Even if pulling the sleeves apart isn't directly representative of any real-world scenario, it does demonstrate the quality of materials and the quality of construction, so in my mind is second only to shuffle feel in terms of grading.
I've had sleeves become brittle and literally fall apart on me after time has passed, so the stretch test is super important to me too ^_^;; Nothing feels quite as bad as your sleeves falling apart in your hands because the edges aren't well bonded TTnTT
@@rawpower2025 I got the white and the black, they're amazing. I loved the feel of Eclipse sleeves but disliked how cloudy the fronts looked, especially when double-sleeved or as the sleeves become relaxed from heavy use.
Okay imma be real honest here. Tolarian's reviews are well known enough that companies should be referencing your criteria during quality assurance testing. There shouldn't even be "bad sleeves" hitting public shelves anymore. Quality assurance team should be doing at minimum the same tests you do before they're even approved for launch. I'd say if a company gets below a B on a new product 2020 and forward, it's not worth giving the company another chance if only for failure to do their research and appropriate testing.
I'd say getting a B grade is fair enough to be worth considering. the gamegenic cons were slight durability issue and a slippery feel. That's about on par with normal ultrapro sleeves in my book. So for a first timer, gamegenic didn't do that bad.
If you’ll notice, Prof specifically mentioned that the two really crappy ones were their company’s first attempt at sleeves. If they are new to the market, I would not blame them for looking to TH-cam reviews as a real source of criticism. That said, if they somehow get a d or an f on their second attempt, they they’re kinda screwed.
If it fails the stress test, it fails the best test. No splits, no breaks, no cracks for the cards I crack from my packs (jk just forcing a rhyme for the jingle, be smart at your LGS and just buy your singles).
@@danielbrazell Either it's not as profitable for the time/space or they are terrible at business! I suspect the first, especially the last year and the prevalence of online markets that suppress the prices of singles that are commonly available...
@@Cergorach what they said was that it wasn't profitable enough to pay for people to organize the cards and keep up with all the new sets that are coming out.
Love my Gamegenic sleeves. I began switching my EDH decks over to them about a month ago. You're right about the inner sleeves. Use KMC inners, they fit perfectly in Gamegenic sleeves.
@@koreyg8552 I find the shuffle as good as Katanas. They're a little bigger than Katanas which makes double sleeving easier. When new the Gamegenics can be a little slippery but you get used to handling them.
I changed to gamegenic mattes over ultra pro eclipse they are far nicer shuffle feel. My eclipse would gather dirt in about a week or 2 but game gennic after a month nothing still like new
As a premium LGS owner, I love your reviews and use the information in them to help provide my customers with the best quality products on the market, though I have been a fan of Dragonshield sleeves since I was a kid and I remember only being able to find them at GP's! (in the UK) They are now and have been for years the product I direct my customers to when they ask what sleeves they should buy. Keep doing what you do, I love seeing your growth as a content provider too over the years. Hello from Scotland!
I've been selling GameGenic sleeves recently at my LGS. I've loved them and have started switching all my 60 card competitive decks to them. Even preferring them over katanas.
@@duditsgrey5148 that's cause the head of GameGenic is a co-founder of Ultimate Guard who makes Katanas. A distributor told me there was some difference of opinions so they left and made their own company.
@@duditsgrey5148 Katanas are shorter and thr backs are more smooth. Great shuffle, but they don't work well, imo, for double sleeving. The Gamegenic sleeves are sized and thr backs feel more like Dragon Shields.
niyr if you’re using the sealable inner sleeve from dragon shields than katanas are absolutely better in every regard. Those are really the only inner sleeve to use anyway since they are full enclosed
Ever since I bought my first pack of Dragon Shield sleeves, I have never gone to another set, I would find it a waste of money and I tell everyone that asks the same thing. The same price as most of any other sleeves, your literally getting best of the best around. They're so good, im shocked they're not selling for $20+ a pack and even if they were, id still pay for them!
@@alexanderneimeth4538 I usually do buy online because my only local game store never has any in stock. But that's a good deal, 10 for $70. But I've got plenty for now.
Gotta say, I love how well these videos are shot. Currently at work and can't listen with audio, but I can still perfectly tell the qualities of the sleeves as you go through them.
