Now wear a whole outfit and makeup based on best and worst colors on you and let people vote which looks good. Brown (darker color) vs Blue (vivid bright colors).
You can still wear the other colours, just not right next to the face. So you can still wear them in a skirt or a pair of trousers, maybe as details in a cardigan.
Hello, I hope you're safe over there? I hope this year brings happiness, prosperity, and love all over the world, I would love 💚us to be good friends in honesty and in trust if you don't mind. I'm Doctor Christopher Johnson from San Francisco, California, where are you from if I may ask?
I agreed with a lot of the bright colors, yellows, and most purples, but she just threw out the whole blue color scheme and I thought a couple shades looked good. Same with a few of the other colors she took out. I thought the dark colors did look good and sophisticated like she said, but they also made you appear paler. Which I guess in South Korea is desirable. It would be cool to see you have this done again in Australia or the US to see if culture plays a part. I think another color pallet could suit you just as well.
It’s warm versus cool tone. Like other comments point, it’s only for colors near your face, so blue jeans are still okay. There is no warm blue. You should watch other color analysis videos bc it’s not about looking paler, it’s about clear bright skin instead of dull (gray cast) skin (like when she’s in blue) or amplifying shadows (like what they were saying about the black color). Also, color appointments would take into account dark or red blemishes, but Tina’s skin is clear so that didn’t factor in. If the goal was just to look paler, dye your hair black and wear black 🥴 (edit to say there can be warm blues, but I stand by the “the goal is bright skin, not pale skin” point for these color analysis appointments. I’ve also tried looking for a color appointment here in the states but since I’m not near any fashion capitols, what’s available to me seems like older women working on limited or outdated color analysis l so I probably have to do an online appointment if I wanted this done well from in the states).
@hvnterly8388 According to many different types of color analysis, there should be SOME blue(s) that suits her. I can't think of any seasonal analysis system that discounts EVERY blue for a particular person. Yes, blue might be considered cool in general, but there are blues that lean warm, or light, or deep, or muted, and so on. In any analysis system I am familiar with, everyone gets blues--it's just a matter of finding which blues work best on you.
Actually someone else did this too, and that youtuber said she wanted to look pale. The person got "mad" (not really mad but best word) at her saying "You don't want to look pale. You want to look bright." Which is the big difference. Both mean lighter, but being pale in this context means looking sickly. Think like Wednesday Addams. Looking brighter brings out the natural highlights and makes you look more lively and stand out. Even people who are "pale" in skin tone don't necessarily look pale like Wednesday.
@@hbarlaam I was mistaken! I looked it up after and there can be blue based reds and red based blues, yellow based blues, and so on. Thank you for also correcting my misinformation 👍 I won’t edit it out for clarity of the comment section, but i do admit my mistake!
I didn't expect that the deeper lip color would be recommended, and I feel like there were more colours in there that suited you. I think it would be interesting to see a video where you create outfits with respect to each season that aren't yours, and try to find ways to make them work somehow, or see if they actually do make you look dull.
I actually liked the cherry red and the one before that you said was too cool toned. I think colours can make us look washed out / cold when we don't have makeup on but with the right makeup we can carry off more colours.
I think it would be interesting to do another color analysis by someone else who is just as reputable just to see the difference and get a second opinion? I really like the makeup, hair and perfume aspect. Also a shopping haul with your new tones would be super cool too.
I actually really liked the pastel muted colors on you, the ones which were shown in the end - muted pinks/beiges. They complimented your skin color very well. And I did really like some reds as well, that she did not pick to your final palette.
I actually completely agree with her, immediately the dark autumn colours sharpened your features and evened out your skin tone whereas the cool colours brought out the veins and dark circles in your face. I do think the teal colours would suit you but that's because teal and dark navy colours also suit dark autumns too. And the bright colours were a bit much
I've always been extremely into fashion, so this is super fascinating to watch. I've been curious about these types of sessions before, so it's really cool to observe one. I've been goth for my entire life (literally since I could form coherent thoughts about my clothes), so maybe I'm biased, but I thought black looked much more striking on you than the dark chocolate brown. That being said I could DEFINITELY see how the darker colors looked better than light! The lighter colors totally washed you out! I thought it was so interesting when she said there were certain lighter colors you could pull off if you did heavier makeup. That makes so much sense! All of this was extremely interesting and worth thinking about, but my motto in life is "if it makes you happy and you're not hurting yourself or others, do it." I definitely believe that extends into the worlds of makeup and fashion. Don't think too hard about whether a color might look good just based on looking at it. Always try something on. You might really love it anyway. If that's the case, wear it. If it makes you happy, you should always consider that first.
I’m also goth and VERY picky with colour. My favourite colours are black purple and green, through I mostly wear black, only wear purple sometimes, and I hardly ever wear green (usually only as an accent with accessories.) I’ve been watching a lot of these videos and I find them so interesting. I’m nearly always able to pick out the “correct” options, I think due to my fascination with colour theory. It’s kind of funny to me how me, who hates most colours, has such an eye for them lol. I’m so curious to what it would be like to get a consultation for myself. I’m 99% sure that I have a neutral undertone, so I really don’t know what would be “my” season. (Though my guess would be winter.) I also don’t really strive to look “bright and healthy” and a lot of the times try to look kinda dead lol, so I wonder how that would influence everything. I think that’s a big part of what interests me in these theories in fashion and makeup, because there’s this widespread idea of the “right” or “correct” way to achieve certain things- that are desirable to the majority of people; but then you could use that exact same theory and apply it to create the opposite effect that is desirable to a nicher audience. Hopefully that made sense 😭 apologies for the long comment I’m just super interested by all this.
