I love Riho even since her Morning Musume days. No question she has the talent, the skills, the beauty, the charm. But still... MO! MO! KO! MomokoMomokoMomoko!!! OMG! Look at the way she dances "all the way through the fingertips," just as Mikiko taught Babymetal to do.
It's better that they have Momokom, Riho, and Kano. That way the Su will always have two dancers on stage with her in case something happens to one of them. Think they want to avoid what Moa having to dance up there alone like when Yui suddenly left.
i love riho in bm, but she has more potential doing her own thing than being in bm. her singing is beautiful and she can *dance* as we’ve seen lol. i just feel she shouldn’t be a permanent member tbh. even if they give her a mic, doing backing vocals and doing their choreographies isn’t going to showcase her full talent. and she’s a freelance dancer with an ig account so its possible they wouldn’t offer her a permanent spot (she probably wouldn’t take the offer anyways :/)
i really love Momoko but Riho won this one. Momo is so good with the happy and energetic songs, but Riho is a strong and precise dancer, a style that fits very well with this song
Himeka said during their study on ASH that time ago.. Suzuka is the best vocalist! and Riho is the best dancer! Imo, Riho is cool, swag and powerful at dance but she also has a nice voice, not really fit to metal but very good to sing pop and Jazz 👏 And Suzuka ofc her voicee!! And her dance too.. powerful, limber and elegant at the same time 👏💚
Here's a thought... they are both amazing. But the future success of Babymetal lies in further evolution of style, experiment, and collaboration, not in becoming a 'tribute act' to their teenage selves. However 'kawaii' the replacement for Yui is, its not the way forward. Also as Metal Galaxy already shows, Sumetal is the voice of Babymetal, and Moa is the choreographer. For the moment she's happy with that. If Moa wants a real singing career (more than "scream and dance") it will not be in Babymetal. I think Yui realised this, her wish to be a singer in her own right would never be fulfilled within Babymetal. And the Avengers will know this too. Their individual talents will always be third on the pedestal behind Su and Moa, unless Momoko and Riho suddenly reveal themselves as a sensational guitarist and bassist. In the short term they deserve the fans, the tours, the experience, the money, but they'll know when its time for them to move on, and so will the Fox God.
@@dimasreidz48 I wasn't looking to beconfrontational or spoil the party, I was just trying to put myself in their shoes for a minute instead of looking at it from a fan perspective. Care to expand on "OK"?
If Yui truly left Babymetal to reach for her own status and fame she must feel really stupid about that decision now, wouldn't she? Heard nothing from her since 2018, when she left the freaking band. Also, why is Suzuka the lead member to you? Do you think of bands as only the singer? Not the collective that makes it all happen? And I'm pretty sure Moa knows she is irreplaceable to the fans, as she saw the response from them when Yui officially left. She simply has no reason to feel second to Suzuka. Fans even complained about there being a "Kami Band West" instead of just the original Kami Band as they felt as if that would make them seem replaceable. Suzuka is not the most important thing about Babymetal. The fans proof that it's about the collective. Now... I command you to smile and cheer as you gaze upon Riho and Momoko dancing!!!!
@@cortanaalbion1328 No disrespect meant to any of them, they're all amazing. But thanks for engaging with the question. Of course they're a team, but Su tends to be perceived (I put it no stronger than that) as the leader. She is the one fans call 'The Queen'. Moa's voice is not much in evidence on Metal Galaxy, and she's not a guitar shredder. Her contribution is her personality, her stage presence, her dance moves, her interaction with Su. I'm certainly not saying she is 'Andrew Ridgeley' and Su is 'George Michael' if you get what I mean, but its not 'Robert Plant' and 'Jimmy Page' either. As for Yui, yes she had to stop for some health problems, but it gave her the 'time out' to reflect on her future path. I hope she is keeping a low profile, getting her life balance back, writing, singing, playing an acoustic guitar, taking her time, and will come back as a unique artist with her own style, like a tomato-eating caterpillar that goes away and comes back as a butterfly. Don't forget these girls all lost 10 years of being 'normal' teenagers, a two year sabbatical is well earned. If she came back she would be welcomed ecstatically, she must know that. My darkest fear is that she feels too alienated from the business to return, or has a health problem that is not being cured after all.
