Bora did this and says so in the Miracle Musical reddit AMA: " I recorded the piano part first. Then I played that recording through my speakers, pointing directly at my piano strings. Leaving a barbell on the sustain pedal to keep them resonating, I recorded the piano strings as the speakers played the piano part."
I was thinking of making an edit to that part where (if you’re into markiplier) we’re walking around markiplier manor then we get shot and fall (in who killed markiplier)
Miracle Musical has some of the band members from Tally Hall. I might be wrong tho but this is not like a huge problem I think Andrew played the piano.@@henryboi_hehe
im currently learning this song on piano, but im not the best at reading sheet music, so i have to watch this over & over again to make sure im playing the left hand right lmao
@@GabrielaMilleo thanks for asking!! im getting there. i have the right hand/main melody going p smooth, but im still struggling with the left. tbh im kinda just waiting for someone to make a midi/piano roll for this since it's a lot easier for me to understand that way lmao
@@resident_simon Nice! Ive tried learning Hidden in The Sand on the piano but I cant really play it, my hands tremble too much, hope you can learn it though! Love this song
I feel as though 1:59 really conveys the array of emotions Simon is really going through upon the sight of his girlfriend murdered 2:00 - 2:15 the enital freak out 2:16 -2:21 the recollect and trying to piece together what happened 2:22 - 2:40 trying to calm himself down, trying to regain his thoughts 2:41 - 3:00 Simon's sorrow starting to kick in 3:01 - 3:31 the crushing reality of the situation finally gets to him
if classical music was a song: (because this song is literally a musical masterpiece, with the arrangement, the key changes, the movements, the instruments + voice)
He was in the forest looking to see the trees But none were there He found a girl She found the Erlking They were in the white wood Gamboling out to picnic In the light leaves broke above Then fell below I was in the middle ground Looking to find the Flowers in the garden Wearying of the hate me hate me not Wait they forgot Woe oh the rot Deeper in they crept Oblivious of the bears and darker terrors Or none were there How did they dare I was in the middle ground Looking to find the Fountain of infinite mirror Tree falling no one would hear Shadow of nobody there Murders of murderers living in fear of it Owls on the night watch Solemn and easily wise to what we thought They thought above Sound broke below They were in the black wood Coveting indiscreetly her for him Or him for her Shown what they were I was in the middle ground Looking to find the Fountain of infinite mirror Tree falling no one would hear Shadow of nobody there Murders of murderers living in fear of it I was in the clearing Buzzing around to hearing but the Bees & birds who knew the words Soon arrived the twilight Finally the night & day remembered How they came to be All for nothing at all All for nothing at all With something to do I was in the forest looking to see the trees But none were there
@@heyo7461 actually, it’s completely different, in The Mind Electric, it didn’t have a deeper piano playing along with it. In Murders, there is. In The Mind Electric, there’s just a single tune, nothing else, like someone is playing with only one to two fingers.
Holy shit this is amazing, I used to dislike the original Murders (I still liked it, but it wasn't my favorite track on the album) but this instrumental makes up for it
idk what you're looking for specifically, but it reminds me of choke from idon'tknowhowbuttheyfoundme. As my sister dubs it, "charlie and the chocolate factory music"
go ahead. sing the words, be cheerful n proud. you deserve it. 🥰 🎶Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror 🎶 🎶Tree falling, no one would hear🎶 🎶Shadow of nobody there🎶
If I had a nickel for every song I know that contains violin and piano and has to do with the murder of a girl close to the male protagonist I would have 2 nickels, which isn't alot but it's weird that it happened twice.
@@patrickosullivan7783 They mean that the shown part, which is 2:41 - 3:00 feels like something out of the song, and they are right, It feels more vintage and significantly calmer, as if it's not related to the actual song. What they are trying to say, is that it would be nice to have that exact part made into an actual vintage-like song, and that they couldn't find the full version and the continuation of that exact piano part, which would be made by someone else, who is talented in re-creating pieces into something new.
