Wait, i don't think its beomgyu's voice . I think its hueningkai and soobin . Don't you think so . If you listen from their cd, its literally sounds like kaibin voice . 😭
@@gracechin3212 no, its hueningkai . Listen carefully . Theres a different between beomgyu and hueningkai voice . Hueningkai voice are deep but more high than beomgyu . But lets wait until they tell us themself .
this gives me flashbacks of beomgyu recommending maze in the mirror to listen to when you're about to sleep but he really emphasized not to listen to eternally lmaoo, he even said he tried it himself and boii didn't like itꉂ (´∀｀) this was beomgyu when he was listening to eternally before sleeping: ( ु⁎ᴗ_ᴗ⁎)ु.σ)_ಠ)
@@nmdarmybts_hope aaww poor angel 🥺 I kinda think Eternally has a sexy sound, so I sometimes blush while listening to it, If I listen before sleeping, I won't sleep for sure lol
That part! Someone asked what song to play while sleeping inna light room w bubbles and yellow sheets and I said eternally, thats BC I didn't listen to the full thing and what's even funnier is that person agreed w me 😭😭😭😭
No way the scariest mv u should check out dreamcatchers mvs for like chase me and goodnight and vixx's voodoo doll for scary/disturbing and or natures mv for girls uncensored
xternl-_- it’s been released! It does a bit of TU story building. If you’re confused by the storyline, it builds upon the universe BigHit has built since TXT’s debut. th-cam.com/video/mxlloUcfUy0/w-d-xo.html. A good video to explain the TU th-cam.com/video/Q4jkD2eLja4/w-d-xo.html.
@@apersonwholovescats79613 sorry i must've been so excited when i saw pd reacting to txt that i forgot bout the pronouns. My bad. That is why i use pd more in the narrative instead of he/she. Will be more careful next time! Tq for pointing it out.
I think we can all agree that pd is us when they heard eternity we were all clowns when we thought its gonna be a slow song...then yeonjun came.......everyone that is why I have trust issues
I swear there HAS to be a choreo for eternally. Cuz like imagine them *just* *sitting* *there* and singing it. I could never watch that and NOT feel awkward
when yeonjun danced to it on their t:time, i hope that was actually him spoiling us about the choreo(ಥ﹏ಥ) but now that we're about to move on to another era and also txt saying that there are songs in this album that seems like it has a choreo but it really doesn't have one... i've already given up(༎ຶ⌑༎ຶ)
the way txt said on their live like theyre literally indeed experiment that eternally song, theyre also confused on what the music turned to.. and when the album release theyre shocked heoe
Totally agree that this is my fav album/ep TXT has released (although TDC:M will always hold a place in my heart). I love being able to see how their music transitions and grows; like, it's crazy just the RANGE of genres and styles they've already tackled and they've only been here a little over year. Also, seeing people's 1st reaction to Eternally will never stop being hilarious😂😂 That song really catches you all the way off guard 1st time around.
If there isn't yet, I wanna see a mashup reaction or reaction compilations for Eternally. Seeing everybody getting shook at the beat switch will never not be funny. That song is a troll, clowning us. MOAs, we're always gonna be a circus 😂
I was fvcking ready to cry when i was listening to eternally for the first time cause the melody is SO , SO emotional but then it suddenly went ..... P.s. : the way it goes back to the first section like it did not make everyone lose their sh*t a few seconds ago makes me want to punch the wall ! P.s 2 : This is my favorite txt album and one of my favorite albums from 2020 so far .... I've always loved and appreciated txt but I could never connect with their besides but this album .... they freaking snapped .... I really hope the producers do this well with their future albums ! P.s.3 : I love how their albums are like actual novels/story books .... even their title track names tell stories , the stories are really interesting to follow !
I feel like each album shows their growth and we would have gotten one more...younger teenage type of song if they hadn't all gotten sick around that same time. But their songs are slowly getting more mature, this album out me in mind of rebellious teenager. Their version of angst. I've actually loved all of their albums so far, even the slower song and I'm not a ballad kind of girl. Eternally still fucks me up though
There is no song in their discography that I don’t like, they just have 3 albums, 20 songs (if you count Sweat) but I love everything they released. It’s hard because usually there is always 1 song, I’m like not really my vibe, especially for the albums groups released in their first years, as they normally get better with time. But TXT in their first year already got me, now 1 year and few months old, they are already 2nd in my top Kpop group, just with their discography alone. Falling in love with the boys too, but with their music alone they got me til the end, and until now make me proud to be a MOA.