I think they all do good, but Riho does have that extra something. She goes hard in this song and I feel she brings an edge with her dancing. I always though Yui was the slightly better performer of the original two, she had great choreography, so I think Riho should be the replacement based on her choreography as well.
You know what bugs me? Riho is far and away the most talented of the avengers, but they always seem to have by far the most fun with momoko. I would prefer if riho got a third spot, but I can almost surefire bet who they would really pick
That's strange, didn't Riho and Su grow up together? I thought I read something about them being long time friends. Plus Momoko is a fair bit younger than Moa and Su, so you'd expect them to get on better with Riho.
I assumed they would get along better with Momoko because she's from Sakura Gakuen, if I'm not mistaken, so she shares that background with Moa and Su.
@....... That's what makes her perfect for Babymetal though. Cuz she's always on task. But occasionally you see her break since su and moa are always goofing around. Riho reminds me of yui in that regard. Momoko is very goofy, and while that's awesome, it shifts that dynamic. But riho is definitely the most talented and experienced of the avengers without question
I think in terms of dancing, which is the bulk of the current role, Momoko is the better dancer, but Riho is the better performer. When I watch Riho I can tell that she's doing movements precisely but the Babymetal choreography is meant to be more natural, which Momoko does better. You can see it most clearly at the start of the video, where Momoko is definitely doing the choreography smoother, but Riho puts emphasis and personality into her movements that makes her fun to watch. I think it's less a matter of a skill difference and more a matter of a difference in experience, in terms of the type of dancing that they've done before, so the question is really whether Riho adapts faster than Momoko gains confidence--as well as their personal dynamics with the original members, of course, as well as where the band is going.
not sure how to say this ... both are good ... only that i find riho metal much sharp compare momoko ... i guess riho metal dance with more passion and confident .. 1 cent opinion ..
July 2020 - Kano is now with the Idol group, @onefive, and they just released a music video. Riho has been chatting with fans on Instagram, and said she was not returning as an Avenger. I have heard nothing about Momoko... hmmm.. she did say her ambition was "I want to be a dancer for an artist." Only the Fox God Knows.
The two dancers are excellent. But I think they keep the place open for Youi if she wants to come back. Observation why Momoko does not participate in interviews ? The fact remains that once again Suzuka shows us the flexibility and the power of her voice.
I don't think any of the Avengers have participated in the interviews because they're not permanent. And honestly, Yui's been gone for 2 years now. Enough is enough.
Wouldn't make sense to bring Yui back now. It was her decision to leave, she's been gone for over 2 years, they've done a whole new album without her, and all the avengers have been putting in work and doing a fantastic job since she left. I don't think it would be fair on Riho, Momoko etc. to say "Yui wants to come back now, see ya."
@@hugoa2637 thats right , Yui you know that 7 years you worked your butt off. sorry means nothing got 3 girls dancing the last year so your out . But Yui will not be back she will have her own career one day hopefully and fans can give her there support for 7 great years ❤ 🍅
I’m really stunned that you refer to Riho & Momoka as Metal. They’re avengers, they didn’t replace Yui, never will, they’re not given mics. They’re dancers not part of the Holy Trinity #ONE
both are excellent dancers, both learned the choreography perfectly and work hard I think it is a editing issue it was very hard to do with the flashing lights, it worked better with Oh! Majinai
@@billietheone9495 To be honest, no I haven't. I've never watched any SG, or any idol anything. I'd barely even consider myself a Babymetal fan, I just find them interesting and see a lot of potential. So I'm by no means the best person to talk about this, and I'm fully willing to admit that you know better than me here. I just know that Riho has an extensive background in singing, while Momoko was a model/actress, so I assumed Riho would be the better singer. But then again I haven't seen anything from them pre-babymetal. If Momoko has been singing as well, then I wouldn't know that, but I'm sure she'd do a decent job as well. After all it's not up to me or you, it's Koba's decision at the end of the day.
![[モーニング娘。BABYMETAL] 鞘師里保ちゃん](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NNR0kKpglqg/mqdefault.jpg)
I love Riho even since her Morning Musume days. No question she has the talent, the skills, the beauty, the charm. But still... MO! MO! KO! MomokoMomokoMomoko!!! OMG! Look at the way she dances "all the way through the fingertips," just as Mikiko taught Babymetal to do.
