back where people know their history and heritage. For all to learn.
Proper considerate and hugely respectful. As it ought to be, as long as the people possess adequate means by which to store, maintain, cherish and exhibit them in theie public domain.
Thank you for this video
Incredible! Kazakhs still have very similar ornaments on their traditional attires! We thought they are solely Kazakh, but now I see they are much more ancient
And these ornaments are the same in Europe. It is called “fleur-de-lis” ( lily flower). It is symbolic in ancient European culture and probably has connection to ancient pre-Christian religion.
@@proudbacteria1373 similarly to scyth-saka people, kazakhs ornaments are zoomorphic. At the same time each typical ornament has its name, examples include "ram horns", "fox/fenec head", "wolf's ears", "swallow wings" and so on. For instance one of the found wooden plaques has a shape of Kazakh ornament called "ram horns" and another one "geese neck"
@@diyartokmurzin7154 Skythian people had Proto-Vedic religion which had connection to European religions and religion of Indian people. If you noticed Mongols still have Celtic knot ornament which they consider as their own ornament. Mongols forgot that they borrowed symbols from European religions.
@@diyartokmurzin7154 Original fleur-de-lis ornament had nothing to do with animals. It is closely related to Indian and European Trident which in India is manifested by Trinity - Brahma, Shiva and Vishnu. Vishnu is equivalent to Birth, Brama is equivalent to Life and Shiva is Death.
Excellent documentary very informative and interesting!! Thank you 😊
Thank you for sharing this, it's very interesting and enjoying to watch.
Beautiful people
I love Mongolian history and culture and I have a lot of respect for them. One of my favourite periods in Mongolian history is the Kublai Khan era when he started to grapple with modernity in the west but respected all faiths - a ruler way ahead of his time. I also love that Marco Polo served in his court for 24 years helping the great Khan understand European culture and trading with Europe. It’s a great read and fascinates me.
The Scythians were not Asian or Mongols. They were proto-Europeans.
@@obxarms7685 See my reply below to @bruanlokissin8615. You'll find Scythian ancestry among the peoples of the Altai and eastern Mongolians. Very rarely will anyone from modern European nations have it outside of the western flanks of the Altai Mountains.
Really, it shouldn't matter - their blood lives on in the people of the land and some parts of their culture still exist if precariously. As for where the finds of the excavations belong, the area is in Mongolia, not any country in Europe, so there is where they should be.
why?
@@obxarms7685 yes that’s right.
They say Kazakh culture, but you are talking about Mongolians!
So many professional archeologists in this thread! Never before have I seen so many.
The professionals are those who taught us to see what is wrong with an excavation like this.
Kazakh people in Mongolia are our Qandas, bloodbrothers. By the way in medieval middle-mongolian, the kipchak-turkic "qandas" transformed into "anda" meaning "brother". And the Kipchak-turkic word for brother "Baurym", transformed to "baurchi" meaning "the most trusted/closest"
That was truly awesome! Thank you for sharing this adventure!
Tank you for watching ! Don't forget to like and subscribe 😉
Totally fascinating!
Amazing. So moving. Such a rich culture slowly dying out. How sad. I wish the remaining traditional Kazakhs all the best. We could probably learn a lot from them.
A beautiful documentary. Thank you so much.
If my memory serves, Mithradates of Pontus (and thorn in Rome's side) had a Scythian woman warrior/lover/partner who fought side by side with him in battle.
I find it hilarious that even super remote nomadic tribes are also like “I hate all these Chinese imported dog shit products” 😂 does Temu or Amazon deliver to a Mongolian plateau?
Amazon does 😂
These type of people will still be riding their horses and living their simple life even if the rest of the world destroys itself.
Yes. We will!
Not necessarily. There is way over the technical ability to make sure all flesh ceases to exist.
Mark 13:20 KJV - And except that the Lord had shortened those days, no flesh should be saved: but for the elect's sake, whom he hath chosen, he hath shortened the days.
Luke 3:6 KJV - And all flesh shall see the salvation of God.
@@kathleennorton2228 yawn.
Enjoyed this very much. Thank you!
I love this channel
Wonderful documentary.. how great it would be to travel through that area - does seem like wonderful people! The archeology is super, and I dearly love archeology.. I'm so thankful to see these things being saved, because so much archeological evidence is being lost to time
Very interesting indeed .
thank you. all the best
So sad to see the remains rained on.