Hawaii part II is supposed to mean "the parting of two lovers" and it's supposed to symbolize one of the protagonists perspectives. So Hawaii part I doesn't really exist
It's to bad that this beautiful song became a tik tok audio..and i am also really sad i used to not know about the album and made dumb ahh videos with the songs..so i must say “Woe oh the rot 💔”.
He was in the forest looking to see the trees But none were there He found a girl She found the Erlking (the lover) They were in the white wood Gamboling out to picnic In the light leaves broke above Then fell below I was in the middle ground Looking to find the flowers in the garden Wearying of the hate me, hate me not Wait they forgot Woe, oh the rot Deeper in they crept Oblivious of the bears and darker terrors Or none were there How did they dare I was in the middle ground Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror Tree falling, no one would hear Shadow of nobody there Murders of murderers living in fear of it Owls on the night watch Solemn and easily wise to what we thought They thought above Sound broke below They were in the black wood Coveting indiscreetly her for him Or him for her Shown what they were I was in the middle ground Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror Tree falling, no one would hear Shadow of nobody there Murders of murderers living in fear of it I was in the clearing Buzzing around to hearing But the bees and birds who knew the words Soon arrived the twilight Finally the night and day remembered How they came to be All for nothing at all All for nothing at all With something to do I was in the forest looking to see the trees But none were there
He was in the forest looking to see the trees But none were there He found a girl She found the Erlking (the lover) They were in the white wood Gamboling out to picnic In the light leaves broke above Then fell below I was in the middle ground Looking to find the flowers in the garden Wearying of the hate me, hate me not Wait they forgot Woe, oh the rot Deeper in they crept Oblivious of the bears and darker terrors Or none were there How did they dare I was in the middle ground Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror Tree falling, no one would hear Shadow of nobody there Murders of murderers living in fear of it Owls on the night watch Solemn and easily wise to what we thought They thought above Sound broke below They were in the black wood Coveting indiscreetly her for him Or him for her Shown what they were I was in the middle ground Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror Tree falling, no one would hear Shadow of nobody there Murders of murderers living in fear of it I was in the clearing Buzzing around to hearing But the bees and birds who knew the words Soon arrived the twilight Finally the night and day remembered How they came to be All for nothing at all All for nothing at all With something to do I was in the forest looking to see the trees But none were there
whoever thought to distort the piano is a genius
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Bora did this and says so in the Miracle Musical reddit AMA:
" I recorded the piano part first. Then I played that recording through my speakers, pointing directly at my piano strings. Leaving a barbell on the sustain pedal to keep them resonating, I recorded the piano strings as the speakers played the piano part."
Bora’s doing
@@boingooingo3317 That was for the piano solo before the "All for nothing at all" part.
@@redfiretf2 so Bora played that piano solo ? I always thought it was Joe
1:43 - 2:01 that gave me chills dude
IKR
Most of the instrumentals have that one special part that you would barely hear normally, but it sounds amazing
YEAH
love ur pfp
*notices ur omori pfp*
2:40 for myself it sounds magical and mysterious
I imagine this part playing through a gramophone while wandering/waltzing through an old person’s house
I was thinking of making an edit to that part where (if you’re into markiplier) we’re walking around markiplier manor then we get shot and fall (in who killed markiplier)
That's the part I like best :)
Not me learning that part on piano-
@The Atari Junk Keyboard it sounds like a musical
The percussion at 3:10 sounds a lot louder than it does in the album version
Other people? What’s this?
Grey Bluey Ah I wasnt expecting other people to reply!! I'm glad to see the fandom alive, too :)
its the same volume, you can just hear it better cause the loud vocals arent covering it
sounds better though
the dislike is the person who was murdered
Correction: the dislike was the murdered murderer who was living in fear of it
@@hilariocitii Murder: The Murder was the Murdered Murderer who was Murdering in murder of it.
