It’s only a joke but in one sense it is true that we the poor in Pakistan and India don’t have the facilities. Lots of intelligent people are wasted by poverty. All the best and good luck.
Dont compare India and Pakistan. India is the most rapidly growing global economy. It has more 1000 Govt. universities and over 11700 startups under 5 years or so. India is in much better position than Pakistan. People are wasted only in Pakistan not in India
@@Pakiza-AliMany indians agreed on the need of a buffer state like pakistan while partition happened. If i am correct Sardar Vallabhai patel ji was one of them.
@@Pakiza-Ali It was accepted long back. Even the most dreaded Hindu Nationalist Vajpayee visited minar e Pakistan in 1999 to lead peace talks we all know what happened after that. Maybe Pakistan should move on and actually think about a future which isn't India, America or China centric for once and stop being a rented garrison for once.
@@Pakiza-Ali Hindu and Sikh Punjabis should never accept this partition. It’s their Gaza situation where they are the Palestinians whose home land got taken.
Jab tak Iss region me Islam hai tab tak extremism khatm nahi hogi, partion to religion ke base par hua tha aur iss region ke muslims ne apna seprate nation manga tha, Hinduo ne apna seprate nation nahi manga aur secularism ko follow Kiya, aaj 25 crore muslims India me rahate hai jabki 1% Hindu rahate hai Pakistan me, wo bhi buri halat me, to aise me extremism kaise khatm hoga, India and Pakistan ke rishte Bhagawan n kare ki achhe ho nahi to Bharat ka bhi beda gark ho jayega.
No nobody is superior than other over race , colour , gender but superior is the one with more good deeds . You need to understand Islam with the approach to understand it bout not with the approach to contradict it , and yeah if any other question i will be happy to answer it
@@Guhgg-uh7ei You did not answer his question, its just yes or no. One word answer and don't beat around the bush please. To anyone reading: His actual answer is yes, he does not respect non Muslims. He said 'by your deeds', and in Islam being a non Muslim is a bad deed, and therefore he does not respect Kaffirs. That's the logic here for anyone wondering. He can't say it directly.
Of course they think so.... They say we have imaan, we will go to jannat... In short radicalized one's are just like zombies.. Who wants other person too becomes zombies like them
So the Lahore resolution was more about creation of autonomous Muslim majority pockets within India rather than the creation of a separate nation called Pakistan. This also meant more "Kashmir" like states and more headaches for India in the future. This is what the British truly wanted. Aren't we glad than Jinnah took his Muslims and went west and east to create his own nation? Imagine having to deal with three Kashmirs! Thank you for a very clear explanation of historical fact.
@@nikhilhembrom8952 it was possible by every congress member everyone except Gandhi family. Jinnah didn't wanted army but exist same like Bhutan, where Bhutan is taken care by indian army. But nehru ego opposed it !
Dear Syed Muzzamilji I listen to all your talks on TH-cam. I really admire your intellectual honesty and courage to say it while living in Pakistan. I do not know how many Pakistanis listen and understand you. But ou should carry on with this. Some one has to tell the truth, and at times has to pay a price for doing it. From this only things will start changing. Stay safe & may God Bless you. Regards,
Sindh was most prosperous state of indian subcontinent but today economy of sindh is just 8lakh crore indias most backward state bihar economy is 10lakh crore well done sharif dynasty bhutto zardari dynasty dynamic imran niazi and mqm
Muzzamil Sir My family from Tehsil Jaddanwala suffered a lot in partition but now I don’t regret it. Rather I thank Zinah for it.Had it not happened in 1947 it was sure to come with much more bloodshed before Bengala desh may be in early fifties.In my opinion all political leaders of congress or Muslim league were followers of Britishers. None of them went to Andaman or to gallows. Zinah wanted number one position which were not possible in presence of Hindus majority, Zinah and Nehru both were least religious.Zinah had only one choice to become number one .That was to play Muslim card deftly which he played for his politics.He was not a prating Muslim but brought Pakistan.Both Britishers and Zinah aimed for it. Pakistan is a boon in disguise for present India. Akhand Bharat will be curse for India.That will be undoing of Zinah and lot of regrets for united India. If Pakistan Muslims can not accept there east Pakistan Muslims how they will tolerate Hindu neighbours.This is all what I have to say.
You can say a lot more about the folly that killed millions of innocent men, women and children. Humanity was degraded in the sub-continent and have not recovered from it and perhaps it will take lot more longer to realise why we became wildly beast to shed blood of each other. I have seen it all. British were backing Jinnah and Mr. Nehru let it happen. Decisions make or break humanity that was disgraceful.
Syed Muzammil Shah You are doing a great job. This the need of the time to revisit the history of partition of India, critically and honestly though it seems quite late. But you deserve big credit.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rdnot really. We learned quite a bit more. Your narrow minded uber rightist radicalized mindset won't be able to grasp it unfortunately.
Why you are hiding the real truth that Jinnah was not the only person behind the demand for Pakistan? I am giving you challenge to share the complete list of Muslim League with their designations. Here is a very little gift for you: Soon after joining the All-India Muslim League in 1945, Hazrat Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat Barelvi toured the NWFP to win support for the Muslim League. On October 1, 1945, Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat organized a historic meeting of the Sunni Ulema Kiram and Mashaikh at Peshawar, which passed resolutions expressing full loyalty with the Muslim League and also expressed complete confidence in Jinnah's leadership. Then he invited the Muslim League leader Mohammad Ali Jinnah to tour the Province which Jinnah did on 24 November 1945. The Pir's vigorous campaign for the Pakistan Movement in the NWFP area contributed significantly to the Muslim League's success in the NWFP referendum held in early part of 1947. The list of Muslim League will destroy all the manipulation made in history that "Only Jinnah was demanding Pakistan? Molvi were opposing Pakistan? Pakistan was not founded as an Islamic State by Muhammad Ali JInnah?" Just one person has contributed the whole province of KPK to Pakistan. I'm sure you will never do this...
While it's crucial to convey the truth, it's important to note that throughout this program, there was no mention of the Khaksar Resolutions presented by Jinnah and approved by the All-India Muslim League. Pakistan suffers because of lies, distortions, and concealments. Asking others to tell the truth begins with speaking it ourselves.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd When you study in Madarsa and bring a Arguments which has No relevance to the current discussion, We in India, call them #Madrsashap. And my Friend you are a Proud #MadarsaShap. Damn, I am Greatful that Pakistan is not with us. Otherwise, it would have been taken so much of our resources to teach a Jahil Awaam.
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd O ustaad, Ye tunny bhi wohi sub kuch nahi kehta diya Jo ye Librandu video mein keh raha hai Aor Tu Lambi tahreer likh k bta raha hai
@@Talhatahir-wp9rdYeh sab bata kay kya mila .. that miskin wazir e azam of your mulk is out there at KSA with his kashkol … so much for Lahore resolutions …
"It's time to leave Your past" "Love your present " "Look forward to your future " You can't change where you came from. "But you can choose where to go from here." "If you won't let your past die, it won't let you Live"
You seems to an intelligent person. But misleading thoughts will enhance your futures. History remains and it is important the coming generations know truth that has gone in the past. Our children should know what were up to in our life time.
The Past never dies.. Its always with you. All along.. will forever stay with you..of course we must carry on forward,, but forget Past means forget your Roots. Who wants to suffer from Dementia or Alzheimer.?? Or the Humans will like to forget Jesus, Moses, Rama, Krishna. Mohammed, Hussein, Buddha or even Gandhi or Jinnah. No no you you have to GoOn but History accompanies you to your last Breath.
Why you are hiding the real truth that Jinnah was not the only person behind the demand for Pakistan? I am giving you challenge to share the complete list of Muslim League with their designations. Here is a very little gift for you: Soon after joining the All-India Muslim League in 1945, Hazrat Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat Barelvi toured the NWFP to win support for the Muslim League. On October 1, 1945, Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat organized a historic meeting of the Sunni Ulema Kiram and Mashaikh at Peshawar, which passed resolutions expressing full loyalty with the Muslim League and also expressed complete confidence in Jinnah's leadership. Then he invited the Muslim League leader Mohammad Ali Jinnah to tour the Province which Jinnah did on 24 November 1945. The Pir's vigorous campaign for the Pakistan Movement in the NWFP area contributed significantly to the Muslim League's success in the NWFP referendum held in early part of 1947. The list of Muslim League will destroy all the manipulation made in history that "Only Jinnah was demanding Pakistan? Molvi were opposing Pakistan? Pakistan was not founded as an Islamic State by Muhammad Ali JInnah?" Just one person has contributed the whole province of KPK to Pakistan. I'm sure you will never do this...