100% totally agree!!!! The reason i'm choosing TXT as my ultimate bias (even tho TXT wasn't the first group I stanning to) because I didn't have song that I don't like from them
TXT give me a major Red Velvet vibes, they're always coming to surprise and i love them for that because it makes me really curious to see how they're gonna grown musically as the years go by. I also agree with eternity being they best work up to date, even if i love tdc magic with all my heart every song in this album stand out so much and everytime i listen to it on loop it gets more exciting. Thanks for your reaction once again.
pd reacting to eternally in a nutshell "woah" "👁👄👁" "wHAT THE" "•~•" "v-v" **is so done with the switch-up** **facepalm** **is sentimental** "what. did. i. just. listen. to." can't wait to see them react to the mv
TXT is gonna make a big name for themselves with the direction they are going~ they are great performers, singers, dancers, rappers, and they are gradually participating in their musical production...im so hyped up for what they'll show us in the future~~
I remember lying down and listening to the whole album at 2:00 am and eternally scared the shit out of me. It didnt help that i live somewhere thats quiet and scary but it was the best experience ive ever had listening to an album.
you know when you’re having a really nice dream and everything is beautiful and magical and stuff and then out of nowhere it turns into a nightmare?? thats eternally
I feel like you're totally gonna freak out at the Eternally MV- like it's apart of their storyline and it's gives the vibe of a cinematic movie or something !! Aaaaaa it's so cool!! And the Puma MV too!!
I personally think you will love the eternally music video because it is an absolute work of ART . I was mind blown and I think it's one of the best kpop music videos cause even if it's long , it makes you feel drawn towards it and you don't feel like pausing the video at all.
PD should definitely check out the Eternally MV. When PD said they were enveloped in a cloud, I was like yeah PD needs to see the MV, I still go and watch it cause every time I watch it I find some thing new that I hadn’t noticed! 🤯
TDC: Eternity seriously got me so excited about the future for TXT, the growth and variety they've shown is amazing. This was the EP that got me so much more into their music, not that their previous songs weren't good but this one showed so much more of them and I can't wait for their future projects!!
When this album comes out, I started to understand TXT. And I really like this group from my heart. I know kpop is often called manufactured. However, while bighit keeps their production on a lined standard, TXT is in my comfortable zone of taste
indeed intellectuals will appreciate Eternally, that song is like a roller coaster ride in a whole another level, it was shocking at first but dang it is so addicting!! I thought their 2nd EP were already amazing, but noooooo this EP just snatched that no. 1 spot for me, their growth for every comeback is insane!!
i truly think this album is one of the bests of this year so far. there's no arguing that. it's such a solid project and it's been MONTHS !!! i cannot stop listening to it ever since it came out
TXT has one of the best discographies in Kpop atm, people should sleeping on them. I would understand if they didn’t know about TXT, but it’s inexcusable when they purposefully refuse to listen to them. I see so much hate towards them from kpop stans for no reason at all. Their songs are so good, people need to atleast give it a listen before judging!!! I really hope they get really really big soon cuz everyone needs to hear them!!! These boys are so talented! They are really unique, their songs are so good, their lyrics are so so good.
pd looked in distress the whole time thru eternally LMFAOOO as we all were i rlly was like is this the same song??? THEN BEOMGYU OUT HERE SAYING HE WANNA END THE WORLD LIKE WTF iconic 10:13 LOVE CHERRY MOTION VIBES FR that was my first thought too wksbsndn
Eternally was the album which got txt the most popularity...everyone's noticing them....they are being the first 4th gen boy group with 1 million sales
LMAOOOO Eternally... I remember that first time fondly. I’m cryinggg that 8:07 face sums it up quite nicely. I was on the bus on my way to work when I heard it and I started looking around like ??? are y’all hearing this ??? like beautiful slow harmonies to like gun shots ?? And heavy bass ??? It was wild. But I’m obsessed with that song even though it’s a nightmare.