Edit: Help, Now Murder sounds weird
@@PerFT__GaL Murder: Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder Murder
@@hilariocitii AHAHAHAHAHA
@I don't even know anymore it’s a new update 💁🏻♂️
1:47 i love the whistling on this part
These instrumental versions are making me think about the originals a lot more
Same here, imo the attention to detail is insane
Wow Joe Hawley is a hell of a composer and piano player. I hope he releases new music some day
Andew Horowitz actually played the Piano. @SophiesIsolations
@@tskrinusThat’s tallyhall…
@@tskrinusandrew actually wasn’t a part of miracle musical, at least from what i’ve heard
@@tskrinusbro wdym it was OBVIOUSLY Ross Federman
Miracle Musical has some of the band members from Tally Hall. I might be wrong tho but this is not like a huge problem I think Andrew played the piano.@@henryboi_hehe
I LOVE the random low note at 1:50
SERIOUSLY the small little things are so fricking cool
3:04, that random high note made my HEART ACHE so much, i felt every pain and moment of the instruments
im currently learning this song on piano, but im not the best at reading sheet music, so i have to watch this over & over again to make sure im playing the left hand right lmao
Are you having any progress?
@@GabrielaMilleo thanks for asking!! im getting there. i have the right hand/main melody going p smooth, but im still struggling with the left. tbh im kinda just waiting for someone to make a midi/piano roll for this since it's a lot easier for me to understand that way lmao
@@resident_simon Nice! Ive tried learning Hidden in The Sand on the piano but I cant really play it, my hands tremble too much, hope you can learn it though! Love this song
@@GabrielaMilleo yooo thanks for the motivation!! really needed that :)) ill let you know if i finish it
@@resident_simon Good luck! It can be tough sometimes but the gratification of completing it sure makes up for it imo
I feel as though 1:59 really conveys the array of emotions Simon is really going through upon the sight of his girlfriend murdered
2:00 - 2:15 the enital freak out
2:16 -2:21 the recollect and trying to piece together what happened
2:22 - 2:40 trying to calm himself down, trying to regain his thoughts
2:41 - 3:00 Simon's sorrow starting to kick in
3:01 - 3:31 the crushing reality of the situation finally gets to him
Very cool take
I actually always thought as 3:10 being the moment the girl was murdered
@@Thestuffdoer More like him finding her dead body
It's a shame that it's him who kills her
Exactly what I thought!!
3:10 oh my god that part sounds so much more dramatic and hardcore when just listening to the instrumental wow
The percussion always sounded like someone patting their lap but like really fast
almost like footsteps
@@liamsarmiento6706 yeah
little einsteins taking off
@@tangled8151 you absolute genius
...masturbation?
Someone described this as distorted piano and they be right
it IS a distorted piano >>
if classical music was a song:
(because this song is literally a musical masterpiece, with the arrangement, the key changes, the movements, the instruments + voice)
miracle musical needs to be more noticed, it’s so good!
@@cagedcorvid YES
"if classical music was a song" i think they already did that a few times
ah yes classical electric guitar
3 MINUTES AND 41 SECONDS OF BORAAAAAAAAAAAA YEA
2:00 -2:20 were the best parts in my opinion ngl
Very beautiful
2:43 - 3:10 the best part. amazing
u have no idea how much i love this
He was in the forest looking to see the trees
But none were there
He found a girl
She found the Erlking
They were in the white wood
Gamboling out to picnic
In the light leaves broke above
Then fell below
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the
Flowers in the garden
Wearying of the hate me hate me not
Wait they forgot
Woe oh the rot
Deeper in they crept
Oblivious of the bears and darker terrors
Or none were there
How did they dare
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the
Fountain of infinite mirror
Tree falling no one would hear
Shadow of nobody there
Murders of murderers living in fear of it
Owls on the night watch
Solemn and easily wise to what we thought
They thought above
Sound broke below
They were in the black wood
Coveting indiscreetly her for him
Or him for her
Shown what they were
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the
Fountain of infinite mirror
Tree falling no one would hear
Shadow of nobody there
Murders of murderers living in fear of it
I was in the clearing
Buzzing around to hearing but the
Bees & birds who knew the words
Soon arrived the twilight
Finally the night & day remembered
How they came to be
All for nothing at all
All for nothing at all
With something to do
I was in the forest looking to see the trees
But none were there
you forgot [the lava]
@@taters7342 (the lover)
I love the piano at 2:41 so much
Nobody's gonna talk about how that few seconds in 2:40 was that audio cut in The Mind Electric?
