And that is what confuses me. But groups that are based on looks can....hiw is that again. Mamamoo as a whole has the most unique voices in kpop history. Up until then yo never heard a voice like any of theirs.
Cherisse Tillman looks wont last long but talents can, no matter how many years gonna past people will still came back for mmm’s voice, soulful and healing
Who says she can't sing. She one of the first voice I fell in love with. She has such control of her voice. I love them all but its so hard to not love Wheein's talent.
They performed this medley for their concert, using some of the performances they did on immortal songs ps. Moonbyul literally has her own radio show 😂 She had interviews with seulgi and soojin too
That’s it. This is MAMAMOO. This is why I can’t stan other groups because they’re set the bar so high. And also this is their concert that usually they’re performed for 4-5 hours/concert which is insane.
To add another nerdy reference to the mix, I saw a vocal coach on TH-cam make an awesome one by describing Mamamoo's voices as the four elements in Avatar. She said that Hwasa's smoky and husky vocals are fire, Wheein's light and beautiful vocals are air, Solar's deep and powerful vocals are earth, and Moonbyul is water for the way she balances the other members out and fits so perfectly with them. Mamamoo really are a fantastic mix of everything 😄 I'm glad you reacted to this, it's an incredible performance that I genuinely never get tired of watching. I'm looking forward to more Mamamoo reactions!
They also won in Immortal Song 3 times. They’re the only girl group in Korea to do that ✨ Also, Hwasa auditioned for JYP, but an agent told her “You have a great voice but you’re fat and ugly” Wheein also auditioned for JYP because Hwasa and her auditioned together. Solar auditioned for 40+ companies (she never auditioned for SM ent because she thought her visuals doesn’t meet the requirement, as she said “why would I hurt myself?”) but was rejected because of her age (she was 21) Also, JYP collaborated with MAMAMOO in their MAMA2019 performance. For JYP to collaborate with a group from a small company, he probably saw the charms, talent, and uniqueness that MAMAMOO has.
Wheein is one of the most sought after Artists to have featuring in other SK artists song. Wheein have the most control and stability, All 4 of them bring something different in all their songs. They put their own mark to all things they do.
Lol, they really are like the Power Rangers. When you unite them, they are just an unstoppable force. They even have a 4 colors concept and everything. You should really react to Mamamoo Acapella Queens. It’s something else. I really hope your still planning on reacting to Queendom soon, even though it might spoil you a little when it comes to two of their songs you haven’t heard yet.
I actually prefer when people pause a lot during reaction, because I want to hear what they think but I also don't want them to miss anything while talking
Sometimes for me, pausing can be kinda annoying, but only if reviewer can't deliver it very well, as long as it's fun, objective, well ok. Pausing is far way better than reviewing but only pointing one member, and ignores the sisters, i mean before doing 'review' will be better to at least research about the members, and mamamoo only have 4 members and all of them have their own charm, so it won't be hard to acknowledge every single of them, aigoo
No long ago Solar made an appearance in a TV show and told that before debut their CEO made them perform in front of other CEOS, and all of them agreed that they will gonna flop, because they were small and didn't had "Idol" looks. Actually Solar didn't even go to SM when she was looking for a casting because she believed that they'll rejected her cuz her visuals. Imagine that, rejecting Solar for her visuals. She's gorgeous.
They are definitely gorgeous, but I think the kpop look then was going for cutesy and innocent looking. These girls are brash, powerful, and focused. Which is funny because these days people latch onto idols like that.
@@KpopPrince The standard for female idol groups back then was Girls Generation and TARA. No wonder that Solar was unsure of SM. Even Red Velvet, visual queens, struggled with that. With AESPA looks like SM wants to return to the tall, thin models standard. But surely if things have changed this time it's because of Mamamoo.
technically Wheein is MAMAMO's neste vocalist, despite being known for her charming voice, she is not as well recognized as Solar and Hwasa Wheein is the queen of collabs, and Ots's in my opinion haha. Love your reactions 💕 please keep reacting to MAMAMOO!!
I'd say among kpop fans this is true but domestically people know of Wheein's vocal talent - she's listed as top 5 vocalists among other singers not necessarily idol singers. And her songs chart no.1 with little promo an d her osts do so well too
Moonbyul tends to be the backup vocals for her own raps and Wheein. Moonbyul and Wheein have very complimentary voices, each with a different kind of brightness that is the makes up the "updraft line" of Mamamoo. 😂 Immortal Songs is one of my favorite live shows for Moonbyul because she wrote a rap for each song and so her portions were all unique to the performance. 🥰 Honestly, I would love to hear what rapper Hwasa sounds like now. In 2014 she sounded like a tiny mouse version of a cross between Rihanna and Nikki Minaj. I mean, I still listen to I Do Me daily but it always makes me giggle because of the delivery. We kind of got that in Hip but it wasn't enough.
Their 4 part harmony is indeed so effortless even when they're just foolinh around. IDK probably it's because of their close bond or RBW simply trained them to death before debuting. Oh and *in my opinion* Whee In has the best vocal among the four. You just haven't seen it ❤️
Probably a little of both. Solar said in an interview that they just do it automatically now after their training. Funniest example, all four were interviewing on a radio show and the host said something interesting or surprising and the Mamamoo members all said, "Ohhhh," in unison and *in harmony.* I laughed my ass off.
HWASA falsetto always gets me Solars belting are alway so clear Wheein honey vocals are so sweet it could cure the saltiest person in the world Moonbyul deep voice is deeper than the deepest part of the ocean! And to answer your question what do u do when u have so many main vocalist YOUR SING WITH ALL U GOT! SING LIKE THERES NO TOMORROW! SING LIKE NO ONES WATCHING!
You’ll see wheein is the best vocalist in mamamoo (therefore making her one of the best in kpop in general) the more you watch. She doesn’t flash and show off as much as solar, and doesn’t have as unique a tone as Hwasa, but wheeins technique, control, range and consistency make her the best. Her tone is also beautiful and angelic, but she can also belt like solar.. they just utilize solar more because she is far and away more powerful. Also, she’s the shyest and most reserved so she suffers from her lack of exposure. Moomoos know about her immense talents, but because hwasa, solar, moonbyul tend to put themselves out there more, it’s their skills that most of the general public focus on first.
This is the best explanation of Wheein. Thank you so much, I just love her so much (all of them actually) but Wheein deserves more than she has. I hope she get that when she releases her album and that rbw start to promoting her more and better
@@ruthsofiatoro7416 it’s alright, because once people begin their mamamoo journey, they always end up falling for wheein. It’s funny.. within the fandom she seems to be the most popular and beloved member, but outside of the fandom she’s just the 4th member of mamamoo, some don’t even know her name but know the other 3.
I'm glad you appreciate all their vocal capabilities. It makes me sad when people only recognize either only Solar, Wheein, or Hwasa rather than the whole package. And I was with Mamamoo since You're the Best era but it makes me feel proud when I hear Moonbyul sing. I started with Moonbyul as my bias, but I cannot get enough from all of them. Sometimes Solar is my bias, then Wheein, and then other songs it's Hwasa. I love these girls and their strong bond. They all give something unique to the group. I would recommend watching their "Words Dont Come Easy" performance. Like :)
Wheein is an ace of kpop, but don’t just take our word for it. It always take a minute for new moos to see it but when you do, it’s honestly so hard to ignore her, even if she’s not your bias lol This was in 2016 during their first concert! And yes, ALL of them actually has auditioned for many other companies before being turned down. Literally Solar’s last resort after 50+ auditions was going to be RBW before she was going to give up auditioning because her parents wanted her to do something more practical. Funny thing, JYP himself asked to collaborate with them last year for their 2019 MAMA stage! He also openly regrets his company passing up on the members who auditioned there but then again we wouldn’t have Mamamoo if one or two of them made it into JYP
Huh, for some reason I thought Solar was nabbed by RBW in one of those random street auditions while training to be a stewardess. I wonder where that story came from. The 40+ auditions definitely sounds more plausible to me.
