Dr. Niraj Rai: India's Genetic History, Aryan-Dravidian Myth Debunked | Abhijit Chavda Podcast 3
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 มิ.ย. 2024
- World's Best Masterclass on Geopolitics: Geopolitics From First Principles.
Enroll here - www.ac.university
Dr. Niraj Rai is one of the world's foremost experts in archaeogenetics and molecular biology.
He is the Group Head of the Ancient DNA Lab at Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences, Lucknow. www.bsip.res.in/bsip_director...
He specializes in the use of next-generation sequencing data to study human population histories.
He has authored and co-authored numerous ground-breaking papers on genetics.
OUTLINE:
00:00 Introduction
00:37 What is DNA?
01:56 What is nuclear (autosomal) DNA and how is it different from other DNA types?
04:00 What is RNA?
04:50 What are haplogroups?
10:46 Out-of-Africa migration: genetic, archaeological evidence
13:22 Out-of-African dispersal: happened via India along coastal route
14:22 The oldest non-African haplogroups (lineages) originated in India
15:58 Haplogroup F: oldest non-African male lineage originated in India
17:25 Incredible diversity in India's genetics; including R1a
18:36 Ancestral "North Indian" & "South Indian" ancestry (ANI and ASI): oversimplified, incorrect, obsolete model of Indian population genetics
23:40 ANI and ASI does NOT correspond to "Aryans" and "Dravidians"
25:04 What is "Iranian ancestry"? How old is it?
26:00 The "Iranian ancestry" found in Rakhigarhi sample was Indian ancestry
27:04 The unproven ASSUMPTION of closeness between Onge (Andamanese) ancestry & Indian ancestry
28:23 What is "Steppe ancestry"; how old is it? Is it present in Indians?
32:44 Steppe ancestry in India: a minor, slow, gradual, trickle-down population influx. Not a major migration.
33:53 Steppe ancestry trickle in India can easily be explained by small Scythian, Kushan, Hunnic influxes in India starting ~2,200 years before present
34:45 India's enormously diverse population cannot be force-fitted into simplistic categories (ASI, ANI, etc.)
38:33 Is Steppe ancestry related to Europe's Yamnaya invaders?
39:22 Rakhigarhi DNA - how old is it, U2 haplogroup (matrilineal)
40:17 Why is it so difficult to extract ancient DNA samples in India?
41:49 Rakhigarhi DNA: Indus periphery ancestry
43:53 Undeniable proof of large-scale Out-Of-India migrations
45:42 The Aryan invasion/migration theory is dead
47:04 Difference between "Harappan" culture and Ganga Plain culture
49:30 R1a1a patrilineal lineage diversified in India at least ~10,000 YBP: most likely originated in Indian subcontinent
53:45 R1b (Yamnaya patrilineal lineage) also most likely originated in India
54:43 Indians have negligible Neanderthal ancestry: how this debunks Aryan invasion/migration theory
57:01 Jati-Varna ("caste") stratification & endogamy in India: what does genetic data show? Founder effects, population bottlenecks
01:02:20 Domestication of horses in ancient India happened at least 4,500 years before present
01:05:09 Indian Zebu cattle spread across the world at least 8,000 YBP
01:07:26 Ancient Indians settled in Australia at least ~6,000 years ago, along with Indian dhole dogs (ancestors of Australian dingos)
01:08:00 Ancient Indian ancestry in Indonesia; modern Indonesians have ~10% Indian ancestry
01:09:52 Denisovan ancestry: found in Tibet, South-East Asia, highland populations
01:10:46 The world's oldest evidence of Agriculture: CONSISTENTLY found in Indian subcontinent. India is the true cradle of civilization.
14:33:21 Lakshadweep islands DNA: exact match with Kerala
01:16:27 The people of Yemen have Indian ancestry
01:17:05 Cultural & genetic affinity between India and Eastern Africa
01:18:24 Queen Ketevan of Kakheti, Georgia: how an ancient murder mystery was solved
01:22:19 What genetic research needs to be undertaken in India, in the future? What big questions remain unanswered?