It’s not really.
But similar instruments and setup
@@hilariocitii no, it is basically the same but distorted to fit the feel of the mind electric and im pretty sure its only in the reversed part
@@heyo7461 actually, it’s completely different, in The Mind Electric, it didn’t have a deeper piano playing along with it. In Murders, there is. In The Mind Electric, there’s just a single tune, nothing else, like someone is playing with only one to two fingers.
@@hilariocitii nice!
@@hilariocitii i hear the left hand chords being played when i listen to the mind electric
3:00 Best part
Never thought how slightly empty it sounded without vocals.
people say murders is overrated but I love it, not just because the last part😭
"What happens whaen you drink the potion?
"You turn into ligma"
"What's ligma?"
3:10
Yes, this song is where that comes from.
Holy shit this is amazing, I used to dislike the original Murders (I still liked it, but it wasn't my favorite track on the album) but this instrumental makes up for it
The hoof clops are massaging my brain.
idk what that is but REAL
I’ve been listening to this on loop
I WAS FLABBERGASTED WJEN I HEARD 3:09
2:00 ( you can ignore this it’s for me )
aight but why should I ignore the fact that someone clearly shares the same favorite part? like seriously, THAT PART IS ABSOLUTELY A V I B E
All three of us
Does anyone know any songs similar to this one ?
idk what you're looking for specifically, but it reminds me of choke from idon'tknowhowbuttheyfoundme. As my sister dubs it, "charlie and the chocolate factory music"
Basically every Tally Hall song
As the world caves in is pretty similar id say
Your pfp reminds me of guildmaster from Explorers of Time!
@@niha4860 I mean kinda
2:40
on my knees begging for a LIVE miracle musical, musical dance performance
2:41 is oddly calming
is there any sheet music for the piano part??
musescore.com/user/13496311/scores/3076966 I think this is it
@@pop2art thank u
What piano part. The whole song?
@@thehornedserpent there's other instruments and parts where the piano isn't playing
My favorite parts: 1:25 and 2:22
This is so fun to sing along to o ma gawdd
The real murder here is what they did to that poor piano
Sounds like a distortion pedal or just a shit ton of compression.
It just sounds like they're pressing the hell out of the keys lmao.
go ahead. sing the words, be cheerful n proud. you deserve it. 🥰
🎶Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror 🎶
🎶Tree falling, no one would hear🎶
🎶Shadow of nobody there🎶
2:40 yeahhhhhh
Edgy piano
3:00 just do it. You won't regret it.
the piano volume increasing though 🔥🔥🔥
2:55 best part
Nobody hear Leitmotivs of The mind electric the hole instrumental? (I don’t mean the end)
I never noticed the knocking sound before
2:48 (don’t mind me)
Never noticed the ever present bass guitar in the far background, barely audible until the middle
This is literally what my thoughts are like
me and who ⁉️
2:58 use it for anything it will fit in XD
If I had a nickel for every song I know that contains violin and piano and has to do with the murder of a girl close to the male protagonist I would have 2 nickels, which isn't alot but it's weird that it happened twice.
omori
Lyrics: “
*whistling*
“
2:41 Timestamp for me :)
3:00 ( for myself )
2:00-2:20 Why does it kind of remind me of Plants vs Zombies?
if someone would make a homer simpson AI cover of Murders, they should make it 'fountain of infinite duff'
The fact that 2:52 only plays once in this song and I can’t find a full version is a shame
What do you mean find a full version?
@@patrickosullivan7783 They mean that the shown part, which is 2:41 - 3:00 feels like something out of the song, and they are right, It feels more vintage and significantly calmer, as if it's not related to the actual song. What they are trying to say, is that it would be nice to have that exact part made into an actual vintage-like song, and that they couldn't find the full version and the continuation of that exact piano part, which would be made by someone else, who is talented in re-creating pieces into something new.
