every single day....I never regret one moment or any money I ever spent supporting him... he was, is, and always will be my joy....his aura filled the entire world with a special energy only he could give....i will love him forever....immortal
Let's not only remember him as an idol who died at the age of 25...Let's remember him as an idol with outstanding talent & a person who saved thousands of fans..Moonbin~ahhh you’ll always be in our heart...
@@reisiens Everywhere everyone is saying this that's why I wrote it... Don't get me wrong...& also I saw no one to correct those posts/articles that he didn’t commit su*cide...
it showed the versatility and how male can do female parts while female can do male part and shows the song more new insted of couples, IT SHOW THAT THEIR CHEM IS CRAZY AND SHOW THE SONG IN A DIFFERENT WTA
His smile when he looks at her is so sweet. She waited 12 years as a trainee to debut and he’s been cheering her on the whole time till the day where they can be on the stage together.
Bin said on UNIVERSE that he saw Sua mention 'Candy In My Ears' as song she wanted to perform with him on Knowing Bros and he suggested it for this stage. Sua also wanted to do a part change (she said it in the same Knowing Bros video) and Bin suggested to do a part change for this stage. He basically made sure they did everything she wanted to do like the sweet but tsundere older brother he is🥺 Bin also clarified on UNIVERSE that Sua didn't blow him a kiss at the end but told him to smile after he was cringing at her aegyo. He also said it was the first time he said 'I love you' to his sister through this song and that their parents really like this performance🥺
@@cocole883 I love how he clarified the kiss part: "Sua didn’t blow me a kiss at the end. What do you mean kiss? That doesn’t make any sense. She told me to smile." Straightforward and peak sibling behavior😂
Today is 19 April 2024 I can't believe that moonbin is no more in this world . But moonbin is permanent in aur heart miss you moonbin . 1 year is completed 🥹🥹🥹
Moon bin's face at the end is the most sibling ahahaha he be like" wtf" when sua did aegyo, and sua was like "SMILE!" And he was like "oh yeah we still on stage" and smile lol
@@susanasu7193 ahahha no, my bro would be like "ew", but then "anyone hurt my sister will be dead" lol. They playin it cool😆 only i can make fun of my sibling lol
@@bananamiruku_ Yes, she participated in Unpretty Rapstar 2 in 2015 when she was still a 16yo trainee and made it to the finals. She is Billlie’s main rapper and lead vocalist. She’s also a fantastic dancer so she’s basically an all-rounder. She was a trainee for 12 years (of which 10 in YG) before finally debuting in November 2021.
@@bananamiruku_ You won’t be disappointed when you stan her: she’s also cute, sweet, funny, cool and charismatic just like her brother. They’re both my bias😅
I dont even stan astro but i've known moonbin since 2020 bcs of seungkwan (im a carat), and everytime i watch this video i cant help the tears that fell. I wish i could go back to the first time i watched this performance, where i was feeling happy and mesmerised by their performance. Now all i feel watching this performance is grief and sadness
This song is performed by numerous idols and it gives sexual vibes but Moon Siblings showed a different vibe to this song. Their performance gave "we are hot siblings and we know it" kind of vibe! I am super proud of Moon Bin and Moon Sua especially that they are my biases! Continue slaying Binnie and Sua!!!
because the song is exactly like that lol but it’s good they’re trying other vibes it will be awkward to if they’re trying the original song vibe lmao they’re both such great performers!
I feel sick to my stomach after hearing the news. I'm not even a stan but I was shaking and almost cried. This is a reminder that we don't know what these idols are going through. Please be kind. Rest in peace, Moonbin 🥀 Praying for his family, friends, and arohas to be given strength.
In the same position. I didn’t know him very well, but the suddenness plus the fact that we have lost so many idols just makes it hurt more each time. Their circumstances can be so cruel 😞
The look on Sua's face when Bin had put his hand on her head playfully...had me cracking up...playful or not only siblings would know what that means...their resemblance however is uncanny making them the male and female version of the other...KBS...if you see this...YOU'LL NEEDZ TO DO MORE OF THESE STAGES...they had fun and enjoyed themselves...and trust me I did as well!!...
Today is your birthday and here I am coming to watch you smile. Doing something you love with your sibling. Really missed you but don't worry, you will always be in my heart. I will never forget you Moonbin
They are actually siblings.. Astro Moon Bin and Billie Moon Sua is related and Moon Sua is the younger sister of Moon Bin (if the Moon didn't give away)
At first i was skeptical of the song choice given that they're siblings, but after watching the performance, this is actually so cute! When sua did the manly part whereas moonbin the girly part, i died laughing 🤣 Also, their cute little adlibs they did so cute!
He was such a great performer and above that a ball of sunshine whose smile could light up the whole room. The little Moonbin came so far and had an amazing journey of 10 years and helped so many people. May his soul rest in peace and may god give power to his friends, family and fans.
I think both of them are great performers, and one more thing is that they trained together when they were kids. That's why I think they are able to perform and deliver this song so well. Bin even said that he had never told 'I love you' to Sua before, but we can see that there is no awkwardness at all when they performed this song. They are truly great performers. I'm looking forward to more and more collab of these siblings in the future.
@@maliablossom7340 He said he doesn’t recall ever saying it to her until this song. Knowing how he is, his love language is through his actions. He gave Sua his card so she can buy food, bought her a new phone, bought albums so he can get in their video call (he got in and the call is in both their vlogs) He watches them during prerecording and gives his honest opinion for any rooms of improvement. He talks about her and her group proudly 💜
it's been more than a year since moonbin's gone and sua is going back to idol activities... the idol industry needs to keep moving but i will never forget moonbin
The way he randomly stopped and just looked at her performing like... Oppa is so proud of his little sister. He has been waiting too long for this collab.
@@NoticeJungMin I think the looks were part of the chore, probably because it's a romantic duet. But his "proud daddy" expressions were his own hehehe.
Binnie once said that thanks to digital age people could see who he was and everything he achieved. Here we are missing you and keeping up your legacy... We still love you Moonbin.
Original: Pass the mic gently to the partner Moon siblings: Poke the mic into the nose or chin XD BUT they killed the stage! So proud of our moon siblings!!
Can we all say that this is the most beatiful performance in a while, comparing to the normal performances here you can see how much they wanted to do this and how they're enjoying their time. This reminds me the special stages of 2nd generation when all the groups collabed without any proplem...c'mon companies let the idols do what they want with who they want sometimes even if they're not siblings
Yes the toxic fans are the problem but also companies are afraid and force the idols to do only "safe" things when in the drama there are kisses, hugs scene and other things. Like in dramas they're acting also in the live stages they're performing so i think that they need all to change the point of view
@@Dahita I'm saying we won't get interactions from them LIKE EVER and this stage collab is one of the few interactions we have gotten where they're just enjoying themselves and having fun.
@@Dahita Do you even know that it's a cover? (I say it because of your other comment talking about the music )also the fact that ppl like you don't like K-pop or are not interested in the news DOES NOT give you the right to mock or be disrespectful to this that is bad for hundreds of people who did enjoy the music that this artist made, meditate before writing a comment then if youre not a fan of K-POP it is not for you, calm your hands and your ego of appearing here, in something that is painful for someone else.