After 75 years,Now it was right Muslims got their own nation, all Muslims from forced to leave for islamic pakistan. My grandparents were lucky to escape with their lives islamic pakistan. They used to hide in graveyards during the day n travelled during the night
I understand your point and it's appropriate in a way but my point of view is that it was not their land to begin with. Islamists were invaders. They were not native to this land. It was our land. Our nation. We just gave it away.
@@anirudhaj9007we Pakistanis are not non-native to this land and didn’t migrate with the invaders. Many people converted. The overwhelming majority of Pakistans are the native population who have lived in that region for millennia proven by DNA tests.
Sir I am always worried about your safety.. please take care of yourself. You are a big asset not only to Pakistan but also to the entire world because you have the guts to say truth. Good God always bless you and your family. I pray goddess Bhavani to be always with you.. and protect you eternally😭👌🙏🙏🙏🙏
I'm indian muslim, trust me some hatred for non-muslims is justified. u don't know how difficult it's to live in such a non-gairat, intolerating & communal country.
سب سے پہلے - ملک کو توڑنے والے شخص کو کیا کہتے ہیں؟ غدار.... غدار۔ ایم اے جناح غدار تھا۔ پاکستان کے نام نہاد قائداعظم کبھی عظیم لیڈر نہیں تھے۔ وہ ایک سادہ آدمی لیکن ہوشیار وکیل تھے۔ جس طرح ہر وکیل ہر مقدمہ جیتنے کی کوشش کرتا ہے، اسی طرح جناح نے ہندوستان کی تقسیم کا مقدمہ پورے عزم اور استقامت کے ساتھ لڑا۔ انہیں کانگریس میں کوئی اہمیت اور حیثیت نہیں ملی، اس لیے اس نے چند بڑے ذمہ داروں کی مدد سے مسلم لیگ کی قیادت سنبھالی اور اپنا ملک توڑا اور غدار بن گئے۔وہ یقینی طور پر ایک باعمل مسلمان نہیں تھا۔ وہ انگریزی بولتا تھا، شراب پیتا تھا اور سور کا گوشت کھاتا تھا۔ وہ بنگلہ دیش کو توڑنے کے اصل مجرم تھے کیونکہ انہوں نے بنگال میں اردو کو نافع بنانے کی کوشش کی حالانکہ وہ خود اردو نہیں جانتے تھے۔ بلوچستان ایک آزاد ریاست تھی۔ اس کی اپنی ثقافت اور اپنی بولی تھی۔ جناح نے وہاں اپنی فوج بھیج کر غیر قانونی طور پر قبضہ کر لیا۔ اس نے قلات کے ساتھ بھی ایسا ہی کیا۔
Love from India ❤. It's good to see that you talked about how Punjab of Pakistan lost its language, culture. I hope people will get more informed and learn more about truth. Thanks brother.
@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf culture can not be imported… Islam is arabic religion and subcontinent muslins are converted one then how come you have different cultures?
That is not true Pakistani Punjabi culture was dominant in India for a long time Indian Punjabi films use to copy Pakistan dialogue and songs. What has Punjabi culture done for India? India Punjab has big alcohol and chitta problem. Punjabi culture does not belong to any religion Hindu Punjabis were first in Punjab they follow Hindi language and Hindi states culture. Shahmukhi language was first in Punjab before Gurmukhi. Punjabi culture beings nothing good bhangra pao munddeyo te Gidhha pao Kudio nobody wants this dirty culture you can keep it in your home.
On religious path i listen to Ustad-E-Muthram Engineer Mohammad Ali Mirza & on Political & Historical views i listen to Syed Muzamal Shah! Love you both! Stay blessed. ✌️❤️
The way you took his name shows your respect oriented arab enslaved devoted mindset. Not that I don't praise him, he's doing good, but not all good. He takes you out of the stories of babay, and pushes you in the stories baba bukhari baba muslim baba trimzi etc. Were they not a baba? Were those books not written after hundreds of years of the demise of founder of Islam? Have you even read, some of the stories are so absurd, shameful and unexplainable in the sahih hadith. Anyway, He's just a man. No need to make anyone your spiritual father. You could listen to the better one he calls his mentor directly, Ghamdi.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
From Bangladesh. I am pretty amazed about the question that has been raised on sovereign units at 7:30 minute. I did read the Lahore resolution earlier but myself have not noticed the duplicity. Thanks a lot for revealing it for the people.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@debrajghosh8446 Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
I respect you Sir. Why people in Pakistan not informed about this, it’s a shame that Teachers even not telling them truth. Thank you for your good work 🙏
I appreciate. Mr Mujammil's effort to uveal real truth of Indo-Pak history. I fee about It is high time Pakistan Public is informed about the blunders played it.
While it's crucial to convey the truth, it's important to note that throughout this program, there was no mention of the Khaksar Resolutions presented by Jinnah and approved by the All-India Muslim League. Pakistan suffers because of lies, distortions, and concealments. Asking others to tell the truth begins with speaking it ourselves.
Syed, you are doing a great and brave job. In addition to the massive identity crisis that engulfs Pakistan, it also needs to go deeper and confront the massive historical trauma of forceful conversions and its impact on the society’s psyche. Someday it needs to make peace with itself and accept and embrace its original Indic roots.
Partition of India was the biggest tragedy of 20 st century , I even have arguments which suggest that it was bigger tragedy than Second World War . The impact it had and has on people for 75 years after the event . 4 million Hindus , Muslims , sikhs , Buddhist killed . According to recent study India’s GDP growth is best in the world with 8% but it will become 10 or 11 % GDP growth if it stops its spending related to Pakistan, terrorism and on borders . Just imagine how much money both countries spent on each other . Second Pakistan became an Islamic country which means there is no free society , no body is allowed to say whatever they want , whatever they want to wear clothes , whatever they want to do . India is growing just because we have somewhat free society and our goal is to become America where everybody is free . Free society helps to improve societies .
@@itzadi786 Meri Jaan har cheez ki freedom hai.. problem yeh hai k hum log ek dosre k mulk mein aatey jate ni.. wohi suntey dakhtey jante Hein jo humhara media humhein baatata hai. That’s all I can say.. rest you can believe what ever you want brother. Stay blessed.
Like the way you speak. Nice voice quality. Good to see you enlightening the people of Pakistan with correct history. Also detailed study on topic before you come with any video is the thing to highly appreciate. Need more people like you for brighter future of Pakistan👍🏻👍🏻
We in India are very happy that Jinnah, with the help of the British, made Pakistan! I shudder to think what would our condition be today if you all were with us!! Muzammil, if only the majority of Pakistani people were like you. Unfortunately, they have been brainwashed for 76 years to an extent that it seems irreversible! 🇮🇳
Sir, Assalamoalikum, you should at least appreciate Syed Muzammil who dare speak the truth. In my opinion, there are very few on Indian side who could speak the truth. You should also note that Ghandhi and Nehru deceived the Muslim Leaders such as Abdul Ghafar Khan and Abul Kalam Azad as they supported AINCongress in its stance against the partition. But in the end Congress signed the partition plan and left the Muslim leaders disappointed. Pakistan Zindabad!
Bro I'm very thankful for person like you please educated Pakistanis citizens with facts and truly analysis so that your country be in the right path. There's no shame for sharing your truth history and culture and politicians should agree with such person like you and whoever are working for the benefit of Pakistanis nation
I'm sorry bro ...but in 20:06 you only said about Punjab partition... clearly you don't have any idea about Bengal partition....the Bengal partition was more bloody, horrible and a major setback for Bengal .... people only talk about the Western part of partition but they ignore the Eastern part where Hindu Bengalis suffered the most and Hindus living in Bangladesh are still suffering
dont judge without knowing. listen to other videos on his channel. he talked about bengal too. but this video is about wrong hx of Pakistan. so he is on point
There is NO LESSON for us Pakistanis in history. Knowing about what, why and how Pakistan came into being is not only a fruitless exercise but seems to be counterproductive as well. Pakistan is! We must ALL concentrate on making the best of it.
AGREED. but such ppl will always exist who want to split hair and find sth that would support their narrative or just for the sake of just birthing an argument. the real tragedy is the little percentage of common folk that fall into such traps.
Hasan Nisar "Jo tareekh ko mask karte...........tareekh unko barbad karte ha"..........'making the best of it' seems too little too late now that "it" has failed MISERABLY
@@KingKong-lb3vh So true......their continual denial of truth is so funny and puts a smile on my face that there is no hope for a people that cannot examine the past to correct the future..........😅😅😅.......hahah and I AM NOT EVENHindu..lol
These things are clearly mentioned in our Pakistan studies book for Class 12 published by National book foundation. It tells that the ambiguity which was caused due to the use of "plural states" was later removed at Madras session of Muslim League in 1941.
I request to all Indian plz follow him and appreciate his work.. Because this kind of person to help progress and develop our neighbor country Pakistan ...! Pakistaniyo aise you tubers ko support kro.. Educated person change everything in Pakistan
Syed Muzammil is a precious stone of Pakistan who enlighten to majority of intellectuals across the Indian subcontinental and unfortunately Pakistani's are not values him.
