Back to Karabakh | ARTE.tv Documentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 เม.ย. 2023
- Two years after the ceasefire between Armenia and Azerbaijan, what is happening in Nagorno-Karabakh? We report on the disputed territory, a militarised zone that is now under Azerbaijan's control, and on the displaced people of Karabakh in Baku.
Back to Karabakh | ARTE.tv Documentary
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel:
/ @artetvdocumentary
🗓 Available until the 05/03/2026
ARTE.tv Documentary is here to tell you more about what’s going on in the world of culture, news and current affairs with powerful, refreshing and entertaining docs subtitled in English for our international fans.
Discover a whole world on #ARTE.tv
#karabakhnow #artetvdocumentary #karabakh
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Swiss Stage DAY 5 // FPX vs TH | FUT vs LEV](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r61uDZTmu44/mqdefault.jpg)
WATCH next: Romania and the War in Ukraine - th-cam.com/video/Ie-OI5sP5n4/w-d-xo.html
@@Leon-tm5tj From a letter sent to the Russian tsar by Alexander Griboyedov, a well-known Russian diplomat and writer:
“Your Majesty, do not allow the resettlement of Armenians in central Russian lands. They are such a tribe that after a few decades they will make a noise to the world that this is the land of our ancestors."
The history of the resettlement of Armenians in the South Caucasus: October 12, 1813 - Russia's victory in the Russo-Qajar war of 1804-1813 and the "Gulustan Treaty" that divided Azerbaijan divided the resettlement of Armenians in Northern Azerbaijan.
According to the data of 1823, only 1.5 thousand out of about 20 thousand families of Karabakh region were Armenian families.
1826-1828 - After the capture of Irevan during the Russo-Qajar war, the Armenian Catholicos Nerses Ashtaraketsi prepared a project on the resettlement of Armenians to Azerbaijan. AS Griboyedov also played a major role in the development and implementation of this plan.
February 10, 1828 - In accordance with Article XV of the Turkmenchay Treaty concluded at the end of the Russo-Qajar war in 1826-28, Armenians were resettled from Iran to Irevan, Karabakh and Nakhchivan.
March 21, 1828 - Immediately after the Treaty of Turkmenchay, the Russian Emperor Nicholas I issued a decree on March 21, 1828, declaring the establishment of an "Armenian province" in the territory of the Irevan and Nakhchivan khanates. The city of Irevan, where 7331 Azerbaijani and 2369 Armenian families lived at that time, was also included in the province.
1828-1829 - According to historical sources, 40,000 Armenians were deported to the Caucasus from Iran and 90,000 from Turkey in 1829-1830, and they were mainly settled in Nakhchivan, Karabakh and Irevan. At the same time, during the long war, hundreds of Azerbaijani settlements were destroyed, thousands of people were killed, and people had to leave their native lands.
In 1832, Azerbaijanis made up 64.8% of the population of Karabakh, and Armenians 34.8%.
In the 1980s, Azerbaijanis made up 41.5% and Armenians 58.2% of the national population in Shusha district. According to the 1897 census in Russia, these figures were 45 and 53%, and in 1917 they were 40.2 and 52.3%. At that time, in terms of the number of Azerbaijanis living in the Caucasus, Iravan province was the third after Baku and Yelizavetpol (Ganja) provinces.
1897 - According to the results of the first census conducted in the Russian Empire, 313,178 Azerbaijanis lived in the Irevan province.
1905-1907 - Taking advantage of the revolutionary processes in Russia and the weakening of the center's control over the provinces in 1905-1907, Armenians committed massacres and looting against Azerbaijanis in Baku, Zangazur, Irevan, Nakhchivan, Ordubad, Echmiadzin, Javanshir and Gazakh, and expelled them from their homes. they lowered. In 1905-1906, Armenians destroyed 200 villages in Ganja and Gazakh provinces, and 75 villages in Shusha, Jabrayil and Zangazur provinces.
1916 - According to the statistics of 1916, the population in 5 districts of Iravan province increased 40 times compared to 1831, ie from 14300 to 570,000. However, during that period, the number of Azerbaijanis increased only 4.6 times and amounted to 246,600 people. While the absolute population growth in 1886-1897 was 40,000, in 1905-1916 it was 17,000, whereas in 1905 the population was 61,000 more than in 1886.
When the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region was formed in 1923, historical injustice was committed, the mountainous and lowland parts of Karabakh were artificially separated, favorable conditions were created for the consolidation of the Armenian population, and the demographic position of Azerbaijanis was severely damaged.
1946-1947 - Immediately after the end of the war of 1941-1945, the resettlement of Armenians from abroad began in Armenia. In 1946, 50,900 Armenians were deported to Armenia from Syria, Greece, Lebanon, Iran, Bulgaria and Romania, and in 1947, 35,400 Armenians from Palestine, Syria, France, the United States, Greece, Egypt, Iraq and Lebanon.
1948 - In 1948, a total of 10,000 Armenians were deported to Armenia from Syria, Lebanon, France, the United States, Egypt, Bulgaria and Romania.
1978 - Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians celebrated the 150th anniversary of their resettlement in 1978, and on this occasion they erected a special monument in the village of Maragashen-Leninavan, Mardakert-Agdara region.
@@Leon-tm5tj The most ridiculous thing that even armenia itself doesn't recognize nonexistent artsakh as their territory. That's why they created a separated republic and are still crying for its recognition in the world, while it is recognized worldwide as Karabakh, the territory of Azerbaijan.
@@Leon-tm5tj I completely agree; and, you're right, the so-called "documentary" is either a sell out, or blatant propaganda. If this is truly stupid research, then this channel can be condemned as incompetent.
Hey ARTE, I hope that the Muslims in YOUR country establish Sharia Law and subject you to it. Just like they did with the Armenians in Arcakh.