This is easily the best EP in Kpop history in my opinion The production in every song is just so rich and full and intense and it overwhelms you and engulfs you in it and takes you for the journey that it wants
Idk who the hell are the creative and production team but I have trust that bighit isnt going anywhere and will continue to go strong. Very proud on how far everyone in that company have come.
Eternally is two-faced song and your reaction to it priceless and then you got "choerry love cherry motion flashback" 🤣🤣 I hope you react to PUMA and Eternally MV Edited: wtf I saw someone comments from 1 weeks ago I'm confused???!?!
some songs just sound wrong when they do the shit that eternally did but HONEY ETERNALLY WAS EXECUTED PERFECTLY the change of beats didn't sound out of place at all oh lord........ the power of this song
Tbh I like Eternally but I was raging internally when I first heard it (and still a little every time) because the beginning of Eternally is my favorite from TXT ever. And the other part is good too but I would just love to enjoy the vibe of the first part without being jarred into another universe off and on. haha. But that being said, I'm so proud of TXT. This album was experimental and innovative. Their last album was too. But I just feel like they keep pushing themselves and the genre and I'm obsessed with that.
This album is really a masterpiece all the b-side are really great... that’s reminds me cix’s albums with literally no SKIPS pls react to their album one day!!
Me: "PD just got Love Cherry Motioned" PD like 5 seconds later: "I just got Love Cherry Motioned" I laughed so fucking hard dude. But yeah aside from that, I wasn't THAT into TXT other than like their main title tracks and then I checked out Puma and thought the album would be worth a listen and I was not disappointed. Like genuinely impressed. Hoping to check out more of their stuff now
When I first listened to Eternally, I immediately thought: *Love Choerry Motion has entered the chat* Then my next thought was “PD is going to LOVE remembering the shock from it😂” but honestly tho, eternally I think is my favorite like I just love the 😇 😈 switching vibes
You need to see Eternally MV, you will understand the song is like a beautiful story that turns into nightmare. You will understand why that song sounds like that.
This album is really just a whole masterpiece. Every track is almost eligible as a title track. I understand how you felt while listening to Eternally, PD. You're not alone sjsjsksksksjjsjsjsk
a perfect listening party for a perfect ep! thank you so much for the reaction pd! i would recommend the two mvs that came out for this cb, "puma" and "eternally" - eternally is a txt style storytelling mv and it's 20 minutes long, but it's so incredible that you barely notice how long it really is. thank you so much from an excited moa
I love Eternally as is, but a little part inside of me secretly wants to have a seperate song for just the soft parts of eternally into one. I know their is a story behind it but just the voice of them during the soft parts is just so beautiful it makes me want to cry.
the way my anticipation grew the more he was vibing to the begining of eternally. just waiting. for him to feel what we all felt. god the slow parts of that song are so beautiful but i was SHOOK.
eternally: dont go breaking my heart :((
also eternally: 'gunshots' 'betrayal' 'beomgyu wants to end this world'
this made me chuckle ngl lmao
Wait, i don't think its beomgyu's voice . I think its hueningkai and soobin . Don't you think so . If you listen from their cd, its literally sounds like kaibin voice . 😭
Nraa Channel its beomgyus voice lol
Nraa Channel its Beomgyu’s voice.
@@gracechin3212 no, its hueningkai . Listen carefully . Theres a different between beomgyu and hueningkai voice . Hueningkai voice are deep but more high than beomgyu . But lets wait until they tell us themself .
LMFAOO I was waiting for Eternally to play
Same 😂😂
Sammeee
SAMELMAOOWJWOUEKSHSJSH
Same!! Lol
Same but at the same time enjoying
Everyone was like " eternally is my new lullaby " but when they heard the beat switch they were like " hell no it's not " 😂😂😂😂
lullaby plus a free nightmare lmao
this gives me flashbacks of beomgyu recommending maze in the mirror to listen to when you're about to sleep but he really emphasized not to listen to eternally lmaoo, he even said he tried it himself and boii didn't like itꉂ (´∀｀)
this was beomgyu when he was listening to eternally before sleeping: ( ु⁎ᴗ_ᴗ⁎)ु.σ)_ಠ)
@@nmdarmybts_hope aaww poor angel 🥺
I kinda think Eternally has a sexy sound, so I sometimes blush while listening to it, If I listen before sleeping, I won't sleep for sure lol
That part! Someone asked what song to play while sleeping inna light room w bubbles and yellow sheets and I said eternally, thats BC I didn't listen to the full thing and what's even funnier is that person agreed w me 😭😭😭😭
@@helencristine1845 that's so strange but I can understand what u mean 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Dang PD is gonna flip shit when they see the Eternally and Puma MV
Eternally MV is a freaking short movie 😂
Melani Rodriguez their pronouns are they/them if you didn’t know.