@@shortdrink873 haha yeah she auditioned for 40+ companies and apparently after getting rejected so many times her parents and Solar decided that she is going to audition for the last time (which happened to be for RBW) and if she doesn't get in, then she will go for air stewardess training. But she passed! And this is just another moment which shows that mamamoo was meant to be
@@shortdrink873 she didn't get nabbbed exactly but she sang for a chance to win something at the mall. Someone from the industry told her she should audition, and she said no, went home and kept thinking about it till she decided to go for it. Then she started auditioning.
wheein has a very versatile voice! the woman can go from a low octave to a whistle note , she prefers the soft r&b sound though , she’s also the most sought out person for ballads ands ost’s , just a little sad that people always push her to the side cause she’s not shown belting like the others often , sad to say many people think that good singing means belting and hitting super high notes, wheein is also does most of the little harmonies so basically she’s the backbone of mamamoo
Moonstar is really slaying it at Immortal Songs. It's early in their career (the first appearances were 2015, not a year after their debut), so she is only rapping, but all the songs a pop songs from the 80 and older (Delilah), so there are no rap parts in them. She wrote all the raps herself and they fit the songs like a glove.
Solar auditioned 50 times including JYP and YG Moonbyul and Wheein were in a group before but it disbanded after 1 week Hwasa auditioned numerous times as well They were like the pioneers in RBW, which was a small and new company back then. Kim Do Hoon, their CEO kinda put them together and composes some of their songs. He often asks for their opinions and inputs on the songs and gives them opportunities to be involved in making their music and wardrobe All of them are vocalists, try and watch Um Oh Ah Yeh music video and you'll know that they don't have main and lead positions. Wheein is sometimes overlooked but her voice is my first love in this group. She has the most versatile technique and she supoorts the songs while Solar and Hwasa belts or doing their runs. But sometimes, Solar and Hwasa supports her when she does her whistle notes
9:34, guess you haven't heard them introduce themselves yet hahaha 4:01 Moonbyul joining to make the 4 part harmony, it isn't much, but it's something. 16:16 He already knew what I was about to write in comments hahaha Perfect! 17:05 oh buddy, oh Prince, this is going to be a fun journey of Wheein discovery 17:50 we really appreciate you bumping this performance up your list before moving down the title tract list. Last one i promise 17:53 I recomend I Miss You Queendom performance. Queendom is a whole other conversation, for a whole other video, but that singular performance was just. ... .Mint!
Mamamoo's concert was over 4 hours , any singer or group can offer that kind of concert must have amazing live singing ability . And of course , MMM is one of the best for sure . Love their live performance , damn good !
Love your reactions , they’re really genuine. Looking forward to more MMM contents The more you discover them the more you’re gonna fall in love with their talents and their dorkiness 🥰 (like me)
oh yeah, and on the auditions thing... yes, every single member of mamamoo was turned down by multiple agencies and i believe every one had tried at least one of the big three (solar did two, i think it was sm that she said she never auditioned for because she didn't think she was pretty enough for their standards). they invariably heard they were great singers but just 'not a good match for our style' or whatever way they were 'politely' turned down, though there were some that bluntly told them things like the 'you're fat and not very pretty' hwasa mentioned getting or the 'aren't you too old to be a kpop trainee' solar got. i mean, kpop fans got their ideas for the ridiculous kpop beauty standards from somewhere... solar said she'd auditioned 40+ times and was about to give up before rbw said yes. wheein and hwasa said they were about ready to pack it in and go back home to jeonju together before rbw signed them. rbw (or really, at the time, wa entertainment) really was the last hope for all four of these girls that other agencies just considered 'not good enough' because they didn't match visual criteria despite how good they were vocally, musically, and performance-wise moonbyul and wheein actually did almost debut together. they were in a short-lived group that i don't believe really even lasted a week. byul was going to be main vocalist and leader (and eldest) with wheein the maknae. when they met up again as rbw trainees, they were happy to see each other and because wheein already knew hwasa (of course), solar was a bit left out at first. as far as these four go, at least. there was a fifth trainee that almost debuted with them as the group's leader but who quit shortly before debut. she was pretty good friends with all the girls, particularly solar and hwasa (and she and hwasa still hang out together. and have a matching tattoo together)
This is from their 2017 Concert Moosical, and they wear heels entire concert. Typical concert of Mamamoo is 4 hours with LIVE band. They said, Mamamoo concert is worth your money. Ahaha yes, JYP said they are 4 soloist in a group, rare gem in the industry. On your own free time, watch their concerts. goodness, I don't know where they get their energy from. Finish the MVs first so that you can compare the LIVE ones and the studio version.
Well the mamamoo comebacks/MV’s songs are- Hello Mr Ambiguous Piano man Un Oh Ah Yes I miss you Taller than you You’re the best New York Décalmonanie Yes I am Paint me Starry night Rainy season Egotistic Wind flower Gleam GogoBebe Hip Dingga Aya Promotional Singles- Girl crush Woo Hoo Taste the feeling Everyday Gleam Wanna be myself And if you want to learn more go to this link en.wikipedia.org/wiki/mamamoo_discography
Can I just say your Mamamoo videos are a pleasure to watch and I look forward to them every week. I can’t wait until you finish their discography and then watch the Dingo medley! It will blow your mind. I so agree with you about Hwasa’s voice, that grit is everything! She’s also just so adaptable she can go from fluid back-up vocals to soaring high notes and back to almost whispering with dreamy, jazzy vocals and then the aggressive growling. She’s just everything to me, and all of the girls are just absolutely amazing.
Soo happy you finally watched this! Their live stages are the best! As you will hear many MooMoo say, they are better live, then even on their albums. Oh when you watch their MVs ... make sure to watch their minor MVs too! and their CFs and OSTs too! those aren't to be missed! They are as good as their main music! Also, when you watch things like Immortal Songs (the tv show), and Queendom (the Mamamoo performances) and want to do reactions... if you either (or you can do both) reverse the image, or just pause (like you already do) you don't have to worry about it being blocked. There are a lot of channels that do that, and the videos are fine, and stay up with no issues, instead of putting them where ppl have to pay to see them. I will put together a list of their Cfs, and OSTs for you, and post them for you! LOVE your reactions! Can't wait for the next!
Immortal song medley is a concert performance of songs that they have performed in Immortal songs. They have done a lot of Immortal song episodes. These songs are just some of the best. The show made them known for their powerful vocals and performances even during their debut year
I fell in love with Wheein in Immortal Songs because she gets to showcase her powerful vocals here. In most of Mamamoo songs, she often steps back and supports the other 3 ladies. A lot of new fans don't know that she can actually hit the same range as Solar and go as low as Moonbyul. If you observe them in Killing voice, she's in charge of doing a lot of harmonies while Hwasa does a lot of adlibs. This is the killing point of Mamamoo. Doing harmonies takes a lot of listening, skill, and humility.
Wheein actually is the best vocalist in Mamamoo, she's known for her sweet/breathy vocals but her lower register is 💯 she's got the healthiest technique and the most stable in the group. Wheein is the backbone of the group for a reason, people may think holding a melody while the other members are belting their ass off is easy but it really is not. She may not always have the moment to do flashy adlibs but when she does, it's insane 🔥💯
mamamoo + live band is the best combo ever. they do that for all their immortal songs performances, all their concerts and basically any other time they're able to finagle a live band into their performances (sometimes it's their labelmates, onewe, that are the band. magic happens then) this medley was for one of their concerts, yeah. i believe 2017, 'moosical: curtain call', based on solar's pink hair. (also, how cute is it that they called their first two concerts 'moosical' and 'moosical curtain call'?). i want to say they performed the medly about halfway through the concert but haven't seen it all at once so am not really sure. i do know that even though this was really just their second solo concert series they were already going way overboard with it. their first concerts constantly went over the two-hour mark you tend to expect for concerts. with the curtain call ones they were breaking the three-hour mark and their more recent concerts, the four seasons spring/summer and fall/winter concerts all went over four hours long, with the final f/w one breaking five hours. just absolute insanity i mean, they do break things up with solo stages for every member (7-10 minutes the first few concerts, 20 minutes for the f/w ones), comedy skits (their two "taller than you" skits in s/s and f/w concerts are beyond hilarious) and vcrs (basically pre-recorded videos played so the girls, the dancers, and the band can catch their breath for a few minutes, change outfits and the stage can be set up for the next performances) but that's still a huge amount of time to perform. these women have legendary stamina mamamoo used to attend up to 4 college festivals a day (even red velvet got surprised when they heard that), performing live every time, each one a 20 minute stage with all the travel time between. that's one of the things that helped build their stamina as well as their reputation. they were the second most invited act to college festivals because of their changing adlibs to suit the venue, festival, city or audience and the way they always had fun together onstage no matter what. only psy was more requested (also, they were guest singers at one of psy's concerts)
This is from their concert in 2017, that's why it's in a larger venue and the audience has Mamamoo lightsticks. This is a medley of the songs they sang on Immortal Songs. It's also worth checking out each of their performances in the show, it's all amazing. They won the show three times. They're the only idol group to win multiple times and is the first rookie group and the only girl group to win.