Ridiculous there is no tent.
No tents used in Mongolia unless it is winter
No wonder the French are not exactly renowned as warriors. The English or German would have been prepared with gloves and tarps.
A marquee at least. Even Time Team carried a few.😊
@willowgreinke7964 we have SO many tents in hollywood. We would donate but our leadership forces it's taxpaying citizens to live in these things. I know I'm jumping topics, but what is "skibbiddy toilet" supposed to mean? And what do I do with all my free AOL minutes CD rom disks now that building 7 is gone?
@margomoore4527 a gloved and tarped warrior is the only thing that will stop climate change
The ancient (ethnic/genetic) Scots of Ireland and Scotland claimed descent from the Scythi. Their Goddess Skytti, or Skatta/Skatha, or scotta (The letters 'a' and 'o' are generally interchangeable in their tongues) was said to be their ancestor, who came from the Scythians. and apparently the name of the isle of skye originates with this legend. where woimen apparently trained warriors in her fashion.
So, why wasn't this mentioned instead of the Amazons with regard to the warrior woman?
Warrior women were common within some Celtic, Scots, and Pictish women.
She apparently bore some relation to, or descent from Egypt's Pharoes.
Interesting and well done documentary.
Very interesting!
Scythians- Xoingnu- huns- mongols/ Turkic.They migrated towards west where the grass was abundant unlike the east dry steppes. The people in Mongolia, some central asia and Altia mountains still wear the hats and customs similar to the Scythians time.The DNA test said it was a europeon woman and Asian man of the bodies. That explains everything.
@@decollector95 I think they will all fall between Xiongnu and Mongal/ Turkic. Turkic applies to people of central asia from western China to Turkey.
a good documentary!
So interesting, thank you.
Given that these people kept bodies for later burial it might be the case that children that died were kept for later burial with honoured adults?
Herodotus said sacrificed
@@lglubbock7593 quite a number of ancient authors 'spiced up' the lives of the 'barbarians' they were writing about, tabloid journalism is nothing new
It's not impossible, but sadly, child sacrifice was practiced by various cultures in the ancient past. This is supported both by the historical records and by archeological evidence, including human remains and mummies. So, child sacrifice among the Scythians - especially with Herodotus's description - seems to be a likely explanation unless other evidence is unearthed to prove that this is incorrect.
@LaughtersMelody whilst child sacrifice seems to have occurred with South American peoples, such activity remains an instinctively unnatural act & would require some pressing psychological reason whereas child mortality is in current times unnaturally low, children were often seen as a precious resource in the survival of a people.
@@pcka12 Herodotus was known for exageration and, frankly, down right lying. Clickbait of his age
Wonderfull video. Congratulations on a excellent outcome.
Herodotus was right again!
Every. Single. Time.
About what?
@@t.durustein2185 everything
@t.durustein2185 arians are scythian royalty. not hebrews
@@gullybull5568 Do you know what arian actually means in Greek?
The way they lived and the lands they occupied seems like we Bulgarians were their descendants. The Old Great Bulgaria as we know it comes from the regions of Volga River and before that we have forgotten our history.
Other than saving these treasures from other thieves you shouldn't be disturbing them at all
Right. So the theives are guaranteed a great haul, and will be digging there in droves. As if that will help anyone or anything. The land and the artifacts all belong to Mongolia, to do with them as they please. Get used to it.
Acting as wise…..,,,,
They’re saving them to keep them from being degraded even more by the ice that’s melting. They have to preserve them for the Mongolian people and were taken to their museum after repairing and cleaning.
Spoken like someone who's afflicted with religious beliefs.
The ppl they are SAVING from destruction and looting are almost 3,000 yrs old. They are not in any meaningful way related to the modern Mongolians.
We all have a right to know the history of humanity.
It is my belief that off-shoots of the Scythians went beyond the Altai Mountains as far south as the Korean Peninsula. I have come to this hypothesis by research into the Art, Religions, and nomadic remnants of Scythian culture analog s that can be found in Korean Archaeology and Shamanistic religions.
