now a day in malaysia they try to correcting the word "every " , (“Whomever Allah guides, no one can lead him astray. Whomever Allah sends astray, no one can guide him. The truest word is the Book of Allah and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The most evil matters are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation. Every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.”) by using quoting from imam nawawi that is not every innovation that misguide. begging help for clear this misconception because as malaysian i concern of my brother of islam.
A women praying different than men, is it an innovation? Every women in India pray different than men, i mean the salaah rules for women in India are different? So Is it an innovation?
What in innovation in Islam? Assalammu'alaikum Wr Wb, First and foremost one must truly and correctly understand what exactly is innovation in the religion (deen) of Islam in order to form or apply the correct judgment of it. To know this one must when reading the following explanations be absolutely sincere in reading it. It must be read with an absolute clear mind and intention to gain the correct insight (wisdom) and not a misconstrued insight (false ideologies). It is in no way to misguide anyone from the truth and correct path. Your misunderstanding in comprehending its true meaning and sense is entirely of your own incorrect judgement or failure to see its light (absolute truthfulness). Bismillahi Rohmannir Rohiim Innovation in Islam relates to making actions or doing things which were not prescribed (deeds) by Nabi SAW nor were there any precedent (origin) from Nabi SAW nor it is mention in The Holy Quran. Hence the true meaning of innovation in the religion (deen) has been far misconstrued by past Islamic Scholars and current Scholars including those who are strong followers (taksub) to these Scholars. What is the actual innovation or form of innovation that is forbidden? It is where one innovates the religion (deen) by 1) intentionally and 2) falsely linking it to the Holy Quran and/or the Sunnah. It is by adding and/or omitting the prescribed (deeds)or precedent (origin) actions or functions which has been perfected in Islam. Hence to pray wudhu for example or similar to it is not an innovation because it was allowed by Nabi SAW as it was a prescribed (deed) and precedent (origin) method for additional prayer (Sunnah prayer). I.e. there was a precedent (origin) in the methodology or steps to pray sunnah. To follow in these steps is absolutely acceptable Inshaa-Allah. Eg. solatut tasbih, nafl, etc. Hence to do anything additional [to what has been prescribed (syariah) in Islam] and then 'think' or 'intent' that one is (or it is) better than the Holy Quran or Sunnah is what is forbidden. None can ever be better than Them. Therefore in my opinion, excessive solawat is allowed as it has been allowed by Allah SWT. Allah SWT commands us to selawat unto Nabi SAW. So it has a precedent (origin) set to it. But to do it in a manner like dancing or jumping about or claim and think that Nabi SAW is present during the solawat is forbidden (innovation). The Khulafa Ar- Roshidin didn't do it as perhaps they'd most certainly breakdown due to their closeness to Nabi SAW or perhaps fear of innovation. They didn't want those after them to create or innovate the religion with a negative mindset. Ie. believing that it is ok to innovate just about anything in the religion. Just like false hadith appeared later on. The companions were very wise and knew the consequence of what will come later. Or perhaps Allah SWT didn't make them do it so as to avoid forbidden innovations and free them of blames. Hope the above explanation will help clear the misconstrued perception of what the real forbidden innovations are and how to apply it correctly and not falsely. Wallahu'alam bissawab. I humbly request that only known scholars comment and not the layman to comment in order to widen our knowledge correctly. Syukran, wassalam.
Understand the difference between those that control and those that empower. Allah swa set the precedent with a concept called ‘free will’ The message should be ‘educate’ yourself. The truth is held on science. Clearly people like this are not educated enough to understand a deeper connection of Islamic laws and why things are done a certain way - ie the placement of the solar system 5 times a day. The vibrational frequency of recitation etc. People like this resort to blind faith to control. Blind faith is worse than no faith at all. May my message be blessed by the Most High.
Blind faith is key in Islam. Don't you remember Isra' Mi'raj? Such a fantastic story back then would require blind faith to believe, and so Abu Bakr radiallahu'anhu did. Your understanding of Islam is greatly flawed. Such modern concepts that you have mentioned were not widely known especially during the time of the prophet sallallahu 'alayhi wassallam, were they fools because of this lack of knowledge? No, in fact, they were the best of the ummah and they achieved what none of us, with our sophisticated and abundant technology and knowledge can never achieve. Your 'education' will lead you nowhere if it ultimately convinces you that 'science' is the truth. The Qur'an is the truth. The sunnah is the truth. 'Science' changes with time, Islam is constant for eternity. Re-educate yourself. Leave those books of science for a while and concentrate on qur'an and hadeeth instead.