Allhumdulliah I thank Allah for the beautiful country Pakistan born on the 27th of the holy month of ramadan And InshaAllah better days are not very far “Pakistan zindabad “ Pakistan paindabad”💚
It refers to states as provinces and independent, autonomous and sovereign refers to complete freedom from British India. And "should be grouped" refers to grouping different units together.
Partition was correct but incomplete, if partition had not taken place, these illiterate people would have ruined India also. Thanks to Jinnah for partition, who abducted his own friend's minor daughter and married her.
Muzammal, while narrating history you have also not told the truth but followed the line adopted by Wali khan in his book “Facts are facts “ the events took place as below. 1.Lahore resolution was presented by Fazal Haq on march 23 adopted a day later but day of presentation is taken as day of resolution. It is commonly believed that Sardar Sikandar Hayat drafted the resolution. 2. It envisaged two independent sovereign states consisting of Muslim majority areas in north east and north west of India. Yes no mention of Pakistan was made. It was primarily done to make Muslim league popular in Muslim majority states resulting in victories of league in those states during 1945 elections. 3. In April 1946 the Muslim legislatures from all the states in their convention at Delhi passed another resolution mentioning Lahore resolution and decided that instead of two it will be one state and name Pakistan was used in it. Hussain Shaheed Suharwardi was the driving force to get this resolution passed. Both Lahore resolution mentioning states and Delhi resolution mentioning one state of Pakistan are inscribed in Minar e Pakistan. Wish you had visited Minar e Pakistan and got clarified your doubts.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd tell me then ke agar "states" se murad pak aur india tha to phir its not a mistake, jab ye koi galti hai hi nahi and they wanted 2 states then why did change it to "state"
@@areebanaveed9485 Muhammad Ali Jinnah's address to the Lahore conference was, according to Stanley Wolpert, the moment when Jinnah, once a proponent of Hindu-Muslim unity, irrevocably transformed himself for the cause of separate Muslim homeland called Pakistan There remains a debate on whether the resolution envisaged two sovereign states in the eastern and western parts of British India. Abdul Hashim of the Bengal Muslim League interpreted the text as a demand for two separate countries. In 1946, Prime Minister H. S. Suhrawardy of Bengal, a member of the All India Muslim League, mooted the United Bengal proposal with the support of Muslim and Hindu leaders, as well as the Governor of Bengal. Although there were and continue to be disagreements on the interpretation of the resolution, it was widely accepted that it called for a separate Muslim state.Opposing opinions focus on the phrase "independent states" claiming this means Muslim majority provinces, i.e. Punjab, Sindh, etc. would be independent of each other. They ignore the phrase "geographically contiguous units." They also rely on the claims of certain Bengali nationalists who did not agree with one state. They accuse their opponents of diverting the "spirit" of the resolution. The majority of the Muslim League leadership contended that it was intended for not only the separation of India but into only 2 states (Muslim majority and Hindu majority). Therefore, it is indeed a statement calling for independence and one Muslim state. Eventually, the name "Pakistan" was used for the envisioned state. he is trying to imply that we have somewhat Naive understanding of the resolution and our textbooks are not correctly protraying this. In reality he is just try to push forward his Liberal agenda.
@@areebanaveed9485 The books are filled with distorted & fabricated history. I don't think anyone would waste their time to reverify the things they are taught in pak studies.
Syed sir the way you explain any topic in your video is very informative and interesting. Applauding from India.amazing keep it up. Pakistan need such influential youtuber like you.😊
Now,Punjab is exacting revenge of its division from other nationalities through brute majority in every sphere,mainly in the military.We are morally and economically bankrupt.
It is a disgraceful abuse of power and a shameful disservice to the pursuit of knowledge and truth. Thanks sayyed Muzamil for revealing it, it's your beauty. More power to you ❤️
I littrly deep think and I found India first and second terrorist first is jinnaha and second is bullshit godse both maybe other religion but same as belong on saitisam
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Look Mr what are the impacts of curriculum scams: If history is inaccurately written and filled with curriculum scams, it can have several negative impacts: Misinformation: False historical narratives can lead to widespread misunderstanding of events, people, and cultures, perpetuating biases and stereotypes. Erosion of Trust: When history is manipulated or distorted for ulterior motives, it undermines trust in educational institutions, historians, and authority figures. Polarization: Misleading historical accounts can exacerbate societal divisions by promoting particular agendas or ideologies, leading to conflict and discord. Stifled Learning: Students may be deprived of a comprehensive understanding of the past, hindering their ability to critically analyze and learn from historical events. Cultural Loss: Distorted histories may marginalize certain communities or downplay their contributions, leading to the erasure of diverse perspectives and experiences. And many things, so he is a good researcher and brave person who dared to say those things openly, I largely appreciate his bravery, undeniable. Moreover I respect your opinion.
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd People like Mr Ijaz Ahmad don't realize that youtubers like Syed are working for Indian govt. Indian govt hire two types of Pakistanis 1) Financially weak 2) Propagandist like Syed. Former are used for assassination programs and later are used for creating pro Indian narratives.
Syed Muzammil is intelligent/ brilliant man who works hard for educating pakistani by showing them truthful evidence, separates emotion from truth, separates lies and propaganda from hidden truth . Pakistan is lucky to have him, i love is dedication , and courage. furthermore he is gifted speaker with good voice-God bless him for his noble cause Dr raj k dhar (USA)
مزمل نیا طارق فتح ہے جو انڈین ویورشپ حاصل کرنے کے لیے انڈین بیانیے کو پرموٹ کررہا ہے باقی اس وقت بی جے پی کا ہندتوا کی نفرت بھی سیاست دیکھ کر مسلمانون کو احساس ہورہا ہے کہ ہندو انتہا پسندی کے ساتھ چلنا سکھ,عیساٸ,مسلم,جین مت,بدھ مت اور کاسٹ سسٹم پر یقین رکھنے والون کا گزر بسر نہین ہوسکتا۔مزمل کی باتون کو سنجیدہ مت لین یہ پاور گیم کا حصہ بن کر صرف انڈین ویورشپ کے چکر مین ہے جو احمعق ہندو سے دے بھی رہے ہین😂
Jinnah was the real culprit! I'm Punjabi and I'm sad to see such disrespect of Punjabi Language pwn it's own Land, Pakistani Punjabi's feels shame while speaking Punjabi but on the other side of Punjabi's proudly speak their Mother tongue!
@@BilquessBibi what does it mean??? Obviously when 13 Million People, more than other 3 provinces people will live in a place, definitely they'll take more budget, and in return they pays the utility bills of all provinces, don't You see that??? Anyhow I was talking about Urdu-ism which's unfair !
@@memyself9959 why unfair??? , are u first Pakistani or Punjabi???? , And secondly Balochistan needs money for development and if we do that , for Pakistan there will be a bright future!!! . Punjab has taken much , now it's time to sacrifice for good!! Without CPEC , RekoDiq and Gwadar , our future is dark
@@BilquessBibi I'm Punjabi first! Because my Genuine identity is Punjab, which is 5K older Civilization, and My Punjab pay the price of Partition, I lost my half of Punjab for this Country, and most importantly, "it doesn't mean if I'm Punjabi, so I can't be a good Pakistani, Obviously a Country should be like where Our Fundaments shouldn't be ignored, Our Culture, Language and Civilization should be guarding by a Country, a country should never be like where People feel shame to their roots, it will not remain longer as it was in Past, because People are getting aware ! Furthermore, If Punjab is taken bigger share from Budget, it doesn't mean the budget shouldn't be disburse unequally with other Provinces!!
Why you are hiding the real truth that Jinnah was not the only person behind the demand for Pakistan? I am giving you challenge to share the complete list of Muslim League with their designations. Here is a very little gift for you: Soon after joining the All-India Muslim League in 1945, Hazrat Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat Barelvi toured the NWFP to win support for the Muslim League. On October 1, 1945, Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat organized a historic meeting of the Sunni Ulema Kiram and Mashaikh at Peshawar, which passed resolutions expressing full loyalty with the Muslim League and also expressed complete confidence in Jinnah's leadership. Then he invited the Muslim League leader Mohammad Ali Jinnah to tour the Province which Jinnah did on 24 November 1945. The Pir's vigorous campaign for the Pakistan Movement in the NWFP area contributed significantly to the Muslim League's success in the NWFP referendum held in early part of 1947. The list of Muslim League will destroy all the manipulation made in history that "Only Jinnah was demanding Pakistan? Molvi were opposing Pakistan? Pakistan was not founded as an Islamic State by Muhammad Ali JInnah?" Just one person has contributed the whole province of KPK to Pakistan. I'm sure you will never do this...