I can't imagine how the team got any equipment to such a remote location. Kudos for all the planning and hard work
I'm just glad that this documentary isn't centered, every time recently I watched a documentary it's heavily censored even if it's just a skeleton, it's ridiculous.
Very good indeed. I liked the way that certain info has been shielded, leaving plenty enough to gain a basic understanding. Nomadic warriors left a vast mark of their 'being'. They were the main cause of so-called civilisation taking to wall building. Perhaps read, 'Walls'. A History of Civilisation in Blood and Brick.
Good example of 19th century archeological excavation. These guys are not professional.
Made me cringe.
Bravo prof. Giscard, are you fine?
Mongolia is a beautiful place
Very good indeed.
It's interesting that he said Alexander The Great lost to the Scythians.
I was always taught that except for skirmishes, the lone battle was at the Battle of Jaxartes, which Macedonia won.
Very amateur excavation. Handling artefacts with bare hands. Picking up bones and just plonking g them in sacks. Incredible
You're a "journalist" who's made a career out of publishing CCP propaganda for Western audiences. What would your grand Winnie the Pooh expect? Destroy everything.
All archeology is an act of destruction. That's why excruciating exact documentation of every day's work is so very important. Also, this seemed to be an act of rescue. All rules suspended in order to rescue delicate organic finds.
@@SandraNelson063 so they were waiting on an ice truck for 4 days but couldn't get a pair of gloves??
We're sorry
Scythians were incredibly fierce horse backed warriors and the steppes are noted in the Bibles descriptions of the last days as part of the coalition coming against Israel as Magog.
Thank you for posting this incredible find.
The original purpose and name of China’s great wall was the “wall of Gog and Magag”.
@appaloosa42 can you provide the source document for your comment? I would really like to dive deeper into it. Thank you.
May God bless you many times today!
Yes, all very interesting, but who were they?
Тәңір жарылқасын қандай әдемі сөз, қазағым аман бол❤
Do we know when this documentary was filmed?
That "Life is Good" hat made me chuckle.
Документарац почиње са Глобалистичком лажи о Глобалном загревању... Како да вам поверујемо остатак емисије? За чију агенду улажете новац у овај програм?
This "Archeology" looks very close to looting in lab coats.
just wandering when someone will be able to dig up my grave and put it on ytube.
Yes, but like they said at the beginning, these are being destroyed by climate changes. They're racing and out of time to find these things.
Agreed
@@danecrude😅
Child sacrifice is sad.
Yah but its 2000 years old so who cares lol
...don't you love the gods??
Adults who sacrificed their children were far from saving knowledge of God. Little did they know that it was only their sacrificed children that would make it into heaven. Children who die before their age of accountability go to heaven, by shear grace.
@@kathleennorton2228 Best comment on any TH-cam channel I've read all week.
It's fascinating that the music at the end of the documentary has the same musical elements as old Scottish and Irish music! Some things transcend not only time, but culture. Is there any way to find out the name of the song at the end of the video?
I wish there was a centralized database of all ancient DNA found an archaeological sites.. just imagine the information that could be gained from that, as it relates to current population dispersions.
I have been slowly working on getting my right arm tattooed with Scythian art.
Thanks👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
- This is NOT how an archaeology team should approach an ancient grave, no gloves, untrained construction workers etc.
- The French fellow is biased, perhaps to satisfy his Mongolian team. Scythians were an Iranic People. They spoke Iranic Languages, not Iranian and many other languages. There is NO language as Iranian.
- If you don’t know the difference between Iranic, Iranian, and Persian, don’t bother to comment!
- Turkic People joined the party long after the Iranic People. Twisting facts, fabricating histories and trying to steal other nations’ histories will NEVER compensate their arriving late to the scene. Never!
Do you not think a lot of this was re-enacted? Time Team talked about re-enactments as cameras were not usually on the finds.
Whose history?
True
Turks didn't expand until about 550 ad
True. Scythians were a group of Iranian peoples and they are even mentioned in the stone carvings of King Darius of the achaemenid dynasty and the holy book Avesta. Even in modern day Iran we have a province called Sistan. Which means the land of the scythians! So scythians were indeed Iranian and indo_european. PanTurks are trying to make a fake history for political reasons and gains.
@@roshanakarya1081 it is Mongol. No Iran or Anatolian Turks have nothing to do with it.
