Watching the video of her coming into the kitchen and just sitting down like nothing happened did it for me! The girl is evil. It doesn't matter how young she is. She isn't insane she knew exactly what she was doing!!!
@@junetomlin1 that's not how it works. Defense has to be IMPARTIAL in the eyes of the law. That's why even the most vile people still have the right to legal defense. You can't let personal feelings get in the way when in court. For all we know her Defense lawyer(s) hates her guts, lol. It's simply their job to try and get the best outcome for their client.
but it was premeditated, she texted her stepfather, pretending to be his wife to see when he was coming home, she waited to shoot him, Carly is dangerous, I know she was only 14, but some children are born evil, sorry its just a fact.
Don't be sorry.. It's just a matter of fact!! This girl is evil and is so dangerous because she look's so sweet, so young and innocent, know one would ever suspect her.. Dangerous!! 🤨
This was really a case of “how dare you go through my private room and discover my weed , burner phone and hookup plans”. She felt so intelligent and adult like that she was not letting her mother and step father get in her way of doing what she felt she had the right to do, despite they only wanted to set guidelines and boundaries to protect her. She is not safe for the public arena
@@reginagilby1101 kids javecwAy too much access at a young age. I asked my grandson when he was 2-1/2 “how do you know my iPad password? “ he said “cause I know it”. He watched me and picked up on it quickly. By age 9 he’d learned to drive a rig across country and knew the freeways all through simulator.
I live in Germany. Germany is a paradise for young murderers because they cannot be convicted until they are 14 years old. Two years ago, two 13-year-old girls murdered their 12-year-old friend in the forest. Both were acquitted because they were not of criminal responsibility at the age of 13. That's how crazy it is in Germany
just because he says "THAT WASN"T HER" means nothing. He walked into horror and she screamed after killing her mother. Of course "that wasn't her" in his usual encounters with her. It means nothing. She played the dramatics and screamed because he got the gun from her. It's not rocket science
Are you familiar with neuroscience and brain development-how it grows and matures? Obviously not. Talk to any neurologist who knows brain development and then get back to me. Tired of repeating myself. Does not do any good.
@@Friendofstfrank Many people are abused and neglected as a child and never kill anyone. Talk to other people who have been abused as children and get back to me. Tired of repeating myself, does no good.
She was terrified because the last thing she expected was for him to grab that gun; when he did, the terror her mother felt washed over her knowing there was a possibility her life could be taken since she had lost control of the weapon. It had nothing to do with a mental health break or psychosis! She is right where she belongs- in prison for the rest of her life!!
Even her stepfather was on her side, don’t you think? And he never was questioned why the loaded gun was so easily to grab for unstable, mentally ill teen?
Das ist ein Kind. Wie wäre es in den usa wenn es weniger Waffen in Privathand gäbe. Es wird Zeit, dass die terroristische Vereinigung NRA verboten wird.
no you did not. Neuroscience-brain grows from back to front and pre-frontal cortex which contains most short-term memory, impulse control, executive decision making and morals has not grown in until age 25 for females and later for males. Likely your peer group and relation were thinking the same way and so you were guided as such altho I imagine you did some silly things. I do not mean to be rude to you. However, I sincerely doubt your brain growth is different from the rest of humanity. This information has been known and was reflected in the shows and movies back in the late 80s. But like most scientific data people forget it over time. Essentially what you have is what we would consider a 7 year olds brain in an adult body. The brain has not fully grown. When you add an ingrown brain with psychotropic medication this is the result.
Seriously, you had the ability to see at 14 how your actions would affect your future??? I've worked with teens for 30 years and they couldn't, didn't have the capacity to understand the depth of their actions.
Oh clearly, but should be in a specialist institution not a jail. Maybe the problem is the system is too concerned with guilty/ not guilty then finding the right place to house her
The only disappointment is that she is now in a facility where she is being treated like she didn't commit a heinous crime. She's just there locked up not allowed to go out anymore but the facility is just like a rehabilitation not a prison.
Here's the problem with the defense's argument, especially when it comes to the testimony of the step father and his feelings that she was out of her mind and didn't even recognize him. First, she texted the step dad to see where he was and when he would be home. Second, he told the friend that she shot her mom three times and had three more for her step dad. That's not insanity. That's not a loss of thought control. Etc. It's pure and simple malice. Intent.
*Heath was almost gone too.* Maybe its shock mixed with wanting their life to be how it was. Mother and daughter probably had issues Not in his presence. This is scary! 👀😔 She did that like walking in a room and walking out like Nothing happened. *Heath needs to Wake up!* 😔😐
What about the victims, a dead Mother and a injured Step Father, a child committed this horrific crime. Stop making excuses and ACCOUNTABILITY for your crimes.
She murdered her mother in cold blood! Carley hunted her down, shot her in the back with her own mother's gun, calmly walked into the kitchen, grabbed her mother's phone and set her stepdad up for murder! After she failed her mission to kill him, she jumps a privacy fence and runs away! Yeah, that wasn't planned out and put into motion! Math ain't mathin! GUILTY as charged!
Tragically, Carly Gregg shot her mother three times in the face. Looking into her mother's eyes, she decides to execute her. I believe that Carly fully deserves her sentence.
Instead of a new trial, investigate creepy stepdad deeper. Something tells me they plotted this, him getting shot and all, and he had Carly believing she’d get off on insanity. I mean we’ve seen the craziest of things. This wouldn’t surprise me🤷♀️
No! That poor man has been thrown under the bus for no reason! He lost his entire family in one instant! It’s only been 6 months. He hasn’t even processed what has happened yet!
Why is it that most of these killer$ claim mental illness when they get caught? I believe some are mentally ill and others are just trying to get away from the crime they committed. This is my opinion and i believe she knew exactly what she was doing. Im not a professional but when i look at her i get this gut feeling that she knew what she was doing.
because they want to be able to murder and get away with it, so they pull the sympathy card. blame the fact that some people DO get away with it because "no they arent insane but they got a chemical imbalance and its the meds or lack thereofs fault" they pay some "expert" in the field to say as much and the jury doesnt know any better
Even bio dad is like: she's not insane. She knows right from wrong. That was dumb defense, but nobody asked me. So there ya have it. Even her blood says she just a psychopath. He refused to partake in her defense because he probably believes she should have pled guilty and taken the 40 year plea. It was a good deal, she IS guilty!