I found your channel and have been so curious about starting MtG. I've been going through all of your content and it's so informative. Your personality and love you pour into each video is beyond exceptional. I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate the help you've provided. I went yesterday into my LGS and they had the free introduction decks you mentioned. It was so exciting to get into the game for free, they even had the swamp deck with a plains deck too I thought would be my fav. You helped start the fire under me to play this incredible game and this is my tip of the hat to you Prof. You are the man!!! 🤘👹🤘 I appreciate you so much.
Your accessories videos were some of the first MTG content I watched when I got into the game. Thank you for being a great role model and a great content creator.
I love the stretch test. I’ve had so many sleeves split while simply sleeving cards. My biggest issue with Dragon Shield art sleeve is the white backing. I want the are with a black backing. I really dislike having a white outline around my cards.
I've exclusively used dragon shield sleeves , just now picked up some game genic matte (love gloss look and HATE glare ) we'll see how they last , if DS made glazed fronts I'd buy them instantly
I'm really glad you continue to do these, I feel like there's no one else that takes this area of our hobby very seriously or speak out about them sufficiently even though it's such a crucial part.
Another great video. I love how objective you are and honest. I have often shared your videos to groups I'm part of, so others with equipment questions can learn.
I love me some Dragon shield sleeves, my only gripe with them is that they cant fit a 100 double sleeved commander into alot of deck boxes like the new GameGenic boxes or even Ultimate guard boxes
Gamegenic are coming out with a line of variants of the squire, sidekick and watchtower that can fit double sleeving with hard inners/sealables in December so that should fix your issue
I genuinely appreciate how much effort you've put forth into your craft. Like for years I've watched. Not subbed (cause I don't use TH-cam that often) but. You're a legend in my books and one worth while 👏♥️
Thanks for the video prof. Its so nice to have access to things like this that make the world feel normal. The world spins, days go by, Prof reviews Magic:The Gathering products. It really helps me feel normal in such a strange and difficult time. I truly hope things are going well for you and yours right now.
Been a fan of the prof since I started playing magic, been on and off for years and recently started playing commander for the first time. Always remembered Dragon Shiekd being well recommended by the prof, and had to grab a set to protect my Omnath, Lord of Creation!
Thank you so much for this video. I’m fairly knew to magic, as I have only played casually with a few friends off and on for about 2 years. I will definitely be getting some dragon shield sleeves for my cards now.
Ryker sleeves were the first sleeves I bought over a year ago. I experienced the pillow-like deck sliding early on but stopped having that issue after a month or so. My most played deck has gained some grime on the sleeves over the past year but still shuffles well. The other deck I have, with Ryker sleeves, has retained the slippery shuffle feel you mentioned. Both have had some damage to the backs yet seem to self heal over time. My stretch tests have been more resilient than what you showed. I'm hoping that this is just an off batch from the manufacturer. The rest of my decks are sleeved with different sleeves that you have recommended in your videos. My current favorite is the Katana sleeves. Thank you again for doing these reviews and helping the magic community!
when I picked up MTG and was looking to get some sleeves at my LGS, the guy behind the counter recommended to go straight to Dragon Shield as the best. I picked up the exact one you used for your demonstration (the golden armour one), and I'm in love with them, so I'm happy that they check out with the Prof
Just got myself today a pack of 3 dragon shields sleeves with classic art alterations on different artists like Monet. Loving them, even more after watching your review. Also, love your channel ever since started to play magic right after Core 21 release. Your product reviews really helped me to understand which ones to get.
Hey prof, I would like to say that I really like the stretch test when it comes to sleeves. I have had a lot of dragon shields split on me, and from your tests this doesn't seem to be very out of the ordinary. On the other hand, eclipses and ultimate guard katanas have never split on me, which also is in line with how tough they were in your stretch test, so I do really feel it is a useful test.
If that's what you use them for, see if you can find some Rook brand Vault sleeves from back in the day. They're stronger at the stretch test than anything. If the professor reviewed a Ridge wallet like a card sleeve or deck box that would be hilarious.
My favorite set so far has been Lorwy. As a child when i started playing, i loved the expansion and block theme, even though i didn't really play but just bought boosters every now and then
Tbh, the hyper-glossy face of those Ryker sleeves would lend themselves wonderfully for displaying foils in a folio/binder. Also I think it's hilarious when Prof just rips through sleeves in the stretch test like it's nothing, but then for really durable sleeves after failing to rip any and then finally gets one to rip, he gets so excited 🤣
Dragon Shields are a tad more expensive(around 70-80ish) but boy do they deliver. I loved that brush artwork with the insignia, so I might hunt for it in my next deck. Nice review prof.