This conversation is super interesting 😃 i am no expert, but from what i understand of colour theory (or rather, my take on it) it is not so much "oh, you mustn't wear these colours" or "you should only wear .... colours". Rather it is understanding the visual effect different colours will have on you. Seasonal colour theory indicates which colours look most HARMONIOUS against your skin. But of course, if looking hatmonious is not your goal, you should wear colours against your season 😉 for instance, if wearing a full black outfit makes you look goth, you most likely are not a Winter, Dark Autumn or Bright Spring. On those seasons, black will look very harmonious. However, if a Summer wears a full black outfit, she is more likely to "make a statement" with her look, so to speak. I am a Bright Spring. Black looks pretty harmonious on me. Bright colours also look less "bright" on me than a softer season. I work in a very professional environment where we can't really go crazy with our looks haha (business consulting firm!). But since i have quite bright colouring, i find i can easily get away wearing bright emerald greens, yellows, hot pinks etc as long as the style of the outfits themselves is "professional". I also routinely wear red lipstick to work and it looks very normal on me, not too "made up". On the other hand, if i wear a dark smoky eye or a deep maroon/ berry lip (dark rather than bright colours) i immediately look like am going to a Halloween party 😂😂 Hope my comment made some sense 😬
Hello, I hope you're safe over there? I hope this year brings happiness, prosperity, and love all over the world, I would love 💚us to be good friends in honesty and in trust if you don't mind. I'm Doctor Christopher Johnson from San Francisco, California, where are you from if I may ask?
People saying certain colors look good on Tina don’t realize that they’re getting affected by a) the camera and lighting and b) makeup in other videos, which can make a big difference. That’s why color consultations happen in person, you can’t accurately gauge what suits someone irl through a camera! Think of all the pretty influencer makeup that looks thick and cakey irl-some colors photograph nicely on someone, but don’t looks as flattering in person, and vice versa.
All the stylist suggested were dark sullen shades while I’ve seen you look beautiful in all other bright colours too, even purple, in your haul videos.
I actually agreed with her analysis. Of course, she can wear anything she wants and still look good but I do think the warm deep colours suit her undertone better. I don’t think they’re sullen either. To me they’re very pretty muted colours
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO!!! That's SO cool that she even suggest scents to match your aura! I want to do a color consult even MORE now, there's always so much more to learn as I see more of these videos!
Me, too!!! This has also been on my bucket list for YEARS and I’m finally getting my first color analysis next month, but can’t wait and have been binge watching these color analysis videos in the meantime. It’s fascinating!
I had mine done years ago, the only thing I wouldn't agree with is that purple is always cool toned. If you mix a warm red and a warm blue you get a warm purple! I'm an autumn and look incredible in warm purples so don't rule out any colour x
I'm so glad she mentioned you can get away with some spring colors; I was remembering your try-on hauls and how that color palette of pinks suited you! I think that while the dark colors look good, the more vivid ones right before the dark ones also suited you. E.g. burgundy looks good on you too, even though she believes the blackened red is best. If you look at "dark autumn" palettes, those colors are actually included. It's not just deep darks as she showed; there are lighter and vivid colors as well. But it's possible that's just the default Western dark autumn palette. I've seen Korean palettes sometimes resemble them and others (like this place) just have the darks.
Ok I have to admit, those brown tones are SO striking on you! Yes there are other colors that look fine too, but I really really see the sophistication of those and how complementary they are to you.
It’s so interesting to see how these color analysis sessions vary by country/culture. This was good Korean practice too! Thanks for sharing Tina. For the record I think you look great in all colors 💜
Thank you for coming back with full video! Flipping color and watching the effect on skin are just so satisfying to me. Hehe Ps. Dark brown and eggplant colors look so good on you❤
I’m obsessed with things like this, and personally, aside from knowing what colors look good on me, I also like using it when I draw original characters. It’s fun to think of my characters’ color palettes to make then distinct from one another 😄
I love color theory in clothes and makeup. It really does make such a difference. There were actually several colors she didn't like for you that I thought looked spectacular on you, really brightening up your features. I think a lot of that could be my own personal preferences to though. Since you have it on video you can go back and really look at each one and what it does for your face and skin and hair. You may find more that you really like on you. Definitely she got you in the right season. So many great colors for you. That charcoal was fantastic on you. I am a bright winter. Over time I have found if I wear the wrong colors, every time I look in the mirror I don't really like what I see, don't feel that I look good, and that can affect my mood for the whole day. If I wear the right colors, even without makeup, I just look "right." Bright, happy, optimistic, and I feel like I have a better day. Colors can definitely affect our mood. The colors we surround ourselves with like walls and furniture should generally be in our color season if we can. If you take a picture of yourself against a good background color for yourself, it will look so much better than if the background is wrong for us. That can affect people's perception of us when they are looking at us in person, too. I painted my bedroom in a deep but bright red, and it makes me feel really happy when I see it, and when I look in a mirror there I feel like I look pretty good. That affects my mood in a positive way. The right scents help, too. I love that she helped you find the right one of those too.
I’m incredibly picky with colours, and although I’m very appreciative of all colours, I hate most of them for me personally; be it wearing or decorating. I mostly wear and decorate with black, but my favourite colour is purple and I use it as an accent for a lot of things. Then I use green for even smaller accents. I am really curious to know if the colours that I love and surround myself with are my “personal” colours or not. I am not someone who strives to look “bright and healthy, etc.” which is usually the goal of finding colours that ‘suit’ you. My preferred aesthetics are much more dark. So im curious to if my preferences actually enhance me according to this theory or not.
I agree! There was a bold pink in there that I loved on Tina but then they opted for a much more muted tone that I personally found less flattering. I thought a lot of the brighter/bolder tones looked great on her.
The thing is, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. What matters most is how you feel about what you are wearing. I think any color would be good as long as you are confident and comfortable.
i dont think blues are the worst for you i know from experience that some people just look awful in blue.... but you nailed it i think this was too restricting for you and you can definitely pull of more colors
Am I think only one who actually agreed with the colour analysis? Obviously, everything is subjective, but I do think the deep warm colours look lovely on you. You’d suit the dark academia look very well! :)
@@miamiric6051 hi. I agree with the analysis too. She's a deep autumn. Because of her pale skin, yellows don't look good on her. Some deep autumns who are more tanned look good in mustardy yellows (see Jannat Ara's vid). Tina can also pull off the pink-peach pastels - the ones shown in the last few minutes.
I think the black looked amazing on you! The beige suited you a lot, I loved all of the red tones on you, I actually liked the bright vivid colors too (it made your skin tone pop more!) and the burnt orange looked AMAZING! ❤
I actually did a colour analysis when I went to Korea last year as well! And watching this video was so nostalgic because I found out that I have the exact skin tone as you Tina 😂 The colours recommended was like those dark Autumn colours and they gave me a booklet which circled the colours that suited me best. I also found out gold suited me better than silver which heavily influenced my decision in buying jewellery now haha. Though I feel kinda bummed because I really like subtle spring summer pastel colours on clothes but I can't wear them because it'll wash me out (according to the analysis) :( But thanks for sharing Tina! It was really enjoyable seeing your experience!
actually i think they just made you more korean vibe looking, but i like the original Tina better. i'm not sure if it's you being shy, you don't look quite comfortable during the progress.