At ~29 mins: _“…the Scythian were mounted archers. Their battle strategy was based on the use of highly mobile forces that could pursue the enemy for hours. The populations that inhabited the steppe, _*_and the people that live there today, employ the same combat tactics and rely on mounted archery.”_*
There’s a lot of mounted archery combat going on today is there?
_“Look out for the mounted archers…”_
_“Not _*_another_*_ group of mounted archers…”_
_“Someone really needs to do something about all those mounted archers…”_
Pretty sure that’s not a today thing.
Mounted archers hunt animals or do battle the same way. What he is referring to are the mounted animal hunters of today. They are really good at hunting and can shoot a rabbit or a marmot while on a galloping horse. This way of life is rapidly disappearing.
@@MegaCavatina marmots are hunted and eaten, but they are an endangered species.
@@KimDammers ALL marmot species? That’s a lot.
To actually see the effects of media(TV) on a nomadic people is shocking. It's all in the eyes.
What kind of archeologist are those people? They touch the scythian objekts with bare fingers. Did not they hear yet that you have to wear gloves touching archeological finds?
They are trainees conscripted for monogolia political employment numbers
You don't have to. In fact, the majority of times, archeologists don't wear gloves while excavating. Typically gloves are only worn when extremely rare or valuable objects are discovered.
@@dai-nippon_digger No, that's not true. I am an archeologist and I know what I am talking about.
@@dai-nippon_digger Oils and debris from your fingers may taint the objects, and there might be something poisonous like arsenic been used to treat the stuff. Think what kind of stuff oil from your hands could do to some specimens especially when they let them be unfrozen like this for a while, they could ruin them or make some marks on them which could make difference in what kind of observations are made about them.
Shocking how French scientists still can’t imagine a world where there is no distinction between different ethnicities, and they can’t understand that there was no concept of Europeans and Asians 2000 years ago, these people were different tribes living next to each others, friends sometimes and enemies at other times, true racism mentality hard to change
The end is spoiled by the grrl-boss mythology: better relegated to to the latest pestilential version of Star Wars.
Anyone who can say with a straight face that women fought with men as equals using blade weapons has obviously never had a fist fight as an adult in their entire life. Laughable!
Thank you!
That is a sad sight indeed - clustered around the television like that. If only they knew what it will cost them.
I know they were in a hurry but that's a very brutal and rough excavation.
Id love to live there in the summer.
Someone didn't think this archaeological dig through very thoroughly.
Yes! They smoked weed (hashish)! A bag of cannabis was also found in a frozen tomb in Siberia.
It grows wild there
Pick and smoke
В России нашли золотой прибор для курения с остатками вещества.
These videos are sooo building on things that I have been learning all my 75 yrs.. It's all beginning to come together, as the scriptures say it will.
Bravo guys for starting this channel I've been with you since the beginning.
I thought, for a long time, that I was the only Church member out there who was interested in all these disjointed things and was beginning to think that perhaps I wasn't on solid Church foundations although I always asked Heavenly Father to let me know if I was about to become one of the ones who would fall at the very end, as I had no intentions of doing so... and He never sent me feelings or words to say I was being misled, so I continued to research. I always wanted to be an archaeologist, but now I'm glad I didn't choose/wasn't allowed to follow that path ("There are no female archaeologists dear" - mid 60's downplaying of women's capabilities still). I was soo discouraged to follow my heart due to the closed mindedness of the "Professionals". But now I am glad andwas free to follow what research or researchers I chose who made more sense and were willing to stand alone like Graham Hancock, Joe Rogan, Brien Foerester etc and now yourselves and your guests like Chief Midegah & Lance.
I love the exploration you're presenting of the BoM and happily subscribe to both N & S models that Lance is exploring, but lean more to the Heartland model. Can you get Wayne May on your show? He is soo interesting and another amazingly knowledgeable guy.
Did (our BoM) man walk with the dinosaurs? Great question.. !
So interesting. But they should o know to never touch the petroglyphs with a finger as the oil from fingers can cause the petroglyphs to deteriorate.
“Drive in the night” is no easy feat in Mongolia
That was really interesting; Thank-You!