@jillytots9999 and? She still killed her mother! She knew/knows right from wrong!period, point blank!! Her bio dad is a piece of 💩 but he's not wrong, she's not insane.
also the mother had that gun because she was afraid of getting shot by the bio dad, could it be in her, Carly's genes? The violence, I mean@@jillytots9999
I get a feeling that step dad was in on this. This is why he was shot in shoulder and lived. Believed the child would be let ho due to being a child with a slap on the wrist. Then the step dad and Carly would live happily ever after. Just my thoughts!
Seems odd mother was shot four times dead without a miss. Stepfather had a minor wound to shoulder, bandaged, and sent home. He even stated he never felt any pain, so maybe all that screaming like in pain was an act. Something just isn't right between stepfather and Carly. Maybe not sexual, but some sort of unusual bound.
She snuck up on her mother. She knew her mother was going through her room for drugs and burn her phones that’s why her mother put a camera in the house because her daughter was sneaking out and lying doing all kinds of shady crap she ambushed her mother, she didn’t want her mother to find out anything that she didn’t already know or possibly new so that was the stopper in her tracks And then she called her friend said I just pumped three bullets my mother said and I got three more in the chamber for my stepdad when he gets here are you squeamish looking at a dead body then took her in the show her mother‘s dead body her mother‘s laying in there when she shot her the first two times screaming help me help me, and she starts humming and singing over her in the kitchen with the gun still behind her back on the stool and then gets up and goes back in there with the gun and put it to her brain and shoots her, she knew exactly what she’s doing. She’s not insane. There’s nothing wrong with that. She just needs to go where she’s at and never get out.
I have questioned this possibility as well. Something with the stepfather and Carly seems odd. I saw him blinking at her during the trial, and consequently, she smiled at him. Strange...
Not only did she kill her mom she called her friend to come over and look at her dead body and she told her friend to get out of the house because she was going shot her stepdad
She does not have the right 4 a new trial! She knew exactly wat she was doing. Imo she's kicking herself 4 not taking the deal. Backfired on her. Tough. She blew her own mother away!!😢 l hope with everything i have this will not b entertained.😡
@@nikkiwalsh2762 It’s a due process thing, and her medicine being off kilter was a major part of the defense theory. The defense should get to present their theory? If you shot someone in self defense and the judge precluded you from arguing self defense, should you get a new trial? Absolutely, because the defense should be able to argue whatever the hell they want to.
@@nikkiwalsh2762 your opinion is different from legality. I am talking legality. She might end up convicted again, but at least that time she will have had due process.
I think there's a possibility that they were trying to treat a mentally healthy girl growing through puberty and it may have messed with her her. Don't 'fix'something that isn't broken. Kids that are growing up, going through teen issues don't always need medication that changes the way their brain function.
Wow! This girl is pure evil. You're the type of people that let people like her out to k-ill again. Then after the fact you'll be like, "We didn't realise." Smh
I feel that there is something very strange about the Stepfather, his screaming on the 911 call was also not right, I thought it was a woman. I could be wrong but the whole situation is unsettling to me. She does not deserve a new trial she is pure evil.
Glad someone questions this sentence that so many on this board cruelly agree too, without really knowing whether Nr. 1 the step dad is involved and manipulated the whole thing, and Nr.2 , the girl truly has a severe mental illness that requires treatment not lifelong incarceration. The whole think is anything but normal.
When the verdicts were announced Carly cried a little bit. When the sentencing was announced she cried again, but both times you can see that she doesn’t really know what’s going on. She’s sad about her sentence, but it seems to me like she doesn’t understand any of it.
I feel bad for the step dad because he’s left to try and figure out what on earth went wrong. His judgment is askew due to such a traumatic experience. Defending her is the only way he can psychologically cope with what happened. He’s in serious denial. That said, I just don’t think life in prison is the right choice for a 14 year old. Yes she should pay a price but I don’t think her entire life should be the payment.
For over 40 years,we brought kids to the ranch for equine therapy and not one of them shot their mother in the face.I never heard any testimony where she claimed DELUSIONS at all.
The media has said that her friend testified that Carly told her that she was hearing voices. The testimony of minors was not allowed to be recorded to protect their identities.
I TOTALLY agree. I am aghast how judgemental and self-righteous so many people on this board are. And this is supposed to be a Christian nation??? I am sure her mother would forgive her and not want her to spend her entire life in prison. Aside from that, I am equally sure that the girl has either a mental illness or she was manipulated by her stepfather, because this deed was anything but normal.
The bio dad saying the defense never contacted him?! Are you kidding me?! You 14 year old daughter is on trial for 1sr degree murder and you didn’t contact anyone to help?! Wow
@@Camiken65 that type of issue has never stopped a prosecutor from using these types of witness before (jail cell mate confessions, drug dealers and fellow criminals)
Doesn't matter if she had auditory hallucinations or if she was or wasn't bipolar. The legal standard in Mississippi for insanity as a plea is that at the time she committed the murder, she knew it was wrong. And she did. Her actions before and after show consciousness of guilt. If she had/has a mental illness that may explain movtive, but it doesn't mean she gets a pass for committing murder.
It is possible to have psychosis and do the most awful things. I think she is dangerous yes, but I think she should be in psychiatric care securely rather than treated as an adult and judged as an adult.
I agree with you. I am aghast how many people cruelly sit in judgement of this 14 year old child, although they/we don't know if she is bipolar or has schizophrenia, but this is not normal behavior of a child who all along got along well with her mother.