IMO another things distinguish Mamamoo from most of groups are: 1. When they harmonize with each other, since they've sing for so long...they know how to *respect* whoever sing the main melody. As you know Solar has crazy power to the point she makes the mic clipping most of the times (ex: "Sexy Back" on JYP Party), but she control her volume so well when she's not the main melody. Wheein could easily steal everyone's attention by doing her clean running notes or high headvoice every 3 seconds 😂, same for Hwasa. But they don't. 2. Despite being a vocal group, Moonbyul's part were never overshadowed by the other's part... In fact the rap part is the most anticipated. Byul also has a great rap tone and refreshing flow, it gives their song extra ummpph everytime.
Well, other companies wouldn't have the audacity to regret. Solar was turned down by probably all of them except SM, just because she didn't even bother going to SM's audition knowing she wouldn't make it anyway. I don't remember Hwasa training at any company prior to RBW. Moonbyul was a vocal in her trainee day. Wheein probably still make it but I think having her best friend really help her mentally. Even when RBW already put MMM together, since their CEO is a well-know producer with lot of connections, he sent MMM's clips to his acquaintances and they all said the girls not gonna make it. So, let's be real, others can't wish they have MMM because none of them would debut MMM if given the chance.
You should go check the dingo medley once you've listened to most of their title tracks. It's a good way to hear how much they've improved over the years. Great reaction as usual, btw!
Its so sad that kpop corp machine conditioned people that girl groups will only have 1 or 2 members that actually sing. You form/have groups exactly because you want voices resonance/disonance or harmonies. Whats the point of groups just taking turns singing, if you only want to hear one voice at a time thats what solo acts are for. Groups is for things you cant do alone like harmonies.
180 comments so far so I'm sure people have mentioned that MMM were just a bunch of dwarfish, unpretty, non-idol material rejects who nobody in their right mind would sign until Kim Dohoon had the novel idea to create a group based on talent. When he showcased the girls for other industry pros before MMM's debut they all said he was nuts and predicted Mamamoo would be ruined. This medley was filmed at one of Mamamoo's Moosical Curtain Call concerts in 2017 and includes some of the songs they had performed on Immortal Songs up til then. If you want to mix in live performances without MV spoilers you could watch any or all of their 14 appearances on Immortal Songs. My favs are Delilah and Backwoods but they're all spectacular vocal showcases. Moosical Curtain Call was only their 2nd series of concerts, the first being the Moosical concerts in 2016. I find it shocking that a group could command the stage and have the audience wrapped around their fingers the way Mamamoo did in only their 2nd set of concerts. They seem like seasoned vets who have performed on countless stages in front of thousands of people for many years. Stamina has never been an issue with Mamamoo. Their 4 Seasons F/W concerts last year ran 4+ hours and the final concert in Hong Kong was 5 hours long according to HK moomoos. You asked for a list of MVs after Ahh Oop!: Don't Be Happy Peppermint Chocolate (DBH & PC are pre-debut collabs. You skipped them but they should not be missed) Um Oh Ah Yeah (title track for Pink Funky album) 1 CM/Taller Than You You're the Best (title track for Melting album) My Hometown Recipe Girl Crush (OST) New York Decalcomanie (title track for Memory album) Memory I Love You Too (live MV; MMM's first love song to moomoos, written by Solar, Moonbyul & Hwasa) Angel (live MV; Angel Line subunit - Solar & Wheein) Dab Dab (live MV; Rap Line subunit - Moonbyul & Hwasa) Woo Hoo (CF) Aze Gag Yes I Am (title track for Purple album) Love and Hate (Moonbyul solo on Purple; no MV but there is a performance video) Paint Me (pre-release single from Yellow Flower album; theme song for the 4 Season 4 Color project) Starry Night (title track for Yellow Flower album) Star Wind Flower Sun (Solar's 2nd love song to moomoos & all their precious people, rap verses by Moonbyul) Be Calm (Hwasa solo on Yellow Flower) Everyday (CF) Egotistic (title track for Red Moon album) Selfish (Moonbyul solo on Red Moon w/feature by Seulgi of Red Velvet) Sky Sky (CF) Wind Flower (title track for Blue;S album) Hello (Solar solo on Blue;S; no MV but watch the double pole dance video set to Hello on Solar's yt channel Solarsido) Gogobebe (title track for White Wind album) 25 (Wheein solo on White Wind) Gleam (CF) Hip (title track for reality in BLACK album) Wanna Be Myself (CF) Dingga Dingga Aya (title track for Travel album) I only listed solo songs that are included on Mamamoo albums but there are lots of solo MVs and other videos.
Yeah, I love to watch every performance of Immortal songs by Mamamoo. They’ve 14 performances. I hope you watch the full performance of Rhythm, Love, Backwoods, and Meeting too.
mamamoo sang this immortal songs medley on their concert, named Moosical, and this performance was legendary. I have watched this medley for like hundreds times and still got me awe like my first times. Hoping to see more Mamamoo's reaction from you
Solar is the most powerful vocalist, Wheein has the best technique, Hwasa is the most versatile and Moonbyul is the best and most passionate rapper. Watch the Queendom performances!
Their ceo once said wheein is the backbone of mamamoo.. because of wheein voice can make beautiful harmonization with any kind of voice and her voice is stable
has moonbyul hosted anything....mmmm... i think its time for you to watch "why mamamoo shouldn't host their own show", yes its a thing hahahaha plus moonbyul has been a host in a radio show for a few months now :) she has even guested RV Seulgi, member of G idle, mamamoo, and more!
I was waiting for this... Thanks for the reaction !!! Yes, all those people who watched this iconic stage in person is privileged.... Don't know when I'll have this privilege.. This stage is a MUST WATCH.! Everyone should experience MAMAMOO's concert atleast once in their lifetime !!!
back two hours later because realized i forgot something in my previous long-winded messages... moonbyul is frequently used as a narrator in their earlier songs, especially the immortal songs covers (where she wrote rap verses for songs that weren't even remotely designed to have them). another female rapper pointed that out when having to pick one of their songs to cover. byul helps control the flow of the song, the emotion. she'll hype things up if the song needs that or slow things down if that's what's needed. and she always changes her flow and style to suit the song instead of just trying to wedge something in as for host... she used to be a very frequent guest on the radio show 'starry night' when it was hosted by sandeul of b1a4 before he had to do his military service. he's one of moonbyul's best friends and had her on practically every episode of his show. he also had her guest dj for him once when he was out and she even took over as temporary dj partway through another episode when he was late coming back from something lately, she's been the dj for tuesday night's 'aven girls' radio show and she calls her episodes 'hamven girls' since one of her favorite nicknames is 'hamster' (which she calls ham or hamham) sandeul and moonbyul went on a show called 'in sync' ('kiss' or 'kissing' in korea) where singers from various backgrounds got together over the course of a weekend at a time and had to find duet partners, usually mixed gender but they did have one song between two men because they'd purposefully had more male singers invited than female. moonbyul was exceptionally worried since she's always just been 'the rapper' for a group all about vocal prowess and didn't expect any of the guys to pick her. because of that she just stuck close to sandeul early on and gave him a really tough decision... he wound up having to pick between a duet with her and one with punch, a solo artist known as an ost queen. punch was sandeul's number one person he wanted to duet with out of everyone on the show. and he wound up picking byul over her because he was more worried for her well-being than his own partner desires the two sang a beautiful song together and it actually made all the other male artists on the show clamor to partner with her afterwards. she suddenly became the most sought-after partner on the show thanks both to sandeul's selflessness and moonbyul's own voice and lower register. it did wonders for her confidence and gave us some absolutely gorgeous songs with byul and the lead singer of jannabi and hongki of ft island. i do wish we'd been able to see a moonbyul/dindin performance too but alas. also, poor sandeul never got to sing with punch on the show though the two became pretty good friends, as did punch and moonbyul. in fact, punch had byul feature on a remake of one of her osts with her and byul had punch feature on one of her songs from the 'dark side of the moon' album
hiii so this perfomance was in 2017 before Moobyul started singing more and gaining more vocal confidence but it's still one of my favorite perfomances of all time
Wheein is objectively the best technical vocalist in Mamamoo. I’d highly recommend reacting to her debut solo live performance of Anymore on Sketchbook. Her high notes and emotion in that stage will blow your mind as she sounds way better live than the studio version.
yes this is from their concert. it's only a medley of some of their immortal songs2 performances. this is just a piece of cake compared to them singing live 4hrs straight in their concerts for 3 consecutive days.
