This is a very good translation. In most cases it matches the two I have but in a few areas I feel your choices are better. I will consult with my co-conspirator of one translation and see how it can help us. And I will report back here when I can. Many thanks. Great work.
@@Omnilatent Translation of copyright material can't be published without authorisation, because it is a derivative work. The German translation remains copyright of the estate by virtue of it being derivative. The re-translation is then a derivative of that. The law is pretty clear on it.
Very well done im from persia ,and just like tolkien i am in love with languages that's why I'm learning my fifth language Korean now ....i have to say though over here life is hard and tolkien sources are scarce ,i love middle earth and tolkien and i read everything original and buy the books original as well,but i wont touch translation, i wont trust anyone to translate his work or god forbid and most likely censor it ...despite Persian being an indo European language and shares grammar and lot of words with english and being 5000 years old and so rich with history and first in the world history, mythology and world wide famous poems ,i refuse to read it anything but english or ...Sindarin.😁 ps.did you know that persian had three scripts the firs persian empire script and second one and the modern one today which is the person arabic script (only European language with this script or one that isn't roman) thoush with persian we added a few alphabets arabs and other native middle easterners didn't have sound for which we did like p or zh and more ...despite this script not working at all with our language which causes a lot of issues and problems for the language top literature professor and others proposed moving to the roman or russian script which works with it ...but with the current murder**** in power very unlikely.
this is so awesome to watch, not many people would be this dedicated to finding a random german poem from 50 years ago, thanks for the great vids
Glad you enjoyed it! And thank you for the kind comments :)
This is one hell of a find, thank you, appriciate your time to translate this sir!
Thank you very much! 😃
WOW! As a german I appreciate your hard work !!!
Thank you very much! That really means a lot 😃
This is a very good translation. In most cases it matches the two I have but in a few areas I feel your choices are better. I will consult with my co-conspirator of one translation and see how it can help us. And I will report back here when I can. Many thanks. Great work.
Oh nice! It's great to hear others have taken a shot at translating this piece. Would love to hear your own results on this.
You cinematography is great, I am sure your channel will grow. A very exciting video, probs to you for making the effort.
Cheers Anders for the kind words :D
I'm speechless. You're amazing.
Oh wow! Cheers!
Awesome, what a treat to hear something new from Tolkien! Thanks for sharing this.
Cheers!
This makes me think of the possibility of other lost tolkien stories
Indeed. Who know what hidden treasures are yet to be unearthed?
Amazing job! Thank you so much for sharing this with us.
You're most welcome :)
Thank you so much for the time and effort you've devoted to this translation, and for sharing it with us!
You’re welcome! And thanks 😃
Well done! Absolutely wonderful ❤😊
Many thanks!
Very cool
If you ever need a German-English translation do give me a shoutout :) Well done!
Cheers Marcel! Most appreciated :)
From when I was young
That’s great 😃
I still have my mom lotr calinders
Well done!
Thanks!
This is so great I really appreciate such fine work!! A question, can you share the full text translation of the prose fragment?
Thank you very much! Unfortunately I cannot share the full text in question, as it is protected by copyright.
Really well done. Expect a take-down from the Estate, though, per their modus operandi
Haha waiting with bathed breath XD
How can a translation of a translation be considered copyrighted, though?
@@Omnilatent Translation of copyright material can't be published without authorisation, because it is a derivative work. The German translation remains copyright of the estate by virtue of it being derivative. The re-translation is then a derivative of that. The law is pretty clear on it.
@@stu356 Wow, copyright sure seems complicated. Thanks for the info!
Very well done im from persia ,and just like tolkien i am in love with languages that's why I'm learning my fifth language Korean now ....i have to say though over here life is hard and tolkien sources are scarce ,i love middle earth and tolkien and i read everything original and buy the books original as well,but i wont touch translation, i wont trust anyone to translate his work or god forbid and most likely censor it ...despite Persian being an indo European language and shares grammar and lot of words with english and being 5000 years old and so rich with history and first in the world history, mythology and world wide famous poems ,i refuse to read it anything but english or ...Sindarin.😁
ps.did you know that persian had three scripts the firs persian empire script and second one and the modern one today which is the person arabic script (only European language with this script or one that isn't roman) thoush with persian we added a few alphabets arabs and other native middle easterners didn't have sound for which we did like p or zh and more ...despite this script not working at all with our language which causes a lot of issues and problems for the language top literature professor and others proposed moving to the roman or russian script which works with it ...but with the current murder**** in power very unlikely.
Thanks for sharing and best of luck with your language lessons :)
Could you give the ISBN of the correct book version? Would like to read it in german.
Sure thing 🙂 ISBN: 360895502X
very great work!
Thank you!
Your translation and cinematography was fantastic! Do you think you could share a link to the full text in German?
Thank you so much! But I’m afraid I can’t share the full German text due to copyright reasons. Sorry 😟
A translation of a translation… sound comparable to the Red Book of Westmarch
Indeed 😃