Is not a war, is an aaggression! The west should be ashamed of making this documentary openly supporting propaganda of a fascist dictatorship, they are making ethinc cleansing supported by their cousins of Israel doing the same thing in palestine, andtheir cousins of Turkey doing the same with Kurdistan. It's ubelivable how this video is actually mystified and biased, the region is inhabited by armenians since really ancient times and you can find may archeological evidences of that wich now being destroied for cultural cleansing porpuses (in fact, it is not a nationalist thing to say that we armenians like other peoples inhabited the area much long before than turk people who got there ), when armenians fight for karabagh they are fighting for what is culturally and historically theirs is , while azerbaijan war is a colonializer war is war of conquer . This is sooo bad, Europe filling his mouth of words such democracy, justice and then openly supports propaganda of a dictator. This documentary is just the result of gas sales, i hope people would read this comment and have a more rational critic view on the situation. In the war Azerbaijan used isis mercenaries, used phosorus gas, breaked a million humanitarian rights, Where was ARTE.tv at that Time? The president of azerbaijan Aliyes is the son of the last president that established in 1993, they are ruled by a dinasty like in medieval time, there is a de facto dictatorship! So? Is this bad only if Putin makes it? Azerbaijan is, in liberal terms as westerns like, mining the right to self determination of armenian people. I can only hope that this corrupt jounalists (because journalism is about describing the truth not making propaganda) will feel at least a little bit ashamed, shame because you choose to look on the other side, shame beacuse you took the easy way of making your job. Azad artsakh! Hura Filestin! Biji kurdistan! Freedom for all oppressed peoples, only with the unity of our struggle we shall win✌
KAZAKHSTAN STANDS FOR AZERBAIJAN
TÜRKİYE with you Brother.
Thank you, Brothers!!!
Yaşasın Qazaxıstan Azərbaycan qardaşlığı 🇦🇿🇰🇿
🇹🇷🤝🇦🇿🤝🇰🇿🤝🇺🇿🤝🇹🇲🤝🇰🇬
Azerbaijan stands for the greater Iran !!!
In my opinion, this documentary doesnt mention the Armenian side of the story. The Republic of Artsakh isnt mentioned once if I listened correctly. Sure Azerbaijan suffered. But so did Armenia. No human being wants war.
Nearly all documentary’s presented only Armenians. And Azeris were mainly the victims in the first war. I like to see their perspective. It’s only fair.
You are right. This video is just azerbaijan lying propaganda.
On youtube there’s nothing but the point of view of the Armenians. The massacres they committed are disguised. Watch what comes out in Karabag when they unearth the mass Azerbaycani graves. The world will see the true face of Armenians in Karabag.
@@minatek1945 Armenia just took back what was given by ussr for the ussr. The have 0 heritage from there even if they build in stolen land it never made it theirs. Sorry they just have not to moved to a stolen land. If it was Armenia that had the Oil, no body would care for Azeries. World worship Ammon and will all be judged for that in the end. The civilians are all mainly innocent, i blame only the greedy goverments and other greedy man that uses them as pions. Armenia is probably the oldest nation of man, so their claims are valid facts. It the Armenia genocide reviving
@@minatek1945I didn't say I didn't like it. I am a Christian and therefor peace should reign. But the current situation is not a solution to the problem. Nagorno-Karabakh should be autonomous in Azerbaijan.
As an Azerbaijani, I grew up with this war. My childhood memories are refugees everywhere, poverty and nightmares that Armenians can occupy our lands. I am in my 30s, and people are still dying in Karabakh. And I want it to end. We need to recognize each other's borders, try to start being neighbors, get to know each other. Because none of us will leave here. We have lived here for generations and will continue to live. We need to become a civilized, prosperous region, and not kill each other.
i agree to all what you saied Armania should not treat Azeries that way but after Azeries victory now i am afried that you will do the same to Armenians
Just make it like Germany and France. Found your own EU (of course with an other name) together with Armenia, Turkey and Georgia, Kazakhstan and so on and stop fighting each other.
The EU stopped the multiple wars between France and Germany and also between Ireland and England...
@@kyorkdabbagh7759 Well all evidence points to the fact the Azeris aren't behaving like Armenians.
When the Armenians invaded and occupied this region they savagely ethnically cleansed 800,000 civilians.
When the Azeris took this place back only a few dozen civilians died.
Big difference
@@williamdavis9562 tf you mean by 800,000 died, they were displaced
@@Jokerlolpopkagamings I said ethnically cleansed.
Look up what it means.
I was born in this war, I was displaced from the house where I was born, I lived in tents and wooden huts for 30 years, the culprits of my lost childhood and youth were Armenians.
I can't stop feeling how the Nagornokarabakh conflict and the Palestine conflict are similar in so many ways, but the first one is so less known at the same time...
Nor any more, Armenians are gone thanks God, Armenians never owns Karabagh is Azerbaijan
@@sammynyc7921cavemen with flip flops are a force to reckon with
No there not look up the war between Armenia and Georgia over a city called Tblisi they tried doing the same thing claiming they had the majority of Armenians there so what it’s still not there city and they lost that war.
Azerbaijan: my experience is that it is the only country to demand black money to be paid to enter the country on top of official visa charges. Whilst I don't wish to generalise, if they are corrupt in a foreign consulate (Tbilisi), I'm not interested in going there at all.
I really felt sad for the soldier that said he regret he was not martyred and survived...after the wounds.....he feels unlucky that his comrades were lucky to get martyred for the country....its very difficult for us all to understand his state of mind.... only brothers in arms can feel and understand that...
As you may already know, the highest stage of submission in Islam is died as a martyr. Moslems believe that martyrs directly ascended to heaven.
Yes its sad how soldiers are convinced to kill each other for imaginary lines of land called boarders. We are all children of Earth
Funny how the soldiers wear patches with turkish flag and how many turkish flags there were at the military cemetery. Could give us a hint what this is all actually about
So what? it's still their land...
Bcoz there is no Azeri there is only Turk..Azeri word created by Russian government to part them from us..
This is because in the last 10 years Azeri soldiers have been trained in Turkey according to NATO standards and they are allies (this is a normal procedure within NATO troops). While Armenia is a Russian military ally.
That's because that Turkey send former Islamic State soldiers to Azerbaijan to aid them in their fight against the Armenians
Tell that to the Armenians who were proudly saying before 2020 that there's no distinction between a Turk and an Azeri in the everyday Armenian language. When they won the first war, they were praising themselves for defeating "Turks". Now, all of a sudden, a Turkish flag in the hands of an Azeri is an uncomfortable sight.
If you combine the last documentary made by Arte on the the topic (which was one-sided pro- Armenian) with this one (which is pro-Azerbaijan) you have a slim chance of getting a balanced journalistic perspective on the topic.
There doesn't seem to be much bias. It's mostly just interviews with people in the region. From my understanding; Armenia invaded in 1988, kicked out all the Azeri's from their internationally recognized territory, Azerbaijan took what is recognized to be theirs in 2020 and is just rebuilding/letting people return to their homes.
there is no pro armenian it is only armenian lies. They killed innocent people, they did holocaust!
@@Adam-pl6vq Azerbaijan started the war
@@Adam-pl6vq you better dig deeper, Armenia did not occupy that area. Armenians have lived there for a long time and the region had a special status under the Soviets.