01:26:01 India needs a lot more geneticists; better policies, direction & leadership
01:27:40 Advice/roadmap for aspiring geneticists
01:31:25 India is a goldmine for future research: linguistics, history, anthropology, sociology, genetics
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL:
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/AbhijitChavda
►Become A Member on TH-cam: / @abhijitchavda
JOIN #AbhijitChavda:
★Discord: / discord
★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
★Website:
★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
#AbhijitChavdaPodcast #NirajRai #Abhijit #Chavda
The more i watch these podcasts the more i realised how ignorant we were about our own motherland. Well thank you sir for these podcasts to expand our views on various topics. Looking forward for more sir!
Exactly
abijit is trying his level best to debunk this myth but what use if he talk in hindi??????
Agreed
@@shivajiraje7555 i feel that he should put english subtitles for non hindi viewers
He's my official History Corrector nowadays. He has taught me a lot more than school could, and his followers have asked him questions that sprung up in my mind. He's an academy in himself!
I am at a loss of words after listening to this podcast. Goosebumps🙀🤯
Seems like aryan tourist theory believers will have hard time sleeping today🤣🤣
Bhai bhai 🤣🤣
Tourist 😂
They've stopped entering discussions. They believe AIT like some chaps believe Earth to be flat...
Absolutely 😅
Lol they got pissed off XD
ITS SAD HOW THE POLITICIAN IN TAMIL NADU USE THIS TRICKS TO MAKE THE TAMIL PEOPLE BLINDLY BELEIVE IN THIS SHIT
"Unlike other ancient civilizations, such as Egypt or Babylon, Phoenicia or even Greece, the ancient culture and civilization of India is not dead...India of the past lives in the present, and will live in the future.” -- #NetajiSubhasChandraBose
Chinese and irani are still here..
@@MrCake-ui8uoIranian civilisation died with the Sassanis.
@@MrCake-ui8uo China not old as our civilization
😂 That's cause you are ignorant @@devendraSingh19aug
Please do these podcasts in English. As an Indian from the South, I struggle to understand Hindi, though I try to.
Love that phrase 'Indian from the south'🤗.
@@priyanshmehta2110 Yes, Indian first. South Indian sounds like I am a different nation, like South Korea. Given Breaking India forces trying to create secession, I'll assert my Indian identity first.
@@rbk9915 I also get angry when people say South Indian or form the South. I never say North Indian or from the North. SOuthern Indian is a far better word or as you put it Indian from the SOuth. I, too, am an Indian from South
Abhijit Sir himself has very much knowledge on this topic. It would be great to see these two scholars discussing about AIT myth. Great for us audience 😁
abijit is trying his level best to debunk this myth but what use if he talk in hindi??????
@@adastra3192 if rathee living in Germany can talk about india why a theoretical physicist can't talk about AIT
@@adastra3192 chacha there is a term called jack of all trades also many people are master of many trades . Don't synch everything. Thoda khul jao bhai .
@@adastra3192 The so called "scholars of history" in India are just political coolies.
@@adastra3192 You realise that those populations also have Indian ancestry of their own, right ?
What a cool and Calm Guy. We need more Dr. Neeraj Sir for such humongous task ✌️🙏
Good to see a guy with same name as me watching same thing
The 2 podcasts were amazing. Waiting to hear from Dr. Niraj Rai.
Shri Abhijit ji, I admire your way of directing the flow of the talk and the logical questions that arise along the discussion. It feels so natural and relates to the audience. Really appreciate your efforts
These kind of research should get more support and limelight ..wonder why we don’t see this in News or TV programs ..
Indian channel must be busy with b gossip.
Indian audience want glamour, drama or masala...... That's why such channels have less followers than silly Vlog Channels of filmstars.
Indian News is busy with Hindu-Muslim, BJP-Congress 😂 although I used to enjoy that but it's hard on mental peace
The much awaited podcast. Surely gonna watch and note every single point. Thank you Guruji !
Edit : Now this is called a scholarly conversation. Thank you for enlightening us with ocean of knowledge.
True that.
wait wtf how u commented 3 days ago?
@@shivajiraje7555 the comments section has been on since the announcement.
abijit is trying his level best to debunk this myth but what use if he talk in hindi??????