Riho on fire🔥🔥🔥
Dancing machine👍👍👍
Riho got the experience but Momoko doing just fine. Imma MoaFanBoy but Riho just really killed it.
I agree she seems like every bit as good of a dancer as Su or Moa. Maybe even a bit better. Give her a mic too!
この違いはリズム感が大きい。いわゆるビートの刻み方。
momokoが1、2、3、4、とカウントをとって踊っているが
rihoは1234、1234、1234、1234ととんでもない細かいカウントをとっている、
さらにrihoはビートを細かくとることによって、1234（ﾜﾝﾂｽﾘｰﾌｫ-）だけでなく、12-4（ﾜﾝﾂｰｰﾌｫｰ）、1-4（ﾜﾝ--,,ｰｰﾌｫ）1,,4（ﾜﾝッッﾌｫｰ）
のように、溜めたり、伸ばしたり、アクセントを取ったり、体を大きく動かすことができる。これは、天性のものだ。変態レベルといってもいい。
さらに言っては、普通、人は体を一つの形としてリズムをとるが、rihoは上半身下半身のカウントの取り方までも違っていて
上下違う動きをしている。これは、リズム感だけでなく、高速で体を動かせたりなどの練習で培うものではなく、持って生まれたセンスや感覚であって、天性のものであり、世界的なダンサーですら、rihoのダンスを評価し、真似できないと言う。
この曲はビートの刻み方がとても細かいので、rihoのダンスが目立つのだろうが、他の曲でも意識して見てみると、すごさがわかる。
補足と言ってはもったいないが、suも同じカウントを取るものとされている。普通ではありえない。
クラストンベリーでは２人の動き、アクセント等がかなりかぶっている。
今までの曲でもこの二人は、同じ動きをしているので、見ていただきたい。
ただ、この完璧であり特異なリズム感である２人が並んだことによって、
今までyuiとmoaが同じカウント取りだったためシンクロし、suが違うカウントでのダンスをしていた、センターを引き立てる、センターが引きつける状態から、
rihoとsuがシンクロし、moaが1人のカウントでダンスをすることによって、センターを引き立てる状態では無くなってしまっている。
クラストンベリーのときから、rihoのダンスが遅れていないが遅れているように感じると言われているのが、２人のカウントは遅取りといって、一つずつの音を聞いてからカウントをとりながらダンスをする、しかしリズムが完璧なため生演奏にズレがあったとしても完璧に合わせることができるが、1人のカウントであるmoaは練習や流れどおりのリズムのカウント数え続ける、きまった一定のカウントであるため、緊張や焦り、演奏にアレンジがあれば早取りといって少しカウントが速まったりズレたりする、そのせいかクラストンベリーでは２人に少しの差があり、違和感があるのだ。
th-cam.com/video/XD6oWVkc5nE/w-d-xo.html
I love momoko but BMC is the song for Riho
Agreed
Why hasn't Riho been permanently named as the third member yet ....she just fits in so well
@Vanilla or Chocolate ? I doubt it. It will leave Moa in a weird spot supporting Su alone. It's better if she has a partner in crime.
It's better that they have Momokom, Riho, and Kano. That way the Su will always have two dancers on stage with her in case something happens to one of them. Think they want to avoid what Moa having to dance up there alone like when Yui suddenly left.
I agree. She shouldn't be playing a second fiddle anymore.
@@jasoneffler9903 who playing 2nd fiddle to who . Do you mean Rino to Su !
10 years of hard work getting BabyMetal to where they are now and someone dances 3rd spot for a year and gets equal billing. Yes that seems fair .
They're delivering the best of themselves each show. Both girls are amazing.
鞘師は昔からカッコいいキメる曲が得意。魅せ方が上手い。
i love riho in bm, but she has more potential doing her own thing than being in bm. her singing is beautiful and she can *dance* as we’ve seen lol. i just feel she shouldn’t be a permanent member tbh. even if they give her a mic, doing backing vocals and doing their choreographies isn’t going to showcase her full talent. and she’s a freelance dancer with an ig account so its possible they wouldn’t offer her a permanent spot (she probably wouldn’t take the offer anyways :/)
3rd CDでBxMxC聞いたときは「はぁ？？」「これライブでやるの？？」でしたが、いやさすが！！
今一番BxMxCにハマってます！！編集ありがとうございます！！
I'm so happy to see RihoRiho (RihoMetal now ) dancing again. Keep living your best life girl. 👌
Rio is very sharp on her moves..