@@Alago44 he couldn’t be there he domestically abused his ex wife / Carly’s mother. The reason she bought the gun in the first place was to protect herself from Carly’s bio dad
Equine psychotherapy can be an incredible therapy for a lot of emotional difficulties but I agree that it’s not appropriate for psychosis/auditory hallucinations 🤷🏼♀️
@@makeupqueen130 Isn’t strange he couldn’t come forward when the trial was going ahead but now wants to make money on Carly’s baby pics . Father of the year 🤮Not
Right!! There’s a lot of issues that need to be examined further. Bio dad couldn’t be bothered to show up. The med switch needs to be examined further.
You are not alone here with your opinion. Unfortunately, too many people on this board are highly judgemental and self righteous, which seems to became a pronounced trait in the US, although it calls itself a "Christian" nation. I am sure Carly's mother would not want her to spend her whole life in prison. If my daughter would kill me, I would not want her to spend a life time behind bars. I would forgive my child, no matter what.
You leave a loaded gun lying around unattended then you must expect you or people you care about to get killed. Guess what? It's your own damn fault, nobody elses. Gun owners need to take responsibility.
Am I the only one that notices the narrative around her would be completely different than if she was a boy? This idea of "Poor Girl" is insane to me, and now blaming the father for not being there for the trail... w.t.f. Systemic misandry.
Did you not watch the Ethan crumbley trial? The whole thing was “poor boy, he had so many emotions😢.” And his parents were blamed so hard they got jail time. You’re just talking to talk
Also no one’s blaming the father for not being there during the trial. It’s just weird that he showed up in time to get paid for a couple of interviews. But if being recognized as an opportunistic weirdo is misandry, then oh well
She should have been hospitalized. It's a insult on mental health . Life without parole judge should be questioned? Mass murder s get less . She was 14 years old lots of time to give this child help .
I am almost amazed to find ONE person, YOU, on this board who question's the girls mental state. I thought I had read somewhere she is schizophrenic, and apparently she had a good relationship with her Mom. Something has got to be wrong with her mental state. I normal healthy kid does not do that no matter what. And I think all those people in this board condemning her are extremely judgemental and incredibly self-righteous.
NOPE SHE DIDNT TAKE THE PLE....SHE HAD HER DAY IN COURT AND ALL THE PROFF WAS GIVEN....IT STANDS AS CHARGED IN MY OPINION AND I WAS OPENED MINDED AND WATCHED THIS....SHE WAS MAD AS SHE COULD BE THATS ALL AND HER STEP-DAD IS TO CLOSE THATS WHY WE HAVE JUDGE AND JURY'S IN AMERICA THE GIRL PLANNED AND KILLED AND HID WHAT SHE DONE TO HER OWN MOTHER WHO LOVED HE MORE THAN ANYONE...GUILTY...
Welche Strafe hätte Carly Gregg in Deutschland bekommen? - In Deutschland wird Jugendstrafrecht ab 14 Jahre bis 17 Jahre angewendet, in vielen Fällen sogar bis zum 21. Lebensjahr. - Höchststrafe sind im Jugendstrafrecht 10 Jahre Haft in einem Gefängnis wo viele Jugendliche die Strafe verbüßen müssen. - Dort können die Jugendlichen ihren Schulabschluss machen und eine Ausbildung beginnen und können nach ihrer Strafe dem Arbeitsmarkt zugeführt werden. - Bis einen Tag vor dem 14. Geburtstag werden Jugendliche in Deutschland überhaupt nicht bestraft. Zum Beispiel gab es im März 2023 in Deutschland einen furchtbaren Mord an einem zwölfjährigen Mädchen. Täterin waren zwei Schülerinnen 12 Jahre und 13 Jahre alt aus dem gleichen Wohnort. Beide Mädchen erhielten keine Strafe und wurden nur dem Jugendamt übergeben und leben nun in einer anderen Stadt. - Carly Gregg verdient eine Strafe, aber nicht lebenslang!
Ich lebe teils in Deutschland, teils in den USA. Auch mir ist der Fall von den beiden Maedchen, den Du hier schilderst bekannt. Was die Justiz in den USA angeht, sind Strafen fuer viele Verbrechen unheimlich grausam und wenn ich sehe, wie Jugendliche, die an einen Autounfall mit Todesfolge schuldig sind, zu lebenslaenglicher Haft verurteilt werden, wird mir schlecht. Auf der anderen Seite sind die Strafen in Deutschland im Allgemeinen etwas zu lasch, aber dafuer auch noch menschlich, was in den USA nicht der Fall ist und nie eine Rolle spielt. Meines Erachtens hat Carly psychische Probleme und braucht Behandlung. Eine andere Moeglichkeit ist dass eine sexuelle Beziehung zwischen ihr und ihrem Stiefvater bestand und derselbe sie irgendwie manipulierte, die Mutter umzubringen. So oder so, sollte sie als Jugendliche behandelt werden.
🤔Why does everyone defend the killer but not the victim or the victims family? She committed an egregious crime and got found guilty. She deserves to be in prison without parole for that. It’s not our job to figure her mental health after she killed someone. It’s the parent’s responsibility to make sure their kids mental health is being cared for properly so this dose t happen.
Her grandparents are sticking by her, and there was a lady that looked like Ashley (sister maybe) that was with them. I’m not sure what other family members there are. I did see the state crossing their fingers and mouthing fingers crossed when the verdict came in, but they could be friends.
What I don’t understand is when are you an adult? I’m curious because she is tried as an adult. But if she was having a sexual relationship with an individual over 18. She is a minor.
something ain't stirring the Koolaid between the stepfather and the stepdaughter. I'm beginning to think they were in on it together. My theory is that there might have been some kind of insurance policy. The text message from the mother's phone was a cue for the stepdad to come in to get "shot" by the stepdaughter so the stepdad could appear to be a "victim," too. How in the world is she able to shoot her mother three times with no problem, but she supposedly aimed for the stepfather's head and missed only grazing his shoulder. My personal opinion is that he didn't sound too stressed on the 911 call, almost like it was rehearsed. Again, this is all theory, but I'm thinking the stepfather convinced the stepdaughter that if she committed the crime, she wouldn't get as much time in prison because of her age.