I made a quick overview of the brushed card sleeves as well (quick 2-minute video). The only thing I didn't do is the stress test because that's more your thing, Professor. lol
Thank goodness for these videos. I recently got into MTG and my friends told me to try some Dragon Shield sleeves but I couldn't be more disapointed in the quality. I was so shocked at how poorly made they were I can't even use them. So I've come here to do sleeve research and find something better quality
Those "Ryu" sleeves are awesome! I picked them up not knowing they were Dragon Shields (No name on the box) and was thrilled when I got them home. They are just as good as the rest in the series, plus look great.
This is the first time I've noticed you switched to 60 FPS. Your animations look a lot smoother! I like it. The higher frame rate makes the shuffling shots just feel nicer to watch as well, very noticeable improvement.
Hey Professor, love the content and all the research you put in, as you recommend Dragon Shield a lot, I would love to see a comparison with all of the different matte colours in terms of opaqueness as I feel this would be really helpful to know before purchasing. Thanks as always, and look forward to your videos :)))
just bought some dragon shield mattes at my local game store yesterday, I hope to see some of those brushed styles the next time I go. Support your local game store! And good video like always Prof
I think you for all the information that you provide for product reviews I bought mini products that you gave a process and I’ve also tried some of the not so good ones to get my own opinion because that’s what matters the most is what I think of it and I think you do a good job of letting everyone know about it but sometimes it could just be for me
Gamegenic was promising , given the superior quality of their deck boxes. Alas, Dragon Shield remains the only choice. And their sealable inner sleeves are the life changer for storing foils and resleeving.
Really like the Brushed Art look. Will pick up some of these, I have a bit of a sealed sleeves collection going. One of all the DS Matte Art ever released.
If the Prof is reviewing a bunch of sleeves, and Dragon Shield are in that collection, you can bet they will come out on top. Almost no need to watch the video before making a decision. Personally, I rarely buy anything but DS now. And if I do, it's only because my LGS only has Ultra Pro and I forgot my sleeves.
I’m imagining you could have these two thin clear sheets you sandwich the card between then use a blowdryer to activate the adhesive and when it cools down cut around the edge of the card with an exacto knife. Then that will eventually get scuffed up and you use the blowdryer to unstick the sheets and repeat with new ones.
I'm not a Magic player, but I found this video whilst looking to see if Ryker sleeves are any good. Really enjoyed watching and seeing how different sleeves can be! Recently got my hands on a sealed copy of Citadels with the dark city expansion, and will definitely be sleeving them to preserve them properly. I've had good experience with Fantasy Flight so far when I got the Citadels classic edition and also for my copy of Mascarade, so I might just get more of those.
Imagine if you are a cardsleeve, just chilling with your bros in a stack.
And suddenly you hear: *"What about the stretch test?"*
I might whisper this into my gf ear
*What about the stretch test*
This conjures images of 'that' scene in the sausage party movie.
😳
@@mattybbg6850 i was looking for this comment.
At least they're getting torn apart by a god.
@@supernoodles908 Found the tiny.
omg this legend made 30 episodes about card sleves omg bro the dedication to his craft is there
Someone's gotta do it
30 episodes *so far*
Help the man out and subscribe/share 🙏
Fantasy North: Wow, the Prof is reviewing our sleeves! Wonder what he thinks of them!
*Fantasy North is listed first
Fantasy North: Oh no
I came here to see if they were good enough to buy as a gift.
Maybe I'll just stick to using them personally.
The absolute WORST part of the sleeves is they are printing on WHITE. Black-bordered cards look AWFUL when they are inside of a white sleeve.
Even if pulling the sleeves apart isn't directly representative of any real-world scenario, it does demonstrate the quality of materials and the quality of construction, so in my mind is second only to shuffle feel in terms of grading.
I feel like it's also an indication they will start to split pretty quickly.
I've had sleeves become brittle and literally fall apart on me after time has passed, so the stretch test is super important to me too ^_^;;
Nothing feels quite as bad as your sleeves falling apart in your hands because the edges aren't well bonded TTnTT
I didn't even know the stretch test existed until today. I also never had that problem with my sleeves before so idk
Was hoping the video covered the Eclipse Gloss, but thank you for covering the alternative sleeve companies, Prof.
More to come!
The Eclipse... WHAT?
