She should make a new series where she remakes some of her old make up looks....Michelle gained so much more experience in the past years,I would like to see a comparison!
your tutorial is great, i based my make up on your tips. i took pictures, but youtube doesn't want me to put a link here in the comments :( if you want, i can send to you via message. i don't have black or silver paint, so i used black eyeshadow (in the eye, i mixed with a little water, so it looked eyelinerish) and pearl eyeliner. i was the best black swan at the party last night ;) tnx and keep on with the great videos!!
Claudia Crock It’s used for theater makeup and also people use it around Halloween for creature makeup . Last year I didn’t have any, I had to make a white face makeup myself.
I can’t believe it has been 13 years! I was reminded about Michelle by Honeysuckle it is so odd to see these videos again. But boy you made my days 13 years ago!!!!🎉
Michelle must be a AN AMAZING artist. Most likely because makeup is just another piece of art for her... (her face is the paper and makeup the materials)
THANK YOU SO SO MUCH FOR THIS TUTORIAL! That hand thing was GENIUS!! I've used it in my skating competitions, cause my free program music is from the black swan. :) I just loved it! ♥
I followed your tutorial for a Halloween party last night and it turned out perfectly! It was a huge help! Thank you for posting this one!! :D I loved Black Swan and this makeup look really is a work of art
i did this for my formal Ariel dance show....it was called "Birds of a feather" and i was the black swan love this look but my make up failed....lolz i was the most creative person there!!! any way Keep up the AWESOME work Michelle!!!!!!
![โอ้เธอช่าง... - บี้เดอะสกา ft. ต๋อง เทวัญ (Prod. by ป๋าเพชร) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zbWhiLFmVL0/mqdefault.jpg)
She should make a new series where she remakes some of her old make up looks....Michelle gained so much more experience in the past years,I would like to see a comparison!
yeees!!
I love watching michelles old videos for entertainment makes me Happy
omg i missed these so much
She used to talk so low
Omg I completely forgot she did this💖
Is it just me or does it sound like she is whispering... No hate BTW
I love Black Swan! You did an AMAZING job, I'm so doing this for halloween and going to be ballsy and use red contacts. Can't wait!
Beautiful. Loved it with the red eyes. This is when u really cared BEFORE u created ur wannabe high end make up
"Haunting and elegant" perfect for weddings! :D
its almost like painting
me: *failed art class*
Odile, The Black Swan!!! :)
I seriously don't understand how some people don't like this, or any other video of Michelle!
your tutorial is great, i based my make up on your tips. i took pictures, but youtube doesn't want me to put a link here in the comments :( if you want, i can send to you via message.
i don't have black or silver paint, so i used black eyeshadow (in the eye, i mixed with a little water, so it looked eyelinerish) and pearl eyeliner.
i was the best black swan at the party last night ;) tnx and keep on with the great videos!!
the red eyes scared the crap outta me ;A;
Her voice has changed so much
I think for this tutorial in particular she was trying to sound haunting and creepy like Black Swan :)
black swan is like my most fave movie and i think you've recreated it beautifully
I've never heard of white foundation before
Claudia Crock It’s used for theater makeup and also people use it around Halloween for creature makeup . Last year I didn’t have any, I had to make a white face makeup myself.
Can u do Princess Aurora look plus be sleeping beauty
omg you use aquarium in the music it totally matches the darkness you acheve
even though I don't have to do ANYTHING with this look, I watched this video. This is the kind of magic Michelle has on me!
its perfectly nice just need i more touch which is the silver should have been a silver mixed with a peachy green and the crown was white ^3^
It's call BLACK swan... It's suppose to be dark and black...
watch the freaking movie -_- Dalina Huynh
Oh, sorry... I didn't want it to sound mean and I'm also sorry cause I haven't watched the movie :(
I'm the same age as u, just 1 year older
lol we shouldn't even be here :v Dalina Huynh
how much eyeliner did you use:)
I love michelle phan but her gentle voice really starts to annoy me after a while o_o
I love her voice like that and I've watched a LOT of her videos
I feel you...
I can’t believe it has been 13 years! I was reminded about Michelle by Honeysuckle it is so odd to see these videos again. But boy you made my days 13 years ago!!!!🎉
why are u wisper
this looks like my niece just did her make up._.
Where was she going..
O.o who the swan?
LOL..your niece that she wanted her make up like that..
That's not what i was trying to transmit ..that her make up looks childish.
i know
I don't understand why this chick is so famous, he work is a bit lousy and DEF "Promise Phan" would do a heck of a better job!!!
I'm not one of those missing the "old michelle phan" but I have to say, I love your voice in this
This was wonderful! I was The Black Swan for Halloween 2011 and used this tutorial for my make up. Keep them coming Michelle!
a great tutorial even after a decade :)
Michelle must be a AN AMAZING artist. Most likely because makeup is just another piece of art for her... (her face is the paper and makeup the materials)
I'm going to a haunted house tonight and this is my costume. Was so happy to see that Michelle had recreated it!! CAN'T WAIT!!!