It’s actually very heavily based on Frank Sinatra’s “All or Nothing at All,” so there technically is a full version.
2:41 😳
i wonder who the 5 murdered people are
earrape piano
You can hear the voices
WHY DOES THIS HAVE 3 DISLIKES???
Bad news: it became 4
@@thehornedserpent worse news: it's 5 now
None now
Staying strong on none
When you have to pay 10 dollars for a drink
3:00
3:00 is awesome
Earrape theme song
yeah ok but what happened to hawaii part 1
Hawaii part II is supposed to mean "the parting of two lovers" and it's supposed to symbolize one of the protagonists perspectives. So Hawaii part I doesn't really exist
@@edynleaf nuh uh
This song is 144 bpm
It's to bad that this beautiful song became a tik tok audio..and i am also really sad i used to not know about the album and made dumb ahh videos with the songs..so i must say “Woe oh the rot 💔”.
It sounds harsher with no lyrics
2:29 - 3:10
(It's for me don't mind me)
how did he-
5 Murders
Still immoral but it’s ok.
Yo discuto con un random en Internet y veo rip mama en su estado
Yo : 3:00
3:00 - 3:30 AHHAHSGEOWBDHW
listen at 2x speed
this is angry
*kaede akamatsu wants to know your location*
1:13 is just bashing a piano
is it just me or why does the intro sound so much like rap god's intro
Lol 70
all
for nothing at all...
*ALL*
*FOR NOTHING AT ALL*
*WITH SOMETHING TO DO*
...
i was in the forest
looking to see the trees
but none were there...
He was in the forest looking to see the trees
But none were there
He found a girl
She found the Erlking (the lover)
They were in the white wood
Gamboling out to picnic
In the light leaves broke above
Then fell below
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the flowers in the garden
Wearying of the hate me, hate me not
Wait they forgot
Woe, oh the rot
Deeper in they crept
Oblivious of the bears and darker terrors
Or none were there
How did they dare
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror
Tree falling, no one would hear
Shadow of nobody there
Murders of murderers living in fear of it
Owls on the night watch
Solemn and easily wise to what we thought
They thought above
Sound broke below
They were in the black wood
Coveting indiscreetly her for him
Or him for her
Shown what they were
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror
Tree falling, no one would hear
Shadow of nobody there
Murders of murderers living in fear of it
I was in the clearing
Buzzing around to hearing
But the bees and birds who knew the words
Soon arrived the twilight
Finally the night and day remembered
How they came to be
All for nothing at all
All for nothing at all
With something to do
I was in the forest looking to see the trees
But none were there
Who’s Candice?
this made me realize how overrated murders is
Why do I feel like this song describes Danganronpa so much lol
He was in the forest looking to see the trees
But none were there
He found a girl
She found the Erlking (the lover)
They were in the white wood
Gamboling out to picnic
In the light leaves broke above
Then fell below
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the flowers in the garden
Wearying of the hate me, hate me not
Wait they forgot
Woe, oh the rot
Deeper in they crept
Oblivious of the bears and darker terrors
Or none were there
How did they dare
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror
Tree falling, no one would hear
Shadow of nobody there
Murders of murderers living in fear of it
Owls on the night watch
Solemn and easily wise to what we thought
They thought above
Sound broke below
They were in the black wood
Coveting indiscreetly her for him
Or him for her
Shown what they were
I was in the middle ground
Looking to find the fountain of infinite mirror
Tree falling, no one would hear
Shadow of nobody there
Murders of murderers living in fear of it
I was in the clearing
Buzzing around to hearing
But the bees and birds who knew the words
Soon arrived the twilight
Finally the night and day remembered
How they came to be
All for nothing at all
All for nothing at all
With something to do
I was in the forest looking to see the trees
But none were there
Thanks.
3:00
2:41
1:59
3:31
3:00
2:00