I am also of that opinion, unless she has a severe mental illness. Something is truly wrong here, but the sentence for a juvenile is extremely harsh. The kid needs help.
If new trial is being thinking , Carly should take the stand. She did wrong we all know that . However , she has the right to that . She is being trying as in adult . Well she can take the stand …… don’t see why not . More, to learn , something is not right . Every family has their story.
If it was the case he refused to co-operate rather than wasn't called, maybe it was because he was gonna be dragged through the mud and hoped the jury wold be sympathetic but now that they weren't he's decided to show his face but also, why didnt this come up in medical records search? If the defence failed to subpoena records far back enough, is that new evidence or ineffective counsel? His testimony only wouldn't wash with me unless there's records to back it up
The outcome can be the same for all I care, but I do think a new trial is warranted. The judge should have allowed the medicinal expert that the defense wanted to testify before the jury testify. That was a big part of the defense theory, and the judge didn’t let them put on a case to that part.
And Carly’s doctors too, they failed her 😢😢 I saw when her doctor spoke… she was laughing and not serious, more about herself and protecting her license! In my opinion…
You're so right! Reminds me of people who say stupid crap like crimes don't happen in their town. This girl is evil. Cold and calculated. She showed her mother's body to her friend like she was a showpiece. She was offered a plea deal and didn't want it. That's her problem.
3:58 Oh, yea? It wasn't Carly? She had already killed her mother and invited her friend over to see the body. How did she act with the friend? Has this ever been asked or addressed?
#CourtTV - What do YOU think?
MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/carly-gregg/?
New Trial.
Watching the video of her coming into the kitchen and just sitting down like nothing happened did it for me! The girl is evil. It doesn't matter how young she is. She isn't insane she knew exactly what she was doing!!!
@@stacyn.Yeah Good luck 👍 with that one! 😂😂
@@TheUniqueme1 Why?
@@sherry8894 Agreed but she probably stopped hearing the voice’s.
Carly don't need a new trial she's good where she's at in prison
Medieval times, inquisition for kid!
No she shouldn't get a new trial. But its Defenses job to try.
DEFENCE HAVE NO CONSCIENCE
You're absolutely clueless. Hope you never need a defense attorney. @@junetomlin1
@@junetomlin1 that's not how it works. Defense has to be IMPARTIAL in the eyes of the law. That's why even the most vile people still have the right to legal defense.
You can't let personal feelings get in the way when in court. For all we know her Defense lawyer(s) hates her guts, lol. It's simply their job to try and get the best outcome for their client.
but it was premeditated, she texted her stepfather, pretending to be his wife to see when he was coming home, she waited to shoot him, Carly is dangerous, I know she was only 14, but some children are born evil, sorry its just a fact.
American system is dangerous, she is a mentally ill child with insufficient support.
Sadly i agree with u...
@@mariannecreighton8194 facts
Don't be sorry.. It's just a matter of fact!! This girl is evil and is so dangerous because she look's so sweet, so young and innocent, know one would ever suspect her.. Dangerous!! 🤨
Truth! Preaching!!!
This was really a case of “how dare you go through my private room and discover my weed , burner phone and hookup plans”. She felt so intelligent and adult like that she was not letting her mother and step father get in her way of doing what she felt she had the right to do, despite they only wanted to set guidelines and boundaries to protect her. She is not safe for the public arena
That’s practically all teenagers imo
Most don't murder their mothers @@reginagilby1101
They use the term burner phone but it was an old iPod they needed to clarify that more. Although it doesn’t make a difference.
@@reginagilby1101 kids javecwAy too much access at a young age. I asked my grandson when he was 2-1/2 “how do you know my iPad password? “ he said “cause I know it”. He watched me and picked up on it quickly. By age 9 he’d learned to drive a rig across country and knew the freeways all through simulator.
it's all on tape what is wrong with this world? She killed her she needs locked up for life. Next
@@djohny-ne3gg mannnnn facts!
Can you not look deeper into why?
@@Paula14609 she is still a murderer
Right up there with Sarah Boone being acquitted under battered spouse syndrome (is Sarah gets her way).
I live in Germany. Germany is a paradise for young murderers because they cannot be convicted until they are 14 years old. Two years ago, two 13-year-old girls murdered their 12-year-old friend in the forest. Both were acquitted because they were not of criminal responsibility at the age of 13. That's how crazy it is in Germany
She knew what she was doing...
She should never be Free
NOOOOOO she's guilty
NO!!! Don’t wast tax payers money!
just because he says "THAT WASN"T HER" means nothing. He walked into horror and she screamed after killing her mother. Of course "that wasn't her" in his usual encounters with her. It means nothing. She played the dramatics and screamed because he got the gun from her. It's not rocket science
Are you familiar with neuroscience and brain development-how it grows and matures? Obviously not. Talk to any neurologist who knows brain development and then get back to me.
Tired of repeating myself. Does not do any good.
@@Friendofstfrank Many people are abused and neglected as a child and never kill anyone. Talk to other people who have been abused as children and get back to me. Tired of repeating myself, does no good.
She was terrified because the last thing she expected was for him to grab that gun; when he did, the terror her mother felt washed over her knowing there was a possibility her life could be taken since she had lost control of the weapon. It had nothing to do with a mental health break or psychosis! She is right where she belongs- in prison for the rest of her life!!
Even her stepfather was on her side, don’t you think? And he never was questioned why the loaded gun was so easily to grab for unstable, mentally ill teen?
I believe her stepdad got to go to prison, and Carly needs a good doctor, not that “blond & smiling “
@@LenaFlower-c8byou should go to prison too for being a clown
@@LenaFlower-c8bFound the lib
No please no. She’s guilt and needs to rot in prison. She’s EXTREMELY dangerous to society.
Das ist ein Kind. Wie wäre es in den usa wenn es weniger Waffen in Privathand gäbe. Es wird Zeit, dass die terroristische Vereinigung NRA verboten wird.
New Trial for what? Camera's don't lie and it was premeditated murder the psycho got what she deserved life in prison
When I was her age I knew right from wrong and had the ability to see how my actions may effect my future. She knew what she was doing.