@@shivajiraje7555 are bhai 99% of his podcasts are in English, Hindi se nafrat hai kya babuji tumhe . Ask for subtitles if you want rather then posting the same comment in every reply . Also Mr Rai is more comfortable in Hindi . Jo bhi teri local language hai be proud of it and also let Hindi bbe a binding language koi dikkat nahi hai usme . Otherwise Sanskrit seekh lo sab ke sab binding ke liye which is pretty tough right now . Stop complaining like a kid. Hindi Hindi , bc dimak kha liya tere same comment ne
The kind of humongous work that goes into such kind of research is unimaginable. Thank you so much for giving us insights on this subject.
This podcast will indeed burst the myth of AIT or AMT and then we will see gradual downfall of Dravidian party of South 😀🙏
Thankyou Guruji for such enlightening episodes 🙏🙏🤩🤩
1problem
This is in Hindi
@@khosrowanushirwan7591 indeed i am wondering if he will provide translations.
@Amiya kumar looks like uhh didn't watch
@Amiya kumar What rubbish. He clearly explains how ANI-ASI are basically premeditated and flawed categories invented by David Reich's labs by eliminating most of the genetic data because it was inconvenient for their preconceived statistical model. At the timestamp mentioned by you, he simply states that he has no choice but to accept it academically for now since its a peer-reviewed study legitimised by a leading journal like Nature, but on 23:20 he says that he's soon coming out with counter studies that will start the process of demolishing the deliberately faulty ANI-ASI hypothesis. Nowhere did he say that ANI-ASI is supported by archaeology, that was said in the context of the Out of Africa migration hypothesis. Improve your listening skills buddy.
@Amiya kumar LOL. I should have guessed. You're just another bumbling Aryan invasion/migration/tourism apologist. If you had better comprehension skills, you'd have understood that the very thrust of this entire conversation was that the supposedly established theory of steppe migration is anything but an "Aryan migration". Why? Because, one, the so-called steppe component entered the Indian genetic pool with a semblance of group entry way too late in history (almost entirely after 500 BCE); two, genetic overlaps with so-called steppe markers during the pre-Harappan and Harappan epochs were way too long-drawn and way too insignificant vis-a-vis the population size of India; three, the sum total of one & two amounts to less than 5% ancestry in available samples even after all kinds of statistical jugglery to construct ANI, while out-of-India genes in the Indus Periphery (greater Iran) stands at 30-40%, which yet again corroborates group migrations of Harappans into all directions when the Saraswati started disappearing; and four, the supposed steppe genes brought in absolutely zero change in material culture in the Indian archaeological record. Capiche?
Yamnaya samples are R1a and R1b dominant. Unless it is unequivocally proven where R1 originated (almost certainly India given it's diversity and STR frequency here), it is impossible to conclude whether Indians carry Yamnaya genes, or vice versa. This CWC>Yamnaya>Iranian>Indo-Aryan nonsense is more of a linguistic theory invented by Western Indologists rather than a genetic fact.
You have much to learn, buddy.
The saddest part is the lack of funding in India :(
Indians are lucky enough to have such great informative Vlogs👌. Who ever watch these Vlogs will have great horizon of knowledge. Thank you so much Mr. AC and Dr.Niraj 🌷
Sir,for South students we need either english subtitles or english language
Long story short .. Aryan invasion theory is busted . At DNA level, no difference between north and South Indians ..
i feel u
Time to unify India with Sanskrit.
@@nw3877 👍
Hello sir, please bring Mr Anuj Dhar again on the topic of Netaji. The last episode you did with him on Shastriji's death mystery was really great. Waiting for a similar one or even a series of them on Netaji Subhas.
Seconded.
Thirded (if there is such word)!
@@JackSordakaPVS language is organic. Let this be a new word if it's not already.
It's coming on 1st February at 9 pm
धन्यवाद आचार्य 🙏🌺
Loved listening to Dr. Niraj Rai ji. He's truly a Gem for Bhārata. Really interesting discussion.
Yo thara bhai Abhijit ! Itni podcast record kar lega Itni podcast record kar lega kisi ne sochi na hogi ! Imagine sir doing this ☠️☠️☠️💥💥
🤣🤣
🤣🤣
😂😂😂👌🏻
Dude 😶😶😶😶
Lmao xD.. Thara Bhai fans spotted..