This is fascinating! I had no idea that choosing a colour to wear could be so in depth. I will definitely consider how colours make me look in more detail from now on! Xxx
Wow, I´d love to get a color analysis done myself : ) You look incredible with the autumn colors and the lipstick at the end suited you soo much, kinda reminded me of red velvets psycho vibes
Very interesting. Usually I see these videos and can't see a difference in what suits someone but here I can. I think they was spot on, darker colours show off your facial features x
This was so cool and insightful! Didn’t know they split the seasons up even more, wonder if they had a translator on hand for the session? Would definitely want to try this next trip to Korea!
I totally agree with her except I think the bronze is a metal that looked really pretty on you too. I do think when you especially have yellow skin tones and olive skin tones, those are the harder ones to figure out colors, in my opinion. Also really super pale like my daughter, she struggled with colors too, not so much now but when she was first starting out and I was very surprised at what Reds looked gorgeous on her, I would never have thought a red would look good with such a pale skin but it really can. We had this done here in the US but it wasn’t like this at all, it was a little different but we did find out what color foundations and what colors look good on us and then they explained the color wheel and which colors would go together well on us but I do highly recommend getting this done if you cannot pinpoint your shades. I know when you’re first starting out with make up just trying to figure out your shade and then if you’re neutral or yellow ect it can be very confusing. My daughter was modeling when she was younger and this is something they recommend for young models and we found it quite fun actually.
This is an interesting process. I would take it with a grain of salt though. The Korean concept of beauty is different from others around the world. They seem to like the porcelain look. I personally like the tanned look. I’ve seen Tina look gorgeous in white and yellow and they seemed to think it wasn’t her colors. Also they chose these dark colors on her. If you want to look like Morticia Adams then go ahead, use black everyday!
Yeah- they’re really rough to foreigners. Her telling her how dark her skin was, taking entire blocks of colors, telling her she looked like a zombie? 😬
yeah beauty standard is different. probably in your country, people hate pale skin and praises tanned skin. i would love to appear brighter tho. maybe it’s just me but caucasians look pretty ugly (sorry if im too blunt) with pale skin but asians look very clean and pretty with pale skin. caucasians somehow look so pretty with tanned skin idk how that works lol.
@@caraperegrine6936I would disagree. I’m not caucasian, but I’ve definitely seen some that look great with paler skin (especially if they have super blonde hair or darker toned hair) and some that look too washed out or orange with tans. They still have undertones to consider.
Whenever Safiya goes back to South Korea, I’d love to see her do this. Although, she already did something similar to this in her Perfect Makeover video… so, I don’t know if she would. I apologize for mentioning another creator. 😅 I’d definitely try this.
Yes and in her perfect makeover video they say that she was an autumn when in her recent vid find out that she is a winter ! I wonder why in previous vid the stylist told she was warm skin ?@@racang6036
Thank you for this helpful video Tina. Before I watched this video, I wasn’t sure why I always wore rose gold and muted browns, reds and greens. And avoided pastels and neons. I just knew instinctually that for some reason those were the colors that worked for my skin, eye, and hair tone. Now I know that autumn deeps work well for your light-olive skin, I can apply that knowledge to myself! I happen to have very similar color tones to you.
I don’t doubt that she’s a professional but professionals can make mistakes too just like anyone can. That being said, I honestly think she has a sort of confirmation bias from the start and just stuck Tina in with the warm dark/black colors. There were so many lighter and brighter colors that looked great on her but the color analyst just disregarded them/stated they were unflattering instead of asking Tina how she felt she looks like with those colors. Imo, Tina didn’t look as lively with those dark colors as she does with the brighter ones.
I actually loved you in those muted, softer autumn colors. The darker ones for sure (like at work, night on the town), but the softer ones were just gorgeous on you, too.
I don’t know if it’s the lighting difference between a video and real life. But I thought the dark bright colors looked beautiful on you and much better than the dark autumn!
You have a very strong olive skin tone (green tint). Did she mention anything about that? Mine is olive too but it makes it so hard for colour analysis. Is it possible to have a warm undertone with olive skin??
Yes I would try this out!! I need help! I have a question though will she be able to help someone who is brown specially when it comes to make up because I know Korean make ups are only targeted towards Asian or more pale skin tones. I wonder if she even has any make up sample foundation at all for brown skins at her store as 😅.
May be helpful if you want to wear blues, but I've read that autumns can wear "harbour blues" - and if you look it up, some of images seem to be warm-toned blues, so I'm sure there has to be a shade if not multiple that suit your season
Omg Tina. I think we have the same skin tone. I think whatever she was saying was entirely correct. I always thought I look best in deep autumn colours she recommended for you. My skin looks brighter at the same time my features pop. The same with muted pastels which are okay on you. When wearing these colours, intuitively I go heavy on the contouring and eye makeup. After watching this video I guess whatever I thought or was doing intuitively wasn’t wrong. Also I cannot wear bright vibrant colours!!! They bring out all my dark spots and my skin just looks dull. This video has proven that I was right. I don’t need to go and check anymore ig 😂
Health can also affect your personal color. Whatever conditions I have caused me to become paler (my old concealer is now my skintone). Some conditions can make you more yellow. I'm a brown-skinned (peachy undertone) autumn mute (low contrast); but I can't help but still buy black clothes. 😅 Most of my clothes are black and I have a few grey and autumn brown pieces; but for spring I'm going to try choosing colorful (non-neutral) autumn mute colors. I've been eyeing greens; so I guess I'm slowly expanding my wardrobe color-wise. I tried on an autumn mute green velvet floral print dress today and my 4yo family member complimented me---so there's definitely an effect. Even though I already know my personal color thanks to Korean blogs and TH-camrs specializing in color analysis (esp. those for brown-skin), I still would want to do this---it seems fun!
This helped me so much! I have very pale skin but I think I am neutral-cool type of olive where you are warm..maybe? Still kinda lost lol. This video helped me so much though to figure out my own colors. I have a better understanding of what would look good on me. Thanks from all the vampires of the world like me :D
I would 100 percent so this. So helpful and fun to see you get this done. You can really tell the difference. I think we are complete opposites, the colors that looked bad on you are my best colors (blues (cobalt) and pinks). Thank you for sharing this whole thing.