Totally agree ✨🦊✨
鞘師さん、カッコいい❗惚れます。
i really love Momoko but Riho won this one. Momo is so good with the happy and energetic songs, but Riho is a strong and precise dancer, a style that fits very well with this song
アクターズスクール広島時代においての鞘師里保さんの迫力ある大きな振付、キレッキレのダンスは当時から定評があり中元すず香さんと共に一つの良き時代を築き上げた💫 アベンジャーズとして岡崎百々子さん、藤平華乃さんと同様BMに大きく貢献しましたね⚡️現在の鞘師さんは、ヴォーカリスト&ダンサーとしてライヴ活動や新曲も発表。藤平さんは@onefive で活躍され、岡崎さんはBMの正式メンバーとなり今後も活躍を期待されており、是非3人ともより一層飛躍して欲しいですね✨
Saw momoko on gp999 and instantly fell in love with her
She deserves to be on the stage
Now she has it !
鞘師頑張れ～❇️
あんな小さかった鞘師が海外で…😭♥️
Riho kills it
Momoko is doing great but Riho fits better IMO
やっぱり鞘師さんかな。音にノッていて迫力がある(ﾟ∀ﾟ)ような気がする〜♪
Himeka said during their study on ASH that time ago.. Suzuka is the best vocalist! and Riho is the best dancer! Imo, Riho is cool, swag and powerful at dance but she also has a nice voice, not really fit to metal but very good to sing pop and Jazz 👏 And Suzuka ofc her voicee!! And her dance too.. powerful, limber and elegant at the same time 👏💚
...and in the end, Momoko won out 😻
BxMxCは特に鞘師！
グルーブ感が全然違う。鞘師がいかに特別かが分かる。
Over all, I love Momoko, but Riho’s style and snap fit this song’s energy just right.
りほりほ大好き💛
It's too bad how some BM fans don't appreciate Riho here.
Guess she was way better at MM where she stands as an Ace.
Here's a thought... they are both amazing. But the future success of Babymetal lies in further evolution of style, experiment, and collaboration, not in becoming a 'tribute act' to their teenage selves. However 'kawaii' the replacement for Yui is, its not the way forward. Also as Metal Galaxy already shows, Sumetal is the voice of Babymetal, and Moa is the choreographer. For the moment she's happy with that. If Moa wants a real singing career (more than "scream and dance") it will not be in Babymetal. I think Yui realised this, her wish to be a singer in her own right would never be fulfilled within Babymetal. And the Avengers will know this too. Their individual talents will always be third on the pedestal behind Su and Moa, unless Momoko and Riho suddenly reveal themselves as a sensational guitarist and bassist. In the short term they deserve the fans, the tours, the experience, the money, but they'll know when its time for them to move on, and so will the Fox God.
Ok
@@dimasreidz48 I wasn't looking to beconfrontational or spoil the party, I was just trying to put myself in their shoes for a minute instead of looking at it from a fan perspective. Care to expand on "OK"?
@@arnewoodman Ok
If Yui truly left Babymetal to reach for her own status and fame she must feel really stupid about that decision now, wouldn't she? Heard nothing from her since 2018, when she left the freaking band. Also, why is Suzuka the lead member to you? Do you think of bands as only the singer? Not the collective that makes it all happen? And I'm pretty sure Moa knows she is irreplaceable to the fans, as she saw the response from them when Yui officially left. She simply has no reason to feel second to Suzuka. Fans even complained about there being a "Kami Band West" instead of just the original Kami Band as they felt as if that would make them seem replaceable. Suzuka is not the most important thing about Babymetal. The fans proof that it's about the collective. Now... I command you to smile and cheer as you gaze upon Riho and Momoko dancing!!!!