Just didn't care IMO
@@trish2179 where you on medication at her age?
no you did not.
Neuroscience-brain grows from back to front and pre-frontal cortex which contains most short-term memory, impulse control, executive decision making and morals has not grown in until age 25 for females and later for males.
Likely your peer group and relation were thinking the same way and so you were guided as such altho I imagine you did some silly things.
I do not mean to be rude to you. However, I sincerely doubt your brain growth is different from the rest of humanity.
This information has been known and was reflected in the shows and movies back in the late 80s. But like most scientific data people forget it over time. Essentially what you have is what we would consider a 7 year olds brain in an adult body. The brain has not fully grown.
When you add an ingrown brain with psychotropic medication this is the result.
@@Friendofstfrank Most kids know it's wrong to shoot their parents. 🤣 All that from you to deny the obvious. Book smart but no common sense it seems.
Seriously, you had the ability to see at 14 how your actions would affect your future??? I've worked with teens for 30 years and they couldn't, didn't have the capacity to understand the depth of their actions.
How does the defense explain Carly telling her friend that she "put 3 in her mom and has 3 more for her stepdad"? That seems very intentional.
Too dangerous to be loose on society
she's like a mini Ezra McCandless
Oh clearly, but should be in a specialist institution not a jail. Maybe the problem is the system is too concerned with guilty/ not guilty then finding the right place to house her
The only disappointment is that she is now in a facility where she is being treated like she didn't commit a heinous crime. She's just there locked up not allowed to go out anymore but the facility is just like a rehabilitation not a prison.
Here's the problem with the defense's argument, especially when it comes to the testimony of the step father and his feelings that she was out of her mind and didn't even recognize him.
First, she texted the step dad to see where he was and when he would be home. Second, he told the friend that she shot her mom three times and had three more for her step dad. That's not insanity. That's not a loss of thought control. Etc. It's pure and simple malice. Intent.
Her stepdad creeps me out so much and I don’t know why.. my stomach literally sinks
Same here. I feel he knows more than anyone knows. He said he's had a special 'relationship ' her
*Heath was almost gone too.*
Maybe its shock mixed with wanting their life to be how it was.
Mother and daughter probably had issues Not in his presence.
This is scary! 👀😔 She did that like walking in a room and walking out like Nothing happened. *Heath needs to Wake up!* 😔😐
No he is a good man who is a victim of this evil act.
Guess we’re finding something to blame a man for. Typical feminist behavior
What about the victims, a dead Mother and a injured Step Father, a child committed this horrific crime. Stop making excuses and ACCOUNTABILITY for your crimes.
She murdered her mom it’s a fact , she belongs in prison
@@micheleanzevino4101 and where she suddenly got the gun? Ha?
She murdered her mother in cold blood! Carley hunted her down, shot her in the back with her own mother's gun, calmly walked into the kitchen, grabbed her mother's phone and set her stepdad up for murder! After she failed her mission to kill him, she jumps a privacy fence and runs away! Yeah, that wasn't planned out and put into motion! Math ain't mathin! GUILTY as charged!
not exactly. Look at the evidence.
Tragically, Carly Gregg shot her mother three times in the face. Looking into her mother's eyes, she decides to execute her. I believe that Carly fully deserves her sentence.
Instead of a new trial, investigate creepy stepdad deeper. Something tells me they plotted this, him getting shot and all, and he had Carly believing she’d get off on insanity. I mean we’ve seen the craziest of things. This wouldn’t surprise me🤷♀️
You think she would not tell his involvement at this point to save herself?
He is just a good guy. That's it. There is no more secret.
The defense and prosecutors would have explored that if suspected. Especially Carlys defense attorneys in hopes to get her a lesser sentence.
It’s a mad world and indeed anything is possible, very little shocks me anyway.
Okay, Alex Jones. 😂😂😂😂
@@chocclatI was thinking the same thing
she hid the gun from the camera. so she knew right from wrong and was not insane. no new trial is needed.
anyone else suspect relations between her and her stepfather???
My exact thoughts.
No! That poor man has been thrown under the bus for no reason! He lost his entire family in one instant! It’s only been 6 months. He hasn’t even processed what has happened yet!
@@sherrymatthews2486 It doesn't seem to bother him too much anymore about the wife! But trying very hard to save his stepdaughter!
That little smile they exchange amongst other things !
@@LorenHarwood-bz5dy Yes, like they're saying it's not over we'll be back together! NOT!
She’s good where she’s at! Bye 👋 Carly! Bye Bye 👋
Keep her in jail! She deserves nothing.
Did she have something going on with the step father .. zero reason he should be supporting her
I thought exactly the same only mum dies ..and he supports her not even being her dad... right
Why is it that most of these killer$ claim mental illness when they get caught? I believe some are mentally ill and others are just trying to get away from the crime they committed. This is my opinion and i believe she knew exactly what she was doing. Im not a professional but when i look at her i get this gut feeling that she knew what she was doing.
because they want to be able to murder and get away with it, so they pull the sympathy card.
blame the fact that some people DO get away with it because "no they arent insane but they got a chemical imbalance and its the meds or lack thereofs fault"
they pay some "expert" in the field to say as much and the jury doesnt know any better
@@leslietisdial5753 she didn’t get caught, if she was that devious she would have removed the indoor cameras.
Even bio dad is like: she's not insane. She knows right from wrong. That was dumb defense, but nobody asked me.
So there ya have it. Even her blood says she just a psychopath. He refused to partake in her defense because he probably believes she should have pled guilty and taken the 40 year plea. It was a good deal, she IS guilty!
@@jgray690 I guess you didn’t hear the the bio dad caused DV to his wife and she fled from him, oh and a druggy too. Great father 🤮
@jillytots9999 and? She still killed her mother! She knew/knows right from wrong!period, point blank!! Her bio dad is a piece of 💩 but he's not wrong, she's not insane.