The more we know, the more we realise that we don't know much. Fantastic podcast 👍👍. So many data points exist, it's a mammoth task to find out links in such a diverse data
It would be good if you added English subtitles for those who don't understand Hindi. I understand so it's not a problem but I'm sure there are many who don't
GREAT PODCAST !!
As always you are doing GREAT and spreading KNOWLEDGE very effectively. Listening expert like Dr. Neeraj Rai give us more clarity and better understanding about Genetic History.
There is only one suggestion, please add English subtitles so that our friends who don't know Hindi can also understand this podcast properly.
Every point is worth to note
2 genius together 👍🙏
Astonishing, it’s time to air this kind of shows in television to reach to common people.
I don't think the television is ready for it 😂 too scared to counter the other side
Absolutely mind blowing! Such heavy podcast learned alot. Definitely will listen again to gain the most of it.
And my deepest and greatest love and respect to doctor Niraj Rai and others like him for the work they are doing ❤
In case of Yemen having indian ancestry, there was some research being conducted but was interrupted due to the Civil War. I wonder what happened to the excavations at Dilmun and some other places?
finally is channel pe kuch content Hindi me aya ! acha laga !
Aree Bhai maine tumhe kareeban 5 baar dekha hai lol. Ye kaisa username leke ghumte ho 🤣🤣
@@astesiaa mene ye ID Pakistanio ke liye create kari thi .
@@TeraBaap-cw6in
LoL, Tum log nahi sudhroge bhai xD.. very good
@@astesiaa to tum sudhar jao.. Vese bhi tum logo ne sudhar ke kya ukhad liya 😂😂
This is master class of knowledge people like me who live in remote area like dantewada chattisgarh got no privilege to listen This kind of super lecture.
Thanks to both of you sir 🙏.
Demise of Aryan Migration Myth 🔥❤️
Aryan invasion , migration , holiday, picnic , honeymoon. 😂✌️😂
More like *"Aryan Imagination Theory"*
@@paulbiju1822 , as i said its upon u ,whos side ur ?
@@paulbiju1822 It doesn’t matter if IVC people spoke Dravidian. It doesn’t prove Aryan invasion happened and destroyed IVC, no proof have been found archeologically and now not even genetically.
@@paulbiju1822 periyar is a பெடோஃபில்.
Wow eagerly waiting....shoutout to the previous two podcasts 🙌❤️great content Abhijit bhai 🙏❤️Jai Hind
@@glennjacksonofficial3001 brother yes it is...that's the sad reality he has to cater to the larger population, maybe..I do understand ur case but I was lucky enough to be brought up in various parts of our country so language isn't an issue... 🙏
This is one of my fav subscriptions ever. This podcast is what we deserved rather than the terrible podcasts/channels with unnecessary jingoism or quite immature line of questioning of Ranveer Allahbadia (Ranveer bro, love you, you bring out the best guests but your questions are terrible)
Right ranveers guest 90% times are great but questioning is hypothetical often
And on top of that, Ranveer always tries to put his thought process into the other guest's mind thereby affecting the originality of the answer. And thereby revolves the discussion into a different perspective altogether which is not desirable by viewers.
Yes bro you 👍 & also my fav. & Knowledge Treasure mine subscription ☺️
Bro check out charvaka podcast and sham sharma show global u can also check out jaipur dialogues pgurus vaad and u can also check out the talks of abhijeet iyyer mitra.
@@HimanshuYadav-ng9md none of them cover topics as interesting and bring a lot of personality instead of facts like Mr. Chavda. Mr. Chavda lays down gems effortlessly and without controversy. Regardless that is a great list of channels
A detailed and very informative conversation. It enlightened many myths surrounding our history. Thank You Neeraj Sir and Abhijit Sir for sharing this knowledge.
Amazing podcast!
Felt good to see two legends together! Dr Niraj has clarity with cool and calm! Thank you Abhijit sir, it's only because of you that we are getting information regarding such unspoken or mistaken lol parts of history!
Namaskaram 🙏
In Mahabharat... Yudhistir answered Yaksha "You can not define cast by birth because there was much intercourse happened between theme. So by Karma you can do."