@@El-vq8tx thank you for letting me know, I've fixed it💜
That's. all I've been thinking about omg
Melani Rodriguez no problem
TXT doesn't have a lot of strong rap sections but when they do, it really slaps.
Especially in Puma it slaps haaard
@@Aro-ed5hf ikr~ the way how yeonjun eats the flow is insane
can't wait to hear more of their rapping in the future(ノ﹏ヽ)
They add it where it is necessary.. they just don't put a random rap in any songs.. so there songs really slaps
IKR! Can’t wait for a full on Cypher thing from them
Eternally has to be a contender for "Bohemian Rhapsody of Kpop" with all the other Kpop songs that brings you in different places
HAHSHSJAJA YES
you're right
eternally, i got a boy, love cherry motion, the holy trinity
Omg, this the most perfect description I've seen. Soooooo true
skz my side as well haha
txt are really the group that the kpop community is sleeping on right now
Louder🙄
Yess
Louderrrr
Say louder kpopies really like to underestimate and underappreciate them
It’s not that they are sleeping on them, they are purposely ignoring them and hating on them. Envy is an ugly thing.
PD's look of *_utter confusion_* during Eternally is SUCH A MOOD. 😆 They done us a bamboozle & PD's kinda mad about it. 😅
Wait how is this comment from a week ago🤯
@@jessica.n Probably Patreon
I came here just to see him reacting to Eternally,because the first time I listened to it, the thing was crazy hahahah
@@adriellechiaki3891 they use they/them pronouns :))
Eternally MV is even scarier than the song, probably the scariest MV in Kpop ever
Astraea Natsuki unsettling, maybe, but i wouldn't say scary
No way the scariest mv u should check out dreamcatchers mvs for like chase me and goodnight and vixx's voodoo doll for scary/disturbing and or natures mv for girls uncensored
@@a.r.m.ymoaengene6250 yess! But Eternally did give me a lot chills and creepy vibes.
@@a.r.m.ymoaengene6250 oof especially vixx voodoo doll 19+ ver. the pain in that mv i swear
Eternally is definitely one of the most unsettling, but not really scary for me
I'm sorry but seeing PD's expressions during Eternally is hilarious!!! They’re so confused...wait until they see the MV.
Hi! PD goes by they/them pronouns if you didn't know
when is the MV btw?
Illy oh! I didn’t kno! Sorry! Making edit now!
xternl-_- it’s been released! It does a bit of TU story building. If you’re confused by the storyline, it builds upon the universe BigHit has built since TXT’s debut. th-cam.com/video/mxlloUcfUy0/w-d-xo.html. A good video to explain the TU th-cam.com/video/Q4jkD2eLja4/w-d-xo.html.
@@hauntedwrld It was already released, it's 19 mins long
the way pd just look like getting crushed while listening to puma and then eternally especially the part switch. thats me. pd is me reacting ahhahaha
their pronouns are they/them
@@apersonwholovescats79613 omg are they, omg I feel bad now, I'll call them them now
@@apersonwholovescats79613 sorry i must've been so excited when i saw pd reacting to txt that i forgot bout the pronouns. My bad. That is why i use pd more in the narrative instead of he/she. Will be more careful next time! Tq for pointing it out.
eternally, not eternity lmao it's confusing.
@@chipmunkse_ HAHAHA omg after hundreds of likes lmao tq for pointing it out 😂
“I got Love Cherry Motion’ed hard” LMFAOOOO THAT’S THE BEST THING I’VE HEARD ALL DAY
Pretty accurate
QwertyOrbit choerry traumatized pd so bad and he’ll never let it go 😭😭😭😭😭
Their reaction to that song was priceless
I was thinking the same thing as him lol.