Har bat pr yaqeen krny sy phly check krn K Har bat wo bnda theek b kr rha ya Nahi blindly trust b nuqsan deta Hy Har bat Pak studies ma b theek nhi blky wo to Hy hi jhoot ka palanda but Har bt muzamil shb b logic K sth Ni bta rhy
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Pakistan was never our goal our goal was Muslim state and remember Pakistan may be no there but a more powerful Muslim state will be there inshallah perking the 20 crore Indians Muslim
No. Because just because some state is in muslim doesn't mean it has to good. Take arab countries or even turkey and Afghanistan.@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf
Jh2 there war 33 muslim big riyasat at the time of India's independence and still you need another state for muslims? Lol such a lame excuse.... Saalo tak hinduo pe julm Kiya jab Hinduo ko power mil Rahi thi toh tumhari fatt gayi ..isliye bhagne ke baad rehne ke liye Pakistan banaya gaya...@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong. The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Punjab and its identity was not devided but broken to peices not only on the base of religion but also on base of ethnicity after partition lahore was devide for muslims then haryana for jat vote , then Himachal for phadhi vote and whats left in india is already khalistan with sikh votes , same people devided by there own bias but ruled by politicians , i sometimes think how politicaly powerful would have been undevided punjab in Indian subcontinent but now its just even ediotic to think about ❤from 🇮🇳
@@I_GarvitSingh this whole was Punjab not even haryana Jammu and Kashmir was also included but the problem with us is this sub human mentality he is not jat so not one of us he is not rajput so not one of us ,this sub humman mentality is the reason for this devisions , no culture is continuous without influence of others I can't speak my language without using haryanvi tongue neither you without Punjabi , so this point is complete schizophrenia
Indians born after independence are very much THANKFUL & INDEBTED TO Jinnah. Only one issue we have to settled is 100% transfer of population. As and when that happened, we will be luckiest of the planet earth.
![[Full] 4 ต่อ 4 Celebrity EP.920 | 3 พ.ย. 67 | one31](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KwiW2M_kAg4/mqdefault.jpg)
Pakistanis arent reading General Knowledge,
Instead they are reading General's Knowledge.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 good one
It’s only a joke but in one sense it is true that we the poor in Pakistan and India don’t have the facilities. Lots of intelligent people are wasted by poverty. All the best and good luck.
Dont compare India and Pakistan. India is the most rapidly growing global economy. It has more 1000 Govt. universities and over 11700 startups under 5 years or so. India is in much better position than Pakistan. People are wasted only in Pakistan not in India
Hahahaha...
Ok bhai 👍👍@@zahidkashmiri1851
I am a Indian here, I thank Jinnah for creation of Pakistan. Thanks a lot..
Bas Sare hi le jata...
Your family had not become a refugee.
You are our friend! But I do not like Jinnah, the millionaire who drew a line which has gone wrong.
@@aagg83 hmare nehru ji n roka
@@zahidkashmiri1851 its good for us
Now I am convinced It’s good India and Pakistan separated. Pakistan is nice buffer country between India and Pakistan’s Western neighbours.
Easy for non punjabjs to say this. Punjab was most affected.
It's nice to hear Indians accept that Pakistan went separate way! Even if it took seventy plus years .....
@@Pakiza-AliMany indians agreed on the need of a buffer state like pakistan while partition happened. If i am correct Sardar Vallabhai patel ji was one of them.
@@Pakiza-Ali It was accepted long back. Even the most dreaded Hindu Nationalist Vajpayee visited minar e Pakistan in 1999 to lead peace talks we all know what happened after that. Maybe Pakistan should move on and actually think about a future which isn't India, America or China centric for once and stop being a rented garrison for once.
@@Pakiza-Ali Hindu and Sikh Punjabis should never accept this partition. It’s their Gaza situation where they are the Palestinians whose home land got taken.
Facts matter to only Pakistanis who recognize the falsehood but unfortunately majority of our Pakistanis don't even care 🇵🇰🙏
Endian
@@aa_572 😜
Muzamil Shah History Distortion Campaign exposed th-cam.com/video/7tRgczGM3is/w-d-xo.html
@@aa_572 prokiyan😂
Has a Ruler Ever Transferred Power Without Threat? Allama Mashriqi’s Impact on Indian Independence
th-cam.com/video/n9ZxIVea7qc/w-d-xo.html
One day extremism will end in this Subcontinent 🇮🇳🇵🇰🇧🇩 Let's hope for it.
Uske liye aapko identity crisis nahi hona chahiye 🥰❤️
❤
As long as isl@m exist , that day will never come.
Jab tak Iss region me Islam hai tab tak extremism khatm nahi hogi, partion to religion ke base par hua tha aur iss region ke muslims ne apna seprate nation manga tha, Hinduo ne apna seprate nation nahi manga aur secularism ko follow Kiya, aaj 25 crore muslims India me rahate hai jabki 1% Hindu rahate hai Pakistan me, wo bhi buri halat me, to aise me extremism kaise khatm hoga, India and Pakistan ke rishte Bhagawan n kare ki achhe ho nahi to Bharat ka bhi beda gark ho jayega.
Even when extremism ends..we don't want the old akhand Bharat,we'll trade just the way we are ..
Muzammil ji, when a Muslim of Pakistan calls a person of another religion "Kaffir" does he consider himself as Superior??
No nobody is superior than other over race , colour , gender but superior is the one with more good deeds .
You need to understand Islam with the approach to understand it bout not with the approach to contradict it , and yeah if any other question i will be happy to answer it
@@Guhgg-uh7ei
You did not answer his question, its just yes or no. One word answer and don't beat around the bush please.
To anyone reading: His actual answer is yes, he does not respect non Muslims. He said 'by your deeds', and in Islam being a non Muslim is a bad deed, and therefore he does not respect Kaffirs. That's the logic here for anyone wondering. He can't say it directly.
They don't have answers in one word if they answer yes or no jalebi kaun bnayega fir ..@xijinpig8982
Of course they think so.... They say we have imaan, we will go to jannat... In short radicalized one's are just like zombies.. Who wants other person too becomes zombies like them
One word ans is NO...
Pakistan is lucky to have such an intellect..love from India
Still he is also afraid of talking about Islam and its practices
He is doing this fir his country. Not for India.@@rajatkm.7
He is not he is munafik he is liberal he should blame islam not politics
@@rajatkm.7not really, he criticizes whatever he finds irrational without putting his own life in danger
When he talk islam is wrong then you can actually tell he is good human being
So the Lahore resolution was more about creation of autonomous Muslim majority pockets within India rather than the creation of a separate nation called Pakistan. This also meant more "Kashmir" like states and more headaches for India in the future. This is what the British truly wanted. Aren't we glad than Jinnah took his Muslims and went west and east to create his own nation? Imagine having to deal with three Kashmirs! Thank you for a very clear explanation of historical fact.
@Sql18908we should also thanked congress leadership to not accept any of there demands
It was more of pressure tactics to extract more from British and underpin congress while there leaders were mostly behind bars
@@nikhilhembrom8952 it was possible by every congress member everyone except Gandhi family. Jinnah didn't wanted army but exist same like Bhutan, where Bhutan is taken care by indian army.
But nehru ego opposed it !
Ruko jara 5 saal har sahar me pakistan milega.
@@HarishSharma-uv1cotrue they are spilling over.
As a Pakistani I am proud to have such a brave and intelligent person 🙏
Dear Syed Muzzamilji I listen to all your talks on TH-cam. I really admire your intellectual honesty and courage to say it while living in Pakistan.
I do not know how many Pakistanis listen and understand you. But ou should carry on with this. Some one has to tell the truth, and at times has to pay a price for doing it. From this only things will start changing.
Stay safe & may God Bless you.
Regards,
Sindh was most prosperous state of indian subcontinent but today economy of sindh is just 8lakh crore indias most backward state bihar economy is 10lakh crore well done sharif dynasty bhutto zardari dynasty dynamic imran niazi and mqm
You should focus on your country.
@@abdullahkhan-pr1ipand it's doing great! Which is why we are laughing looking at you fall off on your bum😂
Sindhs population is 50.5 million.
Bihars population is 90 million and that too according to 2011 census.
@@immu365
Sindh have Karachi ; Bihar don't have Karachi
@abdullahkhan-pr1ip we are happy to see you radicals failing day by day. 😂😂😂
Muzzamil Sir
My family from Tehsil Jaddanwala suffered a lot in partition but now I don’t regret it. Rather I thank Zinah for it.Had it not happened in 1947 it was sure to come with much more bloodshed before Bengala desh may be in early fifties.In my opinion all political leaders of congress or Muslim league were followers of Britishers. None of them went to Andaman or to gallows. Zinah wanted number one position which were not possible in presence of Hindus majority, Zinah and Nehru both were least religious.Zinah had only one choice to become number one .That was to play Muslim card deftly which he played for his politics.He was not a prating Muslim but brought Pakistan.Both Britishers and Zinah aimed for it.