Also he told same thing to "Ajgar"
Cast by birth hai hi nhi hai shree krishna bhi bolte hai.. Karma based hai.. Ye kuch gadho ne bol diya hai.. Like ambedkar
@@kafirhu7089 ambedkar caste by karma mai hi mante the?
@@prashantsinghsisodia6709 bhimte ka muje kese pata hoga.. Unke bhakto se pucho une jyada pata hoga
@@kafirhu7089 search toh kar sakte ho?
Ohh my goodness!! It's just fascinating. Come to know so many new things. Thank you sir for conducting this amazing podcast.🙏😀
Great scholars. Great discussion. A delightful episode.
This is an amazing podcast & loaded with so much information. Thank you so much Abhijit.
Please suggest a book to read about this topic in-depth.
I just have no words to express how much enlightened I feel after watching this podcast. Thank you to both the great people! 🙏🙏
Your Informative videos are helped me in my upsc history optional preparation 🙏🏼
All the best ✨
Hey, there is somehow a belief in me that while giving UPSC exam you won't be qualified if you talk of the real history of Bharat. You are required to speak and write what marxsist historians want you to know. Because the members who make decisions are all products of this education system and they firmly believe in it .Is this true actually? And if it true how Abhijit Sir's videos are helping you pepare for UPSC?
@@rsn4189 yes i agree with you but there are same debates where you can write same nationalist or oriental point of view for ex.aryan invasion theory, British policy like education, railway,utilitarianism, drain of wealth etc.
@@rsn4189 not only in history others subject also like a video sir talked about China's one child policy and how affect there society. this type of example you can never find in books.
@@Indian-pf1nf got it. Thanks
Very Great podcast with neeraj Rai sir , i have watched neeraj sir in sinauli documentory , it was awesome , love the session . JAI SIYARAM 🙏
Wonderful session sir. Truly enjoyed it.
Lot of ground covered in this podcast, if some just documents points discussed here into a wikipedia page, that will be great step to make these findings widely available. Thanks Abhijit Chavda and Dr. Rai
Great Episode again. May God bless your work sir🙏
Was looking forward to this one since long! Thanks a lot for this conversation! Great stuff!
I don't have words to express my feeling. Amazed after listening to this podcast. Finely explained. There is still lot to explore. Accept my appreciation both of you. Eagerly waiting for your another podcast on the similar topic. Thanks
An episode full of knowledge..... thank you sir for doing what you're doing
Abhijit ji please add English subtitles so that this can reach to more people.
Really great session , learned a lot
Mindblowing podcast. Great learning experience.
Scientific evidence based, to the point, detailed and informative. What a show. Thank you Sir. Thank you🙏
Thank you Abhijit Chavda Sir for bringing people like him. Wow ... 🙌🔥
Another gem of a podcast episode!
Absolutely amazing discussion!!! Thanks to you both!!!🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Abhijit, what’s the best way to get in touch with you? I would like to share some lesser known facts
Wowwww.... Woww woww woww.... People who have watched the entire episode will know the level of excitement!!!
Missed watching first half of the podcast while it was premiering as i was busy in cake cutting but rest half was very informative so definitely will first also be😊🙏. Will watch it right now.
As you are doing podcasts with so many great people i would request you to have a podcast dedicated on 'Great Pradhan Manrtri Nehru' and his Blunder ( I mean great steps). I know it would be impossible to sum up it in 1 and half hour session to cover his 'legacy' and ' great deeds' for which we are 'very 'thankful of' 😅
We need a special series for this topic. Also happy birthday Harshit ,Cogito will be doing a QandA shortly please do join.
@@khosrowanushirwan7591 Haha true. BTW Thank You so much 😊❤
Lol, Happy Birthday.. xd.. Sorry for the so called late wish
@@harshit2.02 😊❤️
@@astesiaa Haha no issue at all and Thank You 😄❤
Such a pleasant guy, wonderful conversation. Such gems both of you!
literally outstanding mindblowing podcast sir thank you so much😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
❤️❤️🙏🙏 thank you Abhijit sir for this podcast
NEERAJ SIR real life HERO. ❤❤
Doing a great work in Population Genetics. 👏👏👏👏👏
As expected wonderful session. 👍
One of the best discussions ever.