@@rawpower2025 Ultra Pro Eclipse sleeves can now be purchased in a variety with a non-glazed (ie, gloss) front.
@@rawpower2025 I got the white and the black, they're amazing. I loved the feel of Eclipse sleeves but disliked how cloudy the fronts looked, especially when double-sleeved or as the sleeves become relaxed from heavy use.
@@FoaL1991 I also agree, these are probably the best sleeves I've ever used. Double sleeving is nice and easy and feels good in your hands.
It’s back!!! My favourite series!
I'm glad the "mad professor" hair is back!
Key word being "mad" half the time
Okay imma be real honest here.
Tolarian's reviews are well known enough that companies should be referencing your criteria during quality assurance testing. There shouldn't even be "bad sleeves" hitting public shelves anymore. Quality assurance team should be doing at minimum the same tests you do before they're even approved for launch.
I'd say if a company gets below a B on a new product 2020 and forward, it's not worth giving the company another chance if only for failure to do their research and appropriate testing.
I'd say getting a B grade is fair enough to be worth considering. the gamegenic cons were slight durability issue and a slippery feel. That's about on par with normal ultrapro sleeves in my book.
So for a first timer, gamegenic didn't do that bad.
I think the grades more based on his personal opinion and he wants us to judge for ourselves whether the sleeves are for us rather than just use grade
If you’ll notice, Prof specifically mentioned that the two really crappy ones were their company’s first attempt at sleeves. If they are new to the market, I would not blame them for looking to TH-cam reviews as a real source of criticism. That said, if they somehow get a d or an f on their second attempt, they they’re kinda screwed.
If it fails the stress test, it fails the best test. No splits, no breaks, no cracks for the cards I crack from my packs (jk just forcing a rhyme for the jingle, be smart at your LGS and just buy your singles).
My LGS just stopped selling singles because Wizards is putting out too many products for them to keep up. 😕
@@danielbrazell I don't understand
@@barryswigart1432 you said to buy singles at your LGS, but I can't anymore.
@@danielbrazell Either it's not as profitable for the time/space or they are terrible at business! I suspect the first, especially the last year and the prevalence of online markets that suppress the prices of singles that are commonly available...
@@Cergorach what they said was that it wasn't profitable enough to pay for people to organize the cards and keep up with all the new sets that are coming out.
Love my Gamegenic sleeves. I began switching my EDH decks over to them about a month ago. You're right about the inner sleeves. Use KMC inners, they fit perfectly in Gamegenic sleeves.
How’s the shuffle and feel
Compared
To katanas which I feel are the best out?
@@koreyg8552 I find the shuffle as good as Katanas. They're a little bigger than Katanas which makes double sleeving easier. When new the Gamegenics can be a little slippery but you get used to handling them.
Beanpot ok as long as they are smoother and easier to shuffle than DS. I hate dragon shields . Thank you
I changed to gamegenic mattes over ultra pro eclipse they are far nicer shuffle feel. My eclipse would gather dirt in about a week or 2 but game gennic after a month nothing still like new
Tubbleberry the matte still has a glossy front? Not that hazy shit like eclipse mattes?
Always a good time when Prof reviews product. Classic
0:11 PROF OUT HERE SPITTING FIRE, gonna listen to his bard on my new Raycons 🔥
As a premium LGS owner, I love your reviews and use the information in them to help provide my customers with the best quality products on the market, though I have been a fan of Dragonshield sleeves since I was a kid and I remember only being able to find them at GP's! (in the UK) They are now and have been for years the product I direct my customers to when they ask what sleeves they should buy. Keep doing what you do, I love seeing your growth as a content provider too over the years. Hello from Scotland!
I love the smile that came with the making it rain with the sleeves. Fantastic review. Thanks Prof.
I've been selling GameGenic sleeves recently at my LGS. I've loved them and have started switching all my 60 card competitive decks to them. Even preferring them over katanas.
The gamegentic and katanas look very similar.
@@duditsgrey5148 that's cause the head of GameGenic is a co-founder of Ultimate Guard who makes Katanas. A distributor told me there was some difference of opinions so they left and made their own company.
@@duditsgrey5148 Katanas are shorter and thr backs are more smooth. Great shuffle, but they don't work well, imo, for double sleeving. The Gamegenic sleeves are sized and thr backs feel more like Dragon Shields.