@@dzurfluh2156 Yes, Armenia occupied this territory which is an internationally recognized part of Azerbaijan and no one denies Armenians population of NK who can continue to live there if they want to.
From a third party perspective, I think the biggest driver of the conflict is hatred between the two ethnic groups. It seems to me though that historically and ethnically, Karabakh is Armenian. Since I have substantial reason to suspect the maltreatment of Armenians by Azerbajianis should they live under Azerbajians rule, I understand why Armenians keep rebelling.
Yes, Armenians don't want to live in the Armenophobic corrupt dictatorship, which explicitly hates Armenians, destroys our cultural heritage (like cemetery in Julfa) and denies Armenian Genocide. Could you imagine if, for example, Ukraine while trying to bring back Crimea was full of government-driven anti-Crimean Tatar rhetoric? Azerbaijan manages to be aggressively anti-Armenian and not have the fate that Serbia has with Kosovo
Thank you for a very objective view. It agree with your assessment of the situation. The Azerbaijani Gov. has (very unfortunately) failed to prove it can provide save living standards for Armenians within its borders. Therefore there are only two solution I can see, one being pro Armenia and the other Pro Azerbaijan:
1. NK and a small corridor get assimilated into Armenia and refugees from both countries can return to their homes and are guaranteed safety from both sides.
2. NK gets assimilated into Azerbaijan, including all Armenians living in it, and refugees from both countries can return to their homes and are guaranteed safety from both sides.
Right now Armenia is willing to go with the later, but Baku is 'reluctant' when it comes to safety guarantees for the Armenians. So there's that....
@@davidweber7153
Yeah, both countries and people are largely still stuck in a phase in which statehood is exclusively bound to ethnicity.
This inevitably leads to ethnic cleansing should territories change hands/be disputed.
See Germany and Poland as an example.
Look at the history of Nakhichevan, how everything connected with the Armenians was destroyed
You really didn’t watched the documentary huh ? It’s now mainly Armenians because all Azeris got ethnically cleansed 30 years ago. You clearly Armenian .
I cannot comment on the rights and wrongs, but one thing I know for certain; once you let the Russians in, it takes a couple of generations to get them to leave.
Ukrainians know a thing or two about getting rid of them, give them a call.
There is nothing else to do. The only ally for Armenia is Russia. No one else supports their fight against the Azerbaijan.
The UN don't want to interfere in this conflict.
@@Meortn sorry, but why Armenia fights with Azerbaijan?
@@anarabbasov8634 Cuz Azerbaijan wants to make ethnic cleansing of indegenes Armenian population.
@@anarabbasov8634 because of the dispute over Nagorno-Karabakh?
But since they can't agree with each other, perhaps should some major powers interfere and come up with an solution
One sided documentary, Artsakh is Armenia
Karabaģ Azarbaycanindir Biz Türkler olarak Sonuna kadar Kardeşlerimizin yanındayiz O yüzden Turan Birliģi boşuna kurmadik
I'm not Armenian or azeri but the Armenians lived in the south Caucasus for thousands of years before the nomadic turks arrived
You are armenian
Armenians moved to Karabakh in 1825 from Maraga, Persia after Turkmanchay Treaty
Almost 3 milion people in Azerbaijan ethnic caucasian people like avar, udi, talish lezgi not all of Azerbaijan oguz Turks
so?? with your logic, let's return USA, Canada, Australia etc to aborigines then
@@javidbilalov4182 the logic is you respect and give the native population special rights.
Like civilized countries do.
Finally not a pro-armnenian and one sided documentary. You should always give perspectives from both sides and ask what about the lives on almost 1 Million internally displaced Azeris after the Armenian occupation
An indeed high quality depictition of the conflict. Kudos to the team.
It seems likena very one-sided coverage of the conflict to me. Not one Armenian was interviewed
@@amoreazione3563 they had a full documentqry covering the story mostly from armenian perspective
How much oil dollars Arte got for this crap?
👏Teşekkürler.Çok güzel bir belgesel..
Allah bless you my brothers and sisters in azerbaijan love from pakistan 🇵🇰
This objective report deserves big like and subscription. Thank you!
Karabakh is Azerbaijan 🇦🇿 Long Live Azerbaijan 🇦🇿
Kosovo vs Serbia: 70% kosovars banish ~20-30% serbs from Kosovo.
UN, US, EU etc.: Kosovo is albanian KOSOVO, not Serbia!
Armenia vs Azerbaijan: 70% armenians banish ~20-30% azers from Karabakh.
UN, US, EU etc.: Karabakh is always was Azerbaijan!!
Big Love from Motherland Turkey to Fatherland Azerbaijan. We are 1 nation, 2 States 🇦🇿🇹🇷☝️
@steventaylor3104 Bye Bye Natanyahu (Bibi)
@@MrNogebator Stay with in the topic anyways Kosovo is a region of Serbia it Serbian territory..
@Steven Taylor wait till you get disappointed ☹️😅
The third volume of the Armenian Soviet Encyclopedia (p. 571) contains a list of those who ruled Irevan from the end of the 14th century to 1828. Is there at least one Armenian among them?
1. Emir Saad (end of the XIV century - 1410);
2. Pir Huseyn (son of Emir Saad), Pir Gaib (son of Pir Hussein) - (1410-1420);
3. Abdul (son of Pir Hussein) (1430);
4. Yagub bey (1440);
5. Hasan Ali Qaragoyunlu (1460);
6. Div Sultan Rumlu (1515);
7. Huseynjansultan Rumlu (1550);
8. Shahgulusultan Rumlu (1550-1575);
9. Muhammad khan Tohmah Ustajli (1576-1583)
10. Hydyr Pasha (1583);
11. Muhammad Sharif Pasha (1604);
12. Amir-Guna khan Qajar (1605-1625);
13. Tohmaz Gulu khan Qajar (1625-1635);
14. Kelbeli Khan (1636-1639);
15. Jaghatay Kyotuk Muhammad Khan (1639-1648);
16. Keyhosrov khan (1648-1652);
17. Muhammad Khan (1652-1656);
18. Najafgulu Khan (1656-1663);
19. Abbasgulu khan Gajar 1663-1666);
20. Sefigulu khan (1666-1674);
21.Sarkhan bey (1674-1675);
22.Sefigulu khan (1675-1679);