Niraj Rai has explained things in a very lucid way. Any person even without science background can understand the facts. Excellent work by Niraj Rai and team. Proud of such scientists 👏🏾.
We want all these findings to be in our textbooks. Inspirational for youngsters.
Avijit Chavda as host is awesome, gives space to the guest, questions in a logical fashion and makes the whole discussion very interesting.
Very impressive Dr.Niraj and Abhijit.
I offer my services if needed .
I know a little bit of south Indian languages ~ Telugu by Education till 12th and Medicine in English. Mother tongue Kerala Tamil and alittle bit of spoken Malayalam. Hindi ~ Pravesika (of Dakshin Hindi Prachar Sabha) passed. I am 77+ by age and 😊 in 20s by enthusiasm. My capabilities~ read and translate ~Telugu,Hindi Colloquial Tamil.
This is the best podcast from Abhijit Chavda so far. We want more such videos on history in terms of genetics.
awesome session sir!!!
very informative!!
Very very interesting conversation 🤠
Very good podcast Sir 🙏
Please english subtitles 🙏
Woww... I was waiting for this!!!! Excited!!!!!
try streaming the pre-edited version of podcasts with images and graphics...I think adding a few images won't take much editing effort like in the Ranveer podcasts.
Ranveer has a team of editors
@@franky7388 adding 10 images and few clips
Hope for new findings & research.God bless you both!🙌🎉🤗🌿💚Thank you 🍁
What an amazing discussion. I was making notes while listening to the discussion. Brilliant Brilliant 👏 👌Plan to listen to it again
It was a great session... learn lot today
Keep up the good work. Your videos are very informative and educational for people who want to do serious analysis of indian history.
Wow! Such good questions and doubts. Thank you for going beyond the basics.
Thanku so much for bringing this topic....
History with lens of biology is ❤️
Sir, will u be providing translations? This info needs to get out, especially to rest of us.
This is gonna be a banger for sure.
My greatest respect for both of these knowledgeable indians. I aspire to be like you both one day.
Pls let us know where we can read the works that Niraj sir was mentioning that they have published! I am fascinated by it and want to read more on this.... this podcast was amazing!
I keep coming back to this one Abhijit sir 🙏 sooo important I can’t get over it.
Thank you for this unknown information 🙏🏾
Very interesting & gives a lot of awareness about our people & culture & our ancestors- - great informative talk. I wish I was young I would join you on field. Thank you 🙏💐🇮🇳👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Waiting for this Podcast ❤️
Excited ✌️😊
Thanks for the great podcast.
Askabhijit :
How much data/knowledge/history the Brahmins (gors) hold ? Like gotra, saptarishi, king Lineages, any many other things that even I don't know 😀
GOI through DST/DBT should make a 10-year plan for decoding genetics and ancestral heritage of Indian population...needs funding of hundreds of crores for this mega project...and who better to lead this than Dr. Niraj Rai...
This needs to be in English. We can help to caption it atleast
Plz open a Chanel in Hindi with English subtitles...
Brilliant interview and program Abhijit ji. So very important for the current generation and the older confused generations
Very interesting and informative discussion
Sir please post this on Spotify as well 🙏
Wonderful session.
Sir, Call Neeraj ji again. Wonderful information.. need more episodes
Sir can we donate for the research in areas where government doesn't fund?
This is what type of info I craved for. Thanks a lot.
How many of you think that satyuga is slowly coming as many of us are now becoming aware of the truth of Sanatan dharma 🕉️🕉️
Will take at least 100 years
There is a pralaya before satya yuga.
@@vamsikrishna3855 eagerly waiting for pralay.
@@vamsikrishna3855 okk ..
Nicely explained very informative talk
Brilliant and super informative. I don’t think any other host could have fond justice to such a sensitive topic.
Hello Dr. Neera and Mr. Abhijit Chavda sir ji;
I have been doing research work on the history of ancient India for many years and the basic source of my research has been the history of the ancient world and Kinnauri cultural traditions and Kinnauri language.