I decided to leave the kpop world and just admire it from afar as a momory of my younger years. I was not an Aroha, but was a Buddy and I always loved SinB's interactions with Moonbin. I'm so sorry. I can't bear it.
@@rosesarerose1530 yeah. Moon bin was an idol before Sua. So when she debuted in Billie I'm sure Moon bin was really happy. Go watch the Knowing Bros episode with Billie on it. Sua says who she used to live with (her brother from astro Moon bin). They show a picture and everything.
It's even funny and cute when you know that Bin told 'I love you' to his sister for the first time in his life through this song while Sua always says she loves him when leaving messages to her brother on tv/radio shows.
For those who are saying the song choice is little strange, actually it was sua who mentioned when she was asked what song she wants to cover with his brother moonbin & she said she wants to perform candy in my ears with bin on stage (she also mentioned troublemaker) so it seems like bin respected and supported her choice because it was always sua's dream to debut and perform with bin on stage and this is one of the thing which also kept her motivated in her 12 yrs long training. Even if the song is little sexy but their interactions and so many times saying i love you, saranghae, wo aai ni, te quiero to each other while smiling & teasing & parts switch, it is one of the best performance and they did so well. I'm so so so proud of them & always feel so happy seeing how they support each other always 💜 my favorite kpop siblings 🥰
@@emilylia5809 i wouldn’t say that the song choice is weird/bad for siblings but some of the moves in the choreo were a bit suspicious to me. I don’t think badly of it but they could’ve maybe replaced those. Bin has been one of my ults for years, so i’m really not bashing them, just observing, they were great
@@emilylia5809 i wouldn’t really consider myself western, i’m more somewhere in the middle and again, i’m not saying anything against both of them, they didn’t choregraph the dance, but there were a few suggestive moments. I agree, the dance is really pretty but since we were generally talking about it i mentioned how i feel :)
i can’t believe this is their one and only collab stage… rest in peace moonbin 🕊 i can’t imagine how sua must be feeling right now because moonbin was always her pillar of support.
to people who’s still skeptical about the song choice, I know its questionable but they are obviously just trolling 🤣 the way they made the song fun & cute, both are smiley the whole performance, & the part change (I died laughing at this). It’s not that serious 🤣 just enjoy the interaction.
when I say trolling I meant they chose the song for fun 🤣 and of course they did amazing covering it because they are obviously having fun all throughout the performance 😍
Now that I'm thinking about maybe this song is a gift from the fate to help them spend time together with this song and finally say to each other "I love you" because once moonbin says that it was the first for him saying I love you to his sister through this song. And for Sua I think that this video is the most important for her because she can see their happiness and laugh back then
I know! She's Billlie's main rapper and lead vocal but too many people only know her as rapper. I really love her vocal color and she really could be a main vocal in another group.
I used to watch this with a massive, cheesy smile on my face because it was so lovely to watch two siblings having fun on stage. Weird to think that it’ll come with a different energy now.
Same, it poped up in my fyp on TH-cam and started watching it again and still can't believe he's really gone... but if anything im sure he would've wanted all his fans and the ppl that r watching this video to be happy and smile while doing so, even if he's gone now and it's gonna give a hard time to all the ppl that love him we shouldn't be too sad or cry a lot while watching his videos cuz im sure that he want us to still feel inspired and happy while watching or listening to his work and remembering him in our hearts and be better to the loved ones and go easy on each other. His smile was the brightest❤❤ whatever he was going through it's over now. I hope he rest in peace🕊.
@@Americanhonkee i don't if you've been living under a rock or if ur from another world but this is pretty common and normal to have an idol or any person that u look up to weather famous or non famous and to know that the person that u really liked and gave u inspiration and strength in your lowest times and was usually entertaining you have gone through hard times alone and suddenly die is pretty fucked up idk why u gatta make such fuss just bcuz for some ppl this person that they look up to happen to be a famous singer. But of course im not waiting for u to understand or shed a tear or whatever but just be nicer or just keep going and don't care cuz those kinda comment are the one that may let such thing happen to anyone. I too tbh don't stand the group although they are really talented, didn't know much about them i only knew one of his bandmates cuz he's a famous actor and also know him and whenever i watched something of him he would always smile and give such good vibes and that's how he stuck to my mind when i knew that he passed away i was shocked cuz out of all ppl i didn't expected it. And i could anly imagine how his family fan and friends are feeling right know. So just don't care like u did before reading the article.
@afia3981 Stop spreading false information! We don't know how he died and we might never will! His mother has told us to stop spreading rumors and we should respect her wishes
Several months ago, this was a place where I found joy and cuteness from these adorable siblings But now, it’s just so hurtful and sad Rest in peace Moonbin Stay strong Moon Sua
Hardest part of being a fan is not being able to save the person who saved you during your darkness times. I can't imagine the pain he was enduring. He finally became a star for every aroha. Warm hugs to everyone. I am sure he's in a good place now. 💔😢
The person who decided to end their life must be full of depression and stress. Trust me that feeling doesn't come from just one or 2 days but maybe long time ago. And the sadness and loneliness are killing him. He definitely went through a tough patch for such a long long time. He always pretended to be happy and smile all the time in public. But deep inside, his heart is full of sorrow.
The way they are smiling so big and their smile has a different meaning behind it. Sua is smiling big because her dream came true that she got to perform on stage with his brother. Bin smiling as he is overly proud of his little sister. Omg. They had so much fun with this song. They love each other very much and I wish I could be their sibling too. The way he is overprotective of her. The way they both shine differently. Ugh😭😭 like im proud as their mother why ahahah
I'm not and never have been a fan of Astro but I felt terrible when I received the news that he had died and I cried because I put myself in the fans' shoes and because I've been through this, since I'm a fan of SHINNee. Until today and when Jonghyun died I was devastated, my condolences again to the fans, be strong.
facts about this performance: - bin chose the song after knowing that she (sua) wanted to perform this song with his brother (she also said that she wants to perform bin's song, WHO by ASTRO MOONBIN&SANHA) -bin is the one who also suggested to switch roles update 220628 sua said on bbl that she suggested to switch parts 😭 istg these two - also the first time in a while bin said ily to sua and it was thru this song - moon parents loveees this performance (confirmed by bin thru pms) - this is their first performance as idols siblings - bin also said that during ending fairy sua said SMILE but her side profile looks like shes asking for a kiss/pout facts abt them: - bin debuted 6 years ago, sua debuted late last year and she trained for over 12 years she almost gave up but she was encouraged and motivated by her brother (bin said its nice if she debuts after all the hardships she went thru) - fun fact: bin asked on pms how to apply fansign (online) then arohas replied 'you need to buy albumSSSS' then later on we suspected this name on the winners list and yes it was him. you can watch his vlog about the fansign (ddalgona vlog moonbin on yt) and he praised the girls how good they are and he even said 'sua has my card go by food/meat' hes the sweetest ever! - he also bought an iPhone for sua as per bin 'she's very keen about it, atleast once a day she talks abt how she wanted a new phone so i bought it for her right away' HE'S SO GENEROUS I LOVE HIM pls support each one of them
I don't want to lose the happiness I felt when watching this video, I'll just look at it as his final moments where he was happy with his sister. I'll cherish you Moonbin, hope you are happy whenever you are.