23. Hall of the khan (1679-1688);
24. Murtuzagulu khan (1688-1691);
25. Muhammadgulu khan (1691-1694);
26. Farzali khan Qajar (1694-1700);
27. Zohrab khan (1700-1705);
28. Abdul Muhammad Khan (1705-1709);
29. Mehrali Khan (1709-1719);
30. Allahgulu Khan (1719-1725);
31. Rajab Pasha (1725-1728);
32. Ibrahim Pasha and Mustafa Pasha (1728-1734);
33. Ali Pasha Defterdar (1734);
34. Muhammadgulu khan (1735-1736);
35. Haji Huseyn Pasha (1735)
36. Pirmehmet Khan (1736);
37. Khalil Khan Uzbek (1752-1755);
38. Hasanali khan Qajar (1755-1762);
39. Huseynali khan Qajar (1762-1783);
40. Gulamali khan Qajar (1783-1784);
41. Muhammad khan Qajar (1784-1805);
42. Mehtigulu khan Qajar (1805-1806);
43. Ahmed khan Maragaly (1806-1807);
44. Huseyn khan Qajar (1807-1827).
And what should that mean? Why won't you tell about forced deportation of Armenians from eastern Armenia by shah Abbas, which depopulated our land from Armenians and who populated it with Turks? And if, for example, the Russians appointed Russian governors of the conquered regions, then Russia has the right to Ukraine, Finland, Azerbaijan, etc.? Azerbaijanis have the same imperial consciousness as Russians. You live in the midst of garbage (having a huge oil resources), a huge part of your taxes is spent on the Azerbaijani laundromat and the pastime of the Aliyev family, but dream of seizing foreign lands.
@@SD-zl4uo Azerbaijan is not a developed country, but at least its economy is more than twice higher than armenia's. Unemployment rate in gaymenia is higher than in Azerbaijan. Out of 12 million of armenians in the world, only 3 million are living in armenia. Your country is just a $#|thole, nothing more.
Selam nga rk kosova nga evropa.un jam gezua per ju qe kebi mar karabahin,Por azerbegjani nuk na njef ne pavarsin ende
Dhe vatikani nuk te njeh si shtet. Israeli tani ne fund te njohu si shtet.
Fatkeqesisht kosova nuk esht shtet i pavarur,per ate shumica e vendeve nuk e njohin.
Artsakh is much like Kosovo. By congratulating Azerbaijan you only delegitimize Kosovo and welcome your reincorporation into Serbia. Shame on you!
@@kristaporkhach
Its not same, for many option.
1, kosovo was never part of serbia but after WW.1 things are coming differently.
2. Russia make Serbian big, with Bulgarian together. So Russia its and was from start this who push Armenia in this case, like serbian too.
3. Armenian have lies without end about their Story and politic. Have u forget last war, Armenia say no Armenia soldiers are dying. Even if Russia give them everything in 1992 and in 2020.
So take care and make a comment here not without sense.
@@elvisshahu6603 Google is free, use it Elvis, don’t be a dumbass.
@@elvisshahu6603 I dont have an intention to argue too much with non-educated albanians but i dont want to let you speaking lies neither, your number 1 is one big lie, because serbian orthodox monasteries from 12th century is enough valid argument to shut your mouth up, because your claims that Kosovo was never part of Serbia is bullshit. Its really funny to see how Albanians from Kosovo support for example Ukraine, or Azerbaijan in their fight to return their territories from separatist terrorist groups, while they themselves are separatists, they are just USA's project, their gum stuck to their boots. Greetings, and i recommend to educate if you even have education system on Kosovo, or worse, in Albania, one of the most undeveloped and poorest countries in Europe
There is no "Nagora" front of Karabakh!
"Nagorno" is a Russian word means " the mountainy" which has nothing with the identity or history of the region to do!😏🇦🇿🔥🇹🇷💐 The name of city Khankandi, is changed by russian to "spakaranet" which is not legally! Xankəndi or "Khankandi" has been name of the town before Russian occupation of Azərbaijan!
As a Turk it's amazing that how many of the Azerbaijani soldiers got Turkish patches and Insignia on them, no wonder Armenians were saying they were also fighting with Turkey
Anatolian Turks and Azeri Turks are Turks. Two dictatorial genocide machines, that Turkify indigenous peoples of Western Asia, killing and suppressing peoples that oppose Turkification from mankurts that have little to no blood of real Turkic people of the Eurasian Steppe
The name of our country is officially "Türkiye" since June 2022.
@@SD-zl4uo cope and seethe
@@bledakaan u must be real fun at parties
Before that the Azerbaijani soldiers had to fight with Russia aswell to defend their own country. So what ?
Can Azerbaycan. Vatan toprakları sonsuza kadar özgür oldu. Tüm Azerbaycan ordusunu tebrik ediyorum. Türkiyeden selamlar.
…says a Turk who is from a state that has the Armenian Genocide in its conscience. The war will not end here, it will only take some time before Armenia counterattacks.
@@wovaapelisays a Armenian piç 🐗 we will see what gone happen
You talk so big butt the hole world knows that Armenia en all the Armenians are now 😥😭
Fuck hayastan , mamat qunem hayastan
Like you said this war is not ended , you will see Azerbaijan wil come and take Yerevan🇦🇿🇹🇷
Propaganda bot
I saw what NK looks alike when 2020 war ended, its almost same like when 90' s war ended at that time. Basically there is no development at all. But when i saw this, its seemed in 2 years did more buildings than 30 years of Armenian did
Alhamdulillah, Allahu akbar,! And finally the land of Nagorno Karabakh has returned to its rightful owner Azerbaijan, the territory and land recognized by the UN and the international community, the territory of Azerbaijan has returned completely!
What is the common denominator?
Religion of peace? Or death cult? you tell me!
Nigeria: Muslims vs Christians
India: Muslims vs Hindus
Sri Lanka: Muslims vs Buddhists
Israel: Muslims vs Jews
Philippines: Muslims vs Catholics
Turkey/Armenia: Muslims vs Christians
Nagorno-Karabakh: Muslims vs Christians
Iraq: Muslims vs Kurd Sunni Muslims
Iran: Muslims vs Bahai
Syria: Muslims vs Yezidi
Myanmar: Muslim vs Buddhist
@@MM-bt8ke What is your basis for asking me that?? I just say something that means giving thanks and thanking my god and praising the greatness of my god, just like you say hallelujah if you are a Christian! It looks like you are an Islamophobeic...
When Armenia was in war nobody cares
A war that Armenia itself has started in the very beginning and rejected every single peace proposal that could even slightly be in their favor.
@@kgn0k when Turks negotiate, it's not something that anyone can really accept as solution. When the USSR collapsed, the Azeri's began ethic cleasing in, Sumgait, Kirovabad and BAKU. Armenians had no choice but to fight for territorial integrity.
Armenia did not purpose expansionist policy as the war ended along Artsakh borders. They could have eaisly gone all the way to BAKU to depose the Azeri war families.