@@cortanaalbion1328 No disrespect meant to any of them, they're all amazing. But thanks for engaging with the question. Of course they're a team, but Su tends to be perceived (I put it no stronger than that) as the leader. She is the one fans call 'The Queen'. Moa's voice is not much in evidence on Metal Galaxy, and she's not a guitar shredder. Her contribution is her personality, her stage presence, her dance moves, her interaction with Su. I'm certainly not saying she is 'Andrew Ridgeley' and Su is 'George Michael' if you get what I mean, but its not 'Robert Plant' and 'Jimmy Page' either. As for Yui, yes she had to stop for some health problems, but it gave her the 'time out' to reflect on her future path. I hope she is keeping a low profile, getting her life balance back, writing, singing, playing an acoustic guitar, taking her time, and will come back as a unique artist with her own style, like a tomato-eating caterpillar that goes away and comes back as a butterfly. Don't forget these girls all lost 10 years of being 'normal' teenagers, a two year sabbatical is well earned. If she came back she would be welcomed ecstatically, she must know that. My darkest fear is that she feels too alienated from the business to return, or has a health problem that is not being cured after all.
鞘師って、リズムを大切にしてるよね^ - ^
I think they all do good, but Riho does have that extra something. She goes hard in this song and I feel she brings an edge with her dancing. I always though Yui was the slightly better performer of the original two, she had great choreography, so I think Riho should be the replacement based on her choreography as well.
Riho is just insane! Momoko is great but Riho is just more loose and going with the grove.
I agree. Riho just seemd like she hits the dance moves harder. I think she is most known for her dancing skills. Like Yui was.
Totally agree ✨🦊✨
この動画は、百々子ちゃんはかわいそう。
ダンススキルだけで見れば圧倒的に鞘師なんです！
比肩するものない、プロフェッショナルアイドルダンサーですから。
でも一生懸命感が堪らなく可愛い百々子ちゃん！
鞘師さんのダンススキルの高さは武器だと思ってますが、百々子さんの将来性、伸び代も本当に魅力的。
今すぐYUIの後釜に加えるなら鞘師さん。まだアベンジャー体制が続いて後に加えるなら百々子さんなんじゃないかと予想してます。
GIVE RIHO A MIC TOO, I WANT RIHOMETAL!!!💕
Riho has so much f you I am the sh*t energy on this. (in a good way) ... Kills it! So talented
Great job both of them.
Both are Amazing Time will tell On Fox Day if Momoko Is The Official Third Member BABYMETAL FOREVER !🦊♥🤘
2人とも上手！
華乃ちゃんバージョンもいつか見てみたい^ ^
本当に！！ 私もそう思います！！
どっちも上手でいいじゃないか(´▽｀)
You know what bugs me? Riho is far and away the most talented of the avengers, but they always seem to have by far the most fun with momoko. I would prefer if riho got a third spot, but I can almost surefire bet who they would really pick
That's strange, didn't Riho and Su grow up together? I thought I read something about them being long time friends. Plus Momoko is a fair bit younger than Moa and Su, so you'd expect them to get on better with Riho.
Hard to say. I prefer riho for sure. Momoko just reminds me of old school moa while riho reminds me of old school su or yui on stage
I assumed they would get along better with Momoko because she's from Sakura Gakuen, if I'm not mistaken, so she shares that background with Moa and Su.
@....... That's what makes her perfect for Babymetal though. Cuz she's always on task. But occasionally you see her break since su and moa are always goofing around. Riho reminds me of yui in that regard. Momoko is very goofy, and while that's awesome, it shifts that dynamic. But riho is definitely the most talented and experienced of the avengers without question
I think in terms of dancing, which is the bulk of the current role, Momoko is the better dancer, but Riho is the better performer. When I watch Riho I can tell that she's doing movements precisely but the Babymetal choreography is meant to be more natural, which Momoko does better. You can see it most clearly at the start of the video, where Momoko is definitely doing the choreography smoother, but Riho puts emphasis and personality into her movements that makes her fun to watch. I think it's less a matter of a skill difference and more a matter of a difference in experience, in terms of the type of dancing that they've done before, so the question is really whether Riho adapts faster than Momoko gains confidence--as well as their personal dynamics with the original members, of course, as well as where the band is going.
Biased for Riho, but say keep both! 🤘😎
鞘師神頑張最高
hi thnx for being a long time sub nice channel
RIHO!!!!!
not sure how to say this ... both are good ... only that i find riho metal much sharp compare momoko ... i guess riho metal dance with more passion and confident .. 1 cent opinion ..
And about 5 years more experience
RIHO hands down!