Get Choerryed lmao
Can't wait for PD to see the eternally video!! What a ride
Also love how PD agrees that this album has no skips
Yessss
Seatbelt on, PD?
I think we can all agree that pd is us when they heard eternity we were all clowns when we thought its gonna be a slow song...then yeonjun came.......everyone that is why I have trust issues
Pd actually uses they/them pronouns in case you didn't know
didn't expect to find celeste here lmao
Yeonjun and Hueningkai happened! 🌟
I swear there HAS to be a choreo for eternally. Cuz like imagine them *just* *sitting* *there* and singing it. I could never watch that and NOT feel awkward
when yeonjun danced to it on their t:time, i hope that was actually him spoiling us about the choreo(ಥ﹏ಥ) but now that we're about to move on to another era and also txt saying that there are songs in this album that seems like it has a choreo but it really doesn't have one... i've already given up(༎ຶ⌑༎ຶ)
SAME I'm still holding onto the hope that they'll perform it at a year-end award show!!!
@An_ndrea i'm sorry but what's cwylma?
@@spi1743 I think it's supposed to be can't we keep the monster alive
@@icybird9999 oh i see2x, thanks btw
PD: " Cat & Dog kinda goes REALLY REALLY HARD"
Me: HECK YEAH! "FEEL LIKE CINDERELLA NAEGA BYEONHAE!!!"
*Head bopping intensifies*
I LITERALLY SCREAM FEEL LIKE CINDERELLA NAEGA BYEONHAE WHEN HE SAID THAT
HAAHAH so accurate
Legendary line
I C O N I C and that's on PERIODT.
BARK BARK WOOF WOOF
*dog noises intensifies*
Txt talked on Vlive about how hard and different this album was for them vocally and how experimental it was. I absolutely love this for them!
He will turn mad if he'll know that eternally has 19 mins long mv.....and that's next level art....
LMAO😂
Hiiii pd goes by they/them pronouns ♡
Blue Papaya But he’s clearly a man?
@@joshrogers2719 pronouns dont equal gender
you said it, pal. and yeah, please refer to them as they/them !!
the way txt said on their live like theyre literally indeed experiment that eternally song, theyre also confused on what the music turned to.. and when the album release theyre shocked heoe
It honestly reminds me of a billie eilish song with that beat switch. It was a rlly pleasant surprise
Totally agree that this is my fav album/ep TXT has released (although TDC:M will always hold a place in my heart). I love being able to see how their music transitions and grows; like, it's crazy just the RANGE of genres and styles they've already tackled and they've only been here a little over year.
Also, seeing people's 1st reaction to Eternally will never stop being hilarious😂😂 That song really catches you all the way off guard 1st time around.
Yesss this album is legendary.
ooh yes magic has a place in my heart too
If there isn't yet, I wanna see a mashup reaction or reaction compilations for Eternally. Seeing everybody getting shook at the beat switch will never not be funny. That song is a troll, clowning us. MOAs, we're always gonna be a circus 😂
TDCM, yas my favorite album too!!
I was fvcking ready to cry when i was listening to eternally for the first time cause the melody is SO , SO emotional but then it suddenly went .....
P.s. : the way it goes back to the first section like it did not make everyone lose their sh*t a few seconds ago makes me want to punch the wall !
P.s 2 : This is my favorite txt album and one of my favorite albums from 2020 so far .... I've always loved and appreciated txt but I could never connect with their besides but this album .... they freaking snapped .... I really hope the producers do this well with their future albums !
P.s.3 : I love how their albums are like actual novels/story books .... even their title track names tell stories , the stories are really interesting to follow !
I feel like each album shows their growth and we would have gotten one more...younger teenage type of song if they hadn't all gotten sick around that same time. But their songs are slowly getting more mature, this album out me in mind of rebellious teenager. Their version of angst. I've actually loved all of their albums so far, even the slower song and I'm not a ballad kind of girl. Eternally still fucks me up though
if you'll watch the mvs for puma and eternally you'll get the context more. and trust me you'll love it
There is no song in their discography that I don’t like, they just have 3 albums, 20 songs (if you count Sweat) but I love everything they released. It’s hard because usually there is always 1 song, I’m like not really my vibe, especially for the albums groups released in their first years, as they normally get better with time.