KARABACH AZERBAIJAN FROM SANDZAKBOSNA ESSELAMU ALEJKUM KARDESLER 🐺☪️📿🖤💚🤍🇧🇦🇨🇨⚜️☝️🤝🤝🤝🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷
Turcine uskoro ces i ti kuci.
Aleykum Salam Qardaş 🇦🇿❤🇧🇦
@@samirabdullayev6647 Karabakh is armenia
Karabag je AZERBEJDŽAN . Greathing From Montenegro.
Lots of love 💕 to Azerbaijani 🇦🇿 people from Buffalo New York USA 🇺🇸. I watched the wars in 1994 and 2020 and my heart was in pain for the Azerbaijani people . Allah gave back the land. Let us all live together peacefully in this world . Love ❤️ from USA 🇺🇸
You’re not even American- you’re a mus-lim! 🤦♂️
Teşekürler🇦🇿❤🇺🇸
Amma bize ermenilerin soyqırım törediyine heç bir dövlet inamır. Ermeniler xirisdiyan olduqları üçün, bütün dünya onların yalanına inanır.Kaş her kes sizin kimi heqiqetleri göre bilseydi. Bize edilen zülümleri görüb, inana bilseydi.😔😔
what does that woman mean ? They were not the real owners ? We Armenians Builded Stepanakert go look for yourself how it looks like. They destroyed our churches and they demolished everything ... how can they talk about Barbarians..
You got a taste of what what you started in the 90s now suck it up Azerbaijan won
Go and see what Armenia committed in Aghdam, Fizuli, Jebrayil, Zangilan and so on. Conscience is the good thing if you have it.
QANDON QARABAG SiZiN OLMAYIB GEDiN SiKTiRiN🐷🇦🇲😡
Karabağlıların türkçesi bize daha yakın. Bakülüleri bazen anlamıyorum ama Karabağlıları daha iyi anladım.
The military aggression of Armenia and Russia led to the occupation of 17,000 square kilometers of the most fertile lands of the Republic of Azerbaijan, 900 settlements, 150,000 houses, 7,000 public buildings, 693 schools, 855 kindergartens, 695 medical institutions, 927 libraries, 44 temples, 9 mosques, and 473 mosques. of historical monuments, palaces and museums, 40,000 museum exhibits, 6,000 industrial and agricultural enterprises, 2,670 km of highways, 160 bridges, 2,300 km of water communications, 2,000 km of gas communications, 15,000 km of power lines, 280,000 ha of forests, 1,000 000 ha of agricultural lands and 1,200 km of irrigation systems were destroyed.
I am sure the Azaris will rebuild it, what the armenians did was disgrace and they always cry wolf about what they call "the turkish genocide" while they are the ones who did genocide to the Azari people. Respect for the people of Azarbaijan.🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿
The only aggression was the anti-Soviet seperatism and nationalism of both Armenia and Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan and Armenia lived in peace as long as they were part of one country. What destroyed this unity was their nationalism and seperatism of being seperate entities.
@@tuulo-cw9bn You are way too uneducated to have a valid opinion on this. Calling what the Armenians did a Genocide shows how grossly challenged your mind has to be. Do yourself a favor and don't use words that are too big for you. Stay with the small stuff, small stuff.
@@revolter7094 Wrong. What destroyed it was the day Azerbaijani Civilians decided "hey its a good day to go around the neighborhood and start killing all the armenians we see". Believe it or not, but that shit can ruins friendships.
@@tuulo-cw9bn
1911, mate
Since the territory is internationally recognised as Azerbaijans Azerbaijan has every right to defend itself against seperatism like spain and serbia
What about the other side? there isn’t opinion from the Armenian side to figure out the full picture. And why don’t you tell about that, how Karabakh was given to Azerbaijan as a gift by one dictator.
As an Armenian, I grew up with this war. My childhood memories are refugees everywhere, poverty and nightmares that Azerbaijanese can occupy our lands. I am in my 30s, and people are still dying in Karabakh. And I want it to end. We need to recognize each other's borders, try to start being neighbors, get to know each other. Because none of us will leave here. We have lived here for generations and will continue to live. We need to become a civilized, prosperous region, and not kill each other.
A breath of fresh air hearing someone with reason. Thank you
😂😂😂
To be honest the best option for the region would be something like Northern Ireland....
It is demonstrably true that Azerbaijan is not occupying your "lands."
In fact it is also demonstrably true that Armenia illegally invaded their neighbor and occupied their internationally recognized territory for well over 30 years. Not to mention the ethnic cleansing of 800,000 civilians that it still hasn't apologized or paid reparations for.
So you're right, borders do need to be respected.
You need to allow the corridor between Turkey and Azerbaijan. Recognize Karabakh as Azerbaijan and then there will be peace.
Karabakh shall remain within Azerbaijan insyaallah...Salam from Malaysia.
No such country as Azerbaijan
God is not willing
Azerbaijan is a territory of Iran former republic of USSR !!
Azerbaijan must return to motherland iran and leave occupied Artsakh 🇮🇷❤️🇦🇲
@@mossadagent9582 god is not willing were is god ???
Gotta love the irony of the descendants of Timur the Lame and other invaders from the Turkic homeland of Central Asia referring to others as barbarians and ransackers smh
Armenia will stand!!!
Always had and always will. Armenia is over 6500 BC 🇦🇲❤️🙏
Indeed Armenia will always stand between Turkey and Azerbaijan 🇹🇷🇦🇿
They can stand all they want, they just can't stand on the graves of civilians they've ethnically cleansed while illegally invading and occupying another nation's internationally recognized territory.
@@jasonz9074 😏
@@Ala351 😂😂😂😂🍆
Karabakh is Armenia!!
armenia is West Azerbaijan.
@@irreligiousman3395 ahahahahhahahahahaha bro you read to much scince fiction, or really the situation in historic studies in Azerbijan is going out of hand, what's next...You wanna claim and alphabet?... or I don't know...maybe the begging of civilazed world was in Azerbaijan😂?
Türkiye'den can Azerbaycan'a selamlar, saygılar ve sevgiler. Ebediyen sizinleyiz kardeşlerim ❤ 🇦🇿🇹🇷
Selam, Can Turkiye ! Tesekkurler! Bir millet, iki Devlet : Azerbaycan-Turkiye ! 🇦🇿🇹🇷❤💪🤘👍 Sevincimiz bir,derdimiz bir.Iyi gunde,kotu gunde hep beraber !❤
Shahumyan, karabakh, gandzak naxichevan is Armenian land.
