This book is absolutely stunning and the stories of these men and what they did are outstanding. As an ex solider myself I am in awe at what these people did in Normandy and to the end of the war . What I would love is to see a film or TV series about this regiment as I believe it would be outstanding. Thank James for bringing to life these men and the sacrifices they gave .
I totally agree with that. It is truly a master-piece of a book and rewrites the history of the battle of Normandy. It would be great to see a movie or Netflix series to stand along side the American epic: Band of Brothers.
It is a truly humbling story. Until I read the book I knew nothing about this. The story of what British and Commonwealth troops and particularly the armoured corps, did after June 6 1944, is not well known by ordinary people. Huge sacrifice and huge achievements, it is a story which must be more widely known.
I'm listening to the audio version of the book and the person who stands out is the Rev. Skinner. An incredible human being who looked after " his " men in life and death.
Absolutely. Getting into burned out tanks to retrieve the men's remains for burial. Doing his best to find every lost man, often at great risk to himself. Amazing man.
@@richardjt77 Starting in the 80's when many of the veterans were still alive and attending functions at our drill hall. Stan Perry much more recently, prior to his death last year.
I love hearing James Holland and Al Murray talk about these people. It lifts them out of the pages of history. The passion and humanity comes to life in a way that should be taught in schools…. Very poignant and real and human.
I just want to thank you James for all of your WW2 documentaries. My dad was in the Army and my husbands dad was on the Minnieapolis in WW2.I love all your shows and books, what a great historian you are. My only regret growing up was not talking more about the war and what my dad went thru. You have certainly opened my eyes. You are truly a great man! WW2 Never should be forgotten.
I've just finished the last chapter of this book before headed to work. I have to admit I had a tear in my eyes reading the telegram that the war was over. So much tension, death and destruction and a bluntly written message ended it all. A very excellent book and I'm now starting a large model project to represent their journey towards Bremen. Great work Mr Holland.
Wow! When you read that letter I teared up! What a special hero! Fantastic exhibition! I wish this could come to the U.S. as a traveling museum ~so I could see it! ♥️♥️♥️ or that I would get rich so I could travel…lol
I've just finished listening to the book- what a superb recounting of this period, and these gentlemen you describe seem to so typify many soldiers of that period- determined, brave, selfless, and compassionate. I am in awe of them.
Such an outstanding video which had me in tears. Surely this must be the British version of Band of Brothers. So much sacrifice, so much fear and sadness. Thank you.
What an outstanding account James ,this piece really makes this regt truly stand out, the padre who at times through up when burying the men who were killed is something that stays with you ,absolutely remarkable ...
Thanks James and N.A.M. It's a great book and I look forward to seeing the exhibition in person. I also reread Stuart Hills' book, By Tank Into Normandy, and I got much more out of it having had the maps and insights that James provided. Well done to all concerned - in awe of those men in the Normandy campaign.
The book needs turning into a TV drama akin to Band Of Brothers. Won't happen though the men involved aren't American so no funding would be forthcoming.
Dear James thank you for this presentation and all of the research you have done when writing your book, of which I have a signed copy, but as of yet I have not read as my brain injury does not let me concentrate for too long. I will unfortunately not be able to get to the NAM before the end of the presentation. As someone who has served over 33 year's in the TA of which 23 year's was at carlton including tours of Iraq and Afghanistan I can say I am proud to be associated with the men in your presentation. I have met a few of them, David Render, George Dring and Ken Ewing. However as someone who would like to think I know a bit about Sherwood Ranger war history I would like to think that there would be a few outstanding moments that could have been included which would have celebrated the efficiency, reputation and respect that the SRY gained. They were first tanks on Gold Beach, Stanley Christophersons ride on horse to the outskirts of Bayeux and the capture of Bayeux the next day. Or the the SRY involvement of OP Market Garden and Recce troop being first troops on German soil. Also the fantastic letter of praise from General Horrocks when the SRY was stood down. What you said about Leslie Skinner in my opinion does not scratch the service, and after reading his book the man who worked on Sunday I am always move by how humbled and compassionate he was. I would love to speak with you in person, but you probably won't even read this, but if you do then speak with Steve at the SRY museum.
I think Brothers in Arms belongs right next to Death Traps or Tank! for armored writing but really the depth that Holland shows for the men made me think of Band of Brothers straight through. Well done.
It's too funny how this book is described, but here goes -In the annals of World War II certain groups of soldiers stand out, and among the most notable were the Sherwood Rangers, a derivative of Boys Scouts or romper room. Except you give the young boys the higher score in achievement, in this sega, they must've woke up and decided to play toy soldiers. There higher up, became the Normandy Envision in retrospect historians couldn't decide what the winning circle was in this story, there conventionals pointed in the wrong direction, so far for smarts, notwithstanding. Lisa
Good stuff, but I’d be interested to know how your chances of survival in British infantry or tanks was ‘zero’!! - I think you’ve got slightly carried away there James!