Pakistan is a boon in disguise for present India. Akhand Bharat will be curse for India.That will be undoing of Zinah and lot of regrets for united India. If Pakistan Muslims can not accept there east Pakistan Muslims how they will tolerate Hindu neighbours.This is all what I have to say.
Pakistani Punjabi paindoo love Indian Punjabi paindoo.
Zinah 😂..
Why are you calling him zinah.. 😂
You can say a lot more about the folly that killed millions of innocent men, women and children. Humanity was degraded in the sub-continent and have not recovered from it and perhaps it will take lot more longer to realise why we became wildly beast to shed blood of each other. I have seen it all. British were backing Jinnah and Mr. Nehru let it happen. Decisions make or break humanity that was disgraceful.
Syed Muzammil Shah
You are doing a great job. This the need of the time to revisit the history of partition of India, critically and honestly though it seems quite late. But you deserve big credit.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rdnot really. We learned quite a bit more. Your narrow minded uber rightist radicalized mindset won't be able to grasp it unfortunately.
Why you are hiding the real truth that Jinnah was not the only person behind the demand for Pakistan? I am giving you challenge to share the complete list of Muslim League with their designations. Here is a very little gift for you:
Soon after joining the All-India Muslim League in 1945, Hazrat Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat Barelvi toured the NWFP to win support for the Muslim League. On October 1, 1945, Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat organized a historic meeting of the Sunni Ulema Kiram and Mashaikh at Peshawar, which passed resolutions expressing full loyalty with the Muslim League and also expressed complete confidence in Jinnah's leadership. Then he invited the Muslim League leader Mohammad Ali Jinnah to tour the Province which Jinnah did on 24 November 1945. The Pir's vigorous campaign for the Pakistan Movement in the NWFP area contributed significantly to the Muslim League's success in the NWFP referendum held in early part of 1947.
The list of Muslim League will destroy all the manipulation made in history that "Only Jinnah was demanding Pakistan? Molvi were opposing Pakistan? Pakistan was not founded as an Islamic State by Muhammad Ali JInnah?" Just one person has contributed the whole province of KPK to Pakistan. I'm sure you will never do this...
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd I got that it's right that u born there 😂. It's your fate 😂
While it's crucial to convey the truth, it's important to note that throughout this program, there was no mention of the Khaksar Resolutions presented by Jinnah and approved by the All-India Muslim League. Pakistan suffers because of lies, distortions, and concealments. Asking others to tell the truth begins with speaking it ourselves.
Refreshing to see such intellectuals from Jihadi Pakistan. May almighty God protect this rare talent.
The dude is playing al Taqiya
Ur God is Cow and hanuman monkey..how he will protect him!
Never trust a Muslim
@@nightking8490 what is taqiya according to you how's he playing it ???
Andhbhakt lindu
syed muzzamil shah is the only man who talk about truth and reality .i really appreciate ❤good job sir keep it up
"The Pakistan Experience" is the other one !
@@PritamSingh-lv2cd Wo bewkuff hai. Maine uske bhaut podcast dekhe hai.
If you want the absolute truth you can see Pakistani Mulhid as well !
Yeah if hinddus want their truth they would want it but we hate him
@@PritamSingh-lv2cd Bilkul Bilkul👍👍
Thank you for exposing the lies and encouraging people to find less biased sources of history.
THANK YOU JINNAH .... LOVE FROM INDIA ...
Zabardast Out Standing Sir ...
Mashallah ...
Yaqeen Nhi Aa Raha Keh Pakistan Me Aap Jesa Talent Moujod Hai....Shahbash ... Weldon
I am from INDIA 🇮🇳. And a History major.
Syed you explained well but still there is alot that you haven't touched.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd When you study in Madarsa and bring a Arguments which has No relevance to the current discussion, We in India, call them #Madrsashap.
And my Friend you are a Proud #MadarsaShap.
Damn, I am Greatful that Pakistan is not with us. Otherwise, it would have been taken so much of our resources to teach a Jahil Awaam.
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd Madrsashap
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd O ustaad, Ye tunny bhi wohi sub kuch nahi kehta diya Jo ye Librandu video mein keh raha hai Aor Tu Lambi tahreer likh k bta raha hai
@@Talhatahir-wp9rdYeh sab bata kay kya mila .. that miskin wazir e azam of your mulk is out there at KSA with his kashkol … so much for Lahore resolutions …
"It's time to leave
Your past"
"Love your present "
"Look forward to your future "
You can't change where you came from.
"But you can choose where to go from here."
"If you won't let your past die, it won't let you Live"
You seems to an intelligent person. But misleading thoughts will enhance your futures. History remains and it is important the coming generations know truth that has gone in the past. Our children should know what were up to in our life time.
Start speaking and accepting truth.The journey will be easy.Living with lies will keep us groping in the dark.
The Past never dies.. Its always with you. All along.. will forever stay with you..of course we must carry on forward,, but forget Past means forget your Roots. Who wants to suffer from Dementia or Alzheimer.?? Or the Humans will like to forget Jesus, Moses, Rama, Krishna. Mohammed, Hussein, Buddha or even Gandhi or Jinnah. No no you you have to GoOn but History accompanies you to your last Breath.
Exactly i agreed with you.
Muzamil Shah History Distortion Campaign exposed th-cam.com/video/7tRgczGM3is/w-d-xo.html
One of the finest political engineers. Sir, we need you to make tens of videos on indo-pak history. Love respect and endorsement from Lahore.
I am from 🇮🇳.
Curious to know if more people of 🇵🇰 are as enlightened as him and you 🤔 (genuinely asking)
@@Gappasappa unfortunately no due to lack of education and extreme control freak society.
Lot of history books available read them. He is not historian
Why you are hiding the real truth that Jinnah was not the only person behind the demand for Pakistan? I am giving you challenge to share the complete list of Muslim League with their designations. Here is a very little gift for you:
Soon after joining the All-India Muslim League in 1945, Hazrat Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat Barelvi toured the NWFP to win support for the Muslim League. On October 1, 1945, Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat organized a historic meeting of the Sunni Ulema Kiram and Mashaikh at Peshawar, which passed resolutions expressing full loyalty with the Muslim League and also expressed complete confidence in Jinnah's leadership. Then he invited the Muslim League leader Mohammad Ali Jinnah to tour the Province which Jinnah did on 24 November 1945. The Pir's vigorous campaign for the Pakistan Movement in the NWFP area contributed significantly to the Muslim League's success in the NWFP referendum held in early part of 1947.
The list of Muslim League will destroy all the manipulation made in history that "Only Jinnah was demanding Pakistan? Molvi were opposing Pakistan? Pakistan was not founded as an Islamic State by Muhammad Ali JInnah?" Just one person has contributed the whole province of KPK to Pakistan. I'm sure you will never do this...
After 75 years,Now it was right Muslims got their own nation, all Muslims from forced to leave for islamic pakistan.
My grandparents were lucky to escape with their lives islamic pakistan.
They used to hide in graveyards during the day n travelled during the night
Partition was horrific
It's the same story on both sides. Both the countries have suffered equally. It was no less than a catastrophe.
@@meerosman9696muslims not gone to Pakistan
I understand your point and it's appropriate in a way but my point of view is that it was not their land to begin with. Islamists were invaders. They were not native to this land. It was our land. Our nation. We just gave it away.
@@anirudhaj9007we Pakistanis are not non-native to this land and didn’t migrate with the invaders. Many people converted. The overwhelming majority of Pakistans are the native population who have lived in that region for millennia proven by DNA tests.
Sir I am always worried about your safety.. please take care of yourself. You are a big asset not only to Pakistan but also to the entire world because you have the guts to say truth.
Good God always bless you and your family.
I pray goddess Bhavani to be always with you.. and protect you eternally😭👌🙏🙏🙏🙏
Hatered towards non-muslims is the reasons for all lies....
bhai vo nhi samjhenge ...unka cult bohot kattar hai kuch zyada hi strict rules and jo ki vo bina questions kare follow karte hai
Agreed👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Also reason for their failure
Bhugat rhe hai aaj mai prathna krunga jab tak pakistan mein hindu Sukoon se na rhe kisi ko bhi sukoon na mile
I'm indian muslim, trust me some hatred for non-muslims is justified. u don't know how difficult it's to live in such a non-gairat, intolerating & communal country.