@@PharmacyAveXUY🐷🇦🇲😡
Just declare the current de facto border between Azerbaijan and Armenia as permanent and both should normalize their relations with each other and allow freedom of trade and movement
OMG thank you ohh great person its clear that you are a genius and all of the peoples and countries involved are stupid.Why tf should Azerbaijan give up its internationally recognized (even by Armenia btw) territorry, ffs your comment is so dumb that it hurts my eyes
really? When Azerbaijan proposed negotiations and offers during 30 years between 1st and 2nd karabakh war, none of the western countries had this attitude of “let’s solve issue and establish peace”, now that azeris have gotten advantage over Armenia and move forward towards its goals you guys are become peaceful pro human rights activists. Hypocrisy at the best.
lmao reality doesn't work like that and the war for the Armenians will get much much worse economically in the long run, remember they were the invaders so Azairbaijan will take every inch back
@@musayebquadry7481 who was invaders??? Your country azerbaijan isn’t even older than Coca Cola. But Armenia is over 6500 BC. Do u truly think there was no Artsakh before the 90’s??? Is your mind brainwashed? Google the first church ever completed in Artsakh. It was completed in 1238 called Gandzasar meaning treasure mountain in Armenian and it clearly says ARMENIAN CHURCH, not Azerbaijani or Albanian. ARMENIAN. There was an Armenia in 1238, but no such country called Azerbaijan. Artskah is Armenia and Azerbaijan belongs to Iran. Those are all Armenian lands and u are invaders and occupiers
Armenia at this rate will be reabsorbed by the former Soviet Union
it’s funny, Azerbaijanis play victims now. bunch of immigrants moved to karabak during soviet and called there home when Armenians lived there more than thousand years.
So? is living on the land for billion years give you right to displace 700 000 people ?
karma is bitch isn't it )
It is vice versa. Your ability to twist and turn facts is astonishing
@@helgapotaky5011 is it vice versa? tell me what i don’t know with fact? I just didn’t randomly comment that. it doesn’t take long to find out the truth.
❤️🙏
@@rojetar8304you don't know how to live in peace and co-exist with others, you don't know how to build a successful state, you don't know that all nations of the world have history and roots and none is any special
In 1996, when I was a 9 year boy, one of my teachers gave me a book which had the list of places/regions suffering from occupation. NK was one of them. I felt empathized with our Azeri brotherly people. The 2020 liberation of NK was a great sigh of relief for many Bangladeshis as their coreligionists around the world.
Love from Bangladesh ❤❤❤❤❤
Do you have water in your country 😂
Do you have canals in your country?
Thank you, bro! Love and peace to the people of Bangladesh!
If Artsakh is Azerbaijan, so Bangladesh is Pakistan
Dear brainwashed person, you started Baku Sumgait pogroms don’t forget
This documentary is one-sided. Where is the Armenian story?
You mean the story of when they invaded their neighbor's territory and ethnically cleansed 800,000 civilians?
That story?
What story how they occupied neighboring country for 26 years with help of Russia, Iran and diaspora
@@seljuk6423 Azeri Turks occupied Artsah, and parts of Talyshistan and Lezgistan with the help of russians. And like Russia, which sends ethnic minorities to die in Ukraine, Azerbaijan sends Talysh and Lezgins to die for seizing ethnically and historically Armenian land, so that in Talyshistan and Lezgistan Baku will deny them their rights and impose the Turkic language. Azerbaijan = Russia. Two imperialist dictatorial KGB (Aliyev was the head of the KGB) regimes.
Caption translation at minute 5:00 is inaccurate. The man says Armenians destroyed everything and settled.
They literally destroyed everything and turned it into a barren land, destroyed theaters, architecture, people’s houses. Looked like the end of times.
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations
Haut Karabach churchs is over 1000 year old..karabagh is armenien not azarbedjan..
There was no armenia before 1918. It has no history and culture. Karabakh, Irevan, Zangezur and Goycha are historical Azerbaijani lands.
Those churches belong to Caucasian Albania, not gaymenians.
@@irreligiousman3395 Caucasian Albanian do not exist outside of Azeri historian minds.
Thanks for the documantery. It reflects the true side of armenian occupation which is highly destractive for people who are the owners of this land.
Thank you for telling the realities
So the Armenians were able to displace 750.000 Azerbaijani from the area prior to that
TENK YU ARTE TV🖐🏻
Afganistan stand with our Azerbaijan🎉
Kheyli Memnoun for Islamic emirat of Afghanistan 🇹🇷🇦🇿🇦🇫
@@AramBaba dismantle Armenia 😂
Arte how much did Aliev gives you for this ? The “ desert”
Armenians leave like that because its not part of the Autonomous region. They used it as a security region. They knew when the problem wil
Be solved , they must give that places back to Azeri, beside the Autonomous region of Nagorno Karabach. Stop war.Armenian mothers are mothers and Azeri mothers are mothers too.
Why you cant tolerate an objective documentary? If armenians want to give 7 occupied azerbaijani cities back to Azerbaijan when the problem will be solved, why you demolished all these 7 cities and make it uninhabitable with thousands of mines?
The whole World saw the vandalism in these cities and call them "Hiroshima and Nakasaki" of Caucasia, because armenian vandalism is more worst as Nukes.
You try to overshadow the 30-year occupation. So weird...
Karabak is Azerbaijan ❤
Land belong to Armenia check the Azerbaijan history please and you can check Armenians history how possibly is that check all Azerbaijan land who belongs who give to them check history with out drama all the world now there need oil but soon land return to Armenia please check history again reminding
Karabakh history is Turkish soil. You captured us in our weak time and massacred civilians. We will never fall into this situation. You will never return to Karabakh.🇹🇷🇦🇿
There was no armenia before 1918. It has no history and culture. Karabakh, Irevan, Zangezur and Goycha are historical Azerbaijani lands.
@@irreligiousman3395 sorry you don’t know history don’t read your Azerbaijani turkish history read Oder one’s international history and you can find where Turk come from and when Azerbaijani come from just please when you reading don’t turn the page because that’s the true
@@MuratAltay20 please can you check good history before you jump where the turk azeri come from who owned whole land don’t read turkey azeri history check international history just don’t turn the page when you reading
😂😂😂
karabağ azerbaycanın can azebaycan
@@steventaylor3104Kurds also hate armenians, because before WW1 the armenians dashnaksutyun bandits massacred the kurdish population of Anatolia for their myths of "Greater Armenia".
THIS NEEDS A PEACEFUL & A PERMANENT SOLUTION & THANKS FOR THIS DOCUMENTARY
Armenia lost a golden opportunity when it hands were strong. I think they underestimated the azeris and relied heavily on Russia, France and others. Azeris were beaten 20% of theid land occupies. Thats why Armenian citizens were astounded when they lost. If only if only?