I'm the black swan this year, and I'm going all out! Thanks for the tutorial, Michelle!
My favourite video of Michelle made one of my last makeup for Halloween !!
I played this parttt! I loved having such a great honor, even though it was difficult.
guys you can ask things, but michelle doesn't awnser. She's an artist.
Thumbs up if ya agree.
this is really good makeup for not watching the movie so talented!!!! :)
Can't wait to do this... I've been planning on being Black Swan for Halloween since i saw the movie when it was out in theaters :D
Michelle Phan is a real artist!
This was the very first video I ever saw of hers, I used this for Halloween a few years ago :D
Love you and your awesome videos Michelle!♥
really awesome! i have to admit this is one of your harder looks.but i love it!!
I love this toturial noir everywhere 😍
I was the Black Swan for Halloween this year! Thanks for this wonderful tutorial to make it all the more wonderful!
michellephan is an amazing make up artist, and this one is really good! and creapy...
THANK YOU SO SO MUCH FOR THIS TUTORIAL! That hand thing was GENIUS!! I've used it in my skating competitions, cause my free program music is from the black swan. :) I just loved it! ♥
I used this for Halloween last year and it came out GREAT. Very comprehensible tutorial!
Definitely doing this for Halloween! Can't wait!
I followed your tutorial for a Halloween party last night and it turned out perfectly! It was a huge help! Thank you for posting this one!! :D
I loved Black Swan and this makeup look really is a work of art
your an artist! this looks amazing!
doing this for halloween, needed to know how to do this, thank you! youre so gorgeous btw! :D
Michelle i am a big fan of yours and thanks for this video, I had made an entrance with this makeup at my annual dinner last night xxx
Using this for halloween - TONIGHT! Excited - going to look awesome :D
Thanks to Michelle, I have i know what i'm gonna be for halloween for the next 9 years.
the evil red eyes give me goosebumps >.
Beautiful! Love the look and the music is so pretty.
i dont understand the dislikes. michelle you are awesome
am i the only one who thinks its really funny how serious these videos are?
Watching this over and over, so I don't mess up!
that was fun :) I liked how the red eyes made the silver pop!
Black Swan is one of my favorite movies!
Love this look. Has to be one of my favorites. Like top 3 favorites :)
you are so cute and your turotial is sooo good, your voice is so calm
So beautiful. Thanks-I'll be using this for Halloween!
Michelle this looks amazing! Great job :)
I always enjoy watching make up tut's, not because i'm a make up artist but i'm curious how they do the painting, and the tehniques behind it!
the film is soooooooooooooooooo beautiful and i love this look!!!!!!!!
I successfully did this look for Halloween!(: I got so many compliments, thanks Michelle!
Looks better on you than on one of the most beautiful actresses in hollywood. WOW
omg the contacts are so creepy! this look is impressive and creative
You are really good at this!
Wow! Identical to the look in the movie!
Absolutely beautiful work on the face. I will be bringing my laptop into the bathroom on Halloween,
This is so amazing. Seriously. I try out your tutorials, but I fail. xD You're so talented!!!!
this is beautiful
OMG her voice sounds like she whispers! Love this :)
Thanks for this video! It helped me so much to complete my costume since i was planning being Black Swan for halloween since i saw the film :D
Bro I was looking for a make tutorial, cause im probably gonna be dressin up for Halloween. And I see its you. I watched u when i growing up 😭
Makeup*
Wow that's amazing I doubt I will ever be able to do the makeup this well
"it should look like a whisper" lol.
•
•
•
•
•
Nice tutorial though I love BLACK SWAN!!
You did it better than the actual movie :-)
You're amazing! I could never do this!!
Yeah
you did this so close to christmas!!!
Amazing!!! Great job! It looks almost as exact! 👏
those contacts are crazy!!
You did a remarkable job!
Your voice sounds so soft and pretty :)
that is so cool!!!! good job!
I love these tutorials!!!
This Make-up was amazing *.* Halloween-Party - they all say it looks really good ;) thx Michelle...and I give them this link for own practis!
I love how I always watch makeup videos but never do them :D
I miss Michelle Phan so much. I hope she comes back.
This is not make-up this is ART
thank you so much for posting this :) it's going to be so useful for my halloween costume! :)
Very elegant look .
I love black swan
i did this for my formal Ariel dance show....it was called "Birds of a feather" and i was the black swan love this look but my make up failed....lolz i was the most creative person there!!! any way Keep up the AWESOME work Michelle!!!!!!
Omg, this is beautiful:3 I'm going to try it for a party (:
Wow, you're a great artist!
Being the Black Swan for Halloween ❤
that is amazing you have a talent I've tried all your tutorials there awesome!!!!!
"It should look like a whisper, soft and delicate" because you know, whispers are in fact visible.