@@Glo_ria007 Your opinion is yours alone, I know there are other factors that have not come into play in this case. Thanks for your reply
@@Glo_ria007 Are you on medication?
also the mother had that gun because she was afraid of getting shot by the bio dad, could it be in her, Carly's genes? The violence, I mean@@jillytots9999
I get a feeling that step dad was in on this. This is why he was shot in shoulder and lived. Believed the child would be let ho due to being a child with a slap on the wrist. Then the step dad and Carly would live happily ever after. Just my thoughts!
Me too,
100%!
It’s crossed my mind.
100% agree. I don't know why the prosecutors can't see this.
Could be possible. If he was, why wouldn’t she say something to law enforcement or her attorney? But I do agree, he could be in one way or another.
Um why should she?
Seems odd mother was shot four times dead without a miss. Stepfather had a minor wound to shoulder, bandaged, and sent home. He even stated he never felt any pain, so maybe all that screaming like in pain was an act. Something just isn't right between stepfather and Carly. Maybe not sexual, but some sort of unusual bound.
There’s something about stepdad…..the way his eyes close…..
@@leeasmr3857or when he mouthed “I love you” to her. I think he is just creepy overall.
She snuck up on her mother. She knew her mother was going through her room for drugs and burn her phones that’s why her mother put a camera in the house because her daughter was sneaking out and lying doing all kinds of shady crap she ambushed her mother, she didn’t want her mother to find out anything that she didn’t already know or possibly new so that was the stopper in her tracks And then she called her friend said I just pumped three bullets my mother said and I got three more in the chamber for my stepdad when he gets here are you squeamish looking at a dead body then took her in the show her mother‘s dead body her mother‘s laying in there when she shot her the first two times screaming help me help me, and she starts humming and singing over her in the kitchen with the gun still behind her back on the stool and then gets up and goes back in there with the gun and put it to her brain and shoots her, she knew exactly what she’s doing. She’s not insane. There’s nothing wrong with that. She just needs to go where she’s at and never get out.
I have questioned this possibility as well. Something with the stepfather and Carly seems odd. I saw him blinking at her during the trial, and consequently, she smiled at him. Strange...
@@lydiabell6218 didn’t they say a family member mouthed to her that day she was found guilty “you’re getting out today” something like that?
Not only did she kill her mom she called her friend to come over and look at her dead body and she told her friend to get out of the house because she was going shot her stepdad
If there's no documentation, it shouldn't matter.
Hopefully not, she's guilty
The facts have not changed.
She does not have the right 4 a new trial! She knew exactly wat she was doing. Imo she's kicking herself 4 not taking the deal. Backfired on her. Tough. She blew her own mother away!!😢 l hope with everything i have this will not b entertained.😡
If the judge really did deny a medicine expert, this should be entertained.
@@mlbhighlights2756 absolutely not. Imo.
@@nikkiwalsh2762 It’s a due process thing, and her medicine being off kilter was a major part of the defense theory. The defense should get to present their theory? If you shot someone in self defense and the judge precluded you from arguing self defense, should you get a new trial? Absolutely, because the defense should be able to argue whatever the hell they want to.
@mlbhighlights2756 l don't agree. She's a cold hearted killer. Who was caught on camera. Simple as.
@@nikkiwalsh2762 your opinion is different from legality. I am talking legality. She might end up convicted again, but at least that time she will have had due process.
I think there's a possibility that they were trying to treat a mentally healthy girl growing through puberty and it may have messed with her her. Don't 'fix'something that isn't broken. Kids that are growing up, going through teen issues don't always need medication that changes the way their brain function.
Agreed! Those SSRI’s have known side effects. She needs help not prison!
Wow! This girl is pure evil. You're the type of people that let people like her out to k-ill again. Then after the fact you'll be like, "We didn't realise." Smh
She shouls get the chair. And her creepy, confused, weird Step Dad should be investigated and monitored.
The stepfather is either delusional or has an ulterior motive to lie.
You think he wasn't investigated? Try to use your brain, Perry Mason.
I feel that there is something very strange about the Stepfather, his screaming on the 911 call was also not right, I thought it was a woman. I could be wrong but the whole situation is unsettling to me. She does not deserve a new trial she is pure evil.
The look on the dads face is heartbreaking
14 years old gets a life sentence? What happened to juvenile rights? Juvie Hall until 21.
Glad someone questions this sentence that so many on this board cruelly agree too, without really knowing whether Nr. 1 the step dad is involved and manipulated the whole thing, and Nr.2 , the girl truly has a severe mental illness that requires treatment not lifelong incarceration. The whole think is anything but normal.
When the verdicts were announced Carly cried a little bit. When the sentencing was announced she cried again, but both times you can see that she doesn’t really know what’s going on. She’s sad about her sentence, but it seems to me like she doesn’t understand any of it.
Who in the right mind would kill their mother ??
I feel bad for the step dad because he’s left to try and figure out what on earth went wrong. His judgment is askew due to such a traumatic experience. Defending her is the only way he can psychologically cope with what happened. He’s in serious denial. That said, I just don’t think life in prison is the right choice for a 14 year old. Yes she should pay a price but I don’t think her entire life should be the payment.
She didn’t look stressed out , she looked calm
Waste of taxpayers money. She dangerous as Hell.
I’m wondering why the stepfather wasn’t charged with manslaughter. He left a gun easily accessible by a child who is having mental problems.
There are no laws in that state to support charges.
It was mom's gun.
Oh please!
For over 40 years,we brought kids to the ranch for equine therapy and not one of them shot their mother in the face.I never heard any testimony where she claimed DELUSIONS at all.
The media has said that her friend testified that Carly told her that she was hearing voices. The testimony of minors was not allowed to be recorded to protect their identities.
Precisely, that is why the possibility of schizophrenia needs to be further investigated. A normal child does not do that.
She should get a new trial. She is a teen and the sentencing is too harsh.
I TOTALLY agree. I am aghast how judgemental and self-righteous so many people on this board are. And this is supposed to be a Christian nation??? I am sure her mother would forgive her and not want her to spend her entire life in prison. Aside from that, I am equally sure that the girl has either a mental illness or she was manipulated by her stepfather, because this deed was anything but normal.