Las dos bailan muy bien, elijo las dos xd
July 2020 - Kano is now with the Idol group, @onefive, and they just released a music video. Riho has been chatting with fans on Instagram, and said she was not returning as an Avenger. I have heard nothing about Momoko... hmmm.. she did say her ambition was "I want to be a dancer for an artist." Only the Fox God Knows.
When did Riho say that? I don't think that's true.
natalie.mu/music/news/394761
@@blondebabymetal1033 That happened yesterday. My message is from a month ago
@@blondebabymetal1033 Thank you. I saw that, and shared it with some BM groups where I am an admin. Not surprised! Still rooting for Mo! Mo! Ko!
Riho is former Morning musume , and mokoko newly graduated in Sakura gakuen..
Both great but Riho gives something extra
리후 진짜 대박!!!!!! :00000
この曲音ノリに関してはスーメタルがダントツという事実
some fans want riho permanenty member ....some fans want kano .....ssome fans want momoko
pick only one ....not three
Riho 🥰
2:09 下がるSUMETALかっこよすぎ
この曲はSUが圧倒的すぎる笑
Momoko>
Momokooo🥰🥰
How do people tell the difference between Momoko and Kano?
@Vanilla or Chocolate ? lol Su is really only 2 inches taller than Moa. Those shoes make her look super tall.
@Vanilla or Chocolate ? I've read that she's taller than Su, but Su wears bigger shoes.
RihoMetal
Much prefer to keep it amongst SG members. Hana would have been perfect.
The two dancers are excellent. But I think they keep the place open for Youi if she wants to come back. Observation why Momoko does not participate in interviews ? The fact remains that once again Suzuka shows us the flexibility and the power of her voice.
I don't think any of the Avengers have participated in the interviews because they're not permanent. And honestly, Yui's been gone for 2 years now. Enough is enough.
Wouldn't make sense to bring Yui back now. It was her decision to leave, she's been gone for over 2 years, they've done a whole new album without her, and all the avengers have been putting in work and doing a fantastic job since she left. I don't think it would be fair on Riho, Momoko etc. to say "Yui wants to come back now, see ya."
@@hugoa2637 thats right , Yui you know that 7 years you worked your butt off. sorry means nothing got 3 girls dancing the last year so your out . But Yui will not be back she will have her own career one day hopefully and fans can give her there support for 7 great years ❤ 🍅
Momoko is more sharp..
鞘師と百々子でユニットってのもアリかも。
I’m really stunned that you refer to Riho & Momoka as Metal. They’re avengers, they didn’t replace Yui, never will, they’re not given mics. They’re dancers not part of the Holy Trinity #ONE
鞘師側と百々子側の映像のスピードが違うのは何故？
BPMを会場ごとに変えてるとは思えないから編集上の問題なのか？
それとも何かしら別の意図があるのか？
RIHOにだけMETALを付けてる事から何かしらの悪意があるのかな。
both are excellent dancers, both learned the choreography perfectly and work hard I think it is a editing issue it was very hard to do with the flashing lights, it worked better with Oh! Majinai
MOMOKO THE BEST!!!
All the ppl liking Riho cause she shakes her butt during the "wanna be" part. Admit it?
Maybe.
because it's part of the choreography? try doing that without moving your lowing hip, you'd look ridiculous.
1:44
1:44
1:44
1:44
1:44
1:44
Nothing against Riho at all. She is a great dancer but I will always prefer Momoko
But Riho can sing, meaning she definitely has the edge if they're looking for a permanent member
@@hugoa2637 Momoko can sing as well. She is a former member of Sakura Gakuin just like Yui and Moa.
@@hugoa2637 momoko can sing you know?😑 have you watch her performance in SG or kuroshitsuji live drama?🤔
@@billietheone9495 To be honest, no I haven't. I've never watched any SG, or any idol anything. I'd barely even consider myself a Babymetal fan, I just find them interesting and see a lot of potential. So I'm by no means the best person to talk about this, and I'm fully willing to admit that you know better than me here. I just know that Riho has an extensive background in singing, while Momoko was a model/actress, so I assumed Riho would be the better singer. But then again I haven't seen anything from them pre-babymetal. If Momoko has been singing as well, then I wouldn't know that, but I'm sure she'd do a decent job as well. After all it's not up to me or you, it's Koba's decision at the end of the day.
@....... Finally someone mentions Kano. I am wondering why there isn't much love for her?