This ending did everything right. Rey and Ben together, Finn is getting his Jedi training, Ben and Chewie reconcile, and he even sees Unka Wanwo again.
@@olgak.1139 Ikr. He should have steeped down at least a year ago. But at least we have the WBW, and I still think we're seeing the start of a years long process of tying the universe together with Ahsoka and Bo Catan appearing in The Mandalorian. We could very well have an animated series on Disney+ of so many Force wielding heros helping Rey get to the WBW and restore the Dyad.
I love this version immensely. I wished this was in TROS a Ed made a better ending. Good job. Disney needs to hire you for their story group. You have great insight to Star Wars lore.
The reason why because people are still greed for classics, instead of having a heart with prequels. Because unlike them, I don’t address him as Vader no more because that name is no longer meaning to me, but rather a curse.
Bruh how couldn't JJ have tought of this, Disney should have done the same thing Harry Potter: The Deadly Hollows did, have Episode 9 in 2 movies, part I and II and do this story, Ben would have to do the same thing Revan did for Bastila in KOTOR, another similarity between these characters, The Dyad gets to live, Ben's redemption is *legit earned* , Anakin does something more meaningful in saving Ben, we get to see Finn as a Jedi.
Not only this good. It would actually have worked if they had done a two part film treatment. I seriously think this would work (re-tooled of course of to address the current circumstances ) for a future project. Rey and Ren's story is far from over.
Vittoria Colonna I liked RoS when I went cinema..and I've rewatched few times..I enjoy it mostly..but as months go on I'm more sure it won't stand test of time and Ben Rey thing is past.. the actors themselves have moved on.. can't see any follow up to a flawed maybe skewed film that is controversial to most fans.. seems risk for Disney when are other projects? Maybe is best left as a what if maybe notion..
@@neilmurphy966 in the future they might be willing to return, guys usually leave the big franchise to expand their career and not be associated with just one franchise, give them the time for them to do that and then try to bring them back
I like this. I also think Hux would have helped Ben, because one of the reasons he hated Ben was because of the mumbo jumbo force religion and the Empress was definitely a step in the wrong direction for him there. Ben could have taken Snoke’s advice and harnessed Hux’s abilities for his own end. But like in a way where they never explicitly have a conversation about it, they just both know it’s happening.
The only question I am left with after this theory is what do you do with Rey post IX? She clearly needs redemption, but there's no more story left to her. It's kind of unsatisfying in that regard. But solid theory, enjoyed it thoroughly.
i loved the sequels and i loved episode ix but i love this quite a bit more this i kinda wish 9 was split into two parts like the first half was rise of skywalker and ends with rey killing palpatine left on a cliffhanger then these two videos would be 9 part 2
I think episode 7 should stay as it is but than episode 9 would be episode 8 en this would be a great end for the skywalker saga. They just could make episode 8 a series or in comics or just tell in the opening crawl for episode (8) how kylo killed snoke
You should rewrite the sequels. I'm an amateur animator/music producer, and I can help with things like space battle graphics, fight scenes, and background music. I don't want any money, I'd just be happy to help entertain fans
Age is not really relevant. It’s all about experience and understanding which at this point in his life, Ben has more of than most ever will. This is a time of desperation, where he is reaching for whatever support he can get, as the Resistance is the extreme underdog in a dire situation.
Oh come on. Why does the Most powerful Sith ever born always get defeated by a street rat. Oh wait, I know. So that the alleged good guys can carry the day. Boo humbug. The Emperor should have easily defeated that trash rat, hands down.
This ending did everything right. Rey and Ben together, Finn is getting his Jedi training, Ben and Chewie reconcile, and he even sees Unka Wanwo again.
And we could get our "Happily ever after" like the end of ROTJ. Bob Iger treated TROS miserably like a happily ever after ending ,is a sin!
@@olgak.1139 Ikr. He should have steeped down at least a year ago. But at least we have the WBW, and I still think we're seeing the start of a years long process of tying the universe together with Ahsoka and Bo Catan appearing in The Mandalorian. We could very well have an animated series on Disney+ of so many Force wielding heros helping Rey get to the WBW and restore the Dyad.
That is how is should have been
I love this version immensely. I wished this was in TROS a Ed made a better ending. Good job. Disney needs to hire you for their story group. You have great insight to Star Wars lore.
Haha I wish! Glad you enjoyed
I wish that did happen with Ben. I wish in the end, Anakin would appear and bring Ben back to life. That would have been WAY better!
Disney doesn't know how to make good movies
i actually wanna see more :(
@@coolcoll1262 very true
Plus there would’ve been more to have and imagine if Rey and Ben had a daughter and what could’ve happened Disney wasted so much potential
The reason why because people are still greed for classics, instead of having a heart with prequels. Because unlike them, I don’t address him as Vader no more because that name is no longer meaning to me, but rather a curse.
Well, THIS IS The Rise Of Skywalker.
a skywalker saving a palpatine. the galaxy will never be the same. 👍
I wish this was the end of the actual movie. Rey not dead. Ben not dead. Both being Jedi's together.
Bruh how couldn't JJ have tought of this, Disney should have done the same thing Harry Potter: The Deadly Hollows did, have Episode 9 in 2 movies, part I and II and do this story, Ben would have to do the same thing Revan did for Bastila in KOTOR, another similarity between these characters, The Dyad gets to live, Ben's redemption is *legit earned* , Anakin does something more meaningful in saving Ben, we get to see Finn as a Jedi.