Don't make excuses for her she knows what she was doing 💯 justice for the decese RIP
I don’t believe his testimony. There was nothing about her behavior on tape that indicated what he described.
There’s something about the stepdad
No she shouldn't...this murder was cold and calculating...she shows no remorse....the step dad is strange...
She should NOT!
The bio dad saying the defense never contacted him?! Are you kidding me?! You 14 year old daughter is on trial for 1sr degree murder and you didn’t contact anyone to help?! Wow
Bio dad would not be any kind of reliable witness for either side. Severe mental illness and drug addiction preclude him from participating.
@@Camiken65 that type of issue has never stopped a prosecutor from using these types of witness before (jail cell mate confessions, drug dealers and fellow criminals)
Doesn't matter if she had auditory hallucinations or if she was or wasn't bipolar. The legal standard in Mississippi for insanity as a plea is that at the time she committed the murder, she knew it was wrong. And she did. Her actions before and after show consciousness of guilt. If she had/has a mental illness that may explain movtive, but it doesn't mean she gets a pass for committing murder.
It’s not alleged anymore. She’s been convicted. Why does she keep saying allegedly?
How could you murder your own mother. God bless there family. 😢
She knew exactly what she was doing, this guy is delusional for thinking she didn’t
Was she going to put them both down, leave for a bit,
come home then call the police saying they were
already gone when she got home??! 😔😔😐
Man, please! She knew who you were
It is possible to have psychosis and do the most awful things. I think she is dangerous yes, but I think she should be in psychiatric care securely rather than treated as an adult and judged as an adult.
I agree with you. I am aghast how many people cruelly sit in judgement of this 14 year old child, although they/we don't know if she is bipolar or has schizophrenia, but this is not normal behavior of a child who all along got along well with her mother.
The father should be in prison. What do you mean nobody called you? You are supposed to be there with your child!
@@Alago44 he couldn’t be there he domestically abused his ex wife / Carly’s mother. The reason she bought the gun in the first place was to protect herself from Carly’s bio dad
I think that they should offer her education, and let her get some sort of productive job in prison, not just punish her. That goes for all prisoners.
EQUESTRIAN THERAPY? Oh please... Dafuq is that? They gave her My Little Pony to play with? LOL.
Watever
Equine psychotherapy can be an incredible therapy for a lot of emotional difficulties but I agree that it’s not appropriate for psychosis/auditory hallucinations 🤷🏼♀️
She screamed because he grabbed the gun. She was scared because she probably thought he would shoot back at her.
that or it was all for dramatics
I think after seeing the biological Dads interview, there's a lot more to this sad situation.
agree. lots of lies came out of ashley and carly
Where is that interview so I can see it
@@makeupqueen130 Isn’t strange he couldn’t come forward when the trial was going ahead but now wants to make money on Carly’s baby pics . Father of the year 🤮Not
Right!! There’s a lot of issues that need to be examined further. Bio dad couldn’t be bothered to show up. The med switch needs to be examined further.
@@jillytots9999 he got paid for her baby pics?
Nothing could , would or should alter the verdicts of Guilty Guilty Guilty for this Frozen hearted , Vindictively & Sadistic premeditating murderer
Since trial, verdict and sentencing, I still feel there is something not right!!! I don't care if you all jump down my throat, we'll see
You are not alone here with your opinion. Unfortunately, too many people on this board are highly judgemental and self righteous, which seems to became a pronounced trait in the US, although it calls itself a "Christian" nation. I am sure Carly's mother would not want her to spend her whole life in prison. If my daughter would kill me, I would not want her to spend a life time behind bars. I would forgive my child, no matter what.
She was faking. He seems strange to me.
His smiling and voicing I love you is creepy. He needs investigated impo.
You leave a loaded gun lying around unattended then you must expect you or people you care about to get killed. Guess what? It's your own damn fault, nobody elses. Gun owners need to take responsibility.
Specially when you have kids, teenagers!
I totally agree with you!
AMEN!!
No she should not get a new trial. LET JUSTICE BE SERVED. SHE IS AN EVIL MURDERER.
Carly remembers everything, even where the gun was located that she tipped to retrieve them EXECUTED her MOM
I read Crime and Punishment when I was 15. Never murdered anyone. I’ve always enjoyed books of every genre, especially with a psychological bent.
Am I the only one that notices the narrative around her would be completely different than if she was a boy?
This idea of "Poor Girl" is insane to me, and now blaming the father for not being there for the trail... w.t.f.
Systemic misandry.
Did you not watch the Ethan crumbley trial? The whole thing was “poor boy, he had so many emotions😢.” And his parents were blamed so hard they got jail time. You’re just talking to talk
Also no one’s blaming the father for not being there during the trial. It’s just weird that he showed up in time to get paid for a couple of interviews. But if being recognized as an opportunistic weirdo is misandry, then oh well
No matter how good of a parent you are. None of us are above bringing a psychopath into the world.
She should, get the stepdad, he cannot escape so easily
She should have been hospitalized. It's a insult on mental health . Life without parole judge should be questioned? Mass murder s get less . She was 14 years old lots of time to give this child help .
Totally agree. There are so many triple murders running around after being released on parole.
I am almost amazed to find ONE person, YOU, on this board who question's the girls mental state. I thought I had read somewhere she is schizophrenic, and apparently she had a good relationship with her Mom. Something has got to be wrong with her mental state. I normal healthy kid does not do that no matter what. And I think all those people in this board condemning her are extremely judgemental and incredibly self-righteous.
Wow! To add salt to the wound and resources from tax payers… circus continues.
Such an innocent soul she's just a child to face her life imprisonment conviction God please save her.