Re the question You posed: The temporary conservation measures used for moving the items to the lab in France seemed appropriate to Me. We only see the immediate actions, and I didn’t hear Anyone say that the remains WOULDN’T be kept cool - so that equipment may have been beyond Our sight. It did sound to Me as though the flight of exhumed material would be immediate, so I don’t worry that damaged will occur.
‘Armchair Archeology’ is fun, but I think it’s important to remember that what We see has been edited; I don’t think We have all of the information necessary to make a judgement call regarding the actions of these Archeologists.
38:07 those are small horns???
I remember in one of the readings from Edgar Cayce he mentioned there is more gold buried there than there is circulating in the entire world today... 😮
While I appreciate the finding and examining of the Dead - it is Still tomb robing a desecration- I wish they would return the Body to the tomb..,
What can a large pizza do the an Archaeologist can’t? Feed a family of 4.
I remember reading about this in the National Geographic magazine a few years ago. The woman had tattoos on her upper arm. Shame they didn't show everything once it was cleaned up, otherwise very good documentary. I didn't know about the grave with the man and child.
Mongolian horsemen n women r a glorious sight.
When the narrator says mongolian invasions, he doesn't mean rhe actual Ghengizid Mongqol invasion. She means the hunnic/Xiongnu invasion, which was geographically linked to modern Mongolia. According to modern studies they were most probably predominantly proto-turkic
Earliest recorded use of marijuana is a Scythian fire pit. About 2 .5 metres across full plants and boughs of drug grade cannabis were heaped on coals, a large tent could accommodate a group of warriors, who would sit inside the tent and breathe in the fumes.
Nice show! Great fun , especially l the Woman's Suffrage History. My dear elder cousins grandmother was force fed at the same time. How far we have come. WE WON"T GO BACK!
I'm a Pars(Persian) and one of my friends is a 6 6 red-headed Scythian originally from Ossetia(Ossetians are one of the Iraninc people and the Aryan cousins of the Persians).
If you visit the Perspolis(Parseh) in Shiraz and Bisotun in Kermanshah(both are very historical cities in Iran) you'll see the petroglyph of Scythians with pointy helmets. Interestingly, while on the Perspolis walls, they're seen hand in hand with their Persian cousins, on the Bisotun wall their leader is captured and captivated amongst others because they rebelled against King Dariush The Great(a lesson for some of the Kurds and Azaris who are making the same mistake thinking this time somehow it would be different).
Anyways, as a Pars, I love my Scythian cousins especially those who live in Ossetia, I think about you every once in a while and I hope one day I get the chance to visit and I highly encourage you to come and visit Iran; after all, we're all Iranic people.
Women were different, suggest you look at Boudicca etc not only could they be important but were primary in the tribe
how do they stay on their companion with no saddle without falling? That's impressive. o.o
Cooperation with the animals
19:39. Too late now, but why not a tent to keep
The Sun off??
Not the most careful Archeology excavation and extractions
Actually the first domesticated horse remnants were found in Kazakhstan, not Mongolia so far
There is nothing to see here, the Hungarians are Scythians, Huns and Avars, the Sons and Daughters of Nimrod, the Grandchildren of Hunor and Magor... the high culture of these peoples is already manifested in the extraordinary language of the Magyars, this is where everything comes from, the linguistic expression, as well as the ancient runic writing of the Hungarians the basis of their high culture. ❤🤍💚
The information gained from these tombs is invaluable but they were not dug with best archaeological practice. If these were really the last two untouched ice tombs then they really messed up.
Intact tombs of the kind with hollow chambers or mummified remains will degrade in the presence of oxygen in a very short time. They needed proper climate controlled isolation tents and full PPE to avoid genetic contamination. They just lifted artifacts with bare hands instead of block-lifting. Nowadays we do photogrammetry every few centimeters but this seems to be at least decade old footage so that's excusable, but having great big spoil heaps unsorted and unsifted is not. That arm was quite possibly not detached before the excavation as seen by the adipocere and dried tissues. That clip of picking the beads off of the hat remnants irks me because now we won't know how they were sewn on. The way the stones of the cairns were thrown about is a huge no-no because they all have to be documented exactly. The tools used throughout were not exactly delicate; you don't use pickaxes and shovels and trowels in a grave. This is the time for brushes, spatulas, toothpicks, and pipettes. I could go on but it will just make me angry.
I'm glad the graves were documented but my goodness was it botched.