As always, amazing. Please keep writing and sharing.
This is awesome I love it you did a great job. Thumbs up to you. Two stories you have done that was great story telling. Thank you.
Now every time I watch the movie I will always think of this ending
Not only this good. It would actually have worked if they had done a two part film treatment. I seriously think this would work (re-tooled of course of to address the current circumstances ) for a future project. Rey and Ren's story is far from over.
Hadn’t really thought about it that way but you are absolutely right!
Vittoria Colonna I liked RoS when I went cinema..and I've rewatched few times..I enjoy it mostly..but as months go on I'm more sure it won't stand test of time and Ben Rey thing is past.. the actors themselves have moved on.. can't see any follow up to a flawed maybe skewed film that is controversial to most fans.. seems risk for Disney when are other projects? Maybe is best left as a what if maybe notion..
@@neilmurphy966 in the future they might be willing to return, guys usually leave the big franchise to expand their career and not be associated with just one franchise, give them the time for them to do that and then try to bring them back
This is so good! Thank you for this 👍😁
I loved this! This was so sad. And so good. Poor Rey though! I was devastated when she died in the movie.
I like this. I also think Hux would have helped Ben, because one of the reasons he hated Ben was because of the mumbo jumbo force religion and the Empress was definitely a step in the wrong direction for him there. Ben could have taken Snoke’s advice and harnessed Hux’s abilities for his own end. But like in a way where they never explicitly have a conversation about it, they just both know it’s happening.
but he's already dead by the time this what if begins fam
From now on I will pretend that this story was exactly what happened in EP 9.
Same
The only question I am left with after this theory is what do you do with Rey post IX? She clearly needs redemption, but there's no more story left to her. It's kind of unsatisfying in that regard. But solid theory, enjoyed it thoroughly.
Best ending ever 🤩
It's sad that TH-camrs can write better stories than Disney.
I honestly think Fin should have been Mace Windu level in his connection to the force. Otherwise, this was perfect!!
Agreed
I always wanted to see The First Order X Resistance VS Sith Eternal. Would've been way cooler if Kylo would have turned TFO against Palps.
This should’ve been the ACTUAL ENDING!
About time
This is so much better than the film and it actually fits the title of the rise of skywalker
This is now cannon for me
The Real Rise of Skywalker Part 2 XD
The first time I watched this I cried. I am not at that part yet
I like it! Far better than TROS.
Oh my goodness!!! Bravo! Bravo!
Great fan fic 🤗
Great story man awesome!! So much better than what Disney came up with!!
Very well Done 👏😁
Great
i loved the sequels and i loved episode ix but i love this quite a bit more this i kinda wish 9 was split into two parts like the first half was rise of skywalker and ends with rey killing palpatine left on a cliffhanger then these two videos would be 9 part 2
Ben: dies
Anakin: *not on my watch*
If they made episodes 10-12 it probably would of went along the lines of this.
I think that's the better story
well, she is more of a sith than kylo
Yes new episode, whoop whoop! 😂
WE NEED A PART 3 PLEASE!!!!???
The force ghosts surprisingly never play an integral part in the future or guidance of the new jedi
Do a what if ankin never turned to the dark side
Ben Solo has the High Ground!
That’s exactly HISHE!
amazing!
I think episode 7 should stay as it is but than episode 9 would be episode 8 en this would be a great end for the skywalker saga.
They just could make episode 8 a series or in comics or just tell in the opening crawl for episode (8) how kylo killed snoke
Nice
NICE
I would also like to think in this story Ben is using Anakin saber
Could you make a video about if Luke actually killed Ben when he went into his hut?
This was absolutly beutiful
Amazing
Yay! I didn’t cry this time
The true Rise of Skywalker
Same this would be great 👍 grandfather Anakin Skywalker on Ben solos side
Dude, U should have written TROS. So far I'm liking this way better than the cluser fuck of a film we got.
WOW
This is how the movie should have been, this is way better and gives me waht tros never gave me.... Anikan
much better ending then the movie
This would have been a great way to end the movies. ❤
I think rey/palpatin woud sence the shift in ben and they woud probably fight
I would have actually liked Rey if this had happened.
Nah but like this is how it should have ended
This is a good story but it could use when I was stealing things from the movies something new
Palps +Mareysueeeeeeee=Unlimited Powaaaaaaaa!
You should rewrite the sequels. I'm an amateur animator/music producer, and I can help with things like space battle graphics, fight scenes, and background music. I don't want any money, I'd just be happy to help entertain fans
😂
so, another too young master? finn and ben are 6 years apart fam :/
Age is not really relevant. It’s all about experience and understanding which at this point in his life, Ben has more of than most ever will.
This is a time of desperation, where he is reaching for whatever support he can get, as the Resistance is the extreme underdog in a dire situation.
Oh come on. Why does the Most powerful Sith ever born always get defeated by a street rat. Oh wait, I know. So that the alleged good guys can carry the day. Boo humbug. The Emperor should have easily defeated that trash rat, hands down.
Wow
Nice tie in to TROS & fix it its💩 ending
this is such bs rey isnt powerful at all
that kiss made no senses sorry i got too dislike it
WHY DID YOU LET THE REYLO STAY THE SAME!? YOU COULD HAVE CHANGED IT TO MAKE FINN & REY TO BE TOGETHER!!!