NOPE SHE DIDNT TAKE THE PLE....SHE HAD HER DAY IN COURT AND ALL THE PROFF WAS GIVEN....IT STANDS AS CHARGED IN MY OPINION AND I WAS OPENED MINDED AND WATCHED THIS....SHE WAS MAD AS SHE COULD BE THATS ALL AND HER STEP-DAD IS TO CLOSE THATS WHY WE HAVE JUDGE AND JURY'S IN AMERICA THE GIRL PLANNED AND KILLED AND HID WHAT SHE DONE TO HER OWN MOTHER WHO LOVED HE MORE THAN ANYONE...GUILTY...
Is it odd that he looks down the while giving that statement?
Reminds me of cinnamon brown situation….lucky him didn’t die ? I find him creepy honestly
Welche Strafe hätte Carly Gregg in Deutschland bekommen? - In Deutschland wird Jugendstrafrecht ab 14 Jahre bis 17 Jahre angewendet, in vielen Fällen sogar bis zum 21. Lebensjahr. - Höchststrafe sind im Jugendstrafrecht 10 Jahre Haft in einem Gefängnis wo viele Jugendliche die Strafe verbüßen müssen. - Dort können die Jugendlichen ihren Schulabschluss machen und eine Ausbildung beginnen und können nach ihrer Strafe dem Arbeitsmarkt zugeführt werden. - Bis einen Tag vor dem 14. Geburtstag werden Jugendliche in Deutschland überhaupt nicht bestraft. Zum Beispiel gab es im März 2023 in Deutschland einen furchtbaren Mord an einem zwölfjährigen Mädchen. Täterin waren zwei Schülerinnen 12 Jahre und 13 Jahre alt aus dem gleichen Wohnort. Beide Mädchen erhielten keine Strafe und wurden nur dem Jugendamt übergeben und leben nun in einer anderen Stadt. - Carly Gregg verdient eine Strafe, aber nicht lebenslang!
Ich lebe teils in Deutschland, teils in den USA. Auch mir ist der Fall von den beiden Maedchen, den Du hier schilderst bekannt. Was die Justiz in den USA angeht, sind Strafen fuer viele Verbrechen unheimlich grausam und wenn ich sehe, wie Jugendliche, die an einen Autounfall mit Todesfolge schuldig sind, zu lebenslaenglicher Haft verurteilt werden, wird mir schlecht. Auf der anderen Seite sind die Strafen in Deutschland im Allgemeinen etwas zu lasch, aber dafuer auch noch menschlich, was in den USA nicht der Fall ist und nie eine Rolle spielt. Meines Erachtens hat Carly psychische Probleme und braucht Behandlung. Eine andere Moeglichkeit ist dass eine sexuelle Beziehung zwischen ihr und ihrem Stiefvater bestand und derselbe sie irgendwie manipulierte, die Mutter umzubringen. So oder so, sollte sie als Jugendliche behandelt werden.
sometimes attorneys make me sick. Its on video, she did it and now must pay the price.
🤔Why does everyone defend the killer but not the victim or the victims family? She committed an egregious crime and got found guilty. She deserves to be in prison without parole for that. It’s not our job to figure her mental health after she killed someone. It’s the parent’s responsibility to make sure their kids mental health is being cared for properly so this dose t happen.
Her grandparents are sticking by her, and there was a lady that looked like Ashley (sister maybe) that was with them. I’m not sure what other family members there are.
I did see the state crossing their fingers and mouthing fingers crossed when the verdict came in, but they could be friends.
What I don’t understand is when are you an adult?
I’m curious because she is tried as an adult.
But if she was having a sexual relationship with an individual over 18.
She is a minor.
something ain't stirring the Koolaid between the stepfather and the stepdaughter. I'm beginning to think they were in on it together. My theory is that there might have been some kind of insurance policy. The text message from the mother's phone was a cue for the stepdad to come in to get "shot" by the stepdaughter so the stepdad could appear to be a "victim," too. How in the world is she able to shoot her mother three times with no problem, but she supposedly aimed for the stepfather's head and missed only grazing his shoulder. My personal opinion is that he didn't sound too stressed on the 911 call, almost like it was rehearsed. Again, this is all theory, but I'm thinking the stepfather convinced the stepdaughter that if she committed the crime, she wouldn't get as much time in prison because of her age.
I am also of that opinion, unless she has a severe mental illness. Something is truly wrong here, but the sentence for a juvenile is extremely harsh. The kid needs help.
If new trial is being thinking , Carly should take the stand. She did wrong we all know that . However , she has the right to that . She is being trying as in adult . Well she can take the stand …… don’t see why not . More, to learn , something is not right . Every family has their story.
If it was the case he refused to co-operate rather than wasn't called, maybe it was because he was gonna be dragged through the mud and hoped the jury wold be sympathetic but now that they weren't he's decided to show his face but also, why didnt this come up in medical records search? If the defence failed to subpoena records far back enough, is that new evidence or ineffective counsel? His testimony only wouldn't wash with me unless there's records to back it up
She looks like the Wendy’s logo and Daria from that show in the 90s.
New trial for what??? What do you want the outcome to be? I don't feel safe with this girl out in the world... She killed her own mother!
The outcome can be the same for all I care, but I do think a new trial is warranted. The judge should have allowed the medicinal expert that the defense wanted to testify before the jury testify. That was a big part of the defense theory, and the judge didn’t let them put on a case to that part.
it is called the Injustice system - blud sucking Judges, lawyers and staff need to milk the system. My opinion
And Carly’s doctors too, they failed her 😢😢 I saw when her doctor spoke… she was laughing and not serious, more about herself and protecting her license! In my opinion…
Sure, good luck with that ☝️🤣
I don't know if she is evil. She is sick and dangerous in my opinion and needs to be treated.
people say the dumbest things. It wasnt Carly shooting me, so it must have been an imposter. So stupid, in complete denial.
You're so right! Reminds me of people who say stupid crap like crimes don't happen in their town. This girl is evil. Cold and calculated. She showed her mother's body to her friend like she was a showpiece. She was offered a plea deal and didn't want it. That's her problem.
She may be guilty, but something about this guy seems creepy too.
3:58 Oh, yea? It wasn't Carly? She had already killed her mother and invited her friend over to see the body. How did she act with the friend? Has this ever been asked or addressed?