? All praise is to Allah innovation in this world is a plus if it is to benefit Humanity at Large but there is no such thing as innovation and our Islamic religion the monotheistic believers our religion Islam is complete I should say Allah has religion is complete follow the guidelines to better Humanity Allah Knows Best
A women praying different than men, is it an innovation? Every women in India pray different than men, i mean the salaah rules for women in India are different? So Is it an innovation? Some of the Hadiths mention that there are some difference though they are not that authentic
Ok so din is way of life and does not just encompass acts of worship, such as Salah etc.. So science etc are also part of din.. Ok so when all bida leads to hellfire , RasoolAllah sallAllahu aleihiwasallam did not differentiate between acts of worship or science etc.. So he did not classify bida into different types.. Ok so isn't the classification of bida itself into 2 types, an act of bida? If RasoolAllah sallAllahu aleihiwasallam did not classify into 2 types, isn't it any innovation a bida and destined for hellfire? In short by your definition, if RasoolAllah sallAllahu aleihiwasallam did not classify bida into 2 types then to classify it into religious and non religious is a bida itself.
TWO TYPE OF BIDAAH GOOD BIDAAH AND BAD BIDAAH THAT IS ACCORDING TO PROPHET MUHAMMAD S A.W. . AND ACCORDING TO IMAM SAFI EH ALSO SAID . TWO TYPE OFBIDAAH BAD AND GOOD. BUT SOME ALEEM DID NOT BELIEVE ON THIS SPECIALLY SALAFI MOVEMENT. SOME OF MUSLIM SHOLAR, DID NOT KNOW THAT THEY WERE USED BY THE YAHUD .
Allahu Akbar may Allah reward you ameen
Ameen 🤲🏿
Is saying the shihada if you feel like you did kufur or have wiswas that you did kufur an innovation?
now a day in malaysia they try to correcting the word "every " , (“Whomever Allah guides, no one can lead him astray. Whomever Allah sends astray, no one can guide him. The truest word is the Book of Allah and the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad. The most evil matters are those that are newly invented, for every newly invented matter is an innovation. Every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the Hellfire.”) by using quoting from imam nawawi that is not every innovation that misguide. begging help for clear this misconception because as malaysian i concern of my brother of islam.
A women praying different than men, is it an innovation? Every women in India pray different than men, i mean the salaah rules for women in India are different? So Is it an innovation?
@@nidashheikh yeah.....we muslims are one irrespective of their nationality........we all should follow what our prophet teached us
What in innovation in Islam?
Assalammu'alaikum Wr Wb,
First and foremost one must truly and correctly understand what exactly is innovation in the religion (deen) of Islam in order to form or apply the correct judgment of it.
To know this one must when reading the following explanations be absolutely sincere in reading it. It must be read with an absolute clear mind and intention to gain the correct insight (wisdom) and not a misconstrued insight (false ideologies). It is in no way to misguide anyone from the truth and correct path. Your misunderstanding in comprehending its true meaning and sense is entirely of your own incorrect judgement or failure to see its light (absolute truthfulness).
Bismillahi Rohmannir Rohiim
Innovation in Islam relates to making actions or doing things which were not prescribed (deeds) by Nabi SAW nor were there any precedent (origin) from Nabi SAW nor it is mention in The Holy Quran.
Hence the true meaning of innovation in the religion (deen) has been far misconstrued by past Islamic Scholars and current Scholars including those who are strong followers (taksub) to these Scholars.
What is the actual innovation or form of innovation that is forbidden?
It is where one innovates the religion (deen) by 1) intentionally and 2) falsely linking it to the Holy Quran and/or the Sunnah.
It is by adding and/or omitting the prescribed (deeds)or precedent (origin) actions or functions which has been perfected in Islam.
Hence to pray wudhu for example or similar to it is not an innovation because it was allowed by Nabi SAW as it was a prescribed (deed) and precedent (origin) method for additional prayer (Sunnah prayer). I.e. there was a precedent (origin) in the methodology or steps to pray sunnah. To follow in these steps is absolutely acceptable Inshaa-Allah. Eg. solatut tasbih, nafl, etc.
Hence to do anything additional [to what has been prescribed (syariah) in Islam] and then 'think' or 'intent' that one is (or it is) better than the Holy Quran or Sunnah is what is forbidden. None can ever be better than Them.