I really thought it was a sick joke or a rumor...I'm so so sorry Moonbin. So many of us, Aroha or not, love you. Please rest in peace. I hope wherever you are, you're happy. And please everyone send love and support to all members of Astro and Billlie's Moon Sua, his sister. This is devastating. Please....let's all be kind.
I genuinely thought this was fake news, but I guess it isn’t. Let’s give as much love and support to his family and Sua as we can. Their shock must be unmeasurable compared to ours
@@marshmallow4040 It's still very hard to process. As someone who's a casual listener, watching his performance (especially the one with Sua); always made me grin. He's loved. Lots of strength and condolences to family and everyone affected🤍
I'm on behalf of Shawols here, we know what it feels like...please, Arohas, stay strong! (I'm not an Aroha myself, but I loved him so much just because of his perforances with other idols and this single video...)
It's really upsetting if he died by su*cide, nobody should have to pass like that and I hope he rests in peace..❤ Edit: he died of a stroke which is still sad but im glad he didnt pass of the other cause which would of been even worse. I hope moonbin continues his amazing journey in heaven.
@@thaothelazycat930 He commited suicide. It is fatal situation. He couldnt see his way out and ended himself. At his age with all his sucess he needed to fall in love and settle with someone.He knew it. And yet He couldnt. Too much pressure to keep up with that "idol life".
@@deepdude4719 Uh... I think you should refrain from saying anything that could pinpoint any blame on him. This is a tragic situation. Let's just wish him well on the other side.
I have never really paid attention to Astro but after watching this on repeat, i have fallen in love with Moonbin. Looks like i might become an aroha 😭
i still can’t believe this boy is gone. i used to watch this video with a smile on my face and now i have tears in my eyes. such a beautiful soul, gone far too soon. you will be greatly missed, Moonbin.
Months back i would have never thought i would be coming here with tears in my eyes. This was supposed to be a happy colourful vibe between siblings and now my heart clenches at how heartbroken sua is that she wont be able to be like this with her brother and moonbin...baby...we failed you. I am sorry you had to go through so much.
I remember that I watched this video for few times before, I like their performance so much as so much love between them, although I am not the fan, but still 😥.
moonbin’s face at first looking at sua doing aegyo HAHAHA. Moonbin was smiling from start to finish, he couldnt contain how happy he is 😭 im so glad he's always been there for sua specially during those times when she wanted to stop pursuing to be an idol. Their love and support for each other will always be topnotch!
I am not even a astro fan but I am really devastated to know the news can't even think what his members family fans friends and Moon Sua is going through. Rest in peace Moonbin.
Those who are demanding kbs to do the huenings dobt ask kbs ask the txt and kep1er's label because the Moon Siblings for sure both of their agencies had a hand in this collab... Fantagio knows how Moonbin is so supportive of his sister... And Mystic Story knows how Moon Sua worked so hard to get to where she is right now... Moonbin been waiting for the day Moon Sua debuts... and Moon Sua talked about it mant times that its her dream to be on stage with her brother... and for sure AROHA and BELLLIE'VE banded together and both agency knows about this and they made it happen...
Fr this collab wouldn't be exist if their companies aren't very supportive. Especially mystic story, they know how to treat their artists right and have been very supportive at least from what we see until now. As a moonsua supporter, we know this would never happen if she debuted under her old company. No matter how many invitation they got, but the desicion is on their own companies.
The fandom I am very important, Aroha and Billlie've are very peaceful they love and respect their artists and families Los fandom son muy importantes Aroha y Billlie've aman y respetan a sus artistas y familia
@@vanessatasayco7698 I'm sorry to say this but I think it has nothing to do with fandom being peaceful. I mean, there's no way fandom would get mad over siblings collab 😅
@@ayunniaaafandi mystic is the best... yoon jong shin billlie's CEO is giving them a special release this month... a remake of Patbingsu by their CEO yoon jong shin... hopefully it has mv and they will promote it on music shows...
Coming here to leave my deepest condolences to Moonbin's family. He will live on through every single performance, song, picture he left us, such talent will never be forgotten. 🤍🕊
I don't know anything about ASTRO but I could see the brother and sister affection in their eyes when they performed together. R.I.P Moonbin. You'll always live in our hearts❤🔥
TH-cam and their recommendations… I really thought I could get through it without crying but that kissy face she does to him at the end…got be bawling my eyes out. I don’t even know them that well - I just liked this performance. But I remember sitting in disbelief when I heard of his passing. And now I’m crying because their smiles are so beautiful at the end…😭
Fun facts: They only practiced twice before the actual performance. They also decided to switch on the second part, Moonbin is the female version while Sua is the male version (in case you didn't notice). Sua wanted to perform Candy in My Ears or Troublemaker with her brother and she wants to do the male parts while Moonbin does the female part. Moonbin was the one to suggest they do this song. It was a great collab, and we want more!
it still hurts a lot this was the performance i was watching 15 mins before the news and then just my heart broke into millions of pieces :(( Binnie we miss you so much
![The "business couple" siblings got 6 million views on this video l DNA Mate Ep 46 [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ktAulGGFzuU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K 원테이크] 포레스텔라 - DESPACITO [불후의 명곡2 전설을 노래하다/Immortal Songs 2] | KBS 230715 방송](/img/n.gif)
Who's here is 2024 and still miss moonbin😢😢❤
RIP MOONBIN🪦🕊️
here 😢
every single day....I never regret one moment or any money I ever spent supporting him... he was, is, and always will be my joy....his aura filled the entire world with a special energy only he could give....i will love him forever....immortal
😭😭😭
Here 😢😢
Yes 😢 Moonbin😢😢😢😢😢😢
I can't imagine how Sua is feeling right now.. when people even can't believe it
I know 😭😭
My brain still cannot process this information so I can’t imagine what Sua is going through rn. I hope she’ll stay strong
@@marshmallow4040 istg, it's just soo hard to understand and breathe through it. Lots of strength and a tight hug to Sua🫶🏻
She will need all the love and support
Sending all my condolences and strength to her 🙏
No ones talking about their vocals??? Y'all their range is insane esp Moonbin?? The falsetto has me in a chokehold oml
His lower register, I never really heard from him before, got me shook
his lower register is so sexc and rare!!!😣❤️🔥
@@fluffybeez I think it’s one of the reasons why I’ve been obsessed with this
@@annam3598 our man is so versatile😭 killing us on both ends of the spectrum lmao
@@skree1277 For realz! Why has he hidden this? or is it FanMu I have to fight to unleash this man’s range
it’s nearly been a year since moonbins loss, time flies but he is still remembered
Love ❤
Que hermoso que era que pena. Tan joven partió ❤
time indeed flies. time flies when you're having fun !
Let's not only remember him as an idol who died at the age of 25...Let's remember him as an idol with outstanding talent & a person who saved thousands of fans..Moonbin~ahhh you’ll always be in our heart...
We don't know ih he took his own life or not stop rumor
Police state that nothing proves he suicided, stop spreading false rumors.
@@jeon_9732 they said it was most likely the cause of death it doesn’t mean that died that way
@@jeon_9732 this was not confirmed..his family officially said that he passed away from cardiac arrest/stroke..he passed away peacefully..
@@reisiens Everywhere everyone is saying this that's why I wrote it... Don't get me wrong...& also I saw no one to correct those posts/articles that he didn’t commit su*cide...
reversing the male and female parts was so creative. sua's deep voice suits the male parts while bin's soothing vocals suits the female parts well
agreed! i thought it was so cool
Yh it's sounds really good
Apparently Sua said she really wanted to sing this song and do it part switched and Bin made it happen!