I have to warn you, once you fall inside the Mamamoo rabbit hole, your standard for live singing & stage charisma in girl groups will be dangerously high. - Cheers, Yellow Ranger
Thankyou for choosing this video! You really appreciated the musical aspect, love it. 🎉 Btw if you plan to watch their crackhead video in between, I suggest: 1. Why Mamamoo should stop hosting their own shows - issamo_o 2. Mamamoo being a total chaos on VLive - wheeluv mememoo 3. Just Mamamoo Things - (I forget) 4. Mamamoo being out of control in waiting room interview - MMM_Shortclips
Not only back up dancers, they had a live band for the whole concert. Oh, yes, their energy is amazing. Others have mentioned that Solar did 40 auditions before being picked by RBW, Moonbyul was cut for being overweight by another group, and Hwasa was rejected for being darker skinned, heavier, and less attractive than the typical idol, so yeah, they suffered a lot. No one talks about it, but it's obvious that Solar, Moonbyul, and Wheein had some work done prior to debut, but Hwasa seems to have rejected any plastic surgery whatsoever.
This performance makes me emotional everytime. Getting exhausted even watching is normal. Also you should check delilah on imortal songs mamamoo was rookies then and you can watch wheein kill the high notes.
I wanna know your update schedule. Damn, I am watching all your mamamoo reactions back to back in my spare time. it feels amazing to see appreciating the talent as much as we do. Your reactions are pure and you give attention to every single member, just like a true moomoo!! I really want to see your actions of all the immortal performances of mamamoo separately because they are gold, believe me. My favorites are Sampo, Love, and backwoods. They are focused on their vocals more just as I prefer. You will be blown away by the emotions in these performances.
@@KpopPrince Thanks for informing your schedule. I will keep a check and will definitely watch it. It's rare to find genuine reactions and those who actually appreciate the talent and love kpop as much as we all do. You're doing a great work, keep supporting Mamamoo. 😊🥳👍👍
Yes, this was from their concert, not the actual show itself haha they've performed a lot in Immortal Songs that they can even do a medley of it XD And Byul hosts a radio show! Every tuesday nights :D
Sorry if someone’s already said this or you figured it out, but this is a medley from a concert of some of their performances in Immortal Songs. I think they’ve been on Immortal Songs 13 (?) times and won 3 times. Plenty of great performances there if you want to watch a full song, plus a MMMTV ep that showed their whole prep for one performance.
soo happy you watched this 😍 ugh it’s so amazing. I want to recommend ‘I Miss You’ Queendom performance but if you’re going to watch the show then just wait, bc it’s worth it! so instead I’ll recommend ‘My Star’ from their FW Concert. it’s not a single and there is no MV for it. it just has a really good rock early 00’s vibe.
You've gotta pay more attention to Wheein. These girls are the best vocalists in the industry but Wheein is flawless. And so versatile. I don't know if it's her stability that makes her do the backbone parts of the songs a lot but she routinely has stand out moments in songs. Watch for them. She is a breathtaking vocalist. I'm not even a Moomoo and I'm lowkey obsessed with her.
Killing voice is NOT going to ruin any future mv's you watch!! It's a live performance as well. I actually like the Killing voice versions of some of their songs.
@@KpopPrince She had nothing to do with the incidents. Knetz thought she was the easiest target so got dragged. It took her two years to finally be comfortable and gain confident in herself. 2018 was such difficult year for our wheepup 😔 but glad she is Happy and healthy now
@@KpopPrince the hate had more to do with what her estranged father did. They made her apologize for the actions of someone who abandoned her as a child. I'm still mad about it.
You're right about the other company. Moonbyul and Wheein almost devuted for different company, fortunately they did not and became part of RB* to be MAMAMOO 💛
Please react to Mamamoo I think about a lot by Holy Hwasa. Actually solar said in one of their interview that before their debute, their CEO in RBW recommended them to other companies for more support I guess but all of them or staff always says that "why them? They will be ruin" cause they are not typically an idol beauty at that time that's why they are really good at stage performances.
This was from their Moosical Curtain Call concert in 2017, so 3 years after debut. By this time, they'd already been on Immortal Songs 2 so many times (and already had 2 wins) that they were able to make a MEDELY, and they didn't even include all of the songs they'd done on the show up to that point in this!!
nah no one ever thinks Wheein can't sing. that girl has one of the best vocal techniques in the entire kpop industry
❤️. Period!
Well i see Sir Austin agrees....
And that is what confuses me. But groups that are based on looks can....hiw is that again. Mamamoo as a whole has the most unique voices in kpop history. Up until then yo never heard a voice like any of theirs.
Her ballads are superior. Always no.1 in music charts. Have you seen her duet song festival? No words.
Cherisse Tillman looks wont last long but talents can, no matter how many years gonna past people will still came back for mmm’s voice, soulful and healing
OMG! MooMoo's...LETS GO!
You know it
You are here too Sir Austin...
Aww Sir Austin is here ❤🤗
Dang Sir Austin reacting to other reactions
Why are you so relatable 😂
consider the MooMoos braced, ion know bout the baby Moos tho! Brace yourselves lavss!
Wheein is listed under top 5 vocalist with actual singers not idols. And yess all Mamamoo girls are the best ! They all stand out equally. 🥰
I know of no one that thinks that Wheein can't sing. Some professionals think Wheein has the most control and versatility in her voice.
sooo true she is one of the best vocalists
She is top 5 singer in korea that chosen by producer. She is the only one of girlgroup among singers.
Who says she can't sing. She one of the first voice I fell in love with. She has such control of her voice. I love them all but its so hard to not love Wheein's talent.
We all know all of Mamamoo can sing can dance can rap,except lip synch❤️
11 minutes is nothing to Mamamoo when their concerts last for over 4 hours.
Hahahaha True 😹
Trueee
Exactly 😊
Even they used to perform 4 festivals in a day
With extra hour singing inside the car.
They performed this medley for their concert, using some of the performances they did on immortal songs
ps. Moonbyul literally has her own radio show 😂 She had interviews with seulgi and soojin too
That’s it. This is MAMAMOO. This is why I can’t stan other groups because they’re set the bar so high. And also this is their concert that usually they’re performed for 4-5 hours/concert which is insane.
a msian moo? hello!
@@looloodoo6698 Yess helloo
To add another nerdy reference to the mix, I saw a vocal coach on TH-cam make an awesome one by describing Mamamoo's voices as the four elements in Avatar. She said that Hwasa's smoky and husky vocals are fire, Wheein's light and beautiful vocals are air, Solar's deep and powerful vocals are earth, and Moonbyul is water for the way she balances the other members out and fits so perfectly with them. Mamamoo really are a fantastic mix of everything 😄
I'm glad you reacted to this, it's an incredible performance that I genuinely never get tired of watching. I'm looking forward to more Mamamoo reactions!
Sometimes I think I don't go hard enough with the nerdy references 😁
this is such a great analogy and it perfectly makes sense!!
They also won in Immortal Song 3 times. They’re the only girl group in Korea to do that ✨ Also, Hwasa auditioned for JYP, but an agent told her “You have a great voice but you’re fat and ugly” Wheein also auditioned for JYP because Hwasa and her auditioned together. Solar auditioned for 40+ companies (she never auditioned for SM ent because she thought her visuals doesn’t meet the requirement, as she said “why would I hurt myself?”) but was rejected because of her age (she was 21)
Also, JYP collaborated with MAMAMOO in their MAMA2019 performance. For JYP to collaborate with a group from a small company, he probably saw the charms, talent, and uniqueness that MAMAMOO has.
i feel like if mamamoo now decides to sign with jyp, he's gonna take them instantly. you know what I mean?