Tina you should make a haul video buying a same dress with the no color and yes color so we can compare the actual result. It must be fascinating because I always buy clothes in color that I like instead in color that people told me I look good in 🤣
Korean beauty standards are really different from what I have grown up seeing around me. As a brown-skinned person, I just know if I happen to get a color analysis done in Korea, it'll be brutal. I'll probably get banned from wearing 99.99% of the shades that I use in daily life.
So glad this video is finally out. Been looking forward to it since you teased it on IG. Super helpful and fun video. I would definitely try this type of service if it were available here or if I am traveling to Korea.
I'm sorry but I disagree with a lot of what the color analysis person said...I have seen you in so many colors when you do the clothing try-on videos and I feel like you look gorgeous in so many colors. 💖
I thought if you have more yellow in skin tones you’re essentially cool toned b/c you need more cool tones to balance out the yellow tints in your skin, and vice versa. That’s why in MAC, their colors are in NC (Neutral Cool) for warm tones (who has more red tints), NW (neutral warm) for cool tones (who has more yellow tints in skin)
there are cool yellow and warm yellow tones, as well as cool olive and warm olive tones. People like to use MAC foundations for comparison because it's an easy guideline as MAC foundations has been around for ages in the makeup industry. It's a lot easier to explain individual's mac shades as opposed to newer brands, like say colourpop
MAC's coloring system is based off color theory. Yellow is generally considered cooler than red (pink skin tones have more red than yellow); hence, NC colors have more yellow and less red, C has even less red, NW has more red than yellow, etc.
Muy buen análisis de color. Hay muchas chicas que lo hacen solo con las estaciones y la calidez de la piel pero no miran el brillo! Ni la cantidad de negro que debe tener un color pese a ser de la temperatura correcta. Que ganas que en Colombia hubiera un análisis de este tipo, me encanta. ❤
I am sorry but I think most of the color she cancelled looked really really good on you I remember your purple hair series & you pulled that off so well 👏 please do not set an unnecessary boundary for yourself u look good in most of the colors unless the color itself is not a vibe (IYKWIM)
I've been subconsciously doing this for years and I'm pleased to see this is a professional service! My colours are warm gray, peach, coral, black and navy 😊
What a change!!! Id wished that I could go to korea or that they had a shop where I could do it here or aome kind of way. Since its cheaper here, but im asian and idk all the stylist said Im cool winter cuz of my hair and eye color
This was so interesting! I knew you were an Autumn. 🙂 The makeup and nail colours you could really see what she meant about it suiting you more in terms of it complementing your skin tones the most.Perfume was fascinating, never thought of it that way! Do they do this for men? I wonder what Alfred is? or Zen!
I hate woody smells and musks in perfume. I don’t care if it’s the only thing that fits the vibe, I can’t do it. Citrus undertones all the way. Cinnamon and vanilla are secondary lol
You are slightly warm but I don’t think warmth is a dominant feature for you. Just because we all have temperature, contrast and lightness/depth, doesn’t mean we have those features equally. Most of us have dominant traits. You appear to be medium to high contrast, slightly warm and muted. Deep autumn’s are not muted. As a deep autumn we actually lean vibrant and we look good in intense, strong colors. When I look at you what pops out immediately is your mutedness. I think you’d be happier in a soft season.
Hey guys! Hope you're all having a wonderful day! Thanks for popping by to watch my video. Did anyone guess my season correctly? 🤭
I only realised that the Browns suited you the best
I guessed the season by what you gravitate toward in your makeup pallette in previous videos.
Can I just say thank you for entertaining us! We all learn SO much from you, honoured to be here ❤
You shouldn't always wear brown or dark colours
I personally think that the pastels look good on you
I still think you look lovely in muted coral and peach tones (with warm undertone)
It would be amazing if you make a video following the recommendations she gave you (makeup, clothes colors etc) 💖
Yes that would be nice
Yess
Yes 👍
And then she makes a comparison of what she used to do
Yes, this is a brilliant idea!
Now wear a whole outfit and makeup based on best and worst colors on you and let people vote which looks good. Brown (darker color) vs Blue (vivid bright colors).
Yeeess this is such an interesting video idea!! 😍
orrr wear your best colors vs just colors you like/think are pretty in general and let us vote
You can still wear the other colours, just not right next to the face. So you can still wear them in a skirt or a pair of trousers, maybe as details in a cardigan.
@Don't Read My Profile Photo i wont
Hello, I hope you're safe over there? I hope this year brings happiness, prosperity, and love all over the world, I would love 💚us to be good friends in honesty and in trust if you don't mind. I'm Doctor Christopher Johnson from San Francisco, California, where are you from if I may ask?
I agree!!
She is right charcoal/brown looks so good on you Tina
I agreed with a lot of the bright colors, yellows, and most purples, but she just threw out the whole blue color scheme and I thought a couple shades looked good. Same with a few of the other colors she took out. I thought the dark colors did look good and sophisticated like she said, but they also made you appear paler. Which I guess in South Korea is desirable. It would be cool to see you have this done again in Australia or the US to see if culture plays a part. I think another color pallet could suit you just as well.
Yeah I can't believe there is NO suitable blue. Seems like the analyst needs more drapes.
It’s warm versus cool tone. Like other comments point, it’s only for colors near your face, so blue jeans are still okay. There is no warm blue. You should watch other color analysis videos bc it’s not about looking paler, it’s about clear bright skin instead of dull (gray cast) skin (like when she’s in blue) or amplifying shadows (like what they were saying about the black color). Also, color appointments would take into account dark or red blemishes, but Tina’s skin is clear so that didn’t factor in. If the goal was just to look paler, dye your hair black and wear black 🥴 (edit to say there can be warm blues, but I stand by the “the goal is bright skin, not pale skin” point for these color analysis appointments. I’ve also tried looking for a color appointment here in the states but since I’m not near any fashion capitols, what’s available to me seems like older women working on limited or outdated color analysis l so I probably have to do an online appointment if I wanted this done well from in the states).
@hvnterly8388 According to many different types of color analysis, there should be SOME blue(s) that suits her. I can't think of any seasonal analysis system that discounts EVERY blue for a particular person. Yes, blue might be considered cool in general, but there are blues that lean warm, or light, or deep, or muted, and so on. In any analysis system I am familiar with, everyone gets blues--it's just a matter of finding which blues work best on you.