@@ameliarose47 that's too cute.. When u think about it lol😩😆
it showed the versatility and how male can do female parts while female can do male part and shows the song more new insted of couples, IT SHOW THAT THEIR CHEM IS CRAZY AND SHOW THE SONG IN A DIFFERENT WTA
His smile when he looks at her is so sweet. She waited 12 years as a trainee to debut and he’s been cheering her on the whole time till the day where they can be on the stage together.
😭❤️💞👍🏻
aww :((
Who’s older?
@@amjune716 Bin is older by a year :)
@@therapizza thank yoou 💕💕💕
ムンビンとスアちゃんのこのステージ本当に大好きで何回も見てる。2人とも大好き。仲の良い兄妹で癒された。ムンビンがもう苦しんでませんように。大好きだよ。
💜🫂
ムンビン😢どうか天国でも安らかに…
Bin said on UNIVERSE that he saw Sua mention 'Candy In My Ears' as song she wanted to perform with him on Knowing Bros and he suggested it for this stage. Sua also wanted to do a part change (she said it in the same Knowing Bros video) and Bin suggested to do a part change for this stage. He basically made sure they did everything she wanted to do like the sweet but tsundere older brother he is🥺 Bin also clarified on UNIVERSE that Sua didn't blow him a kiss at the end but told him to smile after he was cringing at her aegyo. He also said it was the first time he said 'I love you' to his sister through this song and that their parents really like this performance🥺
moon bin is so awesome and brave for clarifying things we stannnn
@@cocole883 I love how he clarified the kiss part: "Sua didn’t blow me a kiss at the end. What do you mean kiss? That doesn’t make any sense. She told me to smile." Straightforward and peak sibling behavior😂
Wanna cry, they are so sweet. I love Bin, but what I love more is to see them perform together.
@@lunaurorathena 👍🏻
i somehow can feel how their parent like the performance
am i the only one who's so obsessed with the reversed part? i can't stop repeating
X2
X3
Same!
X4
x5
Their parents must be so proud to see them both on stage together
yeah
Yeah
Two talented, successful children.
Fr
I feel proud just looking at them, so yes definitely!
Today is 19 April 2024 I can't believe that moonbin is no more in this world . But moonbin is permanent in aur heart miss you moonbin . 1 year is completed 🥹🥹🥹
Yes😢
Let his Soul Rest in Peace
Actually, he died on my Birthday Even though It was my special day I loved him a lot I cried
@@Itz_me_sai_shruthi 🙁
@@Itz_me_sai_shruthiMust be hard for you
I cant even imagine the pain of sua and his family.... R. I. P
@@Unknownbanda099 yeah rip
If you had told me months ago that you will cry while watching this, I would not have believed it. Rest In Peace Moonbin.
What happened
@@graceegbe13 moonbin died today
@@marwa9473 my condolences
Totally agree. I watch this now and feel such sadness. Gone too soon!
Benoftheweek’s prediction was right at 6:40 .... on one of his vids😭😭
Moon bin's face at the end is the most sibling ahahaha he be like" wtf" when sua did aegyo, and sua was like "SMILE!" And he was like "oh yeah we still on stage" and smile lol
That’s really cute like most big bro can’t resists their sis
@@susanasu7193 ahahha no, my bro would be like "ew", but then "anyone hurt my sister will be dead" lol. They playin it cool😆 only i can make fun of my sibling lol
Righttt!! He was like “stop it” AHAHAHAHAH I CANTTT
@@vanny3129 yes, he feels wtf with whattttttttttt for first time as his sister annoy him , lol
hahahaha
WE NEED A SPOTIFY VERSION OF THIS COVER !!!!!!!!!!
Please!!!
Yessss
I support with violence haha
Fr
I AGREEEEEE
いつまでも受け継がれるんだろうな、この衝撃 ムン兄妹大好きです
for a rapper, Sua really has a really good singing voice. Lets not even talk about the stage beast that's Moobin. He's perfect
She is Billlie's main rapper and lead vocalist.
She's a rapper???🧍🏻♀️
@@bananamiruku_ Yes, she participated in Unpretty Rapstar 2 in 2015 when she was still a 16yo trainee and made it to the finals. She is Billlie’s main rapper and lead vocalist. She’s also a fantastic dancer so she’s basically an all-rounder. She was a trainee for 12 years (of which 10 in YG) before finally debuting in November 2021.
@@lunaurorathena omg really??👀 What a multitalent..
I love her voice tho. Is this really a sign for me to stan her?😩
@@bananamiruku_ You won’t be disappointed when you stan her: she’s also cute, sweet, funny, cool and charismatic just like her brother. They’re both my bias😅
I can't bear to imagine that we'll not get anymore interaction like these between moon siblings 😭💔
Jue 😮q😅😅😂
💔😢😭🌕🌜Yes.🌛🌕😭😢💔
Same.
mal, que tipo tan apuesto nos perdimos
this performance has its own fandom. the views just dont stop rising
It's so true 😂😂🥲 even people who aren't fans of them are still addicted. Lovelyyy
literally like the dolphin performance
@@lisabluemoon I'm addicted already 😂😍
I'm in this fandom 🤓💜
@@SR-pw6pi me too 😂😂
It's been 15 months, Bin, and life just doesn't feel the same without you:(
😭😭😭💔💔💔
I dont even stan astro but i've known moonbin since 2020 bcs of seungkwan (im a carat), and everytime i watch this video i cant help the tears that fell. I wish i could go back to the first time i watched this performance, where i was feeling happy and mesmerised by their performance. Now all i feel watching this performance is grief and sadness
@@hanna-ce2ig omg same 😢 😿 😭 I known him since 2017
exactly 😢💔
♥️♥️♥️♥️
This song is performed by numerous idols and it gives sexual vibes but Moon Siblings showed a different vibe to this song. Their performance gave "we are hot siblings and we know it" kind of vibe! I am super proud of Moon Bin and Moon Sua especially that they are my biases! Continue slaying Binnie and Sua!!!
ofc the moon siblings won't do sexual vibes haha lol that's awkward for opposite gender siblings
because the song is exactly like that lol but it’s good they’re trying other vibes it will be awkward to if they’re trying the original song vibe lmao they’re both such great performers!
Yeay! Ive same thought
Precisely.
Lit!!!
I feel sick to my stomach after hearing the news. I'm not even a stan but I was shaking and almost cried. This is a reminder that we don't know what these idols are going through. Please be kind. Rest in peace, Moonbin 🥀 Praying for his family, friends, and arohas to be given strength.
same here…
IKR so sad he was my bias in ASTRO and made me feel so happy it felt like just a week ago when they performed this I feel so bad for Sua
Same
I didn't even stan Astro but I cried so hard
In the same position. I didn’t know him very well, but the suddenness plus the fact that we have lost so many idols just makes it hurt more each time. Their circumstances can be so cruel 😞
The look on Sua's face when Bin had put his hand on her head playfully...had me cracking up...playful or not only siblings would know what that means...their resemblance however is uncanny making them the male and female version of the other...KBS...if you see this...YOU'LL NEEDZ TO DO MORE OF THESE STAGES...they had fun and enjoyed themselves...and trust me I did as well!!...