@@anya0717 I guess, he'd ask them to sign before they even have the chance to ask :D
@@anya0717 yes, he won’t even think about it. He’ll just be like “okay you can start right now” lol
@@nanami436 exactly. imagine how much he regrets for not signing them before. if I'm not wrong solar auditioned for jyp right?
i didnt know it was jyp..damn.. so it is true when they prioritized "looks" over "talent" huh. same for sm and yg
Wheein is one of the most sought after Artists to have featuring in other SK artists song. Wheein have the most control and stability, All 4 of them bring something different in all their songs. They put their own mark to all things they do.
Yeahhh. She has so many collabs. Even have a collab with the legend Park Bom
Lol, they really are like the Power Rangers. When you unite them, they are just an unstoppable force. They even have a 4 colors concept and everything. You should really react to Mamamoo Acapella Queens. It’s something else. I really hope your still planning on reacting to Queendom soon, even though it might spoil you a little when it comes to two of their songs you haven’t heard yet.
Oh my God.. power rangers!! Finally found the best description for Mamamoo.. thank youu
I actually prefer when people pause a lot during reaction, because I want to hear what they think but I also don't want them to miss anything while talking
BIG yes
Same
Sometimes for me, pausing can be kinda annoying, but only if reviewer can't deliver it very well, as long as it's fun, objective, well ok.
Pausing is far way better than reviewing but only pointing one member, and ignores the sisters, i mean before doing 'review' will be better to at least research about the members, and mamamoo only have 4 members and all of them have their own charm, so it won't be hard to acknowledge every single of them, aigoo
Actually wheein is considered one of the best vocalists in the industry by professionals
No long ago Solar made an appearance in a TV show and told that before debut their CEO made them perform in front of other CEOS, and all of them agreed that they will gonna flop, because they were small and didn't had "Idol" looks. Actually Solar didn't even go to SM when she was looking for a casting because she believed that they'll rejected her cuz her visuals. Imagine that, rejecting Solar for her visuals. She's gorgeous.
They are definitely gorgeous, but I think the kpop look then was going for cutesy and innocent looking. These girls are brash, powerful, and focused. Which is funny because these days people latch onto idols like that.
Can you please tell which TV show was this on
@@lavanya3562 i think it was boss in the mirror
@@amar1684 thank you!
@@KpopPrince The standard for female idol groups back then was Girls Generation and TARA. No wonder that Solar was unsure of SM. Even Red Velvet, visual queens, struggled with that. With AESPA looks like SM wants to return to the tall, thin models standard. But surely if things have changed this time it's because of Mamamoo.
technically Wheein is MAMAMO's neste vocalist, despite being known for her charming voice, she is not as well recognized as Solar and Hwasa Wheein is the queen of collabs, and Ots's in my opinion haha. Love your reactions 💕 please keep reacting to MAMAMOO!!
I'd say among kpop fans this is true but domestically people know of Wheein's vocal talent - she's listed as top 5 vocalists among other singers not necessarily idol singers. And her songs chart no.1 with little promo an d her osts do so well too
Moonbyul tends to be the backup vocals for her own raps and Wheein. Moonbyul and Wheein have very complimentary voices, each with a different kind of brightness that is the makes up the "updraft line" of Mamamoo. 😂 Immortal Songs is one of my favorite live shows for Moonbyul because she wrote a rap for each song and so her portions were all unique to the performance. 🥰
Honestly, I would love to hear what rapper Hwasa sounds like now. In 2014 she sounded like a tiny mouse version of a cross between Rihanna and Nikki Minaj. I mean, I still listen to I Do Me daily but it always makes me giggle because of the delivery. We kind of got that in Hip but it wasn't enough.
Bring back rapper Hwasaa
Their 4 part harmony is indeed so effortless even when they're just foolinh around. IDK probably it's because of their close bond or RBW simply trained them to death before debuting.
Oh and *in my opinion* Whee In has the best vocal among the four. You just haven't seen it ❤️
Oh yes, just wait to him WheIn haha, It's almost 2 years and I still not wheOut hahaha
Probably a little of both. Solar said in an interview that they just do it automatically now after their training. Funniest example, all four were interviewing on a radio show and the host said something interesting or surprising and the Mamamoo members all said, "Ohhhh," in unison and *in harmony.* I laughed my ass off.
In which radio show can you tell me
@@memes5303 No, sorry. Been too long ago. I meant to save it later and forgot about it until it was too late to find it again.
Its okay
HWASA falsetto always gets me
Solars belting are alway so clear
Wheein honey vocals are so sweet it could cure the saltiest person in the world
Moonbyul deep voice is deeper than the deepest part of the ocean!
And to answer your question what do u do when u have so many main vocalist
YOUR SING WITH ALL U GOT! SING LIKE THERES NO TOMORROW!
SING LIKE NO ONES WATCHING!
You’ll see wheein is the best vocalist in mamamoo (therefore making her one of the best in kpop in general) the more you watch. She doesn’t flash and show off as much as solar, and doesn’t have as unique a tone as Hwasa, but wheeins technique, control, range and consistency make her the best. Her tone is also beautiful and angelic, but she can also belt like solar.. they just utilize solar more because she is far and away more powerful.
Also, she’s the shyest and most reserved so she suffers from her lack of exposure. Moomoos know about her immense talents, but because hwasa, solar, moonbyul tend to put themselves out there more, it’s their skills that most of the general public focus on first.
This is the best explanation of Wheein. Thank you so much, I just love her so much (all of them actually) but Wheein deserves more than she has. I hope she get that when she releases her album and that rbw start to promoting her more and better
@@ruthsofiatoro7416 it’s alright, because once people begin their mamamoo journey, they always end up falling for wheein. It’s funny.. within the fandom she seems to be the most popular and beloved member, but outside of the fandom she’s just the 4th member of mamamoo, some don’t even know her name but know the other 3.
I'm glad you appreciate all their vocal capabilities. It makes me sad when people only recognize either only Solar, Wheein, or Hwasa rather than the whole package. And I was with Mamamoo since You're the Best era but it makes me feel proud when I hear Moonbyul sing. I started with Moonbyul as my bias, but I cannot get enough from all of them. Sometimes Solar is my bias, then Wheein, and then other songs it's Hwasa. I love these girls and their strong bond. They all give something unique to the group. I would recommend watching their "Words Dont Come Easy" performance. Like :)
BOY U ARE THE BEST REACTOR TO OUR IDOL MAMAMOO ....... WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT YOU AND WAITING FOR YOUR COMING REACTION ON MAMAMOO...........✌MOOOMOO
Wheein is an ace of kpop, but don’t just take our word for it. It always take a minute for new moos to see it but when you do, it’s honestly so hard to ignore her, even if she’s not your bias lol
This was in 2016 during their first concert! And yes, ALL of them actually has auditioned for many other companies before being turned down. Literally Solar’s last resort after 50+ auditions was going to be RBW before she was going to give up auditioning because her parents wanted her to do something more practical. Funny thing, JYP himself asked to collaborate with them last year for their 2019 MAMA stage! He also openly regrets his company passing up on the members who auditioned there but then again we wouldn’t have Mamamoo if one or two of them made it into JYP
Mamamoo is the group that wont run away from the sight of hand-held mic 😎
Wheein is the best
Watch queendom I Miss you performance and Wheein anymore
25 and Wheein cover song candy
Solar auditioned over 40 companies including JYP, was rejected for being in their 20s, i guess Hwasa or Wheein auditioned in JYP too, but i'm not sure
It's Hwasa. Byul in SM.
Huh, for some reason I thought Solar was nabbed by RBW in one of those random street auditions while training to be a stewardess. I wonder where that story came from. The 40+ auditions definitely sounds more plausible to me.
@@shortdrink873 haha yeah she auditioned for 40+ companies and apparently after getting rejected so many times her parents and Solar decided that she is going to audition for the last time (which happened to be for RBW) and if she doesn't get in, then she will go for air stewardess training. But she passed! And this is just another moment which shows that mamamoo was meant to be
@@shortdrink873 she didn't get nabbbed exactly but she sang for a chance to win something at the mall. Someone from the industry told her she should audition, and she said no, went home and kept thinking about it till she decided to go for it. Then she started auditioning.
@@asiaargenta aha, thank you for clearing that up!