Actually someone else did this too, and that youtuber said she wanted to look pale. The person got "mad" (not really mad but best word) at her saying "You don't want to look pale. You want to look bright." Which is the big difference. Both mean lighter, but being pale in this context means looking sickly. Think like Wednesday Addams. Looking brighter brings out the natural highlights and makes you look more lively and stand out. Even people who are "pale" in skin tone don't necessarily look pale like Wednesday.
@@hbarlaam I was mistaken! I looked it up after and there can be blue based reds and red based blues, yellow based blues, and so on. Thank you for also correcting my misinformation 👍 I won’t edit it out for clarity of the comment section, but i do admit my mistake!
I didn't expect that the deeper lip color would be recommended, and I feel like there were more colours in there that suited you. I think it would be interesting to see a video where you create outfits with respect to each season that aren't yours, and try to find ways to make them work somehow, or see if they actually do make you look dull.
I actually liked the cherry red and the one before that you said was too cool toned. I think colours can make us look washed out / cold when we don't have makeup on but with the right makeup we can carry off more colours.
I think it would be interesting to do another color analysis by someone else who is just as reputable just to see the difference and get a second opinion? I really like the makeup, hair and perfume aspect. Also a shopping haul with your new tones would be super cool too.
I actually really liked the pastel muted colors on you, the ones which were shown in the end - muted pinks/beiges. They complimented your skin color very well. And I did really like some reds as well, that she did not pick to your final palette.
I actually completely agree with her, immediately the dark autumn colours sharpened your features and evened out your skin tone whereas the cool colours brought out the veins and dark circles in your face. I do think the teal colours would suit you but that's because teal and dark navy colours also suit dark autumns too. And the bright colours were a bit much
I've always been extremely into fashion, so this is super fascinating to watch. I've been curious about these types of sessions before, so it's really cool to observe one. I've been goth for my entire life (literally since I could form coherent thoughts about my clothes), so maybe I'm biased, but I thought black looked much more striking on you than the dark chocolate brown. That being said I could DEFINITELY see how the darker colors looked better than light! The lighter colors totally washed you out! I thought it was so interesting when she said there were certain lighter colors you could pull off if you did heavier makeup. That makes so much sense!
All of this was extremely interesting and worth thinking about, but my motto in life is "if it makes you happy and you're not hurting yourself or others, do it." I definitely believe that extends into the worlds of makeup and fashion. Don't think too hard about whether a color might look good just based on looking at it. Always try something on. You might really love it anyway. If that's the case, wear it. If it makes you happy, you should always consider that first.
I’m also goth and VERY picky with colour. My favourite colours are black purple and green, through I mostly wear black, only wear purple sometimes, and I hardly ever wear green (usually only as an accent with accessories.)
I’ve been watching a lot of these videos and I find them so interesting. I’m nearly always able to pick out the “correct” options, I think due to my fascination with colour theory. It’s kind of funny to me how me, who hates most colours, has such an eye for them lol.
I’m so curious to what it would be like to get a consultation for myself. I’m 99% sure that I have a neutral undertone, so I really don’t know what would be “my” season. (Though my guess would be winter.) I also don’t really strive to look “bright and healthy” and a lot of the times try to look kinda dead lol, so I wonder how that would influence everything.
I think that’s a big part of what interests me in these theories in fashion and makeup, because there’s this widespread idea of the “right” or “correct” way to achieve certain things- that are desirable to the majority of people; but then you could use that exact same theory and apply it to create the opposite effect that is desirable to a nicher audience.
Hopefully that made sense 😭 apologies for the long comment I’m just super interested by all this.
This conversation is super interesting 😃 i am no expert, but from what i understand of colour theory (or rather, my take on it) it is not so much "oh, you mustn't wear these colours" or "you should only wear .... colours". Rather it is understanding the visual effect different colours will have on you.
Seasonal colour theory indicates which colours look most HARMONIOUS against your skin. But of course, if looking hatmonious is not your goal, you should wear colours against your season 😉 for instance, if wearing a full black outfit makes you look goth, you most likely are not a Winter, Dark Autumn or Bright Spring. On those seasons, black will look very harmonious. However, if a Summer wears a full black outfit, she is more likely to "make a statement" with her look, so to speak.
I am a Bright Spring. Black looks pretty harmonious on me. Bright colours also look less "bright" on me than a softer season. I work in a very professional environment where we can't really go crazy with our looks haha (business consulting firm!). But since i have quite bright colouring, i find i can easily get away wearing bright emerald greens, yellows, hot pinks etc as long as the style of the outfits themselves is "professional".
I also routinely wear red lipstick to work and it looks very normal on me, not too "made up". On the other hand, if i wear a dark smoky eye or a deep maroon/ berry lip (dark rather than bright colours) i immediately look like am going to a Halloween party 😂😂
Hope my comment made some sense 😬
Hello, I hope you're safe over there? I hope this year brings happiness, prosperity, and love all over the world, I would love 💚us to be good friends in honesty and in trust if you don't mind. I'm Doctor Christopher Johnson from San Francisco, California, where are you from if I may ask?
People saying certain colors look good on Tina don’t realize that they’re getting affected by a) the camera and lighting and b) makeup in other videos, which can make a big difference. That’s why color consultations happen in person, you can’t accurately gauge what suits someone irl through a camera! Think of all the pretty influencer makeup that looks thick and cakey irl-some colors photograph nicely on someone, but don’t looks as flattering in person, and vice versa.
This!
Agree! Not everything can be perfectly captured through the camera lenses.
True
All the stylist suggested were dark sullen shades while I’ve seen you look beautiful in all other bright colours too, even purple, in your haul videos.
I agree. The consultants concept of beauty is subjective!
And she was rude, telling her entire batches of colors didn’t look good, and that she looked like a zombie. 😬
Yes! I thought of that as well. This is just the consultant’s opinion. Hope she’ll never accept her recommendations
I actually agreed with her analysis. Of course, she can wear anything she wants and still look good but I do think the warm deep colours suit her undertone better. I don’t think they’re sullen either. To me they’re very pretty muted colours
And I think the bluntness might just be a Korean cultural difference?
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO!!! That's SO cool that she even suggest scents to match your aura! I want to do a color consult even MORE now, there's always so much more to learn as I see more of these videos!