"American historians" - unfortunately a lot of the post war history was 'revealed' in the 80's and 90's by American 'historians'. Ambrose, Cornelius Ryan and Carlo D'este, who entirely wrote from an an American perspective and aimed at an American audience. That is fair enough, however what is unforgivable (apart from the historical inaccuracies and if not lies, omissions of fact which were damned misleading) is that certain British historians jumped onto the bandwagon and accepted their interpretation of events without any questions (or looking at primary sources) and before long you have an accepted version of Tea Drinking Shirkers. Unfortunately for myself, my dipping deeper into history was in the 80's, before the internet and before the new breed of British historians (of which Mr Holland is an esteemed member) ignored the accepted narrative and started digging around - and shock horror - actually using primary sources, Regimental diaries, soldiers letters and if lucky, interviews with the people who were actually there and bringing out a more balanced view of the campaign in Normandy and what followed. If you read some of these well researched accounts, the questions change from (for an example) in Attenborough's film of Cornelius Ryan's book a Bridge Too Far, its not 'why are the British tankers making a brew? it's 'why didn't the 82nd secure their primary objective and allow the British armour to cross the bridge'?
This book is absolutely stunning and the stories of these men and what they did are outstanding. As an ex solider myself I am in awe at what these people did in Normandy and to the end of the war . What I would love is to see a film or TV series about this regiment as I believe it would be outstanding. Thank James for bringing to life these men and the sacrifices they gave .
I totally agree with that. It is truly a master-piece of a book and rewrites the history of the battle of Normandy. It would be great to see a movie or Netflix series to stand along side the American epic: Band of Brothers.
Totally agree Phil.. a film would be spot on..
@@markrunnalls7215 it will never happen thou which is very sad 😞
It is a truly humbling story. Until I read the book I knew nothing about this. The story of what British and Commonwealth troops and particularly the armoured corps, did after June 6 1944, is not well known by ordinary people. Huge sacrifice and huge achievements, it is a story which must be more widely known.
I'm listening to the audio version of the book and the person who stands out is the Rev. Skinner. An incredible human being who looked after " his " men in life and death.
Absolutely. Getting into burned out tanks to retrieve the men's remains for burial. Doing his best to find every lost man, often at great risk to himself. Amazing man.
I'm so proud to be a Sherwood Ranger and to have met some of these men.
Hello. When was that?
@@richardjt77 Starting in the 80's when many of the veterans were still alive and attending functions at our drill hall. Stan Perry much more recently, prior to his death last year.
I love hearing James Holland and Al Murray talk about these people. It lifts them out of the pages of history. The passion and humanity comes to life in a way that should be taught in schools….
Very poignant and real and human.
Bravo, Jim! You have done more to help me understand the real-life experiences of British forces in WW2 than any other historian.
To Phil, I so agree and I want to say to you, thank you for your service!!
I just want to thank you James for all of your WW2 documentaries. My dad was in the Army and my husbands dad was on the Minnieapolis in WW2.I love all your shows and books, what a great historian you are. My only regret growing up was not talking more about the war and what my dad went thru. You have certainly opened my eyes. You are truly a great man! WW2 Never should be forgotten.
I've just finished the last chapter of this book before headed to work. I have to admit I had a tear in my eyes reading the telegram that the war was over. So much tension, death and destruction and a bluntly written message ended it all. A very excellent book and I'm now starting a large model project to represent their journey towards Bremen. Great work Mr Holland.
Wow! When you read that letter I teared up! What a special hero! Fantastic exhibition! I wish this could come to the U.S. as a traveling museum ~so I could see it! ♥️♥️♥️ or that I would get rich so I could travel…lol
Just finished Normandy 44, will start reading Brothers in Arms, Excellent writer. Looking forward to visit the Museum in 1 month.
Brilliant book. James Holland is very special when it comes to knowledge on all things WW2. Absolute legend 👌🏻
I can only second all the others who have commented on this book. Apart from the factual content, James' writing style draws you in.
I also love that you display the jacket/uniform for people to touch!!! So many museums don’t allow that. Really cool of you! 🫡
I've just finished listening to the book- what a superb recounting of this period, and these gentlemen you describe seem to so typify many soldiers of that period- determined, brave, selfless, and compassionate. I am in awe of them.
Such an outstanding video which had me in tears. Surely this must be the British version of Band of Brothers. So much sacrifice, so much fear and sadness. Thank you.
Thanks for brilliant talk, James., and congrats to NAM as well.
I'm disappointed I probably won't make it to see this exhibition, so thank you for this video.
I am reading the Book now Brothers in Arms, good book. I am USA army retired M1A1 Tanker
Tank Action by David Render. A must read.
Superb book should be a film about it.would be true gritty & honest .books a tribute to those brave men
This should have been a TV series
Reading the book as we speak. Thank you for this! Excellent!