Thank you jinnah.. hum Bach gaye 😂
Yeah thanks to jinnah
Baat to shai hai ❤
سب چیزوں کو دیکھا جائے پاکستان کا حصہ بلوچستان نہیں ہیں قائم اعظم کی نظر بلوچستان پر قبضہ کا تھا ، اس لئے سمجھ میں نہیں رہی تھی کیا کیا جائے
💯💯
Balochistan theak wese he Pakistan ka hissa hai jaise deccan bharat ka hissa bana 😊
@@zerogravity4749 👍🏻
🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
We stand with you brother ❤️
سب سے پہلے - ملک کو توڑنے والے شخص کو کیا کہتے ہیں؟ غدار.... غدار۔ ایم اے جناح غدار تھا۔ پاکستان کے نام نہاد قائداعظم کبھی عظیم لیڈر نہیں تھے۔ وہ ایک سادہ آدمی لیکن ہوشیار وکیل تھے۔ جس طرح ہر وکیل ہر مقدمہ جیتنے کی کوشش کرتا ہے، اسی طرح جناح نے ہندوستان کی تقسیم کا مقدمہ پورے عزم اور استقامت کے ساتھ لڑا۔ انہیں کانگریس میں کوئی اہمیت اور حیثیت نہیں ملی، اس لیے اس نے چند بڑے ذمہ داروں کی مدد سے مسلم لیگ کی قیادت سنبھالی اور اپنا ملک توڑا اور غدار بن گئے۔وہ یقینی طور پر ایک باعمل مسلمان نہیں تھا۔ وہ انگریزی بولتا تھا، شراب پیتا تھا اور سور کا گوشت کھاتا تھا۔ وہ بنگلہ دیش کو توڑنے کے اصل مجرم تھے کیونکہ انہوں نے بنگال میں اردو کو نافع بنانے کی کوشش کی حالانکہ وہ خود اردو نہیں جانتے تھے۔ بلوچستان ایک آزاد ریاست تھی۔ اس کی اپنی ثقافت اور اپنی بولی تھی۔ جناح نے وہاں اپنی فوج بھیج کر غیر قانونی طور پر قبضہ کر لیا۔ اس نے قلات کے ساتھ بھی ایسا ہی کیا۔
Very true Muzamil bhai truth is always bitter. Seems good
Honest, intelligent....and passionate... very rare gem!
Love from India ❤. It's good to see that you talked about how Punjab of Pakistan lost its language, culture. I hope people will get more informed and learn more about truth. Thanks brother.
We have not lostt our culture but our culture is Islam
Khoteya naal matha ni maari da. Brainwashed Logan nu samjhaan da koi faayda nai
@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf Your culture is to beg, get humiliated at every stop and change father every decade.
@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf culture can not be imported… Islam is arabic religion and subcontinent muslins are converted one then how come you have different cultures?
That is not true Pakistani Punjabi culture was dominant in India for a long time Indian Punjabi films use to copy Pakistan dialogue and songs.
What has Punjabi culture done for India? India Punjab has big alcohol and chitta problem.
Punjabi culture does not belong to any religion Hindu Punjabis were first in Punjab
they follow Hindi language and Hindi states culture. Shahmukhi language was first in Punjab before Gurmukhi.
Punjabi culture beings nothing good bhangra pao munddeyo te Gidhha pao Kudio nobody wants this dirty culture you can keep it in your home.
found a logical pakistani! you are the gem of Pakistan.
On religious path i listen to Ustad-E-Muthram Engineer Mohammad Ali Mirza & on Political & Historical views i listen to Syed Muzamal Shah! Love you both! Stay blessed. ✌️❤️
You should read both side of stories
Same 🙏🏻🤝
You should listen to everyone and keep an open mind. Engr Ali bhai also has many flawed ideas.
@@Xulfimir enjeneer is doing those things which is not bringng unity his work is bringing hatred
The way you took his name shows your respect oriented arab enslaved devoted mindset.
Not that I don't praise him, he's doing good, but not all good. He takes you out of the stories of babay, and pushes you in the stories baba bukhari baba muslim baba trimzi etc. Were they not a baba? Were those books not written after hundreds of years of the demise of founder of Islam? Have you even read, some of the stories are so absurd, shameful and unexplainable in the sahih hadith. Anyway,
He's just a man. No need to make anyone your spiritual father. You could listen to the better one he calls his mentor directly, Ghamdi.
Hat’s off as usual Mr. Sayed Muzamil sayed. Best one and as usual very informative. Pl keep it up.
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Really appreciate the effort to unravel the truth...... Hopefully, the common man Pakistani realize who the true villain is.
Its extremist hindus.
From Bangladesh. I am pretty amazed about the question that has been raised on sovereign units at 7:30 minute. I did read the Lahore resolution earlier but myself have not noticed the duplicity. Thanks a lot for revealing it for the people.
You Are Great Mujlim I Am Like First Human Pakistani.
Eat some beef you are low on testosterone
Mujlim?
Thanks for bringing all this in the limelight, Syed Bhai!
Saw you a couple of days ago, was too shy to come up to you. Good content.
In which city ?
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd you could have just ignored the video if it bothered you this much. Peace
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd mate if you can't bear the facts then why you came to this video
I can't skip Muzammil Bhai's video?? Because their videos contain complete knowledge. ❤❤❤
Right
@@debrajghosh8446 Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
مزمل اب نیا طارق فتح بننے جارہا ہے اسے بھی ذلالت ہی ملے گی۔😅
@@گونجنیوزٹیوی beshak
I respect you Sir. Why people in Pakistan not informed about this, it’s a shame that Teachers even not telling them truth. Thank you for your good work 🙏
I appreciate. Mr Mujammil's effort to uveal real truth of Indo-Pak history. I fee about It is high time Pakistan Public is informed about the blunders played it.
While it's crucial to convey the truth, it's important to note that throughout this program, there was no mention of the Khaksar Resolutions presented by Jinnah and approved by the All-India Muslim League. Pakistan suffers because of lies, distortions, and concealments. Asking others to tell the truth begins with speaking it ourselves.
Syed, you are doing a great and brave job. In addition to the massive identity crisis that engulfs Pakistan, it also needs to go deeper and confront the massive historical trauma of forceful conversions and its impact on the society’s psyche. Someday it needs to make peace with itself and accept and embrace its original Indic roots.
We feel proud for the revelation of facts...
Partition of India was the biggest tragedy of 20 st century , I even have arguments which suggest that it was bigger tragedy than Second World War . The impact it had and has on people for 75 years after the event . 4 million Hindus , Muslims , sikhs , Buddhist killed . According to recent study India’s GDP growth is best in the world with 8% but it will become 10 or 11 % GDP growth if it stops its spending related to Pakistan, terrorism and on borders . Just imagine how much money both countries spent on each other . Second Pakistan became an Islamic country which means there is no free society , no body is allowed to say whatever they want , whatever they want to wear clothes , whatever they want to do . India is growing just because we have somewhat free society and our goal is to become America where everybody is free . Free society helps to improve societies .
Mutual feelings!
😞🙏🇵🇰
Oh stop crying you can not live with 200 million muslims so how would you live with 800 million plus Muslim
Ye kis me ka diya freedom of speech nahi and clothes wegara ki b freedom nahi😂😂😂
Bro change ur news channels.😂😂
@@itzadi786 Meri Jaan har cheez ki freedom hai.. problem yeh hai k hum log ek dosre k mulk mein aatey jate ni.. wohi suntey dakhtey jante Hein jo humhara media humhein baatata hai. That’s all I can say.. rest you can believe what ever you want brother. Stay blessed.
Syed Muzammil sahib , bahut hi Shaandaar✊✊🙏🙏
Like the way you speak. Nice voice quality. Good to see you enlightening the people of Pakistan with correct history. Also detailed study on topic before you come with any video is the thing to highly appreciate. Need more people like you for brighter future of Pakistan👍🏻👍🏻
We in India are very happy that Jinnah, with the help of the British, made Pakistan! I shudder to think what would our condition be today if you all were with us!! Muzammil, if only the majority of Pakistani people were like you. Unfortunately, they have been brainwashed for 76 years to an extent that it seems irreversible! 🇮🇳
Sir,
Assalamoalikum, you should at least appreciate Syed Muzammil who dare speak the truth. In my opinion, there are very few on Indian side who could speak the truth. You should also note that Ghandhi and Nehru deceived the Muslim Leaders such as Abdul Ghafar Khan and Abul Kalam Azad as they supported AINCongress in its stance against the partition. But in the end Congress signed the partition plan and left the Muslim leaders disappointed. Pakistan Zindabad!
We r quite happy in Pakistan
We r free to eat beef mutton chicken,,,
I love ❤❤❤my Pakistan
I love ❤❤❤my Pakistan
Great job brother.Love from BD.
The Lahore Resolution was the biggest scandal of history.
I feel more Pakistanis should watch this video which is based on hard facts but tragedy is many Indians are watching. Anyways kudos to Muzammil bhai
Because most of the people believe partition was good . We never wanted to live with ugly lindus.