That's so absurd to imagine this performance is during a 4H + concert how this girls have the stamina !!!! Keep the good job and keep enjoy Mamamoo
wheein has a very versatile voice! the woman can go from a low octave to a whistle note , she prefers the soft r&b sound though , she’s also the most sought out person for ballads ands ost’s , just a little sad that people always push her to the side cause she’s not shown belting like the others often , sad to say many people think that good singing means belting and hitting super high notes, wheein is also does most of the little harmonies so basically she’s the backbone of mamamoo
Moonstar is really slaying it at Immortal Songs. It's early in their career (the first appearances were 2015, not a year after their debut), so she is only rapping, but all the songs a pop songs from the 80 and older (Delilah), so there are no rap parts in them. She wrote all the raps herself and they fit the songs like a glove.
4 SOLOIST IN A GROUP - MAMAMOO
Yup.... Only 4....all of them.... Every member are soloist.... Became soloist after Mamamoo, spreading wings everywhere
facts! 4 successful SOLOIST showcasing their unique sides in their musicality.❤❤❤
Solar auditioned 50 times including JYP and YG
Moonbyul and Wheein were in a group before but it disbanded after 1 week
Hwasa auditioned numerous times as well
They were like the pioneers in RBW, which was a small and new company back then. Kim Do Hoon, their CEO kinda put them together and composes some of their songs. He often asks for their opinions and inputs on the songs and gives them opportunities to be involved in making their music and wardrobe
All of them are vocalists, try and watch Um Oh Ah Yeh music video and you'll know that they don't have main and lead positions. Wheein is sometimes overlooked but her voice is my first love in this group. She has the most versatile technique and she supoorts the songs while Solar and Hwasa belts or doing their runs. But sometimes, Solar and Hwasa supports her when she does her whistle notes
Moonbyul have own Radio Show ( Moon Night Studio ) every Monday, Wednesday and Friday
I really want to see when LOONA was on it! Pretty sure Dreamcatcher was too
Wheein’s rendition of “With My Tears” on the Hospital Playlist OST is just ❤️ Great song, great artiste, great drama.
I'm already crying just reading "with my tears". Wheein's rendition is just heavenly.
9:34, guess you haven't heard them introduce themselves yet hahaha
4:01 Moonbyul joining to make the 4 part harmony, it isn't much, but it's something.
16:16 He already knew what I was about to write in comments hahaha Perfect!
17:05 oh buddy, oh Prince, this is going to be a fun journey of Wheein discovery
17:50 we really appreciate you bumping this performance up your list before moving down the title tract list.
Last one i promise
17:53 I recomend I Miss You Queendom performance. Queendom is a whole other conversation, for a whole other video, but that singular performance was just. ... .Mint!
Up
(I personally prefer I Miss You in YHY Sketchbook but the one in Queendom is more emotional so okay)
In heels everyone. They jump and perform in HEELS! oh yess these QUEENS!!
Mamamoo's concert was over 4 hours , any singer or group can offer that kind of concert must have amazing live singing ability . And of course , MMM is one of the best for sure . Love their live performance , damn good !
Love your reactions , they’re really genuine. Looking forward to more MMM contents
The more you discover them the more you’re gonna fall in love with their talents and their dorkiness 🥰 (like me)
oh yeah, and on the auditions thing... yes, every single member of mamamoo was turned down by multiple agencies and i believe every one had tried at least one of the big three (solar did two, i think it was sm that she said she never auditioned for because she didn't think she was pretty enough for their standards). they invariably heard they were great singers but just 'not a good match for our style' or whatever way they were 'politely' turned down, though there were some that bluntly told them things like the 'you're fat and not very pretty' hwasa mentioned getting or the 'aren't you too old to be a kpop trainee' solar got. i mean, kpop fans got their ideas for the ridiculous kpop beauty standards from somewhere...
solar said she'd auditioned 40+ times and was about to give up before rbw said yes. wheein and hwasa said they were about ready to pack it in and go back home to jeonju together before rbw signed them. rbw (or really, at the time, wa entertainment) really was the last hope for all four of these girls that other agencies just considered 'not good enough' because they didn't match visual criteria despite how good they were vocally, musically, and performance-wise
moonbyul and wheein actually did almost debut together. they were in a short-lived group that i don't believe really even lasted a week. byul was going to be main vocalist and leader (and eldest) with wheein the maknae. when they met up again as rbw trainees, they were happy to see each other and because wheein already knew hwasa (of course), solar was a bit left out at first. as far as these four go, at least. there was a fifth trainee that almost debuted with them as the group's leader but who quit shortly before debut. she was pretty good friends with all the girls, particularly solar and hwasa (and she and hwasa still hang out together. and have a matching tattoo together)
That time when you realised that "Destiny" is actually about this.... 😢💜
This is from their 2017 Concert Moosical, and they wear heels entire concert. Typical concert of Mamamoo is 4 hours with LIVE band. They said, Mamamoo concert is worth your money.
Ahaha yes, JYP said they are 4 soloist in a group, rare gem in the industry.
On your own free time, watch their concerts. goodness, I don't know where they get their energy from.
Finish the MVs first so that you can compare the LIVE ones and the studio version.
Love your reactions
That's why they don't have main vocalist or dancer they don't like to use those terms
Great artist though
Mamamoo just makes old songs SOUND SO COOL!
Well the mamamoo comebacks/MV’s songs are-
Hello
Mr Ambiguous
Piano man
Un Oh Ah Yes
I miss you
Taller than you
You’re the best
New York
Décalmonanie
Yes I am
Paint me
Starry night
Rainy season
Egotistic
Wind flower
Gleam
GogoBebe
Hip
Dingga
Aya
Promotional Singles-
Girl crush
Woo Hoo
Taste the feeling
Everyday
Gleam
Wanna be myself
And if you want to learn more go to this link
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/mamamoo_discography
Their 2018 mama performance is SO ICONIC
Can I just say your Mamamoo videos are a pleasure to watch and I look forward to them every week. I can’t wait until you finish their discography and then watch the Dingo medley! It will blow your mind. I so agree with you about Hwasa’s voice, that grit is everything! She’s also just so adaptable she can go from fluid back-up vocals to soaring high notes and back to almost whispering with dreamy, jazzy vocals and then the aggressive growling. She’s just everything to me, and all of the girls are just absolutely amazing.
Soo happy you finally watched this! Their live stages are the best! As you will hear many MooMoo say, they are better live, then even on their albums.
Oh when you watch their MVs ... make sure to watch their minor MVs too! and their CFs and OSTs too! those aren't to be missed! They are as good as their main music!
Also, when you watch things like Immortal Songs (the tv show), and Queendom (the Mamamoo performances) and want to do reactions... if you either (or you can do both) reverse the image, or just pause (like you already do) you don't have to worry about it being blocked. There are a lot of channels that do that, and the videos are fine, and stay up with no issues, instead of putting them where ppl have to pay to see them.
I will put together a list of their Cfs, and OSTs for you, and post them for you!
LOVE your reactions! Can't wait for the next!
You should see their performance on Immortal Song 2, they have performed there for 14 times
Immortal song medley is a concert performance of songs that they have performed in Immortal songs. They have done a lot of Immortal song episodes. These songs are just some of the best. The show made them known for their powerful vocals and performances even during their debut year
I fell in love with Wheein in Immortal Songs because she gets to showcase her powerful vocals here. In most of Mamamoo songs, she often steps back and supports the other 3 ladies. A lot of new fans don't know that she can actually hit the same range as Solar and go as low as Moonbyul. If you observe them in Killing voice, she's in charge of doing a lot of harmonies while Hwasa does a lot of adlibs. This is the killing point of Mamamoo. Doing harmonies takes a lot of listening, skill, and humility.