Therefore in my opinion, excessive solawat is allowed as it has been allowed by Allah SWT. Allah SWT commands us to selawat unto Nabi SAW. So it has a precedent (origin) set to it. But to do it in a manner like dancing or jumping about or claim and think that Nabi SAW is present during the solawat is forbidden (innovation).
The Khulafa Ar- Roshidin didn't do it as perhaps they'd most certainly breakdown due to their closeness to Nabi SAW or perhaps fear of innovation. They didn't want those after them to create or innovate the religion with a negative mindset. Ie. believing that it is ok to innovate just about anything in the religion. Just like false hadith appeared later on. The companions were very wise and knew the consequence of what will come later. Or perhaps Allah SWT didn't make them do it so as to avoid forbidden innovations and free them of blames.
Hope the above explanation will help clear the misconstrued perception of what the real forbidden innovations are and how to apply it correctly and not falsely.
Wallahu'alam bissawab.
I humbly request that only known scholars comment and not the layman to comment in order to widen our knowledge correctly.
Syukran, wassalam.
Understand the difference between those that control and those that empower.
Allah swa set the precedent with a concept called ‘free will’
The message should be ‘educate’ yourself. The truth is held on science. Clearly people like this are not educated enough to understand a deeper connection of Islamic laws and why things are done a certain way - ie the placement of the solar system 5 times a day. The vibrational frequency of recitation etc.
People like this resort to blind faith to control. Blind faith is worse than no faith at all.
May my message be blessed by the Most High.
Blind faith is key in Islam. Don't you remember Isra' Mi'raj? Such a fantastic story back then would require blind faith to believe, and so Abu Bakr radiallahu'anhu did. Your understanding of Islam is greatly flawed. Such modern concepts that you have mentioned were not widely known especially during the time of the prophet sallallahu 'alayhi wassallam, were they fools because of this lack of knowledge? No, in fact, they were the best of the ummah and they achieved what none of us, with our sophisticated and abundant technology and knowledge can never achieve.
Your 'education' will lead you nowhere if it ultimately convinces you that 'science' is the truth. The Qur'an is the truth. The sunnah is the truth. 'Science' changes with time, Islam is constant for eternity. Re-educate yourself. Leave those books of science for a while and concentrate on qur'an and hadeeth instead.
? All praise is to Allah innovation in this world is a plus if it is to benefit Humanity at Large but there is no such thing as innovation and our Islamic religion the monotheistic believers our religion Islam is complete I should say Allah has religion is complete follow the guidelines to better Humanity Allah Knows Best
What is the name of the sheikh?
Mohammed salah
So is praying tharaveeh jamah innovation or not?
TARAWE IS A GOOD INNOVATION
A women praying different than men, is it an innovation? Every women in India pray different than men, i mean the salaah rules for women in India are different? So Is it an innovation? Some of the Hadiths mention that there are some difference though they are not that authentic
This is the most detailed video I've come across about the Prophetic ص method of salah
th-cam.com/video/T4auGhmeBlw/w-d-xo.html
Ok so din is way of life and does not just encompass acts of worship, such as Salah etc.. So science etc are also part of din..
Ok so when all bida leads to hellfire , RasoolAllah sallAllahu aleihiwasallam did not differentiate between acts of worship or science etc.. So he did not classify bida into different types.. Ok so isn't the classification of bida itself into 2 types, an act of bida? If RasoolAllah sallAllahu aleihiwasallam did not classify into 2 types, isn't it any innovation a bida and destined for hellfire?
In short by your definition, if RasoolAllah sallAllahu aleihiwasallam did not classify bida into 2 types then to classify it into religious and non religious is a bida itself.
TWO TYPE OF BIDAAH GOOD BIDAAH AND BAD BIDAAH THAT IS ACCORDING TO PROPHET MUHAMMAD S A.W. . AND ACCORDING TO IMAM SAFI EH ALSO SAID . TWO TYPE OFBIDAAH BAD AND GOOD. BUT SOME ALEEM DID NOT BELIEVE ON THIS SPECIALLY SALAFI MOVEMENT. SOME OF MUSLIM SHOLAR, DID NOT KNOW THAT THEY WERE USED BY THE YAHUD .
No ya sufi
The transition of the Quran into other languages is a bidah
GOOD BIDAAH
@@NurNorvilla indeed
Understanding quran is not a new thing in islam
It wont come in the category
Of innovations