Bro I'm very thankful for person like you please educated Pakistanis citizens with facts and truly analysis so that your country be in the right path. There's no shame for sharing your truth history and culture and politicians should agree with such person like you and whoever are working for the benefit of Pakistanis nation
I'm sorry bro ...but in 20:06 you only said about Punjab partition... clearly you don't have any idea about Bengal partition....the Bengal partition was more bloody, horrible and a major setback for Bengal .... people only talk about the Western part of partition but they ignore the Eastern part where Hindu Bengalis suffered the most and Hindus living in Bangladesh are still suffering
dont judge without knowing. listen to other videos on his channel. he talked about bengal too. but this video is about wrong hx of Pakistan. so he is on point
Huge respect for Syed Muzammil. Pure philosopher
There is NO LESSON for us Pakistanis in history. Knowing about what, why and how Pakistan came into being is not only a fruitless exercise but seems to be counterproductive as well. Pakistan is! We must ALL concentrate on making the best of it.
AGREED. but such ppl will always exist who want to split hair and find sth that would support their narrative or just for the sake of just birthing an argument. the real tragedy is the little percentage of common folk that fall into such traps.
Hasan Nisar "Jo tareekh ko mask karte...........tareekh unko barbad karte ha"..........'making the best of it' seems too little too late now that "it" has failed MISERABLY
@@KingKong-lb3vh So true......their continual denial of truth is so funny and puts a smile on my face that there is no hope for a people that cannot examine the past to correct the future..........😅😅😅.......hahah and I AM NOT EVENHindu..lol
@Mrhola-tz6wc ji bilkul sahih kaha but proper sources se info gain kren, in bhai sahb ka content hmesha confirmation biased hota hai
Excellent clarity in presenting facts. Really an upright n unbiased historical analysis
These things are clearly mentioned in our Pakistan studies book for Class 12 published by National book foundation. It tells that the ambiguity which was caused due to the use of "plural states" was later removed at Madras session of Muslim League in 1941.
Totally impressed from Syed muzamil shah ❤
Much Anticipated Bro 👍👍👍
Great work as usual Mr Syed Muzammil , a youtuber for some an inspiration for many
I request to all Indian plz follow him and appreciate his work.. Because this kind of person to help progress and develop our neighbor country Pakistan ...! Pakistaniyo aise you tubers ko support kro.. Educated person change everything in Pakistan
❤ proud of your intellect and knowledge,l wish lndia also has youths like you who can take the society forward ❤
Great work muzammil bhai 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Muzamil Shah History Distortion Campaign exposed th-cam.com/video/7tRgczGM3is/w-d-xo.html
Syed Muzammil is a precious stone of Pakistan who enlighten to majority of intellectuals across the Indian subcontinental and unfortunately Pakistani's are not values him.
We thanks God that we have independent country Pakistan. Thanks Jinnah we are proud of you
If Jinnah was great then why would he have got his daughter married, in india why not in Pakistan?😂😂 Bro he got u scam
Another jahil😂😂
@@durgeshgupta4394
Okay bro,you can say scam. But Pakistan is a reality now accept this. Leave Jinnah's daughter's matter.
Keep up the good work.
Syed Muzammmil.🎉❤
Allhumdulliah I thank Allah for the beautiful country Pakistan born on the 27th of the holy month of ramadan And InshaAllah better days are not very far “Pakistan zindabad “ Pakistan paindabad”💚
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
bus wait he krain better days ka qiyamat tk
@@hamxa314 🤣🤣👩🦰
Never loose hope ☝️ Allah har cheez per qadir ha jo log umeed choar detay han wo zindagee ma kabhi qamyab nhi hotay
@abdulmateen64afsos tumhe knowledge nhi ki country ki taraqqi liberalism se hoti hai.
Brilliant analysis based on sound understanding of the subject.
Love from 🇮🇳❤
Hate from Pakistan
❤❤
❤🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🌹
It refers to states as provinces and independent, autonomous and sovereign refers to complete freedom from British India. And "should be grouped" refers to grouping different units together.
شکر ہے ہم سچائی کو جاننے کی کوشش کر رہے ہیں
شکریہ مزمل شاہ صاحب
Muzamil Shah History Distortion Campaign exposed th-cam.com/video/7tRgczGM3is/w-d-xo.html
Learning so much through your videos. Respect from India ❤
Partition was correct but incomplete, if partition had not taken place, these illiterate people would have ruined India also. Thanks to Jinnah for partition, who abducted his own friend's minor daughter and married her.
Not would happened at the same level as it happens today.
Logical and fact based ...Syed is amazing.
Muzammal, while narrating history you have also not told the truth but followed the line adopted by Wali khan in his book “Facts are facts “ the events took place as below.
1.Lahore resolution was presented by Fazal Haq on march 23 adopted a day later but day of presentation is taken as day of resolution. It is commonly believed that Sardar Sikandar Hayat drafted the resolution.
2. It envisaged two independent sovereign states consisting of Muslim majority areas in north east and north west of India. Yes no mention of Pakistan was made. It was primarily done to make Muslim league popular in Muslim majority states resulting in victories of league in those states during 1945 elections.
3. In April 1946 the Muslim legislatures from all the states in their convention at Delhi passed another resolution mentioning Lahore resolution and decided that instead of two it will be one state and name Pakistan was used in it. Hussain Shaheed Suharwardi was the driving force to get this resolution passed. Both Lahore resolution mentioning states and Delhi resolution mentioning one state of Pakistan are inscribed in Minar e Pakistan. Wish you had visited Minar e Pakistan and got clarified your doubts.
Intahai Professional Andaz Good Job
Salute to u ..... keep exposing pak studies
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd tell me then ke agar "states" se murad pak aur india tha to phir its not a mistake, jab ye koi galti hai hi nahi and they wanted 2 states then why did change it to "state"
@@areebanaveed9485 Muhammad Ali Jinnah's address to the Lahore conference was, according to Stanley Wolpert, the moment when Jinnah, once a proponent of Hindu-Muslim unity, irrevocably transformed himself for the cause of separate Muslim homeland called Pakistan
There remains a debate on whether the resolution envisaged two sovereign states in the eastern and western parts of British India. Abdul Hashim of the Bengal Muslim League interpreted the text as a demand for two separate countries. In 1946, Prime Minister H. S. Suhrawardy of Bengal, a member of the All India Muslim League, mooted the United Bengal proposal with the support of Muslim and Hindu leaders, as well as the Governor of Bengal.
Although there were and continue to be disagreements on the interpretation of the resolution, it was widely accepted that it called for a separate Muslim state.Opposing opinions focus on the phrase "independent states" claiming this means Muslim majority provinces, i.e. Punjab, Sindh, etc. would be independent of each other. They ignore the phrase "geographically contiguous units." They also rely on the claims of certain Bengali nationalists who did not agree with one state. They accuse their opponents of diverting the "spirit" of the resolution.
The majority of the Muslim League leadership contended that it was intended for not only the separation of India but into only 2 states (Muslim majority and Hindu majority). Therefore, it is indeed a statement calling for independence and one Muslim state. Eventually, the name "Pakistan" was used for the envisioned state.
he is trying to imply that we have somewhat Naive understanding of the resolution and our textbooks are not correctly protraying this. In reality he is just try to push forward his Liberal agenda.
@@areebanaveed9485 The books are filled with distorted & fabricated history. I don't think anyone would waste their time to reverify the things they are taught in pak studies.
Syed sir the way you explain any topic in your video is very informative and interesting. Applauding from India.amazing keep it up. Pakistan need such influential youtuber like you.😊
Pakistan is lucky to have you Muzammil, though Pakistanis realise this fact or not. Wish you best, from India.
Now,Punjab is exacting revenge of its division from other nationalities through brute majority in every sphere,mainly in the military.We are morally and economically bankrupt.
It is a disgraceful abuse of power and a shameful disservice to the pursuit of knowledge and truth. Thanks sayyed Muzamil for revealing it, it's your beauty. More power to you ❤️
I littrly deep think and I found India first and second terrorist first is jinnaha and second is bullshit godse both maybe other religion but same as belong on saitisam
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Look Mr what are the impacts of curriculum scams:
If history is inaccurately written and filled with curriculum scams, it can have several negative impacts:
Misinformation: False historical narratives can lead to widespread misunderstanding of events, people, and cultures, perpetuating biases and stereotypes.
Erosion of Trust: When history is manipulated or distorted for ulterior motives, it undermines trust in educational institutions, historians, and authority figures.
Polarization: Misleading historical accounts can exacerbate societal divisions by promoting particular agendas or ideologies, leading to conflict and discord.
Stifled Learning: Students may be deprived of a comprehensive understanding of the past, hindering their ability to critically analyze and learn from historical events.
Cultural Loss: Distorted histories may marginalize certain communities or downplay their contributions, leading to the erasure of diverse perspectives and experiences. And many things, so he is a good researcher and brave person who dared to say those things openly, I largely appreciate his bravery, undeniable. Moreover I respect your opinion.