Wheein actually is the best vocalist in Mamamoo, she's known for her sweet/breathy vocals but her lower register is 💯 she's got the healthiest technique and the most stable in the group. Wheein is the backbone of the group for a reason, people may think holding a melody while the other members are belting their ass off is easy but it really is not. She may not always have the moment to do flashy adlibs but when she does, it's insane 🔥💯
mamamoo + live band is the best combo ever. they do that for all their immortal songs performances, all their concerts and basically any other time they're able to finagle a live band into their performances (sometimes it's their labelmates, onewe, that are the band. magic happens then)
this medley was for one of their concerts, yeah. i believe 2017, 'moosical: curtain call', based on solar's pink hair. (also, how cute is it that they called their first two concerts 'moosical' and 'moosical curtain call'?). i want to say they performed the medly about halfway through the concert but haven't seen it all at once so am not really sure. i do know that even though this was really just their second solo concert series they were already going way overboard with it. their first concerts constantly went over the two-hour mark you tend to expect for concerts. with the curtain call ones they were breaking the three-hour mark and their more recent concerts, the four seasons spring/summer and fall/winter concerts all went over four hours long, with the final f/w one breaking five hours. just absolute insanity
i mean, they do break things up with solo stages for every member (7-10 minutes the first few concerts, 20 minutes for the f/w ones), comedy skits (their two "taller than you" skits in s/s and f/w concerts are beyond hilarious) and vcrs (basically pre-recorded videos played so the girls, the dancers, and the band can catch their breath for a few minutes, change outfits and the stage can be set up for the next performances) but that's still a huge amount of time to perform. these women have legendary stamina
mamamoo used to attend up to 4 college festivals a day (even red velvet got surprised when they heard that), performing live every time, each one a 20 minute stage with all the travel time between. that's one of the things that helped build their stamina as well as their reputation. they were the second most invited act to college festivals because of their changing adlibs to suit the venue, festival, city or audience and the way they always had fun together onstage no matter what. only psy was more requested (also, they were guest singers at one of psy's concerts)
Yes, that was their concert. They performed a medley of their immortal songs.
Moonbyul has her own radio show every Tuesday on and it's really amazing, you're right she does have that MC aura in a lot of their stages.
This is from their concert in 2017, that's why it's in a larger venue and the audience has Mamamoo lightsticks. This is a medley of the songs they sang on Immortal Songs. It's also worth checking out each of their performances in the show, it's all amazing. They won the show three times. They're the only idol group to win multiple times and is the first rookie group and the only girl group to win.
IMO another things distinguish Mamamoo from most of groups are:
1. When they harmonize with each other, since they've sing for so long...they know how to *respect* whoever sing the main melody.
As you know Solar has crazy power to the point she makes the mic clipping most of the times (ex: "Sexy Back" on JYP Party), but she control her volume so well when she's not the main melody. Wheein could easily steal everyone's attention by doing her clean running notes or high headvoice every 3 seconds 😂, same for Hwasa. But they don't.
2. Despite being a vocal group, Moonbyul's part were never overshadowed by the other's part... In fact the rap part is the most anticipated. Byul also has a great rap tone and refreshing flow, it gives their song extra ummpph everytime.
Well, other companies wouldn't have the audacity to regret. Solar was turned down by probably all of them except SM, just because she didn't even bother going to SM's audition knowing she wouldn't make it anyway. I don't remember Hwasa training at any company prior to RBW. Moonbyul was a vocal in her trainee day. Wheein probably still make it but I think having her best friend really help her mentally. Even when RBW already put MMM together, since their CEO is a well-know producer with lot of connections, he sent MMM's clips to his acquaintances and they all said the girls not gonna make it. So, let's be real, others can't wish they have MMM because none of them would debut MMM if given the chance.
This
This is a medley of their Immortal Songs Performance on their own concert. They appeared in Immortal Songs TV Show 13 times and won 3 times
You should go check the dingo medley once you've listened to most of their title tracks. It's a good way to hear how much they've improved over the years. Great reaction as usual, btw!
I love music videos of MMM, but their live stages are EVERYTHING!!
Q: What do you do if you have too many main vocalists?
A: Let them harmonize!!! 💚💚💚💚
Its so sad that kpop corp machine conditioned people that girl groups will only have 1 or 2 members that actually sing. You form/have groups exactly because you want voices resonance/disonance or harmonies. Whats the point of groups just taking turns singing, if you only want to hear one voice at a time thats what solo acts are for. Groups is for things you cant do alone like harmonies.
180 comments so far so I'm sure people have mentioned that MMM were just a bunch of dwarfish, unpretty, non-idol material rejects who nobody in their right mind would sign until Kim Dohoon had the novel idea to create a group based on talent. When he showcased the girls for other industry pros before MMM's debut they all said he was nuts and predicted Mamamoo would be ruined.
This medley was filmed at one of Mamamoo's Moosical Curtain Call concerts in 2017 and includes some of the songs they had performed on Immortal Songs up til then. If you want to mix in live performances without MV spoilers you could watch any or all of their 14 appearances on Immortal Songs. My favs are Delilah and Backwoods but they're all spectacular vocal showcases. Moosical Curtain Call was only their 2nd series of concerts, the first being the Moosical concerts in 2016. I find it shocking that a group could command the stage and have the audience wrapped around their fingers the way Mamamoo did in only their 2nd set of concerts. They seem like seasoned vets who have performed on countless stages in front of thousands of people for many years. Stamina has never been an issue with Mamamoo. Their 4 Seasons F/W concerts last year ran 4+ hours and the final concert in Hong Kong was 5 hours long according to HK moomoos.
You asked for a list of MVs after Ahh Oop!:
Don't Be Happy
Peppermint Chocolate (DBH & PC are pre-debut collabs. You skipped them but they should not be missed)
Um Oh Ah Yeah (title track for Pink Funky album)
1 CM/Taller Than You
You're the Best (title track for Melting album)
My Hometown
Recipe
Girl Crush (OST)
New York
Decalcomanie (title track for Memory album)
Memory
I Love You Too (live MV; MMM's first love song to moomoos, written by Solar, Moonbyul & Hwasa)
Angel (live MV; Angel Line subunit - Solar & Wheein)
Dab Dab (live MV; Rap Line subunit - Moonbyul & Hwasa)
Woo Hoo (CF)
Aze Gag
Yes I Am (title track for Purple album)
Love and Hate (Moonbyul solo on Purple; no MV but there is a performance video)
Paint Me (pre-release single from Yellow Flower album; theme song for the 4 Season 4 Color project)
Starry Night (title track for Yellow Flower album)
Star Wind Flower Sun (Solar's 2nd love song to moomoos & all their precious people, rap verses by Moonbyul)
Be Calm (Hwasa solo on Yellow Flower)
Everyday (CF)
Egotistic (title track for Red Moon album)
Selfish (Moonbyul solo on Red Moon w/feature by Seulgi of Red Velvet)
Sky Sky (CF)
Wind Flower (title track for Blue;S album)
Hello (Solar solo on Blue;S; no MV but watch the double pole dance video set to Hello on Solar's yt channel Solarsido)
Gogobebe (title track for White Wind album)
25 (Wheein solo on White Wind)
Gleam (CF)
Hip (title track for reality in BLACK album)
Wanna Be Myself (CF)
Dingga Dingga
Aya (title track for Travel album)
I only listed solo songs that are included on Mamamoo albums but there are lots of solo MVs and other videos.
Please don't watch sky sky mv lol
They're 4 gauntlets snapping you with harmonization 👌🏻💣
Don’t change the way you react, it’s refreshing seeing a reactor take it all in and digest it properly. Also Moonbyul has her own radio show segments
Yeah, I love to watch every performance of Immortal songs by Mamamoo. They’ve 14 performances. I hope you watch the full performance of Rhythm, Love, Backwoods, and Meeting too.
mamamoo sang this immortal songs medley on their concert, named Moosical, and this performance was legendary. I have watched this medley for like hundreds times and still got me awe like my first times. Hoping to see more Mamamoo's reaction from you
Solar is the most powerful vocalist, Wheein has the best technique, Hwasa is the most versatile and Moonbyul is the best and most passionate rapper.
Watch the Queendom performances!
Their ceo once said wheein is the backbone of mamamoo.. because of wheein voice can make beautiful harmonization with any kind of voice and her voice is stable
For mamamoo that performance was a piece of cake in terms of singing and dancing...
"What you gonna when you have so many vocalist?"
Mamamoo: "Harmonizing"
has moonbyul hosted anything....mmmm... i think its time for you to watch "why mamamoo shouldn't host their own show", yes its a thing hahahaha plus moonbyul has been a host in a radio show for a few months now :) she has even guested RV Seulgi, member of G idle, mamamoo, and more!
idk why, but everytime i watch ur reaction videos i kinda feels like watching it with a friend~ it's so fun😂😂
Thank you, that's so nice 😊
This one of the best mv to truly appreciate they're vocal range
I was waiting for this... Thanks for the reaction !!! Yes, all those people who watched this iconic stage in person is privileged.... Don't know when I'll have this privilege..