But TXT in their first year already got me, now 1 year and few months old, they are already 2nd in my top Kpop group, just with their discography alone. Falling in love with the boys too, but with their music alone they got me til the end, and until now make me proud to be a MOA.
D3bS ACDM RIGHT?! At first I wasnt feeling CWJLTMA or Poppin Star but looking back know theyre amazing. Txt literally has no bad songs 😭😭
100% totally agree!!!! The reason i'm choosing TXT as my ultimate bias (even tho TXT wasn't the first group I stanning to) because I didn't have song that I don't like from them
Sorry if you guys like BlackPink but I tell you that they have the same amount of songs as BlackPink lol
Blackpink = 2016
txt = 2019
@@luckyrage1000 lol really?
Same for me
TXT give me a major Red Velvet vibes, they're always coming to surprise and i love them for that because it makes me really curious to see how they're gonna grown musically as the years go by. I also agree with eternity being they best work up to date, even if i love tdc magic with all my heart every song in this album stand out so much and everytime i listen to it on loop it gets more exciting. Thanks for your reaction once again.
I was thinking the exact same thing!
Ikr😆 they're like the boy versions of RV😂
YES YES YES, I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE!!😁🙌🏼
Reason why I stan both groups. I love how diverse they are and I'm excited to see TXT music development ✨
Oh MY GOSH WHY ARE PPL READING MY MIND. I was at work and I had this thought in my mind. I thought I was only one
pd reacting to eternally in a nutshell
"woah" "👁👄👁" "wHAT THE" "•~•" "v-v" **is so done with the switch-up** **facepalm** **is sentimental** "what. did. i. just. listen. to."
can't wait to see them react to the mv
pd’s pronouns are they/them! pls don’t use he/him pronouns
@@luna-pr3go oh,, im sorry i didn't know, don't worry i edited it ^^
len ah thankyou! sorry if I came across as harsh, I didn’t mean to! :(
TXT is gonna make a big name for themselves with the direction they are going~ they are great performers, singers, dancers, rappers, and they are gradually participating in their musical production...im so hyped up for what they'll show us in the future~~
They're now the first 4th Gen group to be nominated at the AMAs!!
"cat & dog kinda goes hard" KINDA??????? ITS A BANGERRRRRR
Your expression for Eternally priceless.
Watch the MV 😬
i remember getting soooo scared listening to eternally in bed at midnight
THIS IS LITERALLY ME OMG
I remember lying down and listening to the whole album at 2:00 am and eternally scared the shit out of me. It didnt help that i live somewhere thats quiet and scary but it was the best experience ive ever had listening to an album.
Also eternally gave me legit goosebumps.
THE WAY THEY LOOKED SO ANGRY 😂😂
they*
@@zzerutan thank u 💕
you know when you’re having a really nice dream and everything is beautiful and magical and stuff and then out of nowhere it turns into a nightmare?? thats eternally
I feel like you're totally gonna freak out at the Eternally MV- like it's apart of their storyline and it's gives the vibe of a cinematic movie or something !! Aaaaaa it's so cool!! And the Puma MV too!!
there is no single skip on this album fr they're becoming better and better every comeback
✿ Time Stamps !!!
0:00 Puma
6:16 Eternally
THANK U OMF 😭😭
Thank u
Thank you
Thank you
Thanks
everyone knows that we're all waiting for the reaction on that eternally switch up
I personally think you will love the eternally music video because it is an absolute work of ART . I was mind blown and I think it's one of the best kpop music videos cause even if it's long , it makes you feel drawn towards it and you don't feel like pausing the video at all.
The MV for Eternally is absolutely crazy.
PD should definitely check out the Eternally MV. When PD said they were enveloped in a cloud, I was like yeah PD needs to see the MV, I still go and watch it cause every time I watch it I find some thing new that I hadn’t noticed! 🤯
day dream thanks for letting me know, I edited my comment, I was not aware of it, but will keep it in mind going forward! 🙂
TDC: Eternity seriously got me so excited about the future for TXT, the growth and variety they've shown is amazing. This was the EP that got me so much more into their music, not that their previous songs weren't good but this one showed so much more of them and I can't wait for their future projects!!