Yes They look so much like each other! Super cute!
@@nataliepaad1869 yessssssss...😊
It something I do to my siblings as well lol
@@Mina-ux1jg lmaooo..
moonbin shows an "I won" face they are so cute
Today is your birthday and here I am coming to watch you smile. Doing something you love with your sibling. Really missed you but don't worry, you will always be in my heart. I will never forget you Moonbin
i don't stan billlie or astro but this was so adorable 😭 the way they teased each other on stage was so sibling like this was so cute to watch
Thank you 🤗💜
@@rp22222 gerçekten kardeşler mi ?
They are actually siblings.. Astro Moon Bin and Billie Moon Sua is related and Moon Sua is the younger sister of Moon Bin (if the Moon didn't give away)
Stan Billlie for a longer life
you need to stan them you will never regret of it
At first i was skeptical of the song choice given that they're siblings, but after watching the performance, this is actually so cute! When sua did the manly part whereas moonbin the girly part, i died laughing 🤣 Also, their cute little adlibs they did so cute!
I KNOW RIGHT. BUT THAT SOMETHING THEY WOULD deff do too🤣
agreed
what’s this song about?
@@valxx5839 it's a love song. the main chorus revolves around saying that the person's voice sounds like honey
Same.
He was such a great performer and above that a ball of sunshine whose smile could light up the whole room. The little Moonbin came so far and had an amazing journey of 10 years and helped so many people. May his soul rest in peace and may god give power to his friends, family and fans.
I don't know i just came to this video when I heard this news...still shaking...this video will be a pain to watch again 💔
@@shahnm8685 me either.😭 i just cant accept that 😭😭
I am still shocked 😣😣 I hope he is in a better place now😣😣
is it confirmed by the members or the company?
@@lelilshit the company and the media :(
It has been 2 years and I can still say that this performance is LEGEND!!!
But hits hard see Moonbin here… just… make me cry
2:45 is such a sibling moment, i love it
YES they’re so funny I was waiting for someone to point this out
Look at how he's "proud of himself" 😭 his proud smile 😥
me too😊
She was so annoyed
I think both of them are great performers, and one more thing is that they trained together when they were kids. That's why I think they are able to perform and deliver this song so well. Bin even said that he had never told 'I love you' to Sua before, but we can see that there is no awkwardness at all when they performed this song. They are truly great performers. I'm looking forward to more and more collab of these siblings in the future.
when did he say this?
@@mickeymcdonalds6111 The day after the performance, in Universe pm
J. J j hu
Wait I’m sorry, he’s never said I love you to his sister 😂 😭
@@maliablossom7340 He said he doesn’t recall ever saying it to her until this song. Knowing how he is, his love language is through his actions. He gave Sua his card so she can buy food, bought her a new phone, bought albums so he can get in their video call (he got in and the call is in both their vlogs) He watches them during prerecording and gives his honest opinion for any rooms of improvement. He talks about her and her group proudly 💜
This performance is perfect omg, the Moon siblings >>>>
Since they're the Moon siblings, they should do another collab with Loona. 🤣
@@MarkDeSade100 more like Kepler or nmixx??
@@cheri_cola do you even know loona 😐
@@cheri_cola uhm what
@@cheri_cola They said loona bcs luna means moon. Why kepler or nmixx??
it's been more than a year since moonbin's gone and sua is going back to idol activities... the idol industry needs to keep moving but i will never forget moonbin
This is definitely one of the best things happened in kpop this year.
I literally come back to it every other week
The Moon siblings is one of the best things happened in kpop.
100%
RIP MOONBIN you didn't had to go so early 😢you had so much more ahead of you
bye
The way he randomly stopped and just looked at her performing like... Oppa is so proud of his little sister. He has been waiting too long for this collab.
What time please 😅
I think that was part of choreo, but was cute how he looked at her 😊
@@NoticeJungMin timestamp pls
Даша Левочкина I think at 2:17 😊
@@NoticeJungMin I think the looks were part of the chore, probably because it's a romantic duet. But his "proud daddy" expressions were his own hehehe.
This is going to be my number one fave stage performance this 2022.
I knew it was mine at first watch and I’m on day 4 still obsessed
Concuerdo contigo son tan randoms pero los vocales son tremendooos
Yeaa
Mine too
Sameeeee
Binnie once said that thanks to digital age people could see who he was and everything he achieved. Here we are missing you and keeping up your legacy... We still love you Moonbin.
Sua sounds so beautiful. She could already be a solo artist even if she only just debuted. Her stage presence is so strong..
Yaaaa like his brother
Maybe because of her more than 10 yrs of training💪💕
@@emjaycee08 + she was already in unpretty rapstar when she was trainee
@Emerickkie Ohlala yup I know that too cause m a yg stan and I know about some trainees
Yes
Original:
Pass the mic gently to the partner
Moon siblings:
Poke the mic into the nose or chin XD
BUT they killed the stage! So proud of our moon siblings!!
Been laughing too about this ㅠㅠ
So funny 😂
Lmao
time stamp please
I didn’t see that! Am going to watch it again, and I watch it so many times🤦♀️
I can't imagine how Moon Sua's heart is right now. My most sincere condolences to the family, friends and Arohas. May Moonbin rest in peace.
ムンビンはきっと大切な良い思い出だけ天国に持っていってるよね
きょうもお疲れさま
There's something about Moonbin fully clothed in a 3-piece suit that is sexier than when he's shirtless like bruh, calm down
Yeees! Might also be the slicked back hairstyle idk... But waoh, I'm entranced by his looks in this performance
He is with his sister... Gotta look decent 😂😂😂
oh god true
Thiss commenttttt💕💕💕
Tbh I love a 3-piece suit it looks good on everyone 😩
Can we all say that this is the most beatiful performance in a while, comparing to the normal performances here you can see how much they wanted to do this and how they're enjoying their time. This reminds me the special stages of 2nd generation when all the groups collabed without any proplem...c'mon companies let the idols do what they want with who they want sometimes even if they're not siblings
I wouldn't mind seeing more collabs between girl groups and boy groups, but some fans get crazy about it.
fr I wouldn't mind cuz I want to see some new group Collab with each other😭
Yes the toxic fans are the problem but also companies are afraid and force the idols to do only "safe" things when in the drama there are kisses, hugs scene and other things. Like in dramas they're acting also in the live stages they're performing so i think that they need all to change the point of view
That's true. It's beautiful😍
my txtzy hearteu
I'm literally going to cry. We will never get interactions like this from them ever again ☹️💔
What interaction exactly? Two kids doing a rehearsed choreography while singing in playback? You will miss this, really?
@@Dahita Stop being disrespectful and find something better to do besides spreading negativity on the internet
@@Dahita I'm saying we won't get interactions from them LIKE EVER and this stage collab is one of the few interactions we have gotten where they're just enjoying themselves and having fun.
Whatever she meant by interactions should not be a concern to you. Stop being disrespectful at least to the dead.
@@Dahita Do you even know that it's a cover? (I say it because of your other comment talking about the music )also the fact that ppl like you don't like K-pop or are not interested in the news DOES NOT give you the right to mock or be disrespectful to this that is bad for hundreds of people who did enjoy the music that this artist made, meditate before writing a comment then if youre not a fan of K-POP it is not for you, calm your hands and your ego of appearing here, in something that is painful for someone else.