Now it's azeris who's are on a position of strength i hope they use it positively and end this war in an amicable way to all
I would like to congratulate ARTE for the first time, because you have made a report about the Karabakh war that is truthful
Truthful? Half truth, more like it.
This documentary is an interesting watch, I'll give you that. But it barely touches on the Armenian perspective of the story, and is heavily biased towards Azerbaijan.
Now we need the other half.
Karabağ belongs to Azerbaijan!
But Azerbaijan didn't exist before 1918 how it's yours??
No doubt
See map and know reality
@@MrMalmir we are in 2023 and azerbaijan exist
@@nuur1-xr6qk
Won't be for so long if you keep following aliev ambitions
Azerbaijan belongs in IRAN. That's why they are Shia and and speak Persian.
Karabakh was the historical land of Azerbaijan. Only Armenians lived there. The problem is that the Armenians expelled the Azerbaijanis (Turks) from there and made that land their own.
when you say conflict started when soviet union was collapsing. this is often portrayed as if there was no interference from soviets and locals started fighting. truth is the weaker soviet ideolgy get more russian nationalism takes over. and Russian nationalism had always clear purpose of creating puppet Armenian state loyal to them. there was lots of interference in region from armenian and russian nationalist to make this war happen. deportation of azerbaijani people living in armenia before war was a act that started nationalism in Azerbaijan too as a defense mechanism. people doing these criminal acts. ruined millions of lives in both sides. azerbaijan with life loss and refugees and chaos but even in victory armenia also suffered. war criminals came to power in armenia and milked people dry
Justice restored, partly. Karabakh returned to rightful owners 🇦🇿
Rightful owners are Armenians and always will be.
@@Ala351 keep watching it from afar
our family BIBLE is older than Azerbaijan. Keep dreaming.
Support Armenia from Iran
🇦🇲❤️🇮🇷
You mean support from persians, because 30 million iranian azerbaijanis are with their brothers in Rep. Azerbaijan
@@supernova7966 Bullshit Tabriz is forever with Azerbaijan and Turkey
you are only a small part of people who are wrong, why is iran so much drama, iran doesn't have the guts to send missiles to israel
Support to Israel from Azerbaijan.
You have some wrongs. We - Azerbaijan - deocupied the Karabakh. Not Stepanakert - Khankandi and whole Karabakh are part of Azerbaijan. Yes , this dok better that others but still have wrongs moments.
Long live our Azerjaihani brothers and sisters. May god accept and bless your glorious martyrs. Love from Lebanon.
Stuck mentally in the Middle Ages. Enjoy your shithole countries.
give back the land to Armenia
Armenian shouldn't be there. The first Azerbaijan Republic expanded until Zəngəzur. Armenian land was originally more West than the current Armenia.
@@__Man__ it doesnt justified Azerbaijan's aggresion to seperate Armenian from it . Karabakh and its region was Armenia and will be always welcomed Armenian
Azerbaijan should start memorization of the genocide caused by Armenia and accuse Armenia of genocide.
Armenia was there for thousands of years. If you study history of that area you will see even 700 years ago there was no Turkey nor Azerbaijan, which was Armenian lands living millions of Armenian.
Artsakh has been occupited by azerbaijan who came from Altay region with the mongols and turk-seljucks..so Artsakh always was Armenian land and it is Armenian land.🇦🇲❤🇦🇲👍
There is no such thing as fartsakh. It doesn't exist.
Says gaymenian, whose ancestors immigrated to The Caucasus from south-east Anatolia.
❤
@@irreligiousman3395your ancestors are from Mongolia mate
@@agarykane2127 At least, no one denies the fact that Turks have origins in Altay unlike armenians, who are screaming to the world that they are indigenous people of The Caucasus, while they aren't.
Karaba is azarbijan❤
FACTS: What are recognized borders of Armenia according to UN?
The recognized borders of Armenia according to the United Nations encompass the territory that was internationally recognized as part of the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic within the former Soviet Union prior to its independence in 1991. These borders generally correspond to the administrative boundaries of the Republic of Armenia as it declared independence. While Nagorno-Karabakh was de facto controlled by ethnic Armenian forces, it is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan's territory. The United Nations, like most of the international community, does not recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as an independent state and considers it part of Azerbaijan's sovereign territory.
What are recognized borders of Azerbaijan according to UN?
United Nations recognizes the borders of Azerbaijan as those defined by international agreements and relevant UN resolutions. For Azerbaijan, the internationally recognized borders generally encompass the territory of the country as it was before the outbreak of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict in the late 1980s and early 1990s. This includes the regions of Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding areas, which are internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan. Everyone (USA, EU, UN, other reasonable countries) recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan - there is no doubt that Nagorno-Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan. Armenia has previously (1991-1994) occupied that part, and Azerbaijan regained it in 2020.
Nice story bro.
What about turkish illegal occupation of Northern cyprus
@@manotenkerian ONLY FACTS, bro:
According to UN does Northern Cyprus belong to Turkey, or Republic of Cyprus?
The United Nations considers Northern Cyprus to be part of the Republic of Cyprus. The UN does not recognize Northern Cyprus as an independent state or as part of Turkey. Instead, it views Northern Cyprus as territory occupied by Turkish forces since 1974 following the invasion of Cyprus. The Republic of Cyprus is recognized as the legitimate government over the entire island, including Northern Cyprus, although in reality, the island remains divided with the northern part under the control of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, which is recognized only by Turkey.
@veritasfacta wrong. The UN DOESN'T recognize it. Not even any turkic nation recognizes it
so yes, I agree it is illegal turkish occupation of northern cyprus. And it was illegal armenian occupation of nagorno karabakh, azerbaijan regained what lawfully belongs to it.
And it is illegal russian occupation of crimea, and it is illegal israelian occupation of palestinian territories, and it is illegal russian occupation of south ossetia and abkhazia (belongs to georgia)
The UN states that Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast is a disputed region that has the right to self-determination, the surrounding regions are considered occupied. The UN states there is no military solution to this conflict and the OSCE Minsk Group Protocol Protocol will be used for negotiations and a resolution to this conflict.
Now don't try to start quoting outdated UN resolutions before the war ended, weren't binding, or had little votes supporting the resolutions.
If the surrounding regions were very important, then Azerbaijan could have recognized the independence of NKAO with a corridor to Armenia for them returned
i'm not a religious person but i have a massive respect for the Muslim community. i grew up in a very racist catholic country and was constantly told not to associate with them cause they are violent and dangerous. I'm glad that i was always set on deciding for my own experience cause when i spoke to them they showed me that they are nothing but respectful and kind people. It's sad to see how they are treated, hopefully it will improve in the future.