YOUR ETERNALLY REACTION IS ALL IVE BEEN WAITING FOR HAHAHAHDBX
the unexpected switch up is actually what i really love about eternally
when yeonjun opens his mouth to rap.... its game over yall
When this album comes out, I started to understand TXT. And I really like this group from my heart. I know kpop is often called manufactured. However, while bighit keeps their production on a lined standard, TXT is in my comfortable zone of taste
indeed intellectuals will appreciate Eternally, that song is like a roller coaster ride in a whole another level, it was shocking at first but dang it is so addicting!! I thought their 2nd EP were already amazing, but noooooo this EP just snatched that no. 1 spot for me, their growth for every comeback is insane!!
i truly think this album is one of the bests of this year so far. there's no arguing that.
it's such a solid project and it's been MONTHS !!! i cannot stop listening to it ever since it came out
As soon as Eternally started, I just sat there with the most evil grin on my face waiting for PD to get their shit rocked by the beat switch 🤣🤣🤣
My exact same reaction while listening to eternity....TxT takes me to both heaven and hell with that song and I absolutely love it. 😂
I'M WHEEZING WITH THE ETERNALLY REACTION OMFG
TXT has one of the best discographies in Kpop atm, people should sleeping on them. I would understand if they didn’t know about TXT, but it’s inexcusable when they purposefully refuse to listen to them. I see so much hate towards them from kpop stans for no reason at all. Their songs are so good, people need to atleast give it a listen before judging!!! I really hope they get really really big soon cuz everyone needs to hear them!!! These boys are so talented! They are really unique, their songs are so good, their lyrics are so so good.
Honestly your reaction to Eternally was everyone's reaction to Eternally
txt literally have a no skip discography
He had the pikachu meme face when eternally played... I'm crying💀
The way you cant even define TXT by the genre, they just have their own identity no matter what genre it is.
pd looked in distress the whole time thru eternally LMFAOOO as we all were i rlly was like is this the same song???
THEN BEOMGYU OUT HERE SAYING HE WANNA END THE WORLD LIKE WTF iconic
10:13 LOVE CHERRY MOTION VIBES FR that was my first thought too wksbsndn
PD's face while listening Eternally was everythring JAJAJAJAJAAJA
He felt so blessed.... then the ultimate betrayal took place😭😭😭
Your reaction to Eternally was PRICELESS.
6:12 "last but not least we have eternally"
Me: 'CAN'T WAIT' 😈
Eternally was the album which got txt the most popularity...everyone's noticing them....they are being the first 4th gen boy group with 1 million sales
i LOVE watching ppl's reaction to eternally and you did NOT disappoint
I come back here every once in a while to see PDs face during Eternally. Always gives me the giggles 🤭
LMAOOOO Eternally... I remember that first time fondly. I’m cryinggg that 8:07 face sums it up quite nicely. I was on the bus on my way to work when I heard it and I started looking around like ??? are y’all hearing this ??? like beautiful slow harmonies to like gun shots ?? And heavy bass ??? It was wild. But I’m obsessed with that song even though it’s a nightmare.
This is easily the best EP in Kpop history in my opinion
The production in every song is just so rich and full and intense and it overwhelms you and engulfs you in it and takes you for the journey that it wants
Idk who the hell are the creative and production team but I have trust that bighit isnt going anywhere and will continue to go strong. Very proud on how far everyone in that company have come.
I feel like all of us wait for eternally song😅 the greatest twist that I ever heard . Its like riding a rollercoaster haha.
PD is having an existential crisis with Eternally lol😂😂😂
Eternally is two-faced song and your reaction to it priceless and then you got "choerry love cherry motion flashback" 🤣🤣
I hope you react to PUMA and Eternally MV
Edited: wtf I saw someone comments from 1 weeks ago I'm confused???!?!