@@Talhatahir-wp9rd People like Mr Ijaz Ahmad don't realize that youtubers like Syed are working for Indian govt. Indian govt hire two types of Pakistanis 1) Financially weak 2) Propagandist like Syed. Former are used for assassination programs and later are used for creating pro Indian narratives.
Just see Syed's comment section, full of Hindutva Indians
Its good to know these facts as this is indian history as well. For whatever Ms. Jalal may say about Prof. Ishtiaq I am a big fan of his work
Syed Muzammil is intelligent/ brilliant man who works hard for educating pakistani by showing them truthful evidence, separates emotion from truth, separates lies and propaganda from hidden truth . Pakistan is lucky to have him, i love is dedication , and courage. furthermore he is gifted speaker with good voice-God bless him for his noble cause Dr raj k dhar (USA)
مزمل نیا طارق فتح ہے جو انڈین ویورشپ حاصل کرنے کے لیے انڈین بیانیے کو پرموٹ کررہا ہے باقی اس وقت بی جے پی کا ہندتوا کی نفرت بھی سیاست دیکھ کر مسلمانون کو احساس ہورہا ہے کہ ہندو انتہا پسندی کے ساتھ چلنا سکھ,عیساٸ,مسلم,جین مت,بدھ مت اور کاسٹ سسٹم پر یقین رکھنے والون کا گزر بسر نہین ہوسکتا۔مزمل کی باتون کو سنجیدہ مت لین یہ پاور گیم کا حصہ بن کر صرف انڈین ویورشپ کے چکر مین ہے جو احمعق ہندو سے دے بھی رہے ہین😂
Jinnah was the real culprit!
I'm Punjabi and I'm sad to see such disrespect of Punjabi Language pwn it's own Land, Pakistani Punjabi's feels shame while speaking Punjabi but on the other side of Punjabi's proudly speak their Mother tongue!
And yet punjab takes the most budget and takes the most progress and development 😂😂 URDU FIRST 💟
@@BilquessBibi what does it mean???
Obviously when 13 Million People, more than other 3 provinces people will live in a place, definitely they'll take more budget, and in return they pays the utility bills of all provinces, don't You see that???
Anyhow I was talking about Urdu-ism which's unfair !
@@memyself9959 why unfair??? , are u first Pakistani or Punjabi???? , And secondly Balochistan needs money for development and if we do that , for Pakistan there will be a bright future!!! . Punjab has taken much , now it's time to sacrifice for good!! Without CPEC , RekoDiq and Gwadar , our future is dark
@@BilquessBibi I'm Punjabi first! Because my Genuine identity is Punjab, which is 5K older Civilization, and My Punjab pay the price of Partition, I lost my half of Punjab for this Country, and most importantly, "it doesn't mean if I'm Punjabi, so I can't be a good Pakistani, Obviously a Country should be like where Our Fundaments shouldn't be ignored, Our Culture, Language and Civilization should be guarding by a Country, a country should never be like where People feel shame to their roots, it will not remain longer as it was in Past, because People are getting aware !
Furthermore, If Punjab is taken bigger share from Budget, it doesn't mean the budget shouldn't be disburse unequally with other Provinces!!
Syed muzzamil u r just like meee… critical thinker…love u seriously
Why you are hiding the real truth that Jinnah was not the only person behind the demand for Pakistan? I am giving you challenge to share the complete list of Muslim League with their designations. Here is a very little gift for you:
Soon after joining the All-India Muslim League in 1945, Hazrat Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat Barelvi toured the NWFP to win support for the Muslim League. On October 1, 1945, Peer Amin-ul-Hasanat organized a historic meeting of the Sunni Ulema Kiram and Mashaikh at Peshawar, which passed resolutions expressing full loyalty with the Muslim League and also expressed complete confidence in Jinnah's leadership. Then he invited the Muslim League leader Mohammad Ali Jinnah to tour the Province which Jinnah did on 24 November 1945. The Pir's vigorous campaign for the Pakistan Movement in the NWFP area contributed significantly to the Muslim League's success in the NWFP referendum held in early part of 1947.
The list of Muslim League will destroy all the manipulation made in history that "Only Jinnah was demanding Pakistan? Molvi were opposing Pakistan? Pakistan was not founded as an Islamic State by Muhammad Ali JInnah?" Just one person has contributed the whole province of KPK to Pakistan. I'm sure you will never do this...
Excellent research Muzammil the great
needs courage to talk about these topics, huge respect
No brother Dollars are required
Har bat pr yaqeen krny sy phly check krn K Har bat wo bnda theek b kr rha ya Nahi blindly trust b nuqsan deta Hy Har bat Pak studies ma b theek nhi blky wo to Hy hi jhoot ka palanda but Har bt muzamil shb b logic K sth Ni bta rhy
Excellent history knowledge given by you , every Indian and Pakistani should know facts of our tarikh.
সত্য কথা বলার জন্য অনেক সাহস লাগে। আপনার সেটা আছে। আপনার পরিশ্রম স্বার্থক হোক❤❤❤🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Exellant explanation Muzammil saheb.
Hatts off to you sir
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Pakistan's journey and policies
1947 : Pakistan zindabad
1971 : Bangladesh zindabad
2019 Pakistan se Zinda bhag
2027 : Balochistan zindabad
2035 : ek thaa Pakistan
That's what Pakistan used to say about India
How tables have turned
Pakistan was never our goal our goal was Muslim state and remember Pakistan may be no there but a more powerful Muslim state will be there inshallah perking the 20 crore Indians Muslim
No. Because just because some state is in muslim doesn't mean it has to good. Take arab countries or even turkey and Afghanistan.@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf
Jh2 there war 33 muslim big riyasat at the time of India's independence and still you need another state for muslims? Lol such a lame excuse....
Saalo tak hinduo pe julm Kiya jab Hinduo ko power mil Rahi thi toh tumhari fatt gayi ..isliye bhagne ke baad rehne ke liye Pakistan banaya gaya...@@MuhammadAnas-mo6tf
Tanatani andhbhkt from cow belt jahil hindi state
Syed Muzammilji , Indians are so happy that Jinnah created Pakistan that now Indians will also start celebrating Pakistan Day!
Shah Bhai I'm on a family trip
It is for only you giving you like and view
Lots of love
Btw I'm very close to our border very close.😢😢😢❤
Which side?
Tell me what you learned from this video of this pathetic liberal? that the date was wrong.
The name Pakistan was not used in the resolution and the official name of the resolution was Lahore Resolution. It was the Hindu newspapers including Partap, Bande Matram, Milap, Tribune, etc., who ironically coined the name Pakistan Resolution. However, the idea was appreciated by the Muslim masses and the Resolution is more known as Pakistan Resolution. Secondly, the Government and the people of Pakistan wrongly celebrate March 23 as a national day in Pakistan. The actual day when the resolution was passed was March 24. It was only presented on March 23. Lastly, the word “states” and not “state” was mentioned in the Resolution. It means that the authors of the Resolution were foreseeing two separate states in the north-western and eastern zones of India. But if one has a good look at the developments that followed, he or she would conclude that either the word “states” was included as a mistake or the League leadership soon had a second thought to their idea. A Resolution passed at the 1941 Madras session of the League stated, “Everyone should clearly understand that we are striving for one independent and sovereign Muslim State.” In all the speeches that Quaid delivered, he also used the word “an independent homeland” or “an independent Muslim state
Excellent analysis as you always do , impartial fearless rational journalist 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Punjab and its identity was not devided but broken to peices not only on the base of religion but also on base of ethnicity after partition lahore was devide for muslims then haryana for jat vote , then Himachal for phadhi vote and whats left in india is already khalistan with sikh votes , same people devided by there own bias but ruled by politicians , i sometimes think how politicaly powerful would have been undevided punjab in Indian subcontinent but now its just even ediotic to think about ❤from 🇮🇳
Excellent❤
Don't include Haryana we have different culture and own glorious history even from a past.
@@I_GarvitSingh this whole was Punjab not even haryana Jammu and Kashmir was also included but the problem with us is this sub human mentality he is not jat so not one of us he is not rajput so not one of us ,this sub humman mentality is the reason for this devisions , no culture is continuous without influence of others I can't speak my language without using haryanvi tongue neither you without Punjabi , so this point is complete schizophrenia
جیتے رہیں ❤
Indians born after independence are very much THANKFUL & INDEBTED TO Jinnah.
Only one issue we have to settled is 100% transfer of population.
As and when that happened, we will be luckiest of the planet earth.
Lots of love from Multan... thanks muzammil sir for telling truth..🇵🇰
Love from india❤❤
Mostly your content related to issues makes me realize that GM Sayed was the true intellect!!!
Why was the Lahore Resolution presented in English?
Sir I am currently reading this book on your recommendation & it's quite shattering.
Syed is lighthouse for south asia