It is a common belief that the R1a Y haplogroup originated in the Middle East and is also hypothesized to have spread to India 5000 years ago due to migration by Indo-European speakers. While my linguistic study says that the names of hundreds of ancient Eurasian geographic signeture points like Saraswati, Indus, Tibet, Ural, Thinshan, China, Hindu, Hindukush, Mongolia, Siberia etc. are "Kinnauri" Indian language words. Which originated from the mouths of "Kinnauri" Indian language speakers. Which shows that before the Saraswati river dried up, this language was spoken in the above mentioned geographical areas of Eurasia and also by the pyramid builders of Egypt. Which stamps the migration of Kinnauri speakers in Eurasia and Africa. But without genetic study of Kinnauri speaking people of district Kinnaur H.P. we cannot say with certainty whether Kinnauri speaking people went out of India or came to India from outside. If R1a Y haplogroup is found in the DNA of tribals of Kinnaur, then your new R1a Y haplogroup migration theory would have been confirmed that R1a did not come to India from Central Asia but went from India to Central Asia.
मै कई वर्षों से प्राचीन भारत के इतिहास पर शोध कार्य कर रहा हूँ और मेरे शोध का मूल स्त्रोत प्राचीन विश्व का इतिहास और किन्नौरी संस्कृतिक परम्पराये व् किन्नौरी भाषा रहा है।
यह आम धारणा हैकि R1a Y हेप्लोग्रुप का जन्म मध्यपूर्व में हुआ है और यह भी परिकल्पना हैकि 5000 वर्ष पूर्व भारतमें की भारत-युरोपीय भाषियों के द्वारा प्रवास के कारण फैला। जबकि मेरा भाषाई अध्ययन यह कहता हैकि सरस्वती, सिंधु, तिब्बत, यूराल, थिनशान, चीन, हिन्दू, हिन्दुकुश, मंगोलिया, साइबेरिया आदि सैंकड़ो प्राचीन यूरेशिया के भूगौलिक हरताक्षर बिंदुओं के नाम "किन्नौरी"भारतीय भाषा के शब्द है। जिन की उतपति "किन्नौरी"भारतीय भाषा बोलने वालों के मुख से हुई थी। जो दर्शाता है कि सरस्वती नदी के सूखने से पूर्व यह भाषा उक्त यूरेशिया के भूगोलिक क्षेत्रो में और मिस्र के पिरमिंड रचेताओ के द्वारा भी बोली जाती थी। जो यूरेशिया और अफ्रीका में किन्नौरी भाषियों के प्रवास पर मोहर लगाता है। लेकिन जिला किन्नौर के किन्नौरी भाषी लोगों की आनुवंशिक अध्ययन के बिना हम पुख्ततौर पर यह नहीं कह सकते हैकि किन्नौरी भाषी लोग भारत से बाहर गए थे या बाहर से भारत आये थे। यदि किन्नौर के आदिवासियों का डीएनए में R1a Y हेप्लोग्रु पाया जाता है तो आप के नवीन R1a Y हेप्लोग्रुप प्रवास सिद्धांत पर पक्की मोहर लग जाता कि R1a मध्य एशिया से भारत को नहीं आया है अपितु भारत से मध्य एशिया गया था।
The R1a migration theory is made up by Eurocentrists to form a link with a Civilization because at present they don't have any link. Greece is not linked to the Eurocentrists. The mtDNA studies show migration of women from India to the North West. The Eurocentrists are not able to deny that. Then they made two studies, one on R1a and another on Skin Color. The Skin Color done by David Reich is also fudged by including Andamanese Tribes to bring more darkness among Indians in South. And the R1a data is contains conjuncture. Thre R1a* is common in India, and Europe East, but very blank in Eurasia Region in Armenia and Georgia. So, they made a conjucture that R1a may have come from Europe. But, Yamnaya were predominantly R1b. They are said to be progenitor of Sintashta, which the Eurocentrists claim are original Aryans. But if Yamnayas who are R1b, came to India, through Sintashta and BMAC, then Indians should be R1b*. But it's not so. Also, the Eurocentrists, having seen that mtDNA movement is from India to North West, have made a special conclusion that Aryan Migration was only men migration, who came single without wives and children, which I think is ridiculous.
Better podcast channel than Joe Rogan in my Book
Joe Rogan is an idiot, he's anti science, anti vaxx, all conspiracy theory crap. Don't just follow or listen blindly.
Very good conversation