おすすめに出てきたから見にきたよ。ムンビン会いに来てくれてありがとう
I can't believe I'm watching this performance crying. Moobin was an amazing man and will be remembered forever
Agreed. I miss him so much, let’s support sua as much as we can
I remember him forever
At least she'll forever have a video of her performing with her brother... 😢 RIP Moonbin, you did well! ❤
Rest In Peace Moonbin.
Rest in peace 🤍
this is fantastic but also the most randomest song for siblings to do
fr tho, i was so surprised when i know they will sing this🤣🤣
HAHAHA. I cracked🤣 lol. Can't stop laughing they are such a mood🤣 what a cuties. Btw, STAN BILLIE for stage presence like tsuki🤣❤️
HAHAHAHAHA i know righttt
i mean, one of the other choices was Troublemaker... so i guess this is one of the lesser evils lol
*edit: grammar
lol
It's now 2024 and I'm coming back to this video with tears in my eyes - Moonbin was truly such a angel - I hope he is in a happier place now 😭😭
😭😭
Same
😢😢😢😢
Because of how people call idols siblings nowadays just to stress on their friendship I didn't know they were REAL siblings
This is so freaking cute
They are truly siblings, it´s not a joke hahaha
They're real sibling
@@alschive7649 that's "hot"
there's AKMU too
I have uploaded acapella ver of this song🙈 feel free to check it out and share your opinion❤
I don't know but their version of Candy in my ear’s so addicting.
No your right
Yes it is i wish we had a high quality audio only part i would listen to it all day long
FR
I am not an Aroha,but this sitation gives me goosebumps and pure sadness. Sending my deepest condelences to his fans,friends and family.
same
Me too
Me too🕊️😞
Same here 😭😭😭
I decided to leave the kpop world and just admire it from afar as a momory of my younger years. I was not an Aroha, but was a Buddy and I always loved SinB's interactions with Moonbin. I'm so sorry. I can't bear it.
I really miss you Moonbin oppa🥺🥺
RIP Moonbin Oppa
anyone in 2024?
yes me 😭😭😭
I find this so cute omg. They are so funny for switching the roles. Siblings always have a way twist things up.
Are they really siblings 😮😲
@@rosesarerose1530 yes, they r, Moonbin is older😍😆
@@RinRin-pc1zz wow im shoked never knew 😲😲😮 what group is the girl in
@@rosesarerose1530 Billlie, she is MoonSua
@@rosesarerose1530 yeah. Moon bin was an idol before Sua. So when she debuted in Billie I'm sure Moon bin was really happy. Go watch the Knowing Bros episode with Billie on it. Sua says who she used to live with (her brother from astro Moon bin). They show a picture and everything.
They still give off sibling vibes and there's nothing really too wrong about the song choice lol
It's even funny and cute when you know that Bin told 'I love you' to his sister for the first time in his life through this song while Sua always says she loves him when leaving messages to her brother on tv/radio shows.
One of their choises was Troublemaker, interesting how would they perform it.🤔
@@LadyGaladrielOfLothlorien holy sh-💀💀💀God knows lmao😭😭
@@LadyGaladrielOfLothlorien they are gonna perform troublemaker next?
@@LadyGaladrielOfLothlorien the person that came out with the song choices...idk man what in the world-
I'm glad Sua had an opportunity to be on the same stage with her brother and perform with him
Moon siblings are the sweetest siblings ever❤
He PASSED AWAY
@@shinsrealitycheck6474 yeah they know that
Hence why the made this comment
Whenever I watch this video I dont know but my eyes fills with water . I miss u Moonbin . Rest in Peace .
That playful sibling chemistry?! That role switch?! Sua's vocals?! MoonBin's falsetto?? OH LORD I DUNNO HOW MANY TIMES IMMA HIT THAT REPLAY
FRFR U JUST LET OUT ALL THE WORDS OUT OF MY MOUTH
Not gonna lie but this is the best performance in today's MuBank!!! Their voices really harmonized with each other
agree
Really Agree
Totally agree
agreed
agree 10000%
For those who are saying the song choice is little strange, actually it was sua who mentioned when she was asked what song she wants to cover with his brother moonbin & she said she wants to perform candy in my ears with bin on stage (she also mentioned troublemaker) so it seems like bin respected and supported her choice because it was always sua's dream to debut and perform with bin on stage and this is one of the thing which also kept her motivated in her 12 yrs long training. Even if the song is little sexy but their interactions and so many times saying i love you, saranghae, wo aai ni, te quiero to each other while smiling & teasing & parts switch, it is one of the best performance and they did so well. I'm so so so proud of them & always feel so happy seeing how they support each other always 💜 my favorite kpop siblings 🥰
AGREE💜😸
I'm soooo agree with you! 💜💜💜
@@emilylia5809 i wouldn’t say that the song choice is weird/bad for siblings but some of the moves in the choreo were a bit suspicious to me. I don’t think badly of it but they could’ve maybe replaced those. Bin has been one of my ults for years, so i’m really not bashing them, just observing, they were great
@@emilylia5809 i wouldn’t really consider myself western, i’m more somewhere in the middle and again, i’m not saying anything against both of them, they didn’t choregraph the dance, but there were a few suggestive moments. I agree, the dance is really pretty but since we were generally talking about it i mentioned how i feel :)
🙌
i can’t believe this is their one and only collab stage… rest in peace moonbin 🕊 i can’t imagine how sua must be feeling right now because moonbin was always her pillar of support.
😭
This indeed is a very special and beautiful stage. Hoping for the best and condolences for Sua and family.
i was feeling same way its hurting me and many of us
to people who’s still skeptical about the song choice, I know its questionable but they are obviously just trolling 🤣 the way they made the song fun & cute, both are smiley the whole performance, & the part change (I died laughing at this). It’s not that serious 🤣 just enjoy the interaction.
yes cuz they are fun siblings you can see it tho
No, but tell me why their chemistry (NOT romantically of COURSE) is better than most male and female idols special stages 💀💀💀
when I say trolling I meant they chose the song for fun 🤣 and of course they did amazing covering it because they are obviously having fun all throughout the performance 😍
@@truefalse934 because they are having fun! there’s no hint of awkwardness and you can see that they really enjoyed performing together 🥹
@@truefalse934 well because they're SIBLINGS??
obsessed with MOON siblings
hope to see more collabs
so no more collabs:((
rest in peace moonbin.☹️♥️
Their recent TikTok collab in Billlie’s page is my new obsession
Now that I'm thinking about maybe this song is a gift from the fate to help them spend time together with this song and finally say to each other "I love you" because once moonbin says that it was the first for him saying I love you to his sister through this song. And for Sua I think that this video is the most important for her because she can see their happiness and laugh back then
Moon Sua will forever keep this music video with her sibling...MEMORIES
Missing him
People need to talk about Sua's vocal more. Such an amazing voice.
I know! She's Billlie's main rapper and lead vocal but too many people only know her as rapper. I really love her vocal color and she really could be a main vocal in another group.
Well she trained for 12 years
That deep tone of her ascends me everytime...
Seriously....even iam going to comment this
He looked so proud of his sister here, I hope he rests in peace and send all my thoughts and prayers to his loved ones
my heart aches so much for sua, i can't imagine losing my sibling. the joy moonbin brought people will not be forgotten. may he rest in peace.