This stage is a MUST WATCH.! Everyone should experience MAMAMOO's concert atleast once in their lifetime !!!
back two hours later because realized i forgot something in my previous long-winded messages...
moonbyul is frequently used as a narrator in their earlier songs, especially the immortal songs covers (where she wrote rap verses for songs that weren't even remotely designed to have them). another female rapper pointed that out when having to pick one of their songs to cover. byul helps control the flow of the song, the emotion. she'll hype things up if the song needs that or slow things down if that's what's needed. and she always changes her flow and style to suit the song instead of just trying to wedge something in
as for host... she used to be a very frequent guest on the radio show 'starry night' when it was hosted by sandeul of b1a4 before he had to do his military service. he's one of moonbyul's best friends and had her on practically every episode of his show. he also had her guest dj for him once when he was out and she even took over as temporary dj partway through another episode when he was late coming back from something
lately, she's been the dj for tuesday night's 'aven girls' radio show and she calls her episodes 'hamven girls' since one of her favorite nicknames is 'hamster' (which she calls ham or hamham)
sandeul and moonbyul went on a show called 'in sync' ('kiss' or 'kissing' in korea) where singers from various backgrounds got together over the course of a weekend at a time and had to find duet partners, usually mixed gender but they did have one song between two men because they'd purposefully had more male singers invited than female. moonbyul was exceptionally worried since she's always just been 'the rapper' for a group all about vocal prowess and didn't expect any of the guys to pick her. because of that she just stuck close to sandeul early on and gave him a really tough decision... he wound up having to pick between a duet with her and one with punch, a solo artist known as an ost queen. punch was sandeul's number one person he wanted to duet with out of everyone on the show. and he wound up picking byul over her because he was more worried for her well-being than his own partner desires
the two sang a beautiful song together and it actually made all the other male artists on the show clamor to partner with her afterwards. she suddenly became the most sought-after partner on the show thanks both to sandeul's selflessness and moonbyul's own voice and lower register. it did wonders for her confidence and gave us some absolutely gorgeous songs with byul and the lead singer of jannabi and hongki of ft island. i do wish we'd been able to see a moonbyul/dindin performance too but alas. also, poor sandeul never got to sing with punch on the show though the two became pretty good friends, as did punch and moonbyul. in fact, punch had byul feature on a remake of one of her osts with her and byul had punch feature on one of her songs from the 'dark side of the moon' album
The duet show sounds like such a great idea! Glad she was able to rebuild her confidence in singing. Thank you for these great comments!
hiii so this perfomance was in 2017 before Moobyul started singing more and gaining more vocal confidence but it's still one of my favorite perfomances of all time
Wheein is objectively the best technical vocalist in Mamamoo. I’d highly recommend reacting to her debut solo live performance of Anymore on Sketchbook. Her high notes and emotion in that stage will blow your mind as she sounds way better live than the studio version.
yes this is from their concert. it's only a medley of some of their immortal songs2 performances. this is just a piece of cake compared to them singing live 4hrs straight in their concerts for 3 consecutive days.
I have to warn you, once you fall inside the Mamamoo rabbit hole, your standard for live singing & stage charisma in girl groups will be dangerously high. - Cheers, Yellow Ranger
true!!
Thankyou for choosing this video! You really appreciated the musical aspect, love it. 🎉
Btw if you plan to watch their crackhead video in between, I suggest:
1. Why Mamamoo should stop hosting their own shows - issamo_o
2. Mamamoo being a total chaos on VLive - wheeluv mememoo
3. Just Mamamoo Things - (I forget)
4. Mamamoo being out of control in waiting room interview - MMM_Shortclips
Not only back up dancers, they had a live band for the whole concert.
Oh, yes, their energy is amazing.
Others have mentioned that Solar did 40 auditions before being picked by RBW, Moonbyul was cut for being overweight by another group, and Hwasa was rejected for being darker skinned, heavier, and less attractive than the typical idol, so yeah, they suffered a lot. No one talks about it, but it's obvious that Solar, Moonbyul, and Wheein had some work done prior to debut, but Hwasa seems to have rejected any plastic surgery whatsoever.
this is their show and byul has a radio show. she interviewed seulgi and soojin already
This performance makes me emotional everytime.
Getting exhausted even watching is normal.
Also you should check delilah on imortal songs mamamoo was rookies then and you can watch wheein kill the high notes.
yeah this is their concert from a few years ago. There are a few songs that they didn't include here, I recommend 'Delilah'
I wanna know your update schedule. Damn, I am watching all your mamamoo reactions back to back in my spare time. it feels amazing to see appreciating the talent as much as we do. Your reactions are pure and you give attention to every single member, just like a true moomoo!! I really want to see your actions of all the immortal performances of mamamoo separately because they are gold, believe me. My favorites are Sampo, Love, and backwoods. They are focused on their vocals more just as I prefer. You will be blown away by the emotions in these performances.
Thanks so much for the love! I'm kinda off schedule atm with specific releases. I try to upload at 9PM EST each day though
@@KpopPrince Thanks for informing your schedule. I will keep a check and will definitely watch it. It's rare to find genuine reactions and those who actually appreciate the talent and love kpop as much as we all do. You're doing a great work, keep supporting Mamamoo. 😊🥳👍👍
Yes they were on arena bcs they were on their own concert called MOOSICAL in 2016. Only 2 years after their debut like hello queens behavior?
Their harmonisations are no joke, and probably best in Kpop.
I think this was the performance that was given by them after they won the medley singing competition.
Yes, this was from their concert, not the actual show itself haha they've performed a lot in Immortal Songs that they can even do a medley of it XD
And Byul hosts a radio show! Every tuesday nights :D
The “she’s hot” comment for moonbyul is too relatable😂🤍 but the best performance ever.
Sorry if someone’s already said this or you figured it out, but this is a medley from a concert of some of their performances in Immortal Songs. I think they’ve been on Immortal Songs 13 (?) times and won 3 times. Plenty of great performances there if you want to watch a full song, plus a MMMTV ep that showed their whole prep for one performance.
soo happy you watched this 😍 ugh it’s so amazing. I want to recommend ‘I Miss You’ Queendom performance but if you’re going to watch the show then just wait, bc it’s worth it! so instead I’ll recommend ‘My Star’ from their FW Concert. it’s not a single and there is no MV for it. it just has a really good rock early 00’s vibe.
I'm doing Queendom on my Patreon in a few weeks so I probably won't do singular performance reactions 😊
He reacted to Inmortal Songs Medley. I'm manifesting a momo right here
Moonbyul actually is an MC. She’s hosted 2 visual radio shows, Avengirls and Studio Moon Night, and she won awards for Studio Moon Night
You've gotta pay more attention to Wheein. These girls are the best vocalists in the industry but Wheein is flawless. And so versatile. I don't know if it's her stability that makes her do the backbone parts of the songs a lot but she routinely has stand out moments in songs. Watch for them. She is a breathtaking vocalist. I'm not even a Moomoo and I'm lowkey obsessed with her.
Killing voice is NOT going to ruin any future mv's you watch!! It's a live performance as well. I actually like the Killing voice versions of some of their songs.
I can assure you no one thought wheein couldn’t sing
For some reason I remembered her getting a lot of hate or something discussed in the guide.
@@KpopPrince She had nothing to do with the incidents. Knetz thought she was the easiest target so got dragged. It took her two years to finally be comfortable and gain confident in herself. 2018 was such difficult year for our wheepup 😔 but glad she is Happy and healthy now
@@KpopPrince the hate had more to do with what her estranged father did. They made her apologize for the actions of someone who abandoned her as a child. I'm still mad about it.
Korea is ass-backwards sometimes
MAMAMOO IS VOCAL QUEEN NO ONE IN KPOP INDUSTRY CAN BEAT THEM. “no one”
6:35 This is a mamamoo concert! It's just a medley of what they have performed on immortal songs!
You're right about the other company. Moonbyul and Wheein almost devuted for different company, fortunately they did not and became part of RB* to be MAMAMOO 💛
Please react to Mamamoo I think about a lot by Holy Hwasa.
Actually solar said in one of their interview that before their debute, their CEO in RBW recommended them to other companies for more support I guess but all of them or staff always says that "why them? They will be ruin" cause they are not typically an idol beauty at that time that's why they are really good at stage performances.
This was from their Moosical Curtain Call concert in 2017, so 3 years after debut. By this time, they'd already been on Immortal Songs 2 so many times (and already had 2 wins) that they were able to make a MEDELY, and they didn't even include all of the songs they'd done on the show up to that point in this!!
Their new medly is Dinggo Killing voice, it's more vocal. Thank you for reacting