@@1klakak oh I see thanks for the info bro. I have to check those gamegentic ones out
niyr if you’re using the sealable inner sleeve from dragon shields than katanas are absolutely better in every regard. Those are really the only inner sleeve to use anyway since they are full enclosed
Gotta love the dedication to the best of the best of the best card sleeves, good job prof!
Ever since I bought my first pack of Dragon Shield sleeves, I have never gone to another set, I would find it a waste of money and I tell everyone that asks the same thing. The same price as most of any other sleeves, your literally getting best of the best around. They're so good, im shocked they're not selling for $20+ a pack and even if they were, id still pay for them!
Mmmm hmmmmmmmmm..
Lmk
If your willing to buy online I’ve found 10 packs for 70 and change, so if your often build decks I would recommend it.
@@alexanderneimeth4538 I usually do buy online because my only local game store never has any in stock. But that's a good deal, 10 for $70. But I've got plenty for now.
Gotta say, I love how well these videos are shot. Currently at work and can't listen with audio, but I can still perfectly tell the qualities of the sleeves as you go through them.
Your stress tests have always been my favourite
I found your channel and have been so curious about starting MtG. I've been going through all of your content and it's so informative. Your personality and love you pour into each video is beyond exceptional. I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate the help you've provided. I went yesterday into my LGS and they had the free introduction decks you mentioned. It was so exciting to get into the game for free, they even had the swamp deck with a plains deck too I thought would be my fav. You helped start the fire under me to play this incredible game and this is my tip of the hat to you Prof. You are the man!!! 🤘👹🤘 I appreciate you so much.
As soon as the calm music plays I already know which one I am supposed to buy
thanks to videos like this, over time i have switched my ultra pro sleeves for UG Katana and Dragon SHields Matte
dude I love the sleeve videos. Not sure why. Maybe, they seem fun for you to make. They are clear, concise and fun to watch! Thank you.
I love ALL of Prof's content... but, I missed the product reviews. Glad to see a return to form. Super helpful.
Your accessories videos were some of the first MTG content I watched when I got into the game. Thank you for being a great role model and a great content creator.
I love the stretch test. I’ve had so many sleeves split while simply sleeving cards. My biggest issue with Dragon Shield art sleeve is the white backing. I want the are with a black backing. I really dislike having a white outline around my cards.
Prof you make my day with how real and personable you can be! Thanks for making my watch duty better.
I've exclusively used dragon shield sleeves , just now picked up some game genic matte (love gloss look and HATE glare ) we'll see how they last , if DS made glazed fronts I'd buy them instantly
I'm really glad you continue to do these, I feel like there's no one else that takes this area of our hobby very seriously or speak out about them sufficiently even though it's such a crucial part.
A double sleeve kit is really clever. Too bad this specific one isn't good.
The Professor making it rain is something I needed in my life.
It's nice to see you smiling and having fun again.
Thank you for your continued great work both reviewing product and being a positive voice in the community
you know, i chuckle when new sleeve reviews come out but it's actually helped me decide on sleeves in my lgs. thank you prof! :D
I've started double sleeving my standard card decks. Even my Pako Haldan commander deck because of you prof
Getting my son of 11yr old into the game and he loves it this info helps alot. Haven't bought sleeves in years. Thank you sir.
Another great video. I love how objective you are and honest. I have often shared your videos to groups I'm part of, so others with equipment questions can learn.
Always nice to just chill out and watch these, even when I still have sleeves left over.
I love me some Dragon shield sleeves, my only gripe with them is that they cant fit a 100 double sleeved commander into alot of deck boxes like the new GameGenic boxes or even Ultimate guard boxes
"I've won. But at what cost?"
~Dragon *THICC* Shields
I relate because I use Art sleeves with character guard over sleeves and I need a 100+ deck box just for a 60 card deck
I use the dragonshield long box it can hold two double sleeved commander decks
Gamegenic are coming out with a line of variants of the squire, sidekick and watchtower that can fit double sleeving with hard inners/sealables in December so that should fix your issue
Ultra pro satin towers would work perfectly. Plenty of room left with single sleeved commander decks
Pretty sure I've watched this play list 3 times as well as the deck box playlist a few times. Why are these so entertaining lol
Thank you for objectively reviewing the Ryker sleeves! I had a feeling they were too good to be true.