I am from 2024 i miss moonbin so mush i feel so sam i'm about to cry 😢
I used to watch this with a massive, cheesy smile on my face because it was so lovely to watch two siblings having fun on stage. Weird to think that it’ll come with a different energy now.
Same, it poped up in my fyp on TH-cam and started watching it again and still can't believe he's really gone... but if anything im sure he would've wanted all his fans and the ppl that r watching this video to be happy and smile while doing so, even if he's gone now and it's gonna give a hard time to all the ppl that love him we shouldn't be too sad or cry a lot while watching his videos cuz im sure that he want us to still feel inspired and happy while watching or listening to his work and remembering him in our hearts and be better to the loved ones and go easy on each other.
His smile was the brightest❤❤ whatever he was going through it's over now. I hope he rest in peace🕊.
@@Americanhonkee i don't if you've been living under a rock or if ur from another world but this is pretty common and normal to have an idol or any person that u look up to weather famous or non famous and to know that the person that u really liked and gave u inspiration and strength in your lowest times and was usually entertaining you have gone through hard times alone and suddenly die is pretty fucked up idk why u gatta make such fuss just bcuz for some ppl this person that they look up to happen to be a famous singer. But of course im not waiting for u to understand or shed a tear or whatever but just be nicer or just keep going and don't care cuz those kinda comment are the one that may let such thing happen to anyone.
I too tbh don't stand the group although they are really talented, didn't know much about them i only knew one of his bandmates cuz he's a famous actor and also know him and whenever i watched something of him he would always smile and give such good vibes and that's how he stuck to my mind when i knew that he passed away i was shocked cuz out of all ppl i didn't expected it. And i could anly imagine how his family fan and friends are feeling right know. So just don't care like u did before reading the article.
Losing moonbin is our biggest loss he's just so charming and perfect, by just watching this makes me wanna cry
R.I.P our moonbin😭
Wonder what kind of pressure he suffered that led him to take his own life
@@AdrianCHOY Probably the same things he was told made him charming and perfect
@@AdrianCHOY he actually died from a health condition, he didn't die by suicide
@afia3981 Stop spreading false information! We don't know how he died and we might never will! His mother has told us to stop spreading rumors and we should respect her wishes
@@AdrianCHOY do research first. he was sick, not suicide.
Several months ago, this was a place where I found joy and cuteness from these adorable siblings
But now, it’s just so hurtful and sad
Rest in peace Moonbin
Stay strong Moon Sua
I WISH IT WAS ALL A DREAM
MISS YOU MOONBIN STAY SAFE WHERE YOU ARE AND BE HAPPY...... YOU WILL ALWAYS LIVE IN OUR MEMORIES
Hardest part of being a fan is not being able to save the person who saved you during your darkness times. I can't imagine the pain he was enduring. He finally became a star for every aroha. Warm hugs to everyone. I am sure he's in a good place now. 💔😢
The person who decided to end their life must be full of depression and stress. Trust me that feeling doesn't come from just one or 2 days but maybe long time ago. And the sadness and loneliness are killing him. He definitely went through a tough patch for such a long long time. He always pretended to be happy and smile all the time in public. But deep inside, his heart is full of sorrow.
@@xitivloghis cause of death isn't confirmed yet we don't know is he commited suicide or not
Moonbin be like: 💀
😂😂
@@user-rem7c7c8qw please this is not funny don't make jokes out of this
@@user-rem7c7c8qw i'm disgusted
The way they are smiling so big and their smile has a different meaning behind it. Sua is smiling big because her dream came true that she got to perform on stage with his brother. Bin smiling as he is overly proud of his little sister. Omg. They had so much fun with this song. They love each other very much and I wish I could be their sibling too. The way he is overprotective of her. The way they both shine differently. Ugh😭😭 like im proud as their mother why ahahah
concuerdo tanto contigo 🥺
Every performance Sua does you can just see those 10 years of YG charisma engrained into her because of the way she performs.
They can never take that away from her. My girl literally grew up in that dungeon.
In what group is Sua?
@@cruel_summe.r billlie
@@cruel_summe.r Billlie, girlgroup from Mystic Story
I'm not and never have been a fan of Astro but I felt terrible when I received the news that he had died and I cried because I put myself in the fans' shoes and because I've been through this, since I'm a fan of SHINNee. Until today and when Jonghyun died I was devastated, my condolences again to the fans, be strong.
facts about this performance:
- bin chose the song after knowing that she (sua) wanted to perform this song with his brother (she also said that she wants to perform bin's song, WHO by ASTRO MOONBIN&SANHA)
-bin is the one who also suggested to switch roles
update 220628 sua said on bbl that she suggested to switch parts 😭 istg these two
- also the first time in a while bin said ily to sua and it was thru this song
- moon parents loveees this performance (confirmed by bin thru pms)
- this is their first performance as idols siblings
- bin also said that during ending fairy sua said SMILE but her side profile looks like shes asking for a kiss/pout
facts abt them:
- bin debuted 6 years ago, sua debuted late last year and she trained for over 12 years she almost gave up but she was encouraged and motivated by her brother (bin said its nice if she debuts after all the hardships she went thru)
- fun fact: bin asked on pms how to apply fansign (online) then arohas replied 'you need to buy albumSSSS' then later on we suspected this name on the winners list and yes it was him. you can watch his vlog about the fansign (ddalgona vlog moonbin on yt) and he praised the girls how good they are and he even said 'sua has my card go by food/meat' hes the sweetest ever!
- he also bought an iPhone for sua as per bin 'she's very keen about it, atleast once a day she talks abt how she wanted a new phone so i bought it for her right away' HE'S SO GENEROUS I LOVE HIM
pls support each one of them
Thank you for this!
The extra information makes the performance more heartwarming to watch
How can they perform special stage at music bank? Did they get invite to perform? I dont know so i ask cause it was so random hehehe
@@nurjeha3202 ig they were invited to perform, together with the groups who won 1st place in mubank
This is the reason why I love these two ♡
I don't want to lose the happiness I felt when watching this video, I'll just look at it as his final moments where he was happy with his sister. I'll cherish you Moonbin, hope you are happy whenever you are.
I really thought it was a sick joke or a rumor...I'm so so sorry Moonbin. So many of us, Aroha or not, love you. Please rest in peace. I hope wherever you are, you're happy. And please everyone send love and support to all members of Astro and Billlie's Moon Sua, his sister. This is devastating. Please....let's all be kind.
I genuinely thought this was fake news, but I guess it isn’t.
Let’s give as much love and support to his family and Sua as we can. Their shock must be unmeasurable compared to ours
@@marshmallow4040 It's still very hard to process. As someone who's a casual listener, watching his performance (especially the one with Sua); always made me grin. He's loved. Lots of strength and condolences to family and everyone affected🤍
@@adwika_7 you don’t have to be an ASTRO fan to recognize the amount of talent Moonbin had. Let’s continue showing support to everyone involved
I'm on behalf of Shawols here, we know what it feels like...please, Arohas, stay strong! (I'm not an Aroha myself, but I loved him so much just because of his perforances with other idols and this single video...)
It's really upsetting if he died by su*cide, nobody should have to pass like that and I hope he rests in peace..❤
Edit: he died of a stroke which is still sad but im glad he didnt pass of the other cause which would of been even worse. I hope moonbin continues his amazing journey in heaven.