@Melody Dya patreon comments
*ETERNALLY IS THE BIGGEST PLOT TWIST OF 2020*
Do eternally mv and puma mv. They were literally art
ofc txt don't have enough rapping cause txt second rapper didn't even debuted ...i'm crying..please bh let our soobin rapper debut already
I was saying the same bighit give a full rap bside to txt in next album
Txt second rapper didn't even debuted? Who is it? Omg I'm a new MOA please tell me
some songs just sound wrong when they do the shit that eternally did but HONEY ETERNALLY WAS EXECUTED PERFECTLY the change of beats didn't sound out of place at all oh lord........ the power of this song
Tbh I like Eternally but I was raging internally when I first heard it (and still a little every time) because the beginning of Eternally is my favorite from TXT ever. And the other part is good too but I would just love to enjoy the vibe of the first part without being jarred into another universe off and on. haha.
But that being said, I'm so proud of TXT. This album was experimental and innovative. Their last album was too. But I just feel like they keep pushing themselves and the genre and I'm obsessed with that.
If u haven't seen this yet then here u go: th-cam.com/video/RJiodxy5gV0/w-d-xo.html
@@monohanie5778 OHMYGOSH BLESS YOU!!!
This album is really a masterpiece all the b-side are really great... that’s reminds me cix’s albums with literally no SKIPS pls react to their album one day!!
It hurt me when you rate 9 to "Fairy of Shampoo" 😭😂 personally, my favorite song of TXT in general
It’s a remake song is not a txt original song
YES it’s my favorite kpop song like ever 💀
txt‘s discography is elite
The eternally mv definitely gives good context to the bait and switch.
It think Eternally is like when you're dreaming, it can switch from a nice dream to a horrifying nightmare and then back to normala again
Its a bit long but PLEASE PD react to the eternally mv its like nothing I've ever seeeeeeeeen
eternally made me feel like how you did too, the same warmth before the fall
PUMA JUST KEEPS GETTING BETTER AND BETTER AS YOU GO ON I LOVE IT SO MUCH
Me: "PD just got Love Cherry Motioned"
PD like 5 seconds later: "I just got Love Cherry Motioned"
I laughed so fucking hard dude.
But yeah aside from that, I wasn't THAT into TXT other than like their main title tracks and then I checked out Puma and thought the album would be worth a listen and I was not disappointed. Like genuinely impressed. Hoping to check out more of their stuff now
thank you for giving a chance to them🤗
Thank u so much 😊😊
The way you reacted to "Eternally " its basically everyone in 2020. Started nice but then BAM!!
Your reaction to eternally sums up 2020
the moment of silence after eternally 😭
When I first listened to Eternally, I immediately thought: *Love Choerry Motion has entered the chat* Then my next thought was “PD is going to LOVE remembering the shock from it😂” but honestly tho, eternally I think is my favorite like I just love the 😇 😈 switching vibes
Timestamps for everyone ✨
0:09 PUMA
6:16 Eternally
You need to see Eternally MV, you will understand the song is like a beautiful story that turns into nightmare. You will understand why that song sounds like that.
pd-nim, its only the audio you've heard for eternally, what more if you see the mv 🤣
Eternally was THAT song that surprised me so much When it came out i was freaking crazy!!!!
Pd: 8:08 looks at the camera like in the office
Yup thats it we need a reaction for eternally mv
pd having a breakdown listening to eternally is SUCH mood
This album is really just a whole masterpiece. Every track is almost eligible as a title track.
I understand how you felt while listening to Eternally, PD. You're not alone sjsjsksksksjjsjsjsk
Gotta love Eternally (aka whiplash in song form) making people question life itself.
me when i see his reactions on Eternally: same dude. same.
a perfect listening party for a perfect ep! thank you so much for the reaction pd! i would recommend the two mvs that came out for this cb, "puma" and "eternally" - eternally is a txt style storytelling mv and it's 20 minutes long, but it's so incredible that you barely notice how long it really is. thank you so much from an excited moa
I love Eternally as is, but a little part inside of me secretly wants to have a seperate song for just the soft parts of eternally into one. I know their is a story behind it but just the voice of them during the soft parts is just so beautiful it makes me want to cry.
the way my anticipation grew the more he was vibing to the begining of eternally. just waiting. for him to feel what we all felt. god the slow parts of that song are so beautiful but i was SHOOK.
Until this day I'm still waiting for PD's reaction to Eternally MV before the new era contents drops.
They look like their about to cry, laugh, and break something simultaneously while listening to Eternally