I genuinely appreciate how much effort you've put forth into your craft. Like for years I've watched. Not subbed (cause I don't use TH-cam that often) but. You're a legend in my books and one worth while 👏♥️
Thanks for the video prof. Its so nice to have access to things like this that make the world feel normal. The world spins, days go by, Prof reviews Magic:The Gathering products. It really helps me feel normal in such a strange and difficult time. I truly hope things are going well for you and yours right now.
As a player of magic I appreciate you sir! Helping out everyone in the magic community and as well with other tcg games :)
Patiently waiting for eclipse gloss! Thanks for the great vid Prof
Been a fan of the prof since I started playing magic, been on and off for years and recently started playing commander for the first time. Always remembered Dragon Shiekd being well recommended by the prof, and had to grab a set to protect my Omnath, Lord of Creation!
This is the video content that gets me up in the morning.
Thanks Prof! Love your product videos. Have watched loads going back years now, it’s been real helpful for choosing the best accessories
Thank you so much for this video. I’m fairly knew to magic, as I have only played casually with a few friends off and on for about 2 years. I will definitely be getting some dragon shield sleeves for my cards now.
Ryker sleeves were the first sleeves I bought over a year ago. I experienced the pillow-like deck sliding early on but stopped having that issue after a month or so. My most played deck has gained some grime on the sleeves over the past year but still shuffles well. The other deck I have, with Ryker sleeves, has retained the slippery shuffle feel you mentioned. Both have had some damage to the backs yet seem to self heal over time. My stretch tests have been more resilient than what you showed. I'm hoping that this is just an off batch from the manufacturer. The rest of my decks are sleeved with different sleeves that you have recommended in your videos. My current favorite is the Katana sleeves. Thank you again for doing these reviews and helping the magic community!
when I picked up MTG and was looking to get some sleeves at my LGS, the guy behind the counter recommended to go straight to Dragon Shield as the best. I picked up the exact one you used for your demonstration (the golden armour one), and I'm in love with them, so I'm happy that they check out with the Prof
Prof casually spitting hot fire in the opening of a playing card sleeve review video.
If I saw those Ryker sleeves at the store, I would've picked one up.
Thanks for saving me from getting disappointed.
While these reviews might get old for some people I seriously enjoy these videos and always look forward to your reviews Prof!
I have Dragon Shield art mattes for my commander deck, LOVE EM. Those brushed ones look pretty spiffy!
Just got myself today a pack of 3 dragon shields sleeves with classic art alterations on different artists like Monet. Loving them, even more after watching your review.
Also, love your channel ever since started to play magic right after Core 21 release. Your product reviews really helped me to understand which ones to get.
Dragonshield has always been my go to sleeves and I love the art matte and art brush, giving me same great art while also a great shuffle experience
Love the idea of a 150 sleeves for commander decks to replace damaged sleeves which happen for me. Glad I saw the review of it
Well done. I like the Dragon Shield Matte and only use the Petrol color so I can easily move cards from deck to deck.
kaladesh is definitely my fave, the power level was through the roof. It's also such a beautiful plane.
I don't play magic any more, but I will watch the Professor's videos about sleeves and deck boxes.
I love those review because i started playing magic by watching your older reviews
love the Dragonlance books in the background War of the Lance!
Hey prof, I would like to say that I really like the stretch test when it comes to sleeves. I have had a lot of dragon shields split on me, and from your tests this doesn't seem to be very out of the ordinary. On the other hand, eclipses and ultimate guard katanas have never split on me, which also is in line with how tough they were in your stretch test, so I do really feel it is a useful test.
I use card sleeve(s) as a minimalist wallet so this is super helpful!
If that's what you use them for, see if you can find some Rook brand Vault sleeves from back in the day. They're stronger at the stretch test than anything. If the professor reviewed a Ridge wallet like a card sleeve or deck box that would be hilarious.
Bought some Dragon Shield Art Brushed for my Modern Infect deck. Thanks Prof!!
My favorite set so far has been Lorwy. As a child when i started playing, i loved the expansion and block theme, even though i didn't really play but just bought boosters every now and then
Tbh, the hyper-glossy face of those Ryker sleeves would lend themselves wonderfully for displaying foils in a folio/binder.
Also I think it's hilarious when Prof just rips through sleeves in the stretch test like it's nothing, but then for really durable sleeves after failing to rip any and then finally gets one to rip, he gets so excited 🤣
Dragon Shields are a tad more expensive(around 70-80ish) but boy do they deliver. I loved that brush artwork with the insignia, so I might hunt for it in my next deck. Nice review prof.