Magnificent book and more so truly humbled by these men.
Great video summary. James Holland is a great speaker. Always brings an enthusiasm and positivity to complement his excellent scholarship.😊
What an outstanding account James ,this piece really makes this regt truly stand out, the padre who at times through up when burying the men who were killed is something that stays with you ,absolutely remarkable ...
Thanks James and N.A.M. It's a great book and I look forward to seeing the exhibition in person. I also reread Stuart Hills' book, By Tank Into Normandy, and I got much more out of it having had the maps and insights that James provided. Well done to all concerned - in awe of those men in the Normandy campaign.
Just reading James' book right now. Was really good accompaniment to watch this.
The book needs turning into a TV drama akin to Band Of Brothers. Won't happen though the men involved aren't American so no funding would be forthcoming.
Weeeell, there are references to them operating with the "Railsplitters" the 84th US infantry so you never know.
brilliant books
once youve read brothers in arms,read tank action by captain david Render,it brings the 2 stories together
Dear James thank you for this presentation and all of the research you have done when writing your book, of which I have a signed copy, but as of yet I have not read as my brain injury does not let me concentrate for too long. I will unfortunately not be able to get to the NAM before the end of the presentation. As someone who has served over 33 year's in the TA of which 23 year's was at carlton including tours of Iraq and Afghanistan I can say I am proud to be associated with the men in your presentation. I have met a few of them, David Render, George Dring and Ken Ewing. However as someone who would like to think I know a bit about Sherwood Ranger war history I would like to think that there would be a few outstanding moments that could have been included which would have celebrated the efficiency, reputation and respect that the SRY gained. They were first tanks on Gold Beach, Stanley Christophersons ride on horse to the outskirts of Bayeux and the capture of Bayeux the next day. Or the the SRY involvement of OP Market Garden and Recce troop being first troops on German soil. Also the fantastic letter of praise from General Horrocks when the SRY was stood down. What you said about Leslie Skinner in my opinion does not scratch the service, and after reading his book the man who worked on Sunday I am always move by how humbled and compassionate he was. I would love to speak with you in person, but you probably won't even read this, but if you do then speak with Steve at the SRY museum.
I must visit before the exhibition ends. It should be indefinitely displayed somewhere for sure. There must be some place that would want to do that.
This should be shown in every school in UK…
Surprised David Render isn’t featured
I loved the audio book.
Read the book it's excellent 👌
I think Brothers in Arms belongs right next to Death Traps or Tank! for armored writing but really the depth that Holland shows for the men made me think of Band of Brothers straight through. Well done.
fantastic courage of Sherwood rangers yeomanry who drove the nazis back and freed europe from nazi tyranny never forget their bravery
Dringys farrier stables still exist in Fulbeck Lincolnshire, it is now a cafe
What is the name of the book?
Brothers in Arms
Tank Action by David Render.
It's too funny how this book is described, but here goes -In the annals of World War II certain groups of soldiers stand out, and among the most notable were the Sherwood Rangers, a derivative of Boys Scouts or romper room. Except you give the young boys the higher score in achievement, in this sega, they must've woke up and decided to play toy soldiers. There higher up, became the Normandy Envision in retrospect historians couldn't decide what the winning circle was in this story, there conventionals pointed in the wrong direction, so far for smarts, notwithstanding. Lisa
Reverend Skinner buried my Gt Uncle Capt George Jones killed D Day +7😢
Good stuff, but I’d be interested to know how your chances of survival in British infantry or tanks was ‘zero’!! - I think you’ve got slightly carried away there James!
According to Stephen Ambrose and most American historians these guys were a bunch of tea drinking cowards
"American historians" - unfortunately a lot of the post war history was 'revealed' in the 80's and 90's by American 'historians'. Ambrose, Cornelius Ryan and Carlo D'este, who entirely wrote from an an American perspective and aimed at an American audience. That is fair enough, however what is unforgivable (apart from the historical inaccuracies and if not lies, omissions of fact which were damned misleading) is that certain British historians jumped onto the bandwagon and accepted their interpretation of events without any questions (or looking at primary sources) and before long you have an accepted version of Tea Drinking Shirkers.
Unfortunately for myself, my dipping deeper into history was in the 80's, before the internet and before the new breed of British historians (of which Mr Holland is an esteemed member) ignored the accepted narrative and started digging around - and shock horror - actually using primary sources, Regimental diaries, soldiers letters and if lucky, interviews with the people who were actually there and bringing out a more balanced view of the campaign in Normandy and what followed.
If you read some of these well researched accounts, the questions change from (for an example) in Attenborough's film of Cornelius Ryan's book a Bridge Too Far, its not 'why are the British tankers making a brew? it's 'why didn't the 82nd secure their primary objective and allow the British armour to cross the bridge'?
ｐｒｏｍｏｓｍ ☹️