Me, too!!! This has also been on my bucket list for YEARS and I’m finally getting my first color analysis next month, but can’t wait and have been binge watching these color analysis videos in the meantime. It’s fascinating!
I had mine done years ago, the only thing I wouldn't agree with is that purple is always cool toned. If you mix a warm red and a warm blue you get a warm purple! I'm an autumn and look incredible in warm purples so don't rule out any colour x
I'm so glad she mentioned you can get away with some spring colors; I was remembering your try-on hauls and how that color palette of pinks suited you! I think that while the dark colors look good, the more vivid ones right before the dark ones also suited you. E.g. burgundy looks good on you too, even though she believes the blackened red is best. If you look at "dark autumn" palettes, those colors are actually included. It's not just deep darks as she showed; there are lighter and vivid colors as well. But it's possible that's just the default Western dark autumn palette. I've seen Korean palettes sometimes resemble them and others (like this place) just have the darks.
Ok I have to admit, those brown tones are SO striking on you! Yes there are other colors that look fine too, but I really really see the sophistication of those and how complementary they are to you.
U lit up with deeper autumn, wow ,so obvious 😊. She was very good and she had a really trained eye.
It’s so interesting to see how these color analysis sessions vary by country/culture. This was good Korean practice too! Thanks for sharing Tina. For the record I think you look great in all colors 💜
I thought the teal colors looked sooo good with your skin ☺️
The winter dark colors really got me feeling colorblind
lol!
I think you look beautiful in every color! Tina you’re amazing and their lighting doesn’t do you justice plus you’re not sunkissed yet
I still like vibrant red on you! You’re so pretty!
Cherry red. Agree!
I agree I think some of the vibrant colors looked great. I liked the bold cherry red especially. But the bright warm yellow was quite nice too
I live in LA and I love things like this I been in a fashion slump. I would like to do this while visiting Korea.
Thank you for coming back with full video! Flipping color and watching the effect on skin are just so satisfying to me. Hehe
Ps. Dark brown and eggplant colors look so good on you❤
I’m obsessed with things like this, and personally, aside from knowing what colors look good on me, I also like using it when I draw original characters. It’s fun to think of my characters’ color palettes to make then distinct from one another 😄
I love color theory in clothes and makeup. It really does make such a difference.
There were actually several colors she didn't like for you that I thought looked spectacular on you, really brightening up your features. I think a lot of that could be my own personal preferences to though.
Since you have it on video you can go back and really look at each one and what it does for your face and skin and hair. You may find more that you really like on you.
Definitely she got you in the right season. So many great colors for you. That charcoal was fantastic on you.
I am a bright winter. Over time I have found if I wear the wrong colors, every time I look in the mirror I don't really like what I see, don't feel that I look good, and that can affect my mood for the whole day.
If I wear the right colors, even without makeup, I just look "right." Bright, happy, optimistic, and I feel like I have a better day. Colors can definitely affect our mood.
The colors we surround ourselves with like walls and furniture should generally be in our color season if we can. If you take a picture of yourself against a good background color for yourself, it will look so much better than if the background is wrong for us. That can affect people's perception of us when they are looking at us in person, too. I painted my bedroom in a deep but bright red, and it makes me feel really happy when I see it, and when I look in a mirror there I feel like I look pretty good. That affects my mood in a positive way.
The right scents help, too. I love that she helped you find the right one of those too.
I think on personal look different… because the camera lights up when the strong color showing just my thoughts
I’m incredibly picky with colours, and although I’m very appreciative of all colours, I hate most of them for me personally; be it wearing or decorating. I mostly wear and decorate with black, but my favourite colour is purple and I use it as an accent for a lot of things. Then I use green for even smaller accents.
I am really curious to know if the colours that I love and surround myself with are my “personal” colours or not. I am not someone who strives to look “bright and healthy, etc.” which is usually the goal of finding colours that ‘suit’ you. My preferred aesthetics are much more dark. So im curious to if my preferences actually enhance me according to this theory or not.
I agree! There was a bold pink in there that I loved on Tina but then they opted for a much more muted tone that I personally found less flattering. I thought a lot of the brighter/bolder tones looked great on her.
How did you know you were a bright winter? I have been trying to figure out what season I am, but its so confusing😅
The thing is, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. What matters most is how you feel about what you are wearing. I think any color would be good as long as you are confident and comfortable.
So could we see a new clothing haul soon since you now know what colors look best on you. Please that would be great, I miss your try on hauls.
Also even if you're autumn dark you can still wear most colours just in the right tone! And different intensities of it, paler darker etc.
i dont think blues are the worst for you i know from experience that some people just look awful in blue.... but you nailed it i think this was too restricting for you and you can definitely pull of more colors
This is the third video I've seen of this type and it's fascinating to see what a difference these color matching makes in real time!
I watched a lot of your videos with different makeup. You look really amazing with the lipstick color in this video!
The colors she chose for you suit you so well! But girl, those browns are definitely your colors 😍
Am I think only one who actually agreed with the colour analysis? Obviously, everything is subjective, but I do think the deep warm colours look lovely on you. You’d suit the dark academia look very well! :)
I love wearing colours like that but I always found they looked a little off on me as a true summer.
@@miamiric6051 hi. I agree with the analysis too. She's a deep autumn. Because of her pale skin, yellows don't look good on her. Some deep autumns who are more tanned look good in mustardy yellows (see Jannat Ara's vid). Tina can also pull off the pink-peach pastels - the ones shown in the last few minutes.
I think the black looked amazing on you! The beige suited you a lot, I loved all of the red tones on you, I actually liked the bright vivid colors too (it made your skin tone pop more!) and the burnt orange looked AMAZING! ❤
I actually did a colour analysis when I went to Korea last year as well! And watching this video was so nostalgic because I found out that I have the exact skin tone as you Tina 😂 The colours recommended was like those dark Autumn colours and they gave me a booklet which circled the colours that suited me best. I also found out gold suited me better than silver which heavily influenced my decision in buying jewellery now haha. Though I feel kinda bummed because I really like subtle spring summer pastel colours on clothes but I can't wear them because it'll wash me out (according to the analysis) :( But thanks for sharing Tina! It was really enjoyable seeing your experience!