I made a quick overview of the brushed card sleeves as well (quick 2-minute video). The only thing I didn't do is the stress test because that's more your thing, Professor. lol
Yes! Finally a product review video!
Thank goodness for these videos. I recently got into MTG and my friends told me to try some Dragon Shield sleeves but I couldn't be more disapointed in the quality. I was so shocked at how poorly made they were I can't even use them. So I've come here to do sleeve research and find something better quality
Those "Ryu" sleeves are awesome! I picked them up not knowing they were Dragon Shields (No name on the box) and was thrilled when I got them home. They are just as good as the rest in the series, plus look great.
This is the first time I've noticed you switched to 60 FPS. Your animations look a lot smoother! I like it. The higher frame rate makes the shuffling shots just feel nicer to watch as well, very noticeable improvement.
Hey Professor, love the content and all the research you put in, as you recommend Dragon Shield a lot, I would love to see a comparison with all of the different matte colours in terms of opaqueness as I feel this would be really helpful to know before purchasing. Thanks as always, and look forward to your videos :)))
just bought some dragon shield mattes at my local game store yesterday, I hope to see some of those brushed styles the next time I go. Support your local game store! And good video like always Prof
Watching this as I sleeve my deck with the Gamegenic double sleeve pack.
I think you for all the information that you provide for product reviews I bought mini products that you gave a process and I’ve also tried some of the not so good ones to get my own opinion because that’s what matters the most is what I think of it and I think you do a good job of letting everyone know about it but sometimes it could just be for me
Thanks again for another excellent product review video!
Finally! Product reviews are my favorite
Gamegenic was promising , given the superior quality of their deck boxes. Alas, Dragon Shield remains the only choice. And their sealable inner sleeves are the life changer for storing foils and resleeving.
Really like the Brushed Art look. Will pick up some of these, I have a bit of a sealed sleeves collection going. One of all the DS Matte Art ever released.
I saw a sponsored ad for the ryker sleeves, looked over here, and saw you had just made this.
I'm literally getting ready to buy anew commander deck and this has really helped as I wanted to pick up the dragonshield brushed art
man, i bought fresh sleeves 10 minutes ago :( i wish i had seen this first
did you watch his previous sleeves video though?
Which ones did you get? Just curious.
If the Prof is reviewing a bunch of sleeves, and Dragon Shield are in that collection, you can bet they will come out on top. Almost no need to watch the video before making a decision. Personally, I rarely buy anything but DS now. And if I do, it's only because my LGS only has Ultra Pro and I forgot my sleeves.
@@Frostgiantbutsmall Ultra Pro because i bought them at my LGS and they only have those :/
@@tzumburg Corners might catch a bit, but they'll do the job fine =D
I was hoping for Ultra Pro Eclipse Gloss review. Anyway, always a pleasure seeing you review things, prof.
I got those limited edition Dragon.Shield logo sleeves, and they're the best sleeves I've ever used. Always feels like the first shovel
Very useful, as usual! Thanks Prof!
I’m imagining you could have these two thin clear sheets you sandwich the card between then use a blowdryer to activate the adhesive and when it cools down cut around the edge of the card with an exacto knife. Then that will eventually get scuffed up and you use the blowdryer to unstick the sheets and repeat with new ones.
More Prof sleeve moving and tearing them around ASMR we need when the only shuffling we'll be hearing is ourselves.
I thought I would never see the day he upload another one good job
Prof had to go and drop that sick flow at the start. Nice
I'm not a Magic player, but I found this video whilst looking to see if Ryker sleeves are any good. Really enjoyed watching and seeing how different sleeves can be!
Recently got my hands on a sealed copy of Citadels with the dark city expansion, and will definitely be sleeving them to preserve them properly.
I've had good experience with Fantasy Flight so far when I got the Citadels classic edition and also for my copy of Mascarade, so I might just get more of those.
Another good, useful vid. I was about to buy some sleeves I would have been very disdapointed. Thanks Prof!
Ah finally, the card shuffling asmr video I've been waiting for.
I wonder if Company’s will eventually start sending the Prof sleeves for him to review
If companies started doing that, then we would most likely know who not to buy by who didn't send some to him
They already have
Some companies already have. I don’t remember which, though...
This video convinced me to get some dragonshield sleeves for my decks.
I was just thinking of picking up new sleeves! Thanks Prof!
Great video. Great analysis. Thank you for making this.
Thank you for what you do, prof!