The only thing more dangerous than ignorance is arrogance!
Google how Muslim ethnic minorities are treated in Azerbaijan
Can i ask, which country are you talking about?
@@faridagasiyev7042 Iran,, Koshole Iran,
@@admiral20055
They set lies like that in all Westen Moslems are Bad and Aggressive etc..but in the end they build atom and use that to humanity, and no one want talking about that anymore...🙂
@@admiral20055 You don't know shit about islam or muslims
You were told the right thing, they're dangerous and violent people.
Big Love from Motherland Turkey to Fatherland Azerbaijan.
We are 1 Nation, 2 States
🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿🇹🇷🇦🇿
Two fake countries one by 800 yrs history, another 103 yrs history.
Very funny
Conflicts for land like if the planet would had owner
လူသတ်တဲ့လူမျိုး ဝါဒ နဲ့ ----
လူမသတ်တဲ့လူမျိုးဝါဒ , ကွာခြားမှူ့တွေပေါ့"
Very pleased to see your love to your homeland and voice of Holy Quran masha allh filled my heart from 🇵🇰 love and respect
come back to your contry with your flip flop
Without lies Islam dies
Thank you very much , for better objective film.
Nagorna karabakh is azerbaijan and always will be azeri 🇵🇰
Brother country Azerbaijan 🇦🇿 turkey is always standing with you 🇹🇷
Why are you illegally occupying cyprus, if u follow international law?
Pro-azerbaijan propaganda
Thousands of video is pro armenia propaganda, this video is smaller than them
I used to watch arte tv documentaries without much fact-checking, but after this one, it is obvious that the view is biased and presents Azerbaijanis propaganda. Hope reporters can stay more professional when touching such important topics
Do you believe it should introduce Armenian fairy-tales. These people narrate their stories of occupation and forced expulsion. Personally, I saw by my own eyes what destruction was committed by Armenia in those lands.
@@huseynhumbatov9595 Siktir azik
They shall finally be able to return home.
Huge respect to Azerbaijan ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
From India
allah is not god
@@ashanperera3176 But the only true God ....don't be ignorrant pagan
In Veda God is One , leave idol worsholip ....
Islam is the Truth 🌘🌘🌘🌠🌠
@@ashanperera3176
Ask Jesus how call he their God in which name in their Language
Ethiopian political scientist, author of many books and researcher of the legacy of the Ethiopian emperors, professor Tecola Hagos:
"I was shocked to learn that the Armenians stole our alphabet
I was simply amazed that the Armenians so skillfully, shamelessly, cynically and obscenely distorted historical facts. I was just shocked when I first picked up a book written in Armenian. At first I thought it was in Ethiopian, since the letters were from our ancient alphabet. In perplexity, I leafed through this book in a language I did not understand, and before my eyes ancient copies of one of the most ancient alphabets in the world - Ethiopian - came to life. It was a copy of the letters that our ancestors wrote thousands of years ago. I, almost screaming in surprise, showed these letters to my friend, a historian from Addis Ababa University. He smiled and said to me: "Didn't you know? When we stopped writing in our own letters, the Armenians presented them to the whole world as the Armenian alphabet. I devoted several of my lectures to this topic at the university. World science knows that this is the Ethiopian alphabet. , but the Armenians are promoting it to the whole world as their own "
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA What a nonsense...
They make look similar but there is no relation. The Armenian alphabet was not adopted from the Geez alphabet. The Armenian alphabet is uniquely Armenian.
The Armenian alphabet was created by Mesrop Mashtots, who was an Armenian linguist. HE is the one who contributed to Caucasian Albanian and Georgian alphabet. Scholars are the ones who have said this, not just Armenians. The Armenian alphabet was created at 405 AD and that is when we can see Armenian literature. I
@@Ala351 Which scholars? From yerevan state universtity?
Georgian alphabet was created by Pharnavaz I.
@@irreligiousman3395 Modern Western academic consensus recognizes Mashtots as the creator of the Armenian and Georgian alphabets. And you can continue to believe in reptiloids.
@@SD-zl4uo Where are these sources? Provide me with them.
Great documentary
I shit in this documentary
@@robertgregori1384 That's good Potty Man
Very good to see the other side of the story too because everytime the Armenians get the spotlight and cry that we butchered them and what not all that nonsense they killed a lot of people too Esspecially in hocali
A very one sided view.
Artsakh is Armenia.
fartsakh doesn't exist
Christian lie 😂😂
@@JJ-ed5fd You mean Turkish lie. I'm not going to say Muslim lie, because we all know Turks are not true Muslims, since they drink alcohol & eat everything under the sun, right?
Artsakh is Armenia.
Apcax is AM !
Fartsakh ✌🏻
It is Khankendi NOT Stepanakert and it is an integral part of Azerbaijan. No Armenians flags should be allowed there
In your dreams 😂🤣😂
@@Ala351 I don't think they need to dream about it, they're actually doing it.
@@Ala351 there is nothing to dream about when we have actually done something that armenians never expected to be done. So why don't you shut up and continue licking their asses?
Gharabagh is Armenian, your lies can not change it, destroying and buldozing the history would not change the history of the world.
There is a saying in farsi, count the chucks at the end of autumn, it is not over yet
Armenia tried to pull the same thing in Georgia claiming Tblisi a major city and they lost
And you tried to pull the same thing in 2008 with russia and got your ass beat
What dogs think that Karabakh is their land. These are our lands, on which our ancestors lived long ago 🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲
Remember what these Turks and their comrades done for hundreds of years to the Armenians
Armenians lived on Kharabax many many years ago before azerbjeian was created in 1918 . Kharabkh was never in history part of azerbejian .The Soviet Union created the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region within Azerbaijan in 1924 when over 94 percent of the region's population was Armenians. We fight for our lands many many years even with Persia ,azerbejian was not created in that century. Please stop lying your self and stop sending your sons to kill our sons.We will fight and protect our lands.
Fuck off instead of wasting your time here, go and dig archive materials you will see vice versa
You are confusing it with armenia. It was created 105 years ago. It has no history and culture. Karabakh, Irevan, Zangezur and Goycha are historical Azerbaijani lands.
Azarbaizan long live 🎉
Thank you!
বাঙালি মাঁডাঁরঁষোঁডঁ সব জায়গায়! 😜
🇹🇷❤🇦🇿Sonsuza kadar
Armenians have broken the code of honor wars agent Azari was wrong