Wow. Loved that they cover fragrance, hair colour, makeup & nail polish. I would definitely do that if I were to visit Korea
I've always loved warm-toned pastels and soft tones on you
I’ve seen a lot of other color analysis videos & I appreciated the comparison between two shades of the same color to really the difference!
actually i think they just made you more korean vibe looking, but i like the original Tina better. i'm not sure if it's you being shy, you don't look quite comfortable during the progress.
I think the vivid purple actual fits Tina perfectly😮
The darker lipstick looked amazing! It made your lips look fuller and more luscious.
This is fascinating! I had no idea that choosing a colour to wear could be so in depth. I will definitely consider how colours make me look in more detail from now on! Xxx
I would have thought you were cool toned but I agree with the dark brown vs black but I liked the purples
Wow, I´d love to get a color analysis done myself : )
You look incredible with the autumn colors and the lipstick at the end suited you soo much, kinda reminded me of red velvets psycho vibes
Very interesting. Usually I see these videos and can't see a difference in what suits someone but here I can. I think they was spot on, darker colours show off your facial features x
This was so cool and insightful! Didn’t know they split the seasons up even more, wonder if they had a translator on hand for the session? Would definitely want to try this next trip to Korea!
I totally agree with her except I think the bronze is a metal that looked really pretty on you too. I do think when you especially have yellow skin tones and olive skin tones, those are the harder ones to figure out colors, in my opinion. Also really super pale like my daughter, she struggled with colors too, not so much now but when she was first starting out and I was very surprised at what Reds looked gorgeous on her, I would never have thought a red would look good with such a pale skin but it really can. We had this done here in the US but it wasn’t like this at all, it was a little different but we did find out what color foundations and what colors look good on us and then they explained the color wheel and which colors would go together well on us but I do highly recommend getting this done if you cannot pinpoint your shades. I know when you’re first starting out with make up just trying to figure out your shade and then if you’re neutral or yellow ect it can be very confusing. My daughter was modeling when she was younger and this is something they recommend for young models and we found it quite fun actually.
This is an interesting process. I would take it with a grain of salt though. The Korean concept of beauty is different from others around the world. They seem to like the porcelain look. I personally like the tanned look. I’ve seen Tina look gorgeous in white and yellow and they seemed to think it wasn’t her colors. Also they chose these dark colors on her. If you want to look like Morticia Adams then go ahead, use black everyday!
Yeah- they’re really rough to foreigners. Her telling her how dark her skin was, taking entire blocks of colors, telling her she looked like a zombie? 😬
yeah beauty standard is different. probably in your country, people hate pale skin and praises tanned skin. i would love to appear brighter tho. maybe it’s just me but caucasians look pretty ugly (sorry if im too blunt) with pale skin but asians look very clean and pretty with pale skin. caucasians somehow look so pretty with tanned skin idk how that works lol.
Yeah, I thought the plain white contrasted her skin more and made her look tan/glowy. Beige kinda looked washed out imo 😅
@@caraperegrine6936I would disagree. I’m not caucasian, but I’ve definitely seen some that look great with paler skin (especially if they have super blonde hair or darker toned hair) and some that look too washed out or orange with tans. They still have undertones to consider.
i think its more about what colors make you look “bright” not necessarily whiter but yea
Whenever Safiya goes back to South Korea, I’d love to see her do this. Although, she already did something similar to this in her Perfect Makeover video… so, I don’t know if she would.
I apologize for mentioning another creator. 😅
I’d definitely try this.
that's okay! I'm also a fan of her videos!
@@tina_yong, thank you! ❤️
I guess you got your wish cause Safiya just uploaded a video on her getting a color analysis!!!
Yes and in her perfect makeover video they say that she was an autumn when in her recent vid find out that she is a winter ! I wonder why in previous vid the stylist told she was warm skin ?@@racang6036
Thank you for this helpful video Tina. Before I watched this video, I wasn’t sure why I always wore rose gold and muted browns, reds and greens. And avoided pastels and neons. I just knew instinctually that for some reason those were the colors that worked for my skin, eye, and hair tone. Now I know that autumn deeps work well for your light-olive skin, I can apply that knowledge to myself! I happen to have very similar color tones to you.
I don’t doubt that she’s a professional but professionals can make mistakes too just like anyone can. That being said, I honestly think she has a sort of confirmation bias from the start and just stuck Tina in with the warm dark/black colors. There were so many lighter and brighter colors that looked great on her but the color analyst just disregarded them/stated they were unflattering instead of asking Tina how she felt she looks like with those colors. Imo, Tina didn’t look as lively with those dark colors as she does with the brighter ones.
I actually loved you in those muted, softer autumn colors. The darker ones for sure (like at work, night on the town), but the softer ones were just gorgeous on you, too.
I don’t know if it’s the lighting difference between a video and real life. But I thought the dark bright colors looked beautiful on you and much better than the dark autumn!
Dustmoth Stography looks like a good color analysis, I personally think your personality and mood can make
a big difference too
You have a very strong olive skin tone (green tint). Did she mention anything about that? Mine is olive too but it makes it so hard for colour analysis. Is it possible to have a warm undertone with olive skin??
Finally! I was waiting for this video for a long time. I love this type of videos
Yes I would try this out!! I need help! I have a question though will she be able to help someone who is brown specially when it comes to make up because I know Korean make ups are only targeted towards Asian or more pale skin tones. I wonder if she even has any make up sample foundation at all for brown skins at her store as 😅.
May be helpful if you want to wear blues, but I've read that autumns can wear "harbour blues" - and if you look it up, some of images seem to be warm-toned blues, so I'm sure there has to be a shade if not multiple that suit your season
Omg Tina. I think we have the same skin tone. I think whatever she was saying was entirely correct. I always thought I look best in deep autumn colours she recommended for you. My skin looks brighter at the same time my features pop. The same with muted pastels which are okay on you. When wearing these colours, intuitively I go heavy on the contouring and eye makeup. After watching this video I guess whatever I thought or was doing intuitively wasn’t wrong. Also I cannot wear bright vibrant colours!!! They bring out all my dark spots and my skin just looks dull. This video has proven that I was right. I don’t need to go and check anymore ig 😂
I liked the pink, yellow pastels and lavenders on you!!! I felt that darker autumn colours aged you even though they were sophisticated.
Health can also affect your personal color. Whatever conditions I have caused me to become paler (my old concealer is now my skintone). Some conditions can make you more yellow.