Im here on 2024 i cant believe hes gone😭imagine sharing memories with bro in kpop then he died😥i hope shes ok
The ending fairy:
Moonbin: this is my sister no one can touch her, I'm gonna protect her.
While sua being a cute, playful little sister XD
I cant get my head around this fatality. I cant believe he is gone at a such a young age. 25 yo and so talented.
I think you meant to say "passing." Fatality can come off as a little depersonalizing.
@@thaothelazycat930 He commited suicide. It is fatal situation. He couldnt see his way out and ended himself. At his age with all his sucess he needed to fall in love and settle with someone.He knew it. And yet He couldnt. Too much pressure to keep up with that "idol life".
@@deepdude4719 Uh... I think you should refrain from saying anything that could pinpoint any blame on him. This is a tragic situation. Let's just wish him well on the other side.
@@deepdude4719 don’t spread unconfirmed information, we don’t know if it’s suicide or not. that’s just what’s suspected.
@@tzuyology the result seems to be out. Sudden death from exhaustion,but I don't know if its true.🥺
I have never really paid attention to Astro but after watching this on repeat, i have fallen in love with Moonbin. Looks like i might become an aroha 😭
💜💜💜🥺
Might check out his WHO fancam, yt channel: overlay and ode to moon. And his 24 hours cover stage fancam on ode to moon channel.
@@ForeverAroha-pr9tx omg thank you !!!
💜
me too
何度も観にきてるよ
最高の兄妹
i still can’t believe this boy is gone. i used to watch this video with a smile on my face and now i have tears in my eyes. such a beautiful soul, gone far too soon. you will be greatly missed, Moonbin.
I was obbsessed watching this video and now I'm just heartbroken everytime I watch it.
yeah, so sad lose he
We will still miss moonbin but he will be in our hearts Grupo Astro we are with you don't feel alone 😭💔😫 I have tears in my eyes 💔😭😫
They KILLED IT. I couldn't imagine how they're gonna perform this song Lol. But they made it so playful and cute(?)
Moon Siblings are the BEST !!!!
Agree
woa bestie ur comment blew upppp!! guess who i am lol
@@LovelyLikeThis. I saw now lolll😂😂😂
Bestie???
Are you Arabia? 😂
@@rimilroha_7.7.76 nopee.. hint - sua is my sis in law
@@LovelyLikeThis. AHHAHHAHAHAH
I can't..... Its like I'm forgetting everyone I know on the internet 😭. Don't do this to me
Binnie's Wife-Sshi
Months back i would have never thought i would be coming here with tears in my eyes. This was supposed to be a happy colourful vibe between siblings and now my heart clenches at how heartbroken sua is that she wont be able to be like this with her brother and moonbin...baby...we failed you. I am sorry you had to go through so much.
😢😢😢😢
😢😢 same
I remember that I watched this video for few times before, I like their performance so much as so much love between them, although I am not the fan, but still 😥.
Yes what a colorful vibe in this song,still cant believe this 😢😢😢😢😢.
私にとって永遠のいちばんのアイドルだよムンビン
moonbin’s face at first looking at sua doing aegyo HAHAHA. Moonbin was smiling from start to finish, he couldnt contain how happy he is 😭 im so glad he's always been there for sua specially during those times when she wanted to stop pursuing to be an idol. Their love and support for each other will always be topnotch!
I am not even a astro fan but I am really devastated to know the news can't even think what his members family fans friends and Moon Sua is going through. Rest in peace Moonbin.
Those who are demanding kbs to do the huenings dobt ask kbs ask the txt and kep1er's label because the Moon Siblings for sure both of their agencies had a hand in this collab... Fantagio knows how Moonbin is so supportive of his sister... And Mystic Story knows how Moon Sua worked so hard to get to where she is right now... Moonbin been waiting for the day Moon Sua debuts... and Moon Sua talked about it mant times that its her dream to be on stage with her brother... and for sure AROHA and BELLLIE'VE banded together and both agency knows about this and they made it happen...
Fr this collab wouldn't be exist if their companies aren't very supportive. Especially mystic story, they know how to treat their artists right and have been very supportive at least from what we see until now. As a moonsua supporter, we know this would never happen if she debuted under her old company. No matter how many invitation they got, but the desicion is on their own companies.
The fandom I am very important, Aroha and Billlie've are very peaceful they love and respect their artists and families
Los fandom son muy importantes Aroha y Billlie've aman y respetan a sus artistas y familia
@@vanessatasayco7698 I'm sorry to say this but I think it has nothing to do with fandom being peaceful. I mean, there's no way fandom would get mad over siblings collab 😅
luvvv themm and the agencyy
@@ayunniaaafandi mystic is the best... yoon jong shin billlie's CEO is giving them a special release this month... a remake of Patbingsu by their CEO yoon jong shin... hopefully it has mv and they will promote it on music shows...
그 예쁜 미소가 너무너무 그립다..
Coming here to leave my deepest condolences to Moonbin's family. He will live on through every single performance, song, picture he left us, such talent will never be forgotten. 🤍🕊
2:45 is such a beautiful moment. We will all miss Moonbin and forever hold him in our hearts. Rest in peace angel, fly high 🤍
😭😭
Omg I didn't know he passed away. RIP Moonbin
he literally did pat her🫶 so cute and real siblings relationship, moon bin will be missed forever
I don't know anything about ASTRO but I could see the brother and sister affection in their eyes when they performed together. R.I.P Moonbin. You'll always live in our hearts❤🔥
I feel so sorry for his sister and Astro that they lost him, he was my bias wrecker but I will support them
3:26 priceless smiling I missed him so much
@@stay_straykids_ilyfsm_forever same. He was my bias wrecker and rocky was my bias now one left the group and one left the world 😔😢
He was very charsicmatic
I see you every bro
TH-cam and their recommendations…
I really thought I could get through it without crying but that kissy face she does to him at the end…got be bawling my eyes out.
I don’t even know them that well - I just liked this performance. But I remember sitting in disbelief when I heard of his passing. And now I’m crying because their smiles are so beautiful at the end…😭
Fun facts: They only practiced twice before the actual performance. They also decided to switch on the second part, Moonbin is the female version while Sua is the male version (in case you didn't notice). Sua wanted to perform Candy in My Ears or Troublemaker with her brother and she wants to do the male parts while Moonbin does the female part. Moonbin was the one to suggest they do this song.
It was a great collab, and we want more!
How did you know that...where is the source of info... would love to read about it
@@snehagavli5382 moonbin said on private messages of universe days after they performed
Trouble maker would be nice too
Sweet home Alabama
@@Therealest847 yea get off this app if u're gonna have a disgusting perspective
I’m happy she got to perform this stage with him, wishing their whole family so many condolences
when they changed parts I literally died!! also moonbin low voice is so sexy
I love that too
It’s shows how talented they are ..wow
빈아, 오늘도 많이 보고싶다 😔😔😔😓😓
it still hurts a lot
this was the performance i was watching 15 mins before the news and then just my heart broke into millions of pieces :((
Binnie we miss you so much
Same
What news ?
@@ainirazak-m9k About Moonbin's passing
@@ainirazak-m9kmoonbin unfortunately passed away.
@@ainirazak-m9kthe boy (MoonBin) died