I'm a brown-skinned (peachy undertone) autumn mute (low contrast); but I can't help but still buy black clothes. 😅 Most of my clothes are black and I have a few grey and autumn brown pieces; but for spring I'm going to try choosing colorful (non-neutral) autumn mute colors. I've been eyeing greens; so I guess I'm slowly expanding my wardrobe color-wise. I tried on an autumn mute green velvet floral print dress today and my 4yo family member complimented me---so there's definitely an effect.
Even though I already know my personal color thanks to Korean blogs and TH-camrs specializing in color analysis (esp. those for brown-skin), I still would want to do this---it seems fun!
This helped me so much! I have very pale skin but I think I am neutral-cool type of olive where you are warm..maybe? Still kinda lost lol. This video helped me so much though to figure out my own colors. I have a better understanding of what would look good on me. Thanks from all the vampires of the world like me :D
Hi. If you're olive skinned, then I suggest to watch the draping vids of Colour Analysis Studio. They recently analyzed a lady who has olive skin.
If I want to look quite sick I wear bright yellow. I have used it to my advantage. 😊
That’s amazing! The cost and service are very reasonable. It looks like she did a good job!
This looks sooooo fun! I would love to do this! You look beautiful in brown girl, so sophisticated 🤎🤌
I always thought darker colors suit u best. Whenever u make darker makeup look it enhance ur features and ur glowing
I wud never try this..and even on you, that bright yellow top with a stylish black pants wud look bomb!
Yay!!!! I have been searching and waiting for this video to drop!
I would 100 percent so this. So helpful and fun to see you get this done. You can really tell the difference. I think we are complete opposites, the colors that looked bad on you are my best colors (blues (cobalt) and pinks). Thank you for sharing this whole thing.
this was so cool! i love jinhi's personality. this seems like such a cool experience, do you think it's impacted the way you shop since you did it?
Yeah it has, it’s made shopping harder cause I can’t find clothes in my colours 😅
Tina you should make a haul video buying a same dress with the no color and yes color so we can compare the actual result. It must be fascinating because I always buy clothes in color that I like instead in color that people told me I look good in 🤣
Korean beauty standards are really different from what I have grown up seeing around me. As a brown-skinned person, I just know if I happen to get a color analysis done in Korea, it'll be brutal. I'll probably get banned from wearing 99.99% of the shades that I use in daily life.
No you wont. They measure from tone, undertone etc. Not light and dark.
They have a video where they’re doing black celebs too (Jonathan and his sis) and it works for all skin tones
So glad this video is finally out. Been looking forward to it since you teased it on IG. Super helpful and fun video. I would definitely try this type of service if it were available here or if I am traveling to Korea.
I'm sorry but I disagree with a lot of what the color analysis person said...I have seen you in so many colors when you do the clothing try-on videos and I feel like you look gorgeous in so many colors. 💖
I had somehing like this donre when I was in junior high, but I'd definitely like to do it again. This one seems extremely thorough
I've been waiting for this video. Thank you, Tina. 🤗
I thought if you have more yellow in skin tones you’re essentially cool toned b/c you need more cool tones to balance out the yellow tints in your skin, and vice versa. That’s why in MAC, their colors are in NC (Neutral Cool) for warm tones (who has more red tints), NW (neutral warm) for cool tones (who has more yellow tints in skin)
there are cool yellow and warm yellow tones, as well as cool olive and warm olive tones. People like to use MAC foundations for comparison because it's an easy guideline as MAC foundations has been around for ages in the makeup industry. It's a lot easier to explain individual's mac shades as opposed to newer brands, like say colourpop
MAC's coloring system is based off color theory. Yellow is generally considered cooler than red (pink skin tones have more red than yellow); hence, NC colors have more yellow and less red, C has even less red, NW has more red than yellow, etc.
Tina looks beautiful in every colour 😍. I quite dint understand the colour analysis 😵💫
It's so interesting to see this process! I would love to do this too! She moves very fast so the size by side is very helpful!
Am I the only one who thought the blues and mint green looked good on her?
Muy buen análisis de color. Hay muchas chicas que lo hacen solo con las estaciones y la calidez de la piel pero no miran el brillo! Ni la cantidad de negro que debe tener un color pese a ser de la temperatura correcta. Que ganas que en Colombia hubiera un análisis de este tipo, me encanta. ❤
I am sorry but I think most of the color she cancelled looked really really good on you I remember your purple hair series & you pulled that off so well 👏
please do not set an unnecessary boundary for yourself u look good in most of the colors unless the color itself is not a vibe (IYKWIM)
Exactly! she can wear blue and purple --warm times can wear these
I've been subconsciously doing this for years and I'm pleased to see this is a professional service! My colours are warm gray, peach, coral, black and navy 😊
What a change!!! Id wished that I could go to korea or that they had a shop where I could do it here or aome kind of way. Since its cheaper here, but im asian and idk all the stylist said Im cool winter cuz of my hair and eye color
Thanks so sharing, wish we have the same services here in Sydney 😊
Hi. There's a service in Melbourne - they have a YT channel, Colour Analysis Studio.
This was so interesting! I knew you were an Autumn. 🙂 The makeup and nail colours you could really see what she meant about it suiting you more in terms of it complementing your skin tones the most.Perfume was fascinating, never thought of it that way! Do they do this for men? I wonder what Alfred is? or Zen!
Those colors look so good on you, especially as you mature.
We're all so fascinatingly made... those darker earthy colors really do suit you.
Oooh yay! I’ve been waiting for this one 😊
We definitely need a clothing haul that you shopped for in your color palette!!
Been waiting for this video!!
The makeup looks so good!
Lol I forgot how brutal the stylists can be about what colors work and don’t
You are looking absolutely gorgeous everyday & i love to watch your vlog 🤎
I hate woody smells and musks in perfume. I don’t care if it’s the only thing that fits the vibe, I can’t do it. Citrus undertones all the way. Cinnamon and vanilla are secondary lol
You are slightly warm but I don’t think warmth is a dominant feature for you.
Just because we all have temperature, contrast and lightness/depth, doesn’t mean we have those features equally.
Most of us have dominant traits.
You appear to be medium to high contrast, slightly warm and muted. Deep autumn’s are not muted. As a deep autumn we actually lean vibrant and we look good in intense, strong colors.
When I look at you what pops out immediately is your mutedness.